Noj is one of my all time favourites history channels. Remember when he first started focusing on Societ History before you started this series. And mentioned you as a reference point when it comes to polemical/cross referencing over bad history youtubers
You should do an episode with/ on bad empanada, I really would love a deep dive into his research process or a scholarly dismantlement of his sources if that is more appropriate
1:25:30 tikhistory does have an undergraduate degree in history. I would assume that means that he was ‘taught that method’. He has a series of videos on historiography in which he lays out in excruciating detail his qualms with the modern historical method and presents his own methodology through which he analyses history (I can’t be bothered to tell you what differences he makes because firstly I’m not a historian and I myself don’t know the academic standard and secondly it’s a lengthy video) I would assume that he perhaps makes some of his mistakes as a consequence of his fringe perspective on historical analysis and methodology and historiography.
If you watch the video, it's not arguing that there was a "Narodnik Lenin", but saying that there were other types of socialists in Russia in addition to Marxism, which all had an impact on Lenin's thinking growing up.
@@jsmedia-ww6gb Wait did I misremember??? I though he argues that Lenin never left the ideas he had from when he was a Narodnik. Arguing that he was more of a Narodnik then a Marxist.
@Ma_ksi Quote from the video: " I am not personally taking the position that Lenin wasn't a Marxist. Rather this video is to investigate why people accuse him of such, and especially to explore the other writings which could have influenced Lenin's thinking while growing up, in addition to Marx. Being inspired by other sources, or having certain beliefs prior to Marxism, don't disqualify you from being a Marxist ipso facto."
@Ma_ksi Nah at no point does he say Lenin was a Narodnik, just that he grew up in that milieu. It's like pointing out that Marx read Hegel and was inspired by him.
Noj is one of my all time favourites history channels. Remember when he first started focusing on Societ History before you started this series. And mentioned you as a reference point when it comes to polemical/cross referencing over bad history youtubers
You should do an episode with/ on bad empanada, I really would love a deep dive into his research process or a scholarly dismantlement of his sources if that is more appropriate
I would like to see that.
His main channel generally has excellent research, but I have called out one of his videos for errors.
ua-cam.com/video/wwemi8qoGzo/v-deo.html
You might like this.
ua-cam.com/video/wwemi8qoGzo/v-deo.html
Bro stop reading my mind
I'm glad you're a fan.
I don't have 2 hours to watch this today, and probably won't for many weeks. Please take this like as thanks for putting the answer in the thumbnail.
You're welcome.
Goat discussing Goat
1:25:30 tikhistory does have an undergraduate degree in history. I would assume that means that he was ‘taught that method’. He has a series of videos on historiography in which he lays out in excruciating detail his qualms with the modern historical method and presents his own methodology through which he analyses history (I can’t be bothered to tell you what differences he makes because firstly I’m not a historian and I myself don’t know the academic standard and secondly it’s a lengthy video) I would assume that he perhaps makes some of his mistakes as a consequence of his fringe perspective on historical analysis and methodology and historiography.
Yes very definitely. I may critique those historiography videos of his in the future. I've watched them all
I appreciate this discussion, I really enjoy both these channels :)
Thank you!
The videos after the Narodnik Lenin one, yes
If you watch the video, it's not arguing that there was a "Narodnik Lenin", but saying that there were other types of socialists in Russia in addition to Marxism, which all had an impact on Lenin's thinking growing up.
@@jsmedia-ww6gb Wait did I misremember??? I though he argues that Lenin never left the ideas he had from when he was a Narodnik. Arguing that he was more of a Narodnik then a Marxist.
I dont think he said "lenin is more a narodnik than a marxist" but that lenin retained some narodnik ideas after identifying as marxist
@Ma_ksi Quote from the video: " I am not personally taking the position that Lenin wasn't a Marxist. Rather this video is to investigate why people accuse him of such, and especially to explore the other writings which could have influenced Lenin's thinking while growing up, in addition to Marx. Being inspired by other sources, or having certain beliefs prior to Marxism, don't disqualify you from being a Marxist ipso facto."
@Ma_ksi Nah at no point does he say Lenin was a Narodnik, just that he grew up in that milieu. It's like pointing out that Marx read Hegel and was inspired by him.