26 UNSOLVED Harry Potter Questions! ft Tessa Netting
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лип 2017
- TESSA: / tessanetting
These are the types of questions that keep a Harry Potter fan up at night! Tessa Netting and I discuss!! Comment with your unsolved questions!
"WHAT UP WORLD" tshirts: store.dftba.com/products/what-...
FOLLOW ME ON THE THINGS!
twitter: / brizzyvoices
facebook: / brizzyvoices
vlogs: / brizzyvlogs
instagram: / brizzyvoices
twitch: / brizzyvoices
meow! - Розваги
I'd say regarding why there is so few in Harry's year is because that was the climax of the first war, so less people were having children and others were dying. Like 1978-81 was probably on the lower side of wizard babies.
Emily Deanne I always assumed there were multiple dorm rooms for each year, and we just never met all the kids in Harry's year.
Brizzy Voices With boggarts I say they become what you are afraid of, as Remus Lupin (RIP) showed in PoA he jumped in front of Harry's dementor boggart as he was afraid of what it would do to Harry and his classmates. Why else would Lupin jump in front of him?
Brizzy Voices what if I have the characteristics of a Ravenclaw, (which I proudly am) but I want to be a ( for example) hufflepuff. Harry could have been in slytherin. But, he chose to be in gryffendor. So does that mean anyone can choose to be in any house?
Davileca C. Well remember what Harry said in the last movie and I quote "The sorting hat takes your choice into account too" so if you want to be in hufflepuff but the sorting hat thinks your a ravenclaw it will take your choice into account. So I'd say you have a 50/50 chance of getting into either. Because the sorting hat wants to choose what's best for you also
1000 divided by 7 years is approximately 143 students per year. 143 divided by 4 houses is 36 students in each house in each year. So if there are only 10 students in Gryffindor in Harry's year, another house or year would have to make up for this and have more than 36 students. I just feel like there were other students in Gryffindor in his year that were not talked about in the books.
I feel like a lot of the questions could be answered if Harry was MORE OBSERVANT IN HIS EVERYDAY LIFE.
Baylee Morris TRUE
Baylee Morris exactly.
which is why Harry and even Hermione are not in ravenclaw. I mean come on sees writing in a book in same handwriting she's been meticulously copying off a board for the last 5 years and 'it looks like a girl'. come on Hermione thought you were supposed to be the smart one here.
Baylee Morris
Baylee Morris OMG YES
"We're going to give you Felix Felicis and a time turner. Go save the world"
Sure, great story! Now they don't have to deal with grief/ consequences of their actions. No empathy or actual storyline.
I'd love to read that.
TaylerMarie13 y'all liquid luck doesn't do anything it's just using the placebo effect to make you think you're super lucky
That would turn into a complete mess, think about all the stuff the irresponsible students could do with a time-turner, as for the Filex Felicis now that is a good idea 🤔.
A wand strap would grant the user full immunity against disarming spell like Expelliarmus , GENIUS 😂
It sounds like something the twins would sell, after turning it invisible. "Challenge your mate to disarm you while wearing it and watch their face when they can't!"
It's because Harry then wouldn't be able to kill Voldemort with the disarming charm, the Ministry had forbidden such things
Harry knows *one* spell.. Don't take that away from him
in the books slughorn said that if you dont create felix felecies precisely that it could resault in death that is why its so rare
and also if you take it too often the effect gets weaker as well. So even if you know how to produce it and do it right every time it won't necessarily do anything after a week or so. In the films you can actually see slughorn swallowing some potion before the battle starts.
And if you take too much you get nauseous and dizzy
Uh..Ron is sleeping with somebody named Peter.. - Fred
Nice - George
Oh look Ginny is gone! - George
That's.. Cool -Fred
Omg look it says that Voldemort is balancing on Quirrel..-Fred
Haha, let's go throw snoballs at him-George
Wilma Rosenqvist so trruuuueeee
So true! OMG! This is probably what happened!
Wilma Rosenqvist omg lol so gold
Lol
Wilma Rosenqvist omg yes!!!
"Magical puberty😂"
I read your comment a the same time they said it!
“Are you smarter than a fifth grader?”
Wizard: “I’m AS smart as a fifth grader”
Me: I am a fifth grader
what if your fear is bogarts ,
what will u see ??
im gonna like this because no one else will D:
Crazy Latte That’s exactly what I was thinking
OH MY GOD!!!!!!!
Sammmeee
How can you be afraid of a bogart
Mello Melodiaxd there is a phobia phobias, so if they know that bogarts expose fears, they would be afraid of it
My question is what exactly is the function of a rubber duck?
ASeriesOf PotterGames you are smart🙂
ASeriesOf PotterGames but siriusly😏 what is the awnser
ASeriesOf PotterGames i
ASeriesOf PotterGames NOOOOOOOOOOOOO DONT BRING THIS BACK!!!!! THIS TREND IS DEAD SO LEAVE IT DEAD PLEEEEEAAAAAASE
Oh well ah you see
No this is why
"HAPPY Christmas Ron"
"HAPPY christmas harry"
God damn its merry christmas
crystal guardian
Pretty sure saying Happy Christmas instead of Merry Christmas is a British thing.
That’s a British thing
Sabribrib The Potato yah Ron and Harry are British
Sabribrib The Potato they are British
Im British, I say ‘Happy Christmas’ but we say ‘have a merry Christmas!’
This year my year was ruined
I turned 11 and didn't get my hogwarts acceptance letter
Maybe the Owls are just late
That's what I thought !! But I haven't gotten the letter for 3 years !
Semilina the Harry Potter fan Weird I went up to my room and found mine on my floor saying:
To (classified name)
The bedroom at the top of the stairs
I got mine, but it was like a year late. Must just take owls a long time to get to America.
@@blckbrry-_-7547 if you live in America shouldn't you be going to Ilvermorny?
I'm almost 19 and did not so you still have time 🙃
I believe that peeves was born from the mischievous spirit of the students of the school
Harley Quinn you know that's true... right?
Plus I'm a massive Harley Quinn fan too
Harley Quinn he is
WOULD FRED AND GEORGE BE A POSTUGUIST
Cheeto_boss 3 No, because a poltergeist isn’t a ghost. It’s essentially a collection of memories. It’s all the mischievous students mischievous deeds put together. That’s why Peeves can touch solid objects without going through them. Fred might be good friends with Peeves, but Fred would be unable to do the things Peeves does, because Peeves is a poltergeist and Fred would just be a ghost. I like to think though that Fred would make Peeves stop making fun of the first years. I think Peeves would listen because of the way he respected Fred in the books. And no, Fred and George would not be ghosts at Hogwarts. Only Fred would. For obvious reasons.
I KNOW WHAT THE PAINTINGS ARE PAINTED OUT OF... A *_MAGIC_* MARKER
Screaming_ Unicorn omg...😂😂😂
NO, A MAGIC QUILL
Haha
For the bog arts I would assume that they have a fraction of the creatures power like a dementor for example. They would make you feel sad in their presence but the don't suck out your happiness
The reason Peter didn’t appear on the map to Fred and George but he did appear to lupin is that the marauders made the map so they can’t be seen on the map by anyone but another marauder
In the book it was Remus who saw Peter, not Harry. Hope that helps!
Mim Mam but harry saw peter on the map too... and he’s not a marauder
Mim Mam then yy could Harry see them
Wait maybe it’s because he’s a relative of a marauder.
GENIES!!!😮
9:22 the difference between a poltergeist and a ghost is that a ghost is someone who was alive but then didn't want to leave the world when they died and a poltergeist not someone who has died but has been generated in a certain environment. e.g. peeves was generated at hogwarts because of all the mischief that happened with so many young people.
Actually, Jo answered why harry didn't see thestrals before. It was because to see a thestral you have to mourn the death first, you have to take it in. When he was a baby he didn't know what he was seeing. Then when he killed quirrell, he didn't mourn him, nor he really understood what he had done, because he was still too young. It's not until he sees cedric die that he knows what it means and only then he fully feels loss. That's why the next year (5th), when he has grieved, he's able to see thestrals.
And about the technology and the efficient ways of muggles, I think that's the whole point. Back to basics, things we've forgotten, magic is all that matters.
kd sn yeah and after he has mourned he has to get over it and accept it too
It's 11 because in the UK that's the age to go to secondary school(high school) but I like your version better
Sylvia Cherney yeah I’m from the UK and we start high school when we are 11
@@madisonsabsoluterandomness5411 damn your 14 in America 😂😂
That is true
Yep
It never bothered me because in France we begin collège (wich I think is translated Middle School) in the year de are 11 (if there is no problem)
The Hogwarts poltergeist borned like a poltergeist. He never was a human. He born because of the confusion and mess in the school
BRIZZY + TESSA + HP == BEST VIDEO EVER!!💜💜
Zjana Maritz yeeeessssss!! Same here. Best vid ever
THAT IS THE 2 MOST TRUE THING I HAVE HERD
the 1st thing is that I talk about Harry potter in the middle of class and it gets me in trouble
Zjana Maritz yasssssssss!
SO TRUE!!!
There's something that's always bugged me when people say "oh harry why don't you save your parents instead of buck beak?" Even if he did , it would literally create a paradox where harry goes back and isn't an orphan but then he never has to go back , so he would go back again and yadda yadda yadda.
I agree with you.
Also even if Harry wanted to go back and save his parents, he couldn't. The Time Turner that Hermione had belonged to the Ministry, and was limited to go back in time 5 hours. And all of those Time Turners were later destroyed in the battle in the Ministry.
And didn't Hermione says "bad things happens to wizards who meddle with time"
Kalin Moultrie IKR!!!! It makes me so mad
Besides it was just an hourly Time Turner. One turn of the dial was one hour. Harry doesn’t have all day to be spinning dials.
The time turner only goes back in time, is that right? Then if Harry went back 12 year he has to live those 12 without being seen. And is he getting older during that time, some when his 13 year old self disapear there is a 25 year old Potter there to take his place?
I mean it would also just be impossible. There is 8,760 hours in a year. And harry would have to go back 13 years by the time he finds out about the time turner. 113,880 hours in 13 years. He would have to rotate the time Turner this many times. No one could do that. And even then what's he going to do? I guess he could go back and warn Sirius not to make Peter their secret keeper. That would probably be the easiest. But then Voldemort wouldn't have died and the future would be even worse. Yea no he cant change that. They definitely should have used the time turner at the end of book four though.... if he went back or who ever, doesn't have to be harry, they could warn Dumbledore that the cup is a portkey and Dumbledore and a few other powerful wizards could've used the portkey to go to the graveyard and kill Voldemort before he got his power back and stuck Peter in azkaban. I mean I really don't get why they couldn't do this. Maybe its bc the time turners are owned by the ministry of magic and they didn't believe harry so why would they give them a time turner. Idk I just feel like at this point Dumbledore should have his own time turner.
Peeves is basically a manifestation of all the mischievous spirit from the students. If Hogwarts was to be abandoned, Peeves would just disappear.
Wow that actually makes a lot of sense 🤔👍.
i have a question. why didn't harry's parents just choose to be ghosts so they could raise their son.
Because when a wizard dies he or she can only stay as a ghost if they're afraid of continuing and seeing what's next. If you stay as a ghost you're stuck in the middle of that, you didn't continue but you're not alive either. Many wizards that die decide to continue. So if they didn't stay as ghost was because they weren't afraid of continuing.
But if Brizzys theori about the veil is true they could just pass on when Harry dies and join him in the magical afterlife😊❤ that is so cute🥰
We get a glimpse of what death is like in deathly hallows. It's a very confusing thing and Harry viewed it as "boarding" a train (and Dumbledore). I believe that the Wizards aren't entirely sure what is happening so only those who are afraid of death remain behind.
Edit sorry if this is confusing I'm typing from a phone
A ghost is a person who is afraid of death so you cannot choose to be a ghost or not
Not all wizards can chose
I think they just choose to celebrate Christmas for fun. Like I'm Jewish but our family still puts up a tree and puts Chanukah gifts under it cause it's saucy.
CZsWorld Growing up I had a friend who was Jewish, and she would celebrate both Chanukah and Christmas with her family. When we got older they stopped celebrating Christmas, reason being when she was younger it bothered her so much that all her friends got to celebrate Christmas and not her, so her family did. When she got older she understood more, and didn't care about doing something all of her friends were. So, you're not the only one, what you said is entirely possible. Especially because a lot of wizards may be muggle born, half blood, descendents of muggle borns, etc. Hermionie for example probably celebrated Christmas her whole life, so when she has kids they would probably celebrate as a family, then when her children have kids, and so on.
CZsWorld a
I mean, I also have friends who weren't allowed to watch Harry Potter as a kid because their family is so religious, so it goes both ways I guess.
CZsWorld those poor children who didn't watch Harry Potter
Chanukah bush. My dad will get a Christmas tree for my stepmom but will hang Chanukah candles on it like ornaments 😂😂😂
"Turn this water into rum"
Harry:"What's he doing to that water?"
OH I DONT KNOW
Hermione Granger Harry's so stupid at that point
Lol
*A package in the shape of a broom stick is dropped off next to Harry*
Harry: I wonder what it is...
Hermione Granger this is why Harry isn't in ravenclaw
*letters shoot out from the fireplace and fall down on the floor*
harry: *jumps up to get one from the air*
''WAS JESUS A WIZARD??''
Hey, I follow you! Only did about a week ago. You have great content, keep up the phenomenal work!
Sofie Mosegaard Really? Then why was Ollivander’s wand shop established 384 BC? BC as in Before Christ. Magic was around long before Jesus.
I want to like your comment, but the likes are at 69.
illmakeuhowell hahahahaha good one but no he was just gifted when he was born😂😉😐
illmakeuhowell well was Moses a wizard
"I WAS ABOUT TO ENTER PRE-ALGEBRA!!" She would totally say that would't she...
Laura Doan no, she would say, “but I was just learning how to do calculus! Fine I’ll try to learn that in my spare time.” Btw, I’m 11 and doing pre algebra.
OH I WONDER WHAT'S IN THIS BROOM SHAPED PARCEL
Marta Castillo a book
Bellatrix 24601 no its fucking ilvermorny
zaonth dammit... I thought it was some Weasley Wizard Wheezes
Marta Castillo In the book it is a bit better. It is just a long skinny package not a broom wrapped in paper...sure Draco is able to say what it is but consider the source on that one.
Yeah I know, everything in the books is better, I just laugh so much everytime I watch the film xD
Before they go to Hogwarts, wizards learn to talk, walk, read, write, and other basic things from their parents.
Lilly Zarmehrbakhsh But how do their parents learn that in the first place?? That's the question?! 😊
Does that mean that muggle borns would be smarter than wizard borns then?
I think that they would either attend a muggle junior school discreetly or the parents are issued textbooks from the ministry?
Brizzy Voices Tessa Netting regarding the time turner question if you read the phrase on the larger ring it says and I quote: “I mark the hours every one Nor have I yet outrun the sun” so I think that means you can’t go back more than a day cause it can’t outrun the sun so maybe that’s why .
P.S I love you both you’re amazing.
Rodrigo Torres This makes so much more sense now. I have heard people say that you can't go further back than a day before, but I never understood why they thought this. If you mention the inscription it makes way more sense.
Yeah maybe but in the Harry Potter and the cursed child Albus and Scorpius went back for more than 20 years to save Cedric
@@emagroff7099 The cursed child is fanfiction xD
@@emagroff7099 The cursed child is fanfiction xD
Ema Groff Yeah, however that was an experimental time turner
Maybe only the marauders can only see the other marauders on the map
Twin Grace but then how could Harry see pettigrew?
Harry is James’ son, so he’s related to a marauder which would allow him to see peter
I think that James is related Harry and that’s how he can see Peter but Fred and George should be able to see them because we find out in Order of the Phoenix that the Weasley’s are related to Sirius who is a marauder! So Fred and George should be able to see Peter but I don’t think they are using the map to see people so they don’t look for him.
@@danicutler598 You don't think they'd ever check on Ron? One day? In three years?
Can’t be as Snape is able to see lupin going down the tunnel in the third book
My question is, is there like a different prison for wizards who have committed crimes that aren’t horrible enough for Azkaban? Like, if someone robs a jewelry store, for example, that’s not something worthy for Azkaban. So where would they go?
Sophia
If you commit a smaller crime then sometimes (depending on what you did) you can have your wand taken of you as punishment or even broken, this happened to Hagrid (I think it was after he was accused of opening the chamber of secrets) but he took the parts of his wand and put them in a pink umbrella. So to answer your question I am not sure if there is another prison and all this stuff about wands was irrelevant 😃
Nope, you steal a lollipop, you’re going to Azkazaban.
Nope if you steal a chocolate frog you get the death eaters kiss.
In all seriousness I'm pretty sure the ministry snapped people's wands but for something that wasn't even worthy of having your wand broken you would probably have to ask J.K. Rowling herself
I think they start Hogwarts at 11 because that is when secondary school starts in England
That isn’t a theory, that’s a basic fact...
Ravenclaw Panda
And the new york
Or maybe it would be way too dangerous for 6 year olds to go to Hogwarts.
Also by that age pretty much all wizard children have shown signs of magic
Yeah I mean I’m English so it always made sense to me but honestly I prefer their theory 😹
*_M A G I C A L P U B E R T Y_*
me going to hogwarts:
-laptop
-cellphone
-pencil
-tracker for if i loose my wand
-other muggle things that would be of great use...
Hermione said they don't work inside the Hogwarts grounds because there's too much magic in the air
@@lutforrohman4806 true but I think that only applies to electronic devices. Surly a normal ball pen would work just fine. It's been a while since I've read the books so I'm not entirely sure what her exact words were.
My un answered question:
WHERE IS MY HOGWARTS OR ILVERMORNY LETTER?!
Žâčh Çįphęr you can get one
All right, here you go:
1. When Harry uses the Patronus Charm on the Dementor in the Triwizard Tournament, he realizes that it’s a Boggart because it stumbles. So it’s not literally turning into a Dementor-it’s more like a shadow of one.
2. In order to see Thestrals, it’s not enough to see someone die. You also have to understand and process what you’ve seen. Even after seeing Cedric die, he doesn’t see the Thestrals at first because he was still in shock. (And, yes, Harry passes out before Quirrell dies.)
3. I think it’s strongly preferable to tell them _before_ marriage, because otherwise it’s not fair to them. If they’re not cool with it, you modify their memory. Also, Lily didn’t actually do magic at home; Rowling said Petunia was exaggerating. Muggles can enter Diagon Alley if a wizard points it out to them.
4. No, your magical abilities are apparent by age seven. Hogwarts starts at eleven because it’s secondary school. Before that, wizards can either be homeschooled or attend Muggle primary schools.
5. The UK Prime Minister is only informed when the situation puts Muggles at risk. Like if you’re bringing dragons into the country or an alleged mass-murderer escapes from your high-security prison.
6. There’s a democratic election every seven years. (Although they’ll hold earlier elections if the Minister is removed from office.) There’s no limit to a Minister’s term. I highly doubt that Centaurs would have been permitted to vote. They also do not really recognize the Ministry as an authority. They likely would have found these _human_ matters beneath them.
7. NOOOOOO! It drives me crazy whenever people mention this! There was absolutely no reason for the Weasleys to see Pettigrew on the Marauder’s Map. Why would Fred and George be looking at their little brother’s dorm? They only used the Map to sneak around/out of Hogwarts. That’s why they gave Harry the Map-they’d already memorized all the secret passages, which was the main reason they used it. The only individuals they would have cared about seeing on that Map were Snape, Filch, Mrs Norris, etc. And with countless moving dots, they would never just _happen_ to see Pettigrew’s unless he were in the exact place they were looking. And before Sirius escaped, Scabbers was way too lazy for that to happen.
8. Cool question! I assume that it would eventually die. This reminds me of the Ravenclaw riddle about where Vanished objects go.
9. Yes (see #4). Hogwarts is a secondary school. (For Americans, that’s middle school combined with high school.) For primary school education, students attended Muggle schools or were homeschooled.
10. Because it’s a fixed timeline. Also, I know this wasn’t the question, but I often see people upset that the Time Turner was used to save Buckbeak instead of, e.g., Harry’s parents. So just in case anyone here is wondering: They use it to save SIRIUS. Saving Buckbeak is a means to that, and it’s nice because they can save _two_ innocent lives. But they wouldn’t have gone to all that trouble just for Buckbeak. And the only reason they were able to save either one of them was that neither one had been killed/Kissed yet.
11. Since it’s the Department of Mysteries, we can’t be sure, but the brains seem to be corporeal thoughts. (Like Madam Pomfrey tells Ron, “Thoughts can leave deep scars.”) The HP Wiki mentions that Legilimency was likely used there.
12. Yeah, the veil is used as a metaphor for death throughout the series, even when they’re not in the room. But that’s a really neat theory about the ghosts! (Or would their incorporeality prevent them from going through?) It could also be used for the death penalty, if that’s ever a thing…
13. Yes, that was the point! It makes Sirius’s death all the more devastating! But just to remind you, Harry didn’t even open the package until after Sirius’s death. When Sirius gives it to him, he vows never to open the package because he’s worried that Sirius will leave Grimmauld Place to help him and get caught. So when the time comes and he really needs it, he’s forgotten all about it.
14. I’m not entirely sure what the question was here, but the series _did_ take place in the ’90s.
15. BUT THE ÆSTHETIC!!!
16. Skele-Gro is a magical solution to a magic problem. Shrinking your teeth is cosmetic. Even Muggles have acne creams (although ours are way less effective). Eyesight seems different, you know? It’s genetic, so it may be inherently a part of you. Plus it would have to be incredibly specific, as everyone’s eyesight is going to be different. I would definitely not want to mess around with that!
17. Poltergeists are spirits of chaos. They are not dead humans, as they are neither human nor dead. They are probably amortal. Poltergiests usually do not take physical forms (but there are exceptions, like Peeves). Unlike ghosts, which are always incorporeal, poltergeists can move solid objects and directly interact with the physical world.
18. LOL. That would make it harder to conceal your wand and could potentially hinder your wrist movement, although it might prevent you from losing a buttock.
19. Nah, Aurors are way too important for that. But other Ministry employees deal with that sort of thing. Different departments handle different crimes.
20. Because Veritaserum can be fought. It only works on Barty Crouch, Jr. because he was extremely vulnerable at the time. This is similar to how polygraphs are rarely admissible in court.
21. This would definitely depend on the individual. I can’t speak for Christianity, but here’s my personal opinion as an Orthodox Jew: Divine occurrences would not be perceived as magic, as that would detract from their validity. However, magic could potentially be viewed as divine. Additionally, we take many things for granted that can be perceived as miraculous.
22. I WANT TO KNOW SO BADLY. Like, I know I shouldn’t want to, but I do.
23. Yes, you can still remember it. The cool thing is that humans actually do remember all that stuff, but we aren’t able to access our memories in so much detail. And if you leave it in your Pensieve, it’s not that you’ve lost your memory. It’s that you’re able to concentrate on other things. Personally, I think Pensieves could be immensely helpful for people with anxiety.
24. HA HA HA MATH. There were only forty students in Harry’s year. Don’t think about it too much. Although, if you do think about it, think about how the numbers were likely impacted by Voldemort.
25. It’s EXTREMELY difficult to make. Ron asked about it after Harry got Slughorn’s memory. Aside from being super complicated, it takes six months to brew. It also has dangerous side effects if you use it too frequently. In fairness, though, they did use it before the battle of Hogwarts in HBP.
26. Yup, they’re based on the painters’ impressions. But since Dumbledore knew his death was coming, he talked to his portrait a LOT beforehand, in preparation. And I don’t know if portraits ever marry, but the Fat Lady and Violet sure seemed pretty close…
7. I just want to add, that when Pettigrew faked his death the twins would have been around 3 years old. The twins either don't know or remember Pettigrew's name. So IF they just happen to see Pettigrew's name, they would think it just another student.
It's actually likely that the twins _did_ know. Arthur told Ron the story about Pettigrew's finger, and Ron was even younger than the twins.
Can you enlighten me as to when, Arthur told Ron about Pettigrew's Finger? I don't remember that.
Sure! It's a quote from PoA, chapter eleven ("The Firebolt"), page 215 in the American hardcover edition: "Listen… you know what Pettigrew's mother got back after Black had finished with him? Dad told me - the Order of Merlin, First Class, and Pettigrew's finger in a box. That was the biggest bit of him they could find."
TheLadyWhoLunches Thanks :)
It doesn't say when Arthur told Ron that story. I can see Arthur telling them (Ron, Ginny, Fred and George) after Sirius broke out of Azkaban, that would make since.
IF Arthur told them after, then I stand my original comment. "The twins either don't know or remember Pettigrew's name."
That thing with Peter and Ron there is a good theorie for it. Because the maraurders made the map. They enchanted it so only they could see the other maraurders. You sould watch Seamus Gormans theorie about it
Moa de Visser and relatives of them because Harry saw him
The Thestral thing isn't just about seeing someone die, it's also understanding death and Harry at one year did not understand death at all. He also didn't see Quirrell die (at least not in the books); he fainted before it happend.
CAN A DEMENTOR KILL A HORCRUX BY SUCKING ITS SOUL OUT???
In theory, yes. Even though a person lives after their soul has been taken out (Barty Crouch Jr), they're in a vegetative state for the rest of their lives. However, since a horcrux is a piece of a person's soul stuck into an object, it would be possible to suck the piece of soul out and have the object just be a normal object again.
You are a genius
nikkyheravenclaw
IM SHOOK.
nikkitheravenclaw no, a dementor can only suck a living things soul spans I believe that they can only suck a whole soul so I think a dementor could not suck out Voldemort’s soul because you could say he is not a full human.
This is actually smart, though how would the dementor suck it out, when they suck a humans soul out they do it through the mouth..like does the horcrux have to have an opening? What if it's just a piece of metal?
I think Harry couldn't see the thestrals was Bc he couldn't remember the night his parents died. All he says he remembers was a flash of green light and a high pitched scream. He couldn't see them after Quirel Bc he fainted before Quirel officially died. That my thoughts about it. Do u agree?
Yeah I agree cos you also have to be able to understand the death of the person.
Lilly Zarmehrbakhsh i
MAYBE BECAUSE HE SAW TOM RIDDLE DIE WHEN HE DESTROYED THE DIARY..... but technically that was a *memory* of Tom Riddle so who the fuck knows
Shannon Reynolds he saw cedric die at the end of coblet...
The second one is because
When hè was one hè didn’t understand death yet .and when hè killed quirrel it was because hè didn’t kill HIM normaly (with avada kedavra).hè Sees them in YeaR 5 bevause them hè sees cedric die normally and uderstands it.
Maybe (idk if anyone has said this) Harry didn’t see his mom when he dyed because he couldn’t see through the green light of the spell?
Really specific
That is even canon, because J.K. Rowling said that on her old website😉
_I’ve been asked this a lot. _*_Harry didn’t see his parents die. He was in his cot at the time (he was just over a year old) and, as I say in ‘Philosopher’s Stone’, all he saw was a flash of green light._*_ He didn’t see Quirrell’s death, either. Harry had passed out before Quirrell died and was only told about it by Dumbledore in the last chapter._
_He did, however, witness the murder of Cedric, and it is this that makes him able to see the Thestrals at last. Why couldn’t he see the Thestrals on his trip back to the train station? Well, I didn’t want to start a new mystery, which would not be resolved for a long time, at the very end of the fourth book. I decided, therefore, that until Harry is over the first shock, and really feels what death means (ie, when he fully appreciates that Cedric is gone forever and that he can never come back, which takes time, whatever age you are) he would not be able to see the Thestrals. After two months away from school during which he has dwelled endlessly on his memories of the murder and had nightmares about it, the Thestrals have taken shape and form and he can see them quite clearly._
Source: web.archive.org/web/20110623034324/www.jkrowling.com/textonly/en/faq_view.cfm?id=21
I wish you a blessed weekend🙋♀️
I have one:
How come Harry gets “expelled” when he does magic in front of Dudley even though, the muggle-borns perform magic in front of their parents and Dudley was family?
And:
The answer to the question about Wizarding kids before they go to Hogwarts is that some families home school their kids before they go to Hogwarts because that’s what Molly Weasley did for her kids.
Also:
I think ghosts can’t touch things because they would just go right through them and Poulterguists (don’t know how to spell that) can touch and move things(and drop things on students:))
AND:
Peter Pettigrews death was very publicized and he received an order of Merlin first class award so he was pretty famous so the twins had to have known who he was.
Sometimes I forget that there are some unsolved questions in Harry Potter because J.K.Rowling did a pretty good job of answering questions.
My theory about the marauders map (NOTE: this theory is for the books only!!! If it was based on the movies it wouldn't work!!!) = Fred and George Weasley didn't realise Peter Pettigrew in Ron's bed every night on the marauders map because they couldn't see him. The marauders, just in case their map got into the wrong hands, would've made it so that if the user of the map didn't know that the person was an animagus, when that person was in their animagus form, the user of the map would not be able to detect that person. This would make sense as the marauders wouldn't want a teacher to find the map and realise they were all animagi. Harry also didn't see Peter Pettigrew on the map when he was wandering round at night in the books - he instead saw Barry Crouch Jr (the movies changed it to make it more mysterious). To prove this theory, Snape (at the end of book 3) travelled to the shrieking shack. He knew, from the marauders map, that Sirius was there as Sirius was in his human form while at the shrieking shack. However, he had no idea Peter was also with them as he was in his animal form at the time and Snape didn't know he was an animagus. Also, in the fourth book, Rita Skeeter (when in her animal form) is never spotted by Harry. This is because he had no idea that she was an animagus at the time. Theory explained, class close and question answered. Mischief Managed. (NOTE2 = I just want to say that this is a theory I had which I found explained it all quite well - of course Fred and George might've just not looked at Ron or anything too! I just wanted to share this with everyone.)
Also, I forgot to say, I love both of you and your videos so freaking much!!!
Wow that makes sense now!
I feel like such a downer today, but that doesn't explain how Harry saw Peter Petegrew pass him on the map. My guess is Fred and George just didn't pay any attention to where Ron was on the map when they were using it as they'd have no reason to.
Boydgirl if talking strictly about the books Harry never dies see peter pettigrew - he sees barty crouch jr on the map when out of bed I haven't read the third book in a while but I've looked this up and this is what most people have been saying.
Cerys Jones the problem with that is Harry saw Pettigrew ( in animagus from ) on the map
I know that sometime in the books (I forgot when) someone told Harry that petty crimes didn’t require aurors.
(Just a theory.) I think with the Peter Pettigrew one, If they're in their Animagus form they can't be shown on the map because I think if the marauders created a map they wouldn't want to be shown on the map in their Animagus forms.
this is the explanation i could stand behimd, although... Lupin sees Petigrew on the map... so won't work
On the topic of Harry's eyes (and other wizards and witches who wear glasses), my personal theory is that the eyes are seen as the windows to the soul and if you try to change them with magic so the person can see 20/20, part of the person's soul could be damaged, altered, or even destroyed in bad situations. Since the eyes show such character of a person, part of their human nature or entire personality is so authentic and honest that to try to alter the 'windows' to that special place is dangerous and the person could lose all that they are.
Just my personal theory...thats all
laser surgery spell
Kristen Hatley Hasn't everyone established that Harry is dumb? Besides, nobody tells him anything. Even if Ron knew about Eye-Correcting Potions or whatever, he wouldn't tell Harry, because Ron would consider it irrelevant.
Adeline Teoh but Hermione might
My theory is that it's against the Laws of Transfiguration like food.
Kristen Hatley
(don't take this personal it's a joke) no body get eye surgery, the doctors altering your soul. never trust a eye doctor again.
I feel like the pensieve would be like writing down a memory. For example: you write down a memory soon after it happened, so you haven't forgotten any details yet. Later, when you start to forget details of your memory, you can go back, look at what you wrote, and be reminded of what happened. I don't think putting a memory in the pensieve would cause you to forget the memory; I think it's just a way to preserve important memories so you can always remember it perfectly. This could also explain Dumbledore's comment about having "too many thoughts and memories crammed into [his] mind". When something important happens, I'm sure he has a lot of thoughts and theories about it, and he probably DOES feel like there's too many thoughts in his head, and he doesn't want to forget any details in case they turned out to be important information later. Once he puts the memories in the pensieve, he probably feels a sense of relief because it doesn't matter if he forgets a few details because he has the memory preserved. I don't know if that made any sense, but that's just how I always thought it worked! :)
No problem! I'm happy to be able to (potentially) solve one of the great mysteries of Harry Potter XD Thank you so much for responding! I just had an internal freak out session because I didn't think you would actually see this! I love you and your videos!
BUT this doesn´t explain the fact that Snape takes out his memories of lily when he teach oclumancy (at leats tries xD) to harry to prevent him to read them in his mind :/
Oratnik88 Did it ever say that snape took out his memories and put them in a pensieve for the purpose of preventing Harry from reading his mind? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought he just used legilimency.
I dont remember if they say it exactly like that but I remember that snapes takes them out and put them in the pensieve at the beginning of the class and then he put them back. Thats why Harry sneaks in to the pensieve when Snape go out tho see what happen to Wharrington and he enter into the memorie of Jammes bullying Snape , so you can asume that he takes out his memories to prevent harry to read them. (In one ocassion harry actually use legilimency unintended and he watch a snape crying as a kid but thats was a just quick flash of a memory )
Oratnik88 oh, I just assumed snape already had the memories in the pensieve; not just to prevent Harry from seeing them. To me, it doesn't seem like Snape would put his memories in the penseive to keep Harry from seeing them because he wouldn't expect Harry to be good at occlumency, much less legilimency, so he probably wouldn't see a need to do that. And Snape knows that Harry is prone to sneak around the castle, so why would he give him easier access to his memories instead of just keeping them inside his head especially since Snape is an excellent legilimence? I guess there's no definite way to know the answer, but that's what I thought XD
5:30 I think Hermione would send Rose and Hugo muggle homework.
The thestral thing:
In book 7 in Godrics Hollow you hear Voldemorts version of killing Harry's parents. Harry didn't see his parents die
And he fainted before Quirell dies, yeah
Lyvvy what about Tom Riddle in book 2? Was it because the diary was a horcurux that he saw him get destroyed, but couldn’t see the festrals? Because it was only part of Voldemort’s soul?
@@mattea6534 exactly 😉
How did the Horcrux inside of Harry survive when he was bitten by the Basilisk in Chamber of Secrets?
DawsontheRavenclaw if i had to have a guess... harry had to physically die to release the bo d with the horcrux, much like all the objects had to be fully destroyed to "kill" the part of voldemort in them. so because the venom didnt kill harry straight away and he was able to be healed it didnt have the same effect
Tzartrex just as with the regular horcruxes, they have to be damaged beyond repair, by a very powerful weapon or spell.
That's a really good question, because the diadem was destoryed with a basilisk fang that still had venom on it. I believe ky.slime Yolo is correct in saying, however, that the pheonix tears (one of the most powerful and rare magical substances) "healed" Harry and therefore the horcrux was still "intact"
because Fawkes healed Harry's wound with pheonix tears which probably healed the part of voldemort inside him as well.
The horcrux was in his forehead hence the scar. The basilisk bit his arm and the poison didn't make it to his head?
Is there a painting of Umbridge in the headmaster's office?
Peeves dropped and banged things .How did he do that ? Was not he immaterial ???
Was he solid ( that sounds funny 😂)
Peeves is a poltergeist, which means he is not a dead wizard or witch, he is a spirit that causes mischief, in order to cause mischief, he needs to be able to touch things
There's actually a poltergeist where I'm living and he scares me every single night
Mostly because we made the house more Harry Potter we have mostly all the Harry Potter stuff (not all sadly)
Peeves wasn't a ghost he was sort of a manifestation of the angst and misbehavior of the teenagers in hogwarts
Your a great team Brizzy and Tessa. I always look forward to your videos
There's this thing called a rubber duck . What is the function of a rubber duck
Daisy006 SUP what EXACTLY is the function of a rubber duck
I had heard a theory that the veil was a remnant of when Death cut his cloak to give to the third brother, sort of leaving a rip between both worlds. The ministry was built above it to keep it hidden.
Death didn't cut his throat, he gave it to him
This is an intriguing theory!
oooo good one...
Isn't that Harry's Invisibility cloak
Also, could fred and George see Voldemort on Quirrel?
Well, let's say that was true, the map would say "Tom Riddle" and they wouldn't know who that was
Also atom Riddle didn’t have a body and his soul was so broken up it my not register.
How did draco draw harry on the broom getting struck by lightning, like is it like animation?
My question is wtf is a nargle
Puppycakes Me You obliviously don't know Luna Lovegood
Adeline Teoh ikr. Luna is amazing. My question is why Neville and Luna every happend
Because JK is bad at shipping. First she regrets Hinny, and then she gets sweet, sweet Neville with a bitch who dissed and bullshitted about Harry all Fourth Year. I'm not saying that I'm against her ships. Just that she could do better.
Naya Skye OMG same
Adeline Teoh IKR! I've shipped Nuna, then was sad when it didn't happen, then in deathly hallows, Neville says he's mad for Luna! What the heck?!?
I have a Time magazine where they interview JK Rowling and they asked her Where do wizard children go to school before Hogwarts? She responded with "Most are homeschooled, because they aren't really able to control their powers, so it would be dangerous to let them out and about."
I mean I guess that makes sense, but would their parents teach them? Or do they have tutors come to their house? What if both their parents work full time?
As a homeschooler, I can say that homeschooling is very different than what everyone thinks. Most things a child can do on their own.
“That’s a human as a rat as a goblet!” got me that was hilarious and I know I am 3 years late but I was always a fan of Harry Potter so yeah
Do another one of these this is so cute!
*_"Is Jesus a wizard??"_*
I swear I choked on my watermelon slice
Crafty K9 No because he dosent exist
Crafty K9 No because he dosent exist
Annette Becnel mate Jesus was an actual person but historians can't say if he was the son of god
Nicholas alvarado no he didnt exist, and if he did, he was a gigantic liar that made a bunch of people believe in black magic that isn't real
Nicholas alvarado no he didnt exist, and if he did, he was a gigantic liar that made a bunch of people believe in black magic that isn't real
I think the reason the twins never saw or mentioned peter in rons bed is because they never looked at the map closely enough to see. They mentioned they had it memorized it so they probably only checked places to see if there where teaches there.
When Harry saw his parents die, he was to young to process it, being a baby, which meant he couldn't see the thestrals straight away.
HarmonyGames He could see thestrals because he watched Cedric Diggory get killed by Voldemort in book 4
But he had his eyes closed in the book. He only saw the green light through his eyelids. I have wondered for a long time why was he able to see thestrals even though he didn't even see Cedric die.
@@matokaste I believe it was because he was able to come to grips with Cedric's death at the time.
Poltergeist's can solidify and unsolidify along with interact with real objects while ghosts just fall through stuff
I LOVE TESSA'S FACIAL EXPRESSIONS THROUGH THIS WHOLE VIDEO!!!!!
Katie Bee Omg I love your profile pic
Lol especially at 3:04
And yes. There are wizard police. It's mentioned in OOTP. They're called magical law enforcement patrol.
"Will it be the Aurors who catch them?"
"Oh no, This is too trivial for Aurors, it'll be the ordinary Magical Law Enforcement Patrol...(Page 133)"
And in regards to religion, there are religious wizards. There's a Jewish Ravenclaw in the series for sure, as Rowling has stated herself.
SnowDaisyDraws what’s ootp?
"There's a Jewish Ravenclaw in the series for sure..."
Yep.
Siobhan Hogdson order of the phoenix
i'm quite late but i wanna say something......one of most important reasons i fell in love with this series are you two........love u guys...i've watched this video more than 26 times at the very least.....no wonder you two are in ravenclaws......with brains like yours......:)
They didn't see Petigrew because the Maraurders made sure that if someone is animagi the map will not show their names if someone stoll the map since they wanted to keep their secret a secret. The muggle goverment doesn't know about the wizard world only the Minister and Priminister it is mentioned in the books. Wizards get Homeschooled by their parents they teach them how to read, write, and basic math. Harry didn't talk through the mirrow to make sure sirius was in the house because he hadn't opened the package he opened at the end of the year. Peves was a student at hogwarts and chise to come back to stay in school just like moaning myrtle. AND I HAVE A QUESTION OF MY OWN IN THE BOOKS IT ONLY MENTIONS WIZARD SCHOOLS IN THE UK WHAT HAPPENDS TO WITCHES AND WIZARDS IN NORTH AND SOUTH AMERICA AFRICA RUSSIA AND AUSTRALIA!!!!
There are multiple wizarding schools all over the world. JK Rowling talks about it on Pottermore. The US school is called Ilvermorny :-)
Animagi names are on the map. Harry, Fred, and George could all see McGonagall on the map she is a Animagus.
Lol Unicorn
Animagi in a transformed state
Harry saw pettigrew ON THE MAP IN RAT FORM
@@bmoon4589 That's only in the movie.
HARRY IS NOT A RAVENCLAW !
Seamus: Turn this water into rum !
Harry : Whats he doing to that water ?
OH I DONT KNOW
TRUE XD
Granger.Edits Also instead of catching a letter he should have picked one off the ground COME ON HARRY THINK.THINK!!!!!!!
THIS IS SO FUNNY I CANT
If you remember in Deathly Hallows the movie, there was the “cop” that was suspicious of them when they went to break into gringots. That I feel like is a standard everyday cop/guard. The Aurors handle serious wizarding crimes.
My thought of the marauder’s map, Pettigrew situation is -
If there are loads of people in the same place maybe their names are all stacked up on each other?
So when Ron is carrying scabbers with him all the time maybe pettigrews name was hidden by Ron’s?
I think that for muggle borns, one of the Professors at Hogwarts take them to diagon alley. I came up with this since McGonagall had to go to hermione’s house and explain the wizarding world to her muggle parents
I like to think their is a department in the ministry for that occasion
On Wizard Religion: The Fat Friar (Hufflepuff Ghost) was actually a Roman Priest, and was executed for witchcraft, also Dumbledore owned a copy of the Christian bible, and Ariana and Kendra Dumbledore's graves have scriptures and bible verses on them. Thats all lol.
Sul Sul Sims so if u were in the wizarding world, and u were doing things that muggles do, would u be killed for doing "muggle craft" lol? Like having a ball point pen lol
The Felix felises thing is genius
I love this and y'all should do this again😂
“Someone plz make some painting fanfiction”
Me: ON IT
Why didn’t Fred and George see Pettigrew on the Marauders map? *When Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot, and Prong made the map they could make it to where only the Marauders could see the other Marauders on the map so if a teacher or another student finds the map open they can’t use it against them.
WRONG ! Harry saw Pettigrew on the map in the movie, and Snipe saw Lupin on the map, in the books. Theory FAIL.
First imagine how big it is. Then imagine more than 1000 names on this map! When they use it they just look for people around the corner. Names will be on top of one another because of different floors in reality will be a big mess! I am not surprised Fred and George don`t spot him.
i heard that the reason they didn't see Pettigrew was simply because they wouldn't be looking for Ron at night assuming he would be sleeping and anyways they know who is in Gyffindor why would they be looking at their brothers dorm on the map
Shall Notbenamed idk honestly I had just heard it from someone
Harry wasn’t a maurader though so how could he see Petegrew
I'm that type of sub that creepily looks at Brizzy's subscriptions. Anyway, she appears to be a nerdfighter which is pretty cool imo.
Brizzy Voices This is so crazy. I, Ryan, am having trouble coming up a better reference rn. This is always so hard for people like Ryan. Sincerely,
Ryan
Aka not really Ryan
In the order of the Phoenix, Molly Weasley asked Alastor Moody to check if there was a boggart in the cupboard with his magical eye that can see through walls and everything. Moody saw the boggart but the boggart couldn't see him, so he couldn't transform into his biggest fear.
Conclusion : Alastor Moody is the only wizard to have ever seen the real form of a boggart but now that he's dead, no one will ever know :D
Hi!!!!!!!! Love the channel!
I think the reason Harry can't see thestrals is because (I'm pretty sure) although he saw he mother die, he couldn't comprehend death at the time. I'm not quite sure if killing someone counts as seeing death.
Also, I read somewhere that the Maurauder's map only shows those who you are concerned about, so Gred and Forge, whoops, Fred and George wouldn't have seen Petigrew, as they did not know he existed, and therefore, did not care about him.
Was anyone else creeped out by the fact that Harry pretty much stalked Ginny using the Maurauder's map when he was hunting for horcruxes? The book states that he would stare at her dot in the Gryffindor dormitory on the map.........
Last I checked, Moaning Myrtle was also a poltergeist, because she could affect the water in the bathroom.
Pop sockets for wands!!!! LOL! That would be great!
I think if wizards were Christian, they could have destroyed Voldemort with a Bible.............
All these ideas are great but killing counts as seeing death because Cedric Diggory was killed. Also its probably because Harry couldn't see through the green light and his viewing angle when Lily died
You go to Hogwarts at age 11 to make puberty more enjoyable
Padfoot 934 true I need hogwarts I'm 12
Sharpies aren't allowed in muggle school let alone Hogwarts
Mavis Queen I'm allowed to have Sharpies, but I know most schools don't allow them for some weird reason
Mavis Queen I think that there are some students that bring muggle stationary to Hogwarts, and they are just not mentioned. Or maybe it's because some students who do prefer pens over quills could bring them, but they kind of want to perfect their writing with a quill. Especially the muggleborns and muggle raised. They'd be super excited to use a quill and keep at it.
I think Hogwarts is supposed to represent British secondary schools - when you’re 11 you start secondary school in the UK
Cool video. One question about time turners is why didn't Dumbledore use the time turner to save Buckbeak but not Harry's parents? Surely...it would work the same?
I think that kids go to Hogwarts at the age of 11 because that’s when kids usually go to senior school in England
that’s when we go to middle school/ junior high in America
that’s when we go to high school on aussie
@@leviatina no we go into high school when we turning 12 or 13 depending on what age you started school
@@annelise8427 no we go to secondary school at 11
@@jameseastwood2702 aussies only have high school and primary school so that doesnt work
and also, the veil is older than the ministry of magic. the ministry was build around and on top of the veil, to protect/hide it.
[this comes directly from JK rowling]
Interesting.....
Bryan W but what is it exactly
Seth Cool death
Am I the only person that hates it when people say happy Christmas
*IT’S MERRY CHRISTMAS*
Happy Christmas Anya NB
I think it was supposed to be 25 and then Tessa added the whole puberty thing
'Why eleven, is it a puberty thing?'
Me: nope I'm pretty sure it's because that is when you start secondary school 😅
Plus somewhere in the later half of the book series it's stayed that 7 years old is the time by which magic will show itself, if present at all
Ellie X so if Neville showed his magic at 8, was it because he was slow at magic?
@@Azeriiall yep!
How to play: Last digit of your like is what you are
Which Harry Potter book/movie are you secretly in?
1 - Sorcerer's Stone
2 - The Chamber Of Secrets
3 - The Prisoner Of Azkabon
4 - Goblet of Fire
5 - The Order Of the Phoenix
6 - The Half Blood Prince
7 - Deathly Hallows Pt. 1
8 - Deathly Halloween Pt. 2
9 - The Cursed Child
0 - You're not in a book :(
Sabrina Dunseph awesome, I'm gonna die in prisoner of azkabon, kool.
DH pt. 1 …sweet
Sabrina Dunseph I'm from deathly hollows part 2
Sabrina Dunseph order of the Phoenix... I wish it was DH p2
order of the Phoenix
Peeve’s was born because all of the chaotic and crazy energy from all the pre-teens living in the castle.
I love you brizzy and tessa
How do muggle borns get wizard money for diagonal alley and hogsmeade
Lebron Fan 23 in chamber of secrets there’s a part where Arthur Weasley meets Hermione’s parents and Arthur comments on how they’re exchanging muggle money for wizard money at Gringotts. So we can assume muggles can exchange their money at Gringotts :) I wonder if there’s an exchange rate though lol
They exchange Muggle money for wizard money. It talks about it in the chamber of secrets. Arthur Weasley is watching Hermione's parents exchanging their money at Gringotts.
Camila De la torre that’s what I was gonna say!!
They can trade muggle money in for wizard money in some kind of atm at gringott's
Also, a small sum of gold arrivesmwith the person that gives them there lettter and explains about magic to them and there families
Ur hair grows so fast! 💞💞💞💞Love you so much
Brizzy Voices Lol😂 Flashback of 2015 (btw thanks for responding me,ur the only youtuber who did that😊)
Brizzy Voices your a witch then
I think one of the big reasons you're 11 when you get you're Hogwarts letter is because in the UK you start secondary school at age 11 :)
I think we need a update on this video. I love this video