Many people actually do think that this is an nct song because its "hiphop" but Hard is very 90s west coast hiphop. SHINee has hiphop songs in the past in their bsides specially in their earlier years (2008-2010) because they were in fact originally a hiphop group before they debuted as a contemporary r&b group. Juice on the other hand is actually a SHINee coded song. They make a very cohesive album everytime that I can place Juice in their misconceptions album. The HARD album is very SHINee coded and solo coded at the same time that its actually a very perfect 15th year anniv album. All the tracks in the album can be put in their (SHINee) albums and solo albums.🙂 HARD is so expectedly unexpected coz SHINee will never use the same genre twice for their title track hence Hard (a very hiphop rap focused song) Juice can be placed in the Misconceptions album 10X is VERY Jonghyun coded and can be placed in She is album Satellite is very Kibum and can be in Bad love album Identity suits SHINee's 1 of 1 album but also very Kibum Killer album coded The Feeling = Boys Meet You album Like It is so Dont Call Me coded ❤ Sweet Misery is so Taemin and can be in NGDA album but I can imagine Kibum getting this for himself Insomnia IS VERY MINHO CODED PERIOD AS IF ITS STRAIGHT OUTTA CHASE ALBUM Gravity can be place in Onew's Circle album
Hello stranger 🤍 Thank you for taking the time to break down the anniversary album and explain the little underline details! I 100% see your point in JUICE, since I haven’t listen yet to the album I can not comment on all the other information that you mentioned but I will keep it in mind.
Shawol 2008-23 this is shinee sound. shinee ride rythm❤this song trully made for shinee. Mayb if u listen more to their past performance live, u'll be agree and know where did it sound shinee.
HARD is different, and I understand the NCT allegations but, as always, it's SHINee who chose their songs and wanted to try it out. Juice just feels like a continuation of their own song Don't Call Me (2021) tbh. Also, the rest of the album is also very much comfortable, brighter-sounding SHINee music!
Hello stranger 🤍 My opinion in the video is just.. my opinion and not allegations to any of those artists that I mentioned. “Don’t call me” had such a revolutionary SHINee style that it became, in my opinion, the SHINee IT song that somebody newer to the KPOP frenzy could get involved with them since they have a long history. Other than that, this time around it just doesn’t sound like SHINee 100%. It’s amazing how they always want to evolve and grow through their music, style and aesthetics. HARD and JUICE just didn’t convince me 🤷🏼♀️
SHINee debuted in 2008, they are known as their live vocals, also the first experimental group of SM😊 pls react to more SHINee, I recommend Atlantis, don’t call me, why so serious, married to the music, view, tell me what to do, everybody SHINee is known as prince of kpop, they are the blueprint of the 3rd & 4th generation kpop group, they are not NCT haha, they are the seniors of NCT and EXO, they respect SHINee so much
How can someone who says they know SHINee's music say it doesn't sound like SHINee, but NCT, total bullshit and zero knowledge of their discography. a great comeback and a show of combining their solo and what they consider the essence of their group. SHINee chose the songs for their album themselves and it's definitely the best album of the year
Hello stranger 🤍 Knowing them since ‘09 doesn’t always equal to an actual knowledge of a shawol and/or superfan, I never claimed or mentioned to be any of these two 🙋🏼♀️
@@goldienim no offense but statements like "it doesn't sound like them but more like another group" makes you judge from the level of familiarity almost like an expert and that was probably not your goal? Rather, try to express your feelings about whether you like the style or not, and then you will be more credible
Hello stranger 🤍 Shawols are one of the nicest fandoms out there since they mostly reflect the group’s overall energy ✨ I agree with you, SHINee will never be “just another comeback” to the slightest and that’s what makes the group so versatile and unique in so many ways!
You may be an NCT fan, but you're definitely not a SHINee fan, so please don't look at them with colored glasses. SHINee is SM's first experimental group, and the style is different every time they come back, they don't have a fixed style, it can be exaggerated to say 'there is no SHINee there would be no NCT' The style of this song is more like the hippop when they first debuted (2008-2010) and the style of H.O.T in 2000.
Hello stranger 🤍 Knowing a group’s existence doesn’t equal to being a super fan or even part of their fandom. My reactions are based on what I’ve seen, listened and experienced all these years without doing a deep-dive into the details. That’s why I often recommend people to comment their opinion and tips to help me learn more about what I’ve watched/reacted to🙋🏼♀️
Guess it would be good for you to know more about early SHINee sounds to not be so shocked and relate the sound to nct. let’s say SHINee always prove they can also do music that is on trend but put their juice in it (retro sounds+vocals)
Hello stranger 🤍 As I said in the video I’ve been following SHINee since ‘09 so I’m familiar with their b-sides in general. They have implacable music. This time around, for these two songs that I chose to react to, they reminded me a lot of the NCT’s style since now this group is in the company’s “picture”. These two groups have Totally different vibes, style and aesthetic music wise, although in my eyes something got mixed in the making of these two songs. Still slap though 🙋🏻♀️
First with full respect here. NCT and Shinee are from SM. So you will have the same pool of resources like music producers, song writers, art directors, MV sets, etc. I will say they are SM songs and MVs. For me, it is the artists' efforts that count the most and I think both Shinee & NCT works their a** off for their albums & promos. 😊
Hello stranger🤍 I’m a KPOP fan since ‘09 and I had never criticized the artists hard work because something “doesn’t sit right with me”. That’s a completely false mentality in any shape or form but that’s a topic for another video-conversation that soon will be created on my channel 🙋🏼♀️
@@goldienim I'm afraid that is not what I meant.😊 I was just praising and recognizing the artists' hardwork after watching your reaction which inspired me to question myself what is the most important - music, clothes, style, artists, songs, etc... Anyway thank you for making me think!
Clairement vous ne connaissez rien à l'univers de SHINee, sinon vous ne sortiriez pas autant de bêtises. Déjà il est un fait avéré depuis leurs débuts que SHINee ne fait jamais dans le même style de musique et aime explorer tous les genres qui s'offrent à eux. Et un autre fait, c'est qu'à leurs débuts ils ont fait du Hip-hop et cela bien avant NCT. Autre info, SHINee est de la 2ème génération et NCT de la 3ème. Je ne pense sérieusement pas que SHINee est cherché à faire un truc qui ressemble à un autre groupe. Ils sont bien au dessus de ça et n'ont plus rien à prouver. Franchement les gens qui essayent la comparaison sont totalement ridicules et perdent toutes crédibilités en ce disant fan du groupe !!! 😅😂
First of all thanks for your reaction. And I’m sorry, I really don’t want to be rude. But you’re wrong. I know that’s just your opinion. But these songs are not coded NCT at least for HARD. The members chose Hard and remade it from scratch. The comeback was delayed a month because of this. Juice was SM choice for the title track but SHINee did not agree and chose HARD and therefore redid it again because the original sound of Hard did not please them (they talk about it in their roadshow trip). And maybe you need indeed to listen again their earlier albums 😅 I also think you can rest assured, SHINee is not going to become a group like the others, it’s simply impossible. I find it unfortunate that you only hear NCT in these songs and not what SHINee brings to it... I really don’t see NCT (whatever the unit) singing/doing HARD or JUICE in the same way as SHINee (especially since HARD was redo by SHINee). A bit like all people who did a cover of "Move" and never manages to really do it perfectly (just my own opinion). I would finish by saying this, yes, we are usually one of the nicest fandoms but what can irritate us very quickly is to say that SHINee looks like another group as you could see in the comments. For that I would like to apologize (for the rather harsh comments). It’s just as you said, your own opinion. I hope that one day you will be more familiar with SHINee and what they bring to their music and that you can hear what we hear in Hard and Juice without hearing another band instead. (If we were to do this for all the groups that are trying to do the same thing as SHINee ...it would be a full-time job 🙂)
Hello stranger 🤍 Thank you for taking time to leave your own commentary on my video. Before anything else I want to point out that making a reaction to a certain artist doesn’t obligate me to get to know them more before filming the said video. That’s the whole point of making a reaction series, in my opinion 🤷🏼♀️ On the other hand, I find it pretty interesting how the fans react to me mentioning what these songs, to my own ears, sound more familiar with the NCT sound. As I said in the video I’ve known SHINee since ‘09 but after what happened with Jonghyun I’m not comfortable listening to them, in general. After all these years I took the courage to actually give it a try and listen to them successfully without going through a breakdown as it happened to me on their anniversary. A reaction video that is already up on my channel. Technically I would suggest the audience that judged my video harshly to actually do a deep-dive to my own videos to actually understand my POV. But that’s something no reactor has ever said out loud with the solid purpose to not press the KPOP audience in any shape or form. Naturally as a person when I hear a familiar sound I point it out for various reasons and I can assure you that “copying the original” is definitely not one! The NCT producer has worked with other artists before (e.x. HUSH by Lee Chaeyeong) and the sound even though it sounded familiar in my ears it didn’t sound exactly the same as NCT and/or its units. This time around I simply can not listen to HARD & Juice without “seeing” the songs being switched to different groups 🤷🏼♀️ Still that doesn’t mean that the songs don’t slap or that they are not “bombs” or “SOTY”!
This is not a song related to ntc or any of their sub units this is entirely a Shinee song. The reason people relate to it alongside ntc is because it was produced by the same people that work with ntc. If you have any questions feel free to ask
Taemins releasing a new album with possible concert in October this year along with key's new solo album. Onew is on hiatus until his health returns as for Minho there's no info for him releasing anything this year. There's an Also an world tour to come but not a European one.
Hello stranger 🤍 Thank you for the information! I’m 100% looking forward to all these solo projects and aesthetics that Taemin and Key are gonna bring to the table. I hope Onew to get better in the near future and be with us as soon as possible 🧿
@@goldienim your welcome. I'm wondering what they will come out with too. I subscribe to their bubble msg posts which is fun but onew hasn't been on much the others have . I know onews weight has returned to normal from what it was but other than that there's no info on how he is. Hopefully doing well. Oh I forgot to mention taemin will eventually open his own official UA-cam channel but when that will happen I don't know. He might even change his mind when the time comes and not do so. Time will tell
Many people actually do think that this is an nct song because its "hiphop" but Hard is very 90s west coast hiphop. SHINee has hiphop songs in the past in their bsides specially in their earlier years (2008-2010) because they were in fact originally a hiphop group before they debuted as a contemporary r&b group.
Juice on the other hand is actually a SHINee coded song. They make a very cohesive album everytime that I can place Juice in their misconceptions album. The HARD album is very SHINee coded and solo coded at the same time that its actually a very perfect 15th year anniv album. All the tracks in the album can be put in their (SHINee) albums and solo albums.🙂
HARD is so expectedly unexpected coz SHINee will never use the same genre twice for their title track hence Hard (a very hiphop rap focused song)
Juice can be placed in the Misconceptions album
10X is VERY Jonghyun coded and can be placed in She is album
Satellite is very Kibum and can be in Bad love album
Identity suits SHINee's 1 of 1 album but also very Kibum Killer album coded
The Feeling = Boys Meet You album
Like It is so Dont Call Me coded ❤
Sweet Misery is so Taemin and can be in NGDA album but I can imagine Kibum getting this for himself
Insomnia IS VERY MINHO CODED PERIOD AS IF ITS STRAIGHT OUTTA CHASE ALBUM
Gravity can be place in Onew's Circle album
It is perfect commentary 👏
Agreed 100%. The combination of 5 soloist❤
Hello stranger 🤍
Thank you for taking the time to break down the anniversary album and explain the little underline details!
I 100% see your point in JUICE, since I haven’t listen yet to the album I can not comment on all the other information that you mentioned but I will keep it in mind.
Shawol 2008-23 this is shinee sound. shinee ride rythm❤this song trully made for shinee. Mayb if u listen more to their past performance live, u'll be agree and know where did it sound shinee.
the songs Hard and Juice sound the same as in the old Shinee's albums in 2008-2010.
This is not NCT😢 please, listen old bisades from Amigo or 2009 year of us by Shinee
Other in album is like rest of Shinee's sweet sonds🤦🏻♀️
HARD is different, and I understand the NCT allegations but, as always, it's SHINee who chose their songs and wanted to try it out. Juice just feels like a continuation of their own song Don't Call Me (2021) tbh. Also, the rest of the album is also very much comfortable, brighter-sounding SHINee music!
Hello stranger 🤍
My opinion in the video is just.. my opinion and not allegations to any of those artists that I mentioned.
“Don’t call me” had such a revolutionary SHINee style that it became, in my opinion, the SHINee IT song that somebody newer to the KPOP frenzy could get involved with them since they have a long history.
Other than that, this time around it just doesn’t sound like SHINee 100%. It’s amazing how they always want to evolve and grow through their music, style and aesthetics. HARD and JUICE just didn’t convince me 🤷🏼♀️
SHINee debuted in 2008, they are known as their live vocals, also the first experimental group of SM😊 pls react to more SHINee, I recommend Atlantis, don’t call me, why so serious, married to the music, view, tell me what to do, everybody
SHINee is known as prince of kpop, they are the blueprint of the 3rd & 4th generation kpop group, they are not NCT haha, they are the seniors of NCT and EXO, they respect SHINee so much
How can someone who says they know SHINee's music say it doesn't sound like SHINee, but NCT, total bullshit and zero knowledge of their discography. a great comeback and a show of combining their solo and what they consider the essence of their group. SHINee chose the songs for their album themselves and it's definitely the best album of the year
Complétement d'accord avec vous. 👍👏
Hello stranger 🤍
Knowing them since ‘09 doesn’t always equal to an actual knowledge of a shawol and/or superfan, I never claimed or mentioned to be any of these two 🙋🏼♀️
@@goldienim no offense but statements like "it doesn't sound like them but more like another group" makes you judge from the level of familiarity almost like an expert and that was probably not your goal?
Rather, try to express your feelings about whether you like the style or not, and then you will be more credible
Shinee influenced NCT..not the other way around!
Agreed👍👍
Shawols are so nice. These comments ...I am a Shawol. I just want to say: Shinee will never be Just another cb.
Hello stranger 🤍
Shawols are one of the nicest fandoms out there since they mostly reflect the group’s overall energy ✨
I agree with you, SHINee will never be “just another comeback” to the slightest and that’s what makes the group so versatile and unique in so many ways!
SHINee es único en su clase, jamás des por echo algo con estos chicos. Y nunca los compares! Porque no tienen igual....!!
You may be an NCT fan, but you're definitely not a SHINee fan, so please don't look at them with colored glasses.
SHINee is SM's first experimental group, and the style is different every time they come back, they don't have a fixed style, it can be exaggerated to say 'there is no SHINee there would be no NCT'
The style of this song is more like the hippop when they first debuted (2008-2010) and the style of H.O.T in 2000.
Hello stranger 🤍
Knowing a group’s existence doesn’t equal to being a super fan or even part of their fandom.
My reactions are based on what I’ve seen, listened and experienced all these years without doing a deep-dive into the details. That’s why I often recommend people to comment their opinion and tips to help me learn more about what I’ve watched/reacted to🙋🏼♀️
Guess it would be good for you to know more about early SHINee sounds to not be so shocked and relate the sound to nct. let’s say SHINee always prove they can also do music that is on trend but put their juice in it (retro sounds+vocals)
Hello stranger 🤍
As I said in the video I’ve been following SHINee since ‘09 so I’m familiar with their b-sides in general. They have implacable music. This time around, for these two songs that I chose to react to, they reminded me a lot of the NCT’s style since now this group is in the company’s “picture”.
These two groups have Totally different vibes, style and aesthetic music wise, although in my eyes something got mixed in the making of these two songs. Still slap though 🙋🏻♀️
First with full respect here.
NCT and Shinee are from SM. So you will have the same pool of resources like music producers, song writers, art directors, MV sets, etc. I will say they are SM songs and MVs.
For me, it is the artists' efforts that count the most and I think both Shinee & NCT works their a** off for their albums & promos. 😊
Hello stranger🤍
I’m a KPOP fan since ‘09 and I had never criticized the artists hard work because something “doesn’t sit right with me”.
That’s a completely false mentality in any shape or form but that’s a topic for another video-conversation that soon will be created on my channel 🙋🏼♀️
@@goldienim
I'm afraid that is not what I meant.😊
I was just praising and recognizing the artists' hardwork after watching your reaction which inspired me to question myself what is the most important - music, clothes, style, artists, songs, etc...
Anyway thank you for making me think!
These are the high class performances of the 15 year old group
SHINee is THE LEGEND
TAEMIN is THE KING of kings
Clairement vous ne connaissez rien à l'univers de SHINee, sinon vous ne sortiriez pas autant de bêtises. Déjà il est un fait avéré depuis leurs débuts que SHINee ne fait jamais dans le même style de musique et aime explorer tous les genres qui s'offrent à eux. Et un autre fait, c'est qu'à leurs débuts ils ont fait du Hip-hop et cela bien avant NCT. Autre info, SHINee est de la 2ème génération et NCT de la 3ème. Je ne pense sérieusement pas que SHINee est cherché à faire un truc qui ressemble à un autre groupe. Ils sont bien au dessus de ça et n'ont plus rien à prouver. Franchement les gens qui essayent la comparaison sont totalement ridicules et perdent toutes crédibilités en ce disant fan du groupe !!! 😅😂
Up...
Exactly
idk how nct have genre😂, hope you could react their song in this album!
You should check the Sheeny History before declare who is who!!!.......I have read comments below...so you have to learn about it!..🤨🤨🤨
First of all thanks for your reaction. And I’m sorry, I really don’t want to be rude. But you’re wrong. I know that’s just your opinion. But these songs are not coded NCT at least for HARD. The members chose Hard and remade it from scratch. The comeback was delayed a month because of this. Juice was SM choice for the title track but SHINee did not agree and chose HARD and therefore redid it again because the original sound of Hard did not please them (they talk about it in their roadshow trip). And maybe you need indeed to listen again their earlier albums 😅
I also think you can rest assured, SHINee is not going to become a group like the others, it’s simply impossible. I find it unfortunate that you only hear NCT in these songs and not what SHINee brings to it... I really don’t see NCT (whatever the unit) singing/doing HARD or JUICE in the same way as SHINee (especially since HARD was redo by SHINee). A bit like all people who did a cover of "Move" and never manages to really do it perfectly (just my own opinion).
I would finish by saying this, yes, we are usually one of the nicest fandoms but what can irritate us very quickly is to say that SHINee looks like another group as you could see in the comments. For that I would like to apologize (for the rather harsh comments). It’s just as you said, your own opinion. I hope that one day you will be more familiar with SHINee and what they bring to their music and that you can hear what we hear in Hard and Juice without hearing another band instead. (If we were to do this for all the groups that are trying to do the same thing as SHINee ...it would be a full-time job 🙂)
Hello stranger 🤍
Thank you for taking time to leave your own commentary on my video.
Before anything else I want to point out that making a reaction to a certain artist doesn’t obligate me to get to know them more before filming the said video. That’s the whole point of making a reaction series, in my opinion 🤷🏼♀️
On the other hand, I find it pretty interesting how the fans react to me mentioning what these songs, to my own ears, sound more familiar with the NCT sound. As I said in the video I’ve known SHINee since ‘09 but after what happened with Jonghyun I’m not comfortable listening to them, in general.
After all these years I took the courage to actually give it a try and listen to them successfully without going through a breakdown as it happened to me on their anniversary. A reaction video that is already up on my channel. Technically I would suggest the audience that judged my video harshly to actually do a deep-dive to my own videos to actually understand my POV. But that’s something no reactor has ever said out loud with the solid purpose to not press the KPOP audience in any shape or form.
Naturally as a person when I hear a familiar sound I point it out for various reasons and I can assure you that “copying the original” is definitely not one!
The NCT producer has worked with other artists before (e.x. HUSH by Lee Chaeyeong) and the sound even though it sounded familiar in my ears it didn’t sound exactly the same as NCT and/or its units. This time around I simply can not listen to HARD & Juice without “seeing” the songs being switched to different groups 🤷🏼♀️
Still that doesn’t mean that the songs don’t slap or that they are not “bombs” or “SOTY”!
This is not a song related to ntc or any of their sub units this is entirely a Shinee song. The reason people relate to it alongside ntc is because it was produced by the same people that work with ntc.
If you have any questions feel free to ask
Taemins releasing a new album with possible concert in October this year along with key's new solo album. Onew is on hiatus until his health returns as for Minho there's no info for him releasing anything this year. There's an Also an world tour to come but not a European one.
Hello stranger 🤍
Thank you for the information! I’m 100% looking forward to all these solo projects and aesthetics that Taemin and Key are gonna bring to the table.
I hope Onew to get better in the near future and be with us as soon as possible 🧿
@@goldienim your welcome. I'm wondering what they will come out with too. I subscribe to their bubble msg posts which is fun but onew hasn't been on much the others have . I know onews weight has returned to normal from what it was but other than that there's no info on how he is. Hopefully doing well. Oh I forgot to mention taemin will eventually open his own official UA-cam channel but when that will happen I don't know. He might even change his mind when the time comes and not do so. Time will tell