For me you are like an angel unnie the time I was about to lose hope in namjin you jumped up with your videos.... This is the reason I always comment on ur videos and I will support you till very last. Love you so much unnie Borahae 💜💜💜
Your video is exudes warmth and comfort. Please dont stop making videos. Your analysis is amazing and makes one thinks and analyze too. Thank you so much. Dont get tired of making analysis video, ill never get tired of watching. Keep safe
Your video make me cry because the analysis was delicate and beautiful , I like it so much. The Nam Joon's point of view of love is amazing that make me cry. I love your videos. 😊💜🙌
Very well made video. I became a fan when Namjin was at its highest. I could see there was much more than a fan service scenario between them and thought they were in love. Then it gradually changed. They still have a strong bond between them and I feel this will help them chose their lives the way they want. Glad to know I wasn't mad seeing emotions that were not real, they were.
Caraca no show em LV eu achei que estavam voltando a ser carinhosos, um com o outro. Namjin fazendo a onda sexy ..Ai RM apagou as fotos quando o show acabou..Ali só amizade msm 💔💔💔
❤️❤️💕💞🥰🥰 you people won't believe when I say that i always believed that Jin is an angel and mentioned it so many times on so many different platforms..i am stunned to see this video today where RM is thinking Jin as an angel. 😭😭 I am speechless. Thank you for the beautiful video 🙏
This video and reasoning are amazing and comforting 💜 please make more namjin contents like this. 😊 Requesting a part 2 showing the present and boldness from both side 😊
The thing about Jin too is you know he's about to cry or just absolutely sad when he holds his head still and tries not to blink. You can just about see the tears welling up, but he doesn't let them flow. Aw, Jinnie. 🥺 I've watched this quite a few times now, and Jin's face, when he's thinking about something sad, is always heartbreaking. And they are both susceptible to each other's sadness too-like zero immunity. 😅 One cries, and the other either immediately cries or is upset. 😅💕
I absolutely love namjin together they are perfect for each other and I pray they overcome their fears of religion and culture and stay together for ever and eventually marry all my love to you both beautiful guys your army's routing for you 💜 💜😘😘
your words and emotion and meaning are so profound, I feel like I am reading a NAMJIN biopic. This so beautifully written, thanks for saving so many namjin predebut memories and nuances which no one knew.
Some of Namjinist believe theory about broke up. I've same opinion with you when Joon want Jk sing cover some song... only then always make me cry. Oh.. one more thing... GOLD in mandarin(chinese language) mean JINzi
I adore Namjin and hope they stay together forever. BUT I agree with the commenters who said something has changed. Their body language for the Busan concert rehearsals and the concert itself was painful to watch. Namjoon just seemed so angry; ignoring Jin’s heart gesture hurt to watch. The Jin enlistment video felt distant and awkward too - Jimin was watching them sadly and anxiously. I guess the one spark of hope is that they left in the same car after Suga’s D-day concert. We all just want them to be happy whether they’re together or not, but I’ll be sad if they’ve split. Love you Namjin, fighting! 💜
Wow! This was such a good video!! You covered some things I had forgotten about and a few that I hadn’t connected! I love finding out new clues to the real possibility of Namjin! Thank you for making this video! It was really well done and very thoughtful! 😍🥰
Thank you for including RM‘s compositions performed by others(txt). I missed that detail which gives insight into RM‘s thoughts. Well done, well paced video with clear supports for your conclusions. 💜💜💜
I have some negative thoughts about namjin for months. Idk just the feeling of their distance whenever I meet them on the internet (social media, articles, etc). I had this feeling in a random day I cant remember, it suddenly existed. It is weird, ik. Hugs are still there. Playing moments are still there. Just the bond is different. It is like at the edge that 'We can play, be nice with each others as just not to make others worry'. Btw, really appreciate your videos. I really like them. Hope you could find more interesting evidences and make more analysis videos.
I think that they used to be bold when they were younger. We have to take in account that they are now young adults living in a society that wouldn't approve an homosexual relationship. They need to be cautious. But if you watch them carefully, the feelings are still there, growing as strong as themselves.
Thank you so muchhh . I’m a little sad because I know your channel so late. However, I appreciated you so much. I’m rooting for you from now on . I adore your analysis and your observation ❤
My view is they are each other's first love and they don't know how to react after discovering their feelings. Maybe they finally confessed with a little help and teasing by Jimin. Haha...
8:12 when Only Then was playing although Jin dnt look at RM you can see his ears all red. We all know jin ears gets red if he's happy or flustered or sad.
Omg unnie I- I'm speechless. It really makes me wonder if this is the truth. I used to wonder if all those stuff at the beginning were true or just fanservice cause if you see, something between them feels so off specially with joonie. He seems very distant and jin tries so hard to get his attention these days.
It would be wonderful if they didn't have to care what others think. But sadly they do not just for themselves but their careers, them coming out would destroy everything they worked so hard for .
Im actually worried about their present situation. We dnt get to see that warmth specially during Las Vegas concerts. Had their friendship gone sour? It breaks my heart to think so.
Hey!!! Why always negative dear See namjin has been like this maybe because of Jin's injury and we all know our namjoon is god of destruction so maybe he is afraid to hurt Jin, so he is giving a little space to him..... Don't worry stay positive, just keep believing in our ship.....🥰
They are low key on stage, namjoon is the front man on stage, the vlive after had more honey than a beehive. They were low key eyeing each other up, what i did notice was yoongi and jimin were the only pair of a ship to sit next to each other. Jin and namjoon were three people away from each other while hobi was between tae and kookie.
Omg I love your analysis on namjin. I'm binge watching your vids. I know the analysis on Only then before, but did you also know about Run with me by swja and his cover of fools by troye sivan? And also The truth untold, love maze and trivia love. Pls make an analysis about it, I think it's connected to namjin since trivia love sounds like a love confession and in truth untold there's jin's name on the title and I also think Joonie's referring himself as the monster and jin is the beauty, I dunno I may be wrong tho and as for love maze the lyrics speaks volume, at first I thought it's for taekook but as I know namjin I think joonie wrote it for them, namjin that's why he's so excited about it and one of his favorite.
Mi teoría es que Namjin terminaron tal vez por el bien del grupo o lo que sea y quedaron como familia/amigos/compañeros esto porque Namjoon nos ha dejado con dudas de si tiene novio, quien fue la persona que lo engañó etc, esa persona no puede ser Jin así que ellos debieron de haber terminado en buenos términos y de ahí salen canciones como moonchild, don’t de RM y moon de Jin a demás del SM y Que el grupo se separo por almenas dos años y medio por lo que veo, así que habrá que esperar a que bts vuelva para ver como se comportan pero en fin yo si creo que Namjin tuvieron una relación
I totally think that around 2015-2016 Jin knew he was Gay or on the LGB spectrum where Namjoon would still struggle with this thought... There are some videos of this period of time that makes me think that way
Yes,Kimseokjin is Gay,but Namjoon in that era is Straight,but when he fall n love with jin,his literally confusednof his identity.Namjoon seems like a woman too.His sexual appeal is strong,but the day he feel n love with a man,God he might thought also that his gay too.Thats power of LOVE🥰🥰🥰
How can you both not see the obvious??????? SEOKJIN is not gay!!!!!! There’s a bromance between NAMJOON and SEOKJIN!!!!!!!!! Period!!!!! Where is the proof that JIN gay?? In my opinion, there really was love between them! But not now! JIN is not only cold towards JUN, but definitely ignores him! By the way, Calico Cat, does not claim in any of her many videos that they are lovers! If it were true, l would be only glad!!!!!
I am recently into bts i see all ships i too feel namjin is real. Jin in the beginning was very vocal about his love( recently i saw all old videos) but joon later fell for him but fell harder. Now i assume they may be living togethet on n off. ( based on festa 22) namjoon house is like museum, jin has sleeping bag in living room, joon says jins house is like newly weds house, jimin immediately says dont know how much of this vl be cut. Looks like joon wants to open up but jin is reluctant. The more recent appearance could be to avoid any scandal more so when there is truth in it. If its rumor they can deny. Even if u observe all media IVs they had just before jins enlistment, host would invariably ask one about the other. Since people in media n celebrities will be knowing only general public they will not leak into. As the society may be conservative and it just wont hamper their career but whole groups. They dont hv to show audience. They hv to be happy thats it.
But some people say kookie jin is true namjin is just a brother I totally don't understand their point of view please clear us about kookiejin relationships
Kookie is Jinnie's baby, they are just brothers. Notice the difference in the way JK treat Jin and V. Also there are a lot similarities between namjin and taekook, the only difference is namjin is cautious while taekook is a lil bit bolder and braver especially nowadays.
Cảm ơn những video phân tích của bạn. Điều bạn làm thật tuyệt vời. Chúc bạn luôn bình an và hạnh phúc . . . Tôi không hiểu ngoại ngữ nhưng âm nhạc bạn lồng ghép và hình ảnh video cũng khiến tôi hiểu 1 phần nào. Mong bạn có thể cho phép bật phụ đề ngôn ngữ nhiều thứ tiếng trong đó có ngôn ngữ Việt Nam
The fact that so many of RM's songs has Jin's name in them. He wasn't kidding when he said he would carve his love's name in history.
Yeah,he did,thats y i believe Namjin is fucking Real not just ship its really exist🥰🥰🥰
Yes I thought I'm the only one who notice Jin's name in he's song so with his latest song fireworks or flower
Honestly, I got teary-eyed while watching this... I'm happy that Namjoon has gotten more confident
For me you are like an angel unnie the time I was about to lose hope in namjin you jumped up with your videos.... This is the reason I always comment on ur videos and I will support you till very last. Love you so much unnie Borahae 💜💜💜
same here...even I was getting depressed about namjin reality...then suddenly found this angel who really warmed up my namjin heart 🌹💖
Your video is exudes warmth and comfort. Please dont stop making videos. Your analysis is amazing and makes one thinks and analyze too. Thank you so much. Dont get tired of making analysis video, ill never get tired of watching. Keep safe
I think the part about Chinese characters （金=kim=gold）may be difficult for occidentals to understand. Thanks for your support 💜
@@calicocat6688it doesn’t matter, there are enough of use who aren’t monolingual 🤭
Your video make me cry because the analysis was delicate and beautiful , I like it so much. The Nam Joon's point of view of love is amazing that make me cry. I love your videos. 😊💜🙌
Very well made video. I became a fan when Namjin was at its highest. I could see there was much more than a fan service scenario between them and thought they were in love. Then it gradually changed. They still have a strong bond between them and I feel this will help them chose their lives the way they want. Glad to know I wasn't mad seeing emotions that were not real, they were.
Caraca no show em LV eu achei que estavam voltando a ser carinhosos, um com o outro. Namjin fazendo a onda sexy ..Ai RM apagou as fotos quando o show acabou..Ali só amizade msm 💔💔💔
❤️❤️💕💞🥰🥰 you people won't believe when I say that i always believed that Jin is an angel and mentioned it so many times on so many different platforms..i am stunned to see this video today where RM is thinking Jin as an angel. 😭😭 I am speechless. Thank you for the beautiful video 🙏
Ohhhhh this is amazing 🥺😣 I want more. Thanks so much for sharing, we love you 💙🐨🐹💜
This video and reasoning are amazing and comforting 💜 please make more namjin contents like this. 😊 Requesting a part 2 showing the present and boldness from both side 😊
The thing about Jin too is you know he's about to cry or just absolutely sad when he holds his head still and tries not to blink. You can just about see the tears welling up, but he doesn't let them flow. Aw, Jinnie. 🥺 I've watched this quite a few times now, and Jin's face, when he's thinking about something sad, is always heartbreaking. And they are both susceptible to each other's sadness too-like zero immunity. 😅 One cries, and the other either immediately cries or is upset. 😅💕
I absolutely love namjin together they are perfect for each other and I pray they overcome their fears of religion and culture and stay together for ever and eventually marry all my love to you both beautiful guys your army's routing for you 💜 💜😘😘
your words and emotion and meaning are so profound, I feel like I am reading a NAMJIN biopic. This so beautifully written, thanks for saving so many namjin predebut memories and nuances which no one knew.
Ojalá algún día puedan ser felices sin tener que ocultar su amor 💜
Thank you so much for the video. I hope it's come for namjin. They can be happy anywhere in this world
THIS IS THE BEST NAMJIN ANALYSIS VIDEO WILL REWATCHING
You are a blessing to my namjin heart dear....
And of course "only then" song is something that made me believe more 8n namjin.
Some of Namjinist believe theory about broke up. I've same opinion with you when Joon want Jk sing cover some song... only then always make me cry.
Oh.. one more thing...
GOLD in mandarin(chinese language) mean JINzi
Namjoon"s brain is full of Jin
You will go to heaven pray and love god.i believe that the both of you will.just believe.
Wow,mind blowing again🥰🥰
I adore Namjin and hope they stay together forever. BUT I agree with the commenters who said something has changed. Their body language for the Busan concert rehearsals and the concert itself was painful to watch. Namjoon just seemed so angry; ignoring Jin’s heart gesture hurt to watch. The Jin enlistment video felt distant and awkward too - Jimin was watching them sadly and anxiously. I guess the one spark of hope is that they left in the same car after Suga’s D-day concert. We all just want them to be happy whether they’re together or not, but I’ll be sad if they’ve split. Love you Namjin, fighting! 💜
Permission To Cry... 🥺😭
Thank you for keep posting about namjin warm love. 💙💖
Please give lot more videos about namjin. I am so happy after seeing ur video thank u so much
Wow! This was such a good video!! You covered some things I had forgotten about and a few that I hadn’t connected! I love finding out new clues to the real possibility of Namjin! Thank you for making this video! It was really well done and very thoughtful! 😍🥰
Thank you for including RM‘s compositions performed by others(txt). I missed that detail which gives insight into RM‘s thoughts. Well done, well paced video with clear supports for your conclusions. 💜💜💜
Parang sasabog ang puso ko sa sakit,hbang tinitingnan c Namjoon umiiyak dahil kay kimseokjin😭😭😭😭😭
Like so much for this kind analysis...good job..keep going
The lyrics says "love, you so bad love you so bad mold a pretty good lie for you at 10.38
I have some negative thoughts about namjin for months. Idk just the feeling of their distance whenever I meet them on the internet (social media, articles, etc). I had this feeling in a random day I cant remember, it suddenly existed. It is weird, ik.
Hugs are still there. Playing moments are still there. Just the bond is different. It is like at the edge that 'We can play, be nice with each others as just not to make others worry'.
Btw, really appreciate your videos. I really like them. Hope you could find more interesting evidences and make more analysis videos.
The vibe between them has indeed changed from before 🥺 I don't know whether it's for good or bad but let's hope for the best.
ah dont be sad they are fine I believe that❤️
I think that they used to be bold when they were younger. We have to take in account that they are now young adults living in a society that wouldn't approve an homosexual relationship. They need to be cautious. But if you watch them carefully, the feelings are still there, growing as strong as themselves.
Thank you so muchhh . I’m a little sad because I know your channel so late. However, I appreciated you so much. I’m rooting for you from now on . I adore your analysis and your observation ❤
My view is they are each other's first love and they don't know how to react after discovering their feelings. Maybe they finally confessed with a little help and teasing by Jimin. Haha...
You're absolutely right！
Jimin is not the only one. Sometimes Hobi looks at them while teasing each other, and his glance is like: "I know what's going on between you two".
Might be,cause jimin and Rm are also closed,might observed Rm and jin act differently,thats y he become Namjin president🥰
8:12 when Only Then was playing although Jin dnt look at RM you can see his ears all red. We all know jin ears gets red if he's happy or flustered or sad.
I noticed that too...
Omg unnie I-
I'm speechless. It really makes me wonder if this is the truth. I used to wonder if all those stuff at the beginning were true or just fanservice cause if you see, something between them feels so off specially with joonie. He seems very distant and jin tries so hard to get his attention these days.
It would be wonderful if they didn't have to care what others think. But sadly they do not just for themselves but their careers, them coming out would destroy everything they
worked so hard for .
I know namjin always keep things privately but there’s something lost between them recently :’)
I hope the video comes true and they can live happily anywhere in the world
Im actually worried about their present situation. We dnt get to see that warmth specially during Las Vegas concerts. Had their friendship gone sour? It breaks my heart to think so.
Hey!!! Why always negative dear
See namjin has been like this maybe because of Jin's injury and we all know our namjoon is god of destruction so maybe he is afraid to hurt Jin, so he is giving a little space to him..... Don't worry stay positive, just keep believing in our ship.....🥰
@@ruhisinha1930 love you sweetie for the positive note.
They are low key on stage, namjoon is the front man on stage, the vlive after had more honey than a beehive. They were low key eyeing each other up, what i did notice was yoongi and jimin were the only pair of a ship to sit next to each other. Jin and namjoon were three people away from each other while hobi was between tae and kookie.
I was so confused when ox1 came up. It took me so long to remember that Joon worked on it.
Ahh I love NamJin so much ..I hope they will live happily ever after 💜💜💜
I almost cry. Why are prejudices hurt so much good persons who just love each other?
Omg I love your analysis on namjin. I'm binge watching your vids. I know the analysis on Only then before, but did you also know about Run with me by swja and his cover of fools by troye sivan? And also The truth untold, love maze and trivia love. Pls make an analysis about it, I think it's connected to namjin since trivia love sounds like a love confession and in truth untold there's jin's name on the title and I also think Joonie's referring himself as the monster and jin is the beauty, I dunno I may be wrong tho and as for love maze the lyrics speaks volume, at first I thought it's for taekook but as I know namjin I think joonie wrote it for them, namjin that's why he's so excited about it and one of his favorite.
love ur work 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
They are dating from the last 10 years 🔥💋
please come back CALICO CAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
😭😭😭😭😭 please end up together
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🇦🇷💜💜👏🏻👏🏻 boraghae!!
Mi teoría es que Namjin terminaron tal vez por el bien del grupo o lo que sea y quedaron como familia/amigos/compañeros esto porque Namjoon nos ha dejado con dudas de si tiene novio, quien fue la persona que lo engañó etc, esa persona no puede ser Jin así que ellos debieron de haber terminado en buenos términos y de ahí salen canciones como moonchild, don’t de RM y moon de Jin a demás del SM y Que el grupo se separo por almenas dos años y medio por lo que veo, así que habrá que esperar a que bts vuelva para ver como se comportan pero en fin yo si creo que Namjin tuvieron una relación
Dear I really love the way you analyse. Its difficult read the lettering.please change the font or something. I really want to read everything
you can loving love and runway from objek love, trust me hehehe
???????
I totally think that around 2015-2016 Jin knew he was Gay or on the LGB spectrum where Namjoon would still struggle with this thought... There are some videos of this period of time that makes me think that way
Yes,Kimseokjin is Gay,but Namjoon in that era is Straight,but when he fall n love with jin,his literally confusednof his identity.Namjoon seems like a woman too.His sexual appeal is strong,but the day he feel n love with a man,God he might thought also that his gay too.Thats power of LOVE🥰🥰🥰
How can you both not see the obvious??????? SEOKJIN is not gay!!!!!! There’s a bromance between NAMJOON and SEOKJIN!!!!!!!!! Period!!!!! Where is the proof that JIN gay?? In my opinion, there really was love between them! But not now! JIN is not only cold towards JUN, but definitely ignores him! By the way, Calico Cat, does not claim in any of her many videos that they are lovers! If it were true, l would be only glad!!!!!
I am recently into bts i see all ships i too feel namjin is real.
Jin in the beginning was very vocal about his love( recently i saw all old videos) but joon later fell for him but fell harder. Now i assume they may be living togethet on n off. ( based on festa 22) namjoon house is like museum, jin has sleeping bag in living room, joon says jins house is like newly weds house, jimin immediately says dont know how much of this vl be cut. Looks like joon wants to open up but jin is reluctant. The more recent appearance could be to avoid any scandal more so when there is truth in it. If its rumor they can deny. Even if u observe all media IVs they had just before jins enlistment, host would invariably ask one about the other. Since people in media n celebrities will be knowing only general public they will not leak into. As the society may be conservative and it just wont hamper their career but whole groups. They dont hv to show audience. They hv to be happy thats it.
Where i can see your video with Chinese subtitle!? Really like your video!!!
中間的說明變成純英文的了，沒有中文字的嗎?哭。。。
請問B站會上傳中文的嗎? 還是可以告訴我在哪裡可以看得到?
b站一年前有上傳中文版的哦，BV號是BV11o4y1y7HL，這個英文版是重新剪輯的影片☺️
@@calicocat6688 謝謝你，我想我會去把它們全部找來看。還有我真的很想問你，你有覺得他們昨天的演唱會兩個人的互動非常的少嗎?感覺非常奇怪。。。謝謝你的影片，真的很棒。
@@lovemyself9954 的確是變少了很多，有Army在現場高舉著「南俊是雙性戀」的牌子，也許是這個原因，他們想避嫌。
@@lovemyself9954 不好意思 我不太明白，你说的老4 指的是俊吗？所以老6是泰泰 ?
@@calicocat6688 tf that fan was thinking when she bring that kind of sign to the concert exposing isnt good
What do the Korean people think about them.....Me I love them forever but I'm in the States so I don't know how SK feels about them
Put bluntly, they’re tolerated, not celebrated
@@CurvyTomato why
@@pusseyfoot369 Culture and religion, mostly. Things are changing but very slowly
@@CurvyTomato do the people there believe they are a real couple?
But some people say kookie jin is true namjin is just a brother I totally don't understand their point of view please clear us about kookiejin relationships
Jinkook is just brothers dont believe those people
Thank you so much
@@sasikalaravindran224 anytime
Kookie is Jinnie's baby, they are just brothers. Notice the difference in the way JK treat Jin and V. Also there are a lot similarities between namjin and taekook, the only difference is namjin is cautious while taekook is a lil bit bolder and braver especially nowadays.
@@sugabaaabe93 Agreed
Cảm ơn những video phân tích của bạn. Điều bạn làm thật tuyệt vời. Chúc bạn luôn bình an và hạnh phúc
.
.
.
Tôi không hiểu ngoại ngữ nhưng âm nhạc bạn lồng ghép và hình ảnh video cũng khiến tôi hiểu 1 phần nào. Mong bạn có thể cho phép bật phụ đề ngôn ngữ nhiều thứ tiếng trong đó có ngôn ngữ Việt Nam
sjsjsjs❤😱💕💋👀❤️🥳☺️💝😍
sjsjsjs❤💋💔💕💖😱🙈👀😊
Am always happy to hear about this two and of course others 😃💃💃💃💃💃💃
Your analysis are very good..... Keep going 👏..... Check out ur Instagram account plz 😇