So then they'll make a representation to every proposed law, duh. Too much additional bureaucracy and still not clear enough. I became quite cynical, what can I say.
The sentiment of the “voice” is great, the fact that politicians refuse to provide any information on how it will work in practice is extremely concerning. They are basically asking the people to sign a contract without being able to read it first.
That’s not really true. The way it works hasn’t been defined and isn’t part of the referendum. The way it works will be determined by Parliament in future, which means the public essentially maintain control via our elected representatives. It would be a disaster to define how it works as part of the constitution, because that’d make changing it down the road almost impossible.
@@kuribojim3916 no but you are essentially being asked to just trust that the politicians won’t screw it up. It doesn’t have anything to do with the constitution part I know but once the referendum passes you are then putting your complete trust in politicians that they will do something correctly (which they never seem to do) and the fact they will not answer a single question on how they plan for it work in practice, not just in theory, doesn’t fill anyone I know with confidence. They might set it up and leave loopholes where it could leverage it’s legislative position to make changes no one agrees with, on the other hand it could just be more taxpayer funded bureaucracy that the government ignores and is essentially just a way for them to gain social brownie points, it may be somewhere in the middle. The problem is that we don’t know and once you vote yes you have zero idea or control of how it will be set up and implemented. But hey politicians are a trustworthy bunch aren’t they
HAVE. A. FANTASTIC DAY INSIDERS WISHING U. ALL HAVE A GREAT. WONDERFUL THIS WEEK. LIKE. U ALL I ALWAYS. WITH. U LOVE. U. INSIDERS THANKS. I. WATCHED. U. TODAY. TAKE. CARE STAY. STRONG. LOVE. U. LOVE. U ALL
AUSTRALIAN. PEOPLE. WE. HAVE. A VERY. VERY. STRONG LABOR. POLITICIAN THIS. AUSTRALIAN. COUNTRY ALL PEOPLES. CHOICED NOW. WE. HAVE. TO FOLLOW. THE LEADER. WHO.EVER. T HEY. R. THAT
LOOK WHATS. GOING ON NOW NO MORE DESCEPLINE LOT. THINGS HAPPENED WEV HAVE. A GREAT COUNTRY GREAT PEOPLE WE. HAVE. DARKEST. LIFE. BURNING THIS. COUNTRY ALREADY
❤❤❤ HAPPY MON ENJOY YOUR LOVELY. GREAT. DAY INSIDERS IM GLAD. TO. WATCHED. U ALL I LIKE LOVE. U ALL INSIDERS. HOPE. U HAVE. A WONDERFUL. DAYS THIS. WEEK. TAKE. CARE. STAY. STRONG. LOVE. U. ALL
Could you put the tabs in the loading bar with sections of conversation? That would be very helpful on such a long video.
Is right
Please put chapters on these uploads @abc
Dutton and his ilk including the Murdoch media including Speers under that banner could learn a bit from Dominic Perrotet in showing respect.
So good to see Mark Dreyfus have David Speers for breakfast!
It's not the policy of the Australian govnt to share internal discourse. Sketchy
Is this an election in Australia?
So the Voice, is in effect, an advisory lobby body.
I support Neville wrans rail network and John Howards very fast train
Is Australia still Australia
NO MORE. U. S. A. WHY. OUR. GOVT. VOTED. THEM. OF W H AT. THEY WANT. SO WE HAVE. TO BE READY. WHATS. GONNA.HAPPENED.
So then they'll make a representation to every proposed law, duh. Too much additional bureaucracy and still not clear enough. I became quite cynical, what can I say.
The Voice is basically an Advisory body. They can be ignored.
The sentiment of the “voice” is great, the fact that politicians refuse to provide any information on how it will work in practice is extremely concerning. They are basically asking the people to sign a contract without being able to read it first.
That’s not really true. The way it works hasn’t been defined and isn’t part of the referendum. The way it works will be determined by Parliament in future, which means the public essentially maintain control via our elected representatives.
It would be a disaster to define how it works as part of the constitution, because that’d make changing it down the road almost impossible.
@@kuribojim3916 no but you are essentially being asked to just trust that the politicians won’t screw it up. It doesn’t have anything to do with the constitution part I know but once the referendum passes you are then putting your complete trust in politicians that they will do something correctly (which they never seem to do) and the fact they will not answer a single question on how they plan for it work in practice, not just in theory, doesn’t fill anyone I know with confidence. They might set it up and leave loopholes where it could leverage it’s legislative position to make changes no one agrees with, on the other hand it could just be more taxpayer funded bureaucracy that the government ignores and is essentially just a way for them to gain social brownie points, it may be somewhere in the middle. The problem is that we don’t know and once you vote yes you have zero idea or control of how it will be set up and implemented. But hey politicians are a trustworthy bunch aren’t they
Still sounds fishy to me
HAVE. A. FANTASTIC DAY INSIDERS WISHING U. ALL HAVE A GREAT. WONDERFUL THIS WEEK. LIKE. U ALL I ALWAYS. WITH. U LOVE. U. INSIDERS THANKS. I. WATCHED. U. TODAY. TAKE. CARE STAY. STRONG. LOVE. U. LOVE. U ALL
AUSTRALIAN. PEOPLE. WE. HAVE. A VERY. VERY. STRONG LABOR. POLITICIAN THIS. AUSTRALIAN. COUNTRY ALL PEOPLES. CHOICED NOW. WE. HAVE. TO FOLLOW. THE LEADER. WHO.EVER. T HEY. R. THAT
THANKS. DAVID. SPEERS. THATS. THE TOPIC AND. ISSUE. TODAY. UNTIL. NOW. STILL THE. SAME. CANT. SOLVED. PROBLEMS NOW. WHATS. THE. NEXT. ISSUE AGAIN.
Why do you put a full stop in constantly? Makes your comment hard to read
LOOK WHATS. GOING ON NOW NO MORE DESCEPLINE LOT. THINGS HAPPENED WEV HAVE. A GREAT COUNTRY GREAT PEOPLE WE. HAVE. DARKEST. LIFE. BURNING THIS. COUNTRY ALREADY
Why are you yelling?
❤❤❤ HAPPY MON ENJOY YOUR LOVELY. GREAT. DAY INSIDERS IM GLAD. TO. WATCHED. U ALL I LIKE LOVE. U ALL INSIDERS. HOPE. U HAVE. A WONDERFUL. DAYS THIS. WEEK. TAKE. CARE. STAY. STRONG. LOVE. U. ALL