Aung San Suu Kyi a heroine? Even the great Clive James got it badly wrong occasionally. Itself a valuable lesson. But Cultural Amnesia is a terrific book .
I've read 'Cultural Amnesia' and recommend it. It's unique both in its objective (start conversations about important topics and remind us of culturally important people who shouldn't be forgotten), and in its method (expository essays). If the book is somewhat hung up on the cataclysms of Nazism and Stalinism, it's understandable - partly because those cataclysms shouldn't be forgotten and also because of their relevance to today: the medieval barbarism that denounces western liberal democracies. Maniacs who peddle authoritarian utopist ideology based on revealed knowledge or sacred books? We've seen them before, in different times, and now as then they should never be appeased; they must be opposed.
James loved individualism and having a variety of different viewpoints - he understood that that is what fosters creativity. And he understood that collectivism - on the Right and on the Left - seeks to crush individual viewpoints and make everything uniform and boring. So he was very hard on those artists and writers who promoted authoritarian ideologies - he detested both French collaborators with the Nazis and writers who kowtowed to Stalin. He saw that both Fascism and Communism both murdered the human spirit (to say nothing of actual human beings.)
I love Clive James, but I think he'd doubt his own answer at 13:25-13:38 if he witnessed America's current and mostly voluntary slide towards authoritarianism. I miss his voice!
Regarding Operation Cyclone in particular, the CIA spent nearly a billion dollars in funding counter-revolutionaries, known as the "Mujahideen" (meaning, "people who do jihad"). All this in the name of "regime change." We then subsequently turn around and invade Afghanistan's Taliban regime, citing they had connection to radicals like AQ. But the Taliban is there for a reason.. billions of reasons. The red scare pretext has militarized the Afghani people, thanks to our "intervention."
Sorry Prof but I don't agree. Listen to what James says: "Watch out for the beautiful style, the beautiful style may be enshrining an untruth. You've simply got to learn to see through the way it's said to what's said." As I understand him, he's not referring to a hidden agenda (or even the role of simplicity in language) but insisting we cultivate a critical awareness towards the art of rhetoric and other forms of stylish, persuasive speaking and writing.
How things change. I wonder whether he regretted dedicating the book to her. It brings to mind the quote attributed to Abraham Lincoln "Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power." That quote seems to be tailor made for what happened to Aung San Suu Kyi. Clive James admitted that he changed his view of Edmund Wilson 27:54 so maybe he would say the same about her.
There's more civilisation in this video than a million other youtube videos combined. If we wonder what interacting with a super-intelligence will be like, this is it; including, of course, taking care to be intelligible to lesser minds. But the vast majority of humans nontheless feel no need for the insights. They prefer his early funny stuff.
In the book, he tells us he taught himself to read/write in this or that language at least ten times. Is this insecurity or what? Same as his endless posturing as a classics scholar in other tomes. I've no doubt he's erudite and intelligent but he doesn't half beat his own drum. I actually returned this book.
how incredibly fortunate we are to be able to listen and witness these 2 giants. what a legacy for us.i would love to have heard peter robison from stanford interview clive. although i TOTALLY disagree with clive when he says there's no heavenly force that intervenes.it all depends if you know how to kick him/it into gear. no body can refute that when you see something like margy palm defeating the powers that were driving stephen morin the serial killer when they went head to head . Personal Testimony (Story of Stephen Morin), Margy Palm ua-cam.com/video/pMjSmLCuaA0/v-deo.html or the help this divorced woman got; Dinner with an Angel - It's a Miracle ua-cam.com/video/s6BTvsQbWxw/v-deo.html or the jewish cantor and his mrs when they went head to head with the hatred from the kkk .it's a master class in spiritual war fare Did Kindness Change His Life? | It's A Miracle | S4E10 Part 3 ua-cam.com/video/rr1cl3BM3sM/v-deo.html
RIP Clive, you'll be greatly missed.
1😅😅
Clive was spot on here. His book ‘Cultural Amnesia’ is a great book. Loved the chapter on Camu.
Amazing interview. Amazing book. Amazing mind. RIP Clive James.
RIP Clive James. Great spirit.
A great mind. I enjoyed his contribution to culture enormously.
He was so fascinating. At least he is still able to be heard.
A great writer, and a raconteur to boot.
I could listen to this guy all day. (Even though his mind works at a higher level than mine, and I have difficulty keeping up!)
Clive James is a library on legs. I've read ten of his books and intend to read the rest as well. Thanks for posting this, Mr Rubio.
Wonderful man, wise and genuine. Brilliant book. I wish him well in his current bad health.
Clive James makes the world a better place by being in it.
Great interview with Clivey. I just adore him to bits
He was right about many things - bless him RIP
Amazing how recent this was and yet how strange the conversation about the internet sounds.
Aung San Suu Kyi a heroine? Even the great Clive James got it badly wrong occasionally. Itself a valuable lesson. But Cultural Amnesia is a terrific book .
100% agree.
RIP Clive ...you educated me!
Another good man gone...who is replacing these minds...rip Clive, gone but through your work never forgotten
"Terror wants to destabilize your justice system." So much truth in that simple statement.
fantastic interview. thanks for the upload
I wonder did he regret dedicating his book to Aung San Suu Kyi?
Great interview. Thanks for uploading. Look forward to reading the book.
One of the best interviews of James
I've read 'Cultural Amnesia' and recommend it. It's unique both in its objective (start conversations about important topics and remind us of culturally important people who shouldn't be forgotten), and in its method (expository essays).
If the book is somewhat hung up on the cataclysms of Nazism and Stalinism, it's understandable - partly because those cataclysms shouldn't be forgotten and also because of their relevance to today: the medieval barbarism that denounces western liberal democracies. Maniacs who peddle authoritarian utopist ideology based on revealed knowledge or sacred books? We've seen them before, in different times, and now as then they should never be appeased; they must be opposed.
James loved individualism and having a variety of different viewpoints - he understood that that is what fosters creativity. And he understood that collectivism - on the Right and on the Left - seeks to crush individual viewpoints and make everything uniform and boring. So he was very hard on those artists and writers who promoted authoritarian ideologies - he detested both French collaborators with the Nazis and writers who kowtowed to Stalin. He saw that both Fascism and Communism both murdered the human spirit (to say nothing of actual human beings.)
I love Clive James, but I think he'd doubt his own answer at 13:25-13:38 if he witnessed America's current and mostly voluntary slide towards authoritarianism. I miss his voice!
Read also, A Point of View, from his radio series. Did Studs Terkel ever interview him? No matter, I can 'hear' the discussion as it forms in my head.
Great man.
Clive James ( b.1939 ) Australian Television Presenter, Critic, Poet, Broadcaster, Translator and Memoirist.
Australian-born, but working in Britain.
No one speaks like this on UK tv anymore.
A Great Man,
Fascinating guy.
Amazing mind
Regarding Operation Cyclone in particular, the CIA spent nearly a billion dollars in funding counter-revolutionaries, known as the "Mujahideen" (meaning, "people who do jihad"). All this in the name of "regime change." We then subsequently turn around and invade Afghanistan's Taliban regime, citing they had connection to radicals like AQ. But the Taliban is there for a reason.. billions of reasons. The red scare pretext has militarized the Afghani people, thanks to our "intervention."
A fantastic book. So much in it.
I wonder if he’s optimistic about the state of the world now? Somehow I doubt it.
Bill interrupts Clive on a regular basis, but somehow it works.
Sorry Prof but I don't agree. Listen to what James says: "Watch out for the beautiful style, the beautiful style may be enshrining an untruth. You've simply got to learn to see through the way it's said to what's said." As I understand him, he's not referring to a hidden agenda (or even the role of simplicity in language) but insisting we cultivate a critical awareness towards the art of rhetoric and other forms of stylish, persuasive speaking and writing.
The lady from burma didn't turn out so good did she?
How things change. I wonder whether he regretted dedicating the book to her. It brings to mind the quote attributed to Abraham Lincoln "Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power." That quote seems to be tailor made for what happened to Aung San Suu Kyi. Clive James admitted that he changed his view of Edmund Wilson 27:54 so maybe he would say the same about her.
He smiles a little bit like Robin Williamson, no?
Is this from 2007?
There's more civilisation in this video than a million other youtube videos combined. If we wonder what interacting with a super-intelligence will be like, this is it; including, of course, taking care to be intelligible to lesser minds. But the vast majority of humans nontheless feel no need for the insights. They prefer his early funny stuff.
The Saddam Hussein comment hasn't aged well.
In the book, he tells us he taught himself to read/write in this or that language at least ten times. Is this insecurity or what? Same as his endless posturing as a classics scholar in other tomes. I've no doubt he's erudite and intelligent but he doesn't half beat his own drum. I actually returned this book.
Your loss.
Do you mean something like his Dante translations here?
Islam in Britain has been a nightmare and a total disaster.
Clive wasn't a conservative
how incredibly fortunate we are to be able to listen and witness these 2 giants. what a legacy for us.i would love to have heard peter robison from stanford interview clive.
although i TOTALLY disagree with clive when he says there's no heavenly force that intervenes.it all depends if you know how to kick him/it into gear. no body can refute that when you see something like margy palm defeating the powers that were driving stephen morin the serial killer when they went head to head . Personal Testimony (Story of Stephen Morin), Margy Palm ua-cam.com/video/pMjSmLCuaA0/v-deo.html or the help this divorced woman got; Dinner with an Angel - It's a Miracle ua-cam.com/video/s6BTvsQbWxw/v-deo.html or the jewish cantor and his mrs when they went head to head with the hatred from the kkk .it's a master class in spiritual war fare Did Kindness Change His Life? | It's A Miracle | S4E10 Part 3 ua-cam.com/video/rr1cl3BM3sM/v-deo.html