AI Coding with AIDER Architect: Gemini 2.0 Flash vs Claude 3.5 Sonnet (o1, o3 PLAN)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 126

  • @indydevdan
    @indydevdan  3 дні тому +23

    First off - massive thanks 🙏 to everyone who's diving into Principled AI Coding.
    I've packed a ton of value into PAIC for you. Many engineers are already digging in and leveling up.
    The silent launch has gone very well so far including a few hiccups here and there.
    Thanks to everyone who's reported bugs. If you're running into issues, click 'Report an issue'.
    I'm not sleeping until I fix every issue I can for you.
    If there's something you want to see in PAIC that you don't, click 'Ask a question' and let me know.
    Mobile support rolls out soon. Desktop is first prio.
    Stay focused and keep building.
    - idd

    • @MaelSimonApprenTyr
      @MaelSimonApprenTyr 3 дні тому

      Thank you to you! You are the best channel on the subject so far, I've learned so much that it created a passion AND I got a job in that domain last thursday thanks to you! You are the goat of agentic engineer. I recommend you to everyone who talks about this with me.

    • @moresignal
      @moresignal 2 дні тому

      You're walking your own path and taking us on the journey for free. I'll be buying your course and look forward to seeing it.

    • @fcbrants
      @fcbrants 2 дні тому +1

      Re: PAIC - Done! Re: "I'm not sleeping..." - Get some sleep, we need you strong & healthy - we're not going Anywhere :)

    • @קוגבול
      @קוגבול 2 дні тому

      Ask a question url
      should be in this
      current comment though.
      If login is required,
      then you missed feedback
      About core prompting insights
      I dont agree to license
      But will help you
      Efficiently build your PKB

    • @mdrafatsiddiqui
      @mdrafatsiddiqui 2 дні тому

      no xmas discount?

  • @roberth8737
    @roberth8737 3 дні тому +12

    I will be buying this course simply on the basis of the value this channel has already provided. 🐐

  • @haroldpierre1726
    @haroldpierre1726 3 дні тому +7

    I absolutely love this channel!! No hype just loads of information!!

    • @khanra17
      @khanra17 2 дні тому

      No hype ?
      😂 Really?

  • @francoisarbour1207
    @francoisarbour1207 3 дні тому +6

    Hands down the best AI/Coding Channel out there, fantastic work!

    • @adamholter1884
      @adamholter1884 3 дні тому +2

      IndyDevDan and AICodeKing are my go to channels for this

  • @scottx1415
    @scottx1415 2 дні тому +3

    Clearly a more serious approach vs most others posting in this space. Amazing work, liked, subscribed and look forward to updates.

  • @Laxobigging
    @Laxobigging 2 дні тому

    one of the best people in this space, and he's probably the only person providing an evergreen framework. thank you sir.

  • @fredkzk
    @fredkzk 3 дні тому +17

    The "juice" might be with gemini-2.0-flash-thinking-exp-1219. It's the model for the /architect mode

    • @TreeLuvBurdpu
      @TreeLuvBurdpu 3 дні тому

      Is exp-1219 better than 1206?

    • @d.d.z.
      @d.d.z. 2 дні тому +1

      I was about to say the same, even with the thinking and the exp model, not the only flash model.

    • @KevinKreger
      @KevinKreger 2 дні тому +1

      Flash is more Google hype. Try Flash after you run out of Claude requests and prepare to be irritated.

    • @AbuBakr1
      @AbuBakr1 2 дні тому +2

      ​@@TreeLuvBurdpuI found 1206 to be better for coding

    • @rifkiamil
      @rifkiamil 2 дні тому

      @@KevinKreger more irritations are you finding if I may ask? I’d love to know some examples.

  • @BeYob
    @BeYob 2 дні тому +3

    Any chance you can offer a payment plan? I live in Viet Vietnam the price is a bit steep, but I know the value is there.

  • @tonynolan9428
    @tonynolan9428 2 дні тому

    Thankyou. That was a great 30 minutes of my life. Intriguing and captivating to learn from an expert. Ill be joining today.

  • @artdenden
    @artdenden 2 дні тому +1

    This is an excellent video. Thank you very much for making this.

  • @TiquitaRobinson-w5i
    @TiquitaRobinson-w5i 2 дні тому +27

    enterprise-ai AI fixes this (Code complete projects in PHP or Python). AI Coding: Gemini 2.0 Flash

  • @adalovecraft2140
    @adalovecraft2140 2 дні тому +6

    It took me exactly 30 seconds from the time i saw the PAIC url to the point of signing up. Any other "AI Engineer" content creator would have been laughed right off of my subscriptions. You, however, are worth every penny.

    • @wesside5792
      @wesside5792 3 години тому

      Congrats on being "Ai Engineer" and a sucker as well

  • @imflyingoverclouds
    @imflyingoverclouds День тому +1

    Great content! Thank you! I'm heavy user of aider as well.

  • @TimExcellent
    @TimExcellent День тому

    Signed up! Legend. I’m no programmer but have been getting quite good and built a few things, worked out it seems to be more about thinking now and having something else do the doing, so have been absorbing books on coding and it’s been working well -> level up time

  • @MudroZvon
    @MudroZvon 8 годин тому

    A comparison of Aider against other API-based coding tools would be very insightful!

  • @MichelCourtine
    @MichelCourtine 2 дні тому

    I thought I was doing it AI coding right, you just gave me an extra level up upgrade. Thanks

  • @ThePoser010
    @ThePoser010 3 дні тому +2

    NGL I'm always excited to see new videos from you.
    When are you starting a skool?

  • @alexjensen990
    @alexjensen990 2 дні тому

    I would be interested to see how a combination of Sonnet and Gemini worked out. One could lower the cost, potentially, while maintaining most of the speed and accuracy. I may give that a shot tonight or tomorrow to see for myself.
    Great video! Quickly becoming a go to channel for me. Keep up the good work.

  • @callumarul6322
    @callumarul6322 2 дні тому +1

    This was the quickesr purchase I've ever made. Excited to get started! Quick question though - how does aider compare to tools like windsurf and cursor?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому

      👍👍 Lots of great information is waiting for you.
      We're definitely due for a windsurf video on the channel. The key difference between Aider and most tools but Cursor + Windsurf especially is that Aider is THE foundational form of all AI coding assistant. It gives you full control over the context, model, prompt, costs, configuration and much much more.

    • @MoMo-op6yx
      @MoMo-op6yx 2 дні тому

      @@indydevdanWindsurf is my favorite for now!

  • @loryo80
    @loryo80 3 дні тому +1

    BEST OF THE BEST AS USUAL. thank you

  • @techfren
    @techfren 2 дні тому +2

    Love this video thank you

  • @meme-q1e8o
    @meme-q1e8o 2 дні тому +1

    Do you offer student discounts?

  • @ZakkFromSource
    @ZakkFromSource 3 дні тому +1

    Hey is the course suitable for a beginner level programmer?
    I've been learning the the fundamentals of Python, HTML & CSS since August, since the idea of leveraging the power of AI to create software excites me, hence how i found my way here lol.

  • @withmarko
    @withmarko 2 дні тому

    Nice video! Somehow this whole ai coding wave managed to transform coding from a an engineering discipline to an activity that to me feels a bit more like alchemy. Even when I take the exact same steps in my workflow, I get wild differences in quality of output with no clear reason why.

  • @gtrguy17
    @gtrguy17 3 дні тому +1

    Do you teach us how to build Ada or our own Ai developer assistant?

  • @ManWhoLostTooth
    @ManWhoLostTooth 3 дні тому +1

    What is your experience with how Aider handles medium-larger projects?
    I am currently using Cursor to help develop my 100+ script, 15+kloc project and am wondering how Aider would handle it.

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому

      Aider is great for projects of all sizes. I use it to regularly ship features on a 125+kloc repo. 🎯

  • @davefellows
    @davefellows 2 дні тому +1

    I'm surprised you didn't get throttled using Gemini Flash. I tried it in Cline and couldn't get much done as it kept throttling.

  • @marilynlucas5128
    @marilynlucas5128 2 дні тому +1

    I don't think Sonnet is the best anymore. I am getting great results with Deep Seek coder. I just had to imagine what Sonnet's system prompt might be. Then I came up with a really detailed, innovative system prompt and now I am getting better performance using Deep Seek than Sonnet 3.5. It's just the system prompt. You can make magic with it. Now I have my Cline set up functioning far better than Windsurf using Deep Seek coder.

  • @FredPauling
    @FredPauling 2 дні тому +1

    Nice hot take intro on the state of AI. On the mark.

  • @cucciolo182
    @cucciolo182 2 дні тому

    Really nice tutorial on how you managed to make the agents work together! I was wondering if it’s possible to recreate Devin AI using similar techniques

  • @og1236
    @og1236 16 годин тому

    Is there a possibility to pay with PayPal or some other payment provider for people who don't have a credit card?

  • @barungh
    @barungh 3 дні тому +3

    December 2024: Era of Rolling Releases of AI tools and services 😅

  • @DmitryAvramenko
    @DmitryAvramenko 2 дні тому

    Dan, thank you again for an incredible video. Have signed up for your course! Looking forward to learn more. Will you be sharing code for your project inside your paid course?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  День тому +1

      👍 If you liked this video you'll get a ton of value out of the intermediate lessons. No current plans to share the personal knowledge base in PAIC. (Great feedback btw)

  • @KevinKreger
    @KevinKreger 2 дні тому +1

    I had a real world Cypher SQL coding task. Flash was a total fail. It couldn't do postgresql and just kept apologizing. Claude saw a complete pro.

  • @RuneX_ai
    @RuneX_ai 2 дні тому

    Well done with the video dan!

  • @p73737E
    @p73737E 2 дні тому +1

    you must try the experimental versions. they are mind blowing

  • @danteefluellen1290
    @danteefluellen1290 2 дні тому

    Instantly bought the course u have putnme on wirh so many of yiur videos thb u got me here into these tools and stuff. So my i have yhis workflow or whatever of database llm agents noe ur showing there is no need for afents the nodels r the agents and u break the model into smaller chucks to get ur job done. Sp wjen i saw ur course i was thos woll tesch me eveytbing he knows. With so much out there i just need to know to sell to busoness snd work for myself . I just saw a video yesterday talking only 2 percentage of business r using ai. Im thinking om auper far behind but that is not the case at all❤

  • @carinebruyndoncx5331
    @carinebruyndoncx5331 2 дні тому

    Put an announcement up on the currently still free skool community "Coding the future with AI". Tim Kitchens free course covers more of the prompting needed to get to the design making use of a.o. user stories. My feeling is you pick up where he more or les stops, very complementary.

  • @vincentmayer7517
    @vincentmayer7517 3 дні тому

    Love your Chanel im gonna check the course. Is it accessible if I don’t have coding experience?

  • @williamjums5078
    @williamjums5078 2 дні тому

    Hi,
    I have a quick question: would it be possible to enable subtitles if I enroll in the course? English is not my native language, and I find subtitles (in English) very helpful to ensure I fully understand the content without misinterpreting anything.
    Thank you in advance for your response.
    Best regards,

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому

      Hey William. Yes, subtitles will ship soon. I will bump this up for you and ship it into videos over the next couple days (expect pre Friday).

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  12 хвилин тому

      Update: subtitles are now live for every lesson in Principle AI Coding making it easier to understand the content without misinterpreting.

  • @mikegehard6402
    @mikegehard6402 2 дні тому

    How long did it take you to write the prompt?

  • @chrisweeks8789
    @chrisweeks8789 Годину тому

    Looking forward to the new deepseek model

  • @MoMo-op6yx
    @MoMo-op6yx 2 дні тому

    Is the price covers all the modules in the course or we need to pay again to unlock the modules ?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому +1

      One price - 8 videos.
      Start with every beginner lesson unlocked.
      Unlocks for lessons 4-8 happen at 50% watch time of the previous lesson.

  • @fielstem
    @fielstem День тому

    What would you say are the prerequisites to be successful in completing your course?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  День тому +1

      Programming fundamentals, git basics, terminal basics and an understanding that AI is reshaping software. If you have these skills (or can adapt and learn them quickly) you will be successful.

  • @PseudoProphet
    @PseudoProphet 2 дні тому +5

    Try Gemini 1206 as well.

    • @M-dv1yj
      @M-dv1yj 2 дні тому +1

      1206 is smarter than flash 2

  • @davefellows
    @davefellows 2 дні тому

    That's quite a bit of upfront heavy lifting to write out your detailed spec. I find it's more efficient to just iterate with something like Cursor or Windsurf. I guess if you already had a spec then this workflow would make more sense.

  • @cbau0809
    @cbau0809 3 дні тому

    I would like to see you use Gemini as the architect and Claude as the editor

  • @mwdcodeninja
    @mwdcodeninja День тому +1

    Ibhave had good results with running the threats and passing tests output back to aider until the tests pass.

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  День тому

      NICE! This is a powerful (and simple) agentic pattern.

  • @MudroZvon
    @MudroZvon 8 годин тому

    Can DeepSeek V3 code like a champion?

  • @Archonsx
    @Archonsx День тому

    im most excited for llama 4

  • @TreeLuvBurdpu
    @TreeLuvBurdpu 3 дні тому +1

    I think Gemini 1206 is higher on the leaderboards, and it's also free.

  • @JimmyJones-mo2to
    @JimmyJones-mo2to 22 години тому +1

    I grabbed the course, can't wait to get through it!

  • @Marcus889Tech
    @Marcus889Tech 3 дні тому +1

    Bought the course for a cheap and valuable price.

  • @franktfrisby
    @franktfrisby 2 дні тому

    Is mistral able to keep up?

  • @MuneebHussain-d7e
    @MuneebHussain-d7e День тому

    Instead of writing long and specific prompts, wouldn't it be better to write code and use AI code assistance only when you actually need it? Or, for the most optimal approach, just use the cursor?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  День тому

      My take: Over the course of 2025. Writing code by hand is going to be more and more of a mistake every single day.
      Why? Because not leverage Generative AI is a mistake. This is what PAIC is about. It's why I created it in the first place - To make this transition easier.

  • @BeYob
    @BeYob 2 дні тому

    Does it include ADA?

  • @kalyansattaluri8718
    @kalyansattaluri8718 2 дні тому

    hello Dan, I am not getting any video, only audio.. not sure of others, please take a look. Thanks!

    • @kalyansattaluri8718
      @kalyansattaluri8718 2 дні тому

      I meant, in the course. I bought the course and I have only audio. Excited for this.

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому

      Investigating your issue Kalyan. Thank you for letting me know.

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому +1

      Update: Issue identified. It's a video encoding issue (h265 vs h254). Rolling out fallbacks. I will let you know when fix is live.

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  2 дні тому

      Kalyan, this issue has been resolved. Give it another shot. If you run into any additional issues hit 'Report an Issue' and I'll resolve it for you. Thanks for being patient.

    • @kalyansattaluri8718
      @kalyansattaluri8718 2 дні тому

      @@indydevdan Yes. its working. Thank you and Hope you have great holidays!

  • @JacobJarnvall
    @JacobJarnvall День тому

    @indydevdan how can I get in touch with you if I have questions regarding the course? Thanks in advance, Jacob

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  День тому +1

      Hey Jacob. You can email dan@agenticengineer.com with your questions 👍

  • @GoDjMike
    @GoDjMike 2 дні тому +1

    Excellent methodology with reverting the codebase and swapping out agents/models to compare empirically.
    This is exactly what happens at scale- just reverting pre-PR and comparing tests and lints.
    Reminds me of building an algorithm for stock trading, then testing it on historical data to see how it would have done.

  • @puremajik
    @puremajik 3 дні тому

    Hi, I found that Flash 2.0 Reasoning is better for planning and critiquing and Experimental 1206 is better for coding. Perhaps you could try Experimental 1206 vs Claude 3.5 Sonnet?

  • @aibeginnertutorials
    @aibeginnertutorials 2 дні тому

    You are the best of the best on UA-cam. As a former Silicon Valley bro, I appreciate your style of teaching and the excellent content that is actually useful if you are looking to build production grade AI powered agent applications. I have decided to sign up for your course as a start to my New Year. Right now I am finishing up delivery of an NextJS, React, modular Agent app, then Christmas break (first break in a year) then beginning 2025 with your course. Thank you for your excellence, UA-cam needs more of it. All the best.

  • @ethelfrancis2020
    @ethelfrancis2020 2 дні тому

    you got the blustering scammer cadence down perfectly. using so many words without saying anything.

  • @daydahlus
    @daydahlus 3 дні тому

    this mans a hero

  •  2 години тому

    Try the same with DeepSeek V3!

  • @R3ND3RR0R
    @R3ND3RR0R 2 дні тому

    So coding isn’t dead, just syntax

  • @petermsamson
    @petermsamson 2 дні тому +1

    the waving of the (your) hands behind what your showing everyone, is just far to distracting

  • @RuneX_ai
    @RuneX_ai 3 дні тому

    Thank you

  • @anthonyaoun3285
    @anthonyaoun3285 3 дні тому

    Post payment redirects to local host BTW!

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  3 дні тому +1

      Fix rolling out - thank you

  • @aaronabuusama
    @aaronabuusama 3 дні тому

    very cool but the portal is very buggy and there is no community or chat. can you create a telegram chat at least?

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  3 дні тому +2

      You're probably on mobile/tablet (lmk if not). Non-desktop rolling out soon.

    • @rasmusfoy
      @rasmusfoy 2 дні тому +1

      Bought the course immediately.
      You are providing a tonne of value. Looking forward to doing the full course when I’m at my desk in the new year.
      THANK YOU!
      You are one of five channels I follow religiously.

    • @aaronabuusama
      @aaronabuusama 2 дні тому +1

      @@indydevdan on macbook seems to be working now

  • @adamholter1884
    @adamholter1884 3 дні тому

    Aider is fantastic but it's a lot harder to use than Cline

  • @gustavl3638
    @gustavl3638 3 дні тому +7

    where is your course?? take my money 🤑🤑

    • @gustavl3638
      @gustavl3638 3 дні тому +1

      nevermind just saw it 😎

    • @TeamElite03
      @TeamElite03 3 дні тому

      @@gustavl3638where did you see it?

    • @jonbikaku6133
      @jonbikaku6133 3 дні тому

      Lol how are people so gullible

  • @Plife-507
    @Plife-507 3 дні тому

    Love your channel man!!! I'm laying the groundwork to develop a powerful chatbot and knowledge base for market analysis! 💡 The goal is to combine AI with trading expertise, using vector embeddings and automated workflows to process books and PDFs into actionable insights. This system will help analyze trends, create strategies, and decode market behavior-all while prepping for eventual local hosting.

  • @ukukudu
    @ukukudu 2 дні тому

  • @hartmannsson
    @hartmannsson 2 дні тому

    Shut up and take my money!

  • @khanra17
    @khanra17 2 дні тому

    Time spent on making those bs prompt would have made 10 tasks if done manually with just code completion.
    (if you are not a script kiddy)

  • @wesside5792
    @wesside5792 3 години тому

    Chat gpt description. And you used bots to hype up ur COURSE. Lol lol classic. Get outta here lmao

    • @indydevdan
      @indydevdan  3 години тому

      lol. Honestly I get it, but no.
      It's a description generated by a prompt via the api in a specific format. It has the proper format for resources, chapters, hashtags, and yeah a 'ai description' for seo mostly. It saves me a decent amount of time as I'm shipping videos per week. We've literally talked about it on the channel. It's a good use case for LLMs.
      The 'bots' on the other hand are just real ppl minus the 'enterprise-ai AI fixes this...' comment. That seems like bots.

  • @box4soumendu4ever
    @box4soumendu4ever 3 дні тому

    SIR you are one of the best showing us path to follow. Thank you very much for everything you are doing 🥰🥰🙏🏼🙏🏼❤❤🕊🕊🪻