Ayeon's solo part 40 seconds Taeyeon's solo part 33 seconds Tiffany's solo part 32 seconds They sang together in the rest of the parts Ayeon did main singing and high note technique. Tiffany did rap part and low voice support, high note technique. Taeyeon did high note support and high note technique.
Jaselyn G Yes because people were blaming that Taeyeon and Tiffany didn't support Ayeon well but selfishly boasted their vocals instead of giving more parts to Ayeon. However, people don't know how much They cared Ayeon. Tiffany designed and directed the whole stage and outfits to make the rookie girl shine. Ayeon is the beginning and the end of performance with the longest main singing part. She is the one stays in the center with white outfit while TaeTif are supporting vocals in black on the sides. The only thing they did wrong is that TaeTif did their best at singing, which out-shined Ayeon to the point people feel like TaeTif sang the most of the parts.
Ayeon has more line but Taeny stage presence is too strong.. Taeyeon strong voice and Tiffany rap/high notes/english.. the problem is Ayeon is too shy.. she lacks stage presence.. she will shine too if she try to be more open.. i mean not shy..
It's understandable. Standing alone on that stage with that song is scary, and now she has to sing together with two queens Taeyeon and Tiffany. I will die if I was there. lol.
idk why people are pointing out the obvious like that as if there was something wrong with ayeon. she literally was never a trainee, wasn't a trainee yet, didn't do stage or dance training like taeyeon and tiffany did. taeyeon and tiffany had years of training under a huge company, had years of debut to their belt as well as stage and especially concert experience. plus they're idol singers whereas ayeon has always been a ballad/indie singer and has always sang with her piano accompaniment. everyone has a start and absolutely nobody is stellar in the beginning.
@@jinlissul yeah, ppl just explained it bcs that time ppl mad at taeNy thought they're so selfish purposely outshined a yeon, they said taeNy trying so hardd and not support her when she get the most solo part
I dont understand why people are mad about how tiffany and taeyeon "stole" the spotlight from ayeon. I understand that this was her performance and they out-shined her but that is her problem. Finding a person with a good voice is easy, finding a star that can command the stage is hard. She had the most lines, different dress and most screen time, she was given the advantage, but she didn't grab it. She wasn't able to shine and demand the attention from the audience, and that is why she didn't win. That is her fault, not anyone else's.
Charles G I don't care who's more famous. She should be happy that theyre more famous. She should've used the chanced to gain more fans, but she didn't. She let the fact that they're more famous get to her hair and she lost her confidence. Even if I didn't know who taeny was, I still wouldn't have paid attention to her because she has not stage presence. If you're good enough on stage, i dont care who else is on stage, you'll shine just as much.
A yeon is a good singer but her shyness can be felt through her lack of stage presence, something that is key in the music world and helps make performances more riveting. Even if she got the high notes and runs, the lack of stage presence would not have been any different.
Way to make excuses... Ah Yeon is inexperienced so no shit sherlock she's going to have less stage presence than her seniors. But she's the one in the competition and they're supposed to be helping her so giving her the runs and stuff would have made her more memorable regardless. If you see the other performances you'll know what I mean. The YG and JYP artists made the contestants the highlight of the song.
Tash Kay Still going on and on about this? Fine tell me what're you going to do if you're Taeyeon and Tiffany. You're gonna half ass the high notes and the performance so Ah Yeon can take the spotlight? This is Ah Yeon's special stage, so of course they're going to give it their all for her, while people like you see that as selfishness. Like the person you replied said, Ah Yeon hit her high notes part greatly, but she lacks stage presence. Even if Ah Yeon gets some of Taeyeon's high notes, with her level of stage presence that time, it'll still be the same. I watched the practice video and thought that they helped her so much like to tell them if she's not feeling confident or if she's uncomfortable on stage (mind you there might be more things that they helped her with that didn't caught on film). She agreed to do the song anyway, and I think this song is focused on vocals more than the choreo. If they chose another song with more choreo, she's going to be more overshadowed. She's almost always in the center during this performance anyway.
Tash Kay Besides, I don't think Taeyeon and Tiffany willingly chose the parts. The company would've chose the parts for them, and Ah Yeon okay-ed it. You think TT who helped her so much in the practice video actually WANTS Ah Yeon to be overshadowed?
Joshua Ian LOL why are you getting so mad about this? Are you seriously saying there were extras to the practice video and insinuating things that neither you nor anyone else except for the people that were there knew? So you haven't looked at the Miss A video then clearly? That was four people and just Hayi but she definitely stood out. And no Hayi does not have stage presence. Just look at her Mama performance! Infact...the only other video where the contestant is overshadowed again is that Shinee one. Surprise surprise they belong to SM! It would NOT have been the same if Ah Yeon had the high notes. She would have stood out for her SINGING even if her stage presence wasn't up to par. How is just putting her in the center making her stand out? If theres someone in the middle of the stage just singing back vocals and the person next to them is doing runs and high notes then my attention is definitely on the person to the side. Duh. Plus we wouldn't have to hear Tiffany do that terrible strain trying to hit Christina's high note (but why should I even bother pointing this out- you, being the deluded fan you are, will just call me a hater/jealous etc, etc, for giving an honest technical critique)
Tash Kay Oh so they only practiced ONCE which is just in that video and they did the performance this well? Wow you give them too much credit even for the most popular girl group :P. Your fortune telling is not right btw. I won't call you hater/jelly. So by that comment, you're pointing that the fault lies in SM not in TT correct? Then I agree with you. What I don't agree is when people hates on TT for doing their best in this performance. I really think SM chose the parts, cause like you said the Shinee perf has the same problem.
Tbh, the reason Taeyeon and Fany stood out more is they were putting more soul into their singing giving them more of the spotlight while Ayeon barely showed much soul into her singing as well as being pretty stiff so even though she had an upper hand in standing out more because of her dress, more screen time, and solo time; no one focused on her as much because of her lack of charisma and expression. So, sure Ayeon is a good singer but she lacks the necessary emotion to sing as strong as TaeNy.
+Xshiso10 Well TaeNy have been in the industry for years, the know the stage and how to own it, this was a first time for Ahyeon obviously she'd be scared, nervous and stiff smh -_-
+Juliana Gonzalez I'm not hating I'm just stating what's true, she could have at least shown more power with her voice during her parts, because taking different risks as well as showing off is usually what showbiz is all about. Since this was a singing competition, she would have performed a few times before, so she would have already had a bit of a feel of the stage. So who knows? It may have been the sexual concept of the song that may have thrown her off a bit, but I bet since this performance was a long while back she's probably really improved with her presence on stage.
OMO ItsGigi Ahyeon was unexperienced back them and this show is supposed to highlight the contestants, if what you say it's the case then TaeNy are really selfish..
Juliana Gonzalez They aren't selfish. It's more of a habit/a constant thing they do that when they're performing on stage, they always give their best. It's a natural thing for them to stand out more evsn though they have fewer lines because they're the two vocalists of a national girlgroup. They're a whole lot more experienced than Ayeon, and anyone would get overshadowed. They have that stage presence, and I agree that they put more soul into singing unlike Ayeon. Although, Ayeon is really good in singing, but as a performer you should show that you are THE performer regardless of who is/are singing with you.
It wasn't perfect, but it's the fact she's able to play it off and continue going. The worst thing a singer can do is lose confidence, and Tiffany seems well aware of that
Ayeon should learn how to control the stage with Yoona, Yuri, Hyoyeon or Sooyoung..or even Sunny. She got the voice which is already okay. But she's too shy and don't know how to control the stage for her own. Their voice are at the same level even more than Tiffany but not pass Taengoo. But the different between them is those two, TaeNy know who to control their stage appearance. So it's common for them to steal the sportlight from her. They supposed to invited YoonYulHyoSooSun to teach her how to perform on stage with TaeNy. YoonYulHyoSoo don't have a lot of lines in their songs but everytime they on stage, they know how to make the stage become their. People will focus on them while listen to the lead singers sing. It's not TaeNy fault here actually...lol...
Her singing level is more than Tiffany? definitely not.. TaeNy are both a great singer, nothing can defeat them if they've already concured the stage 😂😅
Wth is wrong with you guys Baek Ayeon had more lines, but the only problem was she wasn't energetic. It isn't taeny fault that she was like that instead Taeny tried to put more energy she can Baek Ayeon. Its an amazing performance just enjoy it!
To everyone who says that Tae and Fany should've toned it down with their performance so that Ayeon could shine more, let me as you this: can you ask a god to be anything less than a god? For me, Ayeon HAS talent, that is clear with her voice, but in this performance, she lacked stage presence, that's why people say TaeNy out shined her. It could be either that she was nervous performing with them (and who wouldn't? They're in freaking SNSD, the nations girl group), or that she wasn't comfortable with the song (it IS a very mature song and performance in general, and she was quite young at the time.) or the outfit. To me, she seemed stiff in this performance, but she DOES have an insane amount of talent, be it vocally or dance wise. (I am NOT a hater, just wanted to put it out there.)
I mean I guess, not saying your opinion is wrong but if you watch g-dragons and tops performance with jimin, you could tell they actually tried to give her the spotlight, and she shined bc they actually tried to not outshine her. So I mean, in a way tae and fany could've done a better job at letting her have the spotlight.
I'm guessing its the song. Maybe it's too strong for Ayeon. I dunno. There are good point too if Tae and Fany didn't tone down and Ayeon Level up with them.. It's a case to case basis.. In this case, I think Ayeon got a bit intimidated. It was a chance for her to excel.. and I think she did at the last minute. Sometimes, it's not really good if the featured artist to tone down bec sometimes it means the contestant cannot level out him/herself to the artists. If I were the contestant I would love for my featured artist to give it all. cuz then it will be a good challenge for me to raise my bar up with them.. That's my take
Telling a great singer to sing poorly while not performing poorly is quite difficult. Like, they are supposed to satisfy the listeners, yet they are supposed to make one person stand out? I find it good enough that Ayeon could at least stand by their side. Besides, Ayeon simply isn't as good as Taeyeon or Tiffany, so for Ayeon to actually stand out more than she did here is wanting the impossible. They could've given her more solo time, but she already has the most, and cutting another one off would be very awkward. It simply wouldn't sound good.
J Imactuallydeadinside Ayeon got a lot of line tho~ but she choose not to give her best TaeNy sing that good to cover Ayeon and if you can see They motivated Ayeon to give her best look at Taeyeon dancing while Ayeon is on the center i think she want Ayeon to follow her moved and make Ayeon be confident but Ayeon didnt grab the opportunity to do her part well. Taeny cant do anything about Ayeon stage presence
When I first watched this, I thought, like many others, that Tae and Tiff had more lines, but when I re-watched it, I realized that they actually had fewer lines. I think the reason it felt as if they had more lines was because they stood out and captured the audiences full attention, while A Yeon didn't. Because we are more focused on Taeny, we feel as if they had more parts. It also doesn't help A Yeon's case that she was more reserved in her movements and expression. She pretty much had the same facial expression throughout the whole performance, while Tae and Tiff were enjoying themselves and having fun. I don't claim to be an expert, but to me, although A Yeon is a good singer, she doesn't really have a strong stage presence. However, this is probably just due to her inexperience compared to Taeny.
Keep in mind that : 1. A Yeon was a contestant at this point, a /fourteen-year-old/ at that, while Tiffany and Taeyeon are seasoned artists at the top of their game. Even if they toned it down to just being A Yeon's back dancers, they would still have more presence than her because of how established they are. 2. Different from Jimin and GD's collaboration, all three on this stage are girls. When all three performers are of the same gender and dressed similarly, the audience would naturally compare them in a way they can't compare performers of different genders. 3. Tiffany and Taeyeon had no synergy with A Yeon--or even with Kpopstar, for that matter--because they were probably there for a purpose. This was when TTS started, and this song is right up their alley. Be it the company or the managers that tell them, "Hey look, this gig will take up time but think of it as a good opportunity," they do have to promote themselves first and foremost during any public appearance.
Lee hi was a contestant that collab with all girls too but she looks very comfortable there. I'm not saying that Tiff and Tae wanted to outshine her because they did not. She just didn't really show her best on stage that day
i do believe the purpose of this colaboration performance is to test the contestants stage presence. if she can handle herself or even surpass the more experienced ones like taeyeon and tiffany on stage. even if this is just a special stage. judges still judge you by this performance.
Ahyeon is shy.. It's not her style. She need to work on her stage presence... She needs to know that she's good and beautiful. The other two really shows that they are used in big crowds..
I'm sure Tiffany does, since she was in the U.S. until 15 years old (and that phrase is most of the French words the average American knows). I don't know about the others, but I feel like it may be something Tiffany would tell Taeyeon.
Love K-pop For the record, I wasn't invoking TaeNy when I said my last sentence, _but I do like that you interpreted it that way!_ XD (I was just thinking about cultural exchange and how SoShi would likely talk about lyrics they'd be singing.)
Love K-pop Mdrr, j'ai eu la même réaction que toi.. C'est assez marrant quand on shippe le TaeNy et qu'elles se lancent des sourires en chantant ce genre de chanson. (x
They probably should have changed the arrangement a little to give Ayeon some more of the money notes that Tiffany or Taeyeon would ordinarily sing in duet. That said, Ayeon didn't exactly bring down the house with the money notes she DID sing, so it might not have mattered.
In this song, tiffany seems train her high pitch more harder, before, she could not reach F note, but here, she could reach it. Fany is really hardworker person
You can tell Ayeon was super nervous and just plain not used to performing such song. Taeyeon and Tiffany held back a lot to let Ayeon shine but yea, it just wasn't working. But I'm sure if Ayeon performed this song now, she'd rock it!
Taeyon and Tiffany was spectacular but I don't see why some people blame Ayeon. You're comparing a rookie with veterans and you say it's the rookie's fault? Plus, I'm not sure but I think that they don't really get to fight for having more lines. They just take what they get. Oh well.
Taeny did great I love their powerful voice but Baek Ayeon should have said that she need more lines she has a powerful voice too but she didn't use it ...I believe if she have done that then she would have win ...Great Job Taeny
Taeny really helped Baek Ayeon before the performance, teaching her what should she do. But you can't blame Taeyeon and Tiffany for performing well cause hello, they are trained very well to perform like that, Baek Ayeon needed to have more confidence i think and her facial expression. You can't blame her though cause she was not working at the industry that long as the others
I'm really happy as to how taeyeon enjoy this stage, she confidently hit the high notes and perfectly play in her parts. Ayeon did a great job specially in the first part, it's just taeyeon and tiffany shows how experienced they are.
Poor Ah Yeon... while I do think she could've gotten more parts, part of the reason she didn't do well was her own fault. She lacked stage presence compared to Tiffany and Taeyeon who were overflowing with charisma. They put Ah Yeon in the center most of the time so she should've taken advantage of it more :P
In my opinion it's Ayeon fault. If you watch Park Jimin's live with GD and T.O.P you can see that she feel totally confortable on stage and she really looks like a star and not just like a candidate of a competition...
I think it's a good move that ayeon didn't take lead because being a star is just not being front and center sometimes you have to Lear how to support your partners
Taeyeon and tiffany always give their best it's not their fault that they are just naturally a star that anyone stand beside them they will be outshine no matter what
All three of them did great. Taeyeon and Tiffany did well as expected and Ahyeon did really well for a rookie. Not to mention this is quite a challenging song. Props to her for trying and doing her best. No one here is to blame.
![Park Ji Min With GD&TOP [Oh, Yeah] @KPOPSTAR 20120422](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rM0zHDWEMRA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Fancam] 120212 TaeNy - Lady Marmalade Girls' Generation Tour in Bangkok](/img/n.gif)
Whatever people are saying, it's obvious Tiffany and Taeyeon are stars. They don't try to stand out, they just do.
God. Taeyeon's high notes were so perfect, I am too stunned.
Ayeon's solo part 40 seconds
Taeyeon's solo part 33 seconds
Tiffany's solo part 32 seconds
They sang together in the rest of the parts
Ayeon did main singing and high note technique.
Tiffany did rap part and low voice support, high note technique.
Taeyeon did high note support and high note technique.
Wow u actually counted it
Jaselyn G Yes because people were blaming that Taeyeon and Tiffany didn't support Ayeon well but selfishly boasted their vocals instead of giving more parts to Ayeon. However, people don't know how much They cared Ayeon. Tiffany designed and directed the whole stage and outfits to make the rookie girl shine. Ayeon is the beginning and the end of performance with the longest main singing part. She is the one stays in the center with white outfit while TaeTif are supporting vocals in black on the sides. The only thing they did wrong is that TaeTif did their best at singing, which out-shined Ayeon to the point people feel like TaeTif sang the most of the parts.
good job
Hongjae Yim Excellent!
Andrew Yim well done!
I love how BoA supports taeyeon and tiffany (she even clapped at the end) and baek Ayeon is so awesome
***** it's YG's Pres. Yang Goon...
***** BOA is young
Ayeon has more line but Taeny stage presence is too strong.. Taeyeon strong voice and Tiffany rap/high notes/english.. the problem is Ayeon is too shy.. she lacks stage presence.. she will shine too if she try to be more open.. i mean not shy..
Ayeon is lack of facial expression also
It's understandable. Standing alone on that stage with that song is scary, and now she has to sing together with two queens Taeyeon and Tiffany. I will die if I was there. lol.
idk why people are pointing out the obvious like that as if there was something wrong with ayeon. she literally was never a trainee, wasn't a trainee yet, didn't do stage or dance training like taeyeon and tiffany did. taeyeon and tiffany had years of training under a huge company, had years of debut to their belt as well as stage and especially concert experience. plus they're idol singers whereas ayeon has always been a ballad/indie singer and has always sang with her piano accompaniment. everyone has a start and absolutely nobody is stellar in the beginning.
@@jinlissul yeah, ppl just explained it bcs that time ppl mad at taeNy thought they're so selfish purposely outshined a yeon, they said taeNy trying so hardd and not support her
when she get the most solo part
@@rinarphi9202 that doesn't mean that snsd fans gotta throw ayeon under the bus and throw jabs at her as if she did anything wrong jfc
나오기 전에 소시 안티들이 온갖 개소리하다가 막상 나와서 개찢으니까 파트 가지고 난리치는 전설의 무대네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I dont understand why people are mad about how tiffany and taeyeon "stole" the spotlight from ayeon. I understand that this was her performance and they out-shined her but that is her problem. Finding a person with a good voice is easy, finding a star that can command the stage is hard. She had the most lines, different dress and most screen time, she was given the advantage, but she didn't grab it. She wasn't able to shine and demand the attention from the audience, and that is why she didn't win. That is her fault, not anyone else's.
Charles G I don't care who's more famous. She should be happy that theyre more famous. She should've used the chanced to gain more fans, but she didn't. She let the fact that they're more famous get to her hair and she lost her confidence. Even if I didn't know who taeny was, I still wouldn't have paid attention to her because she has not stage presence. If you're good enough on stage, i dont care who else is on stage, you'll shine just as much.
well at least they should give another parts to baek ahyeon and give her another adlibs
Aliya Natania but what if Ayeon didnt cant the parts or adlib theyre give? And besides its ayeon fault not to grab the opportunity to shine herself
She lacks stage presence. That's it. She should train more.
No better names very very well said
A yeon is a good singer but her shyness can be felt through her lack of stage presence, something that is key in the music world and helps make performances more riveting. Even if she got the high notes and runs, the lack of stage presence would not have been any different.
Way to make excuses...
Ah Yeon is inexperienced so no shit sherlock she's going to have less stage presence than her seniors. But she's the one in the competition and they're supposed to be helping her so giving her the runs and stuff would have made her more memorable regardless. If you see the other performances you'll know what I mean. The YG and JYP artists made the contestants the highlight of the song.
Tash Kay Still going on and on about this? Fine tell me what're you going to do if you're Taeyeon and Tiffany. You're gonna half ass the high notes and the performance so Ah Yeon can take the spotlight? This is Ah Yeon's special stage, so of course they're going to give it their all for her, while people like you see that as selfishness. Like the person you replied said, Ah Yeon hit her high notes part greatly, but she lacks stage presence. Even if Ah Yeon gets some of Taeyeon's high notes, with her level of stage presence that time, it'll still be the same. I watched the practice video and thought that they helped her so much like to tell them if she's not feeling confident or if she's uncomfortable on stage (mind you there might be more things that they helped her with that didn't caught on film). She agreed to do the song anyway, and I think this song is focused on vocals more than the choreo. If they chose another song with more choreo, she's going to be more overshadowed. She's almost always in the center during this performance anyway.
Tash Kay Besides, I don't think Taeyeon and Tiffany willingly chose the parts. The company would've chose the parts for them, and Ah Yeon okay-ed it. You think TT who helped her so much in the practice video actually WANTS Ah Yeon to be overshadowed?
Joshua Ian
LOL why are you getting so mad about this? Are you seriously saying there were extras to the practice video and insinuating things that neither you nor anyone else except for the people that were there knew?
So you haven't looked at the Miss A video then clearly? That was four people and just Hayi but she definitely stood out. And no Hayi does not have stage presence. Just look at her Mama performance!
Infact...the only other video where the contestant is overshadowed again is that Shinee one. Surprise surprise they belong to SM!
It would NOT have been the same if Ah Yeon had the high notes. She would have stood out for her SINGING even if her stage presence wasn't up to par. How is just putting her in the center making her stand out? If theres someone in the middle of the stage just singing back vocals and the person next to them is doing runs and high notes then my attention is definitely on the person to the side. Duh.
Plus we wouldn't have to hear Tiffany do that terrible strain trying to hit Christina's high note (but why should I even bother pointing this out- you, being the deluded fan you are, will just call me a hater/jealous etc, etc, for giving an honest technical critique)
Tash Kay Oh so they only practiced ONCE which is just in that video and they did the performance this well? Wow you give them too much credit even for the most popular girl group :P.
Your fortune telling is not right btw. I won't call you hater/jelly. So by that comment, you're pointing that the fault lies in SM not in TT correct? Then I agree with you. What I don't agree is when people hates on TT for doing their best in this performance. I really think SM chose the parts, cause like you said the Shinee perf has the same problem.
Tbh, the reason Taeyeon and Fany stood out more is they were putting more soul into their singing giving them more of the spotlight while Ayeon barely showed much soul into her singing as well as being pretty stiff so even though she had an upper hand in standing out more because of her dress, more screen time, and solo time; no one focused on her as much because of her lack of charisma and expression. So, sure Ayeon is a good singer but she lacks the necessary emotion to sing as strong as TaeNy.
+Xshiso10 Well TaeNy have been in the industry for years, the know the stage and how to own it, this was a first time for Ahyeon obviously she'd be scared, nervous and stiff smh -_-
+Juliana Gonzalez I'm not hating I'm just stating what's true, she could have at least shown more power with her voice during her parts, because taking different risks as well as showing off is usually what showbiz is all about. Since this was a singing competition, she would have performed a few times before, so she would have already had a bit of a feel of the stage. So who knows? It may have been the sexual concept of the song that may have thrown her off a bit, but I bet since this performance was a long while back she's probably really improved with her presence on stage.
+Juliana Gonzalez if your a performer u can't show that on stage no matter who's on stage with u
OMO ItsGigi Ahyeon was unexperienced back them and this show is supposed to highlight the contestants, if what you say it's the case then TaeNy are really selfish..
Juliana Gonzalez They aren't selfish. It's more of a habit/a constant thing they do that when they're performing on stage, they always give their best. It's a natural thing for them to stand out more evsn though they have fewer lines because they're the two vocalists of a national girlgroup. They're a whole lot more experienced than Ayeon, and anyone would get overshadowed. They have that stage presence, and I agree that they put more soul into singing unlike Ayeon. Although, Ayeon is really good in singing, but as a performer you should show that you are THE performer regardless of who is/are singing with you.
Not an SNSD fan (their music is definitely not my style) but their three main singers are great, particularly Taeyeon.
GablesHorse Ayeon is not in Snsd
Farahnatasha 9022 I know :) I mean Tiffany, Taeyeon and Seohyun.
GablesHorse
:)
Tiff, and Seo is not SNSD's Main singers though, but yeah, among SNSD half of them are good singers Tiff and Seo included.
tine smith I assumed they were, that as the three strongest they deserved a subunit?
ㅋㅋㅋ이 무대 전설이였죠 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 소녀시대 안티들이 아이돌 실력 없는 거품이라고 꽉꽉~~거리다~ 이 무대보고 다들 버러우~~~~ ㅋㅋㅋ
the way tiffany make highnote is perfect
Agree
Agree
It wasn't perfect, but it's the fact she's able to play it off and continue going. The worst thing a singer can do is lose confidence, and Tiffany seems well aware of that
@@GenerationBright no doubt she made it amazing just like in the studio version ♥️♥️👏👏 queen
갓 소녀시대
와우!!!
소녀시대는 진짜 넘사벽이지
소녀시대 만큼 능력있는 걸그룹을 본적이 없는듯
모두가 안정적 평균 수준도 여타 걸그룹을 압도함
괜히 인기있는게 아님
태연의 전설의 악플러 씹압살 무대.
(무대전-> 태연이 케이팝에 나올짬이 되냐ㅋ)
(무대후-> ....
Taeyeon's powerful voice, omg I'm inlove..
It wasn't that powerful, she's done better
but seriously that high notes from tiffany though. (2.28-2.30) goosebumps all over 👍👏
IKR Tiffany Biased here 😚😚
YASSSSS T0T
탱구야 해외가서도 놀자....한국에서만 유명하긴 너무 아쉬운 목소리다 ㄹㅇㅠㅠㅠ많은사람들이 이 음색을 들어야하는디....
이 말에 극공감... 03년생인데 소녀시대를 처음으로 좋아하게됬다면 태연의 아~ 왕자님 이 파트가 넘 좋아서 좋아하게 된 듯
소시 콘서트에서 무대 본 사람들은 알겠지
저게 힘 많이 빼고 배려해주면서 부른거라는 거
Kim Taeyeon nailed it!!!
소시가 잘해서 욕먹은 무대
1. 뮤직뱅크 텔미 커버
2. 케이팝스타 백아연 합동무대
ㅇㅈ!!
케이팝스타 잘 안 봤는데 저 때 태연이랑 티파니
나온다는 말에 30분 전부터 눈 부릅뜨고 있고,,,
진짜 태연 티파니 목 긁는 소리랑 고음이 너무 좋아ㅜ
역시 소녀시대 보컬라인ㅠ 무대를 꽉 채워ㅜㅜ
진심 영원히 사랑해요 노래해줘서 고마워요 언니들
지소앞소영소❤️
Ayeon should learn how to control the stage with Yoona, Yuri, Hyoyeon or Sooyoung..or even Sunny. She got the voice which is already okay. But she's too shy and don't know how to control the stage for her own. Their voice are at the same level even more than Tiffany but not pass Taengoo. But the different between them is those two, TaeNy know who to control their stage appearance. So it's common for them to steal the sportlight from her. They supposed to invited YoonYulHyoSooSun to teach her how to perform on stage with TaeNy. YoonYulHyoSoo don't have a lot of lines in their songs but everytime they on stage, they know how to make the stage become their. People will focus on them while listen to the lead singers sing. It's not TaeNy fault here actually...lol...
SNSD9_ EXO10 Yeah, agree. She just needs to peform more and the confidence will naturally rise.
***** i'd prefered YoonSun if fans keep asking for SHY...they can have SHY. Just give me YoonSun. They can be a duo group just like EunHae 💝
Her singing level is more than Tiffany? definitely not.. TaeNy are both a great singer, nothing can defeat them if they've already concured the stage 😂😅
+Arief Haiqal concured? conquered
bitch plzz. Taeyeon in another level.
wow taeyeon sounds is really really really really powerfull i love it😚
Tiffany is so beautiful and talented
Wth is wrong with you guys Baek Ayeon had more lines, but the only problem was she wasn't energetic. It isn't taeny fault that she was like that instead Taeny tried to put more energy she can Baek Ayeon. Its an amazing performance just enjoy it!
taeyeon is best
Is she now?
Xanath jo For me... Of course
Shujie Jin fine enough n.n shes a good singer
Taeyeon is beyond the best, she's got that 101% stage presence plus excellent voice quality...
To everyone who says that Tae and Fany should've toned it down with their performance so that Ayeon could shine more, let me as you this: can you ask a god to be anything less than a god? For me, Ayeon HAS talent, that is clear with her voice, but in this performance, she lacked stage presence, that's why people say TaeNy out shined her. It could be either that she was nervous performing with them (and who wouldn't? They're in freaking SNSD, the nations girl group), or that she wasn't comfortable with the song (it IS a very mature song and performance in general, and she was quite young at the time.) or the outfit. To me, she seemed stiff in this performance, but she DOES have an insane amount of talent, be it vocally or dance wise.
(I am NOT a hater, just wanted to put it out there.)
I mean I guess, not saying your opinion is wrong but if you watch g-dragons and tops performance with jimin, you could tell they actually tried to give her the spotlight, and she shined bc they actually tried to not outshine her. So I mean, in a way tae and fany could've done a better job at letting her have the spotlight.
I'm guessing its the song. Maybe it's too strong for Ayeon. I dunno. There are good point too if Tae and Fany didn't tone down and Ayeon Level up with them.. It's a case to case basis.. In this case, I think Ayeon got a bit intimidated. It was a chance for her to excel.. and I think she did at the last minute. Sometimes, it's not really good if the featured artist to tone down bec sometimes it means the contestant cannot level out him/herself to the artists. If I were the contestant I would love for my featured artist to give it all. cuz then it will be a good challenge for me to raise my bar up with them.. That's my take
Shannon Khoo Oh yeah, it's totally her job to rise to their level, not their job to tone it down for her. That's the challenge. It's the whole point.
Telling a great singer to sing poorly while not performing poorly is quite difficult. Like, they are supposed to satisfy the listeners, yet they are supposed to make one person stand out? I find it good enough that Ayeon could at least stand by their side. Besides, Ayeon simply isn't as good as Taeyeon or Tiffany, so for Ayeon to actually stand out more than she did here is wanting the impossible. They could've given her more solo time, but she already has the most, and cutting another one off would be very awkward. It simply wouldn't sound good.
J Imactuallydeadinside Ayeon got a lot of line tho~ but she choose not to give her best TaeNy sing that good to cover Ayeon and if you can see They motivated Ayeon to give her best look at Taeyeon dancing while Ayeon is on the center i think she want Ayeon to follow her moved and make Ayeon be confident but Ayeon didnt grab the opportunity to do her part well. Taeny cant do anything about Ayeon stage presence
TaeNy's vocals were so on point omg O_O those high notes...... :O
I really love tiffany's legs! So perfect! And taeny's voice!
When I first watched this, I thought, like many others, that Tae and Tiff had more lines, but when I re-watched it, I realized that they actually had fewer lines. I think the reason it felt as if they had more lines was because they stood out and captured the audiences full attention, while A Yeon didn't. Because we are more focused on Taeny, we feel as if they had more parts. It also doesn't help A Yeon's case that she was more reserved in her movements and expression. She pretty much had the same facial expression throughout the whole performance, while Tae and Tiff were enjoying themselves and having fun. I don't claim to be an expert, but to me, although A Yeon is a good singer, she doesn't really have a strong stage presence. However, this is probably just due to her inexperience compared to Taeny.
preach 👏
i think she just didnt have experience on stage and was kind of insecure, now shes much better
진짜 보아가 자랑스러워할만하다..ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 특별무대 하고 가라니깐 콘서트를 하고가는 소시ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
taeyeon high notes is really really really awesome 😍😍😍😍😍👍👍👍👍👍👍
걍 태연 티파니가 실력이랑 무대장악력이 미쳤음….ㄷ 진심 ㅈㄴ 잘한다… 저게 태연 티파니가 콘서트에서 둘이서 부른것보다 힘빼고 부른거라던데..ㄷ그리고 티파니가 리드보컬이라니..다른 팀이면 무조건 메보감인데
소녀시대는 동작 표정 모든게자연스럽고 즐기는듯하네요 몇년차 프로랑 차이가 날수밖에없어요 저런무대에선
taeyeon daebak!!!
Guys. You know who's really to blame? The camera man. He was too enchanted by Taeny's stage presence thus the lack of screen time for Ayeon. Lol.
She got the most screen time
no she had most!
TAEYEON IS SO PERFECT
At 2:30 Tiffany does something Christina has never done live. Just love it!
tiffany rap 😍😍
Keep in mind that :
1. A Yeon was a contestant at this point, a /fourteen-year-old/ at that, while Tiffany and Taeyeon are seasoned artists at the top of their game. Even if they toned it down to just being A Yeon's back dancers, they would still have more presence than her because of how established they are.
2. Different from Jimin and GD's collaboration, all three on this stage are girls. When all three performers are of the same gender and dressed similarly, the audience would naturally compare them in a way they can't compare performers of different genders.
3. Tiffany and Taeyeon had no synergy with A Yeon--or even with Kpopstar, for that matter--because they were probably there for a purpose. This was when TTS started, and this song is right up their alley. Be it the company or the managers that tell them, "Hey look, this gig will take up time but think of it as a good opportunity," they do have to promote themselves first and foremost during any public appearance.
Lee hi was a contestant that collab with all girls too but she looks very comfortable there. I'm not saying that Tiff and Tae wanted to outshine her because they did not. She just didn't really show her best on stage that day
태연 이런 목소리도 미쳤네... 커버무대로 한 번 더 해주세요ㅠㅠ 김탱구씨는 장르가 태연이라고..ㅜ
TAEYEON's strong voice! Hope your heart is as strong as your voice right now
no offence, Taeyeon slaying 👏❤
Taeyeon's visual and vocals are no joke, I'm telling you
이때 생활관에서 선임들하고 생방송으로 보고있었는데
태연 티파니 파트 나오는순간 선임들이 하나같이
역시 아마추어가 프로는 못이긴다면서 ㅋㅋ
it is not taeny fault of they stole the show. they are member of national girlgroup after all , you will get overshadowed anyway
Taeyeon and tiffany performance is so good!!!! Taeyeon !!!! Her voice is so sooo good!!!
태연은 진짜 못하는 장르가 뭐야..???!?!? Kpop, pop, 트로트, 록...... 걍 다 어울리는데 진짜 뭐지
there are no small parts, only small actors
that applies to ANY stage with ANY crowd
meanwhile, no actor becomes successful by only playing small parts - eventually they need the break and get that big part in order to succeed
@@requiemforamerica8432 she was given a break she didnt use it
no way no way...Taeyeon and Tiffany are so awesome, still focus on them.
boa looks so freaking gorgeous and all three of them got such a powerful voice. especially taeyeon. it was expected of her.
boa?
Exo Taeng yes at 2.22
she must have been so proud of her hoobaes and she look like why the fuck is a yeon here, she does not sing well at all
Exo Taeng then she was memerised by fany and taeyeon vocals
Agnes Por wow! daebak!! sm family jjang!!!
She's a ten year old girl standing and sharing stage with two of the biggests stars of korea, i'd be that way too.
Agree. She's a little timid since she's singing with two international members of an international girl group :3
Exactly, you get my point.
HAHAHA! Maybe we had the same thoughts? Lol.
she's 20 not ten lol
Seriously?! OMG. She looks like 10.
i do believe the purpose of this colaboration performance is to test the contestants stage presence. if she can handle herself or even surpass the more experienced ones like taeyeon and tiffany on stage. even if this is just a special stage. judges still judge you by this performance.
TAEYEON N TIFFANY😍😍😍 THEIR VOCALS IS 😍
Fany high note just wow
나오면 쳐발릴거라던 악플러들
잘하니까 배려못하고 기죽인다고 지랄하던거 잊혀지지가않는다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
에초에 당시 최강자 걸그룹중 보컬 두명이 어떻게 아마추어한테 밀리냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
아니 태연은 애초에 데뷔하자마자 걸그룹 보컬 본좌급 대우였는데도 무시당했었다니
Ahyeon is shy.. It's not her style. She need to work on her stage presence... She needs to know that she's good and beautiful. The other two really shows that they are used in big crowds..
If she was supposed to be the star, she should have gotten christina's part cuz that was the highlight of that song
Imagine being able to perform with SNSD, let alone in 2012? An eternal honor.
킹태연…티파니까지 역시 프로네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ괜히 소시가 아니지 진짜개잘햌ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Seriously,"voulez vous coucher avec moi ce soir?" Do they know what it means?
Taeyeon,your voice killed me,as always
I'm sure Tiffany does, since she was in the U.S. until 15 years old (and that phrase is most of the French words the average American knows). I don't know about the others, but I feel like it may be something Tiffany would tell Taeyeon.
Ahahahah,TaeNy XD
I was chocked because I'm French and when I heard "voulez-vous coucher avec moi ce soir" I was like...WTF
Love K-pop For the record, I wasn't invoking TaeNy when I said my last sentence, _but I do like that you interpreted it that way!_ XD
(I was just thinking about cultural exchange and how SoShi would likely talk about lyrics they'd be singing.)
Love K-pop Mdrr, j'ai eu la même réaction que toi.. C'est assez marrant quand on shippe le TaeNy et qu'elles se lancent des sourires en chantant ce genre de chanson. (x
I dont now what it means please can someone explain me?
They probably should have changed the arrangement a little to give Ayeon some more of the money notes that Tiffany or Taeyeon would ordinarily sing in duet. That said, Ayeon didn't exactly bring down the house with the money notes she DID sing, so it might not have mattered.
OMG Taeyeon's facial expressions are unbelievably terrific!!!!!!!!
how often does anyone even get taeyeon and tiffany as background singers? lol
Probably just this time. It feels different that they were only backgrounds of this performance lol
태연 진짜 사기캐... 진짜 미친듯이 예쁜데 노래를 또 미친듯이 잘해...... 진짜 대존예...
이걸 본 안티들이 '배려심이 없다'는 희대의 드립을 날렸다는 그 무대인가요?
In this song, tiffany seems train her high pitch more harder, before, she could not reach F note, but here, she could reach it. Fany is really hardworker person
Taeyeon's exceptionally gorgeous and beautiful here.
You can tell Ayeon was super nervous and just plain not used to performing such song. Taeyeon and Tiffany held back a lot to let Ayeon shine but yea, it just wasn't working. But I'm sure if Ayeon performed this song now, she'd rock it!
얘네 뭔데 세련됐어....? 8년전인데
taeyeeeooon
오메...실력들이...아이돌원탑답다
Taeyon and Tiffany was spectacular but I don't see why some people blame Ayeon. You're comparing a rookie with veterans and you say it's the rookie's fault? Plus, I'm not sure but I think that they don't really get to fight for having more lines. They just take what they get. Oh well.
Taeny did great I love their powerful voice but Baek Ayeon should have said that she need more lines she has a powerful voice too but she didn't use it ...I believe if she have done that then she would have win ...Great Job Taeny
The special stage didn't affect the score.
Ayeon had the most lines I guess she wasn't confident so it didn't really show
This Taeny performance or Taeny feat Baek Ayeon performance? lol the cameraman must be snsd biased
Baek ayeon got the mos screen time but she isn't memorable
+Nonah Silva do u need flashlight too crazy fan ?
+Nonah Silva lol
I love how Tiff called 'Taeyeon!' then Tae said 'Ti' lastly it was 'Ayeon'. ♥
I think she was going to call "tiffany" but too late Lol
By the way, the cameraman obviously SNSD bias...lol...
SNSD9_ EXO It's the PD
+SNSD9_ EXO How is the cameramen being biased if Baek got more solo time than Tae or Tiffany?
no Ayeon had most screen time !
I love it, tiffany hig notes 😍😍😍😍😍
what a great song¡¡ Taeyeon... the best... a awesome voice
Taeny really helped Baek Ayeon before the performance, teaching her what should she do. But you can't blame Taeyeon and Tiffany for performing well cause hello, they are trained very well to perform like that, Baek Ayeon needed to have more confidence i think and her facial expression. You can't blame her though cause she was not working at the industry that long as the others
I literally died on Tiffany’s rap part ! She’s so amazing
I'm really happy as to how taeyeon enjoy this stage, she confidently hit the high notes and perfectly play in her parts. Ayeon did a great job specially in the first part, it's just taeyeon and tiffany shows how experienced they are.
Taeyeon killing it with those runs!!
Really? I didn't real!y think her voice went well with the song.
@@horyshitu5120 youte being bitter
@@horyshitu5120 listen to the live performance from their concert I think they were better there because they were not trying to outshine Ayeon
Damn Tiffany!!!!!!
Poor Ah Yeon... while I do think she could've gotten more parts, part of the reason she didn't do well was her own fault. She lacked stage presence compared to Tiffany and Taeyeon who were overflowing with charisma. They put Ah Yeon in the center most of the time so she should've taken advantage of it more :P
she was barely doing the dance
Tiffany and Taeyeon has been an idol for a loooong time, they should've hold it bit.
No... they just didn't take her into consideration. It's as simple as that lol they chose a song that fit them not her
In my opinion it's Ayeon fault. If you watch Park Jimin's live with GD and T.O.P you can see that she feel totally confortable on stage and she really looks like a star and not just like a candidate of a competition...
I think it's a good move that ayeon didn't take lead because being a star is just not being front and center sometimes you have to Lear how to support your partners
wow tiffany voice was awsome
Taeyeon and tiffany always give their best it's not their fault that they are just naturally a star that anyone stand beside them they will be outshine no matter what
taeyeon wow
The difference:
Baek A Yeon - Singing
Tiffany & Taeyeon - Performing
AhYeon just like ... frozen ... none emotion when she were singing O;o
Well she was a rookie and Taeny have been preforming many more times then Ahyeon. That's why she is kind of stiff.
I think that even if Taeyeon and Tiffany gave the high notes to her, it will still not work out because she doesn't have stage presence.
taeyeon soooooooooo amazing
All three of them did great. Taeyeon and Tiffany did well as expected and Ahyeon did really well for a rookie. Not to mention this is quite a challenging song. Props to her for trying and doing her best. No one here is to blame.
비주얼 메보 진짜 대박임....태연
Taeny is the best couple in kpop
fany!! i miss you!!
THE CHEMISTRY BETWEEN TAENY IS NO JOKE and their voice is amazingggg they seem to outperformed the original :)) Proud of u girls
The way boa smiled when tiff did her part🥰🥰 she looks so proud
Snsd is probably one of the most successful group that had been launched. The visuals. The vocals. Talented individuals.
Tiffany, Taeyeon too beautiful so people only saw 2 girl lol