Milladoiro es magnífico pero hay que tener cuidado de no mezclar las cosas: una cosa es la música gallega y otra la música irlandesa o escocesa, que no tienen nada que ver más allá de arreglos y apaños contemporáneos.
This album was a mixture of Irish and Galician music. I believe the album titled "25" which is all about this mixture. Also, Irish music actually has a lot in common with the traditional music of Galicia. There was actually a study on it by an American in the 1950's who went to Galicia to document the music and customs. Carlos Nunez did an appearance on it in the US Library of Congress titled "Carlos Nunez: Galician Bagpipes & Flute". It's on UA-cam.
@@johnnonamegibbon3580 first of all greetings from any place. So you think Galician and Irish music are closely related... in what sense... because of both are from European regions or because of some similarities in the instruments? Take into account that the instruments could be found anywhere in Europe (including bagpipes) but the technique that musicians use to play their tunes, in a traditional way as well as rhythms are quite different. Galician traditional music is quite a lot Spaniard but quite similar to other countries music because has received many influences from European music by the Route to Santiago and those influences are found along the Route in Castillian music, for instance. Nowadays we see a lot musicians from many places, countries and cultures playing together and doing some fantastic fusions, but they're only that, musicians who meet to play some tunes together and in their background there are different roots and consequently they belong to different cultures and musical traditions. How would you explain the AfroCeltSoundSystem then?
My point is that native traditional Galician music, while definitely distinct from Irish music, does actually share a lot of similarities to what people consider traditionally Celtic music. Going back to the Medieval period, Alan Lomax, who studies Galicia in the 1950's, points out that you can hear it in Martin Codax's compositions. And remember that the Celtic bagpipe originates in Spain. As do many other Celtic instruments like the Welsh Horn and the like. The early British and Scottish bagpipes are first recorded in Galicia, something Carlos mentions in the seminar. Galician pipes used to sound more like Scottish pipes in the 50's. Until the design changed a bit and became more streamlined. This is true for other Iberian music styles. Look at Castilian music that randomly sounds "Celtic" like _Un soldado menos_ and _Aguasvertientes_ by La Musgaña. Or _Danzas de Burgos_ in the video "Danzas de Burgos - Dulzainada 2013 - Guadalajara". The latter sounds like folk music from Brittany. Yet it's totally Spanish. They actually got that tradition from Spain, not the other way around.
A ver. Busca por ahí la " Alborada de Corcubión". Vale, la has encontrado? Pues eso es lo que toca Milladoiro, una pieza 100% gallega a la que ha visto oportuno la uilleann pope irlandesa, el boozouki griego o otros instrumentos de diversa procedencia, puesson una banda folk, no un grupo estrictamente tradicional. Que te suene irlandés no me sorprende, una por la gaita, otra porque es música gallega, que mal que te pese tiene lo que tiene de atlántica, y ya habló de eso Alan Lomax en su día.
Uno de los grupos de música celta mejores de todos los tiempos!!! Ritmo endiablado!!!!
Milladoiro es magnífico pero hay que tener cuidado de no mezclar las cosas: una cosa es la música gallega y otra la música irlandesa o escocesa, que no tienen nada que ver más allá de arreglos y apaños contemporáneos.
This album was a mixture of Irish and Galician music. I believe the album titled "25" which is all about this mixture.
Also, Irish music actually has a lot in common with the traditional music of Galicia. There was actually a study on it by an American in the 1950's who went to Galicia to document the music and customs. Carlos Nunez did an appearance on it in the US Library of Congress titled "Carlos Nunez: Galician Bagpipes & Flute". It's on UA-cam.
@@johnnonamegibbon3580 first of all greetings from any place. So you think Galician and Irish music are closely related... in what sense... because of both are from European regions or because of some similarities in the instruments? Take into account that the instruments could be found anywhere in Europe (including bagpipes) but the technique that musicians use to play their tunes, in a traditional way as well as rhythms are quite different. Galician traditional music is quite a lot Spaniard but quite similar to other countries music because has received many influences from European music by the Route to Santiago and those influences are found along the Route in Castillian music, for instance.
Nowadays we see a lot musicians from many places, countries and cultures playing together and doing some fantastic fusions, but they're only that, musicians who meet to play some tunes together and in their background there are different roots and consequently they belong to different cultures and musical traditions. How would you explain the AfroCeltSoundSystem then?
My point is that native traditional Galician music, while definitely distinct from Irish music, does actually share a lot of similarities to what people consider traditionally Celtic music. Going back to the Medieval period, Alan Lomax, who studies Galicia in the 1950's, points out that you can hear it in Martin Codax's compositions. And remember that the Celtic bagpipe originates in Spain. As do many other Celtic instruments like the Welsh Horn and the like. The early British and Scottish bagpipes are first recorded in Galicia, something Carlos mentions in the seminar. Galician pipes used to sound more like Scottish pipes in the 50's. Until the design changed a bit and became more streamlined. This is true for other Iberian music styles. Look at Castilian music that randomly sounds "Celtic" like _Un soldado menos_ and _Aguasvertientes_ by La Musgaña. Or _Danzas de Burgos_ in the video "Danzas de Burgos - Dulzainada 2013 - Guadalajara". The latter sounds like folk music from Brittany. Yet it's totally Spanish. They actually got that tradition from Spain, not the other way around.
@@pablodelvalle3545 abrazar o folclore? iso si que é amor¡
A ver. Busca por ahí la " Alborada de Corcubión". Vale, la has encontrado? Pues eso es lo que toca Milladoiro, una pieza 100% gallega a la que ha visto oportuno la uilleann pope irlandesa, el boozouki griego o otros instrumentos de diversa procedencia, puesson una banda folk, no un grupo estrictamente tradicional. Que te suene irlandés no me sorprende, una por la gaita, otra porque es música gallega, que mal que te pese tiene lo que tiene de atlántica, y ya habló de eso Alan Lomax en su día.