I've always found it weird that the steel workers were making little models of Thomas, but I've just had a thought. Maybe the steelworks is secretly the Thomas and Friends merchandise factory.
6:31 If i was singing this song it would be like "I miss the model episodes, i miss Season 1 and 2 and Seasons 3-7, its strange but i even miss seasons 8-12, im not joking, i even miss Seasons 8-12!"
Because it show 3 tracks going in to the Steelworks even though there's 2 tracks going in, this could have been a special if there was 3 tracks because Thomas would escape, forget the Expermental( Fuck grammar) engines and the Special is over.
2:00 I found it odd that TFC mentioned only the Steam Team when James first told him he was going to find thomas! 3:30 Those trees in the road must be part of some folk tale! 3:45 also, Hiro's brake van is in the middle of this train! 6:33 at least he appeared earlier in the special! and Rusty is on the same line as Porter!
6:32 #41 Duck is not the only one who's missing... Lot more engines are missing: All of the narrow gauge engines in Thin Controller's railway( Scarloey, Rheneas, Sir Händel, ... all except Rusty ), Diesel 10, Rex, Bert, Mike( they are in Small Controller's area ), Victor, Bash, Dash, Ferdinand, Murdoch, Neville, ... many many missing engines...
0:16 I didn't even need to comment this, he already did. 2:59 *THOMAS YOU WERE ALWAYS THE FAVORITE YOUR THE MAIN CHARACTER.* 6:36 ( I think ) "I'm not joking I even miss James." Thomas you sound way gayer than you should be.. 9:21 *James sounds even more gay.*
The fact that you roasted the person who voices thomas with one line .i don't understand why people think this show is unrealistic real trains can't sing neither can thomas ! Priceless
I’ll be doing essentially the same thing you’ll be doing after watching this video. The only difference is that when I get finished masturbating, I’m gonna have a little something to show for it.
Extra goofs: When Thomas first meets Berosmith, you can see his face turn upwards slightly towards him. During the "I Want to Go Home" song, if you look up in the top right corner, you can see Rusty running on standard gauge rails.
Me personally, I don't care how unrealistic it is. Thomas has already dragged itself far into Hell at this point. Also, it's a friggin kid's cartoon. TBH tho, I actually kinda like the bouncing, as it allows more expression and emotion towards the engines, and it adds to the comedic effect. The bush scene, when I first saw it, had me laughing hard! Sure, it's unrealistic, but Thomas has groomed itself to be more of a comedy show than a slice of life show in recent years, and I'm perfectly fine with this change! I'm NOT ok with all of the feminism, though...
Has nobody even notice that in the seen with all the engines in the song i want to go home I think it's called did anyone notice that not only is duck missing is that rusty is there and he's is somehow on standard gauge track so instead of duck they went with rusty and made him float on standard size track so yeah that's another problem in the film
Everyone else: *keeps judging any bad moments or just the episodes in general* Me: *awwww look at how cute they are :D* (I’m referring to the engines if you were wondering-)
I found one, in the beginning when Thomas greets random things, the rabbits on the ground are hopping so fast, they can catch up to Thomas! And Thomas is going very fast.
In my opinion there only three minor things wrong; 1) James badgering Thomas to sing at the beginning of the movie. 2) The Experimental Engines didn't go to Sodor, or met the Fat Controller. If he could give engines like Fergus the Traction Engine and Harvey the Crane Engine a home there (and they looked like Experimental Engines) then surely he'd've given them homes there too - as well as protect them from being scraped. 3) Like the previous movie, the Fat Controller doesn't get to sing a song, even though he had plenty of opportunities to do so. However the only major thing I found wrong was Rosie's makeover. In my opinion it was TOTALLY (I'd put this in bold, italic and underlined but for some reason, it won't let me) unnecessary, unwanted and does nothing for her in the slightest, let alone SUIT her. After all, not all roses are red, and there are more than enough red characters (not just engines) on Sodor already - so she doesn't have to be (maybe for her pre-Sodor backstory). In any case, her beautiful original livery not only makes her stand out clearly, and is another step in equality for engines, but also completed the rainbow of liveries Sodor offers; I.e. James (Red) Billy (Orange), Flora (Yellow), Henry (Green), Thomas (Blue), Ryan (Purple) & Rosie (Lavender/Indigo) - take Rosie's lovely lavender coat way and the Rainbow (if not Rosie) is ruined for life. My guess is with poor Rosie someone in the designing or writing team came up with this absurd idea and everyone else thoughtlessly agreed to it without weighing the pros & cons first... That's all I see wrong.
Plus 5 More Sins: - Thomas is Missing Sodor, but it has only been 1 Day, not a whole entire week or month - Wait, Wasn't the Great Railway Show in Bridllington? - Dancing and Singing Trucks - Really that's what Frankie sad about? Victor and Kevin and Den and Dart seem to do their jobs just fine and here at the Steelworks, they aren't really doing that much - Also, Rusty on Standard Gauge Track
That isn't molten steel they're dumping, it's slag; a waste product created from ore refinement.
Hey now, I'm supposed to be the nitpicker.
SamTheTrainFan It said it in the movie.
DieselD199 thanks
Not really your the rip off of Cinema Sins
DieselD199 Watch your mouth! 😆
"Hello bunnies! Hello squirrels! Hello birds! Hello trees! Hello Sky!"
Hello, mental asylum, didn't see ya at the end of the branch
Me too
"I don't know why they say this show is unrealistic. Real trains can't sing...neither can Thomas" - I'm dead
bonus round: every time an engine bounces
Me in reaction to the bouncing: Is this seriously copying that piece of shit called Chuggington?
And we are at 68734 Sins, oh we weren't counting humans, fuck it
OK but, the stories are better than Sharon Miller's
True
LETS GO GO GO < Season 15. I know this comment was put before BWBA but I had to point it out plus no one is gonna read this comment anyway.
I've always found it weird that the steel workers were making little models of Thomas, but I've just had a thought. Maybe the steelworks is secretly the Thomas and Friends merchandise factory.
1:18
In reality, Awdry's rolling in his grave.
Rose Supreme hopefully he'd develop a sense of humor by now.
Next it will be Christopher, than the fans
If you call this humor..
Jisk van der Veen indeed I do. Quite good humor at that. What do you guys want?
You fucking kidding me? You call this movie having a sense of humor
The engines can now move on their wheels. STOP. MOVING. YOUR. FRAMEWORK. This isn't chuggington.
Cuddle Team Leader bruh
there's probably more sins in this comment section than the actual movie
SamTheTrainFan True Dat
SamTheTrainFan I love you
Ding!
I think you should redo this when the uk narration is released
SamTheTrainFan l said how can they lean
"Where's Duck "
Me: I'm not Kidding I even miss Duck , lol
Migiditch Duck is Fanservice
and Rusty on standard gauge.
Yes someone saw Rusty and noticed Duck missing final
Collin Joe he's Still a Standard Gauge Engine
Ethan Schmid I was talking about rusty
You forgot about the giant Bridlington is The Great Railway Show plot hole.
cant forget about that
Hai
To be honest, the bouncing reminded me more of Cars than Chuggington.
Top Quotes of 2017
“I lose friends”
-SamTheTrainFan
6:31 If i was singing this song it would be like "I miss the model episodes, i miss Season 1 and 2 and Seasons 3-7, its strange but i even miss seasons 8-12, im not joking, i even miss Seasons 8-12!"
6:32 If Duck had been there, Unlucky Tug would've called them out for it.
"Thomas would be excellent at *CinemsaSins* ."
...I'm also good at nitpicking :P
You forget one sin for the DVD cover
Because it show 3 tracks going in to the Steelworks even though there's 2 tracks going in, this could have been a special if there was 3 tracks because Thomas would escape, forget the Expermental( Fuck grammar) engines and the Special is over.
This video a UA-camr is a sin for making this sin video
That comment is a sin in it's own right.
My favorite attribute of the movie is that Henry doesn’t move his body around
"I don't know why everyone says this show is unrealistic. Real trains can't sing. Neither can Thomas!"
👌
Ethan P. He can sing though
Every time an engine bounces add 100 sins
Yes
Thank you brave soul
In the "Go Home" scene, Rusty and Porter were on the same track.
And it wasn't dual-track, it was literally the same size of every other track.
2:00 I found it odd that TFC mentioned only the Steam Team when James first told him he was going to find thomas!
3:30 Those trees in the road must be part of some folk tale!
3:45 also, Hiro's brake van is in the middle of this train!
6:33 at least he appeared earlier in the special! and Rusty is on the same line as Porter!
6:32 #41 Duck is not the only one who's missing... Lot more engines are missing: All of the narrow gauge engines in Thin Controller's railway( Scarloey, Rheneas, Sir Händel, ... all except Rusty ), Diesel 10, Rex, Bert, Mike( they are in Small Controller's area ), Victor, Bash, Dash, Ferdinand, Murdoch, Neville, ... many many missing engines...
0:16
I didn't even need to comment this, he already did.
2:59
*THOMAS YOU WERE ALWAYS THE FAVORITE YOUR THE MAIN CHARACTER.*
6:36 ( I think )
"I'm not joking I even miss James." Thomas you sound way gayer than you should be..
9:21
*James sounds even more gay.*
The fact that you roasted the person who voices thomas with one line .i don't understand why people think this show is unrealistic real trains can't sing neither can thomas ! Priceless
I’ll be doing essentially the same thing you’ll be doing after watching this video. The only difference is that when I get finished masturbating, I’m gonna have a little something to show for it.
TheIronEngine lol wut
TheIronEngine
Where the fuck have you been?
ayy jack, nice to see you here x3
Matty Harris , I'm asking the same question.
TheIronEngine iiiii
"Where's Duck?"
I'd be more concerned about why Rusty is moving on Standard Gauge tracks.
Or why Rusty is there at all, but none of the other narrow gauge engines.
9:36 Henry: What did I miss? Me: Boi you missed a lot.
Stop saying "Me:". This isn't a roleplay.
Extra goofs:
When Thomas first meets Berosmith, you can see his face turn upwards slightly towards him.
During the "I Want to Go Home" song, if you look up in the top right corner, you can see Rusty running on standard gauge rails.
Not Anonymous1 yeah I saw it and thought it was pretty strange!
yeah it's strange how they put rusty in
Not Anonymous1 The Face tilting probably isn't a goof and Apparently something he can do
holy cow your right!!!!!!!
Stanley and Harvey are Thomas' Friends
I don't think I'll be able to watch this without bursting into laughing, the bouncing animations reminds me too much of cars lol
if the engines keep bouncing they may bounce off the tracks
You forgot one sin.
At 6:32 Why is Rusty on the standard gauge tracks? And is Rusty the only who Thomas misses from the Skarloey Railway?
More trains created from that filthy long-forgotten biofusion technique, I've had it
A truck sounds like James
6:32:/GOOF:So look on your right hand side and you see rusty but,HE’S ON STANDARD GUAGE TRACK!RUSTY IS A STANDARD.
5:56
Thomas: Cinders And Ashes!
Me if I were sinning this: Literally
The engines are now chuggington characters apparently
...
Sadly
The Fat Conductor has a whole new meaning.
He's Sir Winston Churchill
I'm pretty hungry for some quality entertainment right now, i'm really glad Sam roasted Journey beyond sodor! Now I won't starve!
6:32 You said that Duck wasn't there? Was he replaced with RUSTY?
9:35
Henry: What'd I miss?
Thomas Jefferson: So what'd i miss?
Vhhji
9:34 Henry said "What did i miss?!" That makes me laugh hard
E N G L A N D I S M Y C I T Y
The meme steam engine hello classic Percy's face
Fuck off.
The meme steam engine you f off
"Feminism"
Me: *bursts into laughing* *pauses video* *rolls on the floor of laughing*
I like how he sins lexi every time she speaks
PugaturdleGamen NO DON'T LIKE IT
Honestly. She is a sin.
James is upset that his goods train was taken although he can't stand them
oh the irony
I think there should have been a sin for every letter in the lines lexi had and then multiply it by every time she changes personality.
Finally, someone mentioned the merlin derailed thing.
Title character immunity activate! *gets hit by bucket like he weighs nothing*
Amazing Video as always Sam. I cannot wait to see more I really do love these videos. Keep up the great work! :)
8:17 No sin for the trains rising out of the bushes?
Me personally, I don't care how unrealistic it is. Thomas has already dragged itself far into Hell at this point. Also, it's a friggin kid's cartoon.
TBH tho, I actually kinda like the bouncing, as it allows more expression and emotion towards the engines, and it adds to the comedic effect. The bush scene, when I first saw it, had me laughing hard! Sure, it's unrealistic, but Thomas has groomed itself to be more of a comedy show than a slice of life show in recent years, and I'm perfectly fine with this change!
I'm NOT ok with all of the feminism, though...
6:33 how is rusty on that track? And where is the other narrow gauge engines? And what about skiff?
5:34 or the scrapyard or iron works oh wait THIS IS THE IRONWORKS!!!!!!!!!!
Has nobody even notice that in the seen with all the engines in the song i want to go home I think it's called did anyone notice that not only is duck missing is that rusty is there and he's is somehow on standard gauge track so instead of duck they went with rusty and made him float on standard size track so yeah that's another problem in the film
7:32 the people inside Thomas jumped bu t he mánager to spin his wheels in the air
From the most important thing is being friends but Emily's voice it's just like Jeongyeon from the last chorus it's just like twice.
Everyone else: *keeps judging any bad moments or just the episodes in general*
Me: *awwww look at how cute they are :D*
(I’m referring to the engines if you were wondering-)
Am I the only one who notices James voice changed?!
I said the same thing when I noticed Duck isn't along with others
0:41 *A R E Y O U S U R E A B O U T T H A T ?*
1:30 How can James snort if he has no nostrils?
"**ding** **ding** **ding** "
I'm starting to think you don't like Lexi
During the production of steel, an unusable molten material is made, this is called slag, this is dumped out side.
6:32 didn't you see that Rusty was at the very far right near Flynn and Belle?
It wasn't molten steel dropping out of cars it was slag a byproduct of smelting steel
Wait, isn't slag considered an offensive word in the UK in some cases?
A truck sounds like James.
You forgot to say that James is also vernier then a UA-cam prank Chanel
I was waiting for a “bouncing engines bounds round” and one last ding beneath “The Hottest Place in Town” reading: (Hell)
Everyone asks where Duck is but no one asks why Diesel and Rusty are there.
Lexi: WE KNOW WHAT GUY WHO WAS MENT TO BUILD ON LOGS
me : wut?
Stop saying "Me:". This isn't a roleplay.
I love how u sin every time the big blue mistake embarrassment talks about thomas
Bonus Round: Engines Singing and Bouncing
TheRManProds people think the singing and bouncing are bad *ding* sin counter 190
I found one, in the beginning when Thomas greets random things, the rabbits on the ground are hopping so fast, they can catch up to Thomas! And Thomas is going very fast.
16, Don't these specials reintroduce characters that haven't been shown for years? Wait, its the color change isn't it?
Warning: This video may cause confusion and delay.
Wat...
THIS IS THE HOTTEST PLACE IN TOWN
WELL WARM YA UP WHEN YOUR FEELIN DOWN
6:33
Sinner Announcer: Where's Duck?
Me: Where's Diesel 10?
Stop saying "Me:". This isn't a roleplay.
Interesting sins, the thing that bugs me the most is hurrcaines 3rd and 4th wheels are not connected by coupling rods
The joys of bankruptcy.
So...do the trains drive themselves, or do they need drivers?
Scsigs no at least not after Thomas comes to breakfast
They Do Need Drivers
There drivers are there to put coal and water in the train and to swap tracks
Top 10 question that science can't anwser
Scsigs Both yes and no
0:50 Actually, The Road Vehicles, Tractors, Helicopters, Traction Engine, Buses, Steamrollers, Construction Vehicles and Jets can Talk
Gamebuilder2000 Hi!!
FlowerIris44
Helloylecake
That's 5 Amino Users Spotted in th Wild
Gamebuilder2000 Cool😁
Gamebuilder2000 people to
Gamebuilder2000
Don’t forget the tugboats
🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSS!!!! THAAANK YOOOOOUU!!!
In my opinion there only three minor things wrong;
1) James badgering Thomas to sing at the beginning of the movie.
2) The Experimental Engines didn't go to Sodor, or met the Fat Controller. If he could give engines like Fergus the Traction Engine and Harvey the Crane Engine a home there (and they looked like Experimental Engines) then surely he'd've given them homes there too - as well as protect them from being scraped.
3) Like the previous movie, the Fat Controller doesn't get to sing a song, even though he had plenty of opportunities to do so.
However the only major thing I found wrong was Rosie's makeover. In my opinion it was TOTALLY (I'd put this in bold, italic and underlined but for some reason, it won't let me) unnecessary, unwanted and does nothing for her in the slightest, let alone SUIT her.
After all, not all roses are red, and there are more than enough red characters (not just engines) on Sodor already - so she doesn't have to be (maybe for her pre-Sodor backstory).
In any case, her beautiful original livery not only makes her stand out clearly, and is another step in equality for engines, but also completed the rainbow of liveries Sodor offers; I.e. James (Red) Billy (Orange), Flora (Yellow), Henry (Green), Thomas (Blue), Ryan (Purple) & Rosie (Lavender/Indigo) - take Rosie's lovely lavender coat way and the Rainbow (if not Rosie) is ruined for life.
My guess is with poor Rosie someone in the designing or writing team came up with this absurd idea and everyone else thoughtlessly agreed to it without weighing the pros & cons first...
That's all I see wrong.
Charles Bowditch and the major thing BERESFORD
how does thomas not have a big dent or hole in his side tank after getting hit by the bucket? 8:48
6:33 rusty is in this sequence on standard gauge track
"Where's Duck?"
He's having his 'rectified' render rectified
Also Thank you!!! I've been waiting for someone to do an eww on this special!!!
Plus 5 More Sins:
- Thomas is Missing Sodor, but it has only been 1 Day, not a whole entire week or month
- Wait, Wasn't the Great Railway Show in Bridllington?
- Dancing and Singing Trucks
- Really that's what Frankie sad about? Victor and Kevin and Den and Dart seem to do their jobs just fine and here at the Steelworks, they aren't really doing that much
- Also, Rusty on Standard Gauge Track
Look to the right of the screen at 6:32. You can see Rusty on standard guage rails.
What even is that first goof. lol.
i saw houston when thomas said he also missed james
I didn't watch the movie. What did i miss?
*WHAT DID I MISS?*
*NOTHING OF WORTH*
Wait, you're not going to address the bouncing?
Understandable, have a great day
Finally someone did this!
I wake up to find Sam's Cinema Sins Parody on my notifications. Just the way to start a day.
I TALK TO EVERYTHING BECAUSE I CAN
Thomas The Tank Engine God dang it Tomtom The Dank Engine!
At 8:02 Thomas driver jump out of him But his wheels are spinning tho
It's shown in the movie that the engines can move without their drivers.
I just realized something, how do all the trains move without breaking themselves?
(not as much as chuggington)
Your voice whas awesome for james and gorfon.
w o t
8:22 hurricanes bumps james
Another sin for rusty being in the engine group
3:42 the sin counter says 521