End Smelly Tanks Forever
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 чер 2024
- What makes a fish tank stink? An aquarium that smells bad is not healthy. A stinky tank is a dying tank. An aquarium will die when it is not able to maintain the life of the plants and animals in it. So what kills aaquariums. There are 2 primary causes. Both are a result of bad advice. The first cause of stinky tank is excess food. Even if all the food is eaten the fish may create more waste than the biological activity in the tank is able to covert to energy. Waste that is not converted to energy rots and stinks. The main cause of inadequate biological activity is chemical treatment of the tank. Father Fish believes there are no chemicals that are critical for the health of an aquarium. Most chemicals are doesd in the tank to kill something. This creates death. Death is the opposite of life. Killing living organisms is not an appropriate method to maintain a healthy, living aqurium.
Build a dirted deep sustrate according to Father Fish instructions found in the Father Fish Shoal. Create a good web using Father Fish's techniques. Feed less than daily high quality foode in very small amounts. These procedures, followed carefully will mean your tank will be sweet smelling and thriving with life. and noever, never stink.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @fatherfish
Support me on Patreon
www.patreon.com/user?u=25478137
FATHER FISH is an advocate for natural aquariums. His research over 25 years provides a wealth of information about the creation and maintenance of natural aquariums.
On this channel you will find scientific research as well as personal testimonials by countless hobbyists who have applied the Father Fish System and are enjoying its amazing benefits.
THE FATHER FISH SHOAL on Discord is a wonderful way to meet and make new fishy friends as well as get the help you need.
24/7 live on Discord: / discord
You can buy plants, soil supplement, leaf culture & more:
father-fish-aquarium.myshopif...
For FF store links in other countries:
fatherfish.fish/
Father Fish Facebook Page
/ 3244678768912659
Buy Merch
teespring.com/stores/fatherfish
www.fatherfish.co
All clips and images are used for illustration purposes only.
THE DIY FISH
• FISH TANK AQUARIUMS BE...
Chewy's Bro Aquatics
• FEEDING *ALL OF MY FIS...
• Cleaning THE MOST DISG...
Muscle Fish
• Feeding the Monster 60...
Michael Roman
• The Dirty Community Tank
DVSx86
• Life in a drop of wate...
• Life in a drop of wate...
• Life in a drop of wate...
• Life in a drop of wate...
Psych2Go
• What Your Smell Says A...
Aqua Apprentice
• Seachem Flourish revie...
The Fish Room
• How good is this water...
TANK FISH
• HOW I TREAT FRESHWATER...
MicropolitanMuseum
• Forest soil time lapse
Living with Alyssa
• Video
goldmouth100
• ''OMG'' LOOK AT MY TAN...
Life's Bit
• Algae in microscope | ...
Micro Zoom
• Chlorine is Things Abo...
Aqua Life
• Hole In The Head Disea...
Michael's Fish Room
• Local fish store tour ...
Dr. DVV
• How does Effervescent ...
100% Pure Thailand
• *LARGEST* Aquarium Fis...
Joey Slay Em
• Fahaka puffer feeding ...
#fatherfish #aquarium #fatherfishaquarium #fishhobbyist #deepsubstrate #fishtank #fishfam #fishaquarium #deepsubstrate #walstad #fishtube
00:00 Introduction
00:35 Causes of a stinky tank
02:00 What a stinky tank means
02:42 Father Fish's tanks
04:00 When chemicals are added
11:03 Chemicals and Natural Aquariums
13:00 It's that simple - Наука та технологія
As soon as I stopped swimming in my tank the odor went away . LOL . As you said , feed your fish every few days and this does wonders for the biological system. Thank you Father fish . God bless you brother.
After 15 years without a fish, I just started a new tank inspired by you. Mud, sand, plants, fish and light from the sky. That's great. Thanks for knowledge and philosophy
I watched all ur videos but now I have ten tanks and an angry mom!
Take your mom to the fish store. When she finds a fish she likes help her set up a tank with her favorite fish.
Hahaha that's awesome. Your comment made my day.
Thanks for awesome comment
Before i have a clear water and more artificial plants in my aquarium., not until i watch more than 10 videos of father fish, i rebuild my aqurium, i replace all the artificial plants.
I put deep substrate,sands,grabel a little dritfwood and more plants in my aquarium, and now i have a healty and happy fish in my little eco system.
Thanks to father fish.❤❤❤
I applied the tips of Father Fish "do nothing" and it worked, I was cleaning too much the gravels and the plants had not enough to eat even with the special soil. Now the gravels have somekind of dirt in them and the plants grew up more in a month than in a year, that's crazy, and without CO2. Before that I had algaes on the glass in 3 days, now it's still ok after 2 weeks, the tank stabilized in like a week. I was changing 15% of water each week as I thought I had too much nitrates, but this apparently was too much for the water stability and the effect was negative. I also feed the fish every 3 days instead of everyday.
Thank you father fish
So happy that you chat with us. Preach it Father!
No Stinky Tank, just a Stinky Gov.
Both of my aquariums smell like a POND and I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!! I've followed your method and I'll tell you what, OH MY GOODNESS! Never again will I do the PetStore way of having fish. GO NATURE LOL!
I love all the nature sounds you have going on it really throws it all together having your birds in the background I love it
I ran into this with a couple of my tanks that had gravel only so i started researching and found father fish. They now smell great capped with sand and my mystery snail immediately laid three egg clutches! Best thing i did was find father fish. So incredibly helpful!
Watching your videos brings back memories of Mr. Rogers except you talk about deep substrates 😊. You are such a great teacher and so patient with people. Every video is educational and so informative. Keep up the great work! Love you!
Thanks for the knowledge father fish
Yellowish water can come from leafs,wood tannins or just type of light! Greets from a french guy in Austria! Love your videos!
I miss having a canary! they're so calming!
I moved to Cambodia couple of years ago, every weekend I go fishing and bring back home some of the fish from the Mekong river, but also from road-side ditches, rice fields, puddles, and ponds. Every time I bring fish with me I also bring bucket of sand, mud and plants from the spot, that way fish don't even need to acclimate to my conditions I'm bringing piece of their habitat with them, at this moment I have collected around 30 different species, some of which are pretty unique local variations or even possibly undescribed species. Thing is I used to be afraid to let a whole bunch of plant matter to decompose right there in the tank, but with heavy planting and sand cap that's not an issue at all, that's one advice I adopted from Father Fish, I already had an idea but here I saw practical and methodical way of doing it, it's also very helpful in terms of feeding micro-predators such as bumblebee gobies, boraras and such, which could be quite a challenge to provide with daily portion of cultured food such as brine shrimps.
As for the smell, sometimes water at the location can be quite stinky (mix of rotten egg smell and bit of ammonia bite) especially during the dry season, in which case I would simply add some rain water to the mix and no additional fish food for a couple of days, and it clears up on it's own, no filter, no running water, just sand and leaf litter, I also like to add couple of corals to buffer the acidic reaction of tannins, although sand as a mix of all types of rocks and broken shells can already have the same function
Excellent practices. I would love to do an interview with you. Please join us on the Wednesday Show and Tell. That should be early in the morning for you.
Thanks for all. Great person!!
Thank you Father Fish for another fabulous video, bless you ❤️.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge!
Yeah the pet stores try to push a lot of stuff on you but in reality you don't need it .and I love your method set up your tank in a way where nature can take over! So simple and that's what I have done in a 7 gallon for my betta and he loves it it's like a jungle in there so it really brings out his Natural Instincts for hunting and he does he loves hunting
Ty Father Fish for all of the time and thoughtful and most importanty clear fish keeping advice. Have a great weekend 💖🐠
No smelly tanks here! All my tanks(8) remind me of mountain streams in the woods after a rain shower. Moist and earthy😁☮❤🐠🦐🪴🪴🪴🪴🪴🪴🪴
I rectly set up new tank with Father Fish drep substrate formula. Almost a month from now... Plants and fish thriving ... ❤ From India
Your dedication to the hobby is infectious. Appreciate your words. Thank you Sir!
I like that you readdress concepts from different angles in your videos I think it's a good system.
I like your way when you explain these information sir.. Thanks a bunch
I have a deep well and my fish seem to do really good in the water from it. Even the sand in my tank was taken off of my own property. I live about an hour from Myrtle Beach, so I have no shortage of sand. I can dig down a couple of feet and find really nice sand in my yard. It takes alot to get it clean, but it is beautiful white sand. And it’s soft. My Cory Cats love it. It’s not spread evenly throughout my tank either. The fish move it around. My Pleco loves to bury itself in it sometimes. I have 4 kinds of aquatic plants in it, and one house plant on top. The house plants roots hang down into the water. Before I put the plants and sand in it, it would stay cloudy or green. I was doing 50%-80% water changes every week or two. It’s literally stayed clear ever since, and I haven’t done but one water change. It’s crazy how much of a difference it made. I also put some lava rocks from my koi pond in it to help move it along. I’m hoping it introduced a bunch of beneficial bacteria.
Sounds wonderfl. Add some leaf material fro a local pond and then feed it dry leaves. Just a bit at a time.
Love all your educational videos keep up the good work and keep spreading the good word on how to run a tank naturally
I have an old aquarium (60x30x30cm) and I intend to set it up according to your instructions. I was fascinated by your approach, which, for me, makes perfect sense. I'm currently gathering the materials and buying the plants in stages (it's expensive to buy them all at once...), to set up the aquarium that I'm looking forward to! I will just add a sponge filter to promote water circulation. I'll give you news! Thank you very much for your teachings!
Why buy when its out there for FREE. I would suggest you to visit a near by pond or creek, you will find a wide variety of plants. Take your own time to choose. A gift from Nature!
@@NatureInTankHi! Just want to ask if I can put lucky bamboo in my tank?
@@darimarisnani7880 Yes you can but don't plant it right into the substrate unless you have the stem long enough to peak out of the water column. Lucky bamboo is not an aquatic plant. If you are just having short shoots then just immerse the root and stem part. Don't immerse the whole plant inside the water.
I recently had a problem with a stinky tank, due to rotting leaves. When I first set it up 6 months ago, I put in a LOT of plants. With time, some of them started to win over others in access to light, and some plants started dying. Once I took out the rotting leaves, the smell went away.
Does FF recommend to keep dying plants in?
@@ChickenStrip22 im not sure, I think yes, to an extent, however for me it became too much, but I only skimmed dead leaves from the surface and took out like three dead plants.
You either remove most of the dead plants or changing the tank water to remove those excessive nutrients. One of my betta almost died because I did not do anything mentioned above 😂
Yep over feeding. Makes stinky.
The alternative to chlorinated and chloramine tap water is simple rain water. The stuff that falls from the sky which helps fill and dilute rivers ponds and streams where fish also live. Simple and free. I've been doing it for many years. Collect it and use it.
critical to add food web and dirted deep substrate to rain water.
Va salut din Romania! Si multumesc pentru sfaturi…
Great information 👍👍👍
I watch your videos from the Middle East, thank you
Thank you 😊 i love your videos 💕
Great video, as always. I've been noticing a smell only at night when lights are off. It's a heavily planted tank with a deep substrate and cap. It's been running really well for about 2 years now and going strong! However, the nighttime smell started about 2 months ago, and I even noticed when puncturing the soil bubbles arrise. Any advice on how to support the anaerobic bacteria without causing a smell or on avoiding this happening each night? I do not add any chemicals or extras in the tank. Thank you for any advice.
Add an inch of sand. that should help.
I learned something new today THANKYOU❗❗❗ This is why I'm always watching so grateful and thankful to you always love you so much❣❣❣
Another Master Class on aquarium ecosystems. Thank you Father. Be well from the fish eyed foo's in Michigan :)
Love you Father Fish, thanks to sharing your knowledge and wisdom with us ❤❤❤.My first aquarium ever and is just perfect , i just fallow your advice and omg what a gorgeous little environment i have. Thanks so much
Baba Tüm vidyolarını tekrar tekrar izleyerek bilgilerini tazeliyorum .Çünki her bilgin doğru ve eğitici .İyiki varsın .
Love this video!
Great video! I think I’m going to upload a video of my tank soon on my channel.
♥thank you FF
My respects to Father Fish!
Hahahah..'I say the same thing in different ways": That is so true. May God bless you Fr. Fish with long life and good health!!! Thanks so much for your advice on fishkeeping, it works.
Thanks from India👍👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏
Your discord team is one of the 👌 10/10 ❤
A very helpful team🤝
Hello Father Fish.
After watching your channel I set up my 1st dirted tank a couple months ago.
I've done it with soil from near a local pond, some pond muck, peat moss and capped it with sand.
Loaded up with plants and decaying leaf litter to get the micro-organisms a head start.
Lately I've been noticing more and more bubbles being released from the substrate.
I'm sure it's not trapped bubbles from being set up as I've actually watched some develop at the front glass.
Just wonder what's going on here and if it's anything I should be concerned about.
I've heard you speak of the substrate as a CO2 machine.
Is that what it's doing?
Other than that I couldn't be happier with the tank and the fish and shrimp love it too.
I've learnt more about fishkeeping from you in the last 6mth than I have in the previous 40yrs and have changed the way I've gone about things since.
The gs is nitrogen and probably also CO2. Nothing to worry about.
Guess what I have a bunch of baby fishes I'm over the moon I must be doing something right thankyou FF for your expertise😊 ❤❤❤
Hello father fish, greetings, my sand is a little thin. I would like to make a thicker layer as you recommend. I can add my sand with my aquarium set up.
Right now battling algae in my small 5 gallon. Cut back the light and now waiting to see. Plants loaded up but went a bit hard at beginning
Man, if I was retiring soon I would ask FF if I could open a franchise in Ottawa lol
@0.25 look at the substrate maxing going on here...
We gonna ignore that catfish thst ate that big ass goldfish😂?
Yes we are. Gulpers should never be fed such glorious food.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge . Substrates (for example tropica aquarium substrate) that is commercially available can be used as the supplement?
As part of it, yes. It still needs organics - peat and coposted material.
Thankyou for the educational videos on maintaining a natural tank the natural way.
I needed reasurance on what to do and not to do. Eg. No chemicals are beneficial, water evaporation and topping off tank, adding vitamin C to remove chemicals in tap water.
😊 Please keep reasuring us as the pet shop push water changes for high nitrite levels every 2 days and adding store chemicals. I didnt, i added more plants.
Is there any benefit in testing your water? If so what do you test for in a father fish method tank?
I test to know what my Ph is coming out of the tap. I test nothing else.
I havent done a water change since jan. Just top off with water from the creek
Do you already have it in Portugal?
Whats your opinion on leeches, hydra, and a couple of the other classic "pests" that usually hitch rides on wild found plants? Trying yo get my own little mini ecosystem going but not sure what critters should stay or go conpared to a traditional aquarium
Small fish eat these pests.
I plan to get more plants and cut way back on feeding. But my water seems brown since adding my resurrection jar.
I've always been really critical of your channel but this is one of my favourite videos and really interesting about the vitamin c I thought it would be too acidic if not in a huge system what is the effect on say 40galons ? per 1000mg? I think that your whole method is the ideal method by far. but why wouldn't you remove the chlorine and chloramine first to avoid wiping out any of the biome in your tank or doesn't it matter when it's so diluted? I have 2 tropical tanks and I'm the same they were setup the only time I've done a water change was when I was moving house. I always top up with rodi so I don't raise the tds above natural levels and have shrimp substrate and coral bone for minerals and a plant on top to take up any excess nutrients. my tanks look as clean as any other. only need to clean the algae off once a year. been running like this for over 5 years. it has never ever seen any medication same with any of the materials inside.
TDS is variable based on plant absorption of dissolved minerals. I never add rodi water to insure tds is not lowered. Vit C has marginal effect on Ph. Chloramine is sufficiently low that immediate reduction reduces impact on living oganisms to a negligable level.
Really critical? Really?
@FatherFish very interesting I might try the vitamin c. the only reason I used rodi is it is on hand and when water evaporates the dissolved solids remain its only pure h²o leaving the tank so I am just replenishing that as the rain does. I also only keep shrimp snails and plants in my freshwater setups currently. I also don't test my tds even though I really should especially to see how much the plants are consuming. would you recommend treating the water with vitamin c before adding it to be on the safe side or would it make no difference on a small water change? it does remind me of topping up straight from the tap when working in aquariums only one pretreated the water but that was a highend store and everything was heated in barrels beforehand as well.
and yeah I have been in the past because at first I thought it was purely old thinking and carelessness until I watched multiple videos and your right watching 10 of your videos despite being the same message really shows that it's so much more tbh. less so on the saltwater tank even though it's ideal it just hurt a bit as a reef keeper but after that I decided to collect sand from the bottom of a rockpool and add to one of my reef tanks and they amount of microscopic life that added is incredible. the tank was at the point of being shut down because of dinoflagellates there appears to be some type of worm feasting on them which if that's the case it would be an incredible breakthrough as far as treating dinoflagellates goes if they outpace them
What vitamin c tablets do you recommend?
1000U any brand
In nature, the water drains below the earth and refilled by rain. There has to be a timeframe for this setup or atleast some water changed.
top offs achieve this
@FatherFish I meant all of the accumulated stuff at the bottom waste is waste even if the bacteria breaks it down Eventually will rise to the top shouldn't there be atleast a 1 month Maybe 10% water changes?
More plants + fish = more plants and fish....if you know what i mean.
I think I’m feeding my fish too much, but they beg. The pleading eyes…
You are in their power. Use your big brain to dominate and control them.
I have a 3 inch sandbed in my largest tank. I recently put another couple inches of Eco Complete over the top of that. My plants are doing well, but now I’m wondering if this was not a good idea, since you’re talking about a sand cap?
Ecocomplete will leach nutrients into the water.
Cap it with an inch of sand.
Hey father fish, I have a question that has nothing to do with this video. My tank is about 3-4 weeks old and I noticed a snail inside. I’ve never introduced any snails to my knowledge. Any ides how it could have got there? I’ve used nice pieces of wood from a tree I cut down from outside and river rock from my yard as well ass diet from my back yard.
And something from another tank....
I am trying to promote the deep substrate method in Poland, but it is difficult
Can you put the vit c tablet right in tank?
yes
What substrate will have in goldfish tank ? I found stinky under stones !!! And now brown algae!!
Father Fish, I have a 75 gal of peacock cichlids that are fairly large and have destroyed every kind of plant I have put in the tank (excluding water lettuce). Do you think I could use fake plants to acclimate them and train them to get used to having plants in the tank without destroying them? I can slowly replace fake with real over time. Does this sound like a method that will work?
I do not think you can trick them. lol The best way to do this is a 2 step system. First begin feeding them greel leafy vegetables daily. Secong plant a significant number of parge plants like val and sword, not a few but a lot.
@@FatherFish Thank you very much. I have those plants in abundance.
My tanks smell simular to a natural lake . Everything is healthy
Hello... Good day sir. I have a question...
Can I use a combination of river clay and aqua soil for my planted aquarium? And is it okay if I don't cap it with sand. I mean base layer is river clay and then top it with aqua soil. Is it okay? I have got fresh river mud and clay.
Please reply... Namaste from India.
Sir Which type water use you your aquarium two days old water exit chlorine and choramine
Tap water, Add vitamin C 1 1000U tab per 5 gallons removes chloramine.
@Father Fish
I'm trying to grow red plants. Even when i order them red and put them in my tank, they start growing green. I kicked up the lighting and used a bright RBG light, still most of them grow green. And i fight green water because the lighting is too much. How do i get plants to grow red? Do i have to break down and add CO2?
CO2 will not make them red. Nutrients in the substrate is the key. Do you have a deep substrate> A food web?
@@FatherFish
Yep. I sure do! The tanks is 2 years old 3 inches of dirt and 2 inches of sand from the beach. I've even tried root tabs and no change. Some plants only get red when they grow tall and the tops turn red as they get closer to the light, But the light is bright. I've tried red rotala and other common red plants....they start growing green, never stay red.
I found that a simple cheap seed starting light does the trick. I bought a full spectrum seed starting light for my plant growing obsession last year and found that it keeps red plants red. I don't use any fertilizers in the water coloumn. I had aquasoil on hand and capped it with sand two months ago, before I discovered father fish. It was my only tank set up that way and it is thriving.
I used your method, but there are many particles and algae on the plants. Do I need to increase the water flow?
Perhaps. Join us in the SHOAL to diagnose the issue.
My turtle 🐢 tank gets stinky when he digs deeply. I will add more sand to prevent this. I also have to figure out a way to get plants in there... possibly by adding a light to strong enough to grow duckweed. I will also ask the Shoal how to engineer a spot for rooted plants in a turtle tank.
Turtles eat duckweed, it wouldn't last long, but you can grow it in separate bucket and throw a bunch of it daily to the turtle tank, it also might help with stink, commercial food is full of protein, more than they actually need, plant food acts like a filler, so they don't need to consume all that protein but rather balanced mix
excellent advice.
Hello father fish, am from Ethiopia. Will hydroponic plants supply oxygen to my fish tank? Thank you, your contents are helpful!!
no. They are doing photosynthesis above the water. They will extract CO2 from the water. A little bit of current will provide adequate CO2/O2 exchange.
I have never had a smelly tankbut I feel it was do to this Chanelle
cute but toxic. Don't try it.
Father fish i have 155gallon fish tank and i am keeping single oscar in it but why is my fish always hungry asking for food when ever i walk near tank it swims aggressively asking for food what should i do i feed him twice a day??
Does Chloramine gas off by it's self if you let the water sit a few days?
no. It is a liquid molecule
How would you maintain an overstocked African cichlids tank and keep it natural? they usually destroy the plant
Find the balance
algae are also plants, things with the large surface area, like wood logs, crushed corals, and even leaf litter and sand act as a surface area for algae to grow, I had a similar problem with some voracious herbivores, but this seem to solve the problem, I still toss a bunch of duckweed daily but it gets eaten in matter of hours
Absolutely correct Algae is a natural food source for Mbuna cichlids. They even have special teeth to remove algae from rocks.
The fungus and bacteria breakdown waste and make it available to micro fauna. .
Fungus, bacteria and micro fauna.. How do I make sure these 3 things are present in my aquarium ? what are the signs...
Bring material from a pond or stream and put small amounts in your tank. do this from several sources to insure diversity.
Is putting salt in the tank is vital?
no
Naturales tank loves
Do you sell Vitamin C tablets?
yes
How do you keep the red plants red and alive in a natural tank?
LOTS of light
Got
Stinky everything 😅😅😂
Need to clean up your act lol
I put indian almond leaf on my aba aba tank want to change that leaf in week if its decomposing?😊 1
No. Decomposing is microfauna eating it.
I also I ordered plants from you but they came half rotten. I tried to save them, but then they messed up my tanks. I had to throw them all away.
Did you ask me to replace them? I always replace plants that the USPS has delayed.
@@FatherFish no I didn’t so I would really appreciate that. What do I need to do?
@@FatherFish no I didn’t so I would really appreciate that. What do I need to do?
❤
hi father fish can i put vitamin c tablet directly to my tank with fish inside or not?
Yes. Vit C in any quantity is harmless/
@@FatherFish thank you 🥰🙏🏻
i found it 😅
@@FatherFish1 more question father fish please... can i use expired vitamin c tablet or not? my mom work at hospt. they have expired vit c..
Can someone help? I tried to do ff method and reset and bought lots of plants then went for a walk to my local woods and put lots of dead leaves and sticks in my tank, a day later fish were gasping and dying!?
Maybe it's better to add leaves and sticks progressively, only a few at a time.
Yes. "Lots of" is the incorrect approach. You overwhelmend the biology rather than let it grow slowly. A little bit at a time works wonderfully. A few leaves a week.
😍😍😍❤️
nope. no stinky tank
I’m trying to send a picture, but I’m unable to
U can alwsys join the discord and send that way
I just set up two new tanks with dirt and layer of sand my plans are all dying
Did you push the stems or roots into the dirt layer? In a new tank that will kill them. They should only be planted 1" in the sand.
@@FatherFish I remembered you stressing that point so I kept them in the sand.
I have a dee sand substraate bu he waste just sits on top
If you are not changing water often and not added any chemicals to the tank, you are good. Lot of life's feed on it and in the process, it breaks down the matter small enough that it will get below the sand cap and your plants feed on it. Its a cycle.
@NatureInTank ok thanks I was just worried because I thought the waste was ment to go below the sand and I should probably feed less cause I feed them everyday
Natures' way in Quran 5:31 "God sent down a raven which started to dig up the earth to show the killer how to bury the corpse of his brother. On seeing the raven, (Cain) said, "Woe to me! Am I less able than a raven to bury the corpse of my brother?" He became greatly remorseful."
Aamen
Aamen
Able sat with the Lord in heaven and asked the Lord to save his murderous brother.
To my own experience stinky tank = not enough oxygen 99% of the time.
correct. The cause of low oxygen is the cause of the smell.