I love this aria, and whoever says that he is not the baritone Verdi would have loved to have on the stage, has no ears. He is magnificent, I have heard Macbeth many times and never like this. I there is baritone that fills our eyes of tears, is Dima.
Just look at him. My God he owns that stage. There never will be another. Humble, priceless his stage presence and the sound that comes out of his mouth is not of this world. He takes my breath away. And oh yes, he ain’t bad to look at. So sad you left us so young. Born on my father’s birthday and sadly passed away on my sister’s birthday. I can never get enough.
Tu inolvidable voz, pareciera que se agranda cuando interpretas a Verdi, tu autor preferido!! Cada dia cantas mejor, extraordinario Dmitry!!! Nunca te olvidaremos!!!Arg.Buenos Aires.
Bravo Dimitri la tua, Interpretazione è sublime ti sei calato interiormente in questa,"Romanza" non facile e ricordo che al teatro di Roma eravamo tutti senza, fiato. Prediligo profondamente questa Romanza, che parla, di Pietà Rispetto Amore. Grazie al nostro G. VERDI ed a tutti gli Artisti passati presenti e futuri che vorranno rendere onore alla nostra, Madre Patria che possiede un patrimonio di valore indefinibile ed indistruttibile di musica operistica,🙏💗💛🎵
Mi puoi dare altri dettagli della sua presenza a Roma e in che occasione? Ho solo visto le prove in video del Ballo in maschera al parco della musica con Pappano.Sto cercando testimonianze della sua presenza in Italia e della quasi indifferenza per la sua morte.Ieri sul Mattino di Napoli è uscita una mia lettera al direttore in cui mettevo in rilievo la scorrettezza sia della direzione del teatro,sia della Netrebko che conil marito ed altri si esibivano ne Il TROVATORE in forma di concerto di non aver neppure fatto riferimento al suo nome, pur avendo lui fatto RIGOLETTO nel 2013 in questo famoso tempio della lirica, né tantomeno la Netrebko che ha lavorato con lui in spettacoli immensi tipo Mosca Piazza Rossa centomila spettatori, Met di NY nel Trovatore e tanti altri.Una grave mancata occasione per onorare la memoria di questo grande artista
tiepidi applausi giapponesi mentre meritava ovazione scrosciante Lo rimpiangerete perché non vi sarà più dato di ascoltarlo dal vivo Bravissimo e compianto Dimitri Cerchiamo sempre le sue registrazioni che ci danno tanto godimento RIP caro Dima
Gli applausi saranno sembrati tiepidi forse perché è nella loro natura la riservatezza che noi forse confondiamo con mancato gradimento.Vedi la loro compostezza anche in momenti drammatici come negli ultimi tempi covid
Que talento! que presença! que voz! DH o inesquecível. Essa ária é uma explosão de sentimentos. Obrigada Dima, por tudo que Deus lhe deu e você soube nos presentear com todos seu dons.
Well, I care a damn about what others say about voices they hear and try to judge. I LOVE this one from DH and I can enjoy it every day again and again! ;-) Thanks frufruJ for your uploadings, they gave me already many lovely minutes.
I can't find a better example of all of Hvorostovsky's talents than here. Especially the legato and placement of every note. I hope i can sing like this one day, maybe i will since my voice teacher says my voice is developing like a young Dmitri Hvorostovsky :)
@countceprano I heard him in ROH, heard him perfectly. If your only concern is loudness, he was louder than Alagna. His voice is beautiful AND good for Verdi. "Quite good as Onegin" qualifies for the understatement of the year.
If I can hear a voice over the Orchestra without amplification, and the singer has warmth in their tone(ie not forcing a brightness to make their voice cut), and they can sing with a nice sense of line, then they have every right to be singing the rep. I have heard him live singing Verdi and DM has met all of these requirements. All of this silly bickering about whether or not he is a "Verdi baritone" is ridiculous. What is that anyway? Sounds like the ramblings of frustrate singers.
que dire...les mots n'existent pas pour lui ! TOUT les fées lui avaient donné TOUT et tous les talents de cet art qu'il parageait avec tant d'empahie de par le monde entier bienheureux le Ciel qu'il enhantera pour l'éternité....p ❤️🎶❤️
I've never figured out the people who say Dmitri can't sing or isn't a Verdi baritone, whatever that means.. After years of lessons, go out and see if you can develop the long smooth lines and drama and just beautiful voice (and what's wrong with a beautiful voice). In some later recordings, he gets a little sloppy and too cute, for my way of thinking (but maybe that's for concert versions) But this is awfully damned good singing (and accurate).
@countceprano So relieved to bring it to a more civilized level. Back in the begining, you said you couldn't hear him, I said that I heard him fine. His colour is very interesting, very dark, to me sounds well in Verdi. Especially in this concert you can't argue about the volume. I say the volume is fine. I'm not the only person who says so. I've read bloggers (who are not paid) surprised by DH's voice's volume in contrast to what they had heard. Milnes is not my fav, I dunno why.. am I idiot?
@countceprano What? All your argument is that ROH is not the Met? I don't care about your Met! I didn't say that I like Alagna, who, by the way, was a pleasant surprise as Manrico (just in case you wanna know). Yet again, you say that the only reason I'm wrong is that I believe that DH is a Verdian singer - "And that says it all." Is that all you have to support your argument?
@countceprano Who says that the Met is above other houses? On what grounds do you decide that? And who ever said that Verdi operas need huge voices? I'm hearing him in Europe, he sounds fine, will listen to him. You don't have to, but if you write that he's not a Verdi baritone, I'm going to argue, because I think it's just not true.
Why don't you look at it from the opposite side? They all learn Italian *so well* that the only problem is the occasional confusion of a double/single letter. Really, how many languages do you know that perfectly? ;-)
I am italian and his mastering of our language is astonishing as well as in our songs in ancient neapolitan in PASSIONE DI NAPOLI that leaves me openmouthed even if as a neapolitan I am used listening to Caruso,Gigli, Del Monaco and so on.
@countceprano LOL!!! Brightman and Bocelli... That was a very good one! I hear you, but you have to admit that DH at least have a gorgeous voice to what he is suited for? He is certainly not a "fake" operasinger like the aforementioned.
At all of the opera houses in which I have worked, from all of the talented and succesful colleagues with whom I have worked, never have I heard these sorts of silly ramblings. What does that say about all of you? Leave the casting and singing to the professionals. Just listen to what you like and stop trying to pretend you know anything.
@countceprano In other words, people who don't share your opinion. I don't think Hampson is a Veridan, which doesn't give me the right to call names those who think he is. Your other point on why DH is not a Verdian, besides that YOU don't think so...?
@countceprano People like me, who don't agree with you, i.e.idiots. The person who doesn't see beauty in art, sees just perfect technique/high notes/volume - that is an idiot for me. Are you one? I dare not say. I'm not like you.
@countceprano That's what I call an argument... I suppose all you know about opera you read in reviews... but how do you know it's the "right" reviews and not those who praise Domingo's Rigoletto?
@countceprano So you heard him once, I heard him twice. In bigger roles. I say he's Verdian. You say he's not. What makes you think you're right, and not me?
@countceprano Considering that it's four in the morning here, I'm not sober, and I'm writing in a foreign language, you don't seem to have particularly won this one... But I'm happy for your ego. It apparently needed some stimulus.
@countceprano Met is bigger than European houses... Met is bigger than the houses Verdi composed for. I don't get your argument, and am once again insulted by your comparison. Do you think I know nothing about opera? What makes you think that you are right and I am wrong?
@countceprano Oh, really? "we, who understand voice, think like me. Those who think otherwise, know nothing." Very good. What about all those rave reviews of his Boccanegra?
@countceprano I see we've resorted to insulting each other. Fine. I don't know what you mean by "a couple of hours of reviews", but I assume that a person who dares to call DH a Verdi baritone cannot win your respect. I hope you keep this attitude throughout your life, so that nothing and no one can shake your stone-firm beliefs. Where would Humanity be if not for people like you? We should burn people with other opinions! No matter how they gained them! Their ears are not reliable! Just ours!!!
@countceprano Of course, both official and unofficial reviews. But you know better than anyone, we should be happy that you visited our puny channel and told us that YOU couldn't hear DH at the MET. If not for you, we would be listening to Bocelli, and you opened up our horizons. Because we don't have ears and minds, we know nothing about opera, music or art! Thank God you enlightened us with your unshakable Truth.
I don't know about the other poster, but I saw Hvorostovsky various times at the Met and had no trouble hearing him. I thought he was an excellent singer, and he was very popular with the public at the Met.
@countceprano Credo sia interessante la discussione tra@countceprano@frufruj@salomes7veils,ma ahimè non capisco l'inglese.Sono stati citati dei baritoni,non so se in positivo o negativo,vorrei proporre per un attimo di mettere da parte nomi celebri come Bruson-Cappuccilli-Nucci-Alvarez-McNeill--Zancanaro-Milnes-Bastianini-Merril-Tibbet-London ecc.,e proporre l'ascolto,nella stessa aria,del bar. veneziano Antonio Salvadori,certo meno famoso,non appartenendo allo star system,e sentire un parere.
@Salomes7VeilsCredo sia interessante la discussione tra@countceprano@frufruj@salomes7veils,ma ahimè non capisco l'inglese.Sono stati citati alcuni baritoni,non so se in positivo o negativo,vorrei proporre per un attimo di mettere da parte nomi celebri come Bruson-Cappuccilli-Nucci-Alvarez-McNeill--Zancanaro-Milnes-Bastianini-Merril-Tibbet-London ecc.e proporre l'ascolto,nella stessa aria,del bar. veneziano Antonio Salvadori,certo meno famoso,non appartenendo allo star system,e sentire un parere
@countceprano I simply prefer others in Verdi. I like fuller voices in Verdi. Not my cup of tea. I think DH is much more of a Verdi singer than Hampson. But then, there are many people who like Hampson in Verdi roles. Are they idiots, or do they see something I don't? Is there no point at all in Hampson singing Verdi? Does the fact that I don't see it give me the right to condemn?
@countceprano Because I have ears, I heard him fine here, I think he was great, I do think that he is a Verdian singer. I have no reason to believe otherwise. If you do (apparently based on one night), please do overcome the sacred urge to shred wisdom on us common UA-camrs who are so painfully unaware of the smallness of DH's voice. If you think that I'm wrong because I have a different opinion (your last sentence), I rest my case.
@countceprano My point was that I am not the only one who thinks that way. Unfortunately, you label anyone with a different opinion an idiot. Good for you. I should label you an idiot for uttering the names of DH and Bocelli in the same sentence. All you've said is that you couldn't hear DH at the Met, which makes him not a Verdi baritone. I said that I heard him in Europe and he sounded fine to me. Is there any particular reason why you call me an idiot?
@countceprano Whoa, whoa, whoa, comparing Hvorostovsky to Bocelli??? Are you just trolling me? :-) The singers you say sang with him on that night have pretty big voices, as far as I know, and DH with his beautiful medium-sized voice might have come out as the one with the smallest. The mistake might be on the part of the casting, the size of the orchestra, or just a bad night, but I'm telling you that he was a wonderful Di Luna in ROH and Rigoletto in Vienna.
Breathtaking voice, best baritone ever and most attractive human being on this earth. Irreplaceable!! What a MAN!!!
I prefer my singers to SING TO ME and not SHOUT VAND BVARK AT ME! But yes a nice man, and tragically lost tons too young.
I love this aria, and whoever says that he is not the baritone Verdi would have loved to have on the stage, has no ears. He is magnificent, I have heard Macbeth many times and never like this. I there is baritone that fills our eyes of tears, is Dima.
Besser kann niemand diese Arie singen. Dieser Künstler war einmalig, ein Jahrhundertsänger!! Lilo
Beautiful!
Dear, dear Maestro, dear Dima!
He is The Best forever!
Just look at him. My God he owns that stage. There never will be another. Humble, priceless his stage presence and the sound that comes out of his mouth is not of this world. He takes my breath away. And oh yes, he ain’t bad to look at. So sad you left us so young. Born on my father’s birthday and sadly passed away on my sister’s birthday. I can never get enough.
Auf diese Arie, so gefühlvoll und
ausdrucksvoll gesungen, müsste
Jubel ausbrechen...absolut
phantastisch.
i'm surprised the orchestra can even see their music. but this is awesome. he is all that is man
I could listen to and watch him all day!!!
How much this voice is missed!
Bellissima interpretazione e bellissima voce. Stupendo!!!!!
Tu inolvidable voz, pareciera que se agranda cuando interpretas a Verdi, tu autor preferido!! Cada dia cantas mejor, extraordinario Dmitry!!! Nunca te olvidaremos!!!Arg.Buenos Aires.
I love, love, love, love his voice, his acting, his whole dimenier!!! Everything about him!!! Hope he is singing in heaven!!!
A REALY OPERA DINGER....
ALEX FROM PORTUGAL. 🇵🇹
Thanks BIG DIMITRI.
We dont forget you in your great existence.
Regards.
DIMA und diese Arie...PERFEKT !
Bravo Dimitri la tua, Interpretazione è sublime ti sei calato interiormente in questa,"Romanza" non facile e ricordo che al teatro di Roma eravamo tutti senza, fiato. Prediligo profondamente questa Romanza, che parla, di Pietà Rispetto Amore. Grazie al nostro G. VERDI ed a tutti gli Artisti passati presenti e futuri che vorranno rendere onore alla nostra, Madre Patria che possiede un patrimonio di valore indefinibile ed indistruttibile di musica operistica,🙏💗💛🎵
Mi puoi dare altri dettagli della sua presenza a Roma e in che occasione? Ho solo visto le prove in video del Ballo in maschera al parco della musica con Pappano.Sto cercando testimonianze della sua presenza in Italia e della quasi indifferenza per la sua morte.Ieri sul Mattino di Napoli è uscita una mia lettera al direttore in cui mettevo in rilievo la scorrettezza sia della direzione del teatro,sia della Netrebko che conil marito ed altri si esibivano ne Il TROVATORE in forma di concerto di non aver neppure fatto riferimento al suo nome, pur avendo lui fatto RIGOLETTO nel 2013 in questo famoso tempio della lirica, né tantomeno la Netrebko che ha lavorato con lui in spettacoli immensi tipo Mosca Piazza Rossa centomila spettatori, Met di NY nel Trovatore e tanti altri.Una grave mancata occasione per onorare la memoria di questo grande artista
Scusa,forse non ho detto che mi riferisco al teatro San Carlo di Napoli.Faccio pasticci a volte con questo aggeggio
che voce meravigliosa!
As he said in an interview ( first I learn to feel and than to sing ) .thank you eternal DIMA.unigue interpretation
Дима проживал все, о чем поет, все пропускал через себя. Это редкий дар.И это требовало огромных сил.
Bravissimo
toccante! emozionante! stupendo! brillante e bellissimo baritono,! meraviglia nel mondo!
tiepidi applausi giapponesi mentre meritava ovazione scrosciante Lo rimpiangerete perché non vi sarà più dato di ascoltarlo dal vivo
Bravissimo e compianto Dimitri Cerchiamo sempre le sue registrazioni che ci danno tanto godimento RIP caro Dima
Gli applausi saranno sembrati tiepidi forse perché è nella loro natura la riservatezza che noi forse confondiamo con mancato gradimento.Vedi la loro compostezza anche in momenti drammatici come negli ultimi tempi covid
Incomparable como siempre. Recuerdo eterno al gran Dimitry H.❤️🇦🇷
Отчество?
great performance. and the orchestra and the conductor are great too.
sublime nell'Opera! magnifico nela musica classica! bellissima la sua presenza! immortale nel ricordo!
Adoro la sua musicalità...una sensibilità rara...
Incredible! I never love this aria, bu he amazes me. What a sadness! What a richness of coulour is the second "sol la bestamia!"
Que talento! que presença! que voz! DH o inesquecível.
Essa ária é uma explosão de sentimentos. Obrigada Dima, por tudo que Deus lhe deu e você soube nos presentear com todos seu dons.
Well, I care a damn about what others say about voices they hear and try to judge. I LOVE this one from DH and I can enjoy it every day again and again! ;-)
Thanks frufruJ for your uploadings, they gave me already many lovely minutes.
Great Dima forever, forever!
Que extraordinaria interpretacion, es un aria bellisima. Bravo!!!
Che meraviglia, perché ci hai lasciato,RIP Dima , la tua musica però non morirà mai.
I can't find a better example of all of Hvorostovsky's talents than here. Especially the legato and placement of every note.
I hope i can sing like this one day, maybe i will since my voice teacher says my voice is developing like a young Dmitri Hvorostovsky :)
This is so enjoyable with the beautifu staging. I love the aria.
A. C. S. Thank you, Dima.
grande !!!!
Grata por postar. Maior amor por Dmitri fantástico.
Bless him in heaven .in parts of his singing he reminds me of ettore Bastianini.
Beautiful!
Оставайтесь таким же благородным и прекрасным! Спасибо за Ваш бесценный музыкальный Дар! С Вами надежно и тепло.
Awesome.
Superb
Absolutely beautiful xxx
Bravo! Ci ha lasciato troppo presto.
Gran cantante que fue.
great !!
Bravo!!!
May he rest in peace...
Cet Aria me va au fond du cœur c´est pour cela que j´aime tant Macbeth la musique est tellement belle du début à la fin ...❤❤
EXTRAORDINARIO EN ESTA BELLA ARIA
grazzie, maria
He is totally delishes in everything he does!!!
Bravo 🎼🌷🌷🌷🌷🎼
bravissimo'
Великий, великий артист
Magical 🌹👏👏
Astăzi se comemorează patru ani, de la dispariția prematură, a baritonului Dimitri Hvorostovski.
Dumnezeu să-l odihnească în pace.
🎼🎶👑🙏😢🌷♥👏🌅
Que aplausos mixuruca .
O cara foi perfeito.
Braaaaavooo
Toujours avec sa tonalité parfaite je ne trouve pas d' égale a 😊 lui même ❤meme
@countceprano I heard him in ROH, heard him perfectly. If your only concern is loudness, he was louder than Alagna. His voice is beautiful AND good for Verdi. "Quite good as Onegin" qualifies for the understatement of the year.
Hvorostovsky está en condiciones de cantar todo Verdi. Qué bueno sería escucharlo en Macbeth!
Mi spiace non abbia cantato Macbeth in teatro. Sarebbe stato meraviglioso.
DIMA your voice is full of colours like Rainbow
Rainbow was the name of the band he was in when he was young.
Каким же ОН был совершенным, неземным и недосягаемым. Это - КОСМОС, ВСЕЛЕННАЯ.
If I can hear a voice over the Orchestra without amplification, and the singer has warmth in their tone(ie not forcing a brightness to make their voice cut), and they can sing with a nice sense of line, then they have every right to be singing the rep. I have heard him live singing Verdi and DM has met all of these requirements. All of this silly bickering about whether or not he is a "Verdi baritone" is ridiculous. What is that anyway? Sounds like the ramblings of frustrate singers.
Good
EN ESTA ARIA SE DESEAN UNOS VALORES que hacen honesta la vida, bajo la meditación y plegaria para dar sentido a la vida.
@ElSalvador50 if you develop into a new hvorostovsky, i hope i could listen to your singing one day:-)
que dire...les mots n'existent pas pour lui ! TOUT les fées lui avaient donné TOUT et tous les talents de cet art qu'il parageait avec tant d'empahie de par le monde entier bienheureux le Ciel qu'il enhantera pour l'éternité....p
❤️🎶❤️
I've never figured out the people who say Dmitri can't sing or isn't a Verdi baritone, whatever that means.. After years of lessons, go out and see if you can develop the long smooth lines and drama and just beautiful voice (and what's wrong with a beautiful voice). In some later recordings, he gets a little sloppy and too cute, for my way of thinking (but maybe that's for concert versions) But this is awfully damned good singing (and accurate).
BobWScott .
BobWScott Indeed he is. Arnold Bourbon Amaral 🌹🌿🌏🌎🌍👱👴
Riposa in pace grande dima ai piedi del padre celestial 🙏👑❤️
@countceprano So relieved to bring it to a more civilized level. Back in the begining, you said you couldn't hear him, I said that I heard him fine. His colour is very interesting, very dark, to me sounds well in Verdi. Especially in this concert you can't argue about the volume. I say the volume is fine. I'm not the only person who says so. I've read bloggers (who are not paid) surprised by DH's voice's volume in contrast to what they had heard. Milnes is not my fav, I dunno why.. am I idiot?
👏😔💔💖💝❤🥰
@countceprano What? All your argument is that ROH is not the Met? I don't care about your Met! I didn't say that I like Alagna, who, by the way, was a pleasant surprise as Manrico (just in case you wanna know). Yet again, you say that the only reason I'm wrong is that I believe that DH is a Verdian singer - "And that says it all." Is that all you have to support your argument?
@countceprano Who says that the Met is above other houses? On what grounds do you decide that? And who ever said that Verdi operas need huge voices? I'm hearing him in Europe, he sounds fine, will listen to him. You don't have to, but if you write that he's not a Verdi baritone, I'm going to argue, because I think it's just not true.
Cette voix puissante est restée dans noscoeurs
РОССИЯ - СТРАНА ГЕНИЕВ !!!
Браво !!!
Hear him nowadays in Verdi roles. At least nowadays he IS easy sounding.
Why don't you look at it from the opposite side? They all learn Italian *so well* that the only problem is the occasional confusion of a double/single letter. Really, how many languages do you know that perfectly? ;-)
I am italian and his mastering of our language is astonishing as well as in our songs in ancient neapolitan in PASSIONE DI NAPOLI that leaves me openmouthed even if as a neapolitan I am used listening to Caruso,Gigli, Del Monaco and so on.
@countceprano I have no clue, because I think he's Verdian, which is an opinion you apparently don't share.
@countceprano LOL!!! Brightman and Bocelli... That was a very good one! I hear you, but you have to admit that DH at least have a gorgeous voice to what he is suited for? He is certainly not a "fake" operasinger like the aforementioned.
At all of the opera houses in which I have worked, from all of the talented and succesful colleagues with whom I have worked, never have I heard these sorts of silly ramblings. What does that say about all of you? Leave the casting and singing to the professionals. Just listen to what you like and stop trying to pretend you know anything.
exactly !!!!
@countceprano In other words, people who don't share your opinion. I don't think Hampson is a Veridan, which doesn't give me the right to call names those who think he is. Your other point on why DH is not a Verdian, besides that YOU don't think so...?
@countceprano People like me, who don't agree with you, i.e.idiots. The person who doesn't see beauty in art, sees just perfect technique/high notes/volume - that is an idiot for me. Are you one? I dare not say. I'm not like you.
@countceprano That's what I call an argument... I suppose all you know about opera you read in reviews... but how do you know it's the "right" reviews and not those who praise Domingo's Rigoletto?
@countceprano So you heard him once, I heard him twice. In bigger roles. I say he's Verdian. You say he's not. What makes you think you're right, and not me?
@countceprano Considering that it's four in the morning here, I'm not sober, and I'm writing in a foreign language, you don't seem to have particularly won this one... But I'm happy for your ego. It apparently needed some stimulus.
@countceprano Met is bigger than European houses... Met is bigger than the houses Verdi composed for. I don't get your argument, and am once again insulted by your comparison. Do you think I know nothing about opera? What makes you think that you are right and I am wrong?
@countceprano Oh, really? "we, who understand voice, think like me. Those who think otherwise, know nothing." Very good. What about all those rave reviews of his Boccanegra?
@countceprano Yes. You feel superior based on reasons unknown to me :-)
@countceprano I see we've resorted to insulting each other. Fine. I don't know what you mean by "a couple of hours of reviews", but I assume that a person who dares to call DH a Verdi baritone cannot win your respect. I hope you keep this attitude throughout your life, so that nothing and no one can shake your stone-firm beliefs. Where would Humanity be if not for people like you? We should burn people with other opinions! No matter how they gained them! Their ears are not reliable! Just ours!!!
@countceprano Of course, both official and unofficial reviews. But you know better than anyone, we should be happy that you visited our puny channel and told us that YOU couldn't hear DH at the MET. If not for you, we would be listening to Bocelli, and you opened up our horizons. Because we don't have ears and minds, we know nothing about opera, music or art! Thank God you enlightened us with your unshakable Truth.
frufruJ [[
I don't know about the other poster, but I saw Hvorostovsky various times at the Met and had no trouble hearing him. I thought he was an excellent singer, and he was very popular with the public at the Met.
@frufruJ Renato Bruson... He's good! ;)
@countceprano Credo sia interessante la discussione tra@countceprano@frufruj@salomes7veils,ma ahimè non capisco l'inglese.Sono stati citati dei baritoni,non so se in positivo o negativo,vorrei proporre per un attimo di mettere da parte nomi celebri come Bruson-Cappuccilli-Nucci-Alvarez-McNeill--Zancanaro-Milnes-Bastianini-Merril-Tibbet-London ecc.,e proporre l'ascolto,nella stessa aria,del bar. veneziano Antonio Salvadori,certo meno famoso,non appartenendo allo star system,e sentire un parere.
@Salomes7VeilsCredo sia interessante la discussione tra@countceprano@frufruj@salomes7veils,ma ahimè non capisco l'inglese.Sono stati citati alcuni baritoni,non so se in positivo o negativo,vorrei proporre per un attimo di mettere da parte nomi celebri come Bruson-Cappuccilli-Nucci-Alvarez-McNeill--Zancanaro-Milnes-Bastianini-Merril-Tibbet-London ecc.e proporre l'ascolto,nella stessa aria,del bar. veneziano Antonio Salvadori,certo meno famoso,non appartenendo allo star system,e sentire un parere
Ω!!!!!!Θεε!!!
@countceprano I simply prefer others in Verdi. I like fuller voices in Verdi. Not my cup of tea. I think DH is much more of a Verdi singer than Hampson. But then, there are many people who like Hampson in Verdi roles. Are they idiots, or do they see something I don't? Is there no point at all in Hampson singing Verdi? Does the fact that I don't see it give me the right to condemn?
@countceprano Because I have ears, I heard him fine here, I think he was great, I do think that he is a Verdian singer. I have no reason to believe otherwise. If you do (apparently based on one night), please do overcome the sacred urge to shred wisdom on us common UA-camrs who are so painfully unaware of the smallness of DH's voice. If you think that I'm wrong because I have a different opinion (your last sentence), I rest my case.
@countceprano My point was that I am not the only one who thinks that way. Unfortunately, you label anyone with a different opinion an idiot. Good for you. I should label you an idiot for uttering the names of DH and Bocelli in the same sentence.
All you've said is that you couldn't hear DH at the Met, which makes him not a Verdi baritone. I said that I heard him in Europe and he sounded fine to me. Is there any particular reason why you call me an idiot?
Das war ein Bariton mit der Arie aus Macbeth,wie kann man Domingo als "Bariton" großartig finden!!! Früher als Tenor,grandios.....!!!!
다시 살려내 주세요
@countceprano Whoa, whoa, whoa, comparing Hvorostovsky to Bocelli??? Are you just trolling me? :-)
The singers you say sang with him on that night have pretty big voices, as far as I know, and DH with his beautiful medium-sized voice might have come out as the one with the smallest. The mistake might be on the part of the casting, the size of the orchestra, or just a bad night, but I'm telling you that he was a wonderful Di Luna in ROH and Rigoletto in Vienna.