EWS Reservation: Supreme Court Upholds 10% Quota For EWS With 3:2 split verdict | UPSC | StudyIQ IAS

[@StudyIQEducationLtd]

UPSC IAS (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Batch 8 Starting On 14th NOV'22 | Daily Live Class at 6:00 PM|
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3zFtNFL
UPSC IAS (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Batch 7 |Batch Started On 18th Oct'22 |Daily Live Class at 6:00 PM
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3DzzQ1k
UPSC IAS (Pre + Mains) LIVE Foundation Weekend Batch 2|
New Batch Starting On 27th November '22 |
Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3fzN70j
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE PSIR Optional Batch 3
Batch Starting on 25th November |
To know more visit : bit.ly/3Nu0mfT
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Geography Optional Batch 3
Starting on 14th November |
To know more visit - bit.ly/3gL3o2R
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE History Optional Batch 2
Starting on 10th November |
To know more visit - bit.ly/3TGWOce
UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Sociology Optional Batch 2
Batch Started on 21 NOV'22 |
To know more visit -bit.ly/3sWpkek
UPSC + Uttar Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) LIVE Foundation Combo Batch 2
Admissions closing on 10th NOV'22 |
To Know more visit: bit.ly/3s1AttN
UPSC + Bihar PSC (Pre + Mains) LIVE Foundation Combo Batch 2
Admissions Closing on 10th NOV'22 |
To Know more visit: bit.ly/3zq4aJb
UPSC + Jammu Kashmir PSC (pre + Mains ) Live Foundation Batch 1
Admissions Closing on 10th NOV'22
To Know more visit :
UPSC + OPSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Batch 1
Admissions Closing on 10th NOV'22
To Know more visit :bit.ly/3STkRn8
UPSC + Assam PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation Batch 1
Admissions Closing on 10th NOV'22
To Know more visit : bit.ly/3DPpc6x

[@satyaedutech6954]

Government should provide free education not reservation

[@SILOPshuvambanerjee]

Point hai

[@Jharkhandistudents]

general community k log vi bahut garib he haame parayi karne k lia jaameen bechna parta he....fhir kheti k lia kuch nahi bachta...cast shouldt be the scale of reservation

[@KabindraSahoo]

ST SC OBC are already getting reservation. Why do people want to get a share in the 10% EWS quota. What will be the difference if they came under the EWS quota as well.
The government should rather remove all the reservation quotas and only keep the EWS quota

[@Naoki-ge5xp]

You need to learn about the socio-economic reality of India. Best way would be to go through the arguments made in case.

[@vijetakumar7347]

Accha 😂

[@Dailymotion-i3m]

@@vijetakumar7347 🤣🤣🤣

[@alhamdulillah826]

One enjoying one reservation can't enjoy other reservation for example - an obc can't get the benefits of EWS

[@MukeshSharma-zw6wv]

Right..not anybody take two reservation

[@birsakandir9069]

Answer is Option D
1.Any part can be amend except Basic structure not only part 3.
2. Amendment bill can be introduced either by LS or RS.

[@amanverma7033]

I am an obc but I want that reservation should be given to all on basis on economic conditions not caste

[@vineetkumarverma1135]

Yes

[@VISHALKUMAR-fw8nz]

Yes

[@aayushtyagi5562]

that's how our India will grow💗

[@sayakghoroi9154]

Good decision ..why Genarel candidates suffer for Government exams ..Thank u supreme Court ....

[@thehardtruthsoflife9460]

Supreme court and government should have converted whole 50% reservation into EWS reservation which is currently in different castes . If not so, exisiting reservation should have reduced 2% in all categories . There is no logic to increase resevation upto 60 % .

[@aditimukherjee1572]

Economic reservation is what we needed not on the basis caste or religion

[@Varun32924]

Then eliminate caste discrimination

[@TeluguFactsTV]

I agree

[@AnkeetaGoatFarm]

Agreed

[@Ayodhyabestplaces]

I support

[@kumarjai973]

@@lostboy6080 your wish

[@JustDalbir]

Reservation to SC ST OBC etc should also be economically based ... EWS is much needed.

[@AmanThakur-pm8ql]

Government is absolutely Right, In future need to end all reservation & if want can implement on the basis of EWS.

[@vishalmonga1174]

great decision we need economic quote not on basis of cast and religion,

[@Get_success028]

Then Remove caste first

[@Varun32924]

Then remove caste and caste discrimination

[@Muneerkhan-y3l]

We should need to finish caste first🙏 then no need for the reservation

[@crazyfreezy1888]

Remove Overall reservation... Then every category can enjoy 100% reservation.

[@milindvaidya433]

50 % limit of reservation previously judgment said is abolished now obc ,SC, ST have opportunity to demand 75% reservation.

[@gpanigrahi2751]

Very true, reservation needs to have a time frame. It cannot go indefinitely.

[@cosmicvibes4802]

Education को सस्ता कर दो
हम सब कर लेंगे, कोई reservation नही चाहिए
I 'm an OBC ( चौरसिया)

[@adtutorials1516]

8 lakh per year means 66666 rs per month earn karne wala economic weaker kaise.
I think economic limit must decrease up to 4 to 4.5 lakh per year

[@Khojiutkarsh]

I totally agree with the verdict of sc ..and support the view of justice trivedi

[@kunwarali9649]

FINALLY A Good decision taken by Supreme Court . NOW I CAN USE EWS CERTIFICATE

[@ajayharde8]

Make EWS 50% including all caste, and make other 50% as OPEN

[@vyomaexplorer3630]

EWS ka certificate ameer log bhi bana lete hai ....boht bdi problem

[@dipanshukumar3677]

Right

[@tarupathak3955]

St sc ko kyu ews chahiye? Ek to kam application fee, more attempts and scholarship during education life. Aur kitna chahiye unko

[@infiniteenergyclasses2389]

We want age relaxation in ews

[@chandansingh1144]

Right

[@sonukumarpandey6712]

Agree

[@rmansadotra426]

Shi h

[@Stoic3111]

Right

[@deepanjoydas970]

Good decision by SC and also the time frame comment given by Justice Trivedi should also be considered. Caste based reservations will never end the caste concept from people's mind and it should be reduced through economical basis of segregation.

[@baljeetsingh7874]

Jab tak reservation rahega
Tab tak discrimination rahegi

[@nirajkumarpriyadarshi1913]

Vice versa.

[@manishkumarsingh3857]

Jab tak discrimination rahegi tab tak reservation rahegi.

[@vrajamin7157]

I am S.C and I totally support this decision.
.
.
We Indians can lead world only if we rise above our caste and religion..🇮🇳🇮🇳💪

[@shivamshrotriy7284]

Today i am pretty much cleared regarding the Supreme Court of India. Still there is a decision of 3:2 it's a shame to those judges who are so called highly qualified and intelligent and yet still those great minds think that people are not eligible for reservation on Economic basis.

[@suryanshdwivedi1024]

Agreed

[@chandansingh1144]

Right..

[@PRAJNACONSCIOUSNESS]

Right

[@SandeepMeena79]

Minimum income criteria should be 4 lakh instead of 8 lakh.

[@KRK0109]

Jay ho supreme court ki Jay 🙏🙏

[@muskanpol6768]

After 75 yrs of independence all types of reservation should be prohibited..... And give importance to the merit

[@nikhilkumargoyal8386]

A step towards good move well done NDA govt👍

[@arunji2837]

#remove caste based reservation 🙏🙏

[@shubhamgoel6181]

Great Decision of Supreme court ♥️

[@rohangupta1539]

This is a good move that benefits only weaker people which is beneficial for the poor people

[@WAAHA]

In EWS more rich people take fake income documents saying I am poor economically weak section.

[@sayanhazra088]

3:2
2=reserved quota judges

[@maheshwarkotwal2768]

👌

[@nirajkumarpriyadarshi1913]

What about 3 ?

[@punamkanwar909]

Great 👌 decision supreme court

[@rakshanalam242]

Great decision

[@joy9715hgnis]

Great decision ❤️

[@gk4652]

Me too great

[@enjoythemoment2.o396]

Great

[@soumyarana8258]

This is what I recommend to my political science teacher in ch 3 of class 11 political theory..

[@subhasishsahooOdisha]

A wrong decision by holding economic reservations against caste reservation. SC should revist the constitution and understand the minds of constitutional makers

[@bulbul5938]

EWS मतलब economically weaker sections, SC/St/OBC वाले क्यों नही EWS का रिजर्वेशन ले सकता है,ये articles 16 का violation है, जाति के नाम पर भेद भाव हो रहा है

[@sangeetamurmu5383]

8 lakh per annum Wale gareeb hai to fir ST,SC,OBC waalo ki gareebi 2.5 lakh annual aate hi khatam kaise ho jaati hai

[@hskskneksms3506]

It's not good for general category.... Because u r now fighting for 40% seat which is very less.....

[@rakshanalam242]

Ews is for general category

[@Varun32924]

EWS reservations should be 20%

[@moonwalker2324]

Thank you sir for explaining the debate with such clarity and depth.

[@Shubham_472]

I am curious to know the reasoning of those 2 judges. Economic condition should be the criteria not the cast.

[@nav2787]

I think you are more intelligent than BR Ambedkar

[@debarpandeysarkar2651]

Then remove caste system..

[@pwnweb5734]

Proud og my india and govt. to bring this up

[@StudytoSuccessvishal]

good decision by supreme court

[@ujjwalpaatwal2774]

kya hua decision?

[@vakudibeardefender3953]

The EWS reservation is discriminatory against SC & ST community by avoid them from it.

[@muthallibshaik8676]

I'm EWS. This is the best decision ever made by a government. Kudos to Modi👏🏻🙌

[@MohitYadav-th7fz]

Good Decision by Supreme court 🔥

[@zindagieksafar6552]

Economic weaker section should cover all weaker section irrespective of castes.

[@CBN154]

It actually covers.

[@Dhksksjjsjjs]

@@CBN154 nope

[@manojsharmaadvocate2480]

SC st OBC ka bhi reservation ko khatam karke inme bhi only weaker section ko reservation dena chshye

[@Fact_teller706]

Now all rich businessmen will apply for EWS certificate showing fake income and enjoy the benefits ... Ek kadam past ki aur

[@Railwaysoldier]

Residential land eligibility ko hataya gya h ya nhi must tell sir

[@rajeshkumar95]

ST, SC reservation must be based on economic conditions not on caste. It will uplift the backward family.

[@ajrapidclasses3308]

Great verdict of Supreme Court

[@yogeshsharma-yt6ro]

Option:D

[@tomar8872]

Now 40percent fight for all 😑😑

[@vishnupriya3695]

Sir, can you please make a video on Employees Pension Scheme 1995 and it's 2014 amendment.??

[@mavinash-gx1xj]

The only suffering r the general category candidate not any caste.

[@vinodtripathi9724]

बहुत बढ़िया विश्लेषण

[@Mr.Pandey28]

Reservation should be given based on their income and economic background !!😤😤😤😤

[@NSG2810]

Great decision by the supreme court.

[@Aditya_sharan_singh]

आरक्षण को बंद कर देना चाहिए, चयन सिर्फ योग्यता के आधार पर होना चाहिए |
और जो आर्थिक और समाजिक तौर पर पिछड़े है उन्हे मुफ्त कोचिंग जैसी सुविधा देकर योग्य बनाऐ जाना चाहिए |
चयन का आधार सिर्फ योग्यता होनी चाहिए |

[@milindvaidya433]

Private education ko band karni hogi, education must free

[@shaktishivanandadas]

Give 100% reservation
Why 50 ,60,70, ???

[@intelligentinvestor8882]

Reservation should be banned

[@ShivamSingh-se1wi]

I guess not now

[@jatin....7417]

Caste should be abolished ,,

[@saurabhpachouri3942]

Other 2 judge are hypocrates

[@rahul_rajput42]

5 yr age relaxation for ews candidate

[@sudhanshukumarsharma4143]

Ans D

[@dhirubhaiambani3652]

If government provide equal opportunity then there is no need of reservation

[@gurvindersandhu2921]

60-65k per month/8 lakh yearly income are under poor or ews...
Like wise sc/St 1lakh year ....are poor...
This is not vaild perimeter to define poor or ews....

[@Studytantra24]

Gr8 decision supereme court ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@dhritimankakati9483]

Very good. In fact it needs to be introduced to every other reservation section, mutually exclusively.

[@gobindapradhan3048]

We need age relaxation,also need implementation should be all the state

[@AgFAIZANAHMADBhat]

Plz tell wether the EWS Criteria
Will be changed or not ???

[@MyMarketMyDecision]

जब वोटिंग ही करवानी है तो जनता से वोटिंग करवा लो

[@milindvaidya433]

50 % limit of reservation previously judgment said is abolished now obc ,SC, ST have opportunity to demand 75% reservation.

[@sanidhyadubey1495]

Sir kya residential eligibility criteria ko hataya gaya hai ?

[@beindependent9098]

Modi g hai to mumkin hai ❤

[@PPAL-j8v]

Great decision.....

[@ppiyushmishraa]

Reservation on caste basis has destroyed the very core of government bodies because ineligible are in higher posts

[@ananthram]

Ews is best scheme for economically weaker people but still the governments are taking more money while attempting exams that must be reduced

[@akss7340]

we want age relaxtation

[@As-cp9qd]

Very good decision of the sc 😍😍

[@DevilKinngg]

I think all the 49.5% reservation of India should be revoked because those reservation are based on caste.

[@princechoudhary5772]

Middle class General families suffer the most...

[@fundugaluboy7754]

Finally general categories get reservation . It is fullfill for us.

[@achievers7061]

Reservation policy should be revisited n reexamined.

[@GoodBoy-dh2cx]

Yearly earning should be reduced to 4 lakh per year

[@worldaffair1450]

Then reduced obc earning as well

[@sidy6526]

Yes

[@abhishekdubey5241]

India is not developing coz low emplyment it just due to deployed lower educated person at top position that they never deserve same on sc

[@wakilkumar1356]

10%/18% general cast...

[@jitendrakumararya1163]

good decision by court

[@demon12899]

Diminish all kind of reservation. A country should run on meritocracy.

[@aspirant_kashis]

Great decision 💯💯💯

[@checkmateedits9172]

8 lakh main to sab AA gye 😂😂

[@subodhgautam649]

EWS is fine sir...but its my humble request to govt that please do not implement EWS in surgery courses.

[@mehulrawal9438]

Very good decision.....Abhi baaki reservation me bhi changes hona chahie ..Reservation Caste k hisab se nhi .Gareebi k hisab se hona chahiye

[@naman6491]

Ban Reservation. Cuz of that already those who have talent suffers and education decorates.

[@Varun32924]

Remove caste based discrimination too

[@Shub3]

thank you for season sir

[@bikramkesharisahoo5464]

Wo jo residential land criteria omit hone wala tha, uska kya?