Texas' Power Grid Trouble is Far from Over
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 бер 2021
- Many Texans are still reeling from the power outage crisis that occurred earlier this year.
And "It's not just about Texas," says an environmental engineer. It's about the need to rethink our aging energy infrastructure throughout the U.S. Here’s why-and how it may be a sign of things to come.
PRODUCTION CREDITS:
Produced by:
Ari Daniel
Production assistance:
Christina Monnen and Amanda Willis
Archival:
ERCOT, NOAA, Shutterstock, Storyblocks
arbyreed/flickr/CC BY 2.0
kishjar/flickr/CC BY 2.0
Larry D. Moore/Wikimedia/CC BY-SA 4.0
NuclearVacuum/Wikimedia/CC BY-SA 3.0
Siemens Pressebild/Wikimedia/CC BY-SA 3.0
Tony Webster/Wikimedia/CC BY-SA 2.0
Texas by Linseed Studio from the Noun Project
NASA Earth Observatory, National Weather Service
NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center SVS
Music: APM
Special Thanks: John Watlington
© WGBH Educational Foundation 2021 - Наука та технологія
It's expensive to protect your critical infrastructure from rare events that seldom occur.
But it's F_CKING expensive when you don't.
@Michael Hawthorne 3 times as much power was lost due to natural gas failures compared to wind turbine failures, but you don't actually care about reality anyway, do you? Both types simply needed basic winterization technologies that have been commonly available and in-use elsewhere for decades, but Texas cheaped-out, even after having the same thing happen 10 years ago. Insanity.
Exactly. They are here acting like this wasn't totally avoidable. It's only unavoidable if you are only concerned about profits. Texas F'd up, simple as that.
It's expensive to prepare for Climate Change
Yeah they f’up, and other states have to bail them out...don’t mess with Texas my ass..federal $ begging Texans
@Michael Hawthorne Wind power is forming an increasing amount of the energy mix here in Canada where winters can be brutal. Failure doesn't occur, however, because our wind turbines are adapted to resist the effects of cold weather.
Y'all danced around the main issue: Energy lobbyists completely dominate Texas politics. This is not equitable.
Energy lobbyists and Jesus. lol
Yes!
yep.. can't believe you're the only person talking about it so far in the comments
Jesus, where have I heard that name before? Don't remember. Must be a guy who is ok with letting people die to make a profit. Or better, go into other countries and actively kill them.
The fascist Christianity in the USA is about the opposite of what that Jesus guy had been about.
@@GeorgeWashingtonLaserMusket You belong on a watch list.
I like how he glossed over the 'various reasons' they didn't winterize their grid after the wake-up call in 2011. Yeah, let's take a closer look into that. That's where the blame needs to lie.
(a) COST. (b) "It doesn't happen (often)" They aren't going to spend billions to fix a problem they _know_ they don't have. (of course, the rest of the world knows they have a problem, however, they refuse to admit it.)
ONCE THE BLAME IS DETERMINED THEN WHAT??? WHAT DO YOU DO TO LEADERS TO CHANGE BEHAVIOR!???
@@falcon127 get rid of people like Abbott, Perry and Cruz. Kick em to the curb.
@@JohnDavis-yz9nq Solar and wind are not very recyclable and work poorly in extreme weather. Fire the green new deal people who initially neglected Nuclear and will likely flip flop against it again just because Green Peace and other groups start throwing tantrums.
@@010203109 green energy is here to stay. Abbott tried to blame the power grid failure on green energy and it didn’t work. It backfired on him. Basically we’ve had 2 governors back to back that didn’t do their job.
Well, when you elect politicians that don't believe in governing with the interests of the people in mind, rather lining their own pockets, this IS the result
I find it puzzling, the Hispanic south boarder area is turning more repugnicon than the major city centers. Especially the way they are vilified by the racists.
Yes...not unique to ERCOT,...PG&E after all had a movie made about their extremly poor stance on public safety.
Its the Republican Party, they are cheap and always do things half ass
@@jaridkeen123 please be specific how is the Republicans Party "Cheap"
@@JR-playlists "I find it puzzling, the Hispanic south boarder area is turning more repugnicon than the major city centers. Especially the way they are vilified by the racists."
That, my friend, is the power of the emotional appeal -- and why every one of us should put critical thinking at the top of our to do list.
Superb report. I work in energy efficiency and utility planning, and this overview better explains what happened than a lot of highly technical publications managed to explain.
What happened is that Texas choose to privatize a public utility. Business exists to make a profit... not to provide uninterrupted service.
So during easy times they take a profit... that isn't used to fortify the system that is serving all of Texas. Instead the point is the profit. Not the service.
When the service fails then private owners come to the public with their hands out.... for a bail out.
And you get the worst of both worlds.
You get to pay taxes and a useless profit... for crappy infrastructure that fails you in times of emergency.
It's not a superb report. It's terrible. Not only does it get many facts wrong, it completely ignores congressional testimony. The local papers in Texas got this right, NOVA got it pretty darned wrong. This was a result of rank incompetence in the regulatory agencies, PUC and ERCOT. Run by politically appointed hacks who literally have no clue what they're doing. And literally made maters worse, during the crisis. Check out the testimony, read the local papers. Sheesh.
@@LinasVepstas This is you giving the companies involved in ERCOT a pass.
Gosh who is it that corrupted the regulators?
The companies that didn't want to spend the money on safety upgrades that's who.
Government is owned by business... so that business can blame government when things go wrong... and take profits when things are good for easy pickings.
This is what you are doing.
Fronting for private capitalist who intentionally raped Texas.
Now... what motive would someone have to do that?
Greed.
Never trust a capitalist... they are the worst criminals in human history.
My Tesla solar panels and powerwalls got me through the 44hr Houston blackout
☀️⚡🏡
but did your unicorn survive?
@@davidbrydon3969
Lol
@@davidbrydon3969 It's not _that_ rare. My nephew got through it with his rooftop solar.
Sweet!
@@davidbrydon3969 The unicorn went to Mexico with Ted Cruz and decided to sray there.
Rolling blackout? My power went out at 1AM Monday morning and I didn't get it back until Friday at 4PM.
My daughter and fiance experienced the same thing, 4+ days without power, 6 days without water due to extensive frozen pipes and needed repairs throughout their apt complex. The video addresses the need for extended multi-day (rather than rolling) blackouts in many areas; see vid beginning at 4:25. It was that or have the entire state grid collapse completely, which would have taken many weeks or even months to restore.
Yes indeed it was blackout roll out.
The issue was so bad that they run out of people to turn off so they could turn you back on. Those who didn't lose power were likely on the same circuit as something critical, like a hospital. Lucky them.
Just keep in mind that the reason you don't have power is because privatization failed you. The businesses sought a profit before they sought to make sure they provided good service. No big government regulation saved the people who froze because businesses sought a profit before seeking to provide good service.
What this means is that you don't get to claim privatization is great... you don't get to think Capitalism is great.... you don't get to say big government is bad and regulating companies is bad...And you don't get to think that Texas is great.
It's not... it's a big con job that takes your money and then leaves you freezing in a storm.
Just as it always has.
Because the point of business and markets and capitalism is to MAKE A PROFIT... not provide you with electricity in a storm.
Providing you with electricity in a storm... that is what PUBLIC utilities do.
So what I'm saying is now is the time for you to retract all that bullshit about how great capitalism is... how business provides the best service because of competition.
How did that work out for you?
People froze for unregulated capitalism in your state.
@@blogintonblakley2708 That's part of the story. The other part was rank incompetence of the regulators. They're politically appointed apparatchiks, who are there to hold the GOP party line.
Thankfully I live in East Texas and our county is one of the few not served by ERCOT! We only lost power when some of our many trees iced and broke down power lines. I was disappointed to see that ERCOT is apparently only interested in keeping those part of the profits that should have been sent to making the infrastructure more stable. And I guess that is why so many of the overpaid ERCOT executives resigned immediately after the crisis! When someone is paid over $100,000.00 a year and they failed to do their jobs, the6 should be tried as a criminal, as that is what they are.
Does this mean that we are going to treat Texas like Puerto Rico or Flint Michigan, now?
We should it's what them conservatives been preaching. We should give them a taste of their own medicine. Chances are they'll spit it out.
The problem occured because of too much goverment. But you liberia li s are jealous so stay out of Texas and go hide in.your moms basement. We will explore other worlds while you are slowly destroying you ecomany
@@garymccann2960 Oh bullshit. The problem occurred because Texas privatized is energy grid. And then when the same damned thing happened in 2011 and the feds put together a report letting Texas what they did wrong.
The companies that Texas trusts to provide power did not make the expensive upgrades that would have prevented this latest fiasco.
I retired December 31st after 35 years as a grid operator in both the Eastern and Western Interconnections. If the Texas operators have even half of the emergency operations training that I had, then they would have been able to restore a completely collapsed system in 12 to 24 hours, not the weeks implied in the video.
That's in a perfect world though. If you put a plant in the black in cold weather it won't take much to start freezing equipment then you're just stuck. You can't get the grid back up if you don't have generators.
They probably had less than half your training as a cost saving measure.
@@Banzai51 Chuckle...
I believe that they forgot to mention that 110 lives were lost in that Texas disaster.
111 now.
There was no disaster. It was an inconvenience
Texas at 111 is still less than the 15,000 who died in New York under the guidance of Andrew Cuomo.
When the weasels run the henhouse ....
TX leaning on their neighbors? - Didn't you just say they also were in the same deep freeze?
But they did the required winterizing the federal government demands, so didn't experience a catastrophic failure.
Texas is what happens when energy companies get to make all the rules and write the laws that regulate energy companies.
Indeed...
A lesson in the dangers of selfish, libertarian thinking
@@briand8090 collectivism is a ruse. See history for details.
The goverment appoints libetials from California to sit on the energy board. The goverment forced the use of windmills and solar panel s. Which quit from ice and snow. Combine that with a increase of demand a d you cradhed the grid...... the ptoblem is liberials pushing green energy sacrificing the reliability of tje grid.
@@garymccann2960 of course. Democrats run all the institutions, even in Austin.
They have known for years what needs to be done but choosing instead to keep their wallets fat instead of helping the people they "serve"
"That's what we need to do"...but we won't do it.
With like Rick Perry and Greg Abbott no it will not happen. Not to mention Cancun Cruz. No problem for him. It gets too cold he will go to Mexico and you fend for yourself.
Nobody wants to go to their large bank accounts to pay for it. They want to borrow money from China.. then have the taxpayers and the electricity customers to pay off the loans
@@markadams5823 capitalism my friend. It only works for a selected few people. We need new leadership here in Texas. We have been under 3 republicans back to back and their democracy is not working. Bush, Perry and Abbott are all duds. If you are a Texan think about that when you vote next year. You keep doing what you have been doing and you keep getting what you have been getting. As a Texan I am tired of being stupid by voting these incompetent people in office. How about you?
You GET what ya vote for! Remember this next election!
Ooh you can say that every time someone elect Somebody everywhere.
you also get this if you don't vote. Lots of voter suppression tactics used in Republican strongholds like texas...
@@ThomasBomb45 I understand. And I think WE are all lost. Sadly.
@@ThomasBomb45 EXACTLY. Should have added that, too: "You ALSO get what you DON'T VOTE AGAINST.
@@vernalc2449 And we also should not blame groups for which voting is intentionally made more difficult. There are many minority voters in the south who don't want Republicans in office but don't have much of a say because voting requires waiting in line for 5 hours
From a real Texan Lol: We had power off and on you could say for the first day, it would turn on for an hour then go off for an hour. The time span went lower each time like on for 3 minutes off for an hour, until we had no power at all. For two days we were trying to stay warm with no water and no power in a 30-40 degree house. Yes, we did have a fireplace and we did have a fire in it but that wasn’t enough. This went on for a few days until, we got 1-2 minutes of power every 2 hours on the 3rd or 4th day. CPS energy was saying that they were giving us power but 1-2 minutes WAS IT. After the power came on after almost freezing we still had NO WATER this went on for about a week and 1/2. 1/10 would not go through again.
Lack of planning on your part does not constitute an emergency on my part. In other words, water freezes.
"Low income communities tend to be more vulnerable in a crisis like this..." The swirling graphic at the end was awesome.
So what
Puff piece ...an eight minute tour of a broom closet that assiduously avoids brushing up against the elephant: Texas state politicians in bed with the utilities industry, rolling back regulation and business practices that could have easily prevented dozens of lives and billions of dollars lost by the consumers.
The EPA refused operating plants to temporarily increase their output beyond agreed limits because "Climate Change". NPR is not allowed to tell that story. Commies
@@albing1397 You know what's wrong w/ commies? They appointed Soviet apparatchiks who didn't know what they were doing. Totally incompetent administrators whose only job was to make sure that everyone toes the party line. You know how we do it in Texas? We let the GOP appoint totally incompetent morons whose only job is to make sure everyone toes the GOP party line. Same deal, same end-results. Although kudos to Gov. Abott - he actually fired the appartchik he'd appointed earlier to the PUC. Checkout the testimony in the Texas Leg.
@@albing1397 That's false. A request to exceed the limits was approved.
www.factcheck.org/2021/02/biden-administration-approved-texas-power-request-contrary-to-false-claim/
Texas did not have a sufficient base load capability. Wind and solar are not base load capable generators.
Nor in this case was natural gas base load capable. Solar doesn't work at night. Natural gas didn't work below freezing.
@@danielcarroll3358 - The well heads, lines and compression were all exposed to cold, and froze up. They had also decommissioned their oil generators.
Up in Quebec, we had a reletively short and mild winter this year.
Is it possible that this is a new trend for us too?
mild for you is harsh in most parts of Texas
See an Inconvenient Truth for direction on your question. The heat of this planet moves towards the poles where the planet's rotational speed is slower.
@@briand8090 But their models are exaggerated ... just. like the death estimates from covid. Paid science, sponsored by those who are invested in those results leads to corruption.
Building a new house. Getting a backup generator. Running it on propane.
The estimated damage of 130 billion could have been mitigated wit relatively small investment (compared with the losses) spent over a decade in hardening infrastructure. One has to wonder how much of that 130 billion in losses were actually borne by the power companies. How much money from the state and federal governments is going to these companies to fix the infrastructure that was damaged by the weather? So what is the incentive for them to fix their vulnerabilities to prepare for the next time?
Privatizing and deregulating and use market force? No providers will be willing to invest on the infrastructures because you have to compete for low prices.
They kept power on empty skyscrappers. Wake up!
Interesting.
Beautifully done, especially the imagery and maps
If only Texas was part of the SPP (Southern Power Pool), they could averted this disaster by getting power from surrounding states that share their generating capacity. Just across the Red River, power remained on even though the weather was even worse.
No one had extra power to give it wasn't localized to Texas and Texas does have interconnects with neighboring grids.
They gave as much as they could, but they were also dealing with a cold spike so they didn't have much to spare
Much of the Panhandle of Texas, down to south of Lubbock IS on SPP.
It's not super cold condition. It's not even considered "cold" if you live to the north of Texas and things like this never happened. And those states do not use so many excuses.
It was very cold. I’ve lived many years in Michigan & I had to get under like 4 blankets here and keep my head under them at night. This was no ordinary weather. We are fine and I have no issue with our leaders. I am proud of them and stand with Texas. The best state you can live in
Lord...... cheap energy? I pay 6 cents a kw. In texas was paying 18 cents a kw.
I pay 9 cents here in central Texas...
Try 30 cent in Ca.
@@Moondoggy1941 I'm on smud.
Why not be truly independent and make each building an island? Ditch the grid and get rooftop solar, geothermal heat pumps, and on site electrical storage in each house?
I do not know your age but, if you live another thirty or so years, you will see those changes. Perhaps not universally across the country but a big chunk nonetheless. We're getting there my friend...stick around.
It is happening in Australia.
This is B.S. we've had colder weather for longer periods of time. ERCOT failed!
"We're an example of what happens when you ignore reality" should be Texas' state motto.
Global warming isn't real! It isn't real, if we close our eyes and believe...this deep freeze will never happen again it was a test from God. Yes, God sent it to challenge our faith...and well I go to church every Sunday so even if the next one comes the electricity in my house will stay on! No worries.
@@justintung7981
"Republics are created by the virtue, public spirit, and intelligence of the citizens. They fall, when the wise are banished from the public councils, because they dare to be honest, and the profligate are rewarded, because they flatter the people, in order to betray them. "
--JusticeJoseph Story
"People only accept change when they are faced with necessity, and only recognize necessity when a crisis is upon them."
- Jean Monnet
what a bunch of texas haters!
@@thalesnemo2841 I really liked this post.
Why was the CEO of one of the companies responsible interviewed so much?
This is exactly why we vote for regulations.
This is what happens when the commons are privatized for profits for Uber corporations ! The general welfare is ignored!
Collapse is not only inevitable but assured! The electrical grid must be PUBLICLY RUN AND ACCOUNTABLE !
Day-67 STILL NO GRANULAR AID TO A DESPERATE POPULACE!
Good info but a fluff piece compared to the dirty back room dealings in corporate & Texas government that got us to this place. Tx is a state for corporations, not citizens.
Don't blame stupidity when Greed clearly explains it
¿por qué no los dos?
True they always play dumb while making millions so they can get away with it
There are 3 area's, East, West and Texas.
You have to feel sorry for the poor folk, they get switched off first.
When you design something you hope it will survive extremes of any temperature, taking all eventualities into account.
Saying that this wasn't anticipated was no excuse.
so there was NO plan B, and entire state was screwed. great designing and maintenance.
That was what we call a "complete whitewash". Well done, PBS!
Seems weird that a state with so much oil passing trough it, so many homes would use electricity for heat.
Nobody uses oil for heat, really, it's almost all natural gas or electric heat in homes, with wood burning for vanity reasons.
@@jacobpitts6846 Like they said in the video, 60 percent use electricity for heat. I gotta believe that is in apartments where electric is cheapest to install and have the renter pay the electric bill.
Electrical heat is expensive and clearly strains the grid. They should start there. Cold weather may be rare in some years, but getting as much of that 60% as possible off of electricity reliant heating should be the most straightforward and economically viable things to do right away. Once they reduce the major causes and issues with grid overload, the rest can be dealt with relatively quickly.
@@ronaldlindeman6136
I don't believe I have ever rented an apartment without natural gas appliances. In California, I did once have one with an electric dryer for unknown reasons, and that was bad enough. I wouldn't think that running gas lines to the few areas in an apartment would be anymore problematic than running copper wiring for 240v required for electric equivalent appliances. Natural gas is superior to electricity in almost every way for heat requirements. I'm actually hard pressed to come up with anything other than maybe a soldering iron or coffeemaker, neither of which are substantial energy hogs relatively speaking. There are even practical whole home generators set up to run when the power does go out.
Yeah, I understand that some natural gas lines went down too, but shedding people off of electricity heat use and onto natural gas would provide incentives to upgrade that infrastructure and sell that to skeptical people.
@@GeorgeVCohea-dw7ou Years ago I lived in an apartment with electric heat. I only stayed a short time, the electric heating costs were to high. At first, the apartment complex had electricity in the rent price, then they found out that was to expensive, they rerouted the electrical to each apartment. But as you say, electricity is costly heat. I'm sure they went to natural gas eventually.
you know whats messed up i live in south texas and the power went out on the first night before it was even cold enough to be an issue the second night was 9 degrees i could understand. they were keeping the businesses powered during the day and at night we would get one to two hours a night power. they decided to turn it off point blank they didnt care what would happen alot of people down here are getting ready for this to be normal during the winter now. its sad but needed.
It's simple,....follow the money...
That same week here in Florida it was in the mid 70s that second week of February.
This shows a larger problem. We are becoming way too reliant on power/energy. What happens when the next Carrington Event occurs? It won't be just our power that goes out, we'll also be without communications.
The distributed power that solar farms could offer may provide some relief.
Shows the larger problem that privatization doesn't work. That you need to actually have government regulations.
Turns out Ayn Rand was wrong.
@@robertlongoria765 The problem with electricity is the energy grid and its need to be load balanced. Solar farms add to that problem, not reduce it. The part of the problem that needs to be solved is energy storage.
@@blogintonblakley2708 Ayn Rand is a joke. I tried reading Atlas Shrugged, but couldn't stop laughing. I gave up on the book when Dagny got to Galt's Gultch and there was no lengthy discussion about how her economical theory actually functions. Right, all these old rich white people are going to labor to build that town. Fantasy. And who are they gonna trade with? No economy can function without outside trade. Fantasy. Plus, John Galt was an intellectual property thief. That coach company owned the idea for his imaginary, thermal energy law avoiding motor.
@@briand8090 Yup. Same thing happened to me. I tried reading it in high school and thought... wow here is a person that just doesn't understand why people are social.
Then study her life... you realize how true that is.
Bad thing is that she personally influenced a couple of generations of spoiled rich kids here in the USA... some of whom ended up running some important things. Like the Federal Reserve.
If you are a greedy individualist, then the book is like Carlos Castanedas' work is to the stoned ape crowd.
I've gotten to the point where I see these kinds of movements as religions... just with non anthropomorphic god's.
Like Capitalism's god is property.... something that completely misses people like Sam Harris who for some bizarre reason considers himself atheist.
{shrugs and grins}
Turbine... not Turban
Proper insulation keeps both cool air and warm air inside.
People, go solar and wind with your own storage battery units! Get rid of overhead wires!
There's also the option of thermal heat pumps for both heat and ac efficiency
130 billion dollar bill. All because elected officials decided not to hook the Texas grid to the rest of the country. Given the behavior of officials such as Cancun Cruise I doubt little will change.
Texas is connected to the rest of the grid, just not enough. We were cut off from our East, West, and Mexico links because all those regions were hit with this perfect storm too.
The DC interconnects already exist, but there wasn’t enough power from other states. Get it?
@@obits3 Those HVDC connections only had a capacity of 820 MW which wasn't enough.
While the failure to winterise the grid, the HUGE mistake was to allow end users to participate in the wholesale market.
That is what caused some homes to get bills in the tens of thousands of dollars.
End users should NEVER play in the wholesale market, they don't have the volume for it to make sense, nor do they have the knowledge to create all the required contracts to hedge against events like this.
Wrong lesson. Here is the right lesson: if it can happen at all, it will happen in Texas.
How about Earthquakes and volcanos?
@@erikkovacs3097 earthquakes happen here too.
@@JohnDavis-yz9nq Well....... nothing compared to California. Same with tornadoes. We get them in California too just nothing compared to Texas.
@@erikkovacs3097 I’ve never heard of a tornado in California unless it’s a fire tornado from the wildfires. They have water spouts in Florida which is a tornado on the water.
@@JohnDavis-yz9nq Yes. They are rare. Usually they're just dust funnels. Rarely cause any damage.
High humidity plus freezing temps is what caused this because water is so incredibly heavy.
Snaps power poles and not just power lines.
The good news is that this is a stupendous amount of water.
Enjoy your energy independence and "low" enrgy prices.
Thanks, we will.
Remember, Texas is a hell hole, convince all your friends and loved ones that still believe PBS to stop moving here.
It’s ok Texans will beg for and receive lots of federal $ bailout...that’s what they always do
@@hoaivu2010 thus spaketh troll/nothing to contribute.
🌄Winterize homes and offices, then demand isn't running so close to the margins. Take a whole systems approach. Avoid having so much demand in the first place so that during a severe weather event you still have a large margin for problems should they occur. Too razor thin were the margins that failure was statistically almost a certainty.
Don't invest any money in your future, wait for someone else to do it. Did anyone ever stop to think that may be the reason parents walked to and from school uphill? I guess better to do that than be accused of thinking ahead.
Living in Oklahoma, we have the Oklahoma Municipal Power Authority, each city can join and load balance wind, hydro, coal and natural gas. During the peak hours, the cost per kilowatt hour can surge to be very expensive. The state law allows homeowners to have solar cells but the law doesn't allow the homeowner to turn a profit if they produce more electricity than they consume. At best you can have a $0 electric bill. The cost of the panels, inverters, and batteries quickly makes it too expensive for most homeowners, and the solar panels degrade over time producing less power and batteries last less than 10 years.
Some people have hooked up their battery-electric car to DC power coming off their PV systems. That is also a plan for parking lots to have PV's in the air above the vehicles and charge vehicles during working hours, and not having to convert to AC power (until nobody is charging vehicles.)
There is also some research into 'Vehicle to Grid' where the electrical grid sends power to the vehicle if it needs to or the grid takes power from the vehicle if it needs to.
You get what you pay for.
Is the music really necessary?
And you can vote out the Republican leadership who care about their personal short-term financial benefits rather than the residents of Texas.
This problem is political, not complacency or technological.
They all point to California and claim it is a 'failed state'. Well, California is the fifth largest economy in the world. Doesn't sound like a 'failed state' to me. And you jackasses lost all your power and heat with a little cold weather that killed a bunch of people. I think the Bible talks about glass houses and throwing rocks or something that applies here.
I have been in Dallas in febuary when it has been 80 degrees
Another channel stated
Gas 48%
wind was/is 28%
Solar 5.67%
The talk about winterizing like Minnesota. How about winterizing like Oklahoma.
The Okies suffered, too.
The Ercot-air traffic controller analogy is flawed. Air Traffic Controllers, whether government employees or under contract with the government, are regulated by the FAA (i.e. the government). Ercot is not regulated by the State of Texas or any other government entity.
The grid is ok. What is needed are more power plants
There was a catastrophic bank failure in 2008, AND WHAT REGULATORS DECIDED TO DO WAS "STRESS TEST" THE BANKING SYSTEM before they would be reactivated. From Jersey, I suggest you ask the Engineers how to SEVERELY STRESS TEST the entire energy system ALL THE WAY FROM 120% DOWN TO SCRATCH. To design overall live time-feedback throughout the whole system industrially hardened, and fallback contingency plans, that the system can continue operating and including system self-defense, to minimize losses of all kinds, LIFE, Dollars, resources, inconvenience. I'm saying to design a well-behaved, robust, system to handle all contingencies of weather, disasters, earthquakes, supply-line collapses, Acts of God, terrorists, saboteurs, hackers, External Enemy attacks, acts of war, "all conceivable failure modes." At least put it on the table, articulate all aspects of the system, at least so it can be evaluated, WITH ALL STAKEHOLDERS BEING FULLY INFORMED AND REPRESENTED(residential, commercial, military, industrial). Scientific, fact and evidence-based, non-political, and non-corruptable whatever that means. When 9/11 happened Homeland Security Resulted. You need something a lot better than that, like as if your personal life depends on it. Engineers, not politicians.
TXU used to control the northern half of the state of Texas and answered to the PUC. Then forced deregulation hit and TXU divested all of its generating plants and become Oncore, which only delivers power. Now we reap the dividends of those decisions. Lack of power, poor grid system quality, lack of regulation, and lack of planning and enforcement. The reason why we don't connect our grid outside of Texas? Because THEN we would have to follow the same regulations that everyone else does, which includes proper winterizing and reserve power generation capabilities. This is from the old "there's 49 states and then there is Texas" mentality.
Blame it on Ronald Ray-gun, he is the one that pushed all that deregulation crap. After he made his push, utilities got higher than house payments, and he wasn't even from Texas.
Freeze off is a big lie for nat gas. The power was cut off to the nat gas compressor stations
Pretty irresponsible not to even mention that this isn't the first time Texas' grid froze .. over a decade ago a very cold snap shorter and less broad froze critical parts of ERCOT's grid ... The feds (who cannot force ERCOT to implement changes investigated wrote a nice paper with lots of recommendations that ERCOT ignored ... Allowing the even bigger freeze.
It's important to give a story this important the proper context .. to not even mention this history is a serious journalistic problem.
There are several methods for water removal from the gas pipelines. Water provides no benefit at all to the gas flow, etc. I believe that few water extraction methods were being used in Texas, so the water in the pipes froze, not the gas. That would cost them money. Now the head of Ercot says they see no need to change anything. I bet not. Adding water extraction if it is not being used, on SO MANY systems might cost a lot and that's really all they care about. Also, water in the pipes might corrode the pipes, shortening their life. Perhaps pipelines aren't so wonderful after all?
Here's a great idea, just send every Texan to Cancun for a week or so, Ted can arrange it.
Where ever you go there you are.
Why can't people use common sense anymore. I don't know ANYONE that doesn't plan a foreign vacation at least a month in advance...the storm didn't give a months notice in advance...so Ted was supposed to cancel the trip? To do what exactly? Generate hot air like you? ... Asking for a friend.
@@seetheworldfrommyharley Doubt you know anyone who's been 10 miles away from their home ever. He planned the trip when his wife said "it's cold, lets go to Cancun" after Texas lost power and water.
@@oceannavagator Shows how much you know. I was living in Brazil for 4 months when I commented. It's ok for people to share their opinion just as YOU did
Keep voting for the big Red, Texas, keep being the "lone" star. All about that strength...ain't so strong when nobody comes to bail out your failing power grid.
Raising excessive profits by maintaining on the cheap.
The bells could have been done without in the background.
The state,,,, infrastructure, more infrastructure. Be prepared.
I'm from Canada and I'm a painter duluxe get their raw material from Texas there is no more paint here in Ontario or should I say limited amount
Too much of the dependence on one power source. Green wind and solar will never meet Texas needs.
I don't think you actually watched the video and know the percentage of power that is satisfied by wind/solar energy in Texas.
Spoiler, 80% is through classical resources like natural gas, coal, nuclear energy and so on. So what you're babbling is pure fiction and propaganda, ey.
climate change is about climate instability.
Also, what happens when that freeze event happens over the Atlantic or Pacific Oceans?
Wait a minute! While the Texas power grid is independent of others in the U.S., why not connect with grids in Mexico? Is that a possibility.?
Freezing gas, water and oil totalling $130 Billion costs, because winterisation steps were not implemented by energy companies. That was a huge mistake, costing all the Texans! (Not as softly described at 7:10) . Those unrestricted energy companies who did have power could charge high (a year's) cost to you for a few days power.
Mother nature makes the rules she going to come back around to put it back the way it should be
And She is Great. We love Texas, everyone is cooking ! Check out our Chefs recipes and tools ....
And Abbott wants his reelection
🤣🤣🤣
pointing finger of blame - done. now do what needs to be done and FIX IT!
fixing it starts at determining where the root of the problem lies: the actions and motives of the people responsible for the disaster, and why they had the power to set up this much damage in the first place
Build more power plants more depending electricity and the rise of electric automobiles
Had some trumper bite my head off when i was rude in pointing out the obvious!!
America is a prime example of why Capitalism does not work. The whole Model of Capitalism is to be as Cheap as possible to get the most profit. To achieve this Workers are paid low wages, Work places are unsafe, and businesses don't do things they should do to be prepared because they know the Tax Payer will Bail them out. If Tax Payers are going to have to fix the problem these companies make then they should be owned by the people to ensure the problem doesn't occur in the first place.
But insulation against cold, also works for insulation against cold!
_*Texas experiences rolling blackouts_
...
Generac Holdings - "Say, y'all look cold and miserable. You look like the kind of people that would enjoy some of our reliable, and affordable, premium generators."
And the Republicans & ERCOT have already forgotten February 2021 winter.
VERY SMART MOVE TEXAS LEADERS! DON'T WORRY NOTHING WILL HAPPEN TO YOU! THE US NEVER HOLDS GOVERNMENT LEADERS ACCOUNTABLE!
Republikans just passed a tax payer funded fund to sue other states that drop coal, we are so 🍆ed
Don't worry about.
This time they will fix it.
For real.
DEFINITELY this time.
Fix, yes Fix it.
You can pay me now or you can pay me later!!
Deregulation and privatization of public services that are in fact human needs for life itself, is how these Republican and corporate Democrates stay in office and pad their bank accounts. This must end under Biden and the current, and ongoing Congress. Voters need to start voting for their own best interest, and that's not party ideologies that has done nothing but leave us the 99% behind on all that counts ashumane human care and happiness.
Cmon over to our grid!
In that Texas is connected to the national grid as a provider, it refused to be consumer. The failure is one of both political and corporate intransigence. That impacts Texas more than if Texas died not provide to other states.
unpleasant rapid light flashes not friendly
This is really an example of the have and the have-nots. All of the folks in the high-rise expensive condos kept their light heat and water.
They decided they had to blacken the neighborhoods of the poorest most vulnerable people. Who would freeze to death.
Whereas those wealthy people in the high-rise apartment condo buildings. Could have left the building. Obtained transportation to a hotel outside the city that had power. But poor people next door froze to death. Because their power, heat and water was interrupted. On purpose! So the rich people could stay warm and comfortable and alive. And they could clean out unnecessary people. That become nothing more than a financial burden to the Texas economy. And so when you review all of the monetary figures involved. The old, the poor, the immigrant, the vulnerable people all must die. So the wealthy people can remain comfortable and not have to move out of the city into a hotel for a short while. And be inconvenienced. While their neighbors freeze to death and die.
So I'm sick of this Texas bullshit spin rhetoric garbage I keep hearing down here! It's nothing more than a bunch of neo-Nazi Gestapo fascist extremist conservative dictator pigs. Lining their pockets! Allowing people to die! And that's the conservative Republican Christian family Backspace value way! And they all need to be summarily and promptly, exterminated! We need to do to them what the Italians did to Mussolini. It was called DIY sushi. But they had no WASABI. And so they missed out on a great Mussolini sushi dinner. Only because they had no WASABI. But we have WASABI!
I would personally like to see Ted Cruz filleted. And Rick Perry flash frozen. Freeze-dried. John Cornyn should be pickled. Dan Patrick and Greg Abbott. Should be put in a trash compactor together. And anybody who wants to call themselves a Conservative? Shoot to kill. Because they are the opposite. They are Gestapo Nazi fascist pigs. That want to force their way of life upon everyone else. Because they believe they have the better fascist Nazi Gestapo way. And they are protected by their religious freedom and hiding behind the guise of Jesus. We need to introduce them directly to Jesus as soon as possible. And I am happy to volunteer. I don't like Nazis. I've never liked Nazis. I never will like Nazis. And Nazi is just a euphemism for Texans. Texans are nothing but Nazis. That ripped children babies toddlers, from their mother's arms. With lame excuses. So they can rectify their miss doings. And then get forgiven by Jesus on Sunday. To wreak havoc again. Monday through Saturday. And then repeat the process being forgiven of their sins every Sunday. So they can go out and destroy people's lives again every week. And claiming to do the work of God. Those kinds need to be taken out very quickly. Right between the eyes.
I want to come up with a new semiautomatic weapon that looks just like a Christian cross. You'll hold it vertically and march with it in front of you. And then you just grab it with your right hand. And start pulling the trigger. Aiming the cross at the Christians. To send them to Jesus directly.
It's the new Whammo Jesus Cross Semi-Automatic Handgun. Available in 9 mm and 38 caliber varieties. For use in Europe or the USA.
Coming soon is the Vatican Cross Automatic Rifle. Coming to an armory pulpit near you! You can take out all of those priests, bishops and cardinals in one fell swoop. Everyone's going to want one! That priest or that bishop or that cardinal. And you'll need the Vatican Cross Automatic Rifle to be the winner in your neighborhood competition. For cleansing the Catholic Church of all sexual perverts and child molesting pedophiles. Placed into a prison cell. Which is decoratively lined like a library. Wall to wall to wall full of manuals called Bibles. All of which are glued and screwed together. Because he won't need to be reading any of those. He never got them right the first time. But he should be able to look at what he did not understand the first time. For the rest of their lives. Because Bibles and minor children and sex don't go together. Especially with men that want them to see God. I think they just did. You made certain of it. And now we have to show you God also. God awful. God horrible. God no. God please stop. God I'm sorry. All of those gods you believe in. Because it was not the God of innocence and children. It was the godly fun you knew you could have as a pedophile. Because the church doesn't allow you to have sex. That would be sinful! Yeah that's a cult. Of grown emotionally immature children who like to believe in fairytales their entire lives long. And then from 2000 years ago. Feel they should instruct how everybody should live 21 years into the 21st-century today. What's wrong with that picture? Or poisonous tincture?
And furthermore…
i believe it will happen again, government never learn