Prue & Piper • I'll be the one who took your place

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 89

  • @neishawnjohnson7602
    @neishawnjohnson7602 7 років тому +89

    this sister pairing is beautiful because of Holly and Shannon real life friendship that was incorporated in the show which made the bond stronger thats why i will always love seasons 1-3 because it still focused on the sisterhood and bond not just the magic and their powers.I like paige but the show was at it's best during these times and alot of things could of been prevented if Prue was still alive.

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +2

      Neishawn Johnson I was wondered why all 4 weren’t allowed to be together after patty died if the other 3 didn’t know about Paige and Paige didn’t know about her 3 older sisters even if Paige didn’t have powers yet it would have been more interesting to see how Prue would have reacted to seeing Paige in Person Prues death feels half pointless at this point since all 4 were adult age I always wondered what stopped the other 3 from meeting Paige in person after Patty Died. But I guess we may never know the answer to that question after Patty died

    • @neishawnjohnson7602
      @neishawnjohnson7602 4 роки тому +1

      @@Megz1794 that's so true

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +1

      Neishawn Johnson yeah because I get that they couldn’t be together when they were younger when Patty was Alive for safety reasons that makes sense but as adults after their mom died I mean come on they should have been allowed to be together as adults after their mom died even if one of the 4 didn’t have powers yet

    • @neishawnjohnson7602
      @neishawnjohnson7602 4 роки тому +1

      @@Megz1794 remember the elders didn't know about paige and it was forbidden for witches and whitelighters to be together back. Then same thing happened with piper and leo but they soon change it. Although there was another witch whitelighter born into a witch family. He was the one who was trying to compete with Henry for paige in season 8. So that's another inconsistency.

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +1

      Neishawn Johnson ik Iam just wondering what happened after Prue died that changed the rule of Paige being allowed to be with Phoebe and Piper but not Prue,Piper&Phoebe since Paige was always comparing herself to Prue power wise Prue defientely would have made sure that Paige wouldn’t have felt like she wasn’t as powerful as herself since Prue always had her sisters back fighting and power wise because paiges powers would also be dormant so no one would know she was a Witch/Whitelighter

  • @sarakennedy2633
    @sarakennedy2633 7 років тому +38

    This is a couple years old but this is AMAZING! I loved their relationship, the loved the original three and their relationships too and s1-3 will ALWAYS be the best seasons, I loved Paige dgmw but Prue was my favorite and after she died it wasn't the same, the FACT they barely mentioned her after just annoyed me, idgaf about RL drama or not they still shouldn't if like erased her existence. :( I love their relationship sfm and this song YES!!!

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +1

      Sara Kennedy I feel like it was hard for them to mention her 24/7 since they Lost her just to activate paige’s powers for some reason Paige wasn’t allowed to be reunited with all 3 sisters at the same time after Patty died espeically considering the fact that all 4 are adults for some reason all 4 couldn’t be together as adults after their mom died. Prues death feels half pointless in my opinion it’s like the only reason they killed Prue off was just in order to activate paige’s powers after Prues death.

  • @piperhalliwell11
    @piperhalliwell11 9 років тому +46

    Oh gosh wow this was so beyond beautiful! I loved prue so much. She was my favorite character I hated when she died it broke my heart :( and to see what piper went through over the loss of her
    I loved this so much! I can't stop watching. Amazing job and amazing editing :)

    • @revertinotse8582
      @revertinotse8582 6 років тому +2

      Watching Charmed from 1999 - 2006. From episode 1. Never gets tireding.

  • @swolfe9668
    @swolfe9668 2 роки тому +7

    Holly and Shannen had amazing chemistry, I loved every scene they did, they portrayed Piper's grief very realistically, Holly should have won an Emmy

  • @nataliablanco1711
    @nataliablanco1711 6 років тому +18

    Prue and piper vs phoebe and paige
    My favourite is prue and piper

    • @piperfaifai5511
      @piperfaifai5511 4 роки тому +2

      Natalia Blanco17 mine is prue and piper

    • @loganmcclure60
      @loganmcclure60 3 роки тому +1

      Yep my too me and my husband and family and brother and friend to are the favorite ever thinks for saying that about us not really us if wants to

    • @Poppin-film
      @Poppin-film 3 роки тому +1

      Prue and Phoebe is my favorite

  • @agentlaura961
    @agentlaura961 9 років тому +26

    This is so beautiful to the point that im crying 😍😭😭😭

  • @KitTaylorMusic
    @KitTaylorMusic 7 років тому +20

    Nothing I love more than their sister love. It's like me and my sister ❤️

  • @Felisia97
    @Felisia97 10 років тому +28

    ALL THE CREDS TO YOU!! It's so damn beautiful. Prue was my favorite character and i literally cried my eyes out when she died and you're right, nothing was the same without her and you really made amends for her death

    • @EatenDoll
      @EatenDoll  10 років тому +7

      Awww, thank you so much. I cried to, and I cried making this video though I think I already said that, and I cry everytime I watch All Hell Breaks Lose or the first episodes of the next season with her funeral and just her not being there anymore.
      I still wish she never died. :/

    • @shelbecovington4161
      @shelbecovington4161 9 років тому +2

      +Eaten Doll yes nothing was the same with out her but in away I feel like prue was their for her I mean how could Leo and piper still be together so long with out she made told Leo to not give up on her no madder what so maby she was their for her with out knowing it

    • @neishawnjohnson7602
      @neishawnjohnson7602 7 років тому +3

      Eaten Doll yea you really did because i love their sister pairing.

  • @saloabad
    @saloabad 6 років тому +24

    Seriously Phoebe should have being the one to leave the show, not Prue.

    • @rtozier2011
      @rtozier2011 4 роки тому

      Because it's just lovely to imagine Piper's reaction to the death of her little sister.

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +2

      anafbmad Shannen was the one who decided to leave The series not Alyssa. Also either way regardless we would have gotten Paige because the show is about 3 sisters fighting evil paige’s powers would have been activated regardless of whether or not Prue or Phoebe left the show.

  • @sandramcdonagh409
    @sandramcdonagh409 7 років тому +10

    love prue and piper, their sisterly bond reminds me of me and my best friend of how close we are

  • @guytremblay1647
    @guytremblay1647 2 роки тому +3

    this show could have lasted as much as Supernatural if she remained in the cast .

    • @KiramSider
      @KiramSider 3 місяці тому

      Yep I agree with you on that! Shannen(prue) should have been the one to stay on the show Instead of Alyssa(Phoebe) the two actresses did not get along behind set so the show ended up having to choose between the two of them and they chose Alyssa(Phoebe). I really wish they hadn't no hate against the actress or anything. I just preferred Shannen's acting on the show.
      She was a better character & would have been cool to see prue meet Paige as well!
      Piper,prue, Paige just a better trio in my opinion. But the show cancelled so long ago so many years ago I just still re watch the seasons from time to time....

  • @ashlyndubois1030
    @ashlyndubois1030 7 років тому +14

    I swear, *sniffle* I'm not crying. *sniffle* I'm just... cutting up... *sniffle* Charmed onions, or something... *bawls* OMG SO BEAUTIFUL

  • @taylahmckinley6182
    @taylahmckinley6182 4 роки тому +5

    Everytime I see Piper cry over Prue's death makes me die and I already was crying over her death so...I cried a lot😭😣😟

    • @KiramSider
      @KiramSider 3 місяці тому

      I know this comment is very old I just wanted to send a reply because I still watch charmed from time to time it was always my favorite show back when I was a teen & I don't know it just kinda stuck with me through my adult years! Prue was definitely my favorite sister&witch on the show! Broke my heart when prue was killed off and seeing what piper went through over her death it was heartbreaking! But Phoebe barely even cried over prue's death it was like she didn't care at all. She literally only cried one time! And that was when she was in prue's bedroom holding her jacket and crying into it and Piper walks in on her lol.
      Piper def took it the hardest!!
      Anyway sorry my reply is so long I just really loved prue as well! She was a bad ass witch & sister. She did not deserve to die the way she did.... 💔
      #willforeverlovecharmed

    • @KiramSider
      @KiramSider 3 місяці тому

      And I am a female just using my significant others account for now because I can't remember my account info to login

  • @KiramSider
    @KiramSider 3 місяці тому +1

    Prue& piper's bond was so strong and beautiful!!! It broke my heart when prue was killed off the show. It just wasn't the same without her character. And seeing what piper went through over losing prue it really did make you feel her pain through the screen... Piper def took her death the hardest. Phoebe on the other hand barely even cried over prue's death except one time when she was in prue's bedroom holding her jacket and crying into it and Piper walked in the room lol. But Phoebe didn't really seem to care all that much about prue being dead. maybe that's because the actresses did not like each other behind set i don't really know but she could have played her part a lot better than she did....
    Piper was great though! ❤❤

  • @zhna9
    @zhna9 8 років тому +8

    my fave all the time! super job! love it and can't stop watching it. Prue was my fave, i loved the bonding she had with Piper. So sad she died..

  • @ameliebzh56
    @ameliebzh56 8 років тому +5

    Thank you so much, it's so beautiful. i need more of these, favorite siblings ever ♥

  • @ahh6864
    @ahh6864 7 років тому +7

    I wish I had powers I love this vid

  • @cairatrait1333
    @cairatrait1333 5 років тому +2

    You are not nobody you are not alone i naver had someone is the best is you she is still in my heart she is my favourite person she is to me with you in my life with you all of

  • @andie5533
    @andie5533 8 років тому +5

    Omg I LOVE THIS VIDEO.

  • @lindsaymibach2996
    @lindsaymibach2996 5 років тому +2

    Wow here is a beautiful Song for a Music Video

  • @andreamacleod9734
    @andreamacleod9734 6 років тому +4

    Beautiful...

  • @ogeleazar
    @ogeleazar 6 років тому +4

    What's the episode of 1:10 when Prue tells piper to wake up?

    • @EatenDoll
      @EatenDoll  6 років тому +4

      This is the beginning of 3x03 Once Upon A Time, when Piper and Leo tried to marry in secret at the end of 3x02 and Leo was taken by the elders in the middle of the ceremony because Cole told them, now Piper doesnt know where he is and is worried and dreaming of him. :(

    • @ogeleazar
      @ogeleazar 6 років тому +1

      Eaten Doll oh OK thanks. For a second I thought it was the episode where a man can go into people's dreams, I was confused like I don't remember him going into Piper's dream. But thanks for that. Her death will always be heartbreaking.

  • @ogeleazar
    @ogeleazar 6 років тому +4

    Am I the only one who sees the four charmed ones in pairs? Like I feel Prue and piper are one pair and phoebe and Paige got along better. Like I feel the family tree is split right down the middle with no way to repair it.

    • @aminatkhanzaeva113
      @aminatkhanzaeva113 6 років тому +1

      0:42 which is the series?

    • @chinajohnson9805
      @chinajohnson9805 5 років тому +2

      TBH I have to disagree I think piper and Paige got along better than phoebe and Paige or maybe their relationship was more sisterly to me than what meets the eye piper and Paige bumped head because piper was the oldest and when pure was the oldest what she said is goes so piper expected it to be like that with her being the big sister Paige was An only child so she wasn’t used to somebody else having the final say piper had to learn that even tho she was the oldest she still needed to consider Paige and Paige had to learn that even tho she’s used to doing things her way taking somebody else advice over her own wasn’t always a bad thing once they got past that they were good phoebe and Paige relationship was more like prue and phoebe always bumping heads over phoebes stupid/selfish decisions only this time phoebe was the oldest so she generally got away with it more with Paige than she did with prue & piper usually stayed out of it or took phoebes side

    • @Megz1794
      @Megz1794 4 роки тому +3

      China Johnson I think it’s mainly because Paige was newer and if all 4 would have been allowed to be together as sisters then Paige would be use to being told what to do since Paige Was hesistant to be move in with Piper&Phoebe since they had to make her feel like they didn’t just need her for fighting evil and that they would also need her as a sister the same way Prue,Piper&Phoebe all made each other feel like sisters and like family since they grew up together without Paige.Piper&Phoebe just had to work harder at making Paige feel like a sister after Prue died since Paige never grew up with the other 3 espeically since after Prue died that really left Piper in charge since Piper is the second oldest after Prue so for Paige it was more like what Piper and Phoebe said goes even if Piper for the final say just like for Phoebe How it was what Prue and Piper said goes even though Prue got the final say. It would be like all 3 had to keep each other in control espeically after Prue died and when Paige comes along. Also there’s a chance that when Paige was introduced that one sister needed more time to accept Paige into their lives after losing Prue while one was a tiny bit more accepting while still dealing with the death of an older sister. Prues death probably just made it harder for one sister to be nicer to Paige the group after Prue they had to get use to Piper being in charge which also probably wasn’t entirely 100% easy after the other two had just originally lost Prue.

  • @mariross0310
    @mariross0310 6 років тому +3

    OMG I am speechless.

  • @LEGENDPantherJennings
    @LEGENDPantherJennings 2 роки тому +1

    Beatuifully

  • @meryforever91
    @meryforever91 7 років тому +2

    this video is sooo incredibly stunning... wait.. incredible and stunning!! xo

  • @justinoiler9749
    @justinoiler9749 5 років тому +2

    Justin and Danielle pullin

  • @barbzk2061
    @barbzk2061 3 роки тому +2

    so perfect

  • @nicholasking007
    @nicholasking007 10 років тому +3

    love

  • @viannbare3793
    @viannbare3793 3 роки тому +1

    Prue and Piper.
    Syster's love 😘😘
    Phoebe NO!!!!!👎

  • @fauxyeahjandy
    @fauxyeahjandy 3 роки тому +1

    I'm not gonna cry, I'm not gonna cry! 😭

  • @aminatkhanzaeva113
    @aminatkhanzaeva113 6 років тому +3

    1:35 which is the episode?

    • @EatenDoll
      @EatenDoll  6 років тому +2

      Which image? Prue pushing Piper is 3x09 "Coyote Piper", and hugging on the sofa is 2x10 "Heartbreak city", unless you're talking about Phoebe's voice over?

    • @aminatkhanzaeva113
      @aminatkhanzaeva113 6 років тому +3

      @@EatenDoll where are they on the couch and laughing?

    • @EatenDoll
      @EatenDoll  6 років тому +1

      Yeah it's 2x10 Heartbreak city, they're on the coach at the manor together after leaving Dan & Jack on their own at P3, it's past half of the episode

  • @SokhomDub4
    @SokhomDub4 5 років тому +1

    i love this show so much i dont want it to cancel at all

  • @myaelise6633
    @myaelise6633 5 років тому +1

    Hey what ep was 0:53 ?

  • @claudiawilliams6898
    @claudiawilliams6898 8 років тому

    And me never yet see prue treat Phoebe so and it keep coming to me why she always treat piper nice and not phoebe why??????

    • @Dani-ul1fq
      @Dani-ul1fq 8 років тому +10

      Prue and Phoebe had a rocky relationship, but they did have times that they would bond. Prue and Piper were just closer, they had more time together and when Phoebe left to New York Prue and Piper just got closer. Phoebe always pushed Prue's bottons, but she loved Phoebe a lot they just weren't as close as Piper and Prue.

    • @EatenDoll
      @EatenDoll  8 років тому +7

      Prue and Phoebe were also very close, sometimes I think about doing a video of these two, Prue wasnt unnice to Phoebe, the pilot episode happened at the moment where Prue & Phoebe had some problems so you may keep that in mind but it's not how their relationship was. I've always seen Phoebe and Prue as sisters that challenge each other, weren't afraid to tell each other the truth, and were both so fierce, which made their bond very interesting and close. Prue was also very protective of Phoebe just like she was with Piper, even little Phoebe in season 4 threatens to call Prue who will kick your ass if you don't leave her alone haha, so they were always close they just had some hard times because they had the strong personnalities when Piper was nice one in the middle, her sister's keeper. And just like Prue was always the one saving Piper, it's often Phoebe who's there for Prue.