i have to say your not entirely wrong, just revert the function. Serge Newter is right. man is khabar, and anta is mubtada. From where are we going to know that anta is the mubtada? If you reviewed the video you can clearly see if you want to know where is the mubtada is just answer it. Example: Who are you? the answer is : I'm a student. See the answer first. The mubtada is "I'm" and now word "I'm is referred to "you" which is mentioned in the question, and so the mubtada is you and the khabar is who. Little bit a logical answer why who is the khabar, well because we want to know the "news" of the person we ask. Khabar means news. the question, who are you. We want to know the news about you so the person that asked will answer by giving the news about himself. "I'm a student" edit: Hmm, I don't know probably our brother is forgot about it, from what I know is man anta, man is khabr and anta is mubtada .. Allahu A'lam. May Allah give us His hidayah.....
@@فيرزاغيريفلدي in this case , the sentence before this. ayna baitun mudarisi. here the question word was khabar. also another reason to be confused is because noun of this sentence and pronoun of the new sentencei refer - do we not consider pronoun as only a replacement of a noun. hence the question , any resources where to have this concept clear
very helpful thank u very much
The 1st sentence of the last example: Isn't man khabar and anta mubtada?
Serge Newter who is the mubtada(subject) and anta is the khabar
i have to say your not entirely wrong, just revert the function. Serge Newter is right. man is khabar, and anta is mubtada.
From where are we going to know that anta is the mubtada? If you reviewed the video you can clearly see if you want to know where is the mubtada is just answer it.
Example: Who are you? the answer is : I'm a student. See the answer first. The mubtada is "I'm" and now word "I'm is referred to "you" which is mentioned in the question, and so the mubtada is you and the khabar is who.
Little bit a logical answer why who is the khabar, well because we want to know the "news" of the person we ask. Khabar means news. the question, who are you. We want to know the news about you so the person that asked will answer by giving the news about himself. "I'm a student"
edit: Hmm, I don't know probably our brother is forgot about it, from what I know is man anta, man is khabr and anta is mubtada ..
Allahu A'lam. May Allah give us His hidayah.....
@@فيرزاغيريفلدي in this case , the sentence before this. ayna baitun mudarisi. here the question word was khabar. also another reason to be confused is because noun of this sentence and pronoun of the new sentencei refer - do we not consider pronoun as only a replacement of a noun. hence the question , any resources where to have this concept clear