I am from South, especially Tamil. I think Hindi imposition is a hoax. And all those crying about how their language is dying because of Hindi, they cant even speak properly in their regional language. if anything English is killing off local languages
Finally a tamilian who has brains and actually recognises the real problem. Hindi is like a link language. If you stick to Tamil & I stick to speaking Punjabi we'll both end up banging our heads. Hindi simply serves as bridge. Hope there are more tamilians like you who slowly understand the real purpose of Hindi (not to destroy local language but simply act as a bridge between people from different states) 👍
20:20 No there was some translation error. He said before Persian was the official language in all the provinces but the British changed that and made their local language as the official language in each of the regions.
18:59 Urdu in Tuckic languages means Army "Ordu" - coz it was spoken by the soldiers. Tuckic words were more prominent in the military side where as Persian words are more in the governmental sides. (As Mughals were Turkic people who also used Persian for govt.)
That is a folk origin story. Urdu is a personalized register of the khariboli language spoken around Delhi. It draws vocabulary from Persian and Arabic. There are barely any turkic words in urdu Saving urdu,qainchi,babarchi and yalghar,baaji , that's pretty much it. There are more Portuguese words in urdu than turkic
22:13 okay so the reason you don't see much of Urdu in modern day India, is because a significant population of muslims migrated to pakistan and bangladesh, those were the people who mainly spoke and wrote urdu.
I am a maithili speaker. The Bihar government actually suppress the Maithili language and culture. Maithili is spoken in Bihar, Nepal and Jharkhand. That's why there is a lot of demand of separate statehood for mithila/tirhut. Maithili people have never been part of the larger Bihar identity. It had been separate, but the Bihar government is dominated by people from South Bihar who are obsessed with Hindi and bhojpuri.
I think some Indian states should be reorganized on the basis of language. There is no sense of community in states like Bihar. Our local languages are dying because of this Hindi imposition.
why do you think that ? because kumaoni people are still making songs ? those songs are not as popular as punjabi or hindi songs that kids would wanna learn the language. it is mostly because of old people that these songs have lots of views. pahadi languages are considered dialects of hindi. they need to be protected from hindi, otherwise they'll be extict
I think you should react to videos like these without proper subtitles on live stream, so that chat can correct any misunderstanding and translation error.
48:06 this is so true im from west UP and khadi boli is considered dehati(villagers language) while its the language of land when i speak in khadi boli accent my parents tell me to speak proper hindi cuz im educated
Last census was taken during 2011. The next was 2021 but the pandemic took place So now this is election year So soon after this election census would be taken uptill we follow 2011 census
@@Tushar_roy_11 these are not even 1 percentage of the languages that are spoken in Northern India. I am from uttrakhand if I speak in my mother tounge I bet any normal Hindi speaker will not be able to understand. You want to try?
Ya dude, I do too like most people on SM & I'm gradually starting 2 find it difficult 2 write in Assamese when I need to. I'm sure d future generations (unless they study in Assamese medium) would not be able 2 understand/write Assamese script, although I'm sure it'd continue 2 be spoken (to a lesser extent) in day 2 day life in Assam even in d face of increasing demographic/linguistic changes from outside.
As Indian yeah not just state has different languages but in a state different district has different types of speaking from one languages. Like I am from Gujarat who speak Gujarati but in Surati form. at some other cities or district there are same Gujarati but in other form like Standard Gujarati (which includes the varieties spoken in Mumbai and Ahmedabad), Surati, Kathiyawadi, Kharwa, Khakari, Tarimukhi, Kutchi, etc. In little north and west Gujarat we have Sindhi also. And I can speak 1. Hindi, 2. English, 3. Gujarati (4 different types: Standard Gujarati, Surati, Kathiyawadi, Kutchi) 4. Marwadi, 5. Marathi, 6. Punjabi 7. Little bit of Japanese(Learning) 8. Want to learn Sanskrit
Now you see the problem, as a person from South i really dont have a hate against Hindi and i completely understand the need of a common language but, if you force it, it kills the history of the language of land. Also, i might say that in Karnataka at least, the Konkani and Tulu are actually spreading (i feel), i never spoke Tulu before but now am quite fluent and its mixes up with Kannada too. But i cant write original Tulu. But i guess this proves maybe the merger which eventually forms a dialect under Kannada? Maybe? Anyhow, I speak, 1) Konkani (Mother Tongue) 2) Tulu (Regional Language) 3) Kannada (State Language) 4) Malayalam (bits and pieces) 5) Tamil (can understand only) 6) Hindi (Studied) 7) English (Studied) 5 languages i know from age of 6 and more git added later on. So my solution is Promotion of Multi Linguistic Language from a young age, as done in South. Teach, 1) English - Global language 2) Hindi - Common or Official Language 3) Kannada- State language Regional language will be promoted in community and homes.
@@kumar.193 A good question. The answer is simple. Lets assume you speak language 1 and i speak language 2. Similarly there are 8 other different language speakers in a room alongside us. Now we need to work in a project. Problem is communication. So there are two solutions. 1) Learn all 7 other languages which takes time and can cause unintentional linguistic confusion or mistakes. 2) Construct a new language X so that we all learn 1 language instead of 7 to help reduce time, increase efficiency and avoid cultural, social and linguistic differences. I simplified it but there are more pros and cons to note of.
@@francisaranha6514 So all 8 are already learning a language called English as part of thier education as part of thier education, so why do the same 8 need to learn another language called Hindi.
@@kumar.193 Well this can be answered in various ways. 1) Some group of people dont wish to select an outside language so For them Hindi is a compromise. 2) For some other, they wish to have a common language that has base from Indian civilisation (a continuity). 3) 4 people out of 8 already speak a Language Y which they feel is better to option as its already uniting 4 people so, they prefer to use this instead of Language X as easier for them and solves problems such as continuity of their history or culture or other problems they have.
I am suggesting this again. If u wanna learn about the full history of Indian subcontinent then u need to watch that Kraut video "India and Pakistan a continuing story"
44:10 if both of them is speaking thier mother tongue no one will understand but we all north indians do know standard hindi aswell so we can communicate
Hindi and Urdu are basically the same language hindustani, the formal form of both have zero distinction,Hindi and Urdu are made up languages based on religious politics.
Wrong. The informal form has almost 0 distinctions. But formal hindi uses more sanskrit and formal urdu uses more persian words. At the extremes, it becomes unrecognisable
1:01:34 for real dude. Remember that girl from earlier? Neha Rawat speaking Garhwali, she's from Pauri Garhwal, I'm from Chamoli district of Uttarakhand and I struggled to understand most of the part she said.
I believe this UA-camr should have mentioned that we already learn three languages in school. As someone who has lived in both Maharashtra and Punjab, I understand both Marathi and Punjabi even though I don't speak them fluently. I don't speak Marathi because none of my family is from Maharashtra, and in the part of Maharashtra where I lived, most people didn't speak Marathi either. My point is that I've had many difficulties communicating with people across India, and the only way I managed was because everyone understood Hindi and English. For people like me, who have had to adapt to multiple languages (Punjabi, Hindi, English, Marathi, Gujarati, and various dialects), it can be really challenging, especially as a kid moving to a different state. I understand that culturally, everyone wants their language to thrive, but there are consequences to this that might not be as positive as they seem. Take tourism, for example-visitors from other states or countries would feel more comfortable if they knew they could be understood by the locals. While the idea of promoting every language is admirable, it may not be practical in reality.
Central government has always imposed hindi, in 1980 they cunningly put the bihari languages/eastern branch of ipe (magahi,angika , maithali, bhojpuri sister languages to bengali and Assamese) under hindi dialect, despite them being centuries older than hindi. Shameful.
My research Hindi is like a sharp version of Sanskrit. And Malayalam like having an end gentle slope to Sanskrit. Also Malayalam language is kinda a merge between Sanskrit and Tamil with former being more prominent.. Ill give u eg Word : City / town Sanskrit : Nagara Hindi : Nagar Malayalam : Nagaram Word : unhappy Sanskrit : Dukha Hindi : Dukh Malayalam : Dukham So i meant to say its like From Sanskrit if u eliminate any ending sound like 'aa' it gives Hindi And addition of 'm' sound to Sanskrit gives Malayalam There are many examples and some may be different from my theory
You’re mistaken. The initial part is true. Malayalam developed from manipravalam which was a mix of tamil and sanskrit. But it’s more tamil than sanskrit. Most of the posh words in malayalam ar derived from Sanskrit but common words are derived from tamil. This reason is exactly why english is a germanic language and not a romance language even though majority of english words are of latin and french origin.
@@antiwokehuman yea most of the common words are from Tamil. But the official words are derived from Sanskrit. Nowadays if u consider it'd be more Tamil ish but during earlier times kings would be promoting Sanskrit ised words
Indian states are huge. Therefore same language of that state with many different dialects. So people can distinguish from which part of that state they are from. Whether that person is from North, South, East or West
see if we go by sole numbers maybe less than 15% speak standard hindi as their mother tongue but 75% people can speak hindi as their seconds so it does connect the country
I am from Odisha state (ଓଡ଼ିଶା ରାଜ୍ୟ) Our official languages are 1st lang- Odia 2nd Lang- English 3rd - Hindi/ Sanskrit Even if my 1st lang is Odia Eastern Odisha ( odia language) and western Odisha (Koshli/ Sambalpuri) speak different language We all write read in Odia but western Odisha speak Koshli / Sambalpuri language And every district has its own dialague( Some words are not understandable)
Tulu also has its own film industry and a very active theatre (both traditional and modern) scene. But sadly cultural vibrancy is not enough for recognition under the 8th schedule. The number of votes politicians will get makes more of a difference it seems.
We also had learnt it. And imposed on us like English. But if u speaking English accepting Britisher language what is the problem of accepting a language Hindi which is spoke by more. Than 50% of population. It will make ur life easier. But above all choice is urs.
@@agentfire3312you too are learning English. What wrong in talking in English to south Indians? You don't learn any south indian language as one of the languages in 3 language policy , isn't it? Then how dare you impose 3 languages on others?
@@Aratiii06 I am not imposing any language on u and I don't travel to south. Iam asking u for the hatred of us for Hindi when u can adopt britishers language. Hindi is spoken by half the country u have to learn it for conversation. No one asking u too stop speaking ur native language but adding 1 more arrow to ur archery will strengthen u will not make u weak.
@@agentfire3312 I am not saying we hate Hindi. I am saying why are you imposing Hindi which is leading to hate. If you hate Britishers language, why did you learn English yourself? The 3 language policy is an imposition of Hindi and English too. Let people choose what they want to learn as optional languages instead of compulsion. In 3 language policy, did north Indian states give any compulsory southern languages to learn? If not, why the hate against southern languages?
North Indians languages are very similar . if you know hindi then you can understand everything other. not only North India. I came from West bengal which is east India and we speak bengali but bengali is also pretty similar to hindi. Those who understand bengali can pretty easily understand Hindi
Then why u need Hindi? Just speak in ur mother tounge everywhere u go in northern western eastern and central parts of India which all are same language group. Southern languages are different language family.
You see we don’t like imposition of anything whether it be language, religion or food. Our languages are intimately connected to our culture and our culture is extremely important to us. We preserved it throughout the 1000 years of islamic rule and we will certainly preserve it in independent india. We don’t want to be like bihar.They have lost their identity. It’s sad how such a great land with so much history, which was once a beacon of indian culture has been turned into what it is today. Besides, my grandmothers ancestral home has more history than modern hindi (no offense). I can speak and understand hindi. I have no problems using it. It’s taught in schools here in my state. But that’s about where i draw the line.
@@extraordinarygamer937 lol how? Did you guys beg the invaders to not invade the south after you guys failed miserably against them? 😂 Why don't you come up with a better story. You couldn't even protect yourself let alone others
@@antiwokehuman we did not fail u ungrateful loser, we resisted by constant rebellions that's why no Invader was able to hold on South for long, if it was not for Shivaji Raje you would be speaking Urdu by now and offering prayers in a mosque. You were simply lucky by being far away from Delhi. You fell like pack of cards when Brits with Modern guns arrived so yeah, if it was not for North Indian Kings and rebellions you losers were long gone. Just because a cuck like u is deluded ungratefully will not change history, u had protection from North hence u thrived
@antiwokehuman... reading both your reactions was like an ouch moment for me 😅😂 but I go with you because i found it really stupid what @extraordinarygamer937 said, he maybe somewhat or somewhere right, but the way he put it across really deserved your response 😂😂😂 because what he said was like we didn't have any rulers in the south who protected us and only rulers n people in the north are our saviour 😂😂
@@antiwokehuman I wrote a lengthy response but coward ass YT deleted it, I said it before and I will say it again. You are ungrateful sore b@st@rd, North Indians were constantly in rebellion that's why they could not always control the South. If anyone failed it was you, always boasting how old our language is but nobody in the entire world believe in your delusions, kinda like how h!tler started believing his own propoganda that's what happened with you. Yes the fact is had it not been North Indians and Shivaji your clown a$$ language would have been long replaced by Arabic or Persian
language is a sensitive issue but, even though i want all languages to prosper, as long as india as a republic remains, eventually all people will speak hindi and english both, it will happen naturally, if want to survive u have to go out of your town, village, u will see hindi english in media, bollywood, hoardings all around u. u will speak it and speak it by your own will i don't have problem with any language, not even english, afterall it is an offshoot of the same indo european language family. humans evolve and do languages we can't control it, also in current times east west north northeast central india every where hindi and english is growing, in south also there is growth but slow
49:00 is exactly the point of the video . Language must be preserved . Every language is beautiful in their own way. Dont keep the languages in own big umbrella . Hope our government learn from this and do something to preseve these languages
Uttar means North. This person has not given the correct explanations. So just take it lightly. 3% is correct. Urdu language developed in Lucknow city in India NOT in Pakistan.
I would like to state that I liked the original video as well as your reaction or perhaps its our common linguistic interest, the translations ware wrong on many occasions in the duration of the video, but yes as an Indian living in india I do speak Chhattisgarhi I might be the only Chhattisgarhi speaker in your comment section also because in Chhattisgarh also people speak regional languages and dilects obviously. Other Chhattisgarhis please reply to this comment.
Yes it's unfortunate that the subtitles were incorrect but I was able to get a good understanding despite this. His newer videos have actual English subtitles so it is much better. Thank you for watching! I always enjoy hearing about people and their language they speak
That auto translate is atrocious, the subtitle is exactly opposite of what was spoken several times. Now I'm starting to wonder if the European language videos I watched with auto-translated subtitles were this bad.
Bottom line is so cAlled fight against hindi imposition is just another tool in political arsenal of regional political parties(most national parties advocate for hindi as connecting language rather than english) which most of these critics leave out intentionally As for the dialect i speak more english than hindi but mosty hindi speaker i understand bhojpuri,haryanvi,urdu(since im from up) punjabi(60-70%) so you cant say they are not dialect of hindi And everyone is like that at least here in North cities I would say Hindi has helped to create composite culture here there are all kinds of songs in parties be it haryanvi punjabi bhojpuri and there is hardly ever any hindi song nagin is exception😅 Bhojpuri people celebrate chhat, up and haryanvi cebrrate godhan Punjabi celebrate Lohri in their respective languages isn't that what we want or you just want people to be secluded?
Brother, I am from Uttarakhand and we mainly speak Pahari (Gadhwali ,Kumaoni) here, but the government did not recognize it here and made Hindi and Sanskrit the official language of my state and my mother used to tell me that when she was in school her government teachers used to give her homework for writing essays about "Hindi hamari matra basha hai "isn't it an imposition?😢
It is an imposition I don't know when you guys will understand. And hindi is not a national language. Instead of asking someone else to correct, first you learn.
I don't see people hating Hindi this days It is just a language to communicate with each other History doesn't matter if is old or new But even 17th century it's more than 300 years history of Hindi new but not very new
Indian doesn't have ONE strict official language in the country, but HINDI is considered as a national language due to largely spoken and understandable by almost all Indians.
I don’t know what defines “strict” but Hindi and English are recognized as Official Languages and No Single Language is named as a “National Language”. Hindi is not a National Language, it is widely spoken and understood in North India but that changes when you go South where other than regional languages, English is more widely spoken and understood than Hindi.
If you wanna know about Indian history plz watch any english video on youtube as you can understand it easily. You're actually learning nothing from this hindi video as you are not understanding it properly.
Putting different dialects under Hindi is same as what China does when they put different dialects under single Mandarin. It brings more uniformity, and if government of India wants they can actually extend the Hindi dialect range too, the offical number still puts Hindi at only 40% of India but in relaity it's easily 60-70%
Ceremonial language was the word? Like traditional costumes... video.seems biased...most states have many languages n dialects eg Karnataka has kannada tulu konkani...konkani is state language o Goa but a dialect in neighboring Maharashtra
It's not but you're definitely an ignorant person. The Hindi you're talking about is the Bollywood version which is actually Urdu+Hindi. I suggest you stop watching Bollywood trash. I'm from Punjab and I'm fluent in English Hindi & Punjabi. We speak Hindi in Punjab and never claim Punjabi is being by Hindi.
It's not. Only mumbai and pune . Rest of maha doesn't understand nor give a F about Hindi. But like south indians we should stop responding in Hindi. Outsiders need to learn our language not the other way round.
😂... is Hindi taking over India? Is English taking over America da. Hindi is India's national language. There are other languages but Hindi has always been the primary language above it is of course Sanskrit from which Hindi comes. All of North India speaks multiple dilects of Hindi. Yes Hindi has multiple dilects too 😂... Khadi boli, Maghi, Bhojpur... etc just like in the USA you have different dilects and tones in, which English is spoken... for e.g in New York you would have a different English pronunciation and expressions than in Boston, Texas, California, Colorado, Alaska... in India there are 1000s of sub-sub regional languages all coming from Sanskrit - Hindi.
People who thinks Hindi is imposed forcely have never read Indian constitution properly. Article 351 in Constitution of India 351. Directive for development of the Hindi language It shall be the duty of the Union to promote the spread of the Hindi language, to develop it so that it may serve as a medium of expression for all the elements of the composite culture of India and to secure its enrichment by assimilating without interfering with its genius, the forms, style and expressions used in Hindustani and in the other languages of India specified in the Eighth Schedule, and by drawing, wherever necessary or desirable, for its vocabulary, primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages.
Absolutely not .. Hindi is made from the Hindustani langauge and it has so many imported words from Turkic and Arabic langauge.. Bengali is the closest langauge to Sanskrit, anybody who speaks Bengali can understand some Sanskrit because the "A" shwa sound in Sanskrit is replaced with "O", otherwise everything is same from Grammer to vocabs
@lfc_rushar. You are wrong. Not everyone can understand all languages if they know Hindi. Some can only know and understand Hindi but not grasp the other languages like bihari, bhojpuri, haryanvi, Punjabi, Gujarati, marwadi, Bengali, odia, pahadi etc. And @sornaveln6019 you are wrong too. I am from South India, my mother tongue is Kannada, but I can understand Tamil, Malayalam, Telugu, Gujarati, Punjabi, Bengali, bit of bihari/bhojpuri, I can read write and converse in Hindi. People say if u know Sanskrit you can connect with Hindi, Marathi, Bengali and kannada words to understand the meaning. I don't know Sanskrit but I can definitely understand a lot of languages. Also, telling everyone generally, don't assume people in the south don't understand Hindi. Most of them do. But they choose not to because people who come to work here don't even try to learn the local language and also many are arrogant as to why should I learn. Hence even though we (atleast in Bangalore) try to accommodate and speak to people in all the possible languages but are not respected, we started rebelling that Hindi is not our language, if u want to communicate then learn our language 😊
![Are Hindi and Urdu Are The Same Language?! - India In Pixels Reaction [India 🇮🇳]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BKvqSbNCA7w/mqdefault.jpg)
![I Had No Idea Ancient Indians Had Such Advanced Cities - Odd Compass Reaction [India 🇮🇳]](/img/n.gif)
20:35 Translation is incorrect, he said British made the local language as the official languages and de-persianised.
I am from South, especially Tamil. I think Hindi imposition is a hoax. And all those crying about how their language is dying because of Hindi, they cant even speak properly in their regional language. if anything English is killing off local languages
Finally a tamilian who has brains and actually recognises the real problem.
Hindi is like a link language. If you stick to Tamil & I stick to speaking Punjabi we'll both end up banging our heads. Hindi simply serves as bridge.
Hope there are more tamilians like you who slowly understand the real purpose of Hindi (not to destroy local language but simply act as a bridge between people from different states) 👍
@@Pablo_Escobar_xxx English is the real link language !
Lol you are dumb
@@Pablo_Escobar_xxx Comment: In english
@@Pablo_Escobar_xxxFunny you have conveyed this in english so english is fine for converting between states
15:25 I think that language Dhvivehi is from Maldives
In Lakshadweep its mostly Malayalam language commonly spoken
20:20 No there was some translation error. He said before Persian was the official language in all the provinces but the British changed that and made their local language as the official language in each of the regions.
Now Indian government (bjp) called this divide and rule policy.
18:59 Urdu in Tuckic languages means Army "Ordu" - coz it was spoken by the soldiers. Tuckic words were more prominent in the military side where as Persian words are more in the governmental sides. (As Mughals were Turkic people who also used Persian for govt.)
It's a mix of Sanskrit, parsian, turkic language
That is a folk origin story. Urdu is a personalized register of the khariboli language spoken around Delhi. It draws vocabulary from Persian and Arabic. There are barely any turkic words in urdu Saving urdu,qainchi,babarchi and yalghar,baaji , that's pretty much it. There are more Portuguese words in urdu than turkic
22:13 okay so the reason you don't see much of Urdu in modern day India, is because a significant population of muslims migrated to pakistan and bangladesh, those were the people who mainly spoke and wrote urdu.
I am a maithili speaker. The Bihar government actually suppress the Maithili language and culture. Maithili is spoken in Bihar, Nepal and Jharkhand. That's why there is a lot of demand of separate statehood for mithila/tirhut. Maithili people have never been part of the larger Bihar identity. It had been separate, but the Bihar government is dominated by people from South Bihar who are obsessed with Hindi and bhojpuri.
I think some Indian states should be reorganized on the basis of language. There is no sense of community in states like Bihar. Our local languages are dying because of this Hindi imposition.
@@user-xj3rkf7uyp3 Absolutely agreed. It would also be easier to manage states with low population.
WhatsApp University supermacist spotted who want to encroach other languages and areas, maithali supermacist are no less evil than Hindi supermacist.
I am paharhi kumauni i know three languages kumauni, hindi, english and it is not fading away my culture or language
Garhwali is almost extinct already thanks to Hindi. Garhwali people are ashamed of speaking their own language and prefer Hindi over it.
why do you think that ? because kumaoni people are still making songs ? those songs are not as popular as punjabi or hindi songs that kids would wanna learn the language. it is mostly because of old people that these songs have lots of views. pahadi languages are considered dialects of hindi. they need to be protected from hindi, otherwise they'll be extict
I think you should react to videos like these without proper subtitles on live stream, so that chat can correct any misunderstanding and translation error.
48:06 this is so true im from west UP and khadi boli is considered dehati(villagers language) while its the language of land when i speak in khadi boli accent my parents tell me to speak proper hindi cuz im educated
Last census was taken during 2011.
The next was 2021 but the pandemic took place
So now this is election year
So soon after this election census would be taken uptill we follow 2011 census
North Indian language so close to each other's, if u know Hindi u can understand all the north indian language
No you can't understand even a single sentence
@@jaymehra5927 really? If u know Hindi u can understand Punjabi, haryanvi, bhojpuri, bengali, gujrati etc
@@jaymehra5927 then u are not a north indian language speaker i guess
@@Tushar_roy_11 these are not even 1 percentage of the languages that are spoken in Northern India. I am from uttrakhand if I speak in my mother tounge I bet any normal Hindi speaker will not be able to understand. You want to try?
@@Tushar_roy_11 how? I live in the north India. My language is more than 1000 years old. Dude where is logic?
Bro was afraid to touch North East!! That will be a whole new world..
TO BE HONEST... I USE LATIN ENGLISH LETTER TO WRITE MY TRIBAL OR STATE (ASSAMESE) OR HINDI TO COMMUNICATE OTHER PEOPLE IN SOCIAL MEDIA PLATFORMS....
Ya dude, I do too like most people on SM & I'm gradually starting 2 find it difficult 2 write in Assamese when I need to. I'm sure d future generations (unless they study in Assamese medium) would not be able 2 understand/write Assamese script, although I'm sure it'd continue 2 be spoken (to a lesser extent) in day 2 day life in Assam even in d face of increasing demographic/linguistic changes from outside.
The auto translation was a bit off at times which changed the meanings of some sentences that he said.
As Indian yeah not just state has different languages but in a state different district has different types of speaking from one languages.
Like I am from Gujarat who speak Gujarati but in Surati form.
at some other cities or district there are same Gujarati but in other form like Standard Gujarati (which includes the varieties spoken in Mumbai and Ahmedabad), Surati, Kathiyawadi, Kharwa, Khakari, Tarimukhi, Kutchi, etc.
In little north and west Gujarat we have Sindhi also.
And I can speak
1. Hindi,
2. English,
3. Gujarati (4 different types: Standard Gujarati, Surati, Kathiyawadi, Kutchi)
4. Marwadi,
5. Marathi,
6. Punjabi
7. Little bit of Japanese(Learning)
8. Want to learn Sanskrit
I'm Sourashtrian speaking Sourashtra language from Tamil nadu
Oh! You learnt little Japanese and want to learn Sanskrit. But no mention of any south indian languages. And you bloody want unity!! Awesome!!
@@Aratiii06 hahaha yeah
but I want to learn Telugu because it's sound badass because of Tollywood movie
Now you see the problem, as a person from South i really dont have a hate against Hindi and i completely understand the need of a common language but, if you force it, it kills the history of the language of land.
Also, i might say that in Karnataka at least, the Konkani and Tulu are actually spreading (i feel), i never spoke Tulu before but now am quite fluent and its mixes up with Kannada too. But i cant write original Tulu.
But i guess this proves maybe the merger which eventually forms a dialect under Kannada? Maybe?
Anyhow, I speak,
1) Konkani (Mother Tongue)
2) Tulu (Regional Language)
3) Kannada (State Language)
4) Malayalam (bits and pieces)
5) Tamil (can understand only)
6) Hindi (Studied)
7) English (Studied)
5 languages i know from age of 6 and more git added later on.
So my solution is Promotion of Multi Linguistic Language from a young age, as done in South.
Teach,
1) English - Global language
2) Hindi - Common or Official Language
3) Kannada- State language
Regional language will be promoted in community and homes.
By the way, there is Marathi kokani, Goan-Marathi kokani and Kannada-kokani.
By the way, why is a common language needed?
@@kumar.193 A good question. The answer is simple.
Lets assume you speak language 1 and i speak language 2. Similarly there are 8 other different language speakers in a room alongside us.
Now we need to work in a project. Problem is communication. So there are two solutions.
1) Learn all 7 other languages which takes time and can cause unintentional linguistic confusion or mistakes.
2) Construct a new language X so that we all learn 1 language instead of 7 to help reduce time, increase efficiency and avoid cultural, social and linguistic differences.
I simplified it but there are more pros and cons to note of.
@@francisaranha6514 So all 8 are already learning a language called English as part of thier education as part of thier education, so why do the same 8 need to learn another language called Hindi.
@@kumar.193 Well this can be answered in various ways.
1) Some group of people dont wish to select an outside language so For them Hindi is a compromise.
2) For some other, they wish to have a common language that has base from Indian civilisation (a continuity).
3) 4 people out of 8 already speak a Language Y which they feel is better to option as its already uniting 4 people so, they prefer to use this instead of Language X as easier for them and solves problems such as continuity of their history or culture or other problems they have.
The Subtitles are all over the place 20:20 the correct subtitle would be "The British made the Local languages Official, instead of Persian."
Yeah I saw that, there goes Google messing it up lol next time I should react to these videos on Livestream so the chat can tell me if it's wrong
I am suggesting this again. If u wanna learn about the full history of Indian subcontinent then u need to watch that Kraut video "India and Pakistan a continuing story"
Sounds like you are threathning him 😂😂
44:10 if both of them is speaking thier mother tongue no one will understand but we all north indians do know standard hindi aswell so we can communicate
Hindi and Urdu are basically the same language hindustani, the formal form of both have zero distinction,Hindi and Urdu are made up languages based on religious politics.
Wrong. The informal form has almost 0 distinctions. But formal hindi uses more sanskrit and formal urdu uses more persian words. At the extremes, it becomes unrecognisable
1:01:34 for real dude. Remember that girl from earlier? Neha Rawat speaking Garhwali, she's from Pauri Garhwal, I'm from Chamoli district of Uttarakhand and I struggled to understand most of the part she said.
Oh wow
I believe this UA-camr should have mentioned that we already learn three languages in school. As someone who has lived in both Maharashtra and Punjab, I understand both Marathi and Punjabi even though I don't speak them fluently. I don't speak Marathi because none of my family is from Maharashtra, and in the part of Maharashtra where I lived, most people didn't speak Marathi either.
My point is that I've had many difficulties communicating with people across India, and the only way I managed was because everyone understood Hindi and English. For people like me, who have had to adapt to multiple languages (Punjabi, Hindi, English, Marathi, Gujarati, and various dialects), it can be really challenging, especially as a kid moving to a different state.
I understand that culturally, everyone wants their language to thrive, but there are consequences to this that might not be as positive as they seem. Take tourism, for example-visitors from other states or countries would feel more comfortable if they knew they could be understood by the locals. While the idea of promoting every language is admirable, it may not be practical in reality.
Hindi not old language tamil is older language
yeah tamil and sanskrit are one of the oldest languages as far as i remember right??
Sanskrit (7000 years old)
Tamil (5000 years old)
Yeah this 2 are most oldest language in the world
I don't think anyone claims that Hindi is very old
Who is even saying that
We all know Tamil and Sanskrit are oldest language in the world
@@yellowishyoutubechannel3900dumbest comment 🙄
Central government has always imposed hindi, in 1980 they cunningly put the bihari languages/eastern branch of ipe (magahi,angika , maithali, bhojpuri sister languages to bengali and Assamese) under hindi dialect, despite them being centuries older than hindi.
Shameful.
My research
Hindi is like a sharp version of Sanskrit. And Malayalam like having an end gentle slope to Sanskrit. Also Malayalam language is kinda a merge between Sanskrit and Tamil with former being more prominent.. Ill give u eg
Word : City / town
Sanskrit : Nagara
Hindi : Nagar
Malayalam : Nagaram
Word : unhappy
Sanskrit : Dukha
Hindi : Dukh
Malayalam : Dukham
So i meant to say its like
From Sanskrit if u eliminate any ending sound like 'aa' it gives Hindi
And addition of 'm' sound to Sanskrit gives Malayalam
There are many examples and some may be different from my theory
In sinhala we use words exactly like sanskrit 😊
Same odia
You’re mistaken. The initial part is true. Malayalam developed from manipravalam which was a mix of tamil and sanskrit. But it’s more tamil than sanskrit. Most of the posh words in malayalam ar derived from Sanskrit but common words are derived from tamil. This reason is exactly why english is a germanic language and not a romance language even though majority of english words are of latin and french origin.
@@antiwokehuman yea most of the common words are from Tamil. But the official words are derived from Sanskrit.
Nowadays if u consider it'd be more Tamil ish but during earlier times kings would be promoting Sanskrit ised words
Indian states are huge. Therefore same language of that state with many different dialects. So people can distinguish from which part of that state they are from. Whether that person is from North, South, East or West
The manhwa was LOOKISM...
see if we go by sole numbers maybe less than 15% speak standard hindi as their mother tongue but 75% people can speak hindi as their seconds so it does connect the country
As a Tamilian who don't know Hindi, I also found Graphics Earth's videos are very easy to follow and understand even without captions.
I am from Odisha state (ଓଡ଼ିଶା ରାଜ୍ୟ)
Our official languages are
1st lang- Odia
2nd Lang- English
3rd - Hindi/ Sanskrit
Even if my 1st lang is Odia Eastern Odisha ( odia language) and western Odisha (Koshli/ Sambalpuri) speak different language
We all write read in Odia but western Odisha speak Koshli / Sambalpuri language
And every district has its own dialague( Some words are not understandable)
Juhar bhai
జై జగన్నాథ.. Jai Jagannatha!
Love Odias from Andhra
Tulu also has its own film industry and a very active theatre (both traditional and modern) scene. But sadly cultural vibrancy is not enough for recognition under the 8th schedule. The number of votes politicians will get makes more of a difference it seems.
I am from South of India . I completely hate imposition of hindi on us. We are forced to learn Hindi in school.😢
We also had learnt it.
And imposed on us like English.
But if u speaking English accepting Britisher language what is the problem of accepting a language Hindi which is spoke by more. Than 50% of population.
It will make ur life easier.
But above all choice is urs.
I can talk to entire world in English. That enough. It's a global Language il, I work in English, it give me the food. Then why I need useless hindi.?
@@agentfire3312you too are learning English. What wrong in talking in English to south Indians? You don't learn any south indian language as one of the languages in 3 language policy , isn't it? Then how dare you impose 3 languages on others?
@@Aratiii06 I am not imposing any language on u and I don't travel to south.
Iam asking u for the hatred of us for Hindi when u can adopt britishers language.
Hindi is spoken by half the country u have to learn it for conversation.
No one asking u too stop speaking ur native language but adding 1 more arrow to ur archery will strengthen u will not make u weak.
@@agentfire3312 I am not saying we hate Hindi. I am saying why are you imposing Hindi which is leading to hate. If you hate Britishers language, why did you learn English yourself? The 3 language policy is an imposition of Hindi and English too. Let people choose what they want to learn as optional languages instead of compulsion. In 3 language policy, did north Indian states give any compulsory southern languages to learn? If not, why the hate against southern languages?
North Indians languages are very similar . if you know hindi then you can understand everything other. not only North India. I came from West bengal which is east India and we speak bengali but bengali is also pretty similar to hindi. Those who understand bengali can pretty easily understand Hindi
Yes right
Yes u are right .... bengali is very similar to bihari , odia , Assamese even Nepali ....I can easily understand all the languages...even Panjabi
Bengali and Hindi both are came from Sanskrit, that's why. Bdw I'm also multilingual and I can speak, read and write in Bengali, Hindi and English
Then why u need Hindi? Just speak in ur mother tounge everywhere u go in northern western eastern and central parts of India which all are same language group. Southern languages are different language family.
I'm from Bihar but my Grandma can't speak Hindi.
It is gud enough , continue with english as official n follow the respected regional states languages as official,
No need any national language...
If it works now then I think that's fine too. No reason to impose a strict language over everyone
You see we don’t like imposition of anything whether it be language, religion or food. Our languages are intimately connected to our culture and our culture is extremely important to us. We preserved it throughout the 1000 years of islamic rule and we will certainly preserve it in independent india. We don’t want to be like bihar.They have lost their identity. It’s sad how such a great land with so much history, which was once a beacon of indian culture has been turned into what it is today. Besides, my grandmothers ancestral home has more history than modern hindi (no offense). I can speak and understand hindi. I have no problems using it. It’s taught in schools here in my state. But that’s about where i draw the line.
u were able to preserve ur languages and temples because North and Deccan protected you, as simple as that
@@extraordinarygamer937 lol how? Did you guys beg the invaders to not invade the south after you guys failed miserably against them? 😂 Why don't you come up with a better story. You couldn't even protect yourself let alone others
@@antiwokehuman we did not fail u ungrateful loser, we resisted by constant rebellions that's why no Invader was able to hold on South for long, if it was not for Shivaji Raje you would be speaking Urdu by now and offering prayers in a mosque. You were simply lucky by being far away from Delhi. You fell like pack of cards when Brits with Modern guns arrived so yeah, if it was not for North Indian Kings and rebellions you losers were long gone. Just because a cuck like u is deluded ungratefully will not change history, u had protection from North hence u thrived
@antiwokehuman... reading both your reactions was like an ouch moment for me 😅😂 but I go with you because i found it really stupid what @extraordinarygamer937 said, he maybe somewhat or somewhere right, but the way he put it across really deserved your response 😂😂😂 because what he said was like we didn't have any rulers in the south who protected us and only rulers n people in the north are our saviour 😂😂
@@antiwokehuman I wrote a lengthy response but coward ass YT deleted it, I said it before and I will say it again. You are ungrateful sore b@st@rd, North Indians were constantly in rebellion that's why they could not always control the South. If anyone failed it was you, always boasting how old our language is but nobody in the entire world believe in your delusions, kinda like how h!tler started believing his own propoganda that's what happened with you. Yes the fact is had it not been North Indians and Shivaji your clown a$$ language would have been long replaced by Arabic or Persian
language is a sensitive issue but, even though i want all languages to prosper, as long as india as a republic remains, eventually all people will speak hindi and english both,
it will happen naturally, if want to survive u have to go out of your town, village, u will see hindi english in media, bollywood, hoardings all around u. u will speak it and speak it by your own will
i don't have problem with any language, not even english, afterall it is an offshoot of the same indo european language family.
humans evolve and do languages we can't control it, also in current times east west north northeast central india every where hindi and english is growing, in south also there is growth but slow
49:00 is exactly the point of the video . Language must be preserved . Every language is beautiful in their own way. Dont keep the languages in own big umbrella . Hope our government learn from this and do something to preseve these languages
40:15
No u understood that right, the auto-translation is wrong
Hope you found it interesting
Bhojpuri is official language of nepal and fiji . And also spoken in Trinidad and tobaggo,guyana, suriname, Mauritius
For your information, Indians have communciated with each other for thousands of years, long before English came into being.
Uttar means North.
This person has not given the correct explanations. So just take it lightly. 3% is correct. Urdu language developed in Lucknow city in India NOT in Pakistan.
I would like to state that I liked the original video as well as your reaction or perhaps its our common linguistic interest, the translations ware wrong on many occasions in the duration of the video, but yes as an Indian living in india I do speak Chhattisgarhi I might be the only Chhattisgarhi speaker in your comment section also because in Chhattisgarh also people speak regional languages and dilects obviously. Other Chhattisgarhis please reply to this comment.
Chhattisgarhi is dying for the same reason stated in the video as I am writing this while watching this video.
Yes it's unfortunate that the subtitles were incorrect but I was able to get a good understanding despite this. His newer videos have actual English subtitles so it is much better.
Thank you for watching! I always enjoy hearing about people and their language they speak
That auto translate is atrocious, the subtitle is exactly opposite of what was spoken several times. Now I'm starting to wonder if the European language videos I watched with auto-translated subtitles were this bad.
Yeah it is really bad sometimes. I got a better understanding just listening to him talk and looking at the video lol
Bottom line is so cAlled fight against hindi imposition is just another tool in political arsenal of regional political parties(most national parties advocate for hindi as connecting language rather than english) which most of these critics leave out intentionally
As for the dialect i speak more english than hindi but mosty hindi speaker i understand bhojpuri,haryanvi,urdu(since im from up) punjabi(60-70%) so you cant say they are not dialect of hindi
And everyone is like that at least here in North cities I would say Hindi has helped to create composite culture here there are all kinds of songs in parties be it haryanvi punjabi bhojpuri and there is hardly ever any hindi song nagin is exception😅 Bhojpuri people celebrate chhat, up and haryanvi cebrrate godhan Punjabi celebrate Lohri in their respective languages isn't that what we want or you just want people to be secluded?
50:04 baduga and toda languages are still speaking i tamil nadu
I am belong from bhojpur region and my family members leave in Garhwali speeking region 😂
Your title is grossly wrong. Hindi is India's national lamguage. So, what takeover are you talking about? Change your title of the video.
Brother, I am from Uttarakhand and we mainly speak Pahari (Gadhwali ,Kumaoni) here, but the government did not recognize it here and made Hindi and Sanskrit the official language of my state and my mother used to tell me that when she was in school her government teachers used to give her homework for writing essays about "Hindi hamari matra basha hai "isn't it an imposition?😢
It is an imposition I don't know when you guys will understand. And hindi is not a national language. Instead of asking someone else to correct, first you learn.
Hindi is the national language of one nation I.e Imagination.
I'm here a Hindi man😂
I can 80% understand bhojpuri and bagdi too easy to understand bro and u r saying it's hard 😂😂 no way
Do you know if the dalai llama is connected to India? Do you know where he lives ? Fantastic videos anyway.
he is from Tibet but lives in Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh
We northeast, india mostly speak english n native language
Hindi is most hatred language of india 🇮🇳..
Hindi language don't have older history.. Hindi and urdu both are two sides of one coin..
Stop this politics, Hindi, Tamil, Bengali everything is Indian language, we are all Indian.
hindi is not at all hated...pls dont spread mis info
I have no issue with Hindi
I don't see people hating Hindi this days
It is just a language to communicate with each other
History doesn't matter if is old or new
But even 17th century it's more than 300 years history of Hindi
new but not very new
South Indians like you are the most hated people of India
Indian doesn't have ONE strict official language in the country, but HINDI is considered as a national language due to largely spoken and understandable by almost all Indians.
I don’t know what defines “strict” but Hindi and English are recognized as Official Languages and No Single Language is named as a “National Language”. Hindi is not a National Language, it is widely spoken and understood in North India but that changes when you go South where other than regional languages, English is more widely spoken and understood than Hindi.
If you wanna know about Indian history plz watch any english video on youtube as you can understand it easily. You're actually learning nothing from this hindi video as you are not understanding it properly.
Putting different dialects under Hindi is same as what China does when they put different dialects under single Mandarin. It brings more uniformity, and if government of India wants they can actually extend the Hindi dialect range too, the offical number still puts Hindi at only 40% of India but in relaity it's easily 60-70%
What is Indo Aryan ??! Aryan Invasion theory scientifically debunked.
All are north indian side people are aryan ( migrant people)
@@bhavesh3729 check Rakhi Ghari archeological and DNA evidence.
@@bhavesh3729 Then why the fak they dont look like europeans
english is the multiversal/default language
Watch vox series on election in india. India have world largest election this year
Fun fact the oldest language in the world is tamil 😊
Correction Sanskrit is the oldest language spoken and Tamil is the oldest script language
Fun fact for lie likers
Ceremonial language was the word? Like traditional costumes... video.seems biased...most states have many languages n dialects eg Karnataka has kannada tulu konkani...konkani is state language o Goa but a dialect in neighboring Maharashtra
Hindi is destroying Marathi 😢
It's not but you're definitely an ignorant person.
The Hindi you're talking about is the Bollywood version which is actually Urdu+Hindi.
I suggest you stop watching Bollywood trash.
I'm from Punjab and I'm fluent in English Hindi & Punjabi. We speak Hindi in Punjab and never claim Punjabi is being by Hindi.
It's not. Only mumbai and pune . Rest of maha doesn't understand nor give a F about Hindi. But like south indians we should stop responding in Hindi. Outsiders need to learn our language not the other way round.
😂... is Hindi taking over India? Is English taking over America da. Hindi is India's national language. There are other languages but Hindi has always been the primary language above it is of course Sanskrit from which Hindi comes.
All of North India speaks multiple dilects of Hindi. Yes Hindi has multiple dilects too 😂... Khadi boli, Maghi, Bhojpur... etc just like in the USA you have different dilects and tones in, which English is spoken... for e.g in New York you would have a different English pronunciation and expressions than in Boston, Texas, California, Colorado, Alaska... in India there are 1000s of sub-sub regional languages all coming from Sanskrit - Hindi.
You need education. Hindi is not the national language of india.
Tamil is more than 5000 years old
Hindi ke liye aapna mother culture, tradition, language ko protect nahi kare?😢
East west north south - uttar dakshin purav pashim
It is thekku, vadakku, kizhakku and merkku .
People who thinks Hindi is imposed forcely have never read Indian constitution properly. Article 351 in Constitution of India
351. Directive for development of the Hindi language
It shall be the duty of the Union to promote the spread of the Hindi language, to develop it so that it may serve as a medium of expression for all the elements of the composite culture of India and to secure its enrichment by assimilating without interfering with its genius, the forms, style and expressions used in Hindustani and in the other languages of India specified in the Eighth Schedule, and by drawing, wherever necessary or desirable, for its vocabulary, primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages.
That is why consitution need to be amended to promote India language instead of Mulla-Madrrassuh language.
@@jayasangarnarayanan8743 Hindi is an Indian language originated in India.
@@STARK50 False British created Hindi from Urdu and the man who did it was JOHN B GILCHRIST. The ugly history of Hindi cannot be erased by bluffers.
Telugu is oldest language
Telugu is? I thought Tamil was
Tamil❤️👍
Next video must be.. why can't Pakistan don't grow inspite of 99% Muslims ...... And Follower of Quran
Hindi is the most closest to Sanskrit
No its not
Odiya is most closest to Sanskrit, followed by Kashmiri & Bengali
Absolutely not .. Hindi is made from the Hindustani langauge and it has so many imported words from Turkic and Arabic langauge..
Bengali is the closest langauge to Sanskrit, anybody who speaks Bengali can understand some Sanskrit because the "A" shwa sound in Sanskrit is replaced with "O", otherwise everything is same from Grammer to vocabs
Nope,
Forget odia, even Kannada and telugu, which have more Sanskrit words than Hindi.
@@spilltea4241 🤣🤣🤣🤣 odia not even came from Sanskrit, u can see it's written version more closer to Dravidian language
@@attitudeshorts6413 it's because Dravidian dialect mix with indo Aryan language with the time
@lfc_rushar. You are wrong. Not everyone can understand all languages if they know Hindi. Some can only know and understand Hindi but not grasp the other languages like bihari, bhojpuri, haryanvi, Punjabi, Gujarati, marwadi, Bengali, odia, pahadi etc.
And @sornaveln6019 you are wrong too. I am from South India, my mother tongue is Kannada, but I can understand Tamil, Malayalam, Telugu, Gujarati, Punjabi, Bengali, bit of bihari/bhojpuri, I can read write and converse in Hindi. People say if u know Sanskrit you can connect with Hindi, Marathi, Bengali and kannada words to understand the meaning. I don't know Sanskrit but I can definitely understand a lot of languages.
Also, telling everyone generally, don't assume people in the south don't understand Hindi. Most of them do. But they choose not to because people who come to work here don't even try to learn the local language and also many are arrogant as to why should I learn. Hence even though we (atleast in Bangalore) try to accommodate and speak to people in all the possible languages but are not respected, we started rebelling that Hindi is not our language, if u want to communicate then learn our language 😊