Air vs Coil Shock - Which is best? | Testing MTB Suspension

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 39

  • @danielwu7238
    @danielwu7238 25 днів тому +3

    Your camera man was a great helping hand. Its great to have friends like that.

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@danielwu7238 for sure 👍

  • @worldstallestmidget
    @worldstallestmidget 25 днів тому +3

    I have a e bike also. I use the coil for pedaling up tech and rocky trails and in wet conditions for more grip. I use the air for mello trail rides or at a jump park or where I am going to pop of stuff. But if I forget th swap air for coil I just turn down the high speed down and low speed compression up
    And pro tip to change shocks lay bike sideways on the ground and it doesn’t drop as much and easier to move rear end around an easier to bolt back up

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@worldstallestmidget thank for the laying the bike sideways tip. I was worried about dropping the shock hardware that way.

  • @katanavisionn
    @katanavisionn 25 днів тому +2

    Love your channel man. I just got my polygon collosus n9!

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому +1

      @@katanavisionn heck yeah 👍 stoked for you! I love my N9.

  • @STLMTB
    @STLMTB 24 дні тому +4

    PRO TIP: put a towel under the bike so when those little washers fall, they don't disappear. Especially when over a hard surface like in the shop.

  • @Coolcmsc
    @Coolcmsc 24 дні тому

    Great vid. Not too technical. To the point. Thanks. I’m going to move to a coil thanks to watching this for my SC Bullit e-bike (I should have bought the coil version). You nailed all the reasons a coil is going to be better for me. But, I have taken the time to try two other bikes with coil on my fave trail/park to get to grips with what you set out here. I would advise anybody who can do that to take the opportunity. In the U.K., some LBS’ will lend a coil or shock if they have one that fits, but it’s harder with a coil as the spring is different depending on your weight and the LBS might only have one size spring.

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  24 дні тому +1

      @@Coolcmsc that’s awesome that the LBS is letting you demo a coil shock. Super smart on their part to keep customers happy and buying through them. I’d support that shop 👍

  • @kbellanti
    @kbellanti 25 днів тому

    Great video! I am trying to make up my mind myself on air vs coil on my fuel exe! This helps. Thanks!

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому +1

      @@kbellanti I’d say, Coil if you want to make it enduro/DH capable; Air if you want to make it lighter and more Trail/long ride capable.

  • @gavinneill9134
    @gavinneill9134 20 днів тому

    Hey Jared just curious is your down tube shock mount cracked 13:53
    Great vid stay safe!

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  20 днів тому

      @@gavinneill9134 that was just the way the light was hitting that big weld. Thanks for looking out though 👍

    • @gavinneill9134
      @gavinneill9134 20 днів тому

      Awesome you have got me interested in trying the coil on my n9 👍

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  20 днів тому

      @@gavinneill9134 do it 👍 The Lost Co has a great deal right now on the DHX2. It’s tempting to try a cheaper coil shock, but I think the extra cost is worth it for the Fox coil. Make sure to chat with the Lost Co guys about springs if you e never had a coil shock before. They helped me a lot.

  • @kentnilsson9757
    @kentnilsson9757 25 днів тому

    👍Always nice to compare a coil and a air damper👏
    I compared the Öhlin fork RXF36 M.2 AIR and COIL version, and where I found out after this test that if I would by a Öhlin fork, I would NOT by one Öhlin fork in a air version, because the air chamber is to small to get this fork to work nice. But the Coil version of the same fork is very nice🥰.
    Fox Factory 36mm and Rockshox Lyrik Ultimata 35 forks is the best option of air forks, witch I have both of.
    This Polygon Emtb is seems to be a very interesting Emtb, with the longer swingarm, like the Rotwild R.EXC Ultra or Pro.
    I guess thees bikes would be even more nice with a good coil damper.
    The new Rockshox Vivid with the hydraulik bottom out, could be a nice two air/coli version option to try😊
    The Damper version I have and tryed are both Öhlins TTX22M and Öhlins STX22 witch is very nice damper both of this, but is not easy to get hold of spare parts to the coil damper.
    I also have some Fox Factory DHX2 coil damper and some Fox Factory DPX2 with this small piggyback, that's works realy nice.
    My life has gone from all sorts of summer and winter sports, with or without engines. Snowmobile racing, Motocross, Enduro, road bikes to Mountain bikes and now Emtb Construction frome framset, with now seven diffrent Emtb and Mtb's, at the age of 59 years where I had to leave my whiny cohabitants, when I now ❤love my bikes❤ more then her😂

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@kentnilsson9757 heck yeah man! Tons of good advice there. Always wanted to try that Vivid Shock but never wanted to run a Rockshox Shock with Fox fork 😂 MTB unwritten rules lol

  • @shanereid5663
    @shanereid5663 24 дні тому

    Oil and coil with a progressive spring is better then a slice of fried gold. It’s definitely an upgrade on this linkage design.

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  24 дні тому

      @@shanereid5663 for sure 👍 I’ve never tried a progressive spring but would like to sometime in the future.

  • @trailpimp6369
    @trailpimp6369 21 день тому

    Hell yeah keep it orange

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  21 день тому +1

      @@trailpimp6369 looks so good 🤘

  • @SpencerBaum
    @SpencerBaum 25 днів тому

    Maybe try a less wide angle for the chest footage. Honestly, the best angle is chin or helmet mount

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@SpencerBaum for sure 👍 this was my first time using the Insta360 X4 on the chesty. I’ll change that up in future vids.

  • @Mtb-TrailTime
    @Mtb-TrailTime 25 днів тому

    Any suggestions for an e-bike? I’m looking for an alloy frame. Preferably with enduro specs. I got 6.5k spend per wife’s approval.

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@Mtb-TrailTime Bro, you have to check out the 2024 Polygon Collosus N8XE - All Mountain eBike bikesonline-usa.sjv.io/R5MaDR
      Get that, upgrade the wheels and you got a dream MTB with money to spare.

    • @Chr1s_race
      @Chr1s_race 24 дні тому

      Centurion no pogo

  • @STLMTB
    @STLMTB 24 дні тому

    Oh yeah man, Coil on an E-bike, coil on an Amish bike, coil all the way!!!!

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  24 дні тому

      @@STLMTB DH, enduro, and trail bikes for sure 👍

  • @saulgs00
    @saulgs00 25 днів тому

    On trunion shocks, there is only one way to install them 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @onlysendsmtb
    @onlysendsmtb 25 днів тому +3

    Please go back to GoPro. That FPV footage is not good. I'm surprised you decided to use it.

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @@onlysendsmtb I like the insta360 for certain shots but need a new chesty cam.

    • @SergejGrabun
      @SergejGrabun 25 днів тому

      I agree, quality is worse. Maybe some settings must be checked? What about Action 5 Pro?

    • @JaredHoff
      @JaredHoff  25 днів тому

      @ I want that new Insta360 Acer 2 pro, but DJI is a close second.

  • @kentnilsson9757
    @kentnilsson9757 25 днів тому

    👍I feel and guess that the hydraulik rebound/return on the coli damper, makes the biggest diffrent on the stability between a air and coli version of dampers😋.
    I am Waiting for the first air damper with a REAL HYDRAULIK rebound/return😉