A Song of Ice and Fire the Miniatures Game: 2023 Update Baratheon, Targaryen, Greyjoy, and Martell

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 38

  • @sylspren9007
    @sylspren9007 Рік тому +9

    I wish they'd left Expert Duelest at 3+, but on failure the controller dies having lost the duel..

    • @barneytolentino5980
      @barneytolentino5980 Рік тому

      Nah. It’s still great as is. The +1 Wound will be used more now.

    • @Ghislain82
      @Ghislain82 Рік тому

      They also got rid of the big 3 point Relentless attachments. There was already an opinion in the competitive community that the auto wound was better, now with the high point attachment gone and lower sucess rate now it's just an auto wound.

    • @sylspren9007
      @sylspren9007 Рік тому

      @@Ghislain82 except victarion who remained 3pts. I wonder if that was a mistake.

    • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
      @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

      ​@@barneytolentino5980 in competetive play the auto wound was the option that was picked 90+% of the time. ED was only a problem for casual players

    • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
      @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

      ​@@sylspren9007 they have confirmed that it was not. Which is bonkers but whatever he wouldn't really be worth it at 2 anyways

  • @woodyrobinson9628
    @woodyrobinson9628 Рік тому

    Brian you always do a FANTASTIC JOB

  • @JohnLopez-kr6cu
    @JohnLopez-kr6cu Рік тому

    Love the in-depth analysis you put I your videos. Keep the material coming.

  • @luiscamejo2379
    @luiscamejo2379 Рік тому +2

    I use Qarl often but I am glad they bumped expert duelist up to 5 because it makes the game fairer. My favorite change is that to blacktyde's chosen. I love fielding them pre change and the new ability is even better. Can't wait for Greyjoy attachments

  • @woodyrobinson9628
    @woodyrobinson9628 Рік тому +1

    Thank you sir.
    Much appreciated & enjoyable content

  • @Robbykesterton
    @Robbykesterton Рік тому

    Relentless also isn’t an order, which makes it really strong. As a Targ player, I love it now.

  • @jurtmcalic7074
    @jurtmcalic7074 Рік тому

    Thank you for making these videos!

  • @Robbykesterton
    @Robbykesterton Рік тому

    After initially being a little concerned by the changes, I’ve played some games and realised how well CMON have judged the extent of changes. I’m really impressed by the balance fixes in the game. Just Mel Casino to fix now.

  • @francoislatulippe7183
    @francoislatulippe7183 Рік тому

    About the vassal change: counting as the name for all abilities and effect.
    I think this was worded this way specifically for Satin. He can bond with Ghost the same way Jon can because of this.
    The wording then for all vassals wouldve been the same to prevent interpretations, mistakes and other faq. But im pretty sure Satin is the only one who has access to an ability refering to the commander name and not just tactic cards.

  • @Nomad6763
    @Nomad6763 Рік тому +1

    0:50 Baratheons
    10:57 Targaryens
    28:09 Greyjoys
    45:40 Martells

  • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
    @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

    Coordination tactics was a change because of Greyjoys not Free Folk. The example you gave with free folk was even a thing because giants couldn't be copied since coordination tactics is infantry only. The change was made to fix the issue with drowned men, namely the ability saying 'this unit has 4 wounds'

  • @mrmaat
    @mrmaat Рік тому +1

    Greyjoy main here: Asha got murdered as a copy/paste from Mance. The developers showed zero respect for the Greyjoy ecosystem and completely bricked her as a commander.
    Victarion’s point cost enrages me. He was already the weakest Relentless in the game and Moqorro clone was just a meme and never a viable tactic. The developers bricked Victarion attachment as well.
    Reapers are still underwhelming unless you build the list around them. Sure, with Silenced Men, corpse piles, intimidating presence and vicious and flanking thats -7 with a panic token… and then your opponent plays Kingslayer’s Renown.

  • @amc6354
    @amc6354 9 місяців тому

    Does hardened stack with warrior sons battle prayer ?

  • @Syraphym
    @Syraphym Рік тому +1

    Quite sad to see no improvements to Rose Knights, Baratheon Sentinels, or Thorn Watch, plus all the 2-pt attachments that should be 1 point.

    • @barneytolentino5980
      @barneytolentino5980 Рік тому

      Cry

    • @Sacrilege83
      @Sacrilege83 Рік тому

      ​@@barneytolentino5980 so edgy.

    • @barneytolentino5980
      @barneytolentino5980 Рік тому

      @@Sacrilege83 I don’t mean any harm. I got this same treatment last time when my house was nerfed to the ground. I watched the doom of my house and I stood tall and stalwart to the end.

  • @patrickcharzin3062
    @patrickcharzin3062 Рік тому

    Not super happy about the Queen's men nerf. Compared to the healing other factions have (like Nights Watch or Greyjoys) was an order to draw conviction really that powerful? Whatever. I don't object to Baratheon nerfs in general, but I thought they ought to nerf Stannis the rightful heir instead, and specifically Tactical approach. Its probably the best card in the game, and with the addition of Justin Massey attachment, it can now be drawn from the deck whenever the Bara player desires.

    • @mrmaat
      @mrmaat Рік тому

      I agree - Tactical approach was a real head scratcher when I first played against Stannis RH.

  • @Ghislain82
    @Ghislain82 Рік тому

    Greyjoy Drowned Men have the innate ability Drowned God's Fanatics

  • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
    @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

    I'm confused by your statement about terrain. Are you saying you think casual games should be player choice terrain, but competetive events should use random terrain?

    • @BigTopGaming
      @BigTopGaming  Рік тому

      I think casual games should be whatever you want to do, honestly; I do prefer to use the random table. For competitive events, I prefer the organizer set the tables to shave off an hour of screwing around at events and make table side choices more relevant.

    • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
      @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

      @@BigTopGaming I get that for every other game I've played, but terrain set-up in ASOIAF takes like 5 minutes tops. And generally as a result of having to place 2 each there is atleast a slight side difference.

    • @obyiscushobbyandgaming
      @obyiscushobbyandgaming Рік тому

      @@BigTopGaming I think the random table is fine for casual, but really makes things like MelCasino get more abusive in competetive

  • @barneytolentino5980
    @barneytolentino5980 Рік тому

    So Nute can charge instead of surging forth?

    • @patrickcharzin3062
      @patrickcharzin3062 Рік тому

      The way I read it, no. But I know people who disagree. CMON needs to clarify their clarifications better.

  • @barneytolentino5980
    @barneytolentino5980 Рік тому

    “Missive” 🤣 why not just call it “Letters” or “Envelope”