Really, because the biggest crook is crying after bringing so many crooked laws in his time to loot and development was only in his hidden bank accounts abroad.
When Chimbu was fin minister Inflation was in double digits... Ghotalebaz... Indian economy was classified among fragile 5 economies of the world during UPA. Nirmalaji is doing much better job of managing economy than Chimbu ever did... India has highest forex reserves ever. India's trade deficit is rapidly decreasing. India is fiscal deficit is decreasing and India has achieved its highest ever international credit rating.
@@Real982ax so why should tax payers take the burden??? People go to Dubai and earn 5-6 lakhs per month and send back money tax free.why don't govt tax them?? Tax farmers and businessman
@@SirajGupta-ob1nx not true. Only they escape from income tax which is not a lot considering how many people actually income pay tax. But they still pay taxes for everything else. Government should tax corporates who have seen their revenue quadrupled in last decade and stop writing off their loans
- I pay 30% income tax - I pay 18% , 28% GST - I pay 20% Short term Capital Gains tax - I pay 12.5% Long term capital gains tax - I pay TDS on consulting assignments - I pay VAT , service tax And I get half of my salary for potholed roads , traffic jams , polluted air and bribes for getting work done And organisations like BCCI do thousands of crores in revenue , stay in 5 star hotels , travel to develop countries , hire film stars for shows Pay 0% tax because it’s a charitable organisation India is clearly not for beginners 😂
If we listen to Chidambaram sir ,the more one will feel to listen to him ,Excellent analysis,show his depth of knowledge.let him have a long long life,so that our country get benefits
@@manjunathmnm probably unlikely, Budget is for redistribution of money from one sector to another. Many things were brought up to light in this budget for example employment and benefits to startups etc, so yeah they had to take away the money from somewhere else which turned out to be from Investors. And for ordinary people nothing much will change unless they are into investment and that sort of stuff. "Reallocation" is the only thing anyone should not forget on any budget announcement
This man is a gem. When this man is picked by the biggest economist of 20th century Dr. Manmohan Singh, you honour him to the fullest. This man deserves more than he has received till now. Respect to you sir P.C. Chidambaram.
This is the kind of opposition we need! Thoughtful critique, precise arguments, and, above all, the ability to compel the government to reconsider the budget. It's a unfortunate that 90% of the population won't hear these valuable insights and feedback.
@@anupalchoudhury I understand why you praising the opposition for this constructive criticism as never such constructive talk was heard from the treasury benches (aka ruling party)
The opposition always has suggestions, it's a shame the ruling had shied away from discussion on important legislations & decisions. If you take even 20 minutes to go through the Congress manifesto, one can see the erudite, composed and experienced minds at play. 🙏
@@NeophyteCounsel that's why atal ji is and will be considered the best ever PM of india...he not only listened to opposition and made changes whichever were essential but also more importantly he respected his opposition unlike many other ruling parties who think they r the boss...
but sadly couldn't apply anything during his tenure, sadly India had an inflation of 9-10% during his term but I think that was okay?! and still Sitharaman is worst FM!! the way you all are criticizing the whole budget, i bet you wouldn't have actually read the complete budget by yourself, let alone getting to the actual facts and do analysis by yourself
But do not forget that it was this same Chidambaram who questioned the validity of UPI! He's what's called a foolish intellectual! He was way off the point in 2014!
@@kishkindhaa Agreed Lmao. But yah thats just opposition opposing to something that has not a fixed predictable outcome. I am sure that was stupid of them, even I criticize that but this specific topic is just logically direct. Anything he has mentioned about taxes, and inflation for example are true and will have a direct impact on the people. I am neither a fan of him nor Mrs. Sitaraman here. ps: I haven't yet fully reviewed the budget, but I am sure the highlight has been Employment. I will review it well, but this is by far my opinion.
Then you want to vote the worst looters who are creating division (based on language like in tn and karnataka), based on quote like in karnataka, apacement like in wb and karnataka, development of enemy nation like china, no border infrastructure for the fear of aggregating the enemy, ignoring me including Manipur for many years, article 370 killing innocent erc. One is kursi bachao and another is kursi khicho. FYI I am a christian.
Thanks to Chidambaram. This is what we call Experience, coming from an elderly gentleman. My respects. We should not look at which party, an experienced man comes from, but the Nation requires such experienced persons to guide the people. Jai Hind ! .
you jokers cant realize he said UPI and GST wont work. He swindled crores of public money to his kids business. Shame that you support such characters.
@@Fdsyhhgh do you expect defence minister to be able to shoot a gun or do you expect him to be able to provide leadership to an able team.. being good in subject knowledge has nothing to do with being a good leader.. for me, under her leadership, the economy is in good shape.. that's all matters to me. don't forget, its easy to come prepared with set of question, but its impossible to answer on the same spot to such stupid questions. I'm sure she will give a befitting reply in her next session.
@@566sandeep that is being a visionary. Yes, Chidambaram is not a visionary, but that doesn't discredit his education and ground-level knowledge that enabled him to form these valid points of arguments (and also inconsistencies)
@@selvingreen3585 his ground level knowledge and education also enabled him to term the whole concept of GST as stupid.. while it has been proven with data that GST on ground is much better earlier taxation process (Before u jump the gun,not saying GST cant be improved) And the educated fellow dint tell his party during 2024 elections that the promises of free goodies the party is making will require budget of 90+ lakh crores, more than 2.5 times countries GDP… He is no genius or visionary or ground level person.. he is just one politician, who currently is in opposition and by default has to criticise each and every step of other side
Is that why India was struggling so bad in economics and riddled with scams in congress era? Maybe you read more than you listen you will know his track record.
@@566sandeep Very true, lungi wala bggr does not say population over growth is the cause of unemployement. All these calculations mean better when there is a limit to over populate the country else we will spiral down to hell.
@@gauravgupta322It was 3 times better than the current situation. Everything was more affordable back then. Now everything costs a huge amount of taxes be it your income or any necessity products.
Someone cherished 'Best finance minister ever' in very first time when he stood up. Although listening to the whole speech of this budget debate, indeed he is the best ever of my generation & we need Finance minister like P. Chidambaram who have a well knowledge how to run a country instead of how to kursi bachani hai
middile class ke liye budget mein kabhi kuch nhi milega, aur aap growing economy hai tab to bilkul bhi nhi, kyunki middile class ko growth nhi chahiye inko bas subsidies aur relaxations chahiye hota hai har jagah.
Very valuable points raised. Unemployment and inflation are the serious issues. If the government is very serious of development, then the unemployment and inflation will automatically come down.
Thank you sir for all the very important demands of Indian citizens . Once again I thank you sir fir supporting the public. You voice is of 140 crime people .
Excellent speech! Hats off to you Chidambaram Sir. I am from Tamil-Nadu, and you have made us proud! Even the opposition looks at him with admiration and respect for his wisdom and well researched truth!
Sir 1)Rice -Rs. 50/kg 2)Atta- Rs.55/kg 3)Dal- Rs 130/kg 4)M.oil -Rs. 150/kg 5)Gas - Rs.1103 to 1200/cylinder 6)Ghee- Rs. 680/kg 7)Milk - Rs.- 80/lit 8)Daniya- Rs. 400/kg 9)Jeera - Rs. 900/kg 10)Chilli powder - Rs.650/kg 12)Tata salt - Rs. 30/kg 13)Vegetables - Too high 14)Fish -Minimum Rs. 300/ kg 15)Meat (chicken ) - more than Rs. 300/kg 16) Fruits -Rs. too high 17)Electric bill - too high 18)Property tax- too high 17)Train fare- increasing 18)Flights fare- Too high 19)Medicines price - touch the sky 20)Every medical expenditure - touch the sky. 21)Patrol -Rs.100/lit 22)Diesel- Rs. 95/lit 23)Agricultural cost- too high 24) Education cost - Rs. Too high as the schools are upgraded private. 25) Egg - Rs. 70 (Deshi), Rs. 35 ( boiler) 26)Material of building Price - touch the sky. Bricks - Rs 15/ pice Cement - more than Rs. 500/ pkd Rod- Too high Sand Rs. 9000/ truck But Sir, the fact is that the monthly income of common people is very very low.Only a few are taking honey and they are enjoying themselves.
Now ×2 and that's the price you will get in Manipur. Price of land which cose 5 lakhs is now 25 lakhs. Meat-500+ bricks and cement twice the amount of Delhi. Etc. the only stable job is a government job excluding the state which only the person with money and relationship with the officials get. Now tell me is inflation nothing. 95+% of the population earn through daily wages. If the people in other states are suffering then what about us
Bruh are u bot ? Lol where the fack are u buying atta for 55 , gas for 1100, milk 80 ,tata salt 30 ,chicken for 300 stop lying. Give factual info and edit it .stop these shitty propaganda
What a gentleman and for once i was taken back to those good old days when our lawmakers were really debating. Hopefully we will see a vibrant parliament in the future which will help our country grow. Jai Hind
One of the most amazing speech i have heard till date. He is an experienced ex-finance minister who knew just what to say and to the point putting across every points needed to be asked and showing the reality of india to the current finance minister guiding her what she should be doing... Hope sutaraman gets her lesson, or ready to be insulted by the people of india everywhere. Lots of Respect for chidambaram sir.. jai samvidhan 👏🙌❤️🔥🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Yea makes sense why India was called one of the five fragile economies with double digit inflation and moderate growth when he was the FM along with multiple scams on every single scheme and project that congress govt undertook lol
Knowledgeable person speak with humility, humbleness even while criticizing the announced budget. We need him back as our Finance minister in future for sure.
And knowledgable person was in jail for his over smartness. Chor Chidu. He looted enough and if these people had used their knowledge right way things would have better.
@@venkatadinesh3495 Its so sad that they chose the party of reservations over the party of riches. I would still prefer the elite party over the inequality party
He is right. 1) unemployment crisis is visible. How ELI work when companies are facing crisis self 2) Tomato price in my area remained 80-100rs since April. Potato price 180-200rs/5kg. We all criticize government when it claims there is no inflation and job crisis. PEOPLE ARE NOT BLIND MA'AM. MIDDLE CLASS LOST BELIEVE IN MODI GOVERNMENT. IT IS REALITY
00:03 Former Finance Minister emphasizes on employment linked incentives and Congress Manifesto ideas 03:59 Challenges in job creation and implementation of employment schemes 07:25 Unemployment and inflation are critical issues ignored in the budget. 10:36 Inflation remains a concern for India's economy 13:50 Questioning the adoption of low deflator by the Finance Minister 16:28 Ex-Finance Minister critiques relief given in new tax regime 19:26 Addressing poverty concerns in India's population 22:17 Non-BJP states facing financial discrimination 25:05 Demand for key reforms and responses from the Finance Minister
What a beautiful speech by Mr Chidambaram ! Within this 10 years we could not noticed such type of speech from PM or any other Ministers. This is what education is.
@@hetpatel7656 It was only bad during last two years - 13 and 14. India has the highest growth rate for longest period during first 8 years of UPA gov.
Excellent speech by former FM impregnated with clarity of thoughts.His oratory is a class apart! I wish he were FM.Also,I wish in India,govt.should include such eminent persons in cabinet irrespective of their party affiliations by making constitutional amendments!!
@@ALIYYILA Cope hard - he has NEVER conducted an unscripted press conference in public or participated in debates with the opposition. Such a big wuss, charlatan & an actor -> Should've been in Bollywood instead of destroying a nation with fascist tendencies.
If the so called Finance Minister knows anything about Finance and Taxation, she may have been able to respond/say something. Some say "Ignorance is Bliss"!
@@SADHAM671117 modi talksss high about no corruption or corrupted politicians or politics but BJP HAD MOST JOINS OF CORRUPTED LEADERS IN THE LAST 10YEARS. IF ANY ONE WITH CORRUPTION CHARGES, ED , CBI CASES JOINS BJP. THEN THEY BECOME GAUTAM BUDDHAS AND CLEAN N CLEAR. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤯🤯🤯🤯 WHAT KIND OF FAKE PARTY N FALSE TALKS MODI IS
Do you think she is the REAL finance minister. I believe she is blank because the budget is prepared at PMO and she just reads it out. She is a spokesperson of the government like all other ministers..real work is done by bureaucrats controlled by PMO. Gadkari and Shah may be an exception.
@@critic7408she is representing. And elected as fm. We don't even know buraucrates name so how we rise questions. Bjp not selecting qualified people now she know she is puppet who cant even fulfill her role
Regardless of who is right or wrong.. bt Present FM has an Economics background bro.. n Former FM is a Lawyer.. i do understand n agree Budget is all messed up.. bt economy background wud suffice to understand wat 1 stupid lawyer can tell abt Inflation or economy
I am glad the VP respected the senior member Chidambaram sir and listened to him gladly and didn’t treated him like the other members of the opposition
Madam ji last time said she doesn’t eat onions when asked about skyrocketing onion price, hope this time she doesn’t say she that she is on water diet so she doesn’t know the prices of commodities
That we r treating as a meme..actually that was a castesist slur..that is she from a family who doesnt have onion..but it was not discussed nor she made to apologize
@@mohithpm4954 Leave it. When half of the Indians have their brahminical pride without actually doing that brahmins used to do, what can u expect of a leader chosen by the same people. Birds of feather flock together
best speech however his tiem the inflation was 12%...banks had the highest NPA in history...his auntys time the income tax rates were 90% (1971-72)..still we had 1991 situation...lets follwo what he says...
Ahhhh...more satisfying seing Chairman himself respect personally Chidambaram ji. A point raised also impressed every member in the House, so much smooth!!!
I don't think Ex FM is not fit for that position as i still remember his comments on UPI "do you pay on upi after buying tomatoes" Yes i do pay even ₹5 on UPI...
@@durgaprasad2508 Dear friend, pease diversify your speeches. You will get more good insights. Mr. P. Chidambaram is a good intellectual orator. However, you should inculcate the habit of diversification.
@@pradeep080the inflation rate during p Chidambaram's tenure was constantly around 4.55%- 5% every month , and the lowest inflation rate recorded was 1.75% the 12% inflation rate was just for a very brief period of time it was just a spike due to "global financial crisis" do not spread fake news on internet.
@@pradeep080 Do not spread misinformation on the internet During P. Chidambaram's tenure the inflation rate of india was comparatively lower as compared to nirmala sitaraman's being finance minister , the lowest recorded inflation rate during P. Chidambram's tenure was 1.75% and the 12% you're talking about was just a spike due to the "Global financial crisis" you cannot blame a finance minister for the global financial crisis and increasing commodities prices at a global scale. The thing that worries me is that at his moment there is no global crisis in financials as well as commodities prices are falling globally while the inflation is rising in India.
@@HWK_venom Mr.phaykinfospreader during Chidambaram tenure average inflation was around 10%... An online look up will easily show that info... The average inflation for the Financial year 2013-2014 was 10%. Global economic crisis was in 2008.
I was a hardcore BJP supporter , listening to opposition for the first time , I think he makes sense. She does not deserve even to be an MP let alone FM.
Arrogance fades easily before calm, logical and intellectually sound address. Ex- FM H'ble P. Chidambaram with his experience and well analysed articulation of his speech the economic disparity imposed by this government. We don't need arrogant Finance Minister like N. Sitharaman. We need P. Chidambaram as a Finance Minister.
When Congress was in power. We know all the allied parties how much looted. Corruption terrorism. This chidambaram holding more than 60000crores of corrupted money. You just re enquire the congress government. Everyone of the opponent looted this nation. This data any economist can give. Chidambaram is 420. you all peoples do not know. Considering only the current situation.
That's constructive criticism. The government should be humble enough to accept those suggestions for the sake of the nation.
Really, because the biggest crook is crying after bringing so many crooked laws in his time to loot and development was only in his hidden bank accounts abroad.
They won't
Because they are with coperates
Bhai They be able to handle this constructive feedback
When Chimbu was fin minister Inflation was in double digits... Ghotalebaz... Indian economy was classified among fragile 5 economies of the world during UPA. Nirmalaji is doing much better job of managing economy than Chimbu ever did... India has highest forex reserves ever. India's trade deficit is rapidly decreasing. India is fiscal deficit is decreasing and India has achieved its highest ever international credit rating.
@@cgtim3230 RBI ko credit jata hai .. finance minister ka nai
Budget 2024 in a nutshell
Taxes like america
Services like somalia
What is your annual income . Only 2 crore people pay income tax in our country . In us 20 crore people pay income taxes .
@@Real982ax 100% in India pay exorbitant Ji ST/Ni ST. Don't you know?
@@Real982ax so why should tax payers take the burden??? People go to Dubai and earn 5-6 lakhs per month and send back money tax free.why don't govt tax them?? Tax farmers and businessman
@@SirajGupta-ob1nx not true. Only they escape from income tax which is not a lot considering how many people actually income pay tax. But they still pay taxes for everything else. Government should tax corporates who have seen their revenue quadrupled in last decade and stop writing off their loans
@@Real982ax your idea of taxes only considers income tax??😂😂
Chidambaram was so smooth with his facts and figures....even sitharaman wishes I could have asked him to finalize the budget
@@ayanusmani886 chidambaram was so smooth in his corruption carrier
Chidambaram Sir introduced F&O trading in India and reduced capital gain tax from 10% to 0% , which BJP later reversed back to 18%
@@smalltrader1097 yeh sir &(proxis) can take positions prior and monetise. Your sir bhoo. Corrupt chettiyar
@@sreelakamhome you live in 2024 or 2014?
@@sreelakamhome tu apne ma ke godh me Laut ja fir se baccha ban k
Back then with 20k salary I can Run my family for 1months but now with 37k salary it’s becoming hard to manage.
It's the same story with many 😢
Before how many years?
The government is unable to control inflation, and probably doesnt even know the meaning of the word "Inflation"!
Not even with 1 lakh
Bro I can't even with more than 80k
- I pay 30% income tax
- I pay 18% , 28% GST
- I pay 20% Short term Capital Gains tax
- I pay 12.5% Long term capital gains tax
- I pay TDS on consulting assignments
- I pay VAT , service tax
And I get half of my salary for potholed roads , traffic jams , polluted air and bribes for getting work done
And organisations like BCCI do thousands of crores in revenue , stay in 5 star hotels , travel to develop countries , hire film stars for shows
Pay 0% tax because it’s a charitable organisation
India is clearly not for beginners 😂
India is not for intermediate. For beginners it gives freebies and for advanced it licks their boots.
btw these is no VAT fyi
but bro, I support ur take on BCCI
When govt rule by billionaire mind always like benefit for themself
Copied comment from LinkedIn
If we listen to Chidambaram sir ,the more one will feel to listen to him ,Excellent analysis,show his depth of knowledge.let him have a long long life,so that our country get benefits
This is what we want from opposition!! Constructive criticism, to the point argument and more than anything force govt to revisit budget
But most often the opposition just shamelessly walk out. I want them to question just like he did now
@@alok.01But the problem is will the government revisit ?
@@manjunathmnm probably unlikely, Budget is for redistribution of money from one sector to another. Many things were brought up to light in this budget for example employment and benefits to startups etc, so yeah they had to take away the money from somewhere else which turned out to be from Investors. And for ordinary people nothing much will change unless they are into investment and that sort of stuff. "Reallocation" is the only thing anyone should not forget on any budget announcement
He never criticized the khatakhat schemes in Congress manifesto, which would have caused hyper-inflation.
@@alok.01Even more often, Speaker didn't allow Congress to debate on important issues in Parliament.
This is the difference between educated minister and rubber stamp minister
Onion and garlic minister😂
First he should explain scam
Let's not forget the PM whose manufactured Masters in ' Entire Political Science' is a badly forged joke.
Oi tell the congress minister to uncover all scams then he can talk about others
@@techeves6024 diabolical
This man is a gem. When this man is picked by the biggest economist of 20th century Dr. Manmohan Singh, you honour him to the fullest.
This man deserves more than he has received till now. Respect to you sir P.C. Chidambaram.
I agree
@@the_1_nemesis this FM lady is zero compared to any other past FM
@anishbacal9366 can't agree more. 👍
This is the kind of opposition we need! Thoughtful critique, precise arguments, and, above all, the ability to compel the government to reconsider the budget. It's a unfortunate that 90% of the population won't hear these valuable insights and feedback.
Bas kar Babu sarkar tanashah ke haath me hai tu sarkar se kya umeed karta hai bol
Just watch the views it's more like 99%
@@anupalchoudhury I understand why you praising the opposition for this constructive criticism as never such constructive talk was heard from the treasury benches (aka ruling party)
yess yessss true i can relate, because if i were to contd my science background - i don't think i'll ever get to this kind of stuff
We need better and efficient government. If the present govt can't even do the basic job well then it is not worthy of being in power.
Chidambaram analysed the budget systematically & i want such kind of questions & solutions for issues from opposition.
The opposition always has suggestions, it's a shame the ruling had shied away from discussion on important legislations & decisions. If you take even 20 minutes to go through the Congress manifesto, one can see the erudite, composed and experienced minds at play. 🙏
@@NeophyteCounselfor looting the country
@@NeophyteCounselat play ….planning the next scam
@@NeophyteCounsel that's why atal ji is and will be considered the best ever PM of india...he not only listened to opposition and made changes whichever were essential but also more importantly he respected his opposition unlike many other ruling parties who think they r the boss...
but sadly couldn't apply anything during his tenure, sadly India had an inflation of 9-10% during his term but I think that was okay?! and still Sitharaman is worst FM!! the way you all are criticizing the whole budget, i bet you wouldn't have actually read the complete budget by yourself, let alone getting to the actual facts and do analysis by yourself
The speaker himself is learning the real consequences of the present budget from PC with his full attention.
I wish I talk like Chidambaram , precise and straight to point
But do not forget that it was this same Chidambaram who questioned the validity of UPI! He's what's called a foolish intellectual! He was way off the point in 2014!
❤❤❤
@@kishkindhaa Agreed Lmao. But yah thats just opposition opposing to something that has not a fixed predictable outcome. I am sure that was stupid of them, even I criticize that but this specific topic is just logically direct. Anything he has mentioned about taxes, and inflation for example are true and will have a direct impact on the people.
I am neither a fan of him nor Mrs. Sitaraman here.
ps: I haven't yet fully reviewed the budget, but I am sure the highlight has been Employment. I will review it well, but this is by far my opinion.
@kishkindhaa also don't forget nirmala sitharaman's statements.
I don't eat onions, rupee is not weaker dollar is getting stronger!
Then you want to vote the worst looters who are creating division (based on language like in tn and karnataka), based on quote like in karnataka, apacement like in wb and karnataka, development of enemy nation like china, no border infrastructure for the fear of aggregating the enemy, ignoring me including Manipur for many years, article 370 killing innocent erc. One is kursi bachao and another is kursi khicho. FYI I am a christian.
Thanks to Chidambaram. This is what we call Experience, coming from an elderly gentleman. My respects. We should not look at which party, an experienced man comes from, but the Nation requires such experienced persons to guide the people. Jai Hind !
.
haha during 2013 the experience gentleman had us in 12% inflation...:P he must have confused it for interest rate..:P
you jokers cant realize he said UPI and GST wont work. He swindled crores of public money to his kids business. Shame that you support such characters.
@@pradeep080ha ha how great is it now jerk
@@postwala2667same question to you too jack
Chidambaram or Sita none r fit , both had their chance and yet indian 90% your remains unemployed and Rations r being distributed
Hon’ble Finance minister is living in a bubble and she understands nothing about Inflation or Economy. We need more educated Finance ministers
Pm like educated rahul.. some fraud fm..
She came and presented the budget prepared by a panel and sitting in the parliament
She read Economics and business administration and he was a lawyer. Who would you trust with Economy?
I doubt she is even an economist
@@Fdsyhhgh do you expect defence minister to be able to shoot a gun or do you expect him to be able to provide leadership to an able team.. being good in subject knowledge has nothing to do with being a good leader.. for me, under her leadership, the economy is in good shape.. that's all matters to me. don't forget, its easy to come prepared with set of question, but its impossible to answer on the same spot to such stupid questions. I'm sure she will give a befitting reply in her next session.
The more I listen honorable Chidambaran, the more I realized what an educated n gentlemen he is...
@@jayantatalukdar4899 same intelligent person mocked UPI and laughed if road side vendors will use UPI..
@@566sandeep that is being a visionary. Yes, Chidambaram is not a visionary, but that doesn't discredit his education and ground-level knowledge that enabled him to form these valid points of arguments (and also inconsistencies)
@@selvingreen3585 his ground level knowledge and education also enabled him to term the whole concept of GST as stupid.. while it has been proven with data that GST on ground is much better earlier taxation process (Before u jump the gun,not saying GST cant be improved)
And the educated fellow dint tell his party during 2024 elections that the promises of free goodies the party is making will require budget of 90+ lakh crores, more than 2.5 times countries GDP…
He is no genius or visionary or ground level person.. he is just one politician, who currently is in opposition and by default has to criticise each and every step of other side
Is that why India was struggling so bad in economics and riddled with scams in congress era? Maybe you read more than you listen you will know his track record.
@@566sandeep Very true, lungi wala bggr does not say population over growth is the cause of unemployement. All these calculations mean better when there is a limit to over populate the country else we will spiral down to hell.
Excellent speech by the Hon'ble former finance minister.
Excellent speech by P. chidambaram.
Will there be any answer from the FM's heart. I doubt.
I haven't seen this lady respond yet, she just keeps sitting with Doraemon playing in her mind.😂
@@itsbabumusay she is anti employee anti salaried anti poor anti federal and jumlebaaz
@@itsbabumusay lol
She's a sleeping partner to the economy of India - she'll snore her way through this debacle.
Please stop eating onions and put an end to critisism!!
This is the difference Between Finance minister and Tax Minister....
Look at the economic condition during the Ex FM tenure ☠️
@@gauravgupta322better than todays condition☠️
@@gauravgupta322 well since you are rich brat you will not be affected by this.
So plz sit down and dont talk
@@gauravgupta322It was 3 times better than the current situation. Everything was more affordable back then. Now everything costs a huge amount of taxes be it your income or any necessity products.
@@EnMilgre88 some tasks become tougher to perform when you go out of mediocrity. Have you ever worked in a growing startup?
Someone cherished 'Best finance minister ever' in very first time when he stood up. Although listening to the whole speech of this budget debate, indeed he is the best ever of my generation & we need Finance minister like P. Chidambaram who have a well knowledge how to run a country instead of how to kursi bachani hai
Great Presentation - simple to understand
a failed self styled economist giving lectures when he gifted india with double digit inflation and scams.
Exelent looter on bail
@@Bhagya.Solankiwhat he said is truth.. Just read economic data when Congress ruled during 2004-14..
Very well said Mr. Chidambaram , great reply to FM Nirmala Sitharaman ... Nothing for MIDDLE CLASS BUDGET
middile class ke liye budget mein kabhi kuch nhi milega, aur aap growing economy hai tab to bilkul bhi nhi, kyunki middile class ko growth nhi chahiye inko bas subsidies aur relaxations chahiye hota hai har jagah.
@@pushkarbisht5113that's true and that's not a bad thing. Middle class people just want something in return for the tax they Paying.
Very valuable points raised. Unemployment and inflation are the serious issues. If the government is very serious of development, then the unemployment and inflation will automatically come down.
Unfortunate that these arguments and feedback will not reach to 90% population
unke liye Mandir banaya hua hai
For them honorable Modi ji will sell "Vishwa Guru in another 10 years"
Because they’ll be happy with hindu mandir built by Modi to attract them.
@@d4dexter308 AUR MASZID BHI
More like 99%
I felt dizzy listening to those terms and numbers.Such a knowledgeable person Sir. Salute to you Sir.
U eyes rounded 😅 while listening chidambaram speech in rajyasabha
Thank you sir for all the very important demands of Indian citizens . Once again I thank you sir fir supporting the public. You voice is of 140 crime people .
Excellent speech! Hats off to you Chidambaram Sir. I am from Tamil-Nadu, and you have made us proud! Even the opposition looks at him with admiration and respect for his wisdom and well researched truth!
@@giftsonjoel3299 agreed. But chidambaram is no saint too
Ashole always wanted to destroy Andhra
Sir
1)Rice -Rs. 50/kg
2)Atta- Rs.55/kg
3)Dal- Rs 130/kg
4)M.oil -Rs. 150/kg
5)Gas - Rs.1103 to 1200/cylinder
6)Ghee- Rs. 680/kg
7)Milk - Rs.- 80/lit
8)Daniya- Rs. 400/kg
9)Jeera - Rs. 900/kg
10)Chilli powder - Rs.650/kg
12)Tata salt - Rs. 30/kg
13)Vegetables - Too high
14)Fish -Minimum Rs. 300/ kg
15)Meat (chicken ) - more than Rs. 300/kg
16) Fruits -Rs. too high
17)Electric bill - too high
18)Property tax- too high
17)Train fare- increasing
18)Flights fare- Too high
19)Medicines price - touch the sky
20)Every medical expenditure - touch the sky.
21)Patrol -Rs.100/lit
22)Diesel- Rs. 95/lit
23)Agricultural cost- too high
24) Education cost - Rs. Too high as the schools are upgraded private.
25) Egg - Rs. 70 (Deshi), Rs. 35 ( boiler)
26)Material of building Price - touch the sky.
Bricks - Rs 15/ pice
Cement - more than Rs. 500/ pkd
Rod- Too high
Sand Rs. 9000/ truck
But Sir, the fact is that the monthly income of common people is very very low.Only a few are taking honey and they are enjoying themselves.
According to BJP supporters if u show them these problems you are against India.
Kind info to correct mate.
Dal - 200 or 200/kg.
Cooking Oil - 180/kg.
Now ×2 and that's the price you will get in Manipur. Price of land which cose 5 lakhs is now 25 lakhs. Meat-500+ bricks and cement twice the amount of Delhi. Etc. the only stable job is a government job excluding the state which only the person with money and relationship with the officials get. Now tell me is inflation nothing. 95+% of the population earn through daily wages. If the people in other states are suffering then what about us
Bruh are u bot ? Lol where the fack are u buying atta for 55 , gas for 1100, milk 80 ,tata salt 30 ,chicken for 300 stop lying. Give factual info and edit it .stop these shitty propaganda
What a gentleman and for once i was taken back to those good old days when our lawmakers were really debating. Hopefully we will see a vibrant parliament in the future which will help our country grow. Jai Hind
The speaker quietly enjoying the speech
He knows what will happen to BJP in the upcoming assembly and future Lok Sabha elections
I too noted.
this speaker is a humble man,
@@graceebenezer6085 not like om birla 😂😂
Another one is only know MANYEEE MANYEEEANYEEE 🗣️🗣️
If you think Nirmala Sitharaman is the worst Fin. Minister of India, hit LIKE.
She made this budget while giving blows to her masters
Abolish tax on STOCK MARKET CONGRESS NEVER HAD IT!!!
!
@@111badbradja bjp walon ko extra paise deke khush ho MAZE LO
Worse Finance minister in the history
Yes that job was pretty good@@ranadip111286
I always heard of Shri. Chidambaramji, but this is the first time i listened properly to him. What a great speaker.. Well done sir🎉🎉
Thank you so much Chidambaram sir for giving such a clear explanation of the Budget 2024.Mary John
What an impressive speech
One of the most amazing speech i have heard till date. He is an experienced ex-finance minister who knew just what to say and to the point putting across every points needed to be asked and showing the reality of india to the current finance minister guiding her what she should be doing... Hope sutaraman gets her lesson, or ready to be insulted by the people of india everywhere. Lots of Respect for chidambaram sir.. jai samvidhan 👏🙌❤️🔥🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
This is the different when an educated and a real Economist speaks.
Yea makes sense why India was called one of the five fragile economies with double digit inflation and moderate growth when he was the FM along with multiple scams on every single scheme and project that congress govt undertook lol
Sir chidambaram's voice is so soothing 😊
He should do audiobooks no?😂
@@joelnaya5341 You got that right!
❤ Best arguments from opposition. Keep up
Knowledgeable person speak with humility, humbleness even while criticizing the announced budget. We need him back as our Finance minister in future for sure.
😂😂😂😂
And halal economy too..
And knowledgable person was in jail for his over smartness. Chor Chidu. He looted enough and if these people had used their knowledge right way things would have better.
Give Congress a chance to win in majorities
@@johnlamshaiiawphniaw395no way
Excellent points raised by chidambaram ji
Excellent Speech by P. Chidambaram sir. 💯🔥
We clearly see the difference between Ex-Fin minister & the current Fin. Minister
Watched whole video without skipping a single second,Huge respect for Sir P Chidambaram after this.Schooled her in her own game.
There is no greater eloquent speaker than Mr Chidambaram
Yes
@@roshanthomas4701 congress is blessed with many such speakers.
😂
Forgot he & his son's scams 🤣
@@venkatadinesh3495 Its so sad that they chose the party of reservations over the party of riches. I would still prefer the elite party over the inequality party
Its hard with inflation and all now. Food cost is so much higher. 15k salary not enough
He is right.
1) unemployment crisis is visible. How ELI work when companies are facing crisis self
2) Tomato price in my area remained 80-100rs since April. Potato price 180-200rs/5kg.
We all criticize government when it claims there is no inflation and job crisis.
PEOPLE ARE NOT BLIND MA'AM. MIDDLE CLASS LOST BELIEVE IN MODI GOVERNMENT. IT IS REALITY
what is use of crying now...again people voted and selected the same.
Yes well said. Very disappointing performance.
@@srinivasan1045 that's the problem we already get this situation from 2 nd turm of BJP regulated govt.
@@asharma6419 the prices are high due to less production and other environmental factors
Look at the inflation rates during his tenure 🤡
00:03 Former Finance Minister emphasizes on employment linked incentives and Congress Manifesto ideas
03:59 Challenges in job creation and implementation of employment schemes
07:25 Unemployment and inflation are critical issues ignored in the budget.
10:36 Inflation remains a concern for India's economy
13:50 Questioning the adoption of low deflator by the Finance Minister
16:28 Ex-Finance Minister critiques relief given in new tax regime
19:26 Addressing poverty concerns in India's population
22:17 Non-BJP states facing financial discrimination
25:05 Demand for key reforms and responses from the Finance Minister
What a beautiful speech by Mr Chidambaram !
Within this 10 years we could not noticed such type of speech from PM or any other Ministers.
This is what education is.
Well spoken and precise.
He really is a finance person 🫡
During his regime inflation was double and the trade deficit was very much high..
Because of him congress lost election in 2014
@@hetpatel7656
It was only bad during last two years - 13 and 14.
India has the highest growth rate for longest period during first 8 years of UPA gov.
@@hetpatel7656 Acha and now everything is ok...Kuch bhi
lol 😂 when china was growing at 16+%. @@ij4674
Education is the most powerful weapon which one remove ignorance
Nirmala looks very depressed
She is coz she knows she has laid the foundation of BJP's whitewash in the 2029 elections.
Because she made the entire salaried and investor class hate her overnight. Worst budget
She should not be sad. She just presented a budget created by PMO. I don't believe she has got any role in the finance ministry.
I don't think she knows what a deflator is..
Yes. Madam, no words to say against Mr. Chidambaram statement. It's true
Speaker Mr.Jagdish was so eager to get attention to the Chair that he requested Former FM Mr. Chidambaram to address him also. 😂..
This is how it is supposed to be. Parliamentarians are supposed to speak through the Speaker of House, not directly.
@@cpt.knight8647 true. But his eagerness and style of relaying that was funny.
Excellent speech by former FM impregnated with clarity of thoughts.His oratory is a class apart!
I wish he were FM.Also,I wish in India,govt.should include such eminent persons in cabinet irrespective of their party affiliations by making constitutional amendments!!
Eloquent and Logical. Wish he comes back as FM
Bhakts do not appreciate intellect nor intellectuals...they prefer theater and bluff masquerading as power and intelligence.
Why? To go back and become fragile 5 nation of the globe?Criticism is okay but dont forget the fragility of economy in UPA
God no
@@sanketkapale809 What is the meaning of fragile economy? What kind of economy does prevail now?
@@sanketkapale809 GDP is for the close minded capitalist , ignoring Human development Index and thinking about GDP is wrong ..
Only one doubt, Do honorable FM will be able to understand these points that P Chidambaram mentioned?
Speaker sir will this points be considered or just left out in air?
Excellent .knowledgeable. informative. Thank you sir.
No match for Mr Chidambaram when it comes to Economics. Very difficult for Sitaraman to counter Chidambaram with all these facts and figures
kitne ghotale kiye hain tere economist ne pata hai?
Exactly kitne saare ghotale 😂
@@lazyguy4825don't divert the question! Abhi answers to the questions raised???
@@iandavid17 atleast she hasn't done scams like chidambaram
Chidambaram and his son has done lot's of scams including passport scams they are not clean even congress is not good
Excellent, No Reply from Finance Minister & PM
Was the PM in the house? I believe no.
@@ALIYYILA even if he is present, he won’t answer as most of the time
@@HariAadithri21 they have nothing to say they just know how to fill there pockets from public.
@@ALIYYILA Cope hard - he has NEVER conducted an unscripted press conference in public or participated in debates with the opposition.
Such a big wuss, charlatan & an actor -> Should've been in Bollywood instead of destroying a nation with fascist tendencies.
If the so called Finance Minister knows anything about Finance and Taxation, she may have been able to respond/say something.
Some say "Ignorance is Bliss"!
23:28
Exactly
@@SADHAM671117 modi talksss high about no corruption or corrupted politicians or politics but BJP HAD MOST JOINS OF CORRUPTED LEADERS IN THE LAST 10YEARS. IF ANY ONE WITH CORRUPTION CHARGES, ED , CBI CASES JOINS BJP. THEN THEY BECOME GAUTAM BUDDHAS AND CLEAN N CLEAR. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤯🤯🤯🤯 WHAT KIND OF FAKE PARTY N FALSE TALKS MODI IS
Exactly
A very well conclusion done by the Ex-Finance minister.. absolutely right
Only an educated and dignified person can talk like this 👌👌👌
Now days it's getting irritating to see her face 20:50
When ever you raise your questions she has no answer or a blank look in her face
@@shreehari2167 😂😂😂True
trueeee
Just imagine the pain yesterday. She was everywhere. At least this time they did not say she was Goddess Lakshmi.
Do you think she is the REAL finance minister. I believe she is blank because the budget is prepared at PMO and she just reads it out. She is a spokesperson of the government like all other ministers..real work is done by bureaucrats controlled by PMO. Gadkari and Shah may be an exception.
@@critic7408she is representing. And elected as fm. We don't even know buraucrates name so how we rise questions. Bjp not selecting qualified people now she know she is puppet who cant even fulfill her role
Present FM didn’t understand what former FM Mr Chidambaram saying.😅😅
Regardless of who is right or wrong.. bt Present FM has an Economics background bro.. n Former FM is a Lawyer.. i do understand n agree Budget is all messed up.. bt economy background wud suffice to understand wat 1 stupid lawyer can tell abt Inflation or economy
true
When he was the FM, inflation was in double digits and he suggested to print money during corona. Thank God govt. didn't listen to this nincompoop.
बुढ़िया पागल हो गई है
You understood?
A very practical knowledgeable and polite person
damn we need more people like him
He was also a f5ed up Finance Minister.
I am glad the VP respected the senior member Chidambaram sir and listened to him gladly and didn’t treated him like the other members of the opposition
Chidambaram Sir Great Analysis of the budget. Need more intelligent people like you .
Madam ji last time said she doesn’t eat onions when asked about skyrocketing onion price, hope this time she doesn’t say she that she is on water diet so she doesn’t know the prices of commodities
Finance Minister's argument would be I dont eat onion
FM - I don't pay taxes so don't tell me what to do as I am not your sleeping partner 😂
😂
That we r treating as a meme..actually that was a castesist slur..that is she from a family who doesnt have onion..but it was not discussed nor she made to apologize
@@mohithpm4954 Leave it. When half of the Indians have their brahminical pride without actually doing that brahmins used to do, what can u expect of a leader chosen by the same people. Birds of feather flock together
But I eat your taxes 😈
What a healthy discussion. People should appreciate chidambaram for his vast experience in Indian economy.
best speech however his tiem the inflation was 12%...banks had the highest NPA in history...his auntys time the income tax rates were 90% (1971-72)..still we had 1991 situation...lets follwo what he says...
Learned so much from his speech
Mr. Chidambaram, what intelligent gentleman. Proud to have in our country. Thank.
good during his time inflation was 12% banks were also fnd of listening to him..:P that swhy they had double digit NPA
This is not India's budget! This is the budget of Bihar Andhra and Gujarat 😅
What did they given to Gujarat? In union budget! I think you should re-check your facts... It was only Andhra pradesh and bihar in budget
😂😂@@ahemadkunjada666
Brother silently added Gujrat into the list & thought nobody will notice😂
Adani and Ambani, the best friends of Modi are Gujjus. Adani is based in Gujarat@@ahemadkunjada666
@@Abbas_abbu Dikhado bhai gujarat ham bhi deklenge konsa hamko budget mila hai
Sirji. You are a genius.
Ahhhh...more satisfying seing Chairman himself respect personally Chidambaram ji. A point raised also impressed every member in the House, so much smooth!!!
Lovely preperation sir..
We expect this kind of thorough speeches from leaders like you 🎉
We are blessed with a finance minister with no intention to manage finance but to help only the netas and corporates
Legendary Chidambaram sir. Respect.
This fellow also screwed up budget when he was FM. Only Manmohan was a good FM.
@@vvk594😂😂😂
@@Jt61603 he was the same legend who said UPI won’t work in India. People are illetterate to use phones for banking and transactions
@@vvk594he was far far better than current useless FM
Best speech
I don't think Ex FM is not fit for that position as i still remember his comments on UPI
"do you pay on upi after buying tomatoes"
Yes i do pay even ₹5 on UPI...
Didn't know I had the patience to listen to somebody without skipping or even speeding up the video..
Superb speech with excellent facts. Mr. Chidambaram is a real hero to seat in the chair of Finance Minister. Thanks for Lots of factuals.
Harvard Educated P. Chidambaram❤
I can listen Mr Chidambaram speeches all the day.
@@durgaprasad2508 Dear friend, pease diversify your speeches. You will get more good insights. Mr. P. Chidambaram is a good intellectual orator. However, you should inculcate the habit of diversification.
good during his time inflation was 12% banks were also fnd of listening to him..:P that swhy they had double digit NPA
@@pradeep080the inflation rate during p Chidambaram's tenure was constantly around 4.55%- 5% every month , and the lowest inflation rate recorded was 1.75% the 12% inflation rate was just for a very brief period of time it was just a spike due to "global financial crisis" do not spread fake news on internet.
@@pradeep080 Do not spread misinformation on the internet
During P. Chidambaram's tenure the inflation rate of india was comparatively lower as compared to nirmala sitaraman's being finance minister , the lowest recorded inflation rate during P. Chidambram's tenure was 1.75% and the 12% you're talking about was just a spike due to the "Global financial crisis" you cannot blame a finance minister for the global financial crisis and increasing commodities prices at a global scale. The thing that worries me is that at his moment there is no global crisis in financials as well as commodities prices are falling globally while the inflation is rising in India.
@@HWK_venom Mr.phaykinfospreader during Chidambaram tenure average inflation was around 10%... An online look up will easily show that info... The average inflation for the Financial year 2013-2014 was 10%. Global economic crisis was in 2008.
I was a hardcore BJP supporter , listening to opposition for the first time , I think he makes sense. She does not deserve even to be an MP let alone FM.
She’s not an elected MP btw.
Time to ditch bjp..same case..once hard core supporter..but now never again.
remove bjp
Arrogance fades easily before calm, logical and intellectually sound address. Ex- FM H'ble P. Chidambaram with his experience and well analysed articulation of his speech the economic disparity imposed by this government. We don't need arrogant Finance Minister like N. Sitharaman. We need P. Chidambaram as a Finance Minister.
It is incomprehensible even for the Jagdeep Dhankar.
We really miss such humble but talented expression 🙏🙏🙏 Really fed up of the arrogance and ignorance of the treasury benches.😢😢
@@jafethsamson3627 Don’t judge the book by its cover. Study about his tenure and what actions he had taken to make Indian economic flourish? ❌
@@gauravgupta322Please educate us all about the current government’s actions to make the economy flourish
@@gauravgupta322 Thanks 🙏 for your advice..... But unfortunately the current situation of economy is No Book 📖 but only Cover 😞
Mr Chidambaram adds such dignity to the house with his eloquence.
Strong opposition is crucial. Great representation of people of India
I am a staunch BJP supporter but loved this slap on Nirmala sitharaman
Why be a staunch supporter at all? 😅
@@SkpalTube because we can't deny the fact that BJP is doing somewhat better than what congress did. Congress is full of scams and hindu oppressive.
And from now on you vote for the Congress
translation: *staunch* gawar
Enjoy paying 60% tax. Stop party worshipping and use some common sense
25:40 to 27:22
Must
We need parliamentarian like him who conduct himself so well.
Highly valued speech and showed the govt true face of their budget. So called mata ji nirmala tai
Good speech 👍
Fantastic opposition... HOLD current government accountable on behalf of people.. Well done.. We are proud.
When Congress was in power. We know all the allied parties how much looted. Corruption terrorism. This chidambaram holding more than 60000crores of corrupted money. You just re enquire the congress government. Everyone of the opponent looted this nation. This data any economist can give. Chidambaram is 420. you all peoples do not know. Considering only the current situation.
That kind of discussion we need in every part of our country so that even a lay man could also understand that how economics works
Honorable voice president also agree with Chidambaran sir🙏🙏
Very nicely expressed reg Budget by Ex Finance minister. God bless you sir.
Good counter