Hi Jeremy, nice review as usual. Some comments: 1) I completely agree with you about sight impaired musicians. One of my piano teachers was a very talented blind lady and I hate it when a keyboard or a piano doesn’t have physical controls so that a sight impaired person can use it, especially since so many visually impaired persons are musically active. 2) As for the lack of cables in the box, I cannot agree with you. I have an iPad and ages ago, I bought the Lightning camera connection kit, which I have been using since to connect all my keyboards to my iPad. It is the same for Android devices: simply buy an USB to USB C or to Micro USB adapter, and you’ll be able to connect all your keyboards to your Android phone or tablet. 3) As for saving your settings, I think you can do that precisely on a phone or tablet with the Chordana Play Piano app. That said, the PX-S1000 is probably not the best suited instrument for Trinity keyboard exams. The CT-X3000 would probably be better, because you can store 128 settings and you have an “Examination” category for tones and rhythms, with a “digest” of all tones and rhythms commonly used during keyboard examinations. Could you maybe make a video about which keyboard is best suited for Trinity exams, also depending on which study level you’re in? This would be great. Will you make a video with the Chordana Play Piano app and how to use it with the PX-S1000 and PX-S3000? This would be more than welcome. Cheers, Vinciane.
For Android, USB B to USB C / micro USB is not available in shops. For iOS is different, the apple fanboys are used to having to spend for every little accessory, dongle & cable to work with their devices. In the real world, there is very little practical use for USB B to USB C cables other than for the Chordona. I couldn't find the ability to save on the Chordana app for the PX-S1000. Trinity has 2 different exams for keys. One is ELECTRONICE KEYBOARD, which will need CTX. For Trinity POP & ROCK keyboard, you will need all 88 keys from Grade 2. They are 2 completely different syllabus.
vbdx66 I bought a Casio CDP-S350 for my sister. I bought cables on line. My brother has an iPad with lightening connector. Chordana for Piano app works. My sister has an older iPad with 30 pin connector, Chordana for Piano app is not supported. I wrote twice to CASIO concerning this. I hope Casio develops software to support a 30 pin connector iPad to keyboard, so users with old iPads can use the Chordana for Piano application.
@@JeremySee Hi Jeremy, Reason 10 Maybe solved by 2 pieces of cable connection. First part on mobile device side is common OTG kabel reduction from microUSB B (Male)/ or USB-C (Male) to USB A (Female !!!!) and second part on piano side is typical printer cable USB A (Male) to USB B (Male).
@@JeremySee Jeremy See Hi Jeremy, I am a fan of your pretty reviews, Thank you for them. For Reason 10: Maybe solved by 2 pieces of cable connection. First part on mobile device side is OTG kabel short reduction (can be as accessories in pack of device) from microUSB B (Male)/USB-C (Male) (by type of mobile phone or tablet) to USB A (Female !!!) and second part on piano side is typical printer cable USB A (Male) to USB B (Male).
I just received my Casio Privia PX-S1000 keyboard and I love it. I have noticed some of the things that you have mentioned and I agree with you. Although most aren't an issue with me as I will never play on stage and am not an accomplished pianist. I like how thorough you were in addressing the issues that you covered. And that you didnt totally beat up on this awesome instrument. You gave the opposite opinion as well as the complaints on some issues, very fair and quite informative. Im a fan!😊🎶⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
(Edited) Thanks Jeremy. 4:14 Actually I finally got to try both the PX S1000 and the Yamaha CP 88 yesterday. Unfortunately, The Casio was mounted highest in a 3 tier set up, so I had to stand with no damper pedal! But even from that position, I actually liked the feel of the Casio action better, and I too like a grand piano touch! I've been playing keyboards since the '70's. We have to remember that this Casio at $599 is a MIRACLE. (Clearly the guys who displayed it in the store don't know that.) Lightweight, 6 AA battery capability, built in (though lame) speakers, a good look for the living room, it's almost like you should buy one just to have it around! I do hope that a number of the issues you mention are remedied in the 3000, I anxiously wait for that review. I would want more sounds on the board, and it might be worth the extra couple of hundred bucks. Let's remember, the Yamaha CP 88 was either $2499 or $2699! Like everything else, you have to have BOTH! Q: For a true pianist who plays grands as I do, but still likes some portability, which Kawai do you like the best? Are the newest ones an improvement?
Semi weighted action is usually a spring based action and this piano is not a spring based action. Dual sensors would limited repeated notes and this would be similar to an upright piano. Grand pianos are faster as gravity resets the action quickly and allows u to play repeated notes faster. This is what the third sensor would give you. Nothing wrong with dual sensor, upright pianos are not bad!
So I actually bought this a week ago. My reasons: - it is really light and compact, which is great for my limited space. All other competitors are much bulkier - I liked the keybed action, for me who has dabbled a bit with MIDI keyboards I like that it is not too heavy weighted. It feels a good compromise. Personally I preferred it to the Yamaha p125 or the Roland fp30 - I felt that the piano sounds were a bit better than the Yamaha p 125. At least I liked them more at first test in the music store. - the keys aren’t too noisy. What I don’t like: - the keys have rather sharp edges at the front. This is not a nice feel especially when you play larger intervals and kind of touch the edges. At first I thought I’d return the piano immediately, now I got used to that a bit. I’ll probably keep it and polish the edges a little bit with fine grain sanding paper, but actually this shouldn’t happen at this price range. - the whole usability is rather poor, what with no display at all and all those function keys. I’m glad I watched this video again and got to know about the auto resume setting! It should be on by default! Conclusion: I think it is a solid practice piano for relative beginners like me. It plays well, the main sounds are good (i usually stay at the main grand piano sound anyways), and it is the most compact piano I’ve seen, which is important for me. If you want to gig and play in bands, i don’t think this is the best choice.
Thanks for your honest, more unbiased, review. Not many do this. Looks like in the entry-level segment, the Roland FP-30 is still number 1, and 100 usd less.
both casio are made to be use with the casio app using bluetooth, so you do end up with a "monitor" if you want since you can also choose the sound using the app
I have no use for Blue Tooth MIDI because there is a substantial lag time. Regarding a light piano action, Horwitz, Glen Gould, etc. preferred a light piano action. The Casio PX-S3000 allows Recording audio directly onto a USB thumb drive which you can the stick into your computer. PX-S3000 has many Rhythms.
How's the key action between white and black keys? According to some reviews, the weight of the black keys are so different from white keys that it makes this piano harder to play than other instruments.
Mikko: I'm sure there is a perceptible difference, but reading between the lines, several reviewers are saying that this is only a mild issue in the general scheme of things. We should surmise that not everybody agrees with Piano Forever's strong criticism of the PX-S1000/PxS3000. I have to admit though, that on a previous Casio model I found the black notes harder to play than I had expected. One excellent reviewer said that he prefers the Casio action to the [GHS] action supplied on the Yamaha P-125. So we need to keep things in perspective, since action is partly subjective.
Wait, can you only connect to the Chordana mobile app through USB, not Bluetooth? How weird is that! What if I want to connect the piano to my DAW via USB-MIDI and want to control the piano through the Chordana app while recording MIDI to my DAW? Is this even possible (e.g. through a USB hub or similar)?
Hello Jeremy, thank you for your videos. I feel a bit in love with this one and am grounded after the review. If u please give me your opinion. Am between Casio PX-S1000 and Kawai ES110. Can you make a review ? or maybe share with me your opinion ? i would be really greatful. Thanks
Do you reckon the px s1000 offers a better value for the price when compared with the px 160 ? I’m a beginner willing to get one of those... witch one I should buy?
Hi Jeremy, Great review as always. I have Casio PX300. When PX-S1000 and PX-S3000 were announced, I had my eyes on PX-S3000 from the start. Including the price range, these 2 models may be considered separate class of digital piano. But, will you be reviewing PX-S3000 in the future? Are these deficiencies in 1000 model resolved in 3000 model, at least some? I saw somewhere that S3000 model does have display screen, for instance. Or most of what you said here still true for 3000 model? Thanks, -Yoshi
I know this is a few years old but I wanted to comment to say "thanks" for taking the time to do these videos! I'm hoping to get back into piano but don't have room for a standard type so I'm looking at a digital model. Your videos have been super helpful! I was almost ready to pull the trigger on this model because I can get a slightly used one for a good price. Having said that I watched all three videos on this model and have to say there are a few things that are quite disappointing that you mention here, especially not having the ability to store your settings, only providing a standard metronome and also the usb cable you mention. Now I'm not so sure about this piano. :-) Thanks again! I will continue checking out your reviews. :-)
Jeremy I appreciate you!! I returned a Novation Impulse 61; for the Casio privia xps1000 for 2 main reasons. 1. I travel a lot and for the learning feature it offers, so to hear finding the USB is a pain and it's not good for gigs was very disappointing. What should I do; as the casio is in hold for me?
Hi Jeremy, congratulations for your comment, I liked very much. I would like to buy a piano, but I'm between casio privia px-s1000 and casio privia px160... which would be better to play classical and gospel music please?
Jeremy this is a starter piano, from what I can see. The pricing, and "features" all point this way. NO WAY would I consider this piano for a gig. You nailed all the problems. The "metronome issue", well you are totally correct. Now the S3000, that is another matter, and I am awaiting to see what you think. As a soloist, I am looking for every edge and "stage comfort", the S1000 does not even enter my consideration.
Regarding what is missing that I consider ESSENTIAL to ANY K/B or DP with pretentions to be gigged ( from all manufacturers!) I have only 3 words to add ' DIN MIDI SOCKETS' !!!!! ( I believe that even the PX-s 3000 lacks this ) USB midi is about as much use as a chocolate Fireguard for driving a Roland BK7M , or other Modules/ arranger /Synth Keyboards/ midi Bass pedals/Voice harmonisers etc,etc !!
Thanks for the great review on this keyboard. How can I improve the sound out. The sound from the headphone seems a bit weak. I have to keep it at max volume. Or do you recommend using an external amp. Does using line out vs headphone out increase the sound.
To each their own, but there's no way I would ever buy this one over the p125. There's a reason why the p series has been so successful all these years, and that is keeping it simple and effective. Casio is always trying to cram features into their pianos, but the integration is always disappointing...
Absolutely agree! If features are not easy to access, there is no value! Yamaha does this way better! Tried the Casios and Rolands:before - that made me decide for the P-125.
i bought this but i cant get any sound out of the audio out ports.Is there something you have to do to get sound?i connected ro my steroamp and i get nothing,
thanks! the pivot length is quite short. is it possible to easily play deep in the black keys, close to the pivot point? for example while playing a Gbmaj7 chord with one hand. on my roland bk-5 this is terrible....
I actually started out considering Korg C1 Air for the touch and speakers. After watching your videos, my interest in Korg is shaken. I am not looking for portability. Which model would be better for piano practice?
So I was glad to hear in your list that there were no earth-shaking failures by Casio. And it gives me great confidence that my pre-order of the PX-S3000 was a good decision. I can't wait until it starts shipping. Thank you so much for your experienced opinions.
just got a Casio PX S1000. I feel that when I press more quickly and strongly on certain keys, the sound just go exponential higher and changed, it happens only on certain keys and not on all the keys. Do you notice this issue or it's a damaged product of mine ?
Guess I am such a lucky person! In China, that midi to type c cable you mentioned is so easy and cheap to get online! For cheap, I am talking about price around 4 usd!!
I was considering this piano over the Yamaha P125, but I think i will pass just for the touch buttons. Touch buttons are the first thing to die and who knows how hard is to fix or replace them.
As i am just looking for a small lightweight digital piano to start learning piano, your videos are right on time! I was originally looking at the Yamaha P121 (73 keys are actually a bonus because of limited space), but last week at the music store I noticed the Casio. I also looked at the Roland FP30 shortly. The Casio keys feel a little weird at first because of the fake ivory surface, but I think one will get used to it. Regarding the key bed, they all feel a little different, but somewhat in the same quality range. Personal preference, I’d say. The Casio seemed to sound a little better to me, a little less “artificial” than the Yamaha. But I could only test with crappy headphones, so no final judgment yet. The Roland seems good, but is bigger than the Casio. At the moment I tend towards the casio just because it’s so slim and elegant. I only wish there was a 73 keys version, as 130cm might be too long for the space i I tend to put it... The points you mentioned here are all valid, but no real deal breaker to me.
Thanks for this series of videos. I have to decide between this model and the cdps350, I feel the extra features on the 350 compensate for it not being that professional.
Great video! I have one question. You mentioned that the key action feels light. Can't you adjust that with the 5 key sensitivity option? I was told you would feel the action heavier if you change the key sensitivity from "medium" to "hard" or "harder" in the settings. I don't have this piano yet. But since you have it. Can you try it out or correct me if I'm wrong? I hope you answer this. Great reviews as always!
@@JeremySee That makes sense. I recently bought a Roland fp10 but I'm considering returning it to purchase this Casio pxs1000 since I've been told it's better. But it's really important for me that the keys and action feel closer to an acoustic piano for a future transition. I trust your opinion and I hope you can help me, do you think I should get this Casio or stay with the Roland? Thank you for your help!
Thanks Jeremy. I've watched a number of your reviews and found them very useful. As a beginner I can live with most of these shortcomings. You mentioned the ES110 keyboard being better and this is the only dp in this price range that I have shortlisted. But due to the lack of android support on the Kawai I think my first choice will be the S1000. I have not tried this keyboard yet and hope that it doesn't fall too far short of the Kawai otherwise I will have a dilemma on my hands.
As i said in another thread i bought a px-s1000 today. Your criticism in this video is valid but I must say for my needs the price and the way it works is close to unbeliviable. This wasnt possible just a few years ago. I have tried numerous different digital pianos recently to be sure what to buy and i have no other so good in this price range. -:)
I just ordered the 3000 but now I'm worried that I'm not going to like the action after seeing your review. It appears as though the keys bounce back like the ones on my friend's lower-end Privia 150. Is there another keyboard with better weighted keys but still easy to carry (around 25 lbs/12 kgs)?
Hi Koay, why not D1 for you?, are you tried the Roland FP90, Yamaha P515 and Kawai ES7/8, what about these key actions?, and what about this new Casio key action compared with the mentioned above?... Thanks!.
The point with this piano is beeing a good gigging /study piano at an affordable price.For those who want the ''best'' piano action/piano sound /etc,there are options.
Anyway,your comment about the keybed was what I had in mind it would be.There must be some compromise at this dimension.I have the Px 5 S and the keybed is somehow noisiy.It seems that they fixed this with the new generation.Anyway I have also an old Technics sx p 30 that has a unique acoustic(seems that it was a Steinway) and an electric ,sort of FM ,but different that i could not find on another piano or reproduce on a synth.I would put this in the cathegory of Nord in terms of quality sound.It's got one acoustic and two electric pianos.No editing needed.Keybed is just perfect for me and all friends who played it were amazed.
The USB b to USB c cable is nearly impossible to find. What you want is a OTG (On The Go) cable that is USB c to USB a female. That way you can plug a standard USB b (printer) cable into it.
Jeremy, over the set of three videos I think you have covered the instrument very well with a fair and impartial assessment. As you say, no instrument will be perfect but at the price I think this has no competition (just now), which I gather is your opinion also. Casio provided you with the 1000 so I guess it was not appropriate to compare it with the 3000 which gives a lot more (including that display which the 1000 lacks) for a very small price difference.
Thank you for testing this out and such an honest review. That has really made me reconsider which piano i want to go for. I am a beginner and so far i have played only on a semi weighted Alesis/M-Audio midi keyboard with pianoteq. Haven't tried a real piano yet but i would like to in future. What would be a good digital piano to invest in right now? My main concern is the action and from your review it feels like Roland's FP-30 action might be better than casio's. The sound for me is not as important since i can always use pianoteq for more serious things. Would love some insight from you. And btw great review as always! Very informative!
I had a Privia. I hate all Privia products due to the sharp buttons and shitty ldc screens. This keyboard has the fancy buttons, so what? Blue tooth, people are complaining about the delay time in switching. I have had a Casio CDP-200R, CDP-235R, and just gave a gift to my sister a Casio CDP-S350. Wires are a drag, but the latent delay switching is quick. Cables? Have to buy on line two separate cable to put together to connect to an iPad. I have had a number of other keyboards, such as the Kawai ES8, but they cost too much. I am sticking with Casio CDP-S350 and similar models due to price and functions. I hope CASIO continues to try to hold down their prices. I hate keyboards with too heavy a feel. I like a full 88 note piano keyboard. I do not like cheap piece of plastic, like a toy, 61 note keyboard. Keyboards should be indestructible too. My grandnephew could be rough on it and not break it when he plays Twinkle Twinkle. Also, be careful not to ruin the instrument spilling liquids on it. Though not perfect, it is good enough at the price, the CDP-S350. With an adapter, I hooked up the 1/8” output to 1/4” and plug it into a keyboard amp. Yeah, it is not stereo, so what, another compromise. 12” speaker with a tweeter horn for the highs and lots of inputs: Bass, guitar, keyboard, microphones. That’s right, put the whole band through it at low volume, in a living room playing with family members and friends.
*What could be improved?* 1. Sound engine. The AiR sound engine has been around since 2012 on the PX-5S and stays there throughout many different Privia/Celviano models since then. Casio should inherit the Grand Hybrid sound engine to their smaller models, then combining them with AiX. 2. Built-in speakers. Instead of just 8W + 8W, the PX-S series should have been fitted with more powerful speaker system inside its slim compact design, preferably 15W or 10W 3. Front panel (PX-S3000 only). It's disappointing to see the touchscreen featured in previous generation has been removed. Those LED touch buttons are decent, but combining them with a color touchscreen display would be even better
For the px 1000 it would be a great ideea to layer the piano sound from the keyboard with a good virtual one.It could lead to unbelievable results in a portable package.Ravensrcroft or the Hammersmith or ...whatvere suits ones taste.
I love that the keys are light, after all this isn’t just for piano sounds right? Seems to me this is the perfect partner for an iPad. Just paired up with korg module!
7:15 Casio couldn’t add oleophobic property onto the touchscreen, because the touchscreen is of plastic/perspex or polycarbonate alike material, not glass/ceramic-like material as on our smartphones/watches.
Thank you so much for the review!! I have to agree with your review. I was strongly and immediately disapointed when I played the PX S1000 for the first time. I’m really not a fan of the keyboard. As a classical pianist, the first thing i look for is an almost realistic imitation of a grand piano keyboard (or at least an acoustic keyboard). The rest is all a bonus. You did mention quickly the short pivot problem in your video...But its actually more than a simple « different feeling ». It personnaly bothers me. You cant play properly the « harder » chords. The volume of the speakers is also so poor. The quality is better through headphones, but the volume remains low and poor. You somehow didn’t mention it. I think that could be your #11 lol Overall, i think the piano is a good deal for a beginner player or a beat maker. Not intermediate or advanced player. Definitely not for professionnal gigs.
Jeremy, how can I make the sound of my PX-S1000 BETTER when outputted in an external speakers? 1. When connecting to a basic speaker system and assuming I wanted to make it sound 'Stereo', do I need to use 2 cables to insert into the both LINE OUTs (Left channel and Right Channel) of the piano, or is it enough to just insert 1 cable to the Left Channel Mono? 2. Do I need to purchase a dedicated keyboard amp?
Yes, 2 different cables to 2 different left and right speakers if you want true stereo. The 2 speakers must also be sufficiently far apart. A good keyboard amp has the necessary dynamic range for the lowest to the highest notes.
Jeremy See Jeremy, thanks for this info. The manual only indicated that a single cable when inserted into the Left Channel (Mono) already mix both channels, assuming that it is only connected to a single speaker. Is that true?
Your reviews are great, the best. Based on your review of the Casio PX-S1000 I decided to buy it over the Yamaha P-125... until you got to the cable issue. That is a stunning defect to me. I hate buying electronics that immediately require me to go search for dongles and adapters. If Casio were to let you know where the cable can be purchased and you passed that info along to your subscribers that would be fantastic. By the way, I'm in the USA.
Yes, white is always a good option for hiding fingerprints and scratches and it's very cheerful and elegant. This model is also available in red. Looks stunning! As Jeremy says, the action might disappoint classical players, but as he also briefly mentioned, a softer action can be an advantage too in certain types of performance, and that's including on stage. Speaking of stage use, it is hard to overstress the importance of a lightweight instrument if you do lots of short gigs. None of us is getting any younger. Jeremy mentions the CP88 as being a weight culprit. Actually it's only 18kg, which means it's not the heaviest. Try carrying a Roland RD2000 (21.5kg) or the Yamaha P-515 (22kg) which is supposed to be a portable piano! I agree entirely about the visually challenged bit. And what about playing under strong light? Often we can't see those small lights on our pianos during outdoor performances. And yes, all these pianos priced at US $500+ should have a basic screen. IMO manufacturers have omitted them to punish us for not purchasing more expensive models. But Alesis has broken the trend with its Recital Pro, so I think things will improve. Despite its extra weight, I believe the Korg D1 is the best option for a cheap gigging piano. A gigging piano doesn't really need built-in speakers, but it needs a built-in screen, good connectors, and a robust build if at all possible.
@@JeremySee I know you sometimes express dismay at the number of views of certain videos. Maybe you're only joking about that, but if you're serious about increasing the hits and your following, I suggest using more glamorous thumbnails. I geddit - you like to keep things upbeat and fun, but choosing pianos seems to bring out the conservative aspect of people. It's sad if they don't get to enjoy your quality reviews because they resisted clicking on a fun but OTT thumb nail. I think you should even post your face in each thumbnail. Makes for consistency and building trust.
Thanks for doing the repeated note test. It would be briliant if more reviewers would test this for every keyboard.
Hi Jeremy, nice review as usual. Some comments:
1) I completely agree with you about sight impaired musicians. One of my piano teachers was a very talented blind lady and I hate it when a keyboard or a piano doesn’t have physical controls so that a sight impaired person can use it, especially since so many visually impaired persons are musically active.
2) As for the lack of cables in the box, I cannot agree with you. I have an iPad and ages ago, I bought the Lightning camera connection kit, which I have been using since to connect all my keyboards to my iPad. It is the same for Android devices: simply buy an USB to USB C or to Micro USB adapter, and you’ll be able to connect all your keyboards to your Android phone or tablet.
3) As for saving your settings, I think you can do that precisely on a phone or tablet with the Chordana Play Piano app. That said, the PX-S1000 is probably not the best suited instrument for Trinity keyboard exams.
The CT-X3000 would probably be better, because you can store 128 settings and you have an “Examination” category for tones and rhythms, with a “digest” of all tones and rhythms commonly used during keyboard examinations.
Could you maybe make a video about which keyboard is best suited for Trinity exams, also depending on which study level you’re in? This would be great.
Will you make a video with the Chordana Play Piano app and how to use it with the PX-S1000 and PX-S3000? This would be more than welcome.
Cheers, Vinciane.
For Android, USB B to USB C / micro USB is not available in shops. For iOS is different, the apple fanboys are used to having to spend for every little accessory, dongle & cable to work with their devices. In the real world, there is very little practical use for USB B to USB C cables other than for the Chordona.
I couldn't find the ability to save on the Chordana app for the PX-S1000. Trinity has 2 different exams for keys. One is ELECTRONICE KEYBOARD, which will need CTX. For Trinity POP & ROCK keyboard, you will need all 88 keys from Grade 2. They are 2 completely different syllabus.
vbdx66 I bought a Casio CDP-S350 for my sister. I bought cables on line. My brother has an iPad with lightening connector. Chordana for Piano app works. My sister has an older iPad with 30 pin connector, Chordana for Piano app is not supported. I wrote twice to CASIO concerning this. I hope Casio develops software to support a 30 pin connector iPad to keyboard, so users with old iPads can use the Chordana for Piano application.
@@JeremySee Hi Jeremy, Reason 10 Maybe solved by 2 pieces of cable connection. First part on mobile device side is common OTG kabel reduction from microUSB B (Male)/ or USB-C (Male) to USB A (Female !!!!) and second part on piano side is typical printer cable USB A (Male) to USB B (Male).
@@JeremySee Jeremy See Hi Jeremy, I am a fan of your pretty reviews, Thank you for them. For Reason 10: Maybe solved by 2 pieces of cable connection. First part on mobile device side is OTG kabel short reduction (can be as accessories in pack of device) from microUSB B (Male)/USB-C (Male) (by type of mobile phone or tablet) to USB A (Female !!!) and second part on piano side is typical printer cable USB A (Male) to USB B (Male).
I just received my Casio Privia PX-S1000 keyboard and I love it. I have noticed some of the things that you have mentioned and I agree with you. Although most aren't an issue with me as I will never play on stage and am not an accomplished pianist. I like how thorough you were in addressing the issues that you covered. And that you didnt totally beat up on this awesome instrument. You gave the opposite opinion as well as the complaints on some issues, very fair and quite informative. Im a fan!😊🎶⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Could you do a comprehensive comparison of famous portable pianos, e.g., Yamaha P series, Roland FP series and Kawaii ES series?
(Edited) Thanks Jeremy. 4:14 Actually I finally got to try both the PX S1000 and the Yamaha CP 88 yesterday. Unfortunately, The Casio was mounted highest in a 3 tier set up, so I had to stand with no damper pedal! But even from that position, I actually liked the feel of the Casio action better, and I too like a grand piano touch!
I've been playing keyboards since the '70's. We have to remember that this Casio at $599 is a MIRACLE. (Clearly the guys who displayed it in the store don't know that.) Lightweight, 6 AA battery capability, built in (though lame) speakers, a good look for the living room, it's almost like you should buy one just to have it around!
I do hope that a number of the issues you mention are remedied in the 3000, I anxiously wait for that review. I would want more sounds on the board, and it might be worth the extra couple of hundred bucks. Let's remember, the Yamaha CP 88 was either $2499 or $2699! Like everything else, you have to have BOTH!
Q: For a true pianist who plays grands as I do, but still likes some portability, which Kawai do you like the best? Are the newest ones an improvement?
Semi weighted action is usually a spring based action and this piano is not a spring based action. Dual sensors would limited repeated notes and this would be similar to an upright piano. Grand pianos are faster as gravity resets the action quickly and allows u to play repeated notes faster. This is what the third sensor would give you. Nothing wrong with dual sensor, upright pianos are not bad!
So I actually bought this a week ago. My reasons:
- it is really light and compact, which is great for my limited space. All other competitors are much bulkier
- I liked the keybed action, for me who has dabbled a bit with MIDI keyboards I like that it is not too heavy weighted. It feels a good compromise. Personally I preferred it to the Yamaha p125 or the Roland fp30
- I felt that the piano sounds were a bit better than the Yamaha p 125. At least I liked them more at first test in the music store.
- the keys aren’t too noisy.
What I don’t like:
- the keys have rather sharp edges at the front. This is not a nice feel especially when you play larger intervals and kind of touch the edges. At first I thought I’d return the piano immediately, now I got used to that a bit. I’ll probably keep it and polish the edges a little bit with fine grain sanding paper, but actually this shouldn’t happen at this price range.
- the whole usability is rather poor, what with no display at all and all those function keys. I’m glad I watched this video again and got to know about the auto resume setting! It should be on by default!
Conclusion: I think it is a solid practice piano for relative beginners like me. It plays well, the main sounds are good (i usually stay at the main grand piano sound anyways), and it is the most compact piano I’ve seen, which is important for me.
If you want to gig and play in bands, i don’t think this is the best choice.
A m6/9 I think Yamaha and Roland sounds a bit better and fuller than this
hey which piano should we consider for gigging and all?
Hello. Px-s1000 or cdp-s160? Which one you would buy? The old or new one?
Thanks for your honest, more unbiased, review. Not many do this. Looks like in the entry-level segment, the Roland FP-30 is still number 1, and 100 usd less.
Hank World you must mean the FP-10. The FP-30 is actually a $100 USD more.
both casio are made to be use with the casio app using bluetooth, so you do end up with a "monitor" if you want since you can also choose the sound using the app
I have no use for Blue Tooth MIDI because there is a substantial lag time. Regarding a light piano action, Horwitz, Glen Gould, etc. preferred a light piano action. The Casio PX-S3000 allows Recording audio directly onto a USB thumb drive which you can the stick into your computer. PX-S3000 has many Rhythms.
How's the key action between white and black keys? According to some reviews, the weight of the black keys are so different from white keys that it makes this piano harder to play than other instruments.
Mikko: I'm sure there is a perceptible difference, but reading between the lines, several reviewers are saying that this is only a mild issue in the general scheme of things. We should surmise that not everybody agrees with Piano Forever's strong criticism of the PX-S1000/PxS3000. I have to admit though, that on a previous Casio model I found the black notes harder to play than I had expected.
One excellent reviewer said that he prefers the Casio action to the [GHS] action supplied on the Yamaha P-125. So we need to keep things in perspective, since action is partly subjective.
Wait, can you only connect to the Chordana mobile app through USB, not Bluetooth? How weird is that! What if I want to connect the piano to my DAW via USB-MIDI and want to control the piano through the Chordana app while recording MIDI to my DAW? Is this even possible (e.g. through a USB hub or similar)?
hi, my concern when it comes to action and key weight, which one is better this pxs1000 or the yamaha p125?
Which one's better to buy, the CDP350 or PXS1000 ?
Hi man. One question: What would you rather: PX-S1000 or Korg LP-180?
How to use an audio interface to record songs to MacBook ? An explainer video on that would be great !
besides that I thing test just perfect
Hello Jeremy, thank you for your videos. I feel a bit in love with this one and am grounded after the review. If u please give me your opinion. Am between Casio PX-S1000 and Kawai ES110. Can you make a review ? or maybe share with me your opinion ? i would be really greatful. Thanks
Wouldn't be easier to use a regular USB printer cable with an OTG adapter?
Do you reckon the px s1000 offers a better value for the price when compared with the px 160 ? I’m a beginner willing to get one of those... witch one I should buy?
Hi Jeremy, Great review as always. I have Casio PX300. When PX-S1000 and PX-S3000 were announced, I had my eyes on PX-S3000 from the start. Including the price range, these 2 models may be considered separate class of digital piano. But, will you be reviewing PX-S3000 in the future? Are these deficiencies in 1000 model resolved in 3000 model, at least some? I saw somewhere that S3000 model does have display screen, for instance. Or most of what you said here still true for 3000 model? Thanks, -Yoshi
PX-S3000 does correct many of the deficiencies. Thanks for watching buddy.
I know this is a few years old but I wanted to comment to say "thanks" for taking the time to do these videos! I'm hoping to get back into piano but don't have room for a standard type so I'm looking at a digital model. Your videos have been super helpful! I was almost ready to pull the trigger on this model because I can get a slightly used one for a good price. Having said that I watched all three videos on this model and have to say there are a few things that are quite disappointing that you mention here, especially not having the ability to store your settings, only providing a standard metronome and also the usb cable you mention. Now I'm not so sure about this piano. :-) Thanks again! I will continue checking out your reviews. :-)
Jeremy I appreciate you!! I returned a Novation Impulse 61; for the Casio privia xps1000 for 2 main reasons. 1. I travel a lot and for the learning feature it offers, so to hear finding the USB is a pain and it's not good for gigs was very disappointing. What should I do; as the casio is in hold for me?
Hi Jeremy, congratulations for your comment, I liked very much. I would like to buy a piano, but I'm between casio privia px-s1000 and casio privia px160... which would be better to play classical and gospel music please?
The new keybed of PX-S1000 will be great for your classical and gospel playing.
Isn't key action of fp-30 from roland comparable to es 110?
Jeremy this is a starter piano, from what I can see. The pricing, and "features" all point this way. NO WAY would I consider this piano for a gig. You nailed all the problems. The "metronome issue", well you are totally correct. Now the S3000, that is another matter, and I am awaiting to see what you think. As a soloist, I am looking for every edge and "stage comfort", the S1000 does not even enter my consideration.
Regarding what is missing that I consider ESSENTIAL to ANY K/B or DP with pretentions to be gigged ( from all manufacturers!) I have only 3 words to add ' DIN MIDI SOCKETS' !!!!! ( I believe that even the PX-s 3000 lacks this ) USB midi is about as much use as a chocolate Fireguard for driving a Roland BK7M , or other Modules/ arranger /Synth Keyboards/ midi Bass pedals/Voice harmonisers etc,etc !!
Thanks for the great review on this keyboard. How can I improve the sound out. The sound from the headphone seems a bit weak. I have to keep it at max volume. Or do you recommend using an external amp. Does using line out vs headphone out increase the sound.
So whats your final vote: PX-S1000 or ES 110?
Sebastian Willing ES110 Imo
To each their own, but there's no way I would ever buy this one over the p125. There's a reason why the p series has been so successful all these years, and that is keeping it simple and effective. Casio is always trying to cram features into their pianos, but the integration is always disappointing...
Absolutely agree! If features are not easy to access, there is no value! Yamaha does this way better!
Tried the Casios and Rolands:before - that made me decide for the P-125.
i bought this but i cant get any sound out of the audio out ports.Is there something you have to do to get sound?i connected ro my steroamp and i get nothing,
Well said. I am thinking about getting the PX-3000 which fills in some of your suggestions tfor the PX-S1000.
Thanks, Jeremy, you have covered, in your 3 videos, the features that are important to me. You answered many of my questions.
Matt
thanks! the pivot length is quite short. is it possible to easily play deep in the black keys, close to the pivot point? for example while playing a Gbmaj7 chord with one hand. on my roland bk-5 this is terrible....
I didn't find it difficult to play F#maj7
I actually started out considering Korg C1 Air for the touch and speakers. After watching your videos, my interest in Korg is shaken. I am not looking for portability. Which model would be better for piano practice?
Sir, is privia's key action better or Yamaha p 125?
So I was glad to hear in your list that there were no earth-shaking failures by Casio. And it gives me great confidence that my pre-order of the PX-S3000 was a good decision. I can't wait until it starts shipping. Thank you so much for your experienced opinions.
Sir, I am just concerned with the piano sound and piano playing in a realistic manner. What could be better for me px 1000 or p 125 ?
Thank you very much for really honest and professional test and review , I am waiting for Px-3000 for gigs ( light, battery )
Great review!! The lack of Bluetooth MIDI is the deal breaker for me. I hope they include this in the next model. Until then, I’ll hold off on buying.
just got a Casio PX S1000. I feel that when I press more quickly and strongly on certain keys, the sound just go exponential higher and changed, it happens only on certain keys and not on all the keys. Do you notice this issue or it's a damaged product of mine ?
Guess I am such a lucky person! In China, that midi to type c cable you mentioned is so easy and cheap to get online! For cheap, I am talking about price around 4 usd!!
Nothing is perfect, and this video probes it!. Thanks for your review
I was considering this piano over the Yamaha P125, but I think i will pass just for the touch buttons. Touch buttons are the first thing to die and who knows how hard is to fix or replace them.
Do you think it might be safe to add an oleophobic coat yourself onto the gloss material?
I won't risk adding yourself
Hi
Yamaha P115 or casio px-s1000 for Beginner?
Ist the keyy of px-s1000 lighter?
I mean p125 oder pxs1000
I have $600, should I buy a Casio sp1000 or 600 Big Macs?
Between Yamaha P125, Roland FP-10 and CASIO PX-S1000, what would you choose?
Who would you ask me px s1000
As i am just looking for a small lightweight digital piano to start learning piano, your videos are right on time!
I was originally looking at the Yamaha P121 (73 keys are actually a bonus because of limited space), but last week at the music store I noticed the Casio. I also looked at the Roland FP30 shortly.
The Casio keys feel a little weird at first because of the fake ivory surface, but I think one will get used to it. Regarding the key bed, they all feel a little different, but somewhat in the same quality range. Personal preference, I’d say.
The Casio seemed to sound a little better to me, a little less “artificial” than the Yamaha. But I could only test with crappy headphones, so no final judgment yet.
The Roland seems good, but is bigger than the Casio.
At the moment I tend towards the casio just because it’s so slim and elegant. I only wish there was a 73 keys version, as 130cm might be too long for the space i I tend to put it...
The points you mentioned here are all valid, but no real deal breaker to me.
61 keys would be "great" for me.
Thanks for this series of videos. I have to decide between this model and the cdps350, I feel the extra features on the 350 compensate for it not being that professional.
Can you explain Korg kross2 vs Roland XPS 30
Great video! I have one question.
You mentioned that the key action feels light.
Can't you adjust that with the 5 key sensitivity option? I was told you would feel the action heavier if you change the key sensitivity from "medium" to "hard" or "harder" in the settings. I don't have this piano yet. But since you have it. Can you try it out or correct me if I'm wrong? I hope you answer this.
Great reviews as always!
Adjusting the sensitivity does not alter the physical weight of the keybed. Only adjusts the touch response curve.
@@JeremySee That makes sense. I recently bought a Roland fp10 but I'm considering returning it to purchase this Casio pxs1000 since I've been told it's better. But it's really important for me that the keys and action feel closer to an acoustic piano for a future transition.
I trust your opinion and I hope you can help me, do you think I should get this Casio or stay with the Roland?
Thank you for your help!
Thanks Jeremy. I've watched a number of your reviews and found them very useful. As a beginner I can live with most of these shortcomings. You mentioned the ES110 keyboard being better and this is the only dp in this price range that I have shortlisted. But due to the lack of android support on the Kawai I think my first choice will be the S1000. I have not tried this keyboard yet and hope that it doesn't fall too far short of the Kawai otherwise I will have a dilemma on my hands.
Hello sir, should i buy korg pa600 in 2019?...or should i look for some other models or brands? Plz reply
PA600 is 5 years old model. Look for others.
@@JeremySee thank you sir for your reply, sir can you please suggest any model in this range or any future launch?
Can I use wireless Bluetooth headphones with this?
Hi how about px-s1000 vs cdp-s350
Pls advice my first piano
Both are different. PX-S1000 don't have arranger functions. S350 is an arranger piano.
Jeremy See can you recommend for me ? Thank you in advance.
My question is does this digital piano Bluetooth out to your own Bluetooth speakers ???
Yes
No Bluetooth audio out. Impossible.
As i said in another thread i bought a px-s1000 today. Your criticism in this video is valid but I must say for my needs the price and the way it works is close to unbeliviable. This wasnt possible just a few years ago. I have tried numerous different digital pianos recently to be sure what to buy and i have no other so good in this price range. -:)
Congratulations on a good buy buddy.
@@JeremySee tx
hi jeremy, what is difference between a synthesizer and keyboard? thanks
Synthesizer creates sounds. Keyboard is anything with keys.
I just ordered the 3000 but now I'm worried that I'm not going to like the action after seeing your review. It appears as though the keys bounce back like the ones on my friend's lower-end Privia 150. Is there another keyboard with better weighted keys but still easy to carry (around 25 lbs/12 kgs)?
i dont like korg d1 action which he said is good. i prefer privia action. fp30 action also good
Hi Koay, why not D1 for you?, are you tried the Roland FP90, Yamaha P515 and Kawai ES7/8, what about these key actions?, and what about this new Casio key action compared with the mentioned above?... Thanks!.
The point with this piano is beeing a good gigging /study piano at an affordable price.For those who want the ''best'' piano action/piano sound /etc,there are options.
Anyway,your comment about the keybed was what I had in mind it would be.There must be some compromise at this dimension.I have the Px 5 S and the keybed is somehow noisiy.It seems that they fixed this with the new generation.Anyway I have also an old Technics sx p 30 that has a unique acoustic(seems that it was a Steinway) and an electric ,sort of FM ,but different that i could not find on another piano or reproduce on a synth.I would put this in the cathegory of Nord in terms of quality sound.It's got one acoustic and two electric pianos.No editing needed.Keybed is just perfect for me and all friends who played it were amazed.
Благодарю вас, было очень интересно все это узнать.
Thanks for the review, Jeremy! It can be a good reference and consideration before buying this stuff.
Wondering which digital piano in this price range has the best action
The USB b to USB c cable is nearly impossible to find. What you want is a OTG (On The Go) cable that is USB c to USB a female. That way you can plug a standard USB b (printer) cable into it.
Jeremy, over the set of three videos I think you have covered the instrument very well with a fair and impartial assessment. As you say, no instrument will be perfect but at the price I think this has no competition (just now), which I gather is your opinion also. Casio provided you with the 1000 so I guess it was not appropriate to compare it with the 3000 which gives a lot more (including that display which the 1000 lacks) for a very small price difference.
Thank you for testing this out and such an honest review. That has really made me reconsider which piano i want to go for. I am a beginner and so far i have played only on a semi weighted Alesis/M-Audio midi keyboard with pianoteq. Haven't tried a real piano yet but i would like to in future. What would be a good digital piano to invest in right now? My main concern is the action and from your review it feels like Roland's FP-30 action might be better than casio's. The sound for me is not as important since i can always use pianoteq for more serious things. Would love some insight from you.
And btw great review as always! Very informative!
Hi. Nice video. Love your ways of explaining what you like and what you dislike about the keyboards that you review.
Is the Keybed better than korg rh3 or roland pha4? Im a pianist and only care about the feel of the piano and the keys
The Casio keys feels light.
I had a Privia. I hate all Privia products due to the sharp buttons and shitty ldc screens. This keyboard has the fancy buttons, so what? Blue tooth, people are complaining about the delay time in switching. I have had a Casio CDP-200R, CDP-235R, and just gave a gift to my sister a Casio CDP-S350. Wires are a drag, but the latent delay switching is quick. Cables? Have to buy on line two separate cable to put together to connect to an iPad. I have had a number of other keyboards, such as the Kawai ES8, but they cost too much. I am sticking with Casio CDP-S350 and similar models due to price and functions. I hope CASIO continues to try to hold down their prices. I hate keyboards with too heavy a feel. I like a full 88 note piano keyboard. I do not like cheap piece of plastic, like a toy, 61 note keyboard. Keyboards should be indestructible too. My grandnephew could be rough on it and not break it when he plays Twinkle Twinkle. Also, be careful not to ruin the instrument spilling liquids on it. Though not perfect, it is good enough at the price, the CDP-S350. With an adapter, I hooked up the 1/8” output to 1/4” and plug it into a keyboard amp. Yeah, it is not stereo, so what, another compromise. 12” speaker with a tweeter horn for the highs and lots of inputs: Bass, guitar, keyboard, microphones. That’s right, put the whole band through it at low volume, in a living room playing with family members and friends.
How do I tune a psr e463
*What could be improved?*
1. Sound engine. The AiR sound engine has been around since 2012 on the PX-5S and stays there throughout many different Privia/Celviano models since then. Casio should inherit the Grand Hybrid sound engine to their smaller models, then combining them with AiX.
2. Built-in speakers. Instead of just 8W + 8W, the PX-S series should have been fitted with more powerful speaker system inside its slim compact design, preferably 15W or 10W
3. Front panel (PX-S3000 only). It's disappointing to see the touchscreen featured in previous generation has been removed. Those LED touch buttons are decent, but combining them with a color touchscreen display would be even better
It isn't the same engine as ANY previous model. This is inherited and improved in some ways from the Grand Hybrid.
@@casiomusicgear yes i do believie that. I got one today and it sounds so good, and the keybed is great.
For the px 1000 it would be a great ideea to layer the piano sound from the keyboard with a good virtual one.It could lead to unbelievable results in a portable package.Ravensrcroft or the Hammersmith or ...whatvere suits ones taste.
I love that the keys are light, after all this isn’t just for piano sounds right? Seems to me this is the perfect partner for an iPad. Just paired up with korg module!
Yes, as a controller it is very good action.
What is your opinion of the textured keys? They look SO textured that they would feel uncomfortable to play.
I like the textured black keys very much. But the white keys are a little bit too textured. I get used to it, so i am ok.
@@JeremySee Thank you for your reply!
7:15 Casio couldn’t add oleophobic property onto the touchscreen, because the touchscreen is of plastic/perspex or polycarbonate alike material, not glass/ceramic-like material as on our smartphones/watches.
They should provide registrations function in the mobile app
True.
oK,for a perfect piano action keybed there's the KAWAI VPC1
Thank you so much for the review!!
I have to agree with your review.
I was strongly and immediately disapointed when I played the PX S1000 for the first time. I’m really not a fan of the keyboard. As a classical pianist, the first thing i look for is an almost realistic imitation of a grand piano keyboard (or at least an acoustic keyboard). The rest is all a bonus.
You did mention quickly the short pivot problem in your video...But its actually more than a simple « different feeling ». It personnaly bothers me. You cant play properly the « harder » chords.
The volume of the speakers is also so poor. The quality is better through headphones, but the volume remains low and poor. You somehow didn’t mention it. I think that could be your #11 lol
Overall, i think the piano is a good deal for a beginner player or a beat maker. Not intermediate or advanced player. Definitely not for professionnal gigs.
Jeremy, how can I make the sound of my PX-S1000 BETTER when outputted in an external speakers?
1. When connecting to a basic speaker system and assuming I wanted to make it sound 'Stereo', do I need to use 2 cables to insert into the both LINE OUTs (Left channel and Right Channel) of the piano, or is it enough to just insert 1 cable to the Left Channel Mono?
2. Do I need to purchase a dedicated keyboard amp?
Yes, 2 different cables to 2 different left and right speakers if you want true stereo. The 2 speakers must also be sufficiently far apart. A good keyboard amp has the necessary dynamic range for the lowest to the highest notes.
Jeremy See Jeremy, thanks for this info. The manual only indicated that a single cable when inserted into the Left Channel (Mono) already mix both channels, assuming that it is only connected to a single speaker. Is that true?
TRUE stereo always require two speakers.
I really want you to compare these casio models : px560 vs px s3000.
There is no more PX-560 in Singapore anymore.
Hi @@JeremySee, is PX560 worth the money in 2020 compared with PX S1000 o CDPS350?
Casio Privia PX-S1000 - $599.99 or the Roland FP 10 - $499.99?
roland all the way
How much better does this Keyboard sound over the CDP-S350? Is it very noticeable, slightly noticeable, or not noticeable at all?
Very noticeable to me.
Your reviews are great, the best. Based on your review of the Casio PX-S1000 I decided to buy it over the Yamaha P-125... until you got to the cable issue. That is a stunning defect to me. I hate buying electronics that immediately require me to go search for dongles and adapters. If Casio were to let you know where the cable can be purchased and you passed that info along to your subscribers that would be fantastic. By the way, I'm in the USA.
Are you connecting to an iPhone or an Android phone?
@@JeremySee android at the moment.
With this adaptor you can use your normal phone charging cable. amzn.to/2SNKF6J
@@JeremySee Thanks so much for this link. I'm really glad I subscribed.
Yes, white is always a good option for hiding fingerprints and scratches and it's very cheerful and elegant. This model is also available in red. Looks stunning!
As Jeremy says, the action might disappoint classical players, but as he also briefly mentioned, a softer action can be an advantage too in certain types of performance, and that's including on stage. Speaking of stage use, it is hard to overstress the importance of a lightweight instrument if you do lots of short gigs. None of us is getting any younger.
Jeremy mentions the CP88 as being a weight culprit. Actually it's only 18kg, which means it's not the heaviest. Try carrying a Roland RD2000 (21.5kg) or the Yamaha P-515 (22kg) which is supposed to be a portable piano!
I agree entirely about the visually challenged bit. And what about playing under strong light? Often we can't see those small lights on our pianos during outdoor performances. And yes, all these pianos priced at US $500+ should have a basic screen. IMO manufacturers have omitted them to punish us for not purchasing more expensive models. But Alesis has broken the trend with its Recital Pro, so I think things will improve.
Despite its extra weight, I believe the Korg D1 is the best option for a cheap gigging piano. A gigging piano doesn't really need built-in speakers, but it needs a built-in screen, good connectors, and a robust build if at all possible.
Truly indeed! I think I meant to say CP1 which is 27kgs! The CP88 didn't exist when I was a younger gigging keyboardist. 😳
@@JeremySee I know you sometimes express dismay at the number of views of certain videos. Maybe you're only joking about that, but if you're serious about increasing the hits and your following, I suggest using more glamorous thumbnails. I geddit - you like to keep things upbeat and fun, but choosing pianos seems to bring out the conservative aspect of people. It's sad if they don't get to enjoy your quality reviews because they resisted clicking on a fun but OTT thumb nail. I think you should even post your face in each thumbnail. Makes for consistency and building trust.
Feel bad for Casio Privia PX-S1000 after watching ....
It would be perfect for me if it had the weight of the CDP130 😓😢
"CP88 weighs just 18.6 kg (41 pounds)" -- so less than 2x the weight of the PX-S1000.
If you can afford extra USD150, please do get PX-S3000.
Lol the 7th thing is just knit picking??? Lol almost all of these things are all knit picking
Dude, this is $600 piano. did you expect it to sound and feel like a $250,000 Bosendorfer ?
Get real.