Dr. Phil just explained how prejudiced opinions and insinuations can affect a criminal case very seriously. Thanks to everyone who worked so hard to shine a light on the many areas where the truth and the facts were not disclosed. Where truth does not travel, justice fails to exist. Thank you, Dr. McGraw.
Thank you, Dr. Phil, for speaking on behalf of Mr. Roberson and his daughter, hopefully, now justice will prevail, and Mr. Roberson will be able to go on with his life.
I have a newfound respect for Dr. Phil. The way people are tried needs to change. There needs to be certain requirements of what needs to be addressed during the course of a trial. That this child's comprehensive medical history wasn't presented to the jury is absolutely outrageous. Juries are only allowed to consider what is presented during the trial.
Of course there’s not enough evidence to say it’s baby syndrome come on he could of been panicking and if her head was damaged that’s too happen if 😮if the baby is aldreay 😢dying of all other symptoms
he might be giving testimony to right a wrong, but this is also marketing to gain more viewership. phil mcgraw is a socialist and against conserving the constitution. don't be fooled just because he does one right thing. he's no better than the mainstream media networks that continue to lie, mislead and propagate on behalf of corrupt government and corporations
Dr Phil, you are absolutely brilliant. You definitely are an audience capturer. God bless you for your hard work and dedication to others. Love and hugs from Australia.
This is heartbreaking 😢 as a parent with an autistic child, this scares me as to how there is a clear lack of understanding of how neurodivergent individuals communicate differently. And how detrimental to their lives it can be. Ineffective council was most definitely an issue here also.
My son has Asperger’s and he does not have typical reaction to any emotions at all, he has one face. My son has cried twice in his life, he is 22. He cried when he was born, and when his dog died, if I die tomorrow I don’t know that he would cry. I’ve never seen him laughing, sad, and when he is upset it’s the same face he has when he’s not upset, he can’t even tell me when he’s sick. He graduated high school with a 4.0. He hasn’t gone to college because he can’t be in a room full of people, his anxiety is to the roof. He’s an awesome artist and, this is funny, he works in customer service and his manager told me he wished all his employees had Asperger’s, he works every day, never calls out, works extra hours if asked and it’s at work and hour before clocking in, if asked to work on his day off he goes to work. He’s amazing but a handful at times.
@@jackie_byfaithMy son has a bit of Asperger's and maybe have additional spectrum issues but UC Davis says he is extremely interesting and they want to continue to evaluate him. He is a genius (always has been and figuring out his issues was difficult and he would physically manifest his emotions at school with rocks and kicks!) But now we know and so does he. 14 now and finally gaining acceptance at school. ❤ My son basically has to dumb himself down to hang out with others because others are just so stupid. 😮😢 Luckily this difference is no longer affecting him at the same level and he's able to enjoy like-minded kids with their matching interests in Roblox and Minecraft. Kids need experiences with other kids! Bless our children Lord 🙏 amen 🙏
Exactly a fair concern and easily manipulated in an effort to have a social life. It harkens to the autistic young person killed by police in Colorado I believe.
I’m so glad they are taking this serious for Mr Robertson, as an Autistic person- my heart breaks for him. This man already had to go through the pain of losing his baby girl, who he took to the hospital 16 times because he was knew she was sick. Nurses and Doctors didn’t take that into account- and the arresting officer agrees that this man needs to be freed. I hope he has people who will support him if he is able to be resentenced and let out.
Finally someone speaking truth I have said for many years someone does not have to be held accountable for everything that happens. Sometimes things just happen. Someone is not always at fault. Our legal system has gone overboard with holding people accountable.
The medication given to the child is no longer used because it depresses breathing in those suffering with pneumonia. That medication may have killed her.
Our prosecutors in this country need to get their sh** together. There’s no reason other than ego that this man was convicted. Dr. Phil is saving this man’s life.
How do you know that 100% for sure!? They said in the Hearing that Dr. Phil testified nobody else was at the home!! If so why is Dr. Phil involved in this case & why does he want a new trial. Dr. Phil putting his name behind this is HUGE DEAL & I DOUBT he would if this man was Wrongfully Convicted!!!! Think about that! ~Kim G.
Well done, Phil McGraw. Well done, legislators on the Texas House Committee on Criminal Jurisprudence. I am very grateful that all of you have stepped up to protect a death row inmate. No more executions of innocent people, please. We must do our utmost to safeguard the legal system.
I also don’t believe this man should have to go through another trial at all, he has been through far too much. He should be let out immediately and awarded a extremely large sum of money to at the least start his life and also be provided with free therapy and all sorts of support to cope with all the trauma he has endured because of all the people responsible for putting him in prison. And this still will NOT be enough.
They need to release this man and pay him for the lapse in law that had been applied to him. This poor man was pigeonholed and his defense was under defending him to the point of not even doing their job. 😡
Thank you Dr. Phil for your due diligence, outstanding interview. Let’s pray for a good outcome and for justice for future injustice of the law. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
In the first 17 minutes, it’s proven this case needs to be reviewed. ALL medical records should be put before the jury, every single scan, every single hospital record. Science has proven that the triad of evidence for shaken baby is outdated and in fact false. This man needs to be released.
Imo The reasons why this injustice happened is because 1 basically no representation and I think most importantly, THE JUDGE EXCLUDED THE EVIDENCE. The judge is also to blame!😢😢😢😢😢
Innocent, "Bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema." are you sure.
It was probably an election year when this first went to trial. They always want to act like a 'Justice Warrior.' Pffft. Like they have a clue what that truly means.
@loralieisa it's public knowledge .....Nikki was found to have "a bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema."[11] Additionally, four separate doctors testified Nikki had "multiple blows to different points on the head", which could not have been caused by falling off a bed.[12]
I would say standards for death penalty cases should be much higher. The defendant should be provided with the best defense council team available. The prosecutor office should NOT have total immunity.
Do you listen to his podcast Phil in the blanks? I listen to it constantly. He is brilliant. His podcast is on all the podcast forums and UA-cam. He talks so much more in depth than his show had time for.
Why is there no punishment for officials who hide evidence that does not support their opinion. It should be seen as criminal when prosecutor, law enforcement and others hide exculpatory evidence. As Dr. Phil says, the aim should be justice not conviction. Prosecutors and police who do not understand this should be disqualified!
❤BRAVO! Im im so proud to have had U dr. Mcgrowe ❤❤ thank u so murths for ur wisdom and for shering it whit all of us who want to learrn how to live life whit integreti ❤❤❤
Wow!!! wow! - Truly, truly ever so beautifully expressed such a compassionate statement 😢 👍 ...after reading what you said; I then stopped for a moment and felt emotional tears running down face - and started to cry (in a nice way of cour) like a sense of peace went through me.. lovely example of what a true "Earth Angel " sent here actually looks like among us "Humanoids" we must wake up to this truth hopefully just that one comment that you made will make that little but much needed difference alongside with Dr Phil and his powerful voice- making such strong ever so powerfully overseen points (*_*) Thank YOU, biggest thanks to you there. Lills ☆☆☆ gratitude overwhelmem from my heart to yours much appreciated reflection of such a heartfelt comment ❤️
Retrying hardly seems reasonable. The conviction ought to be overturned. The judge never reciewed the evidence. A effect counsel would have been valuable but how dare the prosecutor not have shared all the evidence during discovery. Shame on the whole system.
@@maureenpetitto1024 absolutely. They probably why they want him dead. He s going to get compensation for all those years. But it's still a life that was stolen.
I disagree that a crime was not committed. The crime that was committed was lies, a horrible lawyer, judge, lack of police work and so much more. Also they took an innocent man’s life and lost years, last moments with his sick daughter and so much more.
Kudos to Dr. Phil, thank you for your service to mankind and all of our communities. Who then is truly responsible for this tragic event? When some people treat doctors as gods and give power to the pharmaceutical industry is when we lose our freedoms . Diminish the government and take back our rights to make decisions
Right 😂he is litterally is compared to lives to a football game the ignorance on the panel like listen too Dr .Phil his life is precious he has a right to live and he has a daughter
Right 😂he is litterally is compared to lives to a football game the ignorance on the panel like listen too Dr .Phil his life is precious he has a right to live and he has a daughter
She had pneumonia and was prescribed a drug that suppresses breathing. That drug is no longer prescribed because it is known to cause death in cases of pneumonia. Hello! He should be released from prison and given all the help he needs to adjust to outside life.
The trial judge ruled to exclude the child's medical history, so her extensive history of her pre-existing health conditions as well as her current condition at her time of death, was withheld from the jury and defense couldn't use her medical history as defense.
His podcast "Phil in the blanks" is way better than his show. He has more room to say how he really feels without having to worry about a network & their rules or agenda.
They are overworked to the extent they think if they can get a plea deal they did great work. Imagine having a total of 15-20 minutes to try to help a client?
The judge is the one that didnt allow in court the medical history of this child. Therefore the judge holds the responsibility of changes and also has to be part of the fix to this problem.
Everyone involved failed this man including his counsel. Everyone should be sued including the hospital, doctors, the judge, prosecutor, the fake nurse that I swear they paid her to lie, EVERYONE of them should be held accountable.
Dr. Phil is so spot on for so many things! Not a lot of people have that ability to think on the spot, or compile a lot of legal records. Also, most people wouldn't speak out, and if they did, it wouldn't go anywhere.
Dr Phil there are very few tv personalities that I trust but you are one that I would trust. I am an empath and can feel and hear the truth in this. He should be released and exonerated.
After seeing this, I have a lot More respect for Dr Phil . As a black , who been through BS police and the system , i know the laws here are my by enemies. I believe there are lot more innocent people either in jail or serving Time. There are so many without a strong voice, there areso many 1:12:17 injutice , it's definitely touching to see justice is being justified.
His autism was not brought out at the trial and in fact did not become known until sometime later. That in itself, would constitute a reexamination of the trial records, etc..
This doesn’t surprise me that all of this was done in Texas. That state just seems to push the guilty button without thinking. And there’s so many people I bet that are in there that are innocent. Dr. Phil is a hero and so glad he has stepped in to save a man’s life.
SHAME on you KEN PAXTON, Mr Attorney General on you actions (or lack Thereof) in this case. YOU NEED put out of your position for ALL your corrupt ACTIONS and COMMENTS
Does anyone have information in regards to the decision made by the committee in this case? I have listened to Dr. Phil and Terry Compton’s testimonies and have invested my hearts hope to the outcome…
That nurse was paid off to accuse this father that he had SA assaulted his child! This is a disgrace all around. So many people need to go to jail. So many people need to be sued and the people that put this poor innocent man in jail are 💩bricks because their credibility and their integrity went down the 💩hole. 😡
This is where I have a problem with the death penalty. This is when prosecutors are wearing blinders and are determined to get a winning charge REGARDLESS of the evidence.
They didn’t have blinders, they needed to accuse someone and close a case. That’s why we have so many innocent people on death row! It’s power and control.
Having a committee meeting such as this involves the repetition of key facts. It's also standard practice for the witness to provide their written opening statement to the committee prior to the day of the committee to be approved in advance.
My only question on Dr Phil ... how can you be intelligent enough in the field of psychology and NOT DETECT the EVIL in OPRAH ????? Doesn't add up !!!!!
I listen to every word from Dr Phil he did not say that the accused is gillty or innocent what he said was the accused had some issue and those issues were not addressed and there were quick conclusion render in this case baby shake and bake syndrome case also Dr Phil said the baby had medical issues and he also said he don't know if that causes the baby death ?
The baby had been to the hospital prior to the dad being around, the baby had been to the hospital many times prior. He never did anything to that baby.
The conclusion of the autopsy stated that the child died as a result of 9 different blunt force injuries. Perhaps Dr. Phil has not been given this information.
Nikki was found to have "a bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema."[11] Additionally, four separate doctors testified Nikki had "multiple blows to different points on the head", which could not have been caused by falling off a bed.[12]
@@shimmer8289 none it was true! The jury person said there was nothing in the autopsy that stated none of it. The only thing was the little bump on her head.
@jackie_byfaith this was recently released by the Attorney General it was extensive but here's a snippets....Dr. Jill Urban, the medical examiner who performed the autopsy on the two-year-old’s corpse, testified during the trial using photographic evidence that Nikki’s head had been repeatedly struck leaving clear impact wounds totally incompatible with merely being violently shaken. Dr. Urban’s findings were reviewed by six supervising medical examiners at the Dallas County Medical Examiner’s Office, all of whom agreed and signed off on her autopsy report. In 2016, when Roberson’s case was being appealed, Dr. Urban unequivocally affirmed that she “quite clearly defined multiple impact sites to the head and ruled that the death was due to blunt force injuries.”
Didn't realize the extent to which 'Innocent until proven guilty' never existed in America, and even now the constitutional right of Habeas Corpus is not in effect at this point since it is still being used to attempt to amend cases in US courts today that use the 'Guilty until proven innocent' doctrine. We all long for the day when the constitutional Habeas Corpus is finally first applied to the US justice system.
Dr Phil holds a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology. (PhD). He *is* a Doctor, but not a Medical Dr, which he has repeatedly informed the Public over the last 40 years.
Dr. Phil just explained how prejudiced opinions and insinuations can affect a criminal case very seriously. Thanks to everyone who worked so hard to shine a light on the many areas where the truth and the facts were not disclosed. Where truth does not travel, justice fails to exist. Thank you, Dr. McGraw.
Thank you, Dr. Phil, for speaking on behalf of Mr. Roberson and his daughter, hopefully, now justice will prevail, and Mr. Roberson will be able to go on with his life.
Prayers for justice
I know and it’s so sad cuz he has been there so long
Already ya know
America. Only in.
Thank you, Dr. Phil for taking action in the right direction. You give me faith in humanity.
This is the Dr Phil I appreciate and love Job well done
I have a newfound respect for Dr. Phil.
The way people are tried needs to change. There needs to be certain requirements of what needs to be addressed during the course of a trial. That this child's comprehensive medical history wasn't presented to the jury is absolutely outrageous.
Juries are only allowed to consider what is presented during the trial.
Yes… no way to stress this enough.
I can't stress your argument enough!!
Of course there’s not enough evidence to say it’s baby syndrome come on he could of been panicking and if her head was damaged that’s too happen if 😮if the baby is aldreay 😢dying of all other symptoms
Bottom line get out your line
he might be giving testimony to right a wrong, but this is also marketing to gain more viewership. phil mcgraw is a socialist and against conserving the constitution. don't be fooled just because he does one right thing. he's no better than the mainstream media networks that continue to lie, mislead and propagate on behalf of corrupt government and corporations
Bravo Dr. Phil.
Dr Phil, you are absolutely brilliant. You definitely are an audience capturer. God bless you for your hard work and dedication to others. Love and hugs from Australia.
Aww, beautiful sentiment❤
Please give this man the key and let him out of prison.
Loved hearing from him. Was real cool to hear about shadow juries.
Dr Phil is a stand up guy. Finally some commonsense it’s a great topic and again Dr Phil took the time to stand firm on his values. Thank you God!
He's actually anything but, but whatever.
I have a new level of respect for Dr. Phil. Solid testimony, sir.
I have been a Dr. Phil worshiper from day one . He is a superiorly intelligent and respectable man .❤
Agreed! Go Dr Phil, I hope he cut ties with Oprah
Amazing interview Dr. Phil
it's testimony, not an interview.
This is heartbreaking 😢 as a parent with an autistic child, this scares me as to how there is a clear lack of understanding of how neurodivergent individuals communicate differently. And how detrimental to their lives it can be. Ineffective council was most definitely an issue here also.
My son has Asperger’s and he does not have typical reaction to any emotions at all, he has one face. My son has cried twice in his life, he is 22. He cried when he was born, and when his dog died, if I die tomorrow I don’t know that he would cry. I’ve never seen him laughing, sad, and when he is upset it’s the same face he has when he’s not upset, he can’t even tell me when he’s sick. He graduated high school with a 4.0. He hasn’t gone to college because he can’t be in a room full of people, his anxiety is to the roof. He’s an awesome artist and, this is funny, he works in customer service and his manager told me he wished all his employees had Asperger’s, he works every day, never calls out, works extra hours if asked and it’s at work and hour before clocking in, if asked to work on his day off he goes to work. He’s amazing but a handful at times.
@@jackie_byfaithMy son has a bit of Asperger's and maybe have additional spectrum issues but UC Davis says he is extremely interesting and they want to continue to evaluate him.
He is a genius (always has been and figuring out his issues was difficult and he would physically manifest his emotions at school with rocks and kicks!)
But now we know and so does he.
14 now and finally gaining acceptance at school. ❤
My son basically has to dumb himself down to hang out with others because others are just so stupid. 😮😢
Luckily this difference is no longer affecting him at the same level and he's able to enjoy like-minded kids with their matching interests in Roblox and Minecraft.
Kids need experiences with other kids!
Bless our children Lord 🙏 amen 🙏
They only found out that Robert was autistic after his trial.
Exactly a fair concern and easily manipulated in an effort to have a social life. It harkens to the autistic young person killed by police in Colorado I believe.
I’m so glad they are taking this serious for Mr Robertson, as an Autistic person- my heart breaks for him. This man already had to go through the pain of losing his baby girl, who he took to the hospital 16 times because he was knew she was sick. Nurses and Doctors didn’t take that into account- and the arresting officer agrees that this man needs to be freed.
I hope he has people who will support him if he is able to be resentenced and let out.
Finally someone speaking truth
I have said for many years someone does not have to be held accountable for everything that happens. Sometimes things just happen. Someone is not always at fault. Our legal system has gone overboard with holding people accountable.
The medication given to the child is no longer used because it depresses breathing in those suffering with pneumonia. That medication may have killed her.
This sounds like a classic case of the doctors think they know everything, and the parents or adults surrounding the child know nothing
IMO the hospital was running scared...
Those with money can walk away unscathed even when guilty. A disabled person relying on a public defender.
@@loralieisa- I’m
Medical -- I agree!!!!
Our prosecutors in this country need to get their sh** together. There’s no reason other than ego that this man was convicted. Dr. Phil is saving this man’s life.
He was convicted because two witnesses saw him shake and threaten Nikki.
How do you know that 100% for sure!? They said in the Hearing that Dr. Phil testified nobody else was at the home!! If so why is Dr. Phil involved in this case & why does he want a new trial. Dr. Phil putting his name behind this is HUGE DEAL & I DOUBT he would if this man was Wrongfully Convicted!!!! Think about that!
~Kim G.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@girloninternet1188link to the source of your claim
Well done, Phil McGraw. Well done, legislators on the Texas House Committee on Criminal Jurisprudence. I am very grateful that all of you have stepped up to protect a death row inmate.
No more executions of innocent people, please. We must do our utmost to safeguard the legal system.
I also don’t believe this man should have to go through another trial at all, he has been through far too much. He should be let out immediately and awarded a extremely large sum of money to at the least start his life and also be provided with free therapy and all sorts of support to cope with all the trauma he has endured because of all the people responsible for putting him in prison. And this still will NOT be enough.
It makes perfect sense to me an innocent man would NEVER confess to murdering their child despite getting a lighter sentence.
Truth. However, people are forced every day to do exactly that.
Commute his sentence, and exonerate him of all charges.
Agreed!!!
They need to release this man and pay him for the lapse in law that had been applied to him.
This poor man was pigeonholed and his defense was under defending him to the point of not even doing their job. 😡
Thank you Dr. Phil for your due diligence, outstanding interview. Let’s pray for a good outcome and for justice for future injustice of the law. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
In the first 17 minutes, it’s proven this case needs to be reviewed. ALL medical records should be put before the jury, every single scan, every single hospital record. Science has proven that the triad of evidence for shaken baby is outdated and in fact false. This man needs to be released.
Praise the LORD FOR HIS TRUTH TALKERS🙌🏼✝️🙏🏼🛐🫶🏼🔥👻
Thank you Dr. Phil. There's no bigger, more powerful voice than yours on the planet for this horrofic injustice.
Imo The reasons why this injustice happened is because 1 basically no representation and I think most importantly, THE JUDGE EXCLUDED THE EVIDENCE. The judge is also to blame!😢😢😢😢😢
Dr.Phil is a full blown genius no one can shut him down.
The health chart alone shows it was a sick child. This man is innocent.
Common sense.
Innocent, "Bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema." are you sure.
@@jr6pc Exactly where did you obtain that information?
It was probably an election year when this first went to trial. They always want to act like a 'Justice Warrior.' Pffft. Like they have a clue what that truly means.
@loralieisa I know right? Unless your THE pathologist on the case, ot was this taken from another case!!
@loralieisa it's public knowledge .....Nikki was found to have "a bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema."[11] Additionally, four separate doctors testified Nikki had "multiple blows to different points on the head", which could not have been caused by falling off a bed.[12]
I would say standards for death penalty cases should be much higher. The defendant should be provided with the best defense council team available. The prosecutor office should NOT have total immunity.
Dr. Phil is a brilliant mind I could listen to him speak for endless hours there is knowledge in everything he says.
Do you listen to his podcast Phil in the blanks? I listen to it constantly. He is brilliant. His podcast is on all the podcast forums and UA-cam. He talks so much more in depth than his show had time for.
I forgot to mention that he discusses current cases and things. It’s fascinating to listen to him
Uhm, uhm, uhm…
Dr phil is a good dude
Why is there no punishment for officials who hide evidence that does not support their opinion. It should be seen as criminal when prosecutor, law enforcement and others hide exculpatory evidence. As Dr. Phil says, the aim should be justice not conviction. Prosecutors and police who do not understand this should be disqualified!
❤BRAVO! Im im so proud to have had U dr. Mcgrowe ❤❤ thank u so murths for ur wisdom and for shering it whit all of us who want to learrn how to live life whit integreti ❤❤❤
Wow!!! wow!
- Truly, truly ever so beautifully expressed such a compassionate statement 😢 👍
...after reading what you said; I then stopped for a moment and felt emotional tears running down face - and started to cry (in a nice way of cour) like a sense of peace went through me.. lovely example of what a true "Earth Angel " sent here actually looks like among us "Humanoids" we must wake up to this truth hopefully just that one comment that you made will make that little but much needed difference alongside with Dr Phil and his powerful voice- making such strong ever so powerfully overseen points (*_*)
Thank YOU, biggest thanks to you there. Lills ☆☆☆ gratitude overwhelmem from my heart to yours much appreciated reflection of such a heartfelt comment ❤️
I'm a bot, and I agree with this statements
Ty Dr Phil for giving your knowledge on all of this
Dr. Phil you just killed it and you know it 🎉
Thank you Dr Phil... I know you're too big to rig or cancel.. but I wish more powerful people would speak the truth
He stood up and interviewed Donald Trump as well which possibly could have caused his career much damage. But all is good.
Retrying hardly seems reasonable. The conviction ought to be overturned. The judge never reciewed the evidence. A effect counsel would have been valuable but how dare the prosecutor not have shared all the evidence during discovery. Shame on the whole system.
Free him.❤❤❤
Commute his sentence and have him sue for unlawful incarceration.
@@maureenpetitto1024 absolutely. They probably why they want him dead. He s going to get compensation for all those years. But it's still a life that was stolen.
Hopefully Dr Phil you tried to save this man life
❤❤❤❤
I disagree that a crime was not committed. The crime that was committed was lies, a horrible lawyer, judge, lack of police work and so much more. Also they took an innocent man’s life and lost years, last moments with his sick daughter and so much more.
I couldn’t agree more!!!!!!!
Why? What arguments do you have??
Kudos to Dr. Phil, thank you for your service to mankind and all of our communities. Who then is truly responsible for this tragic event? When some people treat doctors as gods and give power to the pharmaceutical industry is when we lose our freedoms . Diminish the government and take back our rights to make decisions
I’ve seen 5 year olds make a more compelling case for a donut than Robert Robertsons public defender did for him. 😭😭😭 it’s honestly a shame.
Yes, it's horrific and even worse it's not an isolated event.
Right 😂he is litterally is compared to lives to a football game
Right 😂he is litterally is compared to lives to a football game the ignorance on the panel like listen too Dr .Phil his life is precious he has a right to live and he has a daughter
Right 😂he is litterally is compared to lives to a football game the ignorance on the panel like listen too Dr .Phil his life is precious he has a right to live and he has a daughter
Well one thing is Dr.Phil was not a just a spin off of Oprah he me add his own legacy
Dr Phil thank you for all you do for others.
Dr. Phil is a true truth teller and patriot!
God speed Mr Roberson
Amen ❤
How does this trial overlook that the child had a preexisting condition ❓.
She had pneumonia and was prescribed a drug that suppresses breathing. That drug is no longer prescribed because it is known to cause death in cases of pneumonia. Hello! He should be released from prison and given all the help he needs to adjust to outside life.
Along with other health problems!
The trial judge ruled to exclude the child's medical history, so her extensive history of her pre-existing health conditions as well as her current condition at her time of death, was withheld from the jury and defense couldn't use her medical history as defense.
I miss the show Dr Phill....show I feel like it could come back but get more in depth this time love you Phill.
His podcast "Phil in the blanks" is way better than his show. He has more room to say how he really feels without having to worry about a network & their rules or agenda.
@@amberparker9883oh that's cool, is it on most podcast stations!!!
@@amberparker9883 well I never seen it. I will check it out. Thanks....
He does a show podcast on UA-cam. Phil in the blanks. Looks it up.
His show is still on air and you can also stream them.
Thank You, Dr. Phil!
What a godawful first defense attorney.
They are overworked to the extent they think if they can get a plea deal they did great work. Imagine having a total of 15-20 minutes to try to help a client?
Dr. Phil… never stop.. please. ❤
The judge is the one that didnt allow in court the medical history of this child. Therefore the judge holds the responsibility of changes and also has to be part of the fix to this problem.
Everyone involved failed this man including his counsel. Everyone should be sued including the hospital, doctors, the judge, prosecutor, the fake nurse that I swear they paid her to lie, EVERYONE of them should be held accountable.
@@jackie_byfaith
Absolutely!
Thank you Dr. Phil for speaking for this man
I have a newfound respect for Dr Phil and I didn't know his credentials.
We love you, Dr. Phil 👍 🙏 🤝 💯
Yay, Dr. Phil!!!
This is a classic case of doctor once again jumping to conclusions and not listening to the parents or adults surrounding the child
Beautifully crafted argument on Dr Phils part, he has more than seeded doubt there. Verdict certainly appears to be unsafe.
I love Dr Phil
❤Same here❤
I know from firsthand experience that a baby can have bleeding of the brain simply being born!
Dr. Phil is so spot on for so many things! Not a lot of people have that ability to think on the spot, or compile a lot of legal records. Also, most people wouldn't speak out, and if they did, it wouldn't go anywhere.
Dr Phil there are very few tv personalities that I trust but you are one that I would trust. I am an empath and can feel and hear the truth in this. He should be released and exonerated.
After seeing this, I have a lot More respect for Dr Phil . As a black , who been through BS police and the system , i know the laws here are my by enemies. I believe there are lot more innocent people either in jail or serving Time. There are so many without a strong voice, there areso many 1:12:17 injutice , it's definitely touching to see justice is being justified.
59:00 "how"?! 😟 Accountability, responsibility and an investment in human dignity has been lost.
Is this issue not protected by the federal disability act? What the heck is going on?
His autism was not brought out at the trial and in fact did not become known until sometime later. That in itself, would constitute a reexamination of the trial records, etc..
Wow! I hope he can go back and sue his council, too!
Dr Phil laying out in detail why it's NOT a shaken baby case.
Chair: what would you say if somebody said it was a shaken baby case.
Allllright
impressive !
This doesn’t surprise me that all of this was done in Texas. That state just seems to push the guilty button without thinking. And there’s so many people I bet that are in there that are innocent. Dr. Phil is a hero and so glad he has stepped in to save a man’s life.
Why would Dr Phil get involved.
SHAME on you KEN PAXTON, Mr Attorney General on you actions (or lack Thereof) in this case.
YOU NEED put out of your position for ALL your corrupt ACTIONS and COMMENTS
All about Him always Dr Phill
Good man!!
Does anyone have information in regards to the decision made by the committee in this case? I have listened to Dr. Phil and Terry Compton’s testimonies and have invested my hearts hope to the outcome…
Why isnt that atty held accountable? He should have been sued
Is he even alive?
Can I ask... Where is the mother?
?....
Yeah i want to know more.wherw was the babys mother?
💙
the attorneys that sat on this case need to be disbarred
❤❤❤❤
So odd hearing his name without the applause after 😂
Dear Phil shame on you standing up for Trump
Gee, was his "Defense" counsel a PUBLIC PRETENDER? He wasn't any good at PRETENDING, either, was he?
Representative Darby makes a great point about labeling this situation. They need to find an alternative way of classic such a sensitive thing as SBS
Is this Committee even up with the details of this case? What about all the bruises and marks on the Child?
That nurse was paid off to accuse this father that he had SA assaulted his child! This is a disgrace all around. So many people need to go to jail. So many people need to be sued and the people that put this poor innocent man in jail are 💩bricks because their credibility and their integrity went down the 💩hole. 😡
This is where I have a problem with the death penalty. This is when prosecutors are wearing blinders and are determined to get a winning charge REGARDLESS of the evidence.
They didn’t have blinders, they needed to accuse someone and close a case. That’s why we have so many innocent people on death row! It’s power and control.
I hope anyone here who doesn’t know the facts of this case goes and searches his name and Supreme Court. That poor little child. The horrors.
What? As reported by the highly biased mainstream media? No thanks.
IT'S OBVIOUS THEY WAS NOT LISTENING !
IF THEY HAVE BEEN LISTENING DOCTOR PHIL WOULDN'T HAVE TO REPEAT HIMSELF!
Having a committee meeting such as this involves the repetition of key facts. It's also standard practice for the witness to provide their written opening statement to the committee prior to the day of the committee to be approved in advance.
Dr.Phil shut up everyone down
At least phil is smarter than the defense attorney
What kind of defense lawyer throws their own client under the bus!
12 people isnt enough. Imagine only 12 people deciding who runs the country or other stuff. Happens all the time.
Thank you Lord for people like Dr.Phil, this man has been imprisoned all these years for something he didn’t do
My only question on Dr Phil ... how can you be intelligent enough in the field of psychology and NOT DETECT the EVIL in OPRAH ?????
Doesn't add up !!!!!
@@Samantha-p8q8w
OH P L E A S E !!!!
Where oh where have you been these last 70 yrs ?????
Have you zero discernment ????
@@Samantha-p8q8w She is evil!
I listen to every word from Dr Phil he did not say that the accused is gillty or innocent what he said was the accused had some issue and those issues were not addressed and there were quick conclusion render in this case baby shake and bake syndrome case also Dr Phil said the baby had medical issues and he also said he don't know if that causes the baby death ?
At one hour 5 minutes (give or take) he says he doesn't believe any crime at all was committed. It was a case of a sickly child who fell out of bed.😢
Learn how to properly write sentences. With punctuation.
@@aces553??? You didn't need to put a period puncuation after the word sentences.
The baby had been to the hospital prior to the dad being around, the baby had been to the hospital many times prior. He never did anything to that baby.
Why do people do this ? No education ? It sure makes it difficult to understand their commitments. 🤷🏼♀️
This case either needs to be reheard or the key given to him to walk out!!!!
The conclusion of the autopsy stated that the child died as a result of 9 different blunt force injuries. Perhaps Dr. Phil has not been given this information.
Then why didn't they charge him with that?
Dr. Can you look in to the 14 years old 2003 school boy Luke Mitchell scandal.. fitted up and innocent and still in jail. Please help 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Very reasonable clause to stay a death penalty recommended by Dr Phil.
Dr. Phil should testify for Richard Allen, his rights have definitely been a misjustice.
Were there ever any signs of abuse on the child before when taken to the Dr
Nikki was found to have "a bruise on the back of her shoulder, a scraped elbow, a bruise over her right eyebrow, bruises on her chin, a bruise on her left cheek, an abrasion next to her left eye, multiple bruises on the back of her head, a torn frenulum in her mouth, bruising on the inner surface of the lower lip, subscapular and subgaleal hemorrhaging between her skin and her skull, subarachnoid bleeding, subdural hematoma, both pre-retinal and retinal hemorrhages and brain edema."[11] Additionally, four separate doctors testified Nikki had "multiple blows to different points on the head", which could not have been caused by falling off a bed.[12]
@@shimmer8289 none it was true! The jury person said there was nothing in the autopsy that stated none of it. The only thing was the little bump on her head.
@jackie_byfaith this was recently released by the Attorney General it was extensive but here's a snippets....Dr. Jill Urban, the medical examiner who performed the autopsy on the two-year-old’s corpse, testified during the trial using photographic evidence that Nikki’s head had been repeatedly struck leaving clear impact wounds totally incompatible with merely being violently shaken. Dr. Urban’s findings were reviewed by six supervising medical examiners at the Dallas County Medical Examiner’s Office, all of whom agreed and signed off on her autopsy report. In 2016, when Roberson’s case was being appealed, Dr. Urban unequivocally affirmed that she “quite clearly defined multiple impact sites to the head and ruled that the death was due to blunt force injuries.”
Didn't realize the extent to which 'Innocent until proven guilty' never existed in America, and even now the constitutional right of Habeas Corpus is not in effect at this point since it is still being used to attempt to amend cases in US courts today that use the 'Guilty until proven innocent' doctrine. We all long for the day when the constitutional Habeas Corpus is finally first applied to the US justice system.
Dr. Phil is not a medical doctor
Dr Phil holds a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology. (PhD). He *is* a Doctor, but not a Medical Dr, which he has repeatedly informed the Public over the last 40 years.
No one said he was.