GURNEY AND PAUL ATREIDES REUNITED ON ARRAKIS - DUNE 2
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 тра 2024
- From the critically acclaimed film, Dune 2.
House Harkonnen and the Emperor Sardaukar forces annihilated House Atreides in Dune 1. Gurney led a counter attack on the Harkonnen / Sardaukar and was thought to have perished. - Розваги
Paul taking his time before telling his people not to kill Gurney’s friends
if you look, before he tells them to stop, none go for a kill, just disarming and subduing. My guess is they knew beforehand
They’re smugglers who likely had previous run-ins with the Fremen so they’re right to go hard on them
A pretty significant amount are killed in the book
He don't give af about them smugglers lol
Paul is not a good guy.
I love how as soon as Gurney realizes he's fucked he draws his sword and advances. He knows he's as good as dead so he's gonna go out swining, like a true warrior.
I mean the last time that happened he turned out okay.
I like how it's not the destruction of the sand crawler that provokes him, it's when the aircraft goes down. The moment that machinery falls out of the sky everyone on the ground is a dead man, even if they fled into the desert none of them would survive without rescue. Might as well die fighting rather than by worms or dehydration
@@Legacy0901 like a true warrior
I loved the detail that his still suit was looted from a Sardukar
It's just the helmet no? But that's a good catch
...the helmet is similar but not exactly the same
@@thedragondemands5186 just rewatched the scene. You’re right. Didn’t catch that. Would have been cool if it was though.
Let alone a great adaption of a great book. It's a flicker of water in the desolate wastes of today's entertainment. It's refreshing to enjoy a trip to the theaters, and watch a well-written story once again. The attention to detail is just... spicy.
@@Klaaism just wish they added the little banquet. Loved that part in the books.
The difference between the “Young pup” here and later addressing Paul as “My lord” when he rises to face his destiny, I love that change so much.
Shows you a nice contrast between Duncan and Gurney. While Duncan readily accepts Paul as his Duke, Gurney takes a little bit of time to acknowledge his worthiness as a lord.
Keen eye
You guys made this way to deep. Paul was personally trained by Gurney and Duncan. They spent a lot of time together. Their relationship was more of a family one. Gurney would often refer to Paul as “young pup.” He was also refer to Paul as “my lord” as well. Paul and Gurney had an older/younger brother relationship with each other. The same way Paul and Duncan Idaho had an older/younger brother relationship as well.
@@jimhoover7345 I’m not thinking that deep, you can’t say there isn’t a difference between how he treats him before and how he treats him near the end of the film, to me it no longer felt like brothers.
@@thomasway0320 the only reason he treated Paul differently was because Paul was the new Duke of House Atreides. Has nothing to do with Gurney seeing Paul fulfill his destiny. At the end of Dune Messiah. When Paul gives himself up to the desert. Duncan Idaho reminds a memory he has with himself and Paul. Duncan saw the memory has a father ans son moment they had. Again it has nothing to do with “destiny”
There’s so much detail in the book that you can only nod to certain aspects of them.
Gurney is a religious man and he’s seen consulting his Orange Catholic Bible from time to time and they managed to get a shot of him playing his baliset.
Josh Brolin nailed the character. Gurney is a loving man but he’s also a matchless fighter too and both aspects come across nicely.
Which Dune book does its story mention?
@@juancarloshernandez7509 the first one, literally called Dune
He is also a Bard, who compose songs, and it's well done to show here this side of the character
@@thibaultleglatin3312 Wish we had seen more of this in the film. He rallied people, boosted morale with the instrument.
@@rodrigobogado8756 At that time, it had a Fremen name!
The look on his face when he saw Paul's face says it all.
i don't think people realize just how much this helped Gurney. before finding Paul again, it's clear he was in a dark place (given his song and how it's framed, how he chooses to continuously raid one of the most dangerous planets to sell spice on the black market). his failure weighs heavily on him - he believes he failed House Atreides completely. But seeing Paul alive just restores him. He's back to being a warrior, not a spice smuggler.
they basically just did a lone ronin story arc within the span of 5 minutes
If you take into account his back story, it gets worse. He was rescued as a slave from the Harkoneen world after Raban killed his sister. He would have thought the revenge he wanted was done. Seeing Paul would have reassured him of his friend and Lord was alive, but also he had a shot at the Harkoneens again.
Josh Brolin did such a great job in this movie. I was amused by his singing, and he's clearly overjoyed to see Paul again. Very interesting character.
Gurney walking towards the freemen with no fear, that's fucking bad ass
Gurney was probably the most dangerous man at the outset of the story in Dune. He is Letos Warmaster. Duncan considered him more dangerous than himself. Thats a guy who killed 19 sadukar before the rest took him down.
Those harvesters are just something, man. In a way, you're in this far distant future where technology has developed into something very advance. At the same time, those tech also look and feel like... old, manual, conventional, rough. Functional, advance, but doesn't look like anything futuristic, fancy, shiny like in Star Wars or Star Trek.
It fits the dieselpunk and steampunk aesthetic of the setting.
The post-Butlerian Jihad, automatics and AI were forbidden by the Great Convention. So they were forced to create Mentats, human calculators, and manually manage harvesters.
You see, that was where the original Star Wars hit gold - the "lived-in" world. I'll spare the comment on the shiny and polished sequels.
If you don't know about it already, look up the "Bagger 288". It's the closest thing we have to a huge spice miner (it mines coal instead).
Well real life mining machine doesn't look high tech on the outside, it's the inside that is. So it's still keeping with 'reality'
1:04 imagine if your suit malfunctioned right at that moment. I swear there's so many ways to easily turn this movie into a dark comedy.
I mean, this shit has been used most likely for thousands of years, consider most current tech has been around for less then a 100 often less then 10 years they have had plenty time to figure out the kinks.
"You young pup!!"
Damn that line was good to hear!! 😀😀😀😀😀😀😀
"Save me from this utter morons in other world." Lol. What a song.
The thing I take away from this is that the last time we saw Gurney he was facing a vastly numerically superior force head on. Not only did he survive that, but he was able to get some of his guys out alive as well.
Was there just a field covered in Harkonen bodies they didn't show use somewhere?
Someone pointed this out:
After the Harkonnens launched their land assault on Arrakeen, their airships open fire with a fury of missiles.
They were loosing the battle on the ground, when the Atriedes legions were only in pijamas.
@@iii5539 So...your telling me Gurney and his boys were kicking the Harkonnens ass so bad they higher ups decided to just bomb everything? And he and few of his men survived even that?
Death doesn't apply to Gurney unless he accepts it, does it?
@@iii5539 Why do you think they had to get some sardaukar legions? They wouldn't have been as successful otherwise lol
@noneedtoknow07 The Harkonnens are nowhere near as strong as the Atreides in terms of military prowess. The only reason House Atreides lost is because Emperor Shaddam sent his Sardaukar to help them, and caught them unawares. Leto was already suspicious of it being a setup, but knew that acting distrustful of the Emperor would be open grounds to be executed. If he had more time, he likely would have been able to prepare proper contingencies - we saw he was attempting to ally with the Fremen, which would have greatly strengthened his political power.
Remember that Feyd-Rautha nearly loses to Yueh in a duel while the man has been kept prisoner (likely fed poorly).
@@noneedtoknow07 I’m sure there were multiple fronts, several areas the Harkonnens dropped in and the Atriedes’ emerged.
Thanks for uploading this scene from Dune2
This reunion had more heart then games of thrones john and arya had
I love how they just camp out underneath the sand like that. So sneaky. Much comfier than burning in the sun also
Gurney is like Eomer in LOTR - always loyal
This scene brought a tear to my eye no lie
I just gotta say I love the design of this Spice Harvester from all we got in two of the movies
If anyone's not seen this yet i highly recommen you get to the cinema before its to late
Their beautiful reunion I've been waiting for🥲
I happened to watch the first Dune last night (even though I've seen it a dozen times) and I noticed at the part when Paul was hallucinating when the sand worm was on top of him, Paul says"I recognize your footsteps old man".
So Paul was seeing this moment at the part when his father was trying to save the crew from a giant sandworm.
I love it.
Reunited and it feels so good
This was a heartwarming scene from Dune2
Those mines are the coolest fucking weapons I’ve ever seen
Bro was ready to fight them all
"I recognised your footsteps old man.' Great call back.
В книге говорится , что у Гарни в отряде были замаскированные сардуакары , которые планировали покушение на Пола. Но в фильме это было упущено
Anybody else notice the call back when gurney looks up at the drop ship burning, it felt like the harkonnen battle
They do another callback shot from Gurney in the first film. When Gurney is about to face Rabban, the shot is similar to the first Dune when he's facing the Harkonnen army with the Atreides behind him.
I love Dune 2
Paul needed to be reunited with Gurney
One nugget was missed, the trap that was set, in the book and original movie, the Fremen had laid a thin layer of space across the sand. It was not the "juicy-juicy" as the driver had proclaimed.
Yeah, it was a nice trap, but the Fremen could have used the smugglers and their assets.
Paul took his time to call off fremen from killing Gurney's fellas.
Was Gurney wearing a Sardukar uniform/equipment?
I think so
I was so confused when i first saw this. I thought gurney was working for the harkonnens for a little.
Мощно
What exactly did Paul say at 3:40?
A true bromance.
More like the real cool uncle. Paul has many outstanding male figures who guided him in his life, his father is a good man and a gentleman of honor, his best friend/older brother, Dunca. With all those men as an example, of course he was going to emerge as a great man when he grew up. The boy grew up next to Chads.
❤
Their harvester doesn't have AC.
Flithy hacker. Gurney is using aimbot. No way he just hits a mine flying at that speed, at that range, using a gun with _no sights at all_
He's got slowfall as well
It's called skill
At least he didnt use wallhacks
@@rogueninja4719 😂
*It's a lasgun.*
It fly at the speed of light.
That thing basicaly a hack in itself. You just point and pull the trigger. XD
if the bad guys had any kind of infrared detection this movie could not have been made.
in the first film they said.. the spice will only be taken if everything is full... How is the spice of 1 miner taken that Gurney operates?
In the books theres a bit that says the smugglers pay a percentage to the rulers of arrakis to allow them to keep mining, plus i think they sell it directly to the spacing guild (i dont fully remember if they do or not)
😮
I didn’t understand this part. Was Gurney working for the Harkonnens, or working as a independent security contractor? Didn’t the Harkonnens have a monopoly on spice production? Why would they keep Gurney on security detail for a spice mining operation under Harkonnen rule?
Gurney explains to Paul that he found some wildcat spice harvesters to smuggle survivors back home but he stayed with the wildcat crew for his own reasons. The operation is completely illegal and the Harkonnens would kill them on sight, but the profits are enormous since the Fremen campaign against the Harkonnen's spice operations is so successful.
@@anthonyc8499 Thank you so much for this explanation. It makes more sense with him wearing the captured Sardukar uniform.
@@anthonyc8499Also did Paul know it was Gurney with those smugglers? If so, why did he attack them with the risk of killing him? If not, when Paul found out, then how come he didnt make the Fremen stopped killing Gurneys crewmates/friends earlier? And imagine if Paul didnt see Gurneys face and accidentally killed him...
@@anthonyc8499the Harkonnen wouldn’t kill the smugglers on site. The Harkonnen was paid by the smugglers to illegally harvest spice off Arrakis. This was explained in the book during the dinner scene that was left out in part one.
@@jimhoover7345well they’d probably kill gurney on sight
I think this part should have been fleshed out more. Explain Gurney's journey more instead of him simply *showing up* again.
Read. The. Book. This scene, is actually IN THE SOURCE MATERIAL. It doesn’t go into Gurney and his smuggler journey, because that gurney doesn’t matter and doesn’t exist the moment he knows Paul is alive.
@@codename495 Ohkay then. THE. SOURCE. MAYERIAL. SHOULD. HAVE. DONE. MORE. WITH. THIS. The way he just magically appears out of nowhere feels too cheap.
Damm he sound like Thanos
Same actor
He’s lying it’s not the same actor trust me
"Um dia desses ainda verei esse homem ser incapaz de fazer uma citação, e ele parecerá estar nu - o duque disse."
Just joshin but I always wondered how tf the Freman know where their target is going to land and where to lay in the sand. I also wonder how they submerge themselves? Do they just dig like a dog in the sand or do they crawl in it like Shai-Halud?
The Fremen can see where the spice blooms are, so they stake out the biggest blooms and wait for a harvester to show up. As for hiding in the sand, Dune Part 1 explained this by introducing the sand compactor, a handheld device that could manipulate sand. It’s how the would clear out a space in the sand for their tent, and get back out again.
@TheErockaustin Ohh okay, yeah that makes sense. In part 1, I do remember Duncan mentioning it and it did a lil forcefield thing and Paul used it to punch out of the sand, but other than that I don't believe it's shown again doing anything significant. Makes me wish they showed them setting up at least once. The beginning of part 2 doesn't count since you never see where they go or even how they sniped the Harkonens on top of a mountain but now I'm just complaining about what is otherwise my new favorite IP.
Wait... bro did steal a sardaukar armor? XD He CLEARLY shows he a swordmaster. Althou he was taken offguard by paul here XD
I can tell it was yu by the way you walk
I'm a woman's man no time to talk
i love how josh started falling before he was hit 3:11
is Gurney Halek a bard?
If you attack, you die, if you retreat, you die. Why retreat?
The book version is way better. In fact, Ive been waiting to watch Dune to see how they did this scene. No thanks.
I thought Gurney died??? Somehow Gurney returned - oops wrong movie
Wtf ?
I loved the direction of Dune 2 - Timothee isn;t a good Paul though
Your right he isn't a good Paul, he is a great Paul.
Did you even read the books? Because Timothee Chalamet nailed Paul Atreides character. Or at least he nailed the way Denis wrote Paul’s character in the movie.
this movie was so boring
This scene sucks. It feels shoe horned in. In the trailers for dune 2 you can see they filmed a completely different scene where Paul and Gurney reunite on a little sand dune which looks much better and with less cgi explosions.
This part lacks any subtlety and totally breaks any immersion how the fremen are ready to kill all the crew members but magically stop before causing any actually harm to them. Super lazy.
If I had to guess, it was probably ordered by the higher ups to add more action sequences because this scene takes place in the middle of the movie where the pace has slowed down a bit so the explosions and fighting keep your attention.
What the fuck are you talking about? This scene plays out almost exactly how the chapter in the novel does. Gurney is with the smugglers, they get ambushed by Fremen and the one that gets the upper hand of Gurney turns out to be Paul.
I swear to god people find the most mundane shit to complain about 😂
I honestly feel like before people like you comment. You need to read the damn book. That way you don’t look so stupid. This is exactly what happens in the book. I can’t stand people like this
Tell me you've never read the book without saying you've never read the book
It's obvious you didn't read the book.
@@asdasdasd-sf7sh people don't have to read the book to understand that a scene is flawed. It's about the film making, not the accuracy of the source material.
Dune 2 sucked
Everything sucked. This world sucked too.
No... YOU suck.
@@tiutran2610
It's just YOU who sucks.
You’re Indian bro 🤣🫵
Go shit in the street