@thalmoragent9344 That was another scenario I had in mind. What if the Jedi had a contingency plan in place following Qui-Gon's death, an emergency evacuation to Tannalor. This time, only 3,000 Jedi survive and make to Tannalor.
Jedi & Lords Make what if Anakin Skywalker? Drank from the font of power. and bathe in the pool of knowledge to put it simply basically he becomes even much more powerful stronger faster and smarter than abeloth Because he's the chosen one. and also do you have the other ideas i gave to you yes or no
There's always a problem with time travel. To be more specific: A paradox. IF vader actually went to kill palpatine and succeeded, then he wouldn't have existed in the first place. Therefore, no-one would have returned to kill palpatine or even warned Anakin. For Vader to exist, Anakin shall fall to the dark side, and the only way is by padme being dead so by trying to prevent it, it may have made matters worst. Good story tho.
Probably like how Back to the Future 2 did when Biff went back in time to give his younger self info of future events to exploit, making it where Marty couldn't return to his own timeline until he undid what future Biff did due to the change causing his timeline to be severed and unreachable. The Future Marty was in at the time still existed even when Biff altered the past but once Marty left to go back to his own time, that future can't be reached anymore. So it still exists but is now cutoff from the normal timeline.
Your argument is flawed because it views time too linearly, assuming Vader’s actions in the past would directly erase his existence. While Palpatine played a key role in Anakin’s fall, his descent was driven by internal struggles like fear and ambition, which could still lead him to the dark side even without Palpatine. Killing Palpatine might change events, but it wouldn’t necessarily erase Vader. In many time travel theories, altering the past creates a branching timeline rather than undoing the original one. Vader’s actions could create a new reality where Palpatine doesn’t corrupt Anakin, but his original timeline remains intact. Your logic oversimplifies how time travel could work and ignores the possibility of alternate outcomes/timelines
Dragon ball Z explained this best with Future Trunks. The story unfolding here is an alt timeline that was caused when Vader came back to change what occured.
@@delongorman8099 The same could be said about your argument. The existence of the multiverse is just as plausible as the theory of linear time. I'm sorry to tell you this, but according to canon, the Star Wars universe follows the theory of linear time, as shown in Rebels with the World Between Worlds. That said, I'm going to go with your theory. Removing Palpatine from the equation is what prevents Vader from existing. Although he displayed several dark side tendencies in The Clone Wars, those would have been isolated events if Palpatine hadn't capitalized on them. It would require an intervention from the Force to truly turn him to the dark side since, as explained in the video, Padmé didn't die, and his children are safe. The only way he could truly turn is if another dark side user influenced him.
The last time I was this early, Anakin Skywalker committed War Crimes in the name of the Republic
Dart Vader in title. Got a typo to fix
What if 1,000 Jedi left the Order in protest of the Clone Wars and relocated to Peredia?
What if Peredia was located in the Mass Effect Universe?
How would they get to Peredia?
@@thalmoragent9344 Probably with the Tho Yor.
@snafuthegreat
What about the secret Temple Cal found in Jedi Survivor?
@thalmoragent9344 That was another scenario I had in mind. What if the Jedi had a contingency plan in place following Qui-Gon's death, an emergency evacuation to Tannalor. This time, only 3,000 Jedi survive and make to Tannalor.
there is a divine law always in play in these scenarios. No 2 of the same soul shall exist in the same dimension or time at the same time.
What if Darth Vader and Shmi are Anakins parents
Jedi & Lords Make what if Anakin Skywalker? Drank from the font of power. and bathe in the pool of knowledge to put it simply basically he becomes even much more powerful stronger faster and smarter than abeloth Because he's the chosen one. and also do you have the other ideas i gave to you yes or no
Absolutely loved this story
Pretty Interesting one 👌
What if grievous learned magic from talzin
The reason Vader couldn't get through the family portal: History abhors a paradox
Good idea
Great story 👏🏼
What if Anakin and Shmi escaped slavery when Anakin was 5 years old too Naboo where they met Padme
Wow, this one is very different.
9:04 vader has six fingers
Doesn't Vader's breathing bring his sneaking skill down to zero possibly into the negative?
Yes
There's always a problem with time travel. To be more specific: A paradox. IF vader actually went to kill palpatine and succeeded, then he wouldn't have existed in the first place. Therefore, no-one would have returned to kill palpatine or even warned Anakin. For Vader to exist, Anakin shall fall to the dark side, and the only way is by padme being dead so by trying to prevent it, it may have made matters worst.
Good story tho.
Probably like how Back to the Future 2 did when Biff went back in time to give his younger self info of future events to exploit, making it where Marty couldn't return to his own timeline until he undid what future Biff did due to the change causing his timeline to be severed and unreachable. The Future Marty was in at the time still existed even when Biff altered the past but once Marty left to go back to his own time, that future can't be reached anymore. So it still exists but is now cutoff from the normal timeline.
Your argument is flawed because it views time too linearly, assuming Vader’s actions in the past would directly erase his existence. While Palpatine played a key role in Anakin’s fall, his descent was driven by internal struggles like fear and ambition, which could still lead him to the dark side even without Palpatine. Killing Palpatine might change events, but it wouldn’t necessarily erase Vader.
In many time travel theories, altering the past creates a branching timeline rather than undoing the original one. Vader’s actions could create a new reality where Palpatine doesn’t corrupt Anakin, but his original timeline remains intact. Your logic oversimplifies how time travel could work and ignores the possibility of alternate outcomes/timelines
Dragon ball Z explained this best with Future Trunks. The story unfolding here is an alt timeline that was caused when Vader came back to change what occured.
@@delongorman8099 The same could be said about your argument. The existence of the multiverse is just as plausible as the theory of linear time.
I'm sorry to tell you this, but according to canon, the Star Wars universe follows the theory of linear time, as shown in Rebels with the World Between Worlds.
That said, I'm going to go with your theory. Removing Palpatine from the equation is what prevents Vader from existing. Although he displayed several dark side tendencies in The Clone Wars, those would have been isolated events if Palpatine hadn't capitalized on them. It would require an intervention from the Force to truly turn him to the dark side since, as explained in the video, Padmé didn't die, and his children are safe. The only way he could truly turn is if another dark side user influenced him.
This would have made a better film. Are you listening, Mr. Lucas?
wow
Things