The following speakers talk about the issue of music in Islam Assim Hakeem Abu Musab Khalid Yasin Mohammed Salah Mufti Menk Nouman Ali Khan Tariq Jameel Yasir Qadhi
My question is about islamic music. Like Maher Zain or Sami Yusuf. They sing about Allah and the love of islam. I listen to Quran daily and I hear islamic lessons daily al7amdulellah and islamic music is all I listen to when I listen to music.
MashAllah a beautiful collection , of logical lectures , by variable honourable speakers . Only because WE WANT something to be allowed ( eg music, riba , drinking, extra marital relations etc.) does not make it permissible , therefore we must try hard not to justifying the wrongs . May we be saved from the fitnah of "Ulma e su" and may our lives and hearts be guided to the righteous path. amen
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only).
@@adnanamin3068 The (or music) in your statement is wrong. And you know it. Nobody defies duff. We defy music made by musical instruments! Not by duff! May Allah Guide you and me. Ameen
After i searched on this subject.i found different opinions from scholars...my conclusion is if we dont say music is haram at least it is not right to listen to it, because our Iman will be affected negatively if we do so...i heard Dr Farid Al Ansari talking about it and i liked what he sais....
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only).
@@adnanamin3068 duff is separate though. Most scholarly opinions I have seen say singing and duff (but duff only for women I think) is permitted, with some (but not all) limiting duff to only specific circumstances like you said but isn’t believed to extend to other musical instruments
It's weird, I listen to music, but it doesn't make me avoid prayers and recitations of the quran. I mean, can it be haram because it contains dirty content and that it will push ur connection with Allah away? For example, I listen to lofi musics, it's just beats, but there's no dirty contents in it. I listen to music only when i'm playing video games, going outside for a run or workout, doing my homework, but I still use as much of my time as i can to listen to recitation and also read the quran. Now if ur going to explain something, please, I'd would love to read the comments but without hatred for i am here trying to understand more about this topic and yet im still young trying to profit the remaining of my time in this world to do the right thing like all of u. May Allah guide us all.
Yh im in a similar position to you. I grew up thinking music is haram. I used to think music was all violence,women etc. However , whilst majority of pop music is, i realised a lot isnt and so i listen to lots of underground hip hop. And i was wondering why this would be haram as it doesnt distract me from allah. Sometimes even uplifts my soul. The hadith that says people will try make it halal is only reason i still think it might be or is haram
And im confused as the hadith talks about musical instruments but theres hadiths allowing duff. So im confused as to why the duff is allowed and why a piano or guitar for example isnt. Not saying anyones right or wrong i just want to learn and be best muslim possible inshallah
@@t-4579 But for some reason, i feel this message/hadith is for those who easily get distracted from prayers and go do harmful or bad things, hell, even forget about Allah. But i hope Allah can help me to slowly stop listening to music. But alhamdulilah, i have a strong will and would never forget about my prayers or any obligations for I fear of forgetting. It's like, if i forget one of the obligations, Allah strikes me a warning that makes me tremble of fear, and try to make up for what I have done. It's weird, but it actually happens to me for some reason.
@@tr1cksh0tsn1per3 same. Inshallah allah helps us all become better muslims. As far as music, ive undersrood instruments are said to be haram but the duff isnt. So im wondering why would a guitar not be halal but duff is. And also the lyrics. Plus lots of people say music distracts from god. This can be case as while im listening to music im not thinking of god every second. But thats the same when im watching stuff, or outside or eating. Although if music is constantly preachi ng negative stuff i can see the point
@@t-4579Same here, also I keep seeing this being mentionned, that a insturment called "oud" was being played by muslims long time ago, i like playing with the guitar and it's my main instrument, i play it to keep my cool, BUT it is obviously not replacing the quran, as also quran does the same. I guess it is haram if yyour intentions towards it is bad in which itleads u to haram things, Like im pretty sure if u listen to 6ix9ine, 21 savage, eminem, etc, now that's a BIG load of haram right there 😂 but like, lofi, something that helps me when doing my homework since i can't listen to quran when doing my homework, because quran is something u listen, learn and try to interpret.
1:17 I can confirm this. There are times I don't want to read quran and it's always when I like listening to music. but when I remember that I need guidance and I turn back to Alllah swt and listen to Quran the last thing I want to do is to listen to any kind of music. and I was obsessed with music for many many years.
Al Hamdulilah-thanks for the upload-we can ask these questions all day-but do we really understand what makes our spiritual hearts healthy and what makes them sick. The guidance of the Quran and the example of Prophet Muhammad came to bring us knowledge and guidance on this. This is the purpose of the last revelation to help us be more in tune with our natural disposition(fitrah). When we are more in tune with ourselves, we will be in more better position to determine what can harm us.
But what about the girls singing and the prophet told Abu bakr to leave them. What about the woman who promised to sing for the prophet and he ddnt object?.what about those people who where celebrating and Aisha came out and watched with the prophet until she was satisfied? I know today's music is evil but if singing is so bad why did the prophet not object to those girls?
I believe music is Halala. Hadiths has a lot of contradictions, it's understandable if one decided to throw it away while deciding something. Now if we talk about Quran, it never talked about music. Basic rule is Halal until proven Haram. Well, everywhere I go there will always be someone that says haram 24/7. I just decided that I'll just decide it myself. I feel grateful to be able to listen to music. Yet there will probably be people that will say I am corrupted or something. So if you ask me, if what you want to do was never declared Haram in the Quran, and it doesn't feel wrong to you, deep down it doesnt affect you in a bad way, then go for it. Just ask for forgiveness at the end of the day for things you might have overlooked.
Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our DEEN?
Walaikum Assalam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu Note : This is my opinion, and I'm not a scholar (not even a student of knowledge). I'm just a Muslim brother trying to help you. Answer: To be honest, This depends on you. Our Prophet strictly forbidded wasting time. So it actually depends on you. If you want Jannah, Strive for it. If you want Jahannam, Strive for it.
Ya akhi, if you are spending you whole day without sinning and praying all farz prayers and whatever you are doing for example eating, sleeping doing as per sunnat, then inshAllah you are giving 24 hours a day to the deen, even if you are sleeping, you are inshAllah getting reward for it 😊. These days some stupid tiktokers says 'may toh laytay laytay millions kama raha hu', I say tu laytay laytay inshAllah akhirat bhi kama sakta hay.
While I agree with the general message of not wasting time, it’s important to remember doing normal (permissible) things can also be acts of obedience to Allah if the intention is right e.g., visiting people to maintain the rights of one’s neighbour and keeping true good friends, working to earn money to provide for one’s family and spend in charity, trying to show mercy so you can be shown mercy on the Day of Judgement, keeping to what is halal etc. Though time spent on the deen specifically e.g., dhikr, salah, learning are separately important, don’t underestimate what you can do with your normal daily acts
I was not faithful to the religion i was raised in. nor full heartedly a believer in a god, Yet Music Made me Belive. Nothing so powerfull could come from a mortal human
Same here! The heart touching music of Maher Zain brought me out of ignorance and darkness to see Allah's love! I believe in it's beautiful power, as long as the lyrics are wholesome and clean and the rhythm is not so loud or abusive.
Salam. I have never been so confused in my life. Scholars say that music is Haram and my Ustaz said it’s Haram if it distracts you from the deen. What should I follow?
If you are able to enjoy music then its a problem. If you are truly into the dheen and if u have a high level of eeman then your heart wouldnt even want to listen to music.
i have always been confused about nasheeds having music but the content is totally islamic , it never distracted me but always made me to remember ALLAH, is nasheed also prohibited ???
anza khan I see that you are into kdrama and mabye kpop too. But I am here for some advice and you know to talk. Have you ever found it difficult to stop listening to it? Cuz I have and I wanna stop but it’s soooo hard
salam yasmin !!! i never stopped listening to musical nasheeds cz m not sure about its abandonment ,cz its content is totally pure and i listen nasheeds of awakening record ,what i think, listening songs are abandoned because u start singing unconsiously and unintentionaly that stuff which is not supposed to sing ,but when we listen nasheed and whenever we sing it unconsciously then we sing totally those pure lyrics so this is the reason i am in dilemma
dont be in a dilemma , if it increases the rememberance of Allah s w t and our beloved Nabi e Kareem then it is good . We must learn to differentiate between good and bad and not lump everything together. We must apply logic.
Music is not of haram, todays bad lyrics should be avoided, so know theres nothing wrong with music, listen to all there explanation, not a word from Allah,
Allah commands to be polite and not to plant an evil seed through words, so to follow Allahs commands, I will give brother villa my opinion on this, where does music take you? other to an imaginary place that might even be bad for you. I would challenge him to listen to a beautiful recitation of the qoran, bible or tora, and understand the words, and then compare that to the music. May Allah guide us all.
Sophia Nicole Mikkelsen shut up and dont lie on Allah .. there is no one verse in the Quran says music is haram ... whats is haram is the girls naked andd danced .. a song that have good meanings like songs for the god or prophet is not haram .. u r just a blind maybe Allah to the right bath
I can respectfully disagree with this. We are not gonna sit here and call Beethoven Chopin Rachmaninoff as vulgar and haram, that would be the definition of “ignorance” and Allah disapproves ignorance. If you’re talking about hip hop specifically, in which many of the topics are about guns violence sex and drugs, absolutely. But do not drag composers such as Bach, Erik Satie, and many other legends into the category of “haram”. Do not drag Hussain al Jassmi, Abdulmajeed Abdullah, Maher Zain, Wael Kfoury and Fairouz into the same category. That is a complete disrespect. As a musician, and a pianist myself, I learn the notes, practice, and perform. But the music is not made from me. It all comes from the love of Allah. Allah didn’t grant me the talent of becoming a pianist and all of a sudden demands me to believe this nonsense of “music is Haram”, never has, and never will. You can bring Hadith OR other weak resources but Allah never claimed music as Haram. It all depends on HOW a person uses music, HOW a person composes music and writes the lyrics. It’s about what people do with it. Music itself has no fault of its own. Jummah Mubarek.
You can convince yourself whatever you wish, but your opinion is irrelevant in the light of the Quran and Sunnah. Ignorance is thinking you know more than people who have studied Islam.
please read the book The Music Made Me Do It by Dr. Gohar Mushtaq Biological effects of music on body and brain, Music in light of Quran, hadeeth, sunnah, Islamic scholars, music, drugs and rock'n'roll, classical vs pop music, music and teenage rebellion, music and suicide among youth, Music in Islamic history, Islamic ruling on listening to music, music and endorphins
how listening to Bethoween can make me forget Allah? In this case we can not eat delicious meals also. Because when you get sattisfied from this meal you can forget Allah. I dont agree
Been clean of music for 7 years. Even if I hear it I am not listening I get instances when someone is blasting it in their car and then I feel the corruption entering my heart need to plug my ears cant shut it off.
It varies upon the type of music, for example if you're listening to rap or pop music then it can lead you astray but if its like a country's anthem (i.e Iraq's anthem Land Of The Two Rivers) then it doesnt pose a problem
@@mwaj that's correct, we follow Quran and Sunnah, but do you know, there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only). Infact there is another hadeeth from Sahih ibn Hibban, according to it even other musical instruments are permitted, but I am not very sure about the authenticity of that hadeeth, that's why I personally prefer that it's better to avoid the musical instruments.
It depends upon the type of music for instance if it's like rap or pop it can lead you astray yet also if it's some music of humanity as I call it like Bob Marley or Matisyahu and zusha it makes me feel more connected to god and want to worship more
It depends for you. Some other people will say the lyrics of some rap songs have brought me closer to the religion. These are nothing but tricks people play on themselves. Plus it's about closing all possible doors to evil. For example, why do I have to follow the traffic signals at 2am in the night if the roads are completely empty? It's coz of the possible consequence, not for the current scene. Most imp, we follow the Quran according to the understanding of the companions. We have the Hadith which speaks about musical instruments.
In this yasir qadhi doesn’t believe in music but in another video yasir heading says string and wind instruments are haram but drum music is halal ....?
Praise be to Allah. This hadeeth was narrated by at-Tirmidhi (2442), Ahmad (1630) and Ibn Hibbaan (722) from al-Hasan ibn ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: I memorized from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him): “Leave that which makes you doubt for that which does not make you doubt, for truth leads to reassurance and lies lead to uncertainty.” Classed as saheeh by Shaykh al-Albaani (may Allah have mercy on him). It was also narrated by an-Nasaa’i (5614) without the additional words “for truth leads to reassurance…”
Scholar Polution , Music is Haraam , you will have to answer on the day of judgement , you seem to be better that the Holy prophet himself , stop saying lies to Islam . May Allah gives you hidayat.
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to weddings/eid occasions (by girls only).
Have anyone ever thought that people are starting to judge music exactly like how non-muslims judge Islam? Not looking at the full picture, just the bad side of it.
@@mwaj The 4 Imam are no prophets and there is no verse in the Quran forbids it. There are tons of Hadith which shows the prophet use and love listening to Music , he likes listening to al-ghud . This is what happen when the sheiks smoes shisha
Saleem Roumaldaro please use etiquette, and do not use fabrications against the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. Listen to the Hadith of Sahih Muslim where he ﷺ said there will come a time when people will consider musical instruments Halal. Read what his companions ibn Abbas & ibn Masood said about the Ayah in Surah Luqman. They are the Masters in Tafsir of Quran.
@@mwaj Sorry Bro, Imam Muslim is no prophet , you have not show me a single verse where Allah forbids it , second , for you information , there are no verses as well where Allah says Muslim and Bukhari are second of the Quran , it was Certain Imam Ahmad 7th Century who said that Muslim and Bukhari are most sahih after the Quran, any way , 30 % of hadith in Bukhari and muslim are fabircated according to great scholars . All those 30% are manufactured by Banu Umayya to protect their reign , I think you check yourself first before showing me etiquette , Our Imam these days is everything i Haraam and except what they tell you are Halal .
Jaja walaikum assalam. Music is Haram. No matter whatever you play it with. As for non music nasheeds, dont overdo it. Dont give it precedence over Quran. And By Allah, Quran is more soothing than anything on earth. But as the hadith says, Music and Quran never stay in the same heart.
@@fazalaziz3632 nasheed is music, whether with instruments or not... Quran is recited with musical notes everywhere in the world... u probably don't recite the quran as reading a novel
Where in the Quran does it say this? In the Quran not the hadith. I love the Quran , and most of these statements are bias opinions. I will debate face 2 face with anyone one of you humans over this matter.
There are many prohibitions that are not mentioned in the Quran. We've received the Quran the same way as Hadith, from the same chain of people who have passed it down. Loving the Quran and following it are two different things. Where in the Quran does it mention about Dajjal, the return of Isa. We follow the Quran the way it was understood by the Prophet's companions. If you want to allow yourself to have your own understanding, then you shouldn't have an issue with the extremist terrorist groups who act in according to their own interpretations. It's wrong.
matter of fact the Quran was written a couple years after (p.b.u.h) prophet Mohammed death. In the Quran it states (the book) was revealed not the books. Allah alone is to be worshipped and believe in his messenger,however he never spoke the hadith in the quran.
'We' received it from Jibreel?? Really. When did he come to you? It was directly revealed to one man ﷺ. Why do you trust the Mushaf you have now if it was written after his death, which is not true anyway. It was complied after his death, but written in bits of separate collections during his life. You'll say Allah Said He will Preserve it. Why didn't He Reveal a Book, and then we would be sure it's from the Heavens. He Chose the same men who have compiled it, and passed it down to us, those who passed down His habib ﷺ's narrations and are buried next to him. The same men who Allah Said He is pleased with.
hocam muziq haram amenn her sey gunah internet telewijin allah cclahudan uzaq olan herse haaram muziq bazi insana teseli bende biliyorum haram we hellal ne herqes biliyor irade meselesi
This type of speech only make me more anxious...it seems like Allah is a very angry being who only loves to punish us if you don't listen to Him...and the Life is all about test and trials.
Dear Rakshanda Allah Loves to Forgive & Show Mercy. We are His Creation so He Makes the rules, just like you follow the rules of the country you live in :) Yes It is a life of tests and trials, for an eternal life in the Hereafter :)
{ مَّا يَفۡعَلُ ٱللَّهُ بِعَذَابِكُمۡ إِن شَكَرۡتُمۡ وَءَامَنتُمۡۚ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ شَاكِرًا عَلِيمٗا } [Soera An-Nisāʾ: 147] Sahih International: What would Allah do with your punishment if you are grateful and believe? And ever is Allah Appreciative and Knowing.
I think I can relate. I used to listen to music constantly, even when I wasn’t listening, it was playing in my head, or I was tapping it out, or singing along. I even used to play music. For me it was my comfort, one of the few things that understood me. Quitting alone wasn’t enough-I’d just be left with a craving and emptiness that begged to be filled. I cleared out the music from my phone, and when I wanted to listen, instead I would listen to recitation of the Quran, especially by Al Afasy. It wasn’t the same, but I kept with it. I started getting curious about the meaning, so I followed the recitation in English on quran.com. Gradually it did something to me. I feel like the Quran can touch my heart now in ways music never could. And I have God to understand me and offer me love and hope that is beyond human power to offer. Music still comes to mind from time to time, but I don’t miss it. It doesn’t stay stuck in my head. My friends think I’m missing out, but I feel like now I’ve found what I was looking for all along. May Allah grant both of us patience, guidance, and success.
Look into the issue of dissociation and numbing feelings. Music, binge eating, masturbation, alcohol, drugs etc when they become an addiction usually have some unpleasant emotions as the real cause as to why one turns to these things. If possible, finding something halal (like a certain sport, new friend, new hobby etc) that brings you joy can help with gaining dopamine kicks in a halal way so it becomes easier to give up your current addiction. Also processing and dealing with your unpleasant emotions and traumas if you think you have any is very beneficial. Point is, some form of change is needed to make a sustainable abandonment of the haram addiction because the reason we have it is because if fills some sort of hole within us.
Any religion that believes listening to Mozart, Rachmaninoff and Brahms is sinful is so bizarre as to be laughable. If it specified music with degrading and sexual lyrics, it might be worth taking seriously. But ALL music? Simply a joke.
The joke is how clinged to music, whatever kind, we become that we attack anything against. Classic or not it distracts your heart in merryment or sorrow from reality and shortness of this life.
My God created the heaven and the earth. He created ALL of the world's beauty: great rivers, majestic mountains, and yes - glorious music. I detest Beyonce and Drake. But Rachmaninoff moves me beyond description. When I listen to his symphonies and other compositions, I hear God's hand at work. My God also geve humans the devine spark that allows them to create beautiful things and the intellect with which to create them. You want to hear the voice of God? Listen to Bruckner's 4th Symphony. Or the finale of Mahler's 1st. Listen to Chopin's Nocturns - such beauty created by nothing more than a piano and the person playing it.....and by Chopin himself, of course. I am sure the Quran contains many beautiful expressions, as does the Holy Bible. But if any of those expressions tell me that all music is evil, I know the book is anything but devinely inspired.
Vettel2011 the question is, what did Jesus really teach...to worship him? He even didn't like being praised,he clearly taught us who to worship, pray to, beg for guidance, we pray to the God, Jesus prayed to, the God he without don't showed us we needed as he too needed. Jesus was no ordinary man, born to no father, a miracle from birth....but was he a God. If we look closely with an open mind and heart, we would clearly see Jesus, a very special man, worship and pray and ask for God's guidance in everything he did, heal the sick, raise the dead, turn water into wine, all these miracles and he still said, he cannot do anything by his own will and power but by that of his father, God. Who is our father all, as he said we all are his children, is he a special child, yes, a God? No....you see we say God can do anything ,but God cannot do everything, God cannot lie. And sin, and do things humans do.Jesus clearly served God and taught us all how to do it....what came after, worshipping him, the cross, Jesus never taught any of that....
Listen to the Hadith Mufti Menk stated. Listen to the Tafseer of Surah Luqman. Listen to the verdicts of the Four Imams. Listen to the statement of the Sahabi that Yasir Qadhi mentioned.
There is no Quranic evidence for prohibition of music as it an intergral part of the human makeup as decreed by Allah s w t . Its how you utilise music and lyrics so it is based on application, niyyah and content. It is no different from writing a book or using a knife or a word uttered
Look up hadith by Imam Ja’far As-Sadiq (a.s), where he said that music originated from shaitaan and Kabil. If its from the shaitaan, it cannot be good. You wont be destroyed if you exclude music from your life.
My question is about islamic music. Like Maher Zain or Sami Yusuf. They sing about Allah and the love of islam. I listen to Quran daily and I hear islamic lessons daily al7amdulellah and islamic music is all I listen to when I listen to music.
May Allah protect us from evil and help us become the most righteous person entering jannat ul Firdous Aameen
MashAllah a beautiful collection , of logical lectures , by variable honourable speakers . Only because WE WANT something to be allowed ( eg music, riba , drinking, extra marital relations etc.) does not make it permissible , therefore we must try hard not to justifying the wrongs . May we be saved from the fitnah of "Ulma e su" and may our lives and hearts be guided to the righteous path. amen
maryam mirza but but oh lease
Ameen
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only).
@@farooqmohammedsajawal4844 do you mean loan? If its through Islamic banking, then I personally feel it's ok, but Allah knows the best.
@@adnanamin3068 The (or music) in your statement is wrong. And you know it. Nobody defies duff. We defy music made by musical instruments! Not by duff! May Allah Guide you and me. Ameen
After i searched on this subject.i found different opinions from scholars...my conclusion is if we dont say music is haram at least it is not right to listen to it, because our Iman will be affected negatively if we do so...i heard Dr Farid Al Ansari talking about it and i liked what he sais....
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only).
@@adnanamin3068 duff is separate though. Most scholarly opinions I have seen say singing and duff (but duff only for women I think) is permitted, with some (but not all) limiting duff to only specific circumstances like you said but isn’t believed to extend to other musical instruments
MashAlllah I love the Qur'an
Nothing about the Quran here, it's what people said,
@@affarokurz1486 People said based on what? Yes, Quran 😊
@@adnanamin3068 theres nothing based on the Quran here
@@affarokurz1486 oho, I mean in their opinion in their mind they are taking in the light of Quran and Sunnah, which they might be correct, might not..
Jazakallah. May Allah reward you for conveying truth.
It's weird, I listen to music, but it doesn't make me avoid prayers and recitations of the quran. I mean, can it be haram because it contains dirty content and that it will push ur connection with Allah away? For example, I listen to lofi musics, it's just beats, but there's no dirty contents in it. I listen to music only when i'm playing video games, going outside for a run or workout, doing my homework, but I still use as much of my time as i can to listen to recitation and also read the quran. Now if ur going to explain something, please, I'd would love to read the comments but without hatred for i am here trying to understand more about this topic and yet im still young trying to profit the remaining of my time in this world to do the right thing like all of u. May Allah guide us all.
Yh im in a similar position to you. I grew up thinking music is haram. I used to think music was all violence,women etc. However , whilst majority of pop music is, i realised a lot isnt and so i listen to lots of underground hip hop. And i was wondering why this would be haram as it doesnt distract me from allah. Sometimes even uplifts my soul. The hadith that says people will try make it halal is only reason i still think it might be or is haram
And im confused as the hadith talks about musical instruments but theres hadiths allowing duff. So im confused as to why the duff is allowed and why a piano or guitar for example isnt. Not saying anyones right or wrong i just want to learn and be best muslim possible inshallah
@@t-4579 But for some reason, i feel this message/hadith is for those who easily get distracted from prayers and go do harmful or bad things, hell, even forget about Allah. But i hope Allah can help me to slowly stop listening to music. But alhamdulilah, i have a strong will and would never forget about my prayers or any obligations for I fear of forgetting. It's like, if i forget one of the obligations, Allah strikes me a warning that makes me tremble of fear, and try to make up for what I have done. It's weird, but it actually happens to me for some reason.
@@tr1cksh0tsn1per3 same. Inshallah allah helps us all become better muslims. As far as music, ive undersrood instruments are said to be haram but the duff isnt. So im wondering why would a guitar not be halal but duff is. And also the lyrics. Plus lots of people say music distracts from god. This can be case as while im listening to music im not thinking of god every second. But thats the same when im watching stuff, or outside or eating. Although if music is constantly preachi ng negative stuff i can see the point
@@t-4579Same here, also I keep seeing this being mentionned, that a insturment called "oud" was being played by muslims long time ago, i like playing with the guitar and it's my main instrument, i play it to keep my cool, BUT it is obviously not replacing the quran, as also quran does the same. I guess it is haram if yyour intentions towards it is bad in which itleads u to haram things, Like im pretty sure if u listen to 6ix9ine, 21 savage, eminem, etc, now that's a BIG load of haram right there 😂 but like, lofi, something that helps me when doing my homework since i can't listen to quran when doing my homework, because quran is something u listen, learn and try to interpret.
1:17 I can confirm this. There are times I don't want to read quran and it's always when I like listening to music. but when I remember that I need guidance and I turn back to Alllah swt and listen to Quran the last thing I want to do is to listen to any kind of music. and I was obsessed with music for many many years.
Agreed
Tune yourself to the rhythm of Quran.
Al Hamdulilah-thanks for the upload-we can ask these questions all day-but do we really understand what makes our spiritual hearts healthy and what makes them sick. The guidance of the Quran and the example of Prophet Muhammad came to bring us knowledge and guidance on this. This is the purpose of the last revelation to help us be more in tune with our natural disposition(fitrah). When we are more in tune with ourselves, we will be in more better position to determine what can harm us.
But what about the girls singing and the prophet told Abu bakr to leave them.
What about the woman who promised to sing for the prophet and he ddnt object?.what about those people who where celebrating and Aisha came out and watched with the prophet until she was satisfied?
I know today's music is evil but if singing is so bad why did the prophet not object to those girls?
I believe music is Halala. Hadiths has a lot of contradictions, it's understandable if one decided to throw it away while deciding something. Now if we talk about Quran, it never talked about music. Basic rule is Halal until proven Haram. Well, everywhere I go there will always be someone that says haram 24/7. I just decided that I'll just decide it myself. I feel grateful to be able to listen to music. Yet there will probably be people that will say I am corrupted or something.
So if you ask me, if what you want to do was never declared Haram in the Quran, and it doesn't feel wrong to you, deep down it doesnt affect you in a bad way, then go for it. Just ask for forgiveness at the end of the day for things you might have overlooked.
Asalaamualaikum. We are living at a time where time is ticking fast. Music can lead to addiction. With that being said, it can then be very time consuming. And then you got sports broadcasted on television which is another time consumer. And then you got soaps, movies, media, gaming platforms, paying a visit to your friends, time spent at work, etc. My question is, how much time do we have remaining for our DEEN?
Walaikum Assalam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu
Note :
This is my opinion, and I'm not a scholar (not even a student of knowledge). I'm just a Muslim brother trying to help you.
Answer:
To be honest, This depends on you.
Our Prophet strictly forbidded wasting time. So it actually depends on you.
If you want Jannah, Strive for it.
If you want Jahannam, Strive for it.
This guys pastes the same comment on all religious videos.
Ya akhi, if you are spending you whole day without sinning and praying all farz prayers and whatever you are doing for example eating, sleeping doing as per sunnat, then inshAllah you are giving 24 hours a day to the deen, even if you are sleeping, you are inshAllah getting reward for it 😊. These days some stupid tiktokers says 'may toh laytay laytay millions kama raha hu', I say tu laytay laytay inshAllah akhirat bhi kama sakta hay.
While I agree with the general message of not wasting time, it’s important to remember doing normal (permissible) things can also be acts of obedience to Allah if the intention is right e.g., visiting people to maintain the rights of one’s neighbour and keeping true good friends, working to earn money to provide for one’s family and spend in charity, trying to show mercy so you can be shown mercy on the Day of Judgement, keeping to what is halal etc. Though time spent on the deen specifically e.g., dhikr, salah, learning are separately important, don’t underestimate what you can do with your normal daily acts
I was not faithful to the religion i was raised in. nor full heartedly a believer in a god, Yet Music Made me Belive. Nothing so powerfull could come from a mortal human
Same here! The heart touching music of Maher Zain brought me out of ignorance and darkness to see Allah's love! I believe in it's beautiful power, as long as the lyrics are wholesome and clean and the rhythm is not so loud or abusive.
*For some strange reason, Muslims regard listening to Chopin and Tchaikovsky will make one a wretch*
Im sorry but i love quran and music but they are not in a same class in my loving for them quran more
You cant love both 9uran is much better i stoped music hamdoallah
"One Heart Cannot Love Music And Qur'an At The Same Time"
Salam. I have never been so confused in my life. Scholars say that music is Haram and my Ustaz said it’s Haram if it distracts you from the deen. What should I follow?
If you are able to enjoy music then its a problem.
If you are truly into the dheen and if u have a high level of eeman then your heart wouldnt even want to listen to music.
@@MalaysianAviator737-8 try to avoid them
Nabeeh Mohamed THATS what i do. Thank you
@@MalaysianAviator737-8 😊
i have always been confused about nasheeds having music but the content is totally islamic , it never distracted me but always made me to remember ALLAH, is nasheed also prohibited ???
anza khan I see that you are into kdrama and mabye kpop too. But I am here for some advice and you know to talk. Have you ever found it difficult to stop listening to it? Cuz I have and I wanna stop but it’s soooo hard
salam yasmin !!! i never stopped listening to musical nasheeds cz m not sure about its abandonment ,cz its content is totally pure and i listen nasheeds of awakening record ,what i think, listening songs are abandoned because u start singing unconsiously and unintentionaly that stuff which is not supposed to sing ,but when we listen nasheed and whenever we sing it unconsciously then we sing totally those pure lyrics so this is the reason i am in dilemma
dont be in a dilemma , if it increases the rememberance of Allah s w t and our beloved Nabi e Kareem then it is good . We must learn to differentiate between good and bad and not lump everything together. We must apply logic.
Music is not of haram, todays bad lyrics should be avoided, so know theres nothing wrong with music, listen to all there explanation, not a word from Allah,
Affaro kurz musical instruments are prohibited. TOTALLY. It does not matter the contents, it is said in a sahih nasheed.
I know that people will say old fashioned: but it is haram,
kishmish64 define khamar?
Tommaso Villa and the same to you
Allah commands to be polite and not to plant an evil seed through words, so to follow Allahs commands, I will give brother villa my opinion on this, where does music take you? other to an imaginary place that might even be bad for you.
I would challenge him to listen to a beautiful recitation of the qoran, bible or tora, and understand the words, and then compare that to the music. May Allah guide us all.
Very funny
Sophia Nicole Mikkelsen shut up and dont lie on Allah .. there is no one verse in the Quran says music is haram ... whats is haram is the girls naked andd danced .. a song that have good meanings like songs for the god or prophet is not haram .. u r just a blind maybe Allah to the right bath
im not a practicing Muslim but i have observed what the second speaker said
Well at least start praying brother. may Allah Grant you and us all the strength to conquer our demons.
Salam wa alaykoum, 5 year later. Is there a changement in your relationship with Allah? 🙂
I can respectfully disagree with this. We are not gonna sit here and call Beethoven Chopin Rachmaninoff as vulgar and haram, that would be the definition of “ignorance” and Allah disapproves ignorance. If you’re talking about hip hop specifically, in which many of the topics are about guns violence sex and drugs, absolutely. But do not drag composers such as Bach, Erik Satie, and many other legends into the category of “haram”. Do not drag Hussain al Jassmi, Abdulmajeed Abdullah, Maher Zain, Wael Kfoury and Fairouz into the same category. That is a complete disrespect. As a musician, and a pianist myself, I learn the notes, practice, and perform. But the music is not made from me. It all comes from the love of Allah. Allah didn’t grant me the talent of becoming a pianist and all of a sudden demands me to believe this nonsense of “music is Haram”, never has, and never will. You can bring Hadith OR other weak resources but Allah never claimed music as Haram.
It all depends on HOW a person uses music, HOW a person composes music and writes the lyrics. It’s about what people do with it. Music itself has no fault of its own. Jummah Mubarek.
Man, people be picking Hadiths like its a card game.
You can convince yourself whatever you wish, but your opinion is irrelevant in the light of the Quran and Sunnah. Ignorance is thinking you know more than people who have studied Islam.
@@IADT415 I know music more than the people who have studied Islam.
@@KaisarAnvar May Allah guide you, Ameen
He Guided me well enough to state the fact here but people don't listen.@@IADT415
very nice collection of opinions. But I would put subtitles for the urdu
please read the book
The Music Made Me Do It by Dr. Gohar Mushtaq
Biological effects of music on body and brain, Music in light of Quran, hadeeth, sunnah, Islamic scholars, music, drugs and rock'n'roll, classical vs pop music, music and teenage rebellion, music and suicide among youth, Music in Islamic history, Islamic ruling on listening to music, music and endorphins
how listening to Bethoween can make me forget Allah? In this case we can not eat delicious meals also. Because when you get sattisfied from this meal you can forget Allah. I dont agree
You don’t get to agree. The Sahih Hadith disprove you. This religion is for those who believe in the Quran and Hadith.
Yooo chilll listen to him carefully
yeah well u better listen to rap then without music lol that would probably bring u closer to Allah... I dont agree as well
Mashallah. Could I share this on my channel?
Been clean of music for 7 years. Even if I hear it I am not listening I get instances when someone is blasting it in their car and then I feel the corruption entering my heart need to plug my ears cant shut it off.
لا اله الا الله محمد رسول الله صل الله عليه وسلم
It varies upon the type of music, for example if you're listening to rap or pop music then it can lead you astray but if its like a country's anthem (i.e Iraq's anthem Land Of The Two Rivers) then it doesnt pose a problem
We follow evidences from Quran & Sunnah & understanding of the companions and scholars who follow that methodology, not what we think or what we want
@@mwaj that's correct, we follow Quran and Sunnah, but do you know, there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to wedding/eid occasions (by girls only). Infact there is another hadeeth from Sahih ibn Hibban, according to it even other musical instruments are permitted, but I am not very sure about the authenticity of that hadeeth, that's why I personally prefer that it's better to avoid the musical instruments.
@@hakant43 what question brother
@@adnanamin3068 Brother can you give the reference to that hadith?
@@adnanamin3068 can you give that hadith
It depends upon the type of music for instance if it's like rap or pop it can lead you astray yet also if it's some music of humanity as I call it like Bob Marley or Matisyahu and zusha it makes me feel more connected to god and want to worship more
It depends for you. Some other people will say the lyrics of some rap songs have brought me closer to the religion. These are nothing but tricks people play on themselves. Plus it's about closing all possible doors to evil. For example, why do I have to follow the traffic signals at 2am in the night if the roads are completely empty? It's coz of the possible consequence, not for the current scene. Most imp, we follow the Quran according to the understanding of the companions. We have the Hadith which speaks about musical instruments.
What about the hadeeths in favour of music in Bukhari during weddings, why these scholars are not mentioning that.
In this yasir qadhi doesn’t believe in music but in another video yasir heading says string and wind instruments are haram but drum music is halal ....?
KripticEyeGaming he said daf.
Duff is the only instrument allowed as it was used when Tala Al Badru Alayna when the Prophet came.
Praise be to Allah.
This hadeeth was narrated by at-Tirmidhi (2442), Ahmad (1630) and Ibn Hibbaan (722) from al-Hasan ibn ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) who said: I memorized from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him): “Leave that which makes you doubt for that which does not make you doubt, for truth leads to reassurance and lies lead to uncertainty.” Classed as saheeh by Shaykh al-Albaani (may Allah have mercy on him).
It was also narrated by an-Nasaa’i (5614) without the additional words “for truth leads to reassurance…”
Jazak Allah khairan.
Scholar Polution , Music is Haraam , you will have to answer on the day of judgement , you seem to be better that the Holy prophet himself , stop saying lies to Islam . May Allah gives you hidayat.
Alhamdulillah
Jajakallah khair brother... this helped me
May Allah SWT guide and bless us all
By the way there are some authentic hadeeths in favour of music. Infact as per one hadeeth it is said that the difference between halal wedding and haram wedding is duff (or music). And non of these scholars in the video can deny what I mentioned. Yes regarding musical instruments, I personally feel that it's better to avoid it, and even duff should be limited to weddings/eid occasions (by girls only).
Have anyone ever thought that people are starting to judge music exactly like how non-muslims judge Islam? Not looking at the full picture, just the bad side of it.
can i listen to nasheeds with a bit of music in the back tho?
I miss the old Yassir Qadhi
👍👍👍
br you have done very well but i think you should join the video of dr naik,he has the most follower...may Allah bless us all
What about classical or jazz?
Sheik , stop the non-sense where you say Music is Haraam .
Saleem Roumaldaro
Seems the Hadith of the Prophet ﷺ, and the opinions of the Sahaba, and the 4 Imams don't matter to you. SalamAlaikum
@@mwaj The 4 Imam are no prophets and there is no verse in the Quran forbids it. There are tons of Hadith which shows the prophet use and love listening to Music , he likes listening to al-ghud . This is what happen when the sheiks smoes shisha
Saleem Roumaldaro please use etiquette, and do not use fabrications against the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. Listen to the Hadith of Sahih Muslim where he ﷺ said there will come a time when people will consider musical instruments Halal. Read what his companions ibn Abbas & ibn Masood said about the Ayah in Surah Luqman. They are the Masters in Tafsir of Quran.
@@mwaj Sorry Bro, Imam Muslim is no prophet , you have not show me a single verse where Allah forbids it , second , for you information , there are no verses as well where Allah says Muslim and Bukhari are second of the Quran , it was Certain Imam Ahmad 7th Century who said that Muslim and Bukhari are most sahih after the Quran, any way , 30 % of hadith in Bukhari and muslim are fabircated according to great scholars . All those 30% are manufactured by Banu Umayya to protect their reign , I think you check yourself first before showing me etiquette , Our Imam these days is everything i Haraam and except what they tell you are Halal .
Very true!
Asalam alaykum, my brothers and sisters. Does anyone respectfully know, are nasheeds' haram ?
Jaja walaikum assalam. Music is Haram. No matter whatever you play it with. As for non music nasheeds, dont overdo it. Dont give it precedence over Quran. And By Allah, Quran is more soothing than anything on earth. But as the hadith says, Music and Quran never stay in the same heart.
@@fazalaziz3632 nasheed is music, whether with instruments or not... Quran is recited with musical notes everywhere in the world... u probably don't recite the quran as reading a novel
@@fazalaziz3632 which hadeeth was that?
Where in the Quran does it say this?
In the Quran not the hadith. I love the Quran , and most of these statements are bias opinions. I will debate face 2 face with anyone one of you humans over this matter.
There are many prohibitions that are not mentioned in the Quran. We've received the Quran the same way as Hadith, from the same chain of people who have passed it down. Loving the Quran and following it are two different things. Where in the Quran does it mention about Dajjal, the return of Isa. We follow the Quran the way it was understood by the Prophet's companions. If you want to allow yourself to have your own understanding, then you shouldn't have an issue with the extremist terrorist groups who act in according to their own interpretations. It's wrong.
@@mwaj No he received the Quran from Gabriel, the hadith came from men's interpretations.
matter of fact the Quran was written a couple years after (p.b.u.h) prophet Mohammed death. In the Quran it states (the book) was revealed not the books. Allah alone is to be worshipped and believe in his messenger,however he never spoke the hadith in the quran.
@@mwaj also so I pray to ALLAH for understanding. You made a mistake already by assuming ,that , I just follow my own.
'We' received it from Jibreel?? Really. When did he come to you? It was directly revealed to one man ﷺ. Why do you trust the Mushaf you have now if it was written after his death, which is not true anyway. It was complied after his death, but written in bits of separate collections during his life. You'll say Allah Said He will Preserve it. Why didn't He Reveal a Book, and then we would be sure it's from the Heavens. He Chose the same men who have compiled it, and passed it down to us, those who passed down His habib ﷺ's narrations and are buried next to him. The same men who Allah Said He is pleased with.
hocam muziq haram amenn her sey gunah internet telewijin allah cclahudan uzaq olan herse haaram muziq bazi insana teseli bende biliyorum haram we hellal ne herqes biliyor irade meselesi
Ayşe Kaya ayşe kardeşim haklısnız ama mesele çok hassas dir
This type of speech only make me more anxious...it seems like Allah is a very angry being who only loves to punish us if you don't listen to Him...and the Life is all about test and trials.
Dear Rakshanda
Allah Loves to Forgive & Show Mercy. We are His Creation so He Makes the rules, just like you follow the rules of the country you live in :)
Yes It is a life of tests and trials, for an eternal life in the Hereafter :)
Astaghfirullah
Think before you speak like that
Allah’s Mercy overpowers His Wrath
astaghfirullah would u prefer to enjoy the dunya temporarily and suffer for eternity in the akhira???????
{ مَّا يَفۡعَلُ ٱللَّهُ بِعَذَابِكُمۡ إِن شَكَرۡتُمۡ وَءَامَنتُمۡۚ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ شَاكِرًا عَلِيمٗا }
[Soera An-Nisāʾ: 147]
Sahih International:
What would Allah do with your punishment if you are grateful and believe? And ever is Allah Appreciative and Knowing.
MA
Subhanallah jazakallah
i have a problem i cant stop listening to kpop musik im addicted can someone help me?
Yasmine Chigri you could delete all downloaded songs and turn off your wifi when ever you feel the desire to listen to k-pop.
I think I can relate. I used to listen to music constantly, even when I wasn’t listening, it was playing in my head, or I was tapping it out, or singing along. I even used to play music. For me it was my comfort, one of the few things that understood me.
Quitting alone wasn’t enough-I’d just be left with a craving and emptiness that begged to be filled. I cleared out the music from my phone, and when I wanted to listen, instead I would listen to recitation of the Quran, especially by Al Afasy. It wasn’t the same, but I kept with it. I started getting curious about the meaning, so I followed the recitation in English on quran.com.
Gradually it did something to me. I feel like the Quran can touch my heart now in ways music never could. And I have God to understand me and offer me love and hope that is beyond human power to offer.
Music still comes to mind from time to time, but I don’t miss it. It doesn’t stay stuck in my head. My friends think I’m missing out, but I feel like now I’ve found what I was looking for all along.
May Allah grant both of us patience, guidance, and success.
@@alienturtle1946 Jazak Allah
Look into the issue of dissociation and numbing feelings. Music, binge eating, masturbation, alcohol, drugs etc when they become an addiction usually have some unpleasant emotions as the real cause as to why one turns to these things. If possible, finding something halal (like a certain sport, new friend, new hobby etc) that brings you joy can help with gaining dopamine kicks in a halal way so it becomes easier to give up your current addiction. Also processing and dealing with your unpleasant emotions and traumas if you think you have any is very beneficial. Point is, some form of change is needed to make a sustainable abandonment of the haram addiction because the reason we have it is because if fills some sort of hole within us.
@@alienturtle1946 mashallah!!
jzaakillah
Any religion that believes listening to Mozart, Rachmaninoff and Brahms is sinful is so bizarre as to be laughable. If it specified music with degrading and sexual lyrics, it might be worth taking seriously. But ALL music? Simply a joke.
Salaams. Peace be with you.
The joke is how clinged to music, whatever kind, we become that we attack anything against. Classic or not it distracts your heart in merryment or sorrow from reality and shortness of this life.
A God that would forbid the joy and beauty to be found in music is not a God worth following.
Hooterville World Guardian Satan says 😉
My God created the heaven and the earth. He created ALL of the world's beauty: great rivers, majestic mountains, and yes - glorious music. I detest Beyonce and Drake. But Rachmaninoff moves me beyond description. When I listen to his symphonies and other compositions, I hear God's hand at work.
My God also geve humans the devine spark that allows them to create beautiful things and the intellect with which to create them. You want to hear the voice of God? Listen to Bruckner's 4th Symphony. Or the finale of Mahler's 1st. Listen to Chopin's Nocturns - such beauty created by nothing more than a piano and the person playing it.....and by Chopin himself, of course.
I am sure the Quran contains many beautiful expressions, as does the Holy Bible. But if any of those expressions tell me that all music is evil, I know the book is anything but devinely inspired.
Is obeying Jesus Christ haram in islam?
Vettel2011 brother, Muslims and Islam follows Jesus(Peace be upon him) and His teachings.....Jesus(PBUH).
Vettel2011 the question is, what did Jesus really teach...to worship him? He even didn't like being praised,he clearly taught us who to worship, pray to, beg for guidance, we pray to the God, Jesus prayed to, the God he without don't showed us we needed as he too needed. Jesus was no ordinary man, born to no father, a miracle from birth....but was he a God. If we look closely with an open mind and heart, we would clearly see Jesus, a very special man, worship and pray and ask for God's guidance in everything he did, heal the sick, raise the dead, turn water into wine, all these miracles and he still said, he cannot do anything by his own will and power but by that of his father, God. Who is our father all, as he said we all are his children, is he a special child, yes, a God? No....you see we say God can do anything ,but God cannot do everything, God cannot lie. And sin, and do things humans do.Jesus clearly served God and taught us all how to do it....what came after, worshipping him, the cross, Jesus never taught any of that....
Isn't Zayn malik a pop star?He even has a large number of muslim fans.
Shinigami as far as I know he is either non practicing or he’s renounced islam
Realyy guys it depends on type of music
Sir Nouman ali khan ..Please back your arguments with quran and authentic hadith...
Looks like you didn't watch the whole video
Where are hadiths about music?
Listen to the Hadith Mufti Menk stated. Listen to the Tafseer of Surah Luqman. Listen to the verdicts of the Four Imams. Listen to the statement of the Sahabi that Yasir Qadhi mentioned.
There is no Quranic evidence for prohibition of music as it an intergral part of the human makeup as decreed by Allah s w t . Its how you utilise music and lyrics so it is based on application, niyyah and content. It is no different from writing a book or using a knife or a word uttered
Look up hadith by Imam Ja’far As-Sadiq (a.s), where he said that music originated from shaitaan and Kabil. If its from the shaitaan, it cannot be good. You wont be destroyed if you exclude music from your life.