As usual, absolutely well done to the channel Beyond Crime for this upload. Keep the good work. And regarding if Knox is innocent or guilty, I completely agree with the 2 comments before mine, that she is guilty.
🔴 Hello dear. Psychology and criminology are basically my life, and I have to compliment myself with you because you are 100% right! And because Knox is really 100% guilty! Although I can easily predict that unfortunately a lot will say that she is innocent. But in reality she is 100% guilty!!! Keep it up!
Guilty of what? Not behaving properly after the death of her room-mate? She was in shock! Rudy Guede murdered Meredith, he was with her the night she was murdered, he fled to Germany the morning after, his DNA was on/in Meredith, he did prison time after admitting to the murder...
@@nolies9769 Where do you see it? I see Ruby Guede is guilty, and has probably been breaking in Meredith's house . How come Amanda's dna was nowhere in Meredith's room, but his dna was everywhere?
Agreed. The whole thing was a botched job from start to finish. The local cops didn't do their jobs properly. They didn't secure the scene or collect the evidence in a way that was professional. & the prosecutor was a egotistical, fame hungry, person of questionable intelligence. Who cared more about his pet conspiracy theories then anout the Truth. If this case has taught me anything it's when arrested overseas. Don't say a word to the police & insist on talking to. A representative from the US Embassy before making any statements.
I think she got away w/murder and anyone who profits from the notoriety from a murder like AK did when she used her name to raise money on GoFundMe for her "alien-themed" wedding is a very disturbed individual.
If this case had taken place in the US or the UK then it never would have made it to trail. Simply because the multiple mistakes that the police made. When they were collecting the evidence. The Fact that the police messed around when they were collecting the evidence. This allowed for the contamination of evidence. & for a reasonable suspicion of doubt about the. Validity of the evidence that was collected being uncontaminated. The Fact is we will *NEVER* know if she's guilty or not. Simply because the police Fucked up when they collected their evidence. So if you want to have a go at someone over this case. Then it should be the local Italian police who handled the case. They're the ones who screwed everything up.
I'm Italian and I agree. I studied in Perugia. It is a small city, no experience and actually no professional skills wete shown in Meredith's case. If Amanda was guilty, were the local police and csi whom helped to exonerate her. End of the case.
🔴 Although I can easily predict/deduce that a lot will say that she is innocent, but in reality she was/is 100% guilty! And I hope that the majority of intelligent people that will see this docu won't be fooled by her and therefore they will be enlightened that she is undoubtedly 100% guilty!!!
Great realistic comment dear friend! She is really and completely 100% guilty! But as you said, sadly it's true that some people still can't see the truth! Hopefully they will 👍
I just saw this case and It's strange to me, that the media never seem to ask Amanda about her relationship to Meredith and never show more attention to Ruby who have overwhelming physical evidence of being the culprit although he has never been in the cottage at Meredith before other than the time of the murder. They never seem to be interested to know how Ruby, who seem to be a total stranger, got in the picture; like where did he come from ? did he know Meredith, Amanda, the other two girls, or An.'s boyfriend from before? They also never pay attention to the other 2 girls who also lived there... they never question even them.. If Amanda could be suspicious for living there and acting strange, they could be suspicious too... Did any of them know Ruby, did Ruby know any of them...?! But the media and the police seem to have made this an 'Amanda case' only, instead of "Meredith case", or even "Ruby case" , or "Two other girls case", etc. The facts where they based their suspicion on Amanda, seem so irrelevant and ridiculous as almost showing the police delibertaly trying to escape looking at the proof...! As almoust trying to avoid confronting possible evidence they don't wanna have ...
@@brainstormingsharing1309 'Realistic comment' - which gives no reasons, no arguments of whatsoever, shares no facts, and shows no rational explanation and no explanation of whatsoever ...?! The only thing given there is stamps, labels and judgmental bias! It's a 'demandful convincing-comment', but not a 'conveying-of-information' comment. The commentor doesn't give any info of why he/she thinks so... You call that 'realistic'?!
Utterly GUILTY. But yes, unfortunately she fooled some people. But when one really scrutinize the evidences it becomes clear that she killed Meredith with her boyfriend.
Sorry I dont understand, I've watch this before watching on Netflix just curious and really want idea. But when i read all comments she is guilty as hell and I've seen this video it seems she's not .. Is there any documentaries link for Amanda's guilty? Just reply if anybody has it. Thank you so much!
I have seen many documentaries of this case and, from the beginning, the tunnel vision was evident, added to how disastrous the investigation was and the media circus. I don't care who Amanda Knox is or where she's from, but I truly believe she was sentenced from the moment the authorities set foot on the crime scene, just like Raffaele. They suffered from a "sloppy" part of justice [I don't think all Italian justice is like that], but Meredith and her family suffered twice: the loss and the subsequent circus..
Interesting how most of the "guilty" comments on here has the same type of wording and then NO links. Especially the word "fooled" is seen quite often. Is it one person with multiple accounts? People with a weird agenda? Its just weird af 🤣🤣
As an italian I am so happy to see that many american people are convinced that Amanda Knox is guilty! Of course not only her. They were three! But only one got sentenced as guilty!
Everyone with their eyes open realized almost from the start that she was guilty without any shadow of a doubt! But unfortunately some have not yet opened their eyes after all this time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🫶
The actress playing meredith does a dreadfull attempt ofthe British accent... could they not have cast a better actress ? Or an actual british girl... her accent is unbearable at times to listen to
What I never will understand is when anybody visits another country they should be dealt with the outmost respect after all they are guests in your home if I may. When somebody visits your country they are phrasing your culture and appreciating your culture what I will never understand is why certain counties are so arrogant is to not appreciate that ... This goes to many counties in the world. There are worst criminals within there country than any foreigners. This narrow minded mind set does not allow a country to prosper at a larger scale
Respect has to go both ways. Do you visit someone’s home and act like an animal? Because if you did, it wouldn’t matter what you brought to share for dessert, you’re getting put out on your behind, foot-assisted. Same rules when you visit another’s country. We are not supposed to be so “grateful” for your presence we allow you to make your own rules, and mess up our living room 🤷🏽♀️
Guilty as hell. I have to admit that at first I thought for a while that maybe she was innocent, but then after I read books, watched a whole variety of documentaries and so on, it was completely evident that yes she was definitely guilty!!!!!!!!!!!!
I say that she can thank her stars that she is from USA which is a powerful country, more than Italy i say, and thats why she git off scotfree. Because if it wasnt for the USA, she would have still been rotting in jail here. She is giulty as hell. Im from Italy by the way.
If this case had taken place in the US or the UK then it never would have made it to trail. Simply because the multiple mistakes that the police made. When they were collecting the evidence. The Fact that the police messed around when they were collecting the evidence. This allowed for the contamination of evidence. & for a reasonable suspicion of doubt about the. Validity of the evidence that was collected being uncontaminated. The Fact is we will *NEVER* know if she's guilty or not. Simply because the police Fucked up when they collected their evidence. So if you want to have a go at someone over this case it should be the local Italian police who handled the case.
WOW....my comment remained visible just few minutes...it endet up in a parallel universe (the "most recent" comments only) really very, very quickly....but you know, you will never be able to fool people eternally, sooner or later the truth will come out and as clear as it has always been. .....and now make this comment disappear too....3, 2 , 1....Bye bye 😉
Oh Lord I've seen this, it's so sad and once again, Amanda Knox is guilty of murder along with her bf. There's a movie I watched where a student who took up the name knox who pursued a career in porn to pay for her tuition fees. Even the porn star had reservations about Amanda knox innocence. My heartfelt condolences to the British girl's family. It is sad how sexually abnormal behaviour is robbing the world of people. It is heartbreaking to realise people think sex is as important as oxygen; the gift Amanda knox's friend gives her eventually carried the curse of sin, which probably haunts this Amanda Knox to this day, although she would still claim innocence.
Hello dear, I respect you and your intellect, therefore, that's why I'm sending you this. Okay, I believe that that's your personal and honest opinion based on what you know about the case, but if you study (follow) the case very, very well, you will eventually realise that yes she (& her boyfriend) killed her! Dear, she is really 100% guilty! Kind regards.
My heart and respect goes to Amanda and Raffaeli for what they went through. I hope they managed to forget the suffering and managed to return to their lives 😥😥😥
Yes, it is true that ("unfortunately") she is guilty as hell. And everyone can understand it. "All" one have to do is to know the case very well from different sources, from those in favour and those against, and when finally the evidences are collected, the answer will be that she is guilty without a doubt 😞😠🥹
As usual, absolutely well done to the channel Beyond Crime for this upload. Keep the good work. And regarding if Knox is innocent or guilty, I completely agree with the 2 comments before mine, that she is guilty.
I never believed her or her story. She is 100% guilty in my opinion.
🔴 Hello dear. Psychology and criminology are basically my life, and I have to compliment myself with you because you are 100% right! And because Knox is really 100% guilty! Although I can easily predict that unfortunately a lot will say that she is innocent. But in reality she is 100% guilty!!! Keep it up!
Definitely well said 👏👏👏👏👏
Guilty of what? Not behaving properly after the death of her room-mate? She was in shock! Rudy Guede murdered Meredith, he was with her the night she was murdered, he fled to Germany the morning after, his DNA was on/in Meredith, he did prison time after admitting to the murder...
@@nolies9769 Where do you see it? I see Ruby Guede is guilty, and has probably been breaking in Meredith's house . How come Amanda's dna was nowhere in Meredith's room, but his dna was everywhere?
Ruby Guede is 100% guilty, and the only one guilty in my opinion...!
I feel bad for listening to the media but I have learnt my lesson now. Never trust the media! I am glad Amanda and Rafael are free.
Agreed. The whole thing was a botched job from start to finish. The local cops didn't do their jobs properly. They didn't secure the scene or collect the evidence in a way that was professional.
& the prosecutor was a egotistical, fame hungry, person of questionable intelligence. Who cared more about his pet conspiracy theories then anout the Truth.
If this case has taught me anything it's when arrested overseas. Don't say a word to the police & insist on talking to. A representative from the US Embassy before making any statements.
There is nothing to say except that SHE IS GUILTY. ...
Well said to all those that said that she is guilty 👏 Because she is guilty without a doubt.
100 % .
Yes she is.
@@evoluna3056 as far i know it was maybe the black drug dealer guy. But i understand your point of view.
I think she got away w/murder and anyone who profits from the notoriety from a murder like AK did when she used her name to raise money on GoFundMe for her "alien-themed" wedding is a very disturbed individual.
If this case had taken place in the US or the UK then it never would have made it to trail. Simply because the multiple mistakes that the police made. When they were collecting the evidence.
The Fact that the police messed around when they were collecting the evidence. This allowed for the contamination of evidence. & for a reasonable suspicion of doubt about the. Validity of the evidence that was collected being uncontaminated.
The Fact is we will *NEVER* know if she's guilty or not. Simply because the police Fucked up when they collected their evidence. So if you want to have a go at someone over this case. Then it should be the local Italian police who handled the case. They're the ones who screwed everything up.
I'm Italian and I agree. I studied in Perugia. It is a small city, no experience and actually no professional skills wete shown in Meredith's case. If Amanda was guilty, were the local police and csi whom helped to exonerate her. End of the case.
YES guys, I really don't know how it is possible that some people don't realise that yes she is 100% guilty 🙈🙉🙊
I think she is guilty and u didn't show the whole story here
Why? Cause you say so?
Because we use our brains!
How do you "realize" that she's guilty?! How about that?!
🔴 Although I can easily predict/deduce that a lot will say that she is innocent, but in reality she was/is 100% guilty! And I hope that the majority of intelligent people that will see this docu won't be fooled by her and therefore they will be enlightened that she is undoubtedly 100% guilty!!!
Great realistic comment dear friend! She is really and completely 100% guilty! But as you said, sadly it's true that some people still can't see the truth! Hopefully they will 👍
No she isn't! 👎
I just saw this case and It's strange to me, that the media never seem to ask Amanda about her relationship to Meredith and never show more attention to Ruby who have overwhelming physical evidence of being the culprit although he has never been in the cottage at Meredith before other than the time of the murder.
They never seem to be interested to know how Ruby, who seem to be a total stranger, got in the picture; like where did he come from ? did he know Meredith, Amanda, the other two girls, or An.'s boyfriend from before?
They also never pay attention to the other 2 girls who also lived there... they never question even them.. If Amanda could be suspicious for living there and acting strange, they could be suspicious too... Did any of them know Ruby, did Ruby know any of them...?!
But the media and the police seem to have made this an 'Amanda case' only, instead of "Meredith case", or even "Ruby case" , or "Two other girls case", etc.
The facts where they based their suspicion on Amanda, seem so irrelevant and ridiculous as almost showing the police delibertaly trying to escape looking at the proof...! As almoust trying to avoid confronting possible evidence they don't wanna have ...
@@brainstormingsharing1309
'Realistic comment' - which gives no reasons, no arguments of whatsoever, shares no facts, and shows no rational explanation and no explanation of whatsoever ...?!
The only thing given there is stamps, labels and judgmental bias!
It's a 'demandful convincing-comment', but not a 'conveying-of-information' comment. The commentor doesn't give any info of why he/she thinks so...
You call that 'realistic'?!
would you bet your life on that?
To everyone saying she’s gulity, what is the basis of this? Can you send links as to where I can read or watch the whole story?
To put it like a joke, if she is not guilty, than I am the president ❗
Utterly GUILTY. But yes, unfortunately she fooled some people. But when one really scrutinize the evidences it becomes clear that she killed Meredith with her boyfriend.
Sorry I dont understand, I've watch this before watching on Netflix just curious and really want idea. But when i read all comments she is guilty as hell and I've seen this video it seems she's not .. Is there any documentaries link for Amanda's guilty? Just reply if anybody has it. Thank you so much!
Simply guilty.
Has the Italians heard of DNA testing? Compare the black hair sample with the bar owner . unbelievable wow
I have seen many documentaries of this case and, from the beginning, the tunnel vision was evident, added to how disastrous the investigation was and the media circus. I don't care who Amanda Knox is or where she's from, but I truly believe she was sentenced from the moment the authorities set foot on the crime scene, just like Raffaele. They suffered from a "sloppy" part of justice [I don't think all Italian justice is like that], but Meredith and her family suffered twice: the loss and the subsequent circus..
I suggest anyone that is watching this to do research, she is guilty.
How?
I think this man did it. All the evidence points towards him and him alone.
1️⃣0️⃣0️⃣% GUILTY ❗& I'm really sorry for those that she fooled, by making them think that she's not guilty. She is 100% guilty.
Everything is holly and understandable when it for Americans.
Interesting how most of the "guilty" comments on here has the same type of wording and then NO links. Especially the word "fooled" is seen quite often.
Is it one person with multiple accounts? People with a weird agenda? Its just weird af 🤣🤣
As an italian I am so happy to see that many american people are convinced that Amanda Knox is guilty! Of course not only her. They were three! But only one got sentenced as guilty!
She is so, so guilty that it is needless to say that she is guilty. Although unbelievably some people where completely fooled by her. Sadly.
Why?
Case was poorly prosecuted it was more about Knox’s moral derelections than facts .
The way Amanda was railroaded by the media reminds me so much of what happened to Michael Jackson
My God. This is so bad. She is not guilty. Ruby is the murder!
Because he is black 😂
Guilty and soulless
Well said dear 👍👏
Yes, keep it up
Rudy is the guilty party here, without a doubt.
Everyone with their eyes open realized almost from the start that she was guilty without any shadow of a doubt! But unfortunately some have not yet opened their eyes after all this time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 🫶
The actress playing meredith does a dreadfull attempt ofthe British accent... could they not have cast a better actress ? Or an actual british girl... her accent is unbearable at times to listen to
Chill, its not a Hollywood movie. Take it easy bro!
What I never will understand is when anybody visits another country they should be dealt with the outmost respect after all they are guests in your home if I may. When somebody visits your country they are phrasing your culture and appreciating your culture what I will never understand is why certain counties are so arrogant is to not appreciate that ... This goes to many counties in the world. There are worst criminals within there country than any foreigners. This narrow minded mind set does not allow a country to prosper at a larger scale
Respect has to go both ways. Do you visit someone’s home and act like an animal? Because if you did, it wouldn’t matter what you brought to share for dessert, you’re getting put out on your behind, foot-assisted.
Same rules when you visit another’s country. We are not supposed to be so “grateful” for your presence we allow you to make your own rules, and mess up our living room 🤷🏽♀️
Guilty as hell. I have to admit that at first I thought for a while that maybe she was innocent, but then after I read books, watched a whole variety of documentaries and so on, it was completely evident that yes she was definitely guilty!!!!!!!!!!!!
What about the man who was there in Meredith's room the night of the murder and had dna and fingerprints everywhere?!
After hearing more i say innocent. This little black guy is the guilty one can't spell his name. He his as guilty as hell g'day his name.
I say that she can thank her stars that she is from USA which is a powerful country, more than Italy i say, and thats why she git off scotfree. Because if it wasnt for the USA, she would have still been rotting in jail here. She is giulty as hell. Im from Italy by the way.
no one cares where you're from. what's the motivation behind wanting to kill her housemate? there isn't one.
If this case had taken place in the US or the UK then it never would have made it to trail. Simply because the multiple mistakes that the police made. When they were collecting the evidence.
The Fact that the police messed around when they were collecting the evidence. This allowed for the contamination of evidence. & for a reasonable suspicion of doubt about the. Validity of the evidence that was collected being uncontaminated.
The Fact is we will *NEVER* know if she's guilty or not. Simply because the police Fucked up when they collected their evidence. So if you want to have a go at someone over this case it should be the local Italian police who handled the case.
Just watch the analysis of her demeanor by "The Behavior Panel".. She is endlessly contradictory
There’s a lot of mixed arguments on here honestly not too sure on who’s guilty and who isn’t
I don’t understand why everyone thinks AK is guilty? This doco is clearly showing it was Guday.
This is getting me upset
Amanda Knox is 100% guilty and her Italian boyfriend the one which is black is on jail
Very "intelligent" arguments on comments: "she is guilty because she is guilty"
But the the victim phone are found in the backyard.
Knox is guilty
You're 100% right! Keep it up! 👍👏
She did it 💯 %
Assassina! 😠 😡 👿
WOW....my comment remained visible just few minutes...it endet up in a parallel universe (the "most recent" comments only) really very, very quickly....but you know, you will never be able to fool people eternally, sooner or later the truth will come out and as clear as it has always been.
.....and now make this comment disappear too....3, 2 , 1....Bye bye 😉
Asking for a friend, is she single? Just asking. ?
Guilty
Saw her documentary,and she had a smirk on her face the whole time,talking like the murder was funny,She is Guilty AF
I thought very stupid doing cartwheels stretches etc. Very immure. Not sure if innocent need to know more
Weird police investigation, absolutely weird!
I can‘t believe that Amanda is a free woman today. she‘s GUILTY!!
Amanda was innocent
Italian Fantasist:)
Craappppp
Oh Lord I've seen this, it's so sad and once again, Amanda Knox is guilty of murder along with her bf. There's a movie I watched where a student who took up the name knox who pursued a career in porn to pay for her tuition fees. Even the porn star had reservations about Amanda knox innocence. My heartfelt condolences to the British girl's family. It is sad how sexually abnormal behaviour is robbing the world of people. It is heartbreaking to realise people think sex is as important as oxygen; the gift Amanda knox's friend gives her eventually carried the curse of sin, which probably haunts this Amanda Knox to this day, although she would still claim innocence.
I feel sad for the died young girl but To my understanding this whole Case she is not guilty ( Amanda)
Hello dear, I respect you and your intellect, therefore, that's why I'm sending you this. Okay, I believe that that's your personal and honest opinion based on what you know about the case, but if you study (follow) the case very, very well, you will eventually realise that yes she (& her boyfriend) killed her! Dear, she is really 100% guilty! Kind regards.
@@fastknowledge9474 what's the motive? what reason did amanda have to kill her house mate?
My heart and respect goes to Amanda and Raffaeli for what they went through. I hope they managed to forget the suffering and managed to return to their lives 😥😥😥
Yes, it is true that ("unfortunately") she is guilty as hell. And everyone can understand it. "All" one have to do is to know the case very well from different sources, from those in favour and those against, and when finally the evidences are collected, the answer will be that she is guilty without a doubt 😞😠🥹