Huns Vs Western Roman Empire: Battle of the Catalaunian Plains 451 | 4K Cinematic

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
  • #attila #cinematic #romanempire #aetius
    The Battle of the Catalaunian Plains, took place on June 20, 451 AD, between a coalition, led by the Roman general Flavius Aetius and by the Visigothic king Theodoric I, against the Huns and their vassals, commanded by their king Attila. It proved one of the last major military operations of the Western Roman Empire.
    00:00 - Aetius tracks down Attila
    01:53 - Aetius and Attila's armies square up
    04:15 - Attila begins the battle
    05:35 - Hunnic cavalry skirmish the Romans
    08:00 - Attila withdraws, and prepares to re-engage
    08:25 - The main battle begins
    12:25 - Aetius springs his trap
    14:30 - Attila retreats, aftermath of the battle
    ⬇ The Mods Used ⬇
    Performance maker for massive battles
    Realistic Battle Pack
    Attila Ultimate Animations
    Dux Bellorum part 1 - 3: Roman Reskin Overhaul
    Imperium Barbarorum: Germanic And Barbarian Reskin Overhaul
    Attila: Flora HD 1.0
    Olympian Battle Camera
    Blood and Gore DLC Better Performance
    Pikes Ready in your Hands
    Realistic Charge Impacts
    Larger Battlefield
    Large Units
    No Morale
    Medieval Warfare - Graphic
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 122

  • @WarAndHistory.
    @WarAndHistory.  3 місяці тому +40

    Guys help support the channel so we can continue to make higher quality content for you, go purchase one of our limited edition "Helms deep" Gaming desk mats = epicdesk.shop/collections/bellumethistoria

    • @yaaadutwumwaa6223
      @yaaadutwumwaa6223 3 місяці тому

      😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
      😢
      😢
      😢
      😢😢

    • @williamjenkinson9213
      @williamjenkinson9213 3 місяці тому +3

      Love what yous do.Thank you.

    • @FrankKelly-yx2cw
      @FrankKelly-yx2cw 3 місяці тому

      ​@@yaaadutwumwaa6223is 😢

    • @Maximus1883
      @Maximus1883 2 місяці тому +1

      no gladius's were used in the 5th century AD@@KeeKaiShee

    • @Maximus1883
      @Maximus1883 2 місяці тому

      you don't seem to be taking you're Loss very well@KeeKaiShee

  • @Manschier-0816
    @Manschier-0816 3 місяці тому +15

    Aetius wasn't only a professional soldier , also was a professional officer which know how to managing land's taxes , supply and populations .

    • @michalbock7648
      @michalbock7648 2 місяці тому +2

      and was murdered by his own emperor as a "reward". Apollinaris later said. Sir (he meant emperor Valentinian III.) I do not know what your reasons are but I only know that you have just cut off your right hand with your left.

  • @duane9830
    @duane9830 3 місяці тому +46

    Aetius was a gutsy soldier
    I admire him.

    • @michalbock7648
      @michalbock7648 2 місяці тому +8

      and was murdered by his own emperor as a "reward". Apollinaris later said. Sir (he meant emperor Valentinian III.) I do not know what your reasons are but I only know that you have just cut off your right hand with your left.

    • @duane9830
      @duane9830 2 місяці тому +4

      @@michalbock7648 just shows the empire really was ready to die

    • @michaelrichardson6051
      @michaelrichardson6051 2 місяці тому +5

      The LAST of the Romans.

    • @lancaster5077
      @lancaster5077 2 місяці тому +1

      Both West and East Roman empires were hamstrung by internal conflict. It was catastrophic for the future of the empire.

    • @richardscanlan3419
      @richardscanlan3419 2 місяці тому

      As was Stilicho before him.@@michalbock7648

  • @michalbock7648
    @michalbock7648 2 місяці тому +19

    Aetius was an oustanding officer and commander. He was able to gather a sizeable force at the time and defeated the most dangerous enemy of Rome. After the battle he refused to destroy the remnants of the army of Attila knowing that it would cause trouble with Visigots in the future. He was that smart. He needed Huns as they prevent barbarians living in Gaul to attack Rome itself. Visigots and the others could not invade Italy as their rear would be open, unsecured and vulnarable to attack. History tends to repeat and some thing are obvious. Aetius was murdered by his own emperor and I really like what Sidonius Appolinaris said who was in Ravenna at the time later said. Sir (he meant emperor Valentinian III.) I do not know what your reasons are but I only know that you have just cut off your right hand with your left. There was no one capable to secure roman borders after that. Maiorianus was the last capable emperor was was captured and murdered by his colleague a "roman" general Ricimer. It was common in late roman army that barbarians held high ranks.

    • @lancewilliams4190
      @lancewilliams4190 2 місяці тому +1

      What if Aetius had not been murdered?

    • @michalbock7648
      @michalbock7648 2 місяці тому +2

      @@lancewilliams4190 As you know history doesn´t know if. If he had not been murdered he would have been able to retake North Africa with help of the Eastern Romans, that would have provided grain and gold to Rome. Economy would have been stabilized and Western roman empire would have been able to recruit more troops in order to retake Hispania which was occupied by Visigoths. Aetius´s son would have been emperor and I think Western roman empire would have lastet much longer...These are my predicitions based on knowledge of general Aetius. He was really capable man and he knew very well this: No taxe = no army. No army= no emperor. Simple Logic. Retaking North Africa from Vandals was a key factor to restore partially greatness to Rome.

    • @salmanahmadabbasi6791
      @salmanahmadabbasi6791 Місяць тому +2

      Aegidius, a soldier in the army of Aetius and also a future general for imperator maiorianus also did well in securing Gaul but eventually all the gains of maiorianus and aegidius were nullified by the barbarian ricimer. Maiorianus even tried to retake africa from vandals but failed due to sea storms.

  • @laurenceseale
    @laurenceseale 2 місяці тому +11

    I read"Slave of the Huns" as a boy,I loved it.

  • @captainamerica6525
    @captainamerica6525 2 місяці тому +25

    In 25 years from the date of this battle the Western Roman Empire would be disolved, the emperor deposed, the legions disbanded or fell apart. It's incredible.

  • @cadenschmitt7380
    @cadenschmitt7380 3 місяці тому +12

    This is an awesome battle, i love seeing the ancient history battles

  • @PanzerNekoNo.2
    @PanzerNekoNo.2 2 місяці тому +8

    the cavalry charging scenes were awesome!!!

  • @duane9830
    @duane9830 3 місяці тому +14

    There should be a full hollywood movie about this battle

    • @matthewmatt5285
      @matthewmatt5285 3 місяці тому +1

      Yess,.Then Hollywood could actually put their diversity garbage into a Realistic realm~

    • @Bynk333
      @Bynk333 2 місяці тому +2

      Is id int? Thats shade... but hey something about Atilla was filmed....

    • @castricv
      @castricv Місяць тому

      Attila in 2000 does a reasonable job

  • @kylecrane3054
    @kylecrane3054 3 місяці тому +9

    I love late Roman history, thanks

  • @user-yr3uh7qf3v
    @user-yr3uh7qf3v 3 місяці тому +3

    I'm not a big history guy but I can see how much they loved garlic. They even had a bloody battle to have a garlic field.

  • @michaelrichardson6051
    @michaelrichardson6051 2 місяці тому +5

    Aetius saves Rome only to be assasinated by the Emporer whose rear end he saved.

    • @joet4811
      @joet4811 2 місяці тому +3

      And that pipsqueak of an emperor was in turn assassinated by Aetius's servant.

  • @benitoharrycollmann132
    @benitoharrycollmann132 3 місяці тому +20

    Your content is so well executed. From the pace of the music to the aesthetics of the animation. Truly tremendous.
    Would you ever consider putting together one of the battles mentioned in the Iliad? I'm sure you could bring it to life better than any movie

    • @WarAndHistory.
      @WarAndHistory.  3 місяці тому

      Thank you 🙏

    • @bertplank9892
      @bertplank9892 2 місяці тому

      The animation could be a whole lot better.....depends on available technology I suppose.

  • @charlesyork14
    @charlesyork14 2 місяці тому +7

    I am a military history student and son of a US Navy veteran and I am impressed by this presentation and story. It’s something I didn’t know about until I saw this. Attila was imposing and dangerous but the Romans and their allies were brave and victorious. The use of cavalry was the real game changer especially for the Romans.

  • @mkii699
    @mkii699 3 місяці тому +8

    16:28 damn that hunnic soldier went for the knockout

    • @duane9830
      @duane9830 3 місяці тому +2

      I hate attila as much as hitler, napoleon or william the conqueror.

  • @tenzinalexander
    @tenzinalexander 3 місяці тому +6

    I once read some material on this battle that theorized the Huns abandoned a lot of their nomadic lifestyle by the time the Catalunian Plains battle took place, hence their forces mostly composed of infantry rather than cavalry. I never looked roo far into this to see if that indeed was the case but its something interesting to investigate for anyone here who decides to read up more on this battle.
    The Roman general Flavius Aetius was one of Rome"s greatest and amongst the last great Roman commanders; the emperor Valentinian's execution of him sped up Rone's downfall without a doubt, he could have been Romes last hope; this blunder along with Stilicho's execution.

    • @Andriy_Sklyar
      @Andriy_Sklyar 3 місяці тому +4

      Despite his unjust fate, Flavius Aetius saved what we now call the Western World. He stood up against fate and turned the course of history. As for other Romans, they destroyed themselves, but I would still like to see a world where Aetius saved his Motherland from the ultimate fall.

    • @marschallhistory3286
      @marschallhistory3286 3 місяці тому +1

      Nun ja ich denke nicht das die Hunnen zu diesem Zeitpunkt ihren Nomadischen lebenstiel aufgegeben haben. Zur der Zeit der Schlacht auf den Katalaunischen Feldern. Hat Attila sowohl von Oströmischen als auch vom Weströmischen Hof recht große Tribute verlangt. Und hat gleichzeitig mehrmals die Donau Provinzen gebrandschatzt was den für ihn positiven Nebeneffekt hatte das er immer wieder die Erhöhung des Tributs fordern konnte. Und als er nichts mehr aus den Balken rausholen konnte hat er eben einen Westfeldzug begonnen um Gallien zu Plündern, angefangen mit der Provinz Beatica. Das alles trägt die handschrift eines Nomadischen Kriegsherren der seine Anhängerschaft mit Belohnungen zufriedenstellen muss damit sie ihm nicht die Treue aufkündigt. Zumindest ist das die allgemeine Definition von vormodernen Nomadischen Gesellschaften. Dazu ist die Hunnische vielvöker Konföderation nach Attilas Tod relativ schell zusammengebrochen. Was ein weiteres Merkmal von Dezentralisierten Nomadenreichen ist.
      Und soseher ich Stilicho und Aetius als Fan der Militärgeschichte schätze. So halte ich sie doch für einer der Faktoren durch die sich das Weströmische reich am ende auflöste. Durch ihre große Einflussnahme auf die Altagsgeschäfte des Reiches. Haben sie die Fähigkeit ihrer Kaiser selber zu regieren erheblich eingeschränkt. Und somit die zentralgewalt der eigentlichen Regierung stark geschwächt. Damit haben sie einen Trend begonnen bei dem spätestens Militärdiktatoren wie Ricimer nach belieben gleich mehrere Kaiser auf den Thron und anschließend wieder absetzen konnten. Sogar fähige Männer wie Majorian. Der das Westreich beinahe wiederhergestellt und langfristig überlebnsfähig gemacht hätte wurde von Ricimer gestürzt.

  • @Yoo-Kang
    @Yoo-Kang Місяць тому +1

    this was sick, thanks homie

  • @malgusvitiate7002
    @malgusvitiate7002 3 місяці тому +8

    Stunning video as usual! For the next several videos, you should do the Battle of Kadesh (1274 B.C.E.) and Suppiluliuma vs. Tausret (non-historical) for Pharaoh, the Battle of Artaxata (68 B.C.E.) and Carthage vs. Royal Scythia (non-historical) for Rome II, and the Siege of Milan (452 C.E.) and Vandals vs. Picts (non-historical) for Attila. As always, keep up the awesome work👍!

  • @calebnolan4726
    @calebnolan4726 3 місяці тому +4

    Huh, did not see that win coming. I was all set to lay a wreath for the fallen Roman Empire. Great job!

  • @user-ls6lv2ti1v
    @user-ls6lv2ti1v 3 місяці тому +6

    another masterpiece!!

  • @TinyLoaf96
    @TinyLoaf96 3 місяці тому +7

    wonderful i love your historic battle vids on the roman empire, cant get enough

  • @user-nd3ip2qx7l
    @user-nd3ip2qx7l 3 місяці тому +5

    Cool video, I love the story. Make a video about the battle on the Talas River, please.

  • @alexisking3579
    @alexisking3579 3 місяці тому +2

    This was amazing definitely earned a subscriber

  • @j.b.macadam6516
    @j.b.macadam6516 3 місяці тому +3

    Well done video! I am currently building 15mm armies that fought in that battle, using L' Art de la Guerre miniatures rules. Quite a mishmash of different troop types.

  • @eduardoleva9842
    @eduardoleva9842 2 місяці тому +2

    Excelente informe y animación, Congrats

  • @Heltwars
    @Heltwars 3 місяці тому +3

    Nice Video

  • @swisscheese9097
    @swisscheese9097 3 місяці тому +3

    Nice 🔥🔥

  • @embreis2257
    @embreis2257 2 місяці тому +2

    0:35 the map showing the Hunnic empire reaching the river Rhine is a bit misleading, don't you think? around 450 AD, the territory more or less effectively under Hunnic control was what is today's Romania, Hungary and surrounding areas up the river Danube. they made raids into more western parts of Europe but that is to be expected from a nomadic people like the huns.

  • @wh3391
    @wh3391 3 місяці тому +4

    Attila was a badass

  • @firmtree3902
    @firmtree3902 3 місяці тому +5

    ah~ Eternal Roma!

  • @PanaosSi-pc9uw
    @PanaosSi-pc9uw 2 місяці тому

    Gut gemachtes video übergeschichte.

  • @KARADJORDJIJE
    @KARADJORDJIJE 2 місяці тому +2

    Horde sa istoka kao i danas..Evropa ce pobediti svakako

  • @mohamedmedhat7594
    @mohamedmedhat7594 2 місяці тому +2

    a great battle

  • @beccahorton-he5bu
    @beccahorton-he5bu 2 місяці тому

    Brilliant

  • @Fyrd_Productions
    @Fyrd_Productions 3 місяці тому +2

    I am interested in cinematics and I wondered how you get the AI team to do what you wany or is it another player? If it is another player, does anyone know any tips if you only have ai to work with?

  • @timothylee2772
    @timothylee2772 2 місяці тому +2

    Only if Aetius had lived 20 more years instead of being murdered by the Roman Emperor himself. Perhaps elevated to emperor status. 😢😢😢The fate of the Roman Empire would have been likely different at least in the second half of the 5th century and beyond.

  • @Memes-du3fp
    @Memes-du3fp 3 місяці тому

    🔥🔥

  • @MadMamluk88
    @MadMamluk88 Місяць тому

    I don’t know why but I’m getting PTSD from hearing that conch/bugle when the lines collide.

  • @kdog543
    @kdog543 3 місяці тому +3

    I think it was agagerated a little the horseman the huns werent so great. Didn't the huns horseman lay dowm a barage of arrows and staying out of threat of legions until they were out of arrows except to roman cavery or one part to this battle you miss with Atilla the Hun command anyways great dispictions and animations of war of the times.

  • @user-ug9om5jz2q
    @user-ug9om5jz2q 2 місяці тому +1

    Catalaunum is the distorted name of the province of Catalonia!

  • @julianwilliamson6322
    @julianwilliamson6322 3 місяці тому +2

    What are your PC specs?

  • @CountViscula
    @CountViscula 3 місяці тому +6

    damn visigoths allied with roman? didn't they fight against each other?

    • @WarAndHistory.
      @WarAndHistory.  3 місяці тому +5

      yes they did, but for this battle they allied against the Huns

    • @Krelian89
      @Krelian89 3 місяці тому +3

      The enemy of my enemy its my friend!

  • @Varrants_Bokr
    @Varrants_Bokr 3 місяці тому +4

    The savages really didn’t want to have education and running water, nor did they want to wash regularly, which is why they fought.

  • @tonymondragon3114
    @tonymondragon3114 3 місяці тому +2

    For the algorithm

  • @janicomp
    @janicomp 2 місяці тому +5

    The Battle of Catalonia had no real winner, but both sides suffered huge losses. The Hun invasion led by Attila was stopped by the Roman troops led by Aetius and their allies, but they failed to win. In 452, Attila invaded Italy and withdrew from the city of Rome only with the intervention of Pope Leo I.

    • @hia5235
      @hia5235 Місяць тому +2

      No, there is a clear winner. Aeitius Won.
      The Roman goal was to defeat the Huns and drive them off the land. He won both the battle, and accomplished his goal.
      Attila raided Gaul: but left without his riches. The Baggage train was captured. And he lost the battle. He failed on this campaign.

    • @janicomp
      @janicomp Місяць тому +1

      @@hia5235 The Huns were not defeated, they reached Rome the following year

    • @peterkovacs8294
      @peterkovacs8294 17 днів тому

      Amit láttam előadást és olvasta, abban az volt leírva, hogy a Hun sereg ott maradt a csata helyszínén jól meggyepálva és egy szekérvárat alakított ki! Várták a támadást, de a Rómaiak reggelre elvonult! Azt is olvastam valahol, hogy a tartomány vezetője az egyik hadvezére lett Attilának, így meg aztán főleg hihető, hogy a másik fél nyert! Az ábrázolásról meg annyit, hogy a jelenlegi feltárások hazánkban, Orosz, Kazah, Ázsiában nem igazán támasztják alá, hogy a Hunok mongoloidok lettek volna, ugyanis igen elenyésző számban találnak a sírokban ázsiai típust! Még a keleti Hunoknál is az europid típus volt a többség!

  • @foolofatook4925
    @foolofatook4925 3 місяці тому +3

    Looks like someone got Hunned out to dry in this one…

  • @istvancsizmadia5975
    @istvancsizmadia5975 9 днів тому

    In this battle indeed the different germanic tribes killed each other mostly.Therefore the hun defeat was not too significant. Years later the hun civil war was much more determining for the hun tribes. They left Europe for a while, but later- few centuries later their descendants, the avars, and the hungarians came back to the Carpathian basin to Europe. From this point instead of looting other countries, they started to defend Europe from other eastern steppe nations, like the cumans, or the mongolians.

  • @adokadddok3318
    @adokadddok3318 2 місяці тому +1

    after this battle Atilla khan go tp Rome where is Pop Rome meet him

  • @TenOrbital
    @TenOrbital 2 місяці тому

    Various wargame lists give detailed troop types for the armies involved which could have added another level.

    • @WarAndHistory.
      @WarAndHistory.  2 місяці тому +1

      what do you mean?

    • @TenOrbital
      @TenOrbital 2 місяці тому

      check out Wargames Research Group (WRG) army lists, they make many of the rules sets used in competitive table top figure gaming.
      Their 6th Edition Ancient Rules and De Bellis Magistrorum Militum rules sets have accompanying army lists (4 books for DBMM) for hundreds of ancient and medieval armies, tracking changes in the same army over centuries in some cases.
      The lists give a much more detailed and rigorously-debated corpus on army composition than any other source I've seen. They've been arguing about this stuff for decades now so the latest lists are the product of much scholarly debate. I would recommend the DBMM lists since I much prefer those rules and the way they categorise troops, but opinions differ.

  • @marcoantoniorochapinto455
    @marcoantoniorochapinto455 3 місяці тому +1

    Como ficavam os cadáveres de milhares de guerreiros??

  • @ARKHAMASYLUM-qc7bw
    @ARKHAMASYLUM-qc7bw Місяць тому

    I’m starting to think after watching this battle archers had to be the most hated

  • @roderickreilly9666
    @roderickreilly9666 2 місяці тому

    I thought Aetius chose not to resume the next morning because both sides were suffering from sheer exhaustion. As it was, Atilla struck his camp and left Gaul

  • @fatihcoskun4372
    @fatihcoskun4372 5 днів тому

    Hunlar bu savaşı kaybetmedi.Ama Hunlar bu savaşta istediklerini almadılar.İki yıl sonra Atilla Roma'ya girerek diz çöktürüyor..

  • @Ulises-Gonzalez-3131
    @Ulises-Gonzalez-3131 3 місяці тому +1

  • @Ron-rl8pd
    @Ron-rl8pd 2 місяці тому +1

    Rien à voir avec les "plaines catalanes", il s'agit des Champs Catalauniques dans l'est de la France !!!

  • @chicagogyrl4846
    @chicagogyrl4846 Місяць тому

    So the Franks fought along with Attila, and with Rome! 😂🤣

  • @caesar9414
    @caesar9414 3 місяці тому +4

    The downfall of Attila, and shortly after the western Roman Empire

    • @rome5189
      @rome5189 3 місяці тому +1

      Indeed 😢

  • @turulnemzetseg
    @turulnemzetseg 2 місяці тому

    Ha akkora vereséget szenvedett Attila, hogy a következő évben Róma ellen vonult seregével, de senki nem állta az útját ? Maga a Római püspök térdelt előtte, könyörögve, hogy kímélje meg az örök várost .... elgondolkoztató ez a tény ....

  • @roycarvana3903
    @roycarvana3903 2 місяці тому +2

    Faulty images! Those helmet bushes were not used after 200 AD.

  • @user-ez3qr2rf3q
    @user-ez3qr2rf3q 2 місяці тому

    Аэция позволил уйти Аттиле потому что сам когда-то жил Среди Гуннов и знал и дружил в молодости с Королём гуннов Ругилой - Руа а это был дядя Аттилы и Бледы с помощью Ругилы и Гуннов Аэций в молодости одержал несколько побед над своими врагами Аэция жил и рос среди Гуннов он был отдан в аманаты Короче там много переплетений Всё не напишешь Учите Историю и поймете почему да как и за что и почему так сложилось нууу итд. И конечно же Политика а также в своё время Аэция пользовался услугами Аттилы когда воевал с вестготами Короче всё как Я уже говорил переплетение Судеб и сильных личностей Каждый был силён в своём Амплуа в своей стихии Они испытывали симпатии Они испытывали Дружбу и Вражду они воевали и дружили и они знали друг друга сильные и слабые стороны Ну и конечно же Политика Вот объяснение почему он дал уйти Аттиле в свою очередь Аттила поступил бы также с Аэций не дал бы полного уничтожения и разгрома именно этого своего соперника Как-то так)

  • @micksherman7709
    @micksherman7709 2 місяці тому +1

    Nice eye candy but historically baloney. Most of Attila’s forces were infantry.

    • @WarAndHistory.
      @WarAndHistory.  2 місяці тому +2

      Incorrect

    • @micksherman7709
      @micksherman7709 2 місяці тому +1

      It's a matter of logistics. See Ferill's The Fall of the Roman Empire: the Military Explanation.

    • @marschallhistory3286
      @marschallhistory3286 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@micksherman7709
      Natürlich war die Römische Armee auf eine Ausgefeilte und umfangreiche Logistik angewiesen. Deshalb bestand. (Nach den Quellen die ich gelesen habe die sich wiederum auf die Notia dignitatium stützen). Ungefähr 20-25% der Spätrömischen Armee aus Kavallerie Einheiten. Bei den Hunnen handelte es sich aber um ein Nomdenvolk die innerhalb ihrer von ihnen beherrschten Domäne umherzogen. Und das was sie benötigten von Tributflichtigen Völkern erhielten oder Plünderten. Die Germanischen Gentes die Atilla bei seinen Feldzug nach Gallien folgten (Gepiden, Ostgoten) waren zu der Zeit ebenfalls zu großen Teilen Nomaden. Und bei den Ost und Westgoten ist es zumindest belegt das sie große Kavalleriekontigente einsetzten.

  • @michailkulischov2820
    @michailkulischov2820 2 місяці тому

    How the Kommunikat if skool was no there, lol was habe die gemacht du verstehst das e 2024 ahahaa, how romans calculate a aquedukt with romans nr System without 0 lol

  • @rome5189
    @rome5189 3 місяці тому +1

    The last days of a dying empire 😢

  • @user-bx7mk4dw2o
    @user-bx7mk4dw2o Місяць тому

    Teodorico el visigodo ganó esa batalla

  • @deanbraden7695
    @deanbraden7695 2 місяці тому

    Way to noisy

  • @selvampoomani5218
    @selvampoomani5218 3 місяці тому

    Second pin?

  • @Paleontolygy
    @Paleontolygy 3 місяці тому

    first. pin???

  • @gaborszarka2124
    @gaborszarka2124 3 місяці тому +4

    Hungary is always! Atilla, Csaba, Aladár.

  • @gaborjuhasz5610
    @gaborjuhasz5610 3 місяці тому +2

    Aetius didn't win.
    Atilla stayed in the battlefield.

    • @WarAndHistory.
      @WarAndHistory.  3 місяці тому +7

      what?

    • @gaborjuhasz5610
      @gaborjuhasz5610 3 місяці тому +3

      @@WarAndHistory. What do you mean "what"?
      The wings are run away,
      Atilla moved back he's chariot-laager,and waited all night....
      The batle itself still on,all night..
      Aitius left the battlefield on the day secund,Atilla about 5-6 days later....
      As you see :You made a good one on false information.....
      Always the winners stay on the battlefield .
      Secondly Aetius grow up in King Ruga house ,(he was Atilla uncle,)
      He did knows:what you don't, like speaking Hun?/Magyar language, fluently,...
      Knowing the Hun force ,habits, power efficiency, (Horse archery, with reflex-bows,😄)
      (But is also true Atilla grow up in Honorius house as a "Prisoner of peace "😁)
      And after the batle with a fatal defeat
      in the wery next year, he (Atilla)shouldn't capable for a campaign
      untill Rome.....
      Where are the victorius Roman army?
      ...
      Our Chronicles are say differently,
      But ignored by the mainstream,

    • @marschallhistory3286
      @marschallhistory3286 3 місяці тому

      ​@@gaborjuhasz5610
      Die Mainstream Medien berichten durchaus auch von den Ausgang der Schlacht wie sie ihn gerade geschildert haben. Und Außerdem diskutieren Historiker heute noch über das genaue Ende der Schlacht. Außerdem kann es wirklich sein das er das Schlachtfeld verlassen hat. Die Plünderungen der Provinz Beltica und des Alanischen Siedlungsgebiets reichten vermutlich aus um seine Anhängerschaft vorerst zufriedenstellen. Da braucht er die Schlacht gar nicht mehr vortsetzen wo doch das Risiko bestand dass des Patt sich doch noch in eine Niederlage verwandelt könnte. Außerdem haben alle Männer im Römischen Staatsaparat mindestens latain und Grichisch gesprochen. Weil man ohne dieses Maß an Bildung gar nicht zur in die höhere Gesellschaft hätte aufsteigen können.

  • @user-px5pj2rg4l
    @user-px5pj2rg4l Місяць тому

    망치와 모루전술

  • @silverblack1816
    @silverblack1816 2 місяці тому

    Настоящее имя Атиллы, это Адыл. Это имя кыргызское, именно кыргызские племена из глубин Азии пришли в Европу.

  • @svetlanaodintsova4615
    @svetlanaodintsova4615 4 дні тому

    Стоит правильно освящать в истории то что было стёрто теми кому выгодно извращение истории по всему миру

  • @svetlanaodintsova4615
    @svetlanaodintsova4615 4 дні тому

    И стоит оспорить то что по цифрам не соответствует истории- это про цифры которые в истории не соответствуют Датам и годам когда происходили эти битвы и сражения и числа (цифры ) не соответствуют ВЕКАМ которыми нас кормят ЛЖИВЫМИ Датами говоря про исторические ДАТЫ- ЛЕТА от РОЖДЕСТВА ХРИСТА - в истории не может быть ДАТ которыми нас кормили (ЛЖИВЫМИ цифрами и стертыми в ВЕКАХ забытыми СРАЖЕНИЯМИ войнами восстаниями и просто СТЫЧКАМИ - у них нет названия -как и сейчас ВНИМАНИЕ!- пример: развал страны РСфСР и СССР сколько конфликтов насчитали произошло и предшествовало развалу страны- сколько народу погибло- никто не считал! - кого уничтожали по заказу а кого просто уничтожали ради захвата богатств ( в маленьком или большом) понимании Село- деревня- город и СТО(100) лиц и у каждой страны есть самый главный и лицо которое управляет и разваливает но прихлеБАЕВ никто не считает Союз(Уния ) называется - из скольки букв состоит слово(Союз) из Четырёх- могу поспорить что значение и само слово состоит из Пяти букв но нам предоставляют слово как из ЧЕТЫрех и никто не обращает на слово СОЮЗ подразумевая (УНИЯ) тоже состоит из ЧЕТЫрех букв и говорят и ЛЖИВОЕ обманчивое слово СОЮЗ(УНИя) говоря про равенство ЦИфР тоже четыре - а вот и нет снова ОБМАН показывая ЧЕТЫре а НЕГЛАСНО показывают ВЛАСТЬ всего ПЯТИ в цифровом обозначении