Top 5 Best Fishing Spinners for Trout? Is it Panther Martin, Rooster Tail or Rapala?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @williamf.buckleyjr3227
    @williamf.buckleyjr3227 5 років тому +15

    The answer is simple: whichever one the trout are in the mood for that day. I've had feasts AND famines with all three brand names mentioned.
    Thirty casts with the Panther, not even a follow. Second cast on a Rapala, BANG.
    Next week, same spot, complete opposite results.

    • @gannongrant7121
      @gannongrant7121 3 роки тому

      A trick: watch series at KaldroStream. I've been using them for watching loads of movies recently.

    • @ariesskylar489
      @ariesskylar489 3 роки тому

      @Gannon Grant definitely, I have been watching on Kaldrostream for since december myself :D

  • @FishingCircle
    @FishingCircle 5 років тому +2

    I use a simple gold spoon in most of my videos and LOVE it! Panther Martins, kastmasters, and a blue fox vibrax are my other go-to's. Nice content

  • @jasonwieczorek5343
    @jasonwieczorek5343 6 років тому

    That green one is amazing.... brook, rainbow and brown trout all seem to love it in my experience! As soon as I seen that on your table I decided to finish watching your video and not to my surprise that was your go to as it is mine!!! I even like the reverse green blade black weighted ones... that color green is killer!

  • @rogueandreel1357
    @rogueandreel1357 6 років тому +10

    You should definitely list/link these in the description

  • @rogerlocke6975
    @rogerlocke6975 6 років тому +3

    Excellent video ! You are definitely on the right track. If you are interested, I'll share the lures I discovered over the past 40 years of fishing the Pacific Northwest for tout in Lakes and Rivers/Streams. ?
    #1) 1/8th oz. Black Rooster Tail Spinner with the Silver Blade. "Old School Original" #2) 1/8th oz. Yellow body with Red Dots and Silver Blade Panther Martin Spinner. #3) 1/8th oz. Silver with Red Dots Z-Ray Wobbler. #4) One Inch Jointed Rocky Jr. Balsawood Minnow Plug. #5) Size 8 Black or Olive Wooly Bugger Trout Flys w/a lead split shot up 18" to 24", split shot sized to get it down to the river bottom w/o snagging up, w/a strip pause retrieve. Or a very tiny Marabou Jig in Black, with white eyes.
    Last but not least, 4lb test with a thin diameter, in clear or slightly green color, and a 4' 9" to a 6.5' Fiberglass rod, Not graphite, and preferably an all cork handle with sliding rings for the ultimate sensitivity, avoiding metal and plastic on the handle at all cost...

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  5 років тому

      Thanks for the share! Sorry I took so long to respond, I'll be doing a lot of fishing this month so I think I'm going to have to go buy all the lures on your list to try them out!

  • @anthonycolbourne4206
    @anthonycolbourne4206 2 роки тому

    6:27 I find if the Rooster Tails have a slightly bent main shaft, they tend to not work well at slow retrieve speeds. In general really they tend to work best at faster speeds. I would add the Abu Reflex Arctic Spoon to the list.

  • @rikrox42067
    @rikrox42067 7 років тому +5

    I also love Panther Martin's for trout. Mainly because I catch a lot and also you can cast upstream and it still spins coming down current. Unlike Rooster Tails. Must have something to do with the Martins blade weight and in-line type blade. Having said that.............size 3 and 5 and sometimes 7 black and silver original floating Rapala's are my go to not just for trout but for near everything. I consistently catch Steelhead trout, brown trout, rainbow trout, largemouth bass, smallmouth bass, perch, walleye, saugeye, northern pike, musky, bluegills, crappie. I have not caught a lot of channel catfish or bullheads but I have caught a few with a rapala. Pretty much stick to nightcrawlers or even long thin slices of steak for the cats. Anyhow, just my 2 cents. If I were dropped off in the wilderness with a fishing pole and had to choose 1 lure it would surely be a 3 or 5 black and silver original floating Rapala. Oops that was 2. Uhm I guess a 3. Wait on 2nd thought a 5. No, no, no a 3. Maybe. Or a 5. lololol

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  7 років тому

      LOL see it's not as easy you might think to choose just 1 lol. I'll definitely have to pick up a black and silver rapala. Thanks for the recommendation!

  • @highsnburgers4862
    @highsnburgers4862 6 років тому +2

    The willow leaf blade on the Roostertails sinks faster, runs deeper and requires more speed or current to spin. The Panther Martin's through-blade (no clevis) spins quickest and fishes shallow the best - start reeling in slow just as it hits the water. Mepps spinners also work very well and have the best all-around blades that have been copied by many lure makers- try the Black Fury on blue sky days.

    • @craigleith100
      @craigleith100 5 років тому

      Hey bud I'm new to spinner fishing and although I've used and caught trout on a couple of spinners I don't know how the sizing works, is it weight or hook size or something else? Hope you can help thanx in advance. 💙🎣💯
      ✌💙👍 from Scotland 🙋 ©®

  • @ChrisG9978
    @ChrisG9978 3 роки тому +2

    It's not so much the spinner, it's putting the spinner in the right place at the right time. Chance plays a big role, then technique. If you want to lower your chance of snagging, clip off the treble hooks and replace them with single Siwash hooks. The Siwash hook should be larger than the treble to maintain the spinner action as close to the original as possible. The other advantage of using a single hook on a spinner...you can bait them to give your spinner a higher chance of a hit.

    • @BornIn1500
      @BornIn1500 2 роки тому +1

      Exactly. Over the decades, I notice little to no difference in which spinner colors catch fish.

  • @robertchillcott7669
    @robertchillcott7669 5 років тому +2

    Panther Martin cost a little more but their worth it. With the offset blade on the shaft you can fish it at lower retrieve speeds....... thanks for sharing

  • @freemindas
    @freemindas 6 років тому +5

    Blue Fox Vibrax is really good !

    • @c_b8s4
      @c_b8s4 4 роки тому

      Ive never caught a thing on them. Gold, silver, gold shiner, and silver shiner. To be honest im glad you guys find success, but I get incredibly upset that i have no luck with em. Same with trout magnets.

    • @freemindas
      @freemindas 4 роки тому +1

      @@c_b8s4 I have tried mepps and some other brands and I personally find Blue Fox Vibrax the best. They are very durable and made of high quality parts razor sharp triple hook they never cause twisting and tangles in the line and I love the resistance they have in the water when retrieved which makes it easy to control them in terms of speed and depth. They are also heavy for their size compared to other brands that I have used and that helps with the casting range and accuracy. I use them to fish mostly chub in the river. My favourite colour is silver.

  • @drawlr55
    @drawlr55 5 років тому

    No Mepps? Panther Martin used to be my go-to, and I still use them a lot, but for the past couple of years, I've had more overall luck with Mepps. This year, my two trout killers were a #3 Brown Trout Mepps Aglia and a #6 original pattern PM (brass blade, black body with yellow spots). While fishing on a small river in south central Idaho, I caught over 30 trout in about 4 hours on these two lures, mostly on the Mepps. Later in the year, I caught a 2+ lb Tiger Trout in a local Utah reservoir on the Mepps. I started using Mepps a few years ago when I wasn't having much luck with my PMs. So, I pulled out a standard brass Mepps Aglia, which I hadn't used in years, and my luck suddenly changed. So, if you haven't tried Mepps, give them a try. (I am not a Mepps spokeman or representative.)

  • @bryanwyckoff9192
    @bryanwyckoff9192 6 років тому +5

    Panther Martin's and mepps are the way to go, never been able to get a rooster tail to work long enough to catch a fish. That's stream fishing in northern California.

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  5 років тому

      What mepps do you recommend? I've never had any luck with them but I think I just haven't used the right ones.

    • @garysavala665
      @garysavala665 2 роки тому

      0 mepps or 1 for trout .

  • @MountainManWiggie
    @MountainManWiggie 6 років тому +2

    Hey man. Utah fisher here. My GO TO since I was a kid has always been Jakes Spin-a-lures. I use the gold with red spots in sunny weather and the silver with red spots in cloudy. Im gonna have to check out that last one though. Seems worth a try. Good vid....

  • @SlayermikesVideos
    @SlayermikesVideos 6 років тому +5

    I make cheap ones at home nothing fancy and the work awesome plus the cool thing is you can use different weights depending on water depth cost to me 75 cents a piece. Those ones your showing are like 6$ each in trout streams snags are expensive,Make your own give it a try

  • @Bobb1julie
    @Bobb1julie 3 роки тому

    Thanks for sharing .. If you go to SCHEELS now , they have your favorite flo green/ hammered silver on sale for $3.99 each ..I just bought 5 .. Thanks again .. Tight lines

  • @rogerwilco1777
    @rogerwilco1777 5 років тому

    Natural color skirted Panther Martins, crawdad crankbaits, and small rapalla rattle traps are all I need to crush trout anywhere in oregon.

  • @uncutfishing
    @uncutfishing 6 років тому +7

    It is very interesting, but, with all due respect, I think this ranking could've easily been upside down. That is, there is no principle difference between most of these spinners, imho. When trout are not super active (which is most of the time), takes are inconsistent and sporadic, so if you keep on changing lures, it may seem that some lures work better than others, when in reality those are all just coincidences. In other words, if you fished the same spinner all the time, the result would probably have been exactly the same, imho.
    The only difference I can see (disclaimer: I never used neither Panther Martins, nor Rooster Tails, so it's just a guess), is that Rooster Tail will dive faster and will have a smaller spinning radius (less resistance, less control) than the Panther Martins. Plus, I agree that sometimes having some feathers or fibers on the treble may have some kind of effect, but it's hard to tell. That's it. BTW, I think you should've dropped the rather dated Countdown you showed, it's a spinners list anyways.
    BTW, with that being said, I too have a top spinner (Mepps Aglia TW copper No. 2 or 3, it's what I use in most on my vids ;)), but, to be frank with you, it is probably the matter of psychological attachment or quite irrational overconfidence in a thing, i.e. this spinner is best for me, the fisherman. The peace of mind I get using this spinner is easy to confuse with its effectiveness when catching trout, of which I still have little understanding even after 20+ years of fishing pretty much for trout only ;)
    Thanks for the list and tight lines!

    • @danfromga3002
      @danfromga3002 6 років тому +2

      Well said brother. I have not noticed much difference in colors, only size. Either they are hitting or they aren't in my experience.

    • @freemindas
      @freemindas 6 років тому

      Well said.

    • @5555nickel
      @5555nickel 6 років тому +1

      Im from Maine and when it comes to Brook trout I've had the most luck with the Panther Martin #2 yellow teardrop with red dots I've tried all the top lures and nothing catches me more fish than that lure, for Brown trout a black and white rooster tail

    • @c_b8s4
      @c_b8s4 4 роки тому

      Perfectly said. If you have confidence in what you are fishing with you do not worry about if you are doing things right or wrong. You focus on the fish.

  • @GraysonMckernan
    @GraysonMckernan 6 років тому

    I live in the Sierras and don’t have much luck with anything, mostly because I suck, but I’ll have to try some of these out.

  • @zoranmilivojevic2982
    @zoranmilivojevic2982 2 роки тому

    Panter Martin, comet, black furry, veltic,ilba, mosca .

  • @brunobormann-ULTRALIGHTRS
    @brunobormann-ULTRALIGHTRS 5 років тому

    Cool friend !!! Nice spiners and lures. Here in Brazil i used a lot that ! Hard hug 🌲🎣🎥

  • @omgwhymeomgwhyme3457
    @omgwhymeomgwhyme3457 6 років тому +2

    I work in Spanish fork and just started fishing trout. Are you fishing that pond befor the golf course?

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  5 років тому

      Sorry I took so long to reply, I fish the newish reservoir in Springville and then Hobble Creek quite a bit.

  • @m.w.h.9253
    @m.w.h.9253 4 роки тому +1

    You should try some Joe's flies. Works well for me.

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  4 роки тому

      I actually started using Joe's Flies after I recorded this video (guess I should make an update video) and have had some good luck with them. Which ones have been working best for you? I made a short video on the ones that have been working well for me, you can check it out here ua-cam.com/video/E55ZgvOvgaE/v-deo.html

    • @m.w.h.9253
      @m.w.h.9253 4 роки тому +1

      @@nathanyoung1771 I have about 8 or 10 of them. But I like the short stricker and royal coachman or any with some brown on the fly.

  • @mrlifetime64
    @mrlifetime64 6 років тому

    hello nathan- i must tell you that the rooster tails are FABULOUS-however you need some other patterns-the reason the dontspin is the wire in front get bent and needs to be gently straightened- i have fished roosters for 60 years and we also sold them in our tackle store foryears- (mayfly...clown...yellow coach dog-,..flame coach dog-..bumblebee are the outstanding colors however you will find that they are very hard to locate

    • @uplaywithfire7564
      @uplaywithfire7564 6 років тому

      Bob Tack the bumble bee gets em while others don't !

    • @bobbybbridges8133
      @bobbybbridges8133 5 років тому

      You got the try the silver vibrax number two gold seems to work best in murky water silver seems to work best in clear and sunny weather Clearwater is great for the silver I'm about to try the black.

  • @RuggedSportsmen
    @RuggedSportsmen 6 років тому +1

    Yellow with red spots/silver blade or black with yellow spots/silver blade for panther martins. Brown trout, white, red, or rainbow trout for rooster tails. All get bit every time I use them.

    • @al.trzy_blu.e
      @al.trzy_blu.e 6 років тому +1

      RuggedSportsmen yellow w red spots silver blade is the hot one.... 🤘🏼

  • @guyh.4553
    @guyh.4553 6 років тому

    Yes, gold work better in brighter conditions.
    For me, out West, my go-to's are 1) Rooster Rails, 2) Super Duper's, 3) Blue Fox, 4) Mepps, 5) Rapala's - Original.
    I'm surprised about Rooster Tails not working in Sierra's. For me, again out west, I have 5 colors/patterns that I use either solely or in combination. Hot Pink, Hot Orange, Silver, Firetiger, and Rainbow Trout. And I don't own any Panther Martin lures.

  • @sumyraabid
    @sumyraabid 4 роки тому

    Do you put bait on it too? Sorry I'm a beginner

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  4 роки тому

      I've seen people put salmon eggs or a chunk of worm on their lures but I've never had any luck doing that so I just use the lures most of the time.

  • @Ranger42
    @Ranger42 5 років тому

    Just getting into fishing with spinners. Do you use some type of ball bearing swivels to attach the panther martins? And what type of line and weight to you recommend for fishing Sierras?

    • @matthewr9629
      @matthewr9629 5 років тому

      Yeah, you should attach a swivel to stop line twist. You can also attach a swivel to a leader, and then the leader to the spinner.

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  5 років тому

      Best practice is to use a swivel... However I just tie them straight to the line usually. The streams I fish are usually so shallow that the extra weight of the swivel usually leads to more snags. The line does wear out a little faster because of the line twist but I'm willing to deal with that rather than snags and losing lures do to snags. Hope that helps.

  • @Marqjosh
    @Marqjosh 5 років тому

    I prefer Joes flies and Mepps 2 or 3. I got this Mepps pattern in Portugal I can’t find here in size 3 and it keeps hitting fish. Just plain gold with black dots

  • @omgwhymeomgwhyme3457
    @omgwhymeomgwhyme3457 6 років тому +2

    White trout magnet with gold jig head for 12.5 incher hoble creek

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  5 років тому +1

      I've been loving the trout magnets at the Springville Resevoir, do you jig them in Hobble Creek or float them with a bobber?

  • @mosicnflowmuasyaj9748
    @mosicnflowmuasyaj9748 6 років тому

    On 6:30 I think is imitates a hairy caterpillar👍

  • @alexalvarado_1972
    @alexalvarado_1972 6 років тому

    Where did you buy tackle box?

  • @Msquad321
    @Msquad321 6 років тому

    Issue: Panther Martin blades stop spinning easily. It's because the wire shaft gets dirty or very slightly corroded. Almost impossible to see, but it increases the friction on the blade or the clevis on a Roostertail. Solution: "Scrape (very lightly) the shaft, with a single edge razor blade. Then clean the shaft with a toothbrush and isopropyl alcohol. You will have to repeat the process after fishing the lure a few times. What you are removing is microscopic dirt mixed with the goo from suspended algae. I've tried every inline spinner known to mankind. I've settled on the chrome bladed Mepps Aglia size "00" (1/12 oz) undressed, with the red tubing over the treble shank. The Mepps will still get dirty. I squash the barbs half way down. It really helps with hooksets.

  • @deezynutz4742
    @deezynutz4742 5 років тому

    I just caught a 4 lb rainbow on a black and gold rooster tail, needless to say the rooster tail was destroyed after landing that elephant of a fish.

  • @nathanmitchell9431
    @nathanmitchell9431 5 років тому

    My name is Nathan too 😁

  • @ManStandsAloneIsAStrongMan
    @ManStandsAloneIsAStrongMan 7 років тому

    Mepps no.2 chrome blade best trout spinner I have ever used..

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  7 років тому

      I've honestly never had luck with Mepps (probably wasn't trying the right ones) I'm definitely going to put the No.2 chrome blade on my shopping list. Thanks!

    • @snussnus86
      @snussnus86 6 років тому

      Copper with red dots and no.2 👌

  • @mrlifetime64
    @mrlifetime64 6 років тому

    roosters are hot- you need the rite colors- yellow coach dog flame coach dog gold blades- may fly clown 1/16-1/8-1/4 they are fantastic fantastic fantastic believe me- the wire shank gets bent then they won't spin properly-u can straighten them but it can be difficult

  • @TwoStageTrigger
    @TwoStageTrigger 6 років тому

    I mostly use Mepps.

  • @EKEACRES
    @EKEACRES 5 років тому +1

    Don't waste your money on store bought spinners. They are a rip off, because you can make your won for 1/8 of the cost, and they are exactly the same.

    • @DavyWhitezel
      @DavyWhitezel 5 років тому

      As someone who wants to start making his own spinners/ bucktails but doesnt know where to learn, is there any videos or websites you could point me to?

    • @EKEACRES
      @EKEACRES 5 років тому +1

      @@DavyWhitezel I have some video's on my channel, and if you search (How to make spinners, bucktail lures) on UA-cam,..Thousands come up to choose from.

  • @jodyschultz5870
    @jodyschultz5870 4 роки тому

    It's so hard to be scientific about this and filter out the noise. Monday, river at 9:00 pm, 4 fish in 20 min. Tue, same river same time identical gear and lure, 1h 30 min, not a bite. I find that when fish are on the "bite" they will often hit almost anything and I have seen 4 or 5 guys all hooking up at the same time with different lures as a school comes through. I guess it's in the slow times that lure selection can help squeak out a fish. Forget lure selection. Maybe a fly on a float or a worm on the bottom but switching gear can eat into fishing time so sometimes it's better to stay with a lure and maybe walk the river if you can or move the boat.

  • @paulwatkins2333
    @paulwatkins2333 2 роки тому

    Vibrax wins :)

  • @dwightstewart7181
    @dwightstewart7181 6 років тому +2

    Hey, if I paint the name "Panther Martin" on my spinners, does that mean I'll catch more? Fish are so picky about name brands.

  • @Carlb328
    @Carlb328 6 років тому +3

    I hate rooster tails. It's like they're designed not to spin, or sink for that matter.

  • @dsmith3134
    @dsmith3134 4 роки тому +1

    Joe’s Flies. Short Striker

    • @nathanyoung1771
      @nathanyoung1771  4 роки тому

      I've actually started using Joe's Flies since I recorded this video, I've been really impressed. Just did a video about my favorite ones, which styles have you had luck with? Here's that vid ua-cam.com/video/E55ZgvOvgaE/v-deo.html

  • @richardruiz4668
    @richardruiz4668 3 роки тому

    What the heck? No KastMaster? Those always hit for me. Your missing out. Where have you been that your not using those. They aren't even a new thing.

  • @marciananton9226
    @marciananton9226 3 роки тому

    Fishing where trout are stocked seem like cheating to me. I've never heard of that until UA-cam.

  • @patrickkerner1471
    @patrickkerner1471 5 років тому

    Disagree, #1 blue fox, #2 CP Swing, #3 real worms with pencil floats made in Germany (SMALL FLOATS AND SINKERS RULE)!

  • @Карабас-й9м
    @Карабас-й9м 6 років тому

    переведите все

  • @jamesmichaelis1483
    @jamesmichaelis1483 Рік тому

    No its actually Mepps

  • @WheresTheSauce
    @WheresTheSauce 6 років тому

    Mepps life........