As Stay I'm embarrassed and disappointed with that comment "composers working with them would only need to carry a spoon", the person who wrote it had no respect for other producers and songwriters who work together with 3racha to make amazing songs and sounds, in the same way that we respect and have to respect 3racha's hard work, we owe that same respect to the whole team, not just the producers, but a whole team of stylists, directors, producers, composers etc, who work together, very well indeed, to bring us admirable content. Skz are talented, incredible artists and professionals, but to show us all this, they had and have help from other professionals around them, thank you very much to the producers and composers who, together with 3racha, make tracks of a wonderful quality, I understand that this comment could have been made with a tone of humor, but it is still disrespectful, we do not need to belittle the work of one person to praise the work of others, always good to remember this (I'm sorry if there are grammatical errors, English is not my native language).
Thats right, they will work easier with 3racha but doesnt mean they are just a free rider, they already have the same understanding as both team have exeprience in producing so the work can be faster and more efficient, people need to note that
There’s a publishing division in JYPE and they produce tracks for the artists. Among them are Armadillo, Versachoi and others. Sometimes SKZ get the track from them and they always acknowledge the publishers in their song credits.
Well said!!! As a stay and an old kpop fan i often find hyperbola comment from fandom to discredit the hard-work of the team behind the scene. I found it disturbing and disrespectful. They only praise the artist and the fandom hardwork only, we can enjoy masterpiece and content of course because all the team work between the artist and staff producers stylist all you name it. You can praise your artist and your fandom but just don’t disregard or discredit the hard work team behind that. Its so easy tho
As a Stay I wasn’t sure how I felt about the “only carrying a spoon” comment. Producers & lyricists put in so much work as well. Sure 3racha are a big part, but then so are they. I think no matter what group they are making music for, no matter how much contribution, they deserve to be treated with respect.
I was thinking exactly this ♡ I feel like that comment was highly disrespectful. They, just as 3RACHA, are composers. If you think that what 3RACHA do is amazing, you should admire their work too. Doesn't matter how tiny or big was their input, it is there.
Whoever commented about them along with 3racha is definitely wrong, u might say its just a joke but for someone's job to make music from scratch when u don't even know a single thing about it is wrong! Stray kids always thank the ppl behind and who always help them, just like 3racha help each other bc they will have more ideas than just working alone also means so much that they also have other producers with them 3racha and skz are talented but we also shouldn't disregard the ppl who helped them, staffs, directors,prod, choreographers, dancers, editor etc. Stray kids already said it themselves, we as fans should also appreciate them
There’s a publishing division in JYPE and they produce tracks for the artists. Among them are Armadillo, Versachoi and others. Sometimes SKZ get the track from them and they always acknowledge the publishers in their song credits.
"Only carrying a spoon" whoever made that comment I hope you realize that just because 3RACHA is producers doesn't mean they can't get help for other producers too. Having ideas and making it together is how a masterpiece is born. Please have an opinion that is respectful and appreciate other's hard work. Respect both 3RACHA and the producers
As someone who wants to compose in the future as a job its reassuring that you can do it at any age. Thanks for answering these questions, it was super helpful!
“Only need to carry a spoon” that comment was really rude… I am sure 3RACHA won’t take that as a compliment as it is disrespectful to their coworkers. This kind of comments could be negatively affected the reputation of SKZ and their fandom, Stay. We all know 3RACHA are always humble and thankful for all the help they received, but some people don’t know a lot about SKZ may misunderstand. Put that comment aside, it’s really good to see producers answer questions that I was curious about!
That "only need to carry a spoon" comment is honestly disrespectful but as the guy said it is "half right, half wrong" since 3RACHA writes, produces and composes their songs and they only need a little help from other composers/producers but of course let's also give credits to them nonetheless. And yeah we can always give our opinions but just a reminder to all Stay that let's always be respectul.
![[ENG] Who was the hardest idol to guard among BTS, EXO, WANNAONE, TWICE, NCT and AB6IX? I BODYGUARD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sOCaIUZaLB0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ENG] Who was the hardest idol to guard among BTS, EXO, WANNAONE, TWICE, NCT and AB6IX? I BODYGUARD](/img/tr.png)
![[다섯플릭스] 있지 특) 예능감 미침. 냅다 드러누움. 워너비 어깨춤 레전드 찍음. | 흥큰집 사람들 하이라이트 | Ep.1 | Mnet 231004 방송 (ENG SUB)](/img/n.gif)
💌00년생 작곡가💌의 궁금증이 해결됐다면 구독&좋아요 꾸욱👍
제왑 😎영앤리치😎 00년생 작곡가…현실은? -01:08
냄새(?)가 난다..🎊대박냄새🎊 ITZY 띵곡이 탄생한 곳? -01:46
요즘 작곡가들 '방탄' 때문에 힘들다고😭? -04:50
JYP 걸그룹 장인이라며!!! 팬들이 분노한 이유? -05:30
너희 본진도 작곡가 고인물이니..?😰 -06:03
As Stay I'm embarrassed and disappointed with that comment "composers working with them would only need to carry a spoon", the person who wrote it had no respect for other producers and songwriters who work together with 3racha to make amazing songs and sounds, in the same way that we respect and have to respect 3racha's hard work, we owe that same respect to the whole team, not just the producers, but a whole team of stylists, directors, producers, composers etc, who work together, very well indeed, to bring us admirable content. Skz are talented, incredible artists and professionals, but to show us all this, they had and have help from other professionals around them, thank you very much to the producers and composers who, together with 3racha, make tracks of a wonderful quality, I understand that this comment could have been made with a tone of humor, but it is still disrespectful, we do not need to belittle the work of one person to praise the work of others, always good to remember this (I'm sorry if there are grammatical errors, English is not my native language).
Thats right, they will work easier with 3racha but doesnt mean they are just a free rider, they already have the same understanding as both team have exeprience in producing so the work can be faster and more efficient, people need to note that
There’s a publishing division in JYPE and they produce tracks for the artists. Among them are Armadillo, Versachoi and others. Sometimes SKZ get the track from them and they always acknowledge the publishers in their song credits.
Well said!!! As a stay and an old kpop fan i often find hyperbola comment from fandom to discredit the hard-work of the team behind the scene. I found it disturbing and disrespectful. They only praise the artist and the fandom hardwork only, we can enjoy masterpiece and content of course because all the team work between the artist and staff producers stylist all you name it. You can praise your artist and your fandom but just don’t disregard or discredit the hard work team behind that. Its so easy tho
진짜 스키즈 애 완죤 좋어요..
헐 이분들이 쓰리라차랑 같이 '애' 작업하셨구나 노래 진짜 좋았어요 !!
쓰리라차가 형... 아니 잠만 그래도 쿼카랑은 동갑이시잖아요... 3라차가 형 소리 듣는 거 좀 어색하고 그래...
근데 한이도 00년생이야...
3라차형들이....ㅎ 형?? 형이라고???
As a Stay I wasn’t sure how I felt about the “only carrying a spoon” comment. Producers & lyricists put in so much work as well. Sure 3racha are a big part, but then so are they. I think no matter what group they are making music for, no matter how much contribution, they deserve to be treated with respect.
Yes you're crt
Same eventho skz are their own producers but that doesnt mean there arent any producers who are helping them ,give these people credits too guys .
@@felixswifeu7976 yes stays will definitely give them credit ❤️
@@felixswifeu7976 exactly!
I was thinking exactly this ♡
I feel like that comment was highly disrespectful. They, just as 3RACHA, are composers. If you think that what 3RACHA do is amazing, you should admire their work too.
Doesn't matter how tiny or big was their input, it is there.
스키즈 대단하긴 하지..
와...00년생이라니....천재들이시네요 진짜!! 스키즈 애 진짜 좋아요 으허어
스키즈 보자마자 들어옴... 애 너무 좋은데ㅜㅜ 대단하십니당
스트레이키즈 애,, 진짜 너무좋아요
이런 노래 많이 해주시길,,,,,,,
같은 스키즈 팬이지만 저 댓글 왜 저렇게 말하냥..ㅠㅠ 마지막 마무리 작업 하신다는 거 보니 편곡 다 하시는 거 같은데 곡 만들 때 편곡이 젤 중요해요ㅠㅠ 같이 고생해주셔서 감사합니당...ㅠㅠ
스트레이키즈 "애" 잘 듣고 있어요😉
Whoever commented about them along with 3racha is definitely wrong, u might say its just a joke but for someone's job to make music from scratch when u don't even know a single thing about it is wrong!
Stray kids always thank the ppl behind and who always help them, just like 3racha help each other bc they will have more ideas than just working alone also means so much that they also have other producers with them
3racha and skz are talented but we also shouldn't disregard the ppl who helped them, staffs, directors,prod, choreographers, dancers, editor etc.
Stray kids already said it themselves, we as fans should also appreciate them
its really nice to know about the people..like composers,stylists,....they deserves much more respect.and recognition
Not shy, kidding me, and 애 are my fav songs🥺💓
There’s a publishing division in JYPE and they produce tracks for the artists. Among them are Armadillo, Versachoi and others. Sometimes SKZ get the track from them and they always acknowledge the publishers in their song credits.
우와 스키즈 이름 보이자마자 바로 들어옴
와,, 애 작업 같이 하셨다니 넘 조아요
"Only carrying a spoon" whoever made that comment I hope you realize that just because 3RACHA is producers doesn't mean they can't get help for other producers too. Having ideas and making it together is how a masterpiece is born. Please have an opinion that is respectful and appreciate other's hard work. Respect both 3RACHA and the producers
제왑삐 덕후로써 진짜 낫샤이, 키딩미, 애 다 너무너무 좋아해요🥰 앞으로도 우리 애들 좋은 곡 더 많이많이 써주세요🤩
"OH" is so beautiful ❤️ . thanks to making such a beautiful songs~
Thanks for support and working with 3RACHA . I really love OH songs. Good job 👍
우리 쓰리라차 애들이 좀 천재아이돌이라서요ㅎㅎ
와 제왚 작곡 담당하시는 분들 평균나이가 20대 초반인것에대해 . 진짜 대단한 회사가아닌가 하는 생각이 새삼스럽게 아니 애 너무좋아요진짜 장난아니에요 앞으로도 활약 기대하겠숨니다 !! 쓰리라차 짱 최고
아닌데 .. 제왑 소속 작곡가중 가장 유명한 심은지 .이우민은 30대일건데 ..
"Respect" Chan said...
우와 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 감사한 분들이였군요!! 스키즈 애 최고예요ㅠㅠㅠ 너무너무너무 좋은 곡 작업해주셔서 감사해요!
허어어얼 애 너무 좋아서 스키즈 곡 중에서도 특히 많이 들었어요 앞으로도 쓰리라차랑 많이 작업해주세요😍😍
Not just their artist but jype composer Also talented
와 낫샤이 진짜 좋아해요.. 독특하면서도 있지스럽고 중독성있는.. 집에 틀어박혀 있는 저랑 나이 차이도 얼마 안나는데 진짜 대단..👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
저희 쓰리라차는 자랑스러운 음악 천재들이라서요
As a Stay thank you for your work.
I so glad how JYPE artist or composer or others looks like real family.. Respect
Seems like 2000 is really a golden generation for kpop
Theyre the golden dragon gen for a reason
Kidding me 내 최애 노랜데 이분들이 하신 거라니 천재세요 ????
잘생겼어요 꼬비님
I just want to say that OH is one of my fav skz song 💙
낫샤이는 정말 여러번 들었는데 안 질려요 좋아요 진짜!!
OH ??????? 오마갓... 젤 저아하는 스키즈 노래애요 영광입니다 작곡가님
와 낫샤이작곡가님 얼굴 궁금했는데 나이도 어리지만 얼굴도 훈훈하시넹
오호 스키즈 애 좋습니다 좋은곡 많이 부탁합니다
낫샤이랑 애 진짜 내 최애곡들인데 다 이분들 작품이었구나 진짜 최고입니다👍👍
Thank you for making such a good songs🥺🙏🏻 stay really enjoy 애🥰
스키즈♡♡
스키즈 애도 좋지만 다른 노래도 다 좋아요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
삼라차 천재들
레전드🙊
Oneus' In My Arms is so good!!! Thank you for having a part of this beautiful song.
애 진짜 좋던데!!
달라달라 워너비가 가장 인기가 있었지만.. 개인적으로 낫샤이가 지금까지 넘버원임.. 진짜 구성도 좋고 퍼포먼스까지 멋졌는데... 생각보다 덜 터짐ㅠ좋은 곡 많이 맹그러서 있지 주세요..
나도 낫샤이가 최애ㅠㅜ
Ahhhh the composers of Stray Kids OH ❤ I love OH i listen to it a lot. The melody and music is so nice. Thank you for working with 3RACHA ❤
SHOUT OUT TO THESE AMAZING COMPOSERS!!
thank you for those masterpieces ♡
아 코비 넘 잘생겼어요,,
쓸라차가 형이라니... 낯설다 애들아
Not shy was my first ITZY fav song after that I started listening to them 🥰
Not Shy 작곡가 코비님…
Thank you for the music
For me, I enjoyed it very much
I'm so sorry if there's any immature comments
I respect you
So my favourite itzy's bside track is came from toilet.. nice
Yezzz, great job guys, love these composers.
As someone who wants to compose in the future as a job its reassuring that you can do it at any age. Thanks for answering these questions, it was super helpful!
All the producers that worked with 3racha have said same good things about them, really nice to hear from the producers themselves
Thank you for your work!!
와 미친 00년생이었구나,,,,,,,,,
I'm pretty sure JYPE gonna be the real Leader in Entertainment 🔥🔥🔥
Look how Stray Kids n Itzy being 4th Gen Leader
When you can't listen to Itzy's songs anymore without thinking of the composer sitting on the toilet writing it down😂
i hope you guys will make a song for JYPE new GG....
I see keyword "JYP", i click the video. Simple
It definitely works. 😁
왠지 작곡도 젊고 어릴 때 새로운 느낌을 많이 낼 수 있지 않을까 싶음. ㅋㅋ 앞으로도 기대할게요.
3racha best producer
Here for skz
They look as if they’re as close as siblings :D
Come on...you guys do amazing jobbb.
와 지성이랑 동갑이네
stray kids лучшие
“Only need to carry a spoon” that comment was really rude… I am sure 3RACHA won’t take that as a compliment as it is disrespectful to their coworkers. This kind of comments could be negatively affected the reputation of SKZ and their fandom, Stay. We all know 3RACHA are always humble and thankful for all the help they received, but some people don’t know a lot about SKZ may misunderstand.
Put that comment aside, it’s really good to see producers answer questions that I was curious about!
thank u for this video!!! I always want to know abt the composer of all these bob songs.... Can't wait for your future good song KOBEE and Holy M...
👌👌👌
Hacen muy buen trabajo :)
근데 발음 좋으시다
I really love not shy tho
I dont know why but i really hope next time they will compose a song for twice whether it is b side or main track… i really like it
ㅋㄱㅋㄷㅋㄷㅋㄱㄱㅋㅋ을언니친구의친구가낫샤이작사간데
They're the same age as HAN. I feel old🤧
Gue komen biar genep 100
wow he made ONEUS In my arms?! SKJLSJKSLJSLKSJKSKJSL!! OMG!!! THAT'S ONE OF MY FAVES!!
That "only need to carry a spoon" comment is honestly disrespectful but as the guy said it is "half right, half wrong" since 3RACHA writes, produces and composes their songs and they only need a little help from other composers/producers but of course let's also give credits to them nonetheless.
And yeah we can always give our opinions but just a reminder to all Stay that let's always be respectul.
me, who born in 2000 :
uh… was this necessary
I can assure you ICSM was born cuz of JYP and he was the reason why Nayeon ended up screaming while laying on the floor