For real. Also, why the hell does Fincher's cinematography do that, by the way? My eyes turn into Fincher's camera for the rest of the day after I watch one of his movies.
That means your legally obligated to stay alive until he uploads the enneagram 4 video...and hopefully by then you’ll have so many other reasons to stay :)
I’m sorry you’re miserable! I’m a 4w5 as well and not the healthiest either... but there is so much still worth living for. Feeling unhealthy and/or alone isn’t all there is! Something that helps me is trying to ground myself and connect with people and realize that my current feelings & thoughts aren’t necessarily truthful or real.
I hope you’ll also stick around for the Type 5 video as it’s your wing!@@charliebeans3202 no surprise that another Type 4 gives the most validating and insightful response. #Superpower.
Dear Enneagram 1s, You are amazing, hard working, influential, natural leaders, and thoughtful (so so thoughtful) as you think out everything so deeply. You are great advice givers. You are world changers and difference makers. You do the work others don't want to. You care about the little things and the people who often go unnoticed. You speak out for the oppressed, standing up for what is right. You are honest and truthful. You are fun. Yes fun! When you are in good health you are a joy to be around. You might correct and perfect but its only because you see the potential in things. You love so big in your own ways. You are the first to take up responsibility and do it with little compliant. You are a stable person in other people's lives and a friend people can count on. You change the world by improving the small things. Because the small things often turn out to be the big things. We love you ones! Thank you for making the world a more safe, effective, strong and beautiful place. Love, An Enneagram 2
YO! I've never seen Black Swan but knowing that it ends not with her accepting her flaws as she is but KILLING them and becoming perfect no matter the cost is amazing and would be so cathartic for me, a 1.
@@arowace498 I know! :) It's like the end of Nightcrawler or Whiplash, they don't give you the typical twist swerve ending you expect. Too many movies nowadays are too scared to do anything out of the norm in plot structure like this
I can’t explain how big of an impact this series is already having on me and how I’m able to view people as complex, but ultimately cut from the same cloth. I’m so so so excited ☺️
Just have to say, you are brilliant and these videos on enneagram are so well informed and easy to follow. The dissection of type one was so interesting to watch, especially as someone who had previously mistyped myself as a one. I'm really looking forward to learning more about the other types, and of course eventually my own!
These are actually amazing. I'm a 1 and I can not tell you how sick I am of "ones are the clean perfectionists" and they care about little details of everything and they always follow the rules" which just makes us sound like rigid freaks. I break rules all the time if I think they're stupid and I like things being clean and tidy but not a whole lot more than anyone else. I really appreciate how you stick to the core motivations and what it actually means to be a 1 - the inner critic, the struggle with anger, the passion for our own sense of justice etc. Rather than the little behavioural things that we don't all display like being a neat freak or loving lists and having post-its everywhere. Absolutely nailed it in a really fair and objective way - just like how us ones like it. Can't wait for more videos :)
I am so happy you spoke about unhealthy/healthy types as well as 'social, self-preservation and one-to-one' too!!! I seriously can't wait for the type 9 video to come out
You said in your intro video that you'd know your type when it made you uncomfortable, embarrassed, and made you cry. You did this in this one. It really hit me when you described the Iron Man and Captain America story arcs. I always knew they spoke to me on a really deep level, and you just made it make so much sense as to why. Thank you for making this video. It really touched me
Loooove this series !!! I feel like Chidi Anagonye is also a good example of a transition from an unhealthy to a healthy type one throughout the Good Place
@@shockingheaven yeah he's generally typed in the community as a 6w5 [because it's ultimately his indecision that kills him and 1s are much more sure of their own opinions] but it's his fixation with *moral* philosophy that makes him very relatable to us 1s (:
As a one, I 100% agree that Chidi is a one. Ones (like myself) can be very indecisive and hyper fixated on making the “right” decision (even though, as we figure out in growth, that there is no right decision in life). He literally spends his life learning about right and wrong. He’s the epitome of a self preservation one paralyzed by wanting to be “right” or “good”. To those who say he is a 6, SP ones can mistype as 6 and Vice versa🤷🏻♀️. To me, it seems like his fear is more out of whether his decision will make him a good or bad person (which puts a ton of weight on that decision). Being fearful doesn’t automatically make him a 6. Also, Eleanor is definitely a seven and they tend to play off of each other just like any one-seven pairing
Can't WAIT for Five (my type)! I personally relate a lot to One so this was so eye-opening, THANK YOU. 16:00 "...Ones realise that they aren't guilty for disobeying their inner-critic, nor obligated to obey it." Brilliant.
Really well done! I have an Enneagram 1 brother that I always refer to as a modern day medieval knight, but like the chivalrous and upright version. Can't wait for the rest of the series.
AMAZING content!! Can’t wait for the others -knowing I’ll wait a lot for my number 9. (Though I do see Tony stark more as a three, it makes sense he’s a 7)
I just discovered that enneagram through a school project. Of course, nobody exactly fits the mold to the letter, however, this system as well as your videos and explanation, has helped me understand a lot about myself. It is uncanny, however, somewhat comforting how much I fit the description of a reformer. It's almost like a sigh of relief.
Top notch stuff!! This is honestly what I’ve needed for so long. An opportunity to not just hear about types but see them in their experience and development! Thank you so much 👏
So I have a family member I consider to be a bit to reliant on the enneagram to see the world and others. A bit black and white per say (yes they're a one). Anyway despite being very familiar with these concepts you helped me understand that person better. Thanks. Also I just really enjoy how well put together and thoughtful your videos are.
I love both the enneagram and movies so this is like a dream come true. I love seeing your takes on all the characters and I’m excited for not just my type but all the types you’ll cover.
Bro, I literally checked your channel this weekend to see if you'd posted this yet, so glad to see it's out. I understand how much effort this takes. As a 1, thank you What you are doing is a beautiful and compelling integration to 2 powerful things: deeper self-awareness through the enneagram, and the transformative captivation of engaging storytelling. Eagerly awaiting all the rest
0:00 - Intro to Type One 0:25 - Description of Ones (correcting injustice, in conflict with feelings/Impulses, desires to improve self and world) 2:00 - Weaknesses of Ones (they can overdo focus on ideals that they engage in emotional passion: anger) 3:05 - One's Connect to Four and Seven (move to four in unhealth, move to seven in health/growth) 3:27 - Instinctual Subtypes (self-preservation ones seek perfection of self, social ones believe they know the right way to be, 1-to-1 One try to perfect others/environment) 3:53 - Ones in Movies (themes: justice, order, grace. Ones make good heroes 😎 and villains 😈) 4:45 - Unhealthy Ones (high cost to pursuit of perfection. Obsessed, Repressed, and Destructive) 5:17 - Natalie Portman's Character in Black Swan (unhealthy self-preservation one) 6:38 - Javert in Les Miserables (unhealthy social one) 7:20 - Thanos, Frolo, John Doe, Ra's al Ghul (unhealthy 1-to-1 one) 8:13 - Examining Ones through Batman Trilogy (Bruce Wayne healthy 1-to-1 one) 11:11 - Average Type Ones in Film (Hermione Granger, Nicholas Angel in Hot Fuzz, Will Turner from Pirates, Andrew Garfield's character in Silence) 12:33 - Healthy Type Ones in Film (Captain America, King T'Challa, Atticus Finch, Prince Ashitaka, Juror #8, Dumbledore) 15:10 - Andy Dufresne | Shawshank Redemption (starts unhealthy, moves to health, leads to reformation of Shawshank) 16:28 - The Ending that you should really watch because Josh Keefe put a ton of effort into this.
I think I'm a 4w3 but I can't wait to watch all of the videos to see what rings true. I didn't expect to connect with type 1 but honestly some of it rang a bit true so I'm excited to see all of your videos
This is great. Very well done Josh. I"m somewhat new to the Enneagram but I really appreciate how much you actually know the movies and the characters that you use to illustrate different types. I've seen similar videos where people try and use comic book characters or super hero comparing them with Enneagram numbers where it was clear that the person really didn't know enough about these characters to make such easements. So as a 1, I especially appreciate your due diligence in this regard. Keep up the great work! Looking forward to the other 8 videos in the series!
I gotta say Josh, it is so amazing to see someone so young understanding these things so clearly. Your research is obviously thorough and you're presenting these FACTS of daily interpersonal life in such an accessible way. My wife and I have been studying these things for years and we are in awe of your analysis and "decryption" of these slender threads that bind us together as humans. Keep up the AMAZING work!
Wow this moved me on a deep level. Made previous insight from learning about the Enneagram solidify more. When you can identify how certain movie characters and the themes they go through apply to your own life, it gives you a whole new perspective and clarity on your own patterns and what you need to do to be healthier/how to integrate. Thanks man!!
This is really good! I can’t wait to see more! (But actually I can - sometimes quality takes time and I do prefer quality over quantity, so technically speaking, I really *can* wait for the next one. So keep up the good work!)
The silence the deconstruction of faith was one of my top videos and was about to share it with my family If you can bring it back up that would be greatly appreciated
Loved the video, can't wait to see more! But I feel like Tony is more of an 8 than a 7. He's so afraid of weakness that he literally builds a suit of armor around himself and tries to build one around the world (Ultron). And he follows the 8 arrows: when he's unhealthy he becomes secretive and fearful like a 5, and when he's healthy he becomes more caring like a 2. Just my thoughts though!
This is actually a very interesting take on Tony and I'm tempted to agree with you actually. But he could also be a disintegrating 7 who moves towards 1. 8s follow rules, Tony enjoys breaking them (7). Just my thoughts
@@bettymbuyi6246 Thanks! I have to disagree about 8s following the rules though. 8s--known as "the challengers"--are assertive contrarians who test people and systems, because their core fear is being weak and controlled by others. So they definitely don't follow other people's rules when they don't want to. Healthier 8s are fierce protectors for their loved ones and anyone they perceive to be weak. To me that sounds way more like Tony than the description for 7s, who are versatile, optimistic, and mostly just looking to have a good time. Source: www.enneagraminstitute.com/type-8
This is really something special. Thank you for putting this together. Exploring the Enneagram through a cogent analysis of film is exactly what my geek side needed. Can't wait to see more.
So happy to be a one right now. It's the fact that both batman, captain america, and black panther are the same enneagram as me but more so that I won't have to wait for my own video.
Really liked this and the other enneagram videos, explained through movie characters. I hope you have some spare time in the future to complete the other types who lack a video.
This is such an insightful, unique, compelling video - I love the exploration of psychology through cinema. It can make it all feel a lot more instantly relatable. I can't wait for Type Four (and the others too, of course...but especially Four :P ) !!
Spot on! I love 7’s and always admire 3’s. Never ends well w/ 3’s because the ones I knew sacrificed morals for achievement/short term highs which irks my entire being. I know this is not everyone.
Hey. I just wanted to say, I saw the first video you said, you're making a ten parter of all the types. You are really dedicated to explaining this personality test right. and, I know what I am now thanks to you. I really hope each video is appreciated and I'll be watching 4's very closely. I love this whole idea. you are inspiring
Good video. A few corrections, though: 1. Judge Frollo is a social subtype. The description of so1 fits him better. Take a look at sx1 and so1 by Naranjo or Beatrice Chestnut. Typing judge Frollo as sx1 is misunderstanding of sx and so types or him as a character. A way to see the diffrence between a sp/so/sx 1: Sp1: "I must be better" So1: "the people around me and I must be better" Sx1: "the people around me must be better" 2. Dolores Ambrige is a so2. A very common mistype. Again, take a look at so2 by Naranjo. A way to check: 1 disintegrates into 4, 2 disintegrates into 8. Dolores Ambrige shows no traits of so4, but alot of so8 (being dominating, powerhungry, getting things only her way) 3. Joker from 2012 Batman is sx 4. Again, read Naranjo. Sx4 motto is: "I suffer, so I will make you suffer too". He is jealous of people of Gotham, and wants to bring up the worst in them. Sx7 are more focused on escaping negative feelings 4. Batman is a sp1. I am not even going to comment - read the book The video is nicely edited and narrated, but it has mistakes in understanding of enneagram and in character analysis. This kind of shallow analysis spreads misinformation and undermines the complexity and beauty of psychology behind typing sistems
I used to think I was a 7, but I'm 100% a Self Pres. 1. I feel the need to become perfect. Growing up I was told so many things about my family that I consider bad. My whole family are recovering drug users and alcoholics and I feel the need to be perfect. However not for them, I've never been the academic student that can maintain perfect grades for my family rather I do it for myself. I want to prove that I'm not like them to myself. I want to become a lawyer and make a change in the system I see as corrupt or imperfect. However out of the need for control due to my past mistakes I decided to take control of my impulses and compulses. I won't become an addict even with my addictive personality because of the control I maintain. But since all this I've made a lot of self growth. I've gained the ability to accept the lack of control and lack of perfections. Right now what I seek is to live a life of bbalance.I've accepted perfections don't exist and I can't make everything perfect.
This is amazing!! As a type one I can attest that this was both accurate and helpful for me. If quality content like this takes a while, take your time; we love it, but we’ll wait patiently as long as you need!
@14:11 Another interesting thing here to keep in mind is that Captain America and Iron Man have opposite MBTIs, the former being ISFJ and the latter being ENTP. So it’s not just a clash of core enneagram motivations, but also how they perceive and judge the world. Massive growth opportunities for both heroes (but not without a lot of conflict and friction between them understandably)
MORE VIDEOS! MORE VIDEOS! Give the people what they want!!! Seriously, I have enjoyed and shared and am thirsty for more. I appreciate your wit and even though I'm a decade or so ahead of you, it sounds like we had the same childhood. (I participated in a puppet team that performed veggie tale songs for your generation). I'm also neuro a-typical and appreciate the enegram being explained through characters I know and the metaphor of cinema I understand. Great job in this creative expression. You're helping others grow. You're very good at this.
Please please please, continue this series! I assume it’s not dead, I’m just worried because this video hasn’t gotten that many views. I love the editing because I get to be reminded of how many awesome movies there are. I also like learning more about the enneagram. Can’t wait for the next video.
I'd just like to say thanks for this video. It helped me to realize areas in my life where I've been perfectionistic and set me on a journey of understanding myself better. I've got a lot to work through, but at least I'm a bit more aware. I hope you're doing okay.
This video is so good, it has me, a 9w1, questioning if I am really a 1 instead. Good job. I am subscribing so I can hopefully see your video on 9s... judging from the time in between uploads... in 3 years. I'm kidding. There is some truth to that, isn't there? Haha 😉 Great video!!
I think some of those characters in your video are 4s with a strong arrow to 1. 4s also want to be perfect to be loved whereas 1s want to be perfect to feel they are in control. Different motivation, similar behaviour. The character in black swan is a 4 in my opinion, she is using perfection to find her value.
I WISH I had the binge watching option
my god SAME
I hate that as a 9 I will have to wait forever for the 9 video, but thanks for making these!! They are awesome!!!
LOL same here...sort of as a type 7
Same but type 8
Hate to be a 9. I wish im 6
Lol yess!!! Me too 😭😭😭😭😭
Same hahaha but sure I'll enjoy the whole series :)
*I've been thinking about the Enneagram video for 3 months* you hacked my brain like David Fincher's cinematography
For real. Also, why the hell does Fincher's cinematography do that, by the way? My eyes turn into Fincher's camera for the rest of the day after I watch one of his movies.
I had no idea how common a type 1 and type 7 duo was, I am a type 1 and both my fiance and best friend are type 7's! Wild!
Wow that's neat! I was surprised as well to look though enneagram 👀
No!!! I wish it wasn’t over!!! Can’t wait for the whole rest of the series!!!
same here!!
This is seems like zodiacs or whatever they are called
Worthless personality categories
@@vintheguy it’s a tool. you don’t have to use it.
@@freebeerishere
Rather shit tool though
@@vintheguy uhhh yeah exactly
I'm unhealthy and miserable 4w5 and honestltly me wanting to see a video about type 4 is what keeps me alive
[sends hugs]
That means your legally obligated to stay alive until he uploads the enneagram 4 video...and hopefully by then you’ll have so many other reasons to stay :)
I’m sorry you’re miserable! I’m a 4w5 as well and not the healthiest either... but there is so much still worth living for. Feeling unhealthy and/or alone isn’t all there is! Something that helps me is trying to ground myself and connect with people and realize that my current feelings & thoughts aren’t necessarily truthful or real.
I hope you’ll also stick around for the Type 5 video as it’s your wing!@@charliebeans3202 no surprise that another Type 4 gives the most validating and insightful response. #Superpower.
i'm a 4w5 and also waiting ugh
Dear Enneagram 1s,
You are amazing, hard working, influential, natural leaders, and thoughtful (so so thoughtful) as you think out everything so deeply. You are great advice givers. You are world changers and difference makers. You do the work others don't want to. You care about the little things and the people who often go unnoticed. You speak out for the oppressed, standing up for what is right. You are honest and truthful. You are fun. Yes fun! When you are in good health you are a joy to be around. You might correct and perfect but its only because you see the potential in things. You love so big in your own ways. You are the first to take up responsibility and do it with little compliant. You are a stable person in other people's lives and a friend people can count on. You change the world by improving the small things. Because the small things often turn out to be the big things. We love you ones! Thank you for making the world a more safe, effective, strong and beautiful place.
Love,
An Enneagram 2
As someone struggling with being a 1. Thank you for this, it made me tear up.
This was SO beautiful. Thank you! 💗
Okay, I was already tearing up during the analysis, now I'm crying. Thank you 🥲🤍
I feel so seen!
What a blessing to read ☺️
YO! I've never seen Black Swan but knowing that it ends not with her accepting her flaws as she is but KILLING them and becoming perfect no matter the cost is amazing and would be so cathartic for me, a 1.
Yeah I’ve never seen that movie either but it looks awesome, glad it was mentioned in this vid
I don't mean to burst your bubble but I don't think it's supposed to be a triumphant moment
It's a really amazing movie, definitely recommended
@@arowace498 I know! :) It's like the end of Nightcrawler or Whiplash, they don't give you the typical twist swerve ending you expect. Too many movies nowadays are too scared to do anything out of the norm in plot structure like this
@@arowace498 i don't think anyone would doubt that xD
SO sorry you got spoiled the ending though, it was SUCH an amazing, hypnotizing experience :)
I can’t explain how big of an impact this series is already having on me and how I’m able to view people as complex, but ultimately cut from the same cloth. I’m so so so excited ☺️
Just have to say, you are brilliant and these videos on enneagram are so well informed and easy to follow. The dissection of type one was so interesting to watch, especially as someone who had previously mistyped myself as a one. I'm really looking forward to learning more about the other types, and of course eventually my own!
These are actually amazing. I'm a 1 and I can not tell you how sick I am of "ones are the clean perfectionists" and they care about little details of everything and they always follow the rules" which just makes us sound like rigid freaks. I break rules all the time if I think they're stupid and I like things being clean and tidy but not a whole lot more than anyone else. I really appreciate how you stick to the core motivations and what it actually means to be a 1 - the inner critic, the struggle with anger, the passion for our own sense of justice etc. Rather than the little behavioural things that we don't all display like being a neat freak or loving lists and having post-its everywhere. Absolutely nailed it in a really fair and objective way - just like how us ones like it. Can't wait for more videos :)
I am so happy you spoke about unhealthy/healthy types as well as 'social, self-preservation and one-to-one' too!!! I seriously can't wait for the type 9 video to come out
You said in your intro video that you'd know your type when it made you uncomfortable, embarrassed, and made you cry. You did this in this one.
It really hit me when you described the Iron Man and Captain America story arcs. I always knew they spoke to me on a really deep level, and you just made it make so much sense as to why.
Thank you for making this video. It really touched me
Loooove this series !!! I feel like Chidi Anagonye is also a good example of a transition from an unhealthy to a healthy type one throughout the Good Place
I thought he was a 6w5
@@shockingheaven yeah he's generally typed in the community as a 6w5 [because it's ultimately his indecision that kills him and 1s are much more sure of their own opinions] but it's his fixation with *moral* philosophy that makes him very relatable to us 1s (:
As a one, I 100% agree that Chidi is a one. Ones (like myself) can be very indecisive and hyper fixated on making the “right” decision (even though, as we figure out in growth, that there is no right decision in life). He literally spends his life learning about right and wrong. He’s the epitome of a self preservation one paralyzed by wanting to be “right” or “good”. To those who say he is a 6, SP ones can mistype as 6 and Vice versa🤷🏻♀️. To me, it seems like his fear is more out of whether his decision will make him a good or bad person (which puts a ton of weight on that decision). Being fearful doesn’t automatically make him a 6.
Also, Eleanor is definitely a seven and they tend to play off of each other just like any one-seven pairing
😭 I loved that show to death as an infp
I have a 1 wing and watching characters overcoming their problems and becoming a healthy type one never gets boring!
Can't WAIT for Five (my type)! I personally relate a lot to One so this was so eye-opening, THANK YOU.
16:00 "...Ones realise that they aren't guilty for disobeying their inner-critic, nor obligated to obey it." Brilliant.
The idea for this video series didn't strike me as compelling enough to deserve so much work... I've already been proved wrong, great job!
Really well done! I have an Enneagram 1 brother that I always refer to as a modern day medieval knight, but like the chivalrous and upright version. Can't wait for the rest of the series.
The return of the king
YES! First a video on the enneagram in general, now one on Type 1s: I’m seeing a pattern and I like where this is going!
me a type 9 realizing i’m gonna have to wait for months for the type 9 video 🧍♀️
I cannot wait for the rest of the series’s, I’m so hooked
So excited for this series. I’m a type 3 so hopefully I don’t have to wait as long as others for my type to be covered ;)
AMAZING content!! Can’t wait for the others -knowing I’ll wait a lot for my number 9.
(Though I do see Tony stark more as a three, it makes sense he’s a 7)
More of an 8
I just discovered that enneagram through a school project. Of course, nobody exactly fits the mold to the letter, however, this system as well as your videos and explanation, has helped me understand a lot about myself. It is uncanny, however, somewhat comforting how much I fit the description of a reformer. It's almost like a sigh of relief.
Finally!!!
My fave content creator is BACK ✨
This is the best enneagram video I’ve ever seen
Top notch stuff!! This is honestly what I’ve needed for so long. An opportunity to not just hear about types but see them in their experience and development! Thank you so much 👏
Genuinely excited for the rest of this series!
So I have a family member I consider to be a bit to reliant on the enneagram to see the world and others. A bit black and white per say (yes they're a one). Anyway despite being very familiar with these concepts you helped me understand that person better. Thanks. Also I just really enjoy how well put together and thoughtful your videos are.
I love both the enneagram and movies so this is like a dream come true. I love seeing your takes on all the characters and I’m excited for not just my type but all the types you’ll cover.
Please keep making these, they are so fun and make enneagram so simple to understand.
Bro, I literally checked your channel this weekend to see if you'd posted this yet, so glad to see it's out. I understand how much effort this takes. As a 1, thank you
What you are doing is a beautiful and compelling integration to 2 powerful things: deeper self-awareness through the enneagram, and the transformative captivation of engaging storytelling.
Eagerly awaiting all the rest
0:00 - Intro to Type One
0:25 - Description of Ones (correcting injustice, in conflict with feelings/Impulses, desires to improve self and world)
2:00 - Weaknesses of Ones (they can overdo focus on ideals that they engage in emotional passion: anger)
3:05 - One's Connect to Four and Seven (move to four in unhealth, move to seven in health/growth)
3:27 - Instinctual Subtypes (self-preservation ones seek perfection of self, social ones believe they know the right way to be, 1-to-1 One try to perfect others/environment)
3:53 - Ones in Movies (themes: justice, order, grace. Ones make good heroes 😎 and villains 😈)
4:45 - Unhealthy Ones (high cost to pursuit of perfection. Obsessed, Repressed, and Destructive)
5:17 - Natalie Portman's Character in Black Swan (unhealthy self-preservation one)
6:38 - Javert in Les Miserables (unhealthy social one)
7:20 - Thanos, Frolo, John Doe, Ra's al Ghul (unhealthy 1-to-1 one)
8:13 - Examining Ones through Batman Trilogy (Bruce Wayne healthy 1-to-1 one)
11:11 - Average Type Ones in Film (Hermione Granger, Nicholas Angel in Hot Fuzz, Will Turner from Pirates, Andrew Garfield's character in Silence)
12:33 - Healthy Type Ones in Film (Captain America, King T'Challa, Atticus Finch, Prince Ashitaka, Juror #8, Dumbledore)
15:10 - Andy Dufresne | Shawshank Redemption (starts unhealthy, moves to health, leads to reformation of Shawshank)
16:28 - The Ending that you should really watch because Josh Keefe put a ton of effort into this.
I mainly wrote the timeframes out to mainly help me as I come back to this video time and again (because I'm a one)! Hope it's helpful to others 😀
I’m more excited for this series than almost any tv show. Can’t wait for the next videooooo
I think I'm a 4w3 but I can't wait to watch all of the videos to see what rings true. I didn't expect to connect with type 1 but honestly some of it rang a bit true so I'm excited to see all of your videos
im so glad you talked about how iron man and captain américa have opposite arcs in the MCU
🙌🏽 High five from this Enneagram 5 creator! Loving this series!!! ❤️. Enneagram is a game changer.
This is great. Very well done Josh. I"m somewhat new to the Enneagram but I really appreciate how much you actually know the movies and the characters that you use to illustrate different types. I've seen similar videos where people try and use comic book characters or super hero comparing them with Enneagram numbers where it was clear that the person really didn't know enough about these characters to make such easements. So as a 1, I especially appreciate your due diligence in this regard. Keep up the great work! Looking forward to the other 8 videos in the series!
I gotta say Josh, it is so amazing to see someone so young understanding these things so clearly. Your research is obviously thorough and you're presenting these FACTS of daily interpersonal life in such an accessible way. My wife and I have been studying these things for years and we are in awe of your analysis and "decryption" of these slender threads that bind us together as humans. Keep up the AMAZING work!
Wow this moved me on a deep level. Made previous insight from learning about the Enneagram solidify more. When you can identify how certain movie characters and the themes they go through apply to your own life, it gives you a whole new perspective and clarity on your own patterns and what you need to do to be healthier/how to integrate. Thanks man!!
Have had youtube for years, legit just allowed notifications for the first time ever. all because this series
This is really good! I can’t wait to see more!
(But actually I can - sometimes quality takes time and I do prefer quality over quantity, so technically speaking, I really *can* wait for the next one. So keep up the good work!)
The silence the deconstruction of faith
was one of my top videos and was about to share it with my family
If you can bring it back up that would be greatly appreciated
Black Swan is such a perfect film to portray the internalised unhealthy type 1. Truly the new blueprint for the downfall of the obsessed artist trope
Loved the video, can't wait to see more! But I feel like Tony is more of an 8 than a 7. He's so afraid of weakness that he literally builds a suit of armor around himself and tries to build one around the world (Ultron). And he follows the 8 arrows: when he's unhealthy he becomes secretive and fearful like a 5, and when he's healthy he becomes more caring like a 2. Just my thoughts though!
This is actually a very interesting take on Tony and I'm tempted to agree with you actually. But he could also be a disintegrating 7 who moves towards 1. 8s follow rules, Tony enjoys breaking them (7). Just my thoughts
@@bettymbuyi6246 Thanks! I have to disagree about 8s following the rules though. 8s--known as "the challengers"--are assertive contrarians who test people and systems, because their core fear is being weak and controlled by others. So they definitely don't follow other people's rules when they don't want to. Healthier 8s are fierce protectors for their loved ones and anyone they perceive to be weak. To me that sounds way more like Tony than the description for 7s, who are versatile, optimistic, and mostly just looking to have a good time. Source: www.enneagraminstitute.com/type-8
This is really something special. Thank you for putting this together. Exploring the Enneagram through a cogent analysis of film is exactly what my geek side needed. Can't wait to see more.
Your description of type 1 made me cried. I never felt as understood as I watched your video. Thank you ❤️🙏
So happy to be a one right now. It's the fact that both batman, captain america, and black panther are the same enneagram as me but more so that I won't have to wait for my own video.
I cant wait for the 5 video 🙌 do we know when the next one is coming I'm too excited!
PLEASE make the rest! This was incredible!
i literally knew nothing about this stuff and now im utterly fascinated CAN YOU PLEASE make the other videos im already starving
Really liked this and the other enneagram videos, explained through movie characters. I hope you have some spare time in the future to complete the other types who lack a video.
This video put my life in a new perspective. Thank you. I can't wait to see the rest of your series.
as a cinephile & type one, this was so well done. thank you my day is made :)
This is such an insightful, unique, compelling video - I love the exploration of psychology through cinema. It can make it all feel a lot more instantly relatable. I can't wait for Type Four (and the others too, of course...but especially Four :P ) !!
Spot on! I love 7’s and always admire 3’s. Never ends well w/ 3’s because the ones I knew sacrificed morals for achievement/short term highs which irks my entire being. I know this is not everyone.
THANK YOU for giving the timestamp to avoid spoilers!
Hey. I just wanted to say, I saw the first video you said, you're making a ten parter of all the types. You are really dedicated to explaining this personality test right. and, I know what I am now thanks to you. I really hope each video is appreciated and I'll be watching 4's very closely. I love this whole idea. you are inspiring
the healthiest 1's not only discover grace for themselves, but give grace to others as well. loved it!
The Batman journey was honestly perfect to showcase ones. Great thinking!
Can’t wait for this series to be completed!
Dude i was just wondering earlier today when you're going to release the enneagram series😂😂😂
I did indeed find this long after it was uploaded, and I can now binge on the whole series! Thanks for this great series!
My husband is a 1, and I have watched this video twice. It is so spot on!
Wow. This is so accurate. This fits my entire life. Thank you.
Good video. A few corrections, though:
1. Judge Frollo is a social subtype. The description of so1 fits him better. Take a look at sx1 and so1 by Naranjo or Beatrice Chestnut. Typing judge Frollo as sx1 is misunderstanding of sx and so types or him as a character. A way to see the diffrence between a sp/so/sx 1:
Sp1: "I must be better"
So1: "the people around me and I must be better"
Sx1: "the people around me must be better"
2. Dolores Ambrige is a so2. A very common mistype. Again, take a look at so2 by Naranjo. A way to check: 1 disintegrates into 4, 2 disintegrates into 8. Dolores Ambrige shows no traits of so4, but alot of so8 (being dominating, powerhungry, getting things only her way)
3. Joker from 2012 Batman is sx 4. Again, read Naranjo. Sx4 motto is: "I suffer, so I will make you suffer too". He is jealous of people of Gotham, and wants to bring up the worst in them. Sx7 are more focused on escaping negative feelings
4. Batman is a sp1. I am not even going to comment - read the book
The video is nicely edited and narrated, but it has mistakes in understanding of enneagram and in character analysis. This kind of shallow analysis spreads misinformation and undermines the complexity and beauty of psychology behind typing sistems
What I've seen thus far -- intro, types 1,2, and 3 -- are freakin brilliant. Keep up your fabulous work, Josh.
Please keep doing these! I'm very excited to see the other ones.
Oh boy, I'm going to have to wait for a while until type 9.
Can't wait to see Enneagram 4 in Film!!!
My midroll ad was about enneagrams lol. Nice job.
I've literally been waiting and checking your channel every so often for MONTHS in anticipation for this series!! You did not disappoint! Great job!
as an INFJ 1w2 i feel very out of place in what seems like a world of 7s and 4s, but this video was unexpectedly cathartic. thank you (:
I used to think I was a 7, but I'm 100% a Self Pres. 1. I feel the need to become perfect. Growing up I was told so many things about my family that I consider bad. My whole family are recovering drug users and alcoholics and I feel the need to be perfect. However not for them, I've never been the academic student that can maintain perfect grades for my family rather I do it for myself. I want to prove that I'm not like them to myself. I want to become a lawyer and make a change in the system I see as corrupt or imperfect. However out of the need for control due to my past mistakes I decided to take control of my impulses and compulses. I won't become an addict even with my addictive personality because of the control I maintain. But since all this I've made a lot of self growth. I've gained the ability to accept the lack of control and lack of perfections. Right now what I seek is to live a life of bbalance.I've accepted perfections don't exist and I can't make everything perfect.
I love this series and hope you continue
This is amazing!! As a type one I can attest that this was both accurate and helpful for me. If quality content like this takes a while, take your time; we love it, but we’ll wait patiently as long as you need!
*me picking my skin*
"They pick at their skin"
The way i jumped.😂
This Video is Amazing. Thank you so much for making it !!
Okay watching this definitely made me understand type 1 better ngl, thanks for making and sharing this series! I look forward to watching the rest
This is great. Can't wait for the other eight.
@14:11 Another interesting thing here to keep in mind is that Captain America and Iron Man have opposite MBTIs, the former being ISFJ and the latter being ENTP. So it’s not just a clash of core enneagram motivations, but also how they perceive and judge the world. Massive growth opportunities for both heroes (but not without a lot of conflict and friction between them understandably)
I think I just found my new favorite YT series. Amazing work!!
I adore the way you explore how the different enneagram types manifest based on the sx/so/sp focuses
MORE VIDEOS! MORE VIDEOS!
Give the people what they want!!!
Seriously, I have enjoyed and shared and am thirsty for more.
I appreciate your wit and even though I'm a decade or so ahead of you, it sounds like we had the same childhood.
(I participated in a puppet team that performed veggie tale songs for your generation).
I'm also neuro a-typical and appreciate the enegram being explained through characters I know and the metaphor of cinema I understand.
Great job in this creative expression. You're helping others grow.
You're very good at this.
I just know that getting to type two is gonna hurt, cause that’s where I tend to fall on the enneagram. I’m gonna get read like a book
I’m looking forward to seeing your book read
Please please please, continue this series! I assume it’s not dead, I’m just worried because this video hasn’t gotten that many views. I love the editing because I get to be reminded of how many awesome movies there are. I also like learning more about the enneagram. Can’t wait for the next video.
THIS VIDEO IS AMAZING! I can't WAIT to see all the other types!!!
Honestly I would really love to see this kind of video for all the enneagrams 😍
Man, I just found your channel. And it's awesome!
Please keep working towards finishing these. You do such a great job.
I'd just like to say thanks for this video. It helped me to realize areas in my life where I've been perfectionistic and set me on a journey of understanding myself better. I've got a lot to work through, but at least I'm a bit more aware. I hope you're doing okay.
This video is so good, it has me, a 9w1, questioning if I am really a 1 instead. Good job. I am subscribing so I can hopefully see your video on 9s... judging from the time in between uploads... in 3 years. I'm kidding.
There is some truth to that, isn't there? Haha 😉 Great video!!
This is an insanely cool series. I'm not even a 1, and I watched this whole video with rapt interest. Can't wait to see more.
I'm so excited for the 4 video, but also very nervous because it's pretty common for people to really fuck up when it comes to explaining fours
I think some of those characters in your video are 4s with a strong arrow to 1. 4s also want to be perfect to be loved whereas 1s want to be perfect to feel they are in control. Different motivation, similar behaviour. The character in black swan is a 4 in my opinion, she is using perfection to find her value.
Thank you for this!! It's so much easier to remember the types with video references. 🙌
well worth the wait, looking forward to seeing more
somehow, this describes Light Yagami so well! He is the perfect example of an unhealthy one. It is also so strange as to how similar he is to Thanos-