Basically the judges said that she has talent, but because she doesn't understand Korean she can't express the message of the song and it lacks emotion. They realize she's very young and has time to learn and improve, so they gave her a chance. I believe she's signed now, learning Korean very quickly.
Did you hear the news today? I hope things go alright for her... I feel like the judges told her the song lacked emotion because they wanted her to sing with more passion, Megan Lee has that ability! I think she was nervous in front of everyone, and so she tried to 'outdo' everyone else by singing as loud as possible. Which made the vocals go off tune a bit, and so they were talking about "America tries to show off their vocals" XD
You are so beautiful and so amazing. Don't take anything to personally Megan!!! Keep doing your best!!! I know you love to sing and it's going to be harder in Korean but you can do it!!! Hwaiting!!!
Some comments are saying why did they talk about America? It isn't because they were racist, but because of the cultural differences. For example, when they talked about how America likes to "show off" their vocals instead of singing correctly, that was actually true. In choir, many people would try to sing as loud as they can, and because of this, it makes the notes sound off. Instead of singing naturally, Megan Lee was "yelling/screaming" out the notes... I'm pretty sure they choose these three judges because of they know how to judge singers. Sometimes, I don't get why people would be like "I bet these judges are not as good as the participant". No offense, but most participants are good, but their voices are still raw and untrained, so we shouldn't be biased all the time. Anyways! Congrats for Megan Lee for passing the round
Mochi Jimin It's so hilarious to see the comments saying that BangPD-nim was rude and other things, but actually he was stric and analytic. And now that "rude judge" it's the father of BTS and they would never get this far without this incredible man. This "rude" way to criticize the talent is the way BTS was rise. Love and respect to Bang Shihyuk 💜
thanks guys for everything and the support!! sorry for not putting subtitles! i forgot!! >_< I am currently still in Korea (which means good things! :D) and will be here until the end of january or maybe even longer (if i am doing well :P) thanks for cheering for me!!
@ardenBcho awww thanks unni :) it was pretty harsh but i totally undertsnad why and how the judges were telling me these reviews and i am working so hard now to improve my nubish korean :p hwaiting unni
hx everyone for supporting during this mbc show ^__^V i had so much fun in Korea bcuz it was my very first trip to korea! My experience was amazing & you guys were amazing supporters!! yay My Korean wasn't good enough to make everyone happy but I'm working hard to improve ^^ Born in America wasn't my choice~no matter what i I'm proud to be Korean-American & love being Korean-American ^^ Thankful for my supportive parents & family for loving me who I am & will miss you everyone^^ love, Megan
When I see you sing in this video, I first think, "Meh". But then I see that this video was uploaded about 3 years ago! You've really grown to be a wonderful singer, so please keep singing! :D
I was like "She can surely sing." and then I saw you run out of the room w/ Luna & Krystal from f(x) I was like "YOU ARE SO DAMN LUCKY." haha. But yeah. YOU ROCK! \m/
eshh cried at the end, so happy for you...i love singing too and please don't give up cause you have great talent...yes he may have thought she was tryna show off cause you know when you sing you also need to feel the song not just sing it..like he said put emotion, so guys the judges have points too(:
Beautiful Video! So proud of you! Wow, congrats ~ I know you can make it to the end! ^_^ Ah~ Look at Luna and Krystal at the end! I bet they were proud of you as well!
Congratulations! This is just another small step towards an amazing future for you. I think that one judge was trying to channel some Simon, and he was a bit harsh on you but there is 1 thing you can take from it - Being blessed with such amazing talent isn't a free pass, and some people forget that when they become stars. Remember to never take it for granted and always sing from the bottom of your heart! Good luck!!
@angle021 That's whats so special and different about kpop idols. They're not just singers, they are entertainers. They entertain with every part of their being (singing, dancing, looks, personalities). And there are plenty of "singers" that can't really sing... especially in American music...
so supportive. idk if my parents would ever be supportive with my decision to become a singer or an actress or a dance or a model or anything related to the media. fighting.
I never knew that my one and first comment to one of your video will make people made. It was only to encourage you to keep on learning/speaking Korean, so you will succeed in Korea. I think you have an awesome voice and would like to see you be successful in the music industry
hey!! congrats!! and keep strong!!! Some people might not be receptive to you because you are a korean american but just remember the koreans over here that are rooting for you!!
chill there, guys. what the judge meant by "the way you sing now seems like you are just trying to show off your skills" is that she sings just.... to sing, meaning that she doesn't put all her emotions in the song. Well, I guess that's it.
i LUV how ur laughing and smiling up there, ur having fun and those judges are too harsh... heehee im korean and i understand everything they're saying.... YOU? SHOWING OFF??? your just doing what u lov.... those.. thosee.... bleh.
I've redirected here from your Konglish cover of Rocketeer. And now I'm excited to see you sing in Korea and in the United States! I hope that people will recognize your talents even more, and that you'll be able to learn some Korean too :P
Ok, if you watch this video from last year, and her other video when she auditioned. THERE IS ONE HUGE DIFFERENCE. Keep it up Megan :) I'll be supporting you when you get through 8DD
OMG YOU CAN SING AND DANCE!!!... woaah! Aigoo!! ur so good!! All the best for MBC! Hope u make it... if u dont then somethings wrong with those people!... HWAITING ahaha
yay ! congratulations ! good luck I really hope you make it :) you're going to like make it to the finals because you have uniqueness or something and then you'll became a kpop star and then you'll meet famous kpop people like super junior and 2pm . I'm jealous :( you have serious talent. when become famous don't forget about you're UA-cam viewers :) . fighting~!!
@apxmusic simple, because they are already celebrities and has a great deal of popularity,.. the point here is she's auditioning in korea for a show which will make her a celebrity, i think the judges gave the right decision to pull her out since their would be much suitable person than her hu also has talent..i mean after this show they'll become instant celeb, no need for 3-4yrs workshop, if she has been chosen then they'll need to make her study the language, accent, and a whole lot more..
You are too cute megan, especially for being so positive even when they were criticizing that you were what they call "Showing off!" -____- You're just too good for 'em. They can't handle you ; D
You have a great voice, definitely very different that most Korean singers, but I believe that's what will help your career. Keep up the good work, you're awesome. ps: subtitles would be great =)
you did a great job megan! good luck for the up coming rounds. i auditioned too but i didn't make the 2nd round :( but im happy you made it through!!!!! XD
WOW CONGRATS MEGAN!!! i read some other comments that translated, and whoa that was pretty harsh >.< but i'm glad they put you through!! i hope you take their criticism with a grain of salt, but listen and understand what they want from you :D good luck!!!
The part where you put the annotation/ translation of the person saying "hmmm i forgot here.....ummmm -__-" Let me go ask my mom!" I actually thought that was what he was saying. xD
@apxmusic they are successful because they are korean celebrities singing a japanese song, they do have the right accent and emotions when they sing since they rehearse it alot, and had a lot of help. why don't you try hearing someone from korea(hu's bad in english) sings in ur native language, with all those wrong pronunciation, accent and emotions, even how great a person's talent is, it's still no use since you won't gonna enjoy it, .. but don't get me wrong megan is AN AWESOME singer.
eesh that was pretty harsh. But then again they are looking for someone who has THE potential and can express their feelings into the song. But you did great! Theres always next time (:
@EJCLProductions Not all Koreans, but these judges were definitely bashing on her because she is American. "In America it's kinda the thing to show off their vocals...they always do these things with their hands...."
@KyoraLove actually if Megan were to sign with a Korean label, I'd assume that she would sign with YG entertainment. Megan has stated on Popseoul that she's a HUGE YG fan. Fan of 2ne1, fan of Big Bang. So yeah I'd assume she'd go with YG plus YG is assume.
Basically the judges said that she has talent, but because she doesn't understand Korean she can't express the message of the song and it lacks emotion. They realize she's very young and has time to learn and improve, so they gave her a chance.
I believe she's signed now, learning Korean very quickly.
Did you hear the news today? I hope things go alright for her... I feel like the judges told her the song lacked emotion because they wanted her to sing with more passion, Megan Lee has that ability! I think she was nervous in front of everyone, and so she tried to 'outdo' everyone else by singing as loud as possible. Which made the vocals go off tune a bit, and so they were talking about "America tries to show off their vocals" XD
But she’s already famous in America. 🖕
You are so beautiful and so amazing. Don't take anything to personally Megan!!! Keep doing your best!!! I know you love to sing and it's going to be harder in Korean but you can do it!!! Hwaiting!!!
Some comments are saying why did they talk about America? It isn't because they were racist, but because of the cultural differences. For example, when they talked about how America likes to "show off" their vocals instead of singing correctly, that was actually true. In choir, many people would try to sing as loud as they can, and because of this, it makes the notes sound off. Instead of singing naturally, Megan Lee was "yelling/screaming" out the notes... I'm pretty sure they choose these three judges because of they know how to judge singers. Sometimes, I don't get why people would be like "I bet these judges are not as good as the participant". No offense, but most participants are good, but their voices are still raw and untrained, so we shouldn't be biased all the time.
Anyways! Congrats for Megan Lee for passing the round
Hitman bang!
Mochi Jimin It's so hilarious to see the comments saying that BangPD-nim was rude and other things, but actually he was stric and analytic. And now that "rude judge" it's the father of BTS and they would never get this far without this incredible man. This "rude" way to criticize the talent is the way BTS was rise. Love and respect to Bang Shihyuk 💜
thanks guys for everything and the support!! sorry for not putting subtitles! i forgot!! >_< I am currently still in Korea (which means good things! :D) and will be here until the end of january or maybe even longer (if i am doing well :P) thanks for cheering for me!!
I just now realized that luna and krystal from f(x) were there lols
Bang-PDnim? is dat u?
krizziamia ocio OMG i was thinking the same thing😂
@ardenBcho awww thanks unni :) it was pretty harsh but i totally undertsnad why and how the judges were telling me these reviews and i am working so hard now to improve my nubish korean :p hwaiting unni
hx everyone for supporting during this mbc show ^__^V
i had so much fun in Korea bcuz it was my very first trip to korea! My experience was amazing & you guys were amazing supporters!! yay
My Korean wasn't good enough to make everyone happy but I'm working hard to improve ^^ Born in America wasn't my choice~no matter what i I'm proud to be Korean-American & love being Korean-American ^^ Thankful for my supportive parents & family for loving me who I am & will miss you everyone^^
love, Megan
Congrats Megan!!! You deserve it.
I'll look forward to watching the future videos
You can count on all of us who are watching for support :)
im so excited!! definitely cheering you on!!!
Hitman bang....The second audition😂😂
When I see you sing in this video, I first think, "Meh". But then I see that this video was uploaded about 3 years ago! You've really grown to be a wonderful singer, so please keep singing! :D
I'm soooooo proud of you Megan, may dreams go farther than you can imagine! :) Good Luck!!!
Yay!! =) Good Luck on future rounds Megan!!
You go girl!!! :) I wish and pray that you make a difference in the world. This will truly inspire the next generations.
I was like "She can surely sing." and then I saw you run out of the room w/ Luna & Krystal from f(x) I was like "YOU ARE SO DAMN LUCKY." haha.
But yeah. YOU ROCK! \m/
Congratulations!!!! You sound so beautiful, i knew without a doubt you would get through.
@tenishotshot thanks for the wonderful translation ;)
I love your mom! She seems really cool and supportive.
Woahhhhhhh! CONGRATULATIONS!!! I really hope you get to fulfill your dreams!
yay! congrats, megan! so glad you made it!
eshh cried at the end, so happy for you...i love singing too and please don't give up cause you have great talent...yes he may have thought she was tryna show off cause you know when you sing you also need to feel the song not just sing it..like he said put emotion, so guys the judges have points too(:
Good luck in the future rounds !
I was getting teary eyed watching this~!
You are amazing! :D
Her mom is Korean, she's half.
AND AND AND ... Fighting!
Beautiful Video! So proud of you!
Wow, congrats ~ I know you can make it to the end! ^_^
Ah~ Look at Luna and Krystal at the end! I bet they were proud of you as well!
Congratulations! This is just another small step towards an amazing future for you.
I think that one judge was trying to channel some Simon, and he was a bit harsh on you but there is 1 thing you can take from it - Being blessed with such amazing talent isn't a free pass, and some people forget that when they become stars. Remember to never take it for granted and always sing from the bottom of your heart! Good luck!!
I love you Megan lee
Yay!! Go Megan! Good Luck!
I never wanted any other youtuber to succeed more than you... Keep doing what you do cuz its damn awesome
@angle021 That's whats so special and different about kpop idols. They're not just singers, they are entertainers. They entertain with every part of their being (singing, dancing, looks, personalities).
And there are plenty of "singers" that can't really sing... especially in American music...
omg congrats!!
i hope to see u singing on stages someday!
hope u win!
Good luck on future episodes!!
so supportive. idk if my parents would ever be supportive with my decision to become a singer or an actress or a dance or a model or anything related to the media. fighting.
omg.. I started tearing up when they said congrats! you DO have talent (:
aww, I cried for you. I'm going to look up the episodes! :D
CONGRATS!!!!!!! I hope you win!!!
Your Voice Megan is like an Angels
CONGRATS Megan!! :D
and GOOD LUCK for the next rounds! We'll all support you! HWAITING~!! xD
That was amazing you go girl!
I never knew that my one and first comment to one of your video will make people made. It was only to encourage you to keep on learning/speaking Korean, so you will succeed in Korea. I think you have an awesome voice and would like to see you be successful in the music industry
hey!! congrats!! and keep strong!!! Some people might not be receptive to you because you are a korean american but just remember the koreans over here that are rooting for you!!
I watched this last week. Megan I hope u win. :) Fighting!!!
good luck on there megan i would like to see you debut soon^^
good job! i expect to be in the crowd pointing at you on stage screaming "omg! i knew her when she was just a youtube star!! woooo!"
Yay Megan, congrats and good luck in the future rounds, if only I knew what the judges said
chill there, guys. what the judge meant by "the way you sing now seems like you are just trying to show off your skills" is that she sings just.... to sing, meaning that she doesn't put all her emotions in the song. Well, I guess that's it.
she is signed with Soul Shop Entertainment. watch her song 'Oppa"
AWWEH She is so cute at the end!!
i LUV how ur laughing and smiling up there, ur having fun and those judges are too harsh... heehee im korean and i understand everything they're saying.... YOU? SHOWING OFF??? your just doing what u lov.... those.. thosee.... bleh.
Congrats Megan! Your voice is amazing
congrats!!! u're amazing!!! looking forward to the next episodes!!! :D
I've redirected here from your Konglish cover of Rocketeer. And now I'm excited to see you sing in Korea and in the United States! I hope that people will recognize your talents even more, and that you'll be able to learn some Korean too :P
Ok, if you watch this video from last year, and her other video when she auditioned.
THERE IS ONE HUGE DIFFERENCE.
Keep it up Megan :) I'll be supporting you when you get through 8DD
Congratulations Megan! Korean Pride!
Ahhhh congrats Megan!!:) how exciting!!!
Congrats! You sang so beautifully!
wow they were harsh on you! but you pulled it together good job I'll be rooting for you!
OMG YOU CAN SING AND DANCE!!!... woaah! Aigoo!! ur so good!!
All the best for MBC! Hope u make it... if u dont then somethings wrong with those people!...
HWAITING ahaha
I was like about to go awwwww cuz of the judges tone and then BOOSH....YOU MADE IT GRATZZ!...Hope u WIN GOLD or 1st OR Something
yay ! congratulations ! good luck I really hope you make it :) you're going to like make it to the finals because you have uniqueness or something and then you'll became a kpop star and then you'll meet famous kpop people like super junior and 2pm . I'm jealous :( you have serious talent. when become famous don't forget about you're UA-cam viewers :) . fighting~!!
I love you Meagan!!!!
its unbelieveble i understand most of it...im so happy~
you will be my favorite singer Megan!!!
NOT HITMAN BANG LMAOOOOOOO HIS HAIR
!!! CONGRATS!!! Ahhhhh so happy for you!!! =D Good luck on your next episode!!! =D
aww yay!! congrats :) good luck with the future rounds!! you can do it!
omo! you danced to Wonderful..Though it was (not that) old song of Big Bang.. and I'm currently into that song.! xD so happy..
Yaaayyyy~~!!!! Congratulations Megan
lol your laugh is so funny at the beginning XD hehe but you are truly a great singer! Never give up girl :)
@apxmusic simple, because they are already celebrities and has a great deal of popularity,.. the point here is she's auditioning in korea for a show which will make her a celebrity, i think the judges gave the right decision to pull her out since their would be much suitable person than her hu also has talent..i mean after this show they'll become instant celeb, no need for 3-4yrs workshop, if she has been chosen then they'll need to make her study the language, accent, and a whole lot more..
You are too cute megan, especially for being so positive even when they were criticizing that you were what they call "Showing off!" -____- You're just too good for 'em. They can't handle you ; D
Congratz you passed! ;D
Megan hwaiting!
she has such an amazing voice : )
You have a great voice, definitely very different that most Korean singers, but I believe that's what will help your career. Keep up the good work, you're awesome.
ps: subtitles would be great =)
you did a great job megan! good luck for the up coming rounds. i auditioned too but i didn't make the 2nd round :( but im happy you made it through!!!!! XD
awww ur so cute!! Congrats! keep on going!!!
WOW CONGRATS MEGAN!!! i read some other comments that translated, and whoa that was pretty harsh >.< but i'm glad they put you through!! i hope you take their criticism with a grain of salt, but listen and understand what they want from you :D good luck!!!
awesome! wish you good luck!
congrats!! keep up the great work!! GODO LUCK! :D
The part where you put the annotation/ translation of the person saying "hmmm i forgot here.....ummmm -__-" Let me go ask my mom!" I actually thought that was what he was saying. xD
Omg congratzzzz !!!
ohh when he said "congrats" iwas like ommmmmmmg so happy for you :))
good luck!
CONGRATS!!!! GOOD LUCK! :D
OMG! I never knew you tried out for this! :O
Awesome!!! :D
@apxmusic they are successful because they are korean celebrities singing a japanese song, they do have the right accent and emotions when they sing since they rehearse it alot, and had a lot of help. why don't you try hearing someone from korea(hu's bad in english) sings in ur native language, with all those wrong pronunciation, accent and emotions, even how great a person's talent is, it's still no use since you won't gonna enjoy it, .. but don't get me wrong megan is AN AWESOME singer.
so cool! congrats again!
i can't believe those judges are saying such mean things! don't get discouraged or i will cry! keep singing! inlighten america!!!
CONGRATZ!!!
I can't believe you got in cause I think those judges were strict about you not speaking full Korean I'm so happy for you!
youre an amazing singer! the judges are only being harsh on you to make you more extraordinary. :)
eesh that was pretty harsh. But then again they are looking for someone who has THE potential and can express their feelings into the song. But you did great! Theres always next time (:
@EJCLProductions Not all Koreans, but these judges were definitely bashing on her because she is American. "In America it's kinda the thing to show off their vocals...they always do these things with their hands...."
@KyoraLove actually if Megan were to sign with a Korean label, I'd assume that she would sign with YG entertainment. Megan has stated on Popseoul that she's a HUGE YG fan. Fan of 2ne1, fan of Big Bang. So yeah I'd assume she'd go with YG plus YG is assume.
Why soo many talents?! sing dance instruments and cute smiles ]: im jealous lol~
CONGRATS!!!!! :)
omg when i was watching this i was went omg omg did you make it omg omg and when they said yes i was LIKE CHEERING YOU ON lol hahaha
p.s. can't wait to see you become famous in Koreaaaa >