Forza Horizon 5 vs Gran Turismo 7 vs The Crew Motorfest - Toyota Supra Sound Comparison

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 січ 2025
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 106

  • @MotoGamesTV
    @MotoGamesTV  Рік тому +5

    Real life for comparison: ua-cam.com/video/ciW-NyC1Bg0/v-deo.html

  • @acerusea5156
    @acerusea5156 Рік тому +86

    The Crew Motorfest sound reminds me of how cars in the mid 2000s Blackbox NFS games used to shift up gears

    • @aiden241
      @aiden241 Рік тому +18

      In fact, some Blackbox members did join Ivory Tower after the studio was disbanded

    • @EldenBorn
      @EldenBorn Рік тому +8

      Crew Motorfest has the best sounds of all three when it comes to muscle cars though.

    • @KikuraKun
      @KikuraKun Рік тому +5

      Really love the ProStreet

    • @redhunnid5142
      @redhunnid5142 Рік тому +5

      1:04 Bro yes when the Crew Moterfest Supra came on I started making the stank face it sounded so good the turbos and engine sounds reminded me of Blackbox NFS days in a modern day game I’m like modern day NFS doesn’t even sound this good anymore 😮‍💨🔥

    • @recon1673
      @recon1673 Рік тому +1

      @@aiden241 Makes sense why the audio sounds the way it does.

  • @1eyepaul
    @1eyepaul 8 місяців тому +11

    People want realistic sounds, when a game like gt comes out with realsitic sounds. Waa waaa i want loud sounds that sound unrealistic and then complain that sounds arent realistic

  • @itsrtvbaby
    @itsrtvbaby Рік тому +31

    The Crew Motorfest supra sounds REALLY good just reving in neutral! But when it starts to move it doesn't sound as a great. Neither one truly captured the essence of a stock supra, all though Gran Turismo is good at making their sounds muffled like a stock car.

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +2

      03:04 gran turismo 7 mk4 supra not muffled you can hear that distinct 2jz sound

  • @MJTbreww
    @MJTbreww Рік тому +89

    They all sound good to me, different in ways but good. GT’s is closest to sounding stock for sure though

    • @dogma39-c4j
      @dogma39-c4j Рік тому +4

      Nah. Problem is compression at high RPMs make them all sound like F1 cars. The Crew actually sounds damn good because you can hear the motor running at idle

    • @SixSpeedSeven
      @SixSpeedSeven Рік тому

      @@olavofernandes7286 they are. motogames said so if you read the comments

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +8

      @@dogma39-c4j but it's not authentic also you cannot here the distinct rumble of 2jz unlike gran turismo 7

    • @lucasnagringa
      @lucasnagringa 5 місяців тому

      i have all three games and crew mtf definitely sounds irl, gt is too computerized feels like “artificial” in higher rpm

  • @barmyneddy1789
    @barmyneddy1789 Рік тому +27

    GT7 is simply in a different league

  • @disracenboi336
    @disracenboi336 Рік тому +9

    I have a 2JZ, pd nailed the stock sound. 5:06, that is super impressive.

  • @andreasmoller9798
    @andreasmoller9798 Рік тому +23

    The car model in fh5 is really bad they need to fix it, gt7 is in a league on their own for the models,

    • @Skkura....6-19
      @Skkura....6-19 Рік тому +1

      Car model in forza is kinda old and defective

    • @fifteen8850
      @fifteen8850 Рік тому +1

      Idk man it looks fine

    • @andreasmoller9798
      @andreasmoller9798 Рік тому +3

      @@fifteen8850 no it dosen’t looks very outdated if you campare to gt7 model, forza likes to recycle old models they are doing the same thing gran turismo did with gt5 and gt6

    • @Skkura....6-19
      @Skkura....6-19 Рік тому +1

      @@andreasmoller9798 forza recycle old model from forza motorsport and just put in on new forza

    • @Skkura....6-19
      @Skkura....6-19 Рік тому +1

      This is one reason why forza is eco friendly

  • @kotarojujo2737
    @kotarojujo2737 Рік тому +6

    forza and the crew sounds like tuned one and gt7 sound close to the stock version.

  • @TheChosenStudios-h9b
    @TheChosenStudios-h9b 10 місяців тому +1

    The thing is. Gran turismo is good because they get the actual car in a studio with high quality acoustic equipment.

  • @donairechristianp
    @donairechristianp Рік тому +3

    TCM really reminds me of the old NFS games, from U2 to Carbon

  • @LawWonderTV9
    @LawWonderTV9 Рік тому +4

    Well, I must say. Though I don't own a PlayStation 5, I have to say that Gran Turismo 7's Supra sounds more superior. I kinda like a nice bass sounding engine. And although I don't care for Forza Horizon 5 and am saving up for The Crew Motorfest, I must say that Gran Turismo 7 has the better sounding Supra in my opinion.

  • @4thManonCross
    @4thManonCross Рік тому +6

    Gt7 sounds the realest but their is no decibel or volume increase in the sounds as the Rev increases, only the pitch changes so 1000rpm is at the same volume as 6000 rpm hence it sounds muffled. This flaw is more obvious in exterior sounds. That's their only Flaw The Crew sounds like an after market tuned Supra especially in shifting, but sounds good for what it is. For za sounds alright but way too racous

    • @recon1673
      @recon1673 Рік тому

      Forxa usea raytraced audio so that probably is why it sounds like that.

    • @kronosbalmond6472
      @kronosbalmond6472 Рік тому

      @@recon1673That ray traced audio or granular audio they used or whatever is the sole reason why most of the cars sound synthesized and completely artificial. Sometimes the Supra and R34 in FH5 sounds like its blowing trumpets.

    • @recon1673
      @recon1673 Рік тому +1

      @kronosbalmond6472 Well yea, but it also improved the dynamics with how sounds are produced in Forza.

  • @andrewandrew3713
    @andrewandrew3713 Рік тому +6

    In reality gt7 "has" the best sound as far as 2jz is concerned, og players know the sound completely changes when you hear the Supra in a replay, it's crazy good, literally one of the meanest 2jz sounds i've ever heard

  • @joaogoncalo2006
    @joaogoncalo2006 Рік тому +1

    Good Afternoon, MotoGamesTV. Very cool your video, continue to bring more videos and news on your channel, a big hug and may God bless you.

  • @Rustic_3851
    @Rustic_3851 2 місяці тому

    GT7 gets the Stock 2JZ-GTE sound which is obviously natural to the ears.
    TCM and FH5 sound like they’re modified but either way, they sound amazing even if it ain’t a stock sound.

  • @redhunnid5142
    @redhunnid5142 Рік тому +6

    The Crew MF beats all of them for exterior sound but GT7 has them all beat for interior FH5 tried but The Crew MF and GT7 got FH5 beat at least FH5 has good graphics but that’s not saying much all three games have gotten to the point where there graphics are extremely good like I don’t see these games looking better than what we have now the only way they would look different is if they’re in a different setting

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому

      Actually gran turismo 7 wins you can also listen to the distinct 2jz rumble

  • @thewitcher9118
    @thewitcher9118 Рік тому +2

    Меня бесит, то что в FH5 отсутствует анимация переключения на этой тачке

  • @baraa501
    @baraa501 Рік тому +12

    Grand Trizmo 7 is excellent, but I feel that the sound is muffled. By the way, I have three games, all of them are wonderful

    • @rickj_3726
      @rickj_3726 Рік тому

      you can still change the silencer

    • @baraa501
      @baraa501 Рік тому

      @@rickj_3726 Did not understand me

    • @gouravpreetsingh
      @gouravpreetsingh Рік тому +3

      it's muffled because the sound is actually coming from a distance to which the car is placed, it's an incredible detail in GT7, as when you take a rear engined car, and in first person mode, with 3d headphones you can listen to the sound coming from backwards, and in third person mode, you can experience how well the audio placement is, rather than just recording and playing the sounds, GT7 does it better than FH5 and TCMF

    • @fokuz2025
      @fokuz2025 Рік тому

      @@baraa501bro the crew motorfest isn't even out🤦🏿‍♂️

    • @baraa501
      @baraa501 Рік тому

      @@fokuz2025 🗿

  • @Francescog762
    @Francescog762 Рік тому +16

    I think that the Crew motorfest will beat the old Driveclub engine sound king 👑

    • @mnogoborets5676
      @mnogoborets5676 Рік тому +1

      You are right, but second place GT 7

    • @jortepap
      @jortepap Рік тому +1

      Lol.. Dirt Rally (2.0) is better than all of these. Waay more realistic sounds and still punchy

    • @bottomtext593
      @bottomtext593 Рік тому

      Nah they still got a long way to go. The FXXK in that game sounds so good it's unholy

  • @christopherspence5866
    @christopherspence5866 Рік тому

    Amazing Video 🔥🔥🔥

  • @youtubedenizen1068
    @youtubedenizen1068 Рік тому +2

    My problem with Forza is that the model they have for the Supra is very old and a little broken. GT7 and The Crew Motorfest are so much better

    • @recon1673
      @recon1673 Рік тому

      FM is probably going to update models finally, after all it's on Series consoles only

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому

      @@recon1673 don't think so

  • @tekarsenic
    @tekarsenic Рік тому +2

    Neither of them sound stock. Not really. Not compared to the vid you attached for reference. FH5 gets the closest tho with its 'street' exhaust sound. TCM is the most lively aka Hollywood. GT7... I've lost faith in their team far as exterior sounds go, but cockpit audio they're winning. FH5 a close 2nd, but in order to really tell you'd need to equip the street exhaust since loads of sounds are out of order in FH5 ( rolleyes ). I really hope that the TCM team tones down the transmission sounds. They're a bit over the top.
    My assessment
    Exterior Audio:
    1: TCM
    2: FH5
    3: GT7
    Cockpit Audio:
    1:GT7
    2:FH5
    3:TCM

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +1

      Gran turismo 7 wins the sound and tone is authentic

    • @MotoGamesTV
      @MotoGamesTV  Рік тому +5

      @@olavofernandes7286 In GT7 exhaust was stock. I didn't install any upgrades.

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому

      @@MotoGamesTV oh OK but it was making those rattle sound

    • @kronosbalmond6472
      @kronosbalmond6472 Рік тому

      I think GT7 has the best stock sounding 2JZ-GTE sound while Forza Horizon 5 sounds like a blowing trumpet due to their use of granular audio. I mean this was not required and not even pleasant to ears. The crew motorfest did a great job on the sound department and the Supra sounds amazing.
      Exterior Audio:
      1.GT7
      2.TCM
      3.FH5(shit sound, not even close to stock sounding supra)
      Cockpit Audio:
      1. GT7
      2. TCM
      3. FH5(it sounds good in the interior though)

    • @tekarsenic
      @tekarsenic Рік тому

      @@kronosbalmond6472 Neither of the other 2 ( GT7 or Motorfest ) capture the feel of the car. When I'm in cockpit cam in FH5, I feel more like I'm in the actual car than I am in either other game. Motorfest is too hollywood while GT7 is too 'safe'. At least Forza isn't afraid to take risks with untrusted tech in order to capture the feel of the cars. Sure, they're not 100% spot on with the tone, but the feel is definitely closer.

  • @artarealmblazer
    @artarealmblazer Рік тому

    I’m so glad I’m not a nitpicking gearhead. They all sound like fucking cars to me.

  • @RodJavierG
    @RodJavierG Рік тому

    En forza para que el sonido del Supra se escuche hermoso tienen que ponerle el escape deportivo en la modificaciónes

  • @amidoespotatoes
    @amidoespotatoes Рік тому +1

    Gran turismo has alot of reverb like it was on a stage or sum on an open area so yeah, pretty sucks

  • @Lucassainte-rose
    @Lucassainte-rose 9 місяців тому

    Engine sounds in gt7 are too quiet in 3rd person

    • @1eyepaul
      @1eyepaul 8 місяців тому

      That's realistic. You think ever car screams when you're outside?

  • @cristianfernandez1930
    @cristianfernandez1930 Рік тому +1

    Motorfest sounds very exaggerated in stock wtf
    forza and gt are more similar to the real sound

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +2

      Only gran turismo 7 to the stock Toyota supra mk4 rz with manual transmission japanese spec with 90s recaro sporty seat for the rz-s trim from factory
      The other two sound like modified

  • @comdrive3865
    @comdrive3865 Рік тому +1

    Gt7= muffled sound.
    Forza = angry sound
    Motorfest = best sound

    • @Zotek7263
      @Zotek7263 Рік тому +1

      Gt7 is the closest sound to the real life,the crew is more like a old nfs on ps2

  • @joemaristaana4241
    @joemaristaana4241 11 місяців тому

    man gt7 eargasm

  • @ivanor8621
    @ivanor8621 Рік тому +8

    Granturismo, the always popcorn simulator

    • @ivanor8621
      @ivanor8621 Рік тому

      @@olavofernandes7286 sure...

    • @JotaV2502
      @JotaV2502 Рік тому

      ​@@ivanor8621 It is, look at the titanium pipe

    • @ivanor8621
      @ivanor8621 Рік тому

      you are not well

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +1

      Because the exhaust pipe is stock also the tone is correct of 2jz

    • @ivanor8621
      @ivanor8621 Рік тому

      @@olavofernandes7286 I have gt7, all cars have popcorn and transmission sound like every car in the world has racing shifter

  • @olavofernandes7286
    @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +7

    Gran turismo 7 wins

  • @rollsroyce8385
    @rollsroyce8385 Рік тому +2

    GT7 king

  • @pietergouws8521
    @pietergouws8521 Рік тому

    Why is GT even here

  • @sergioavila7577
    @sergioavila7577 Рік тому +1

    Top 1 crew

  • @mutaazx
    @mutaazx Рік тому +1

    The Crew is always the best and strongest🔥🔥

  • @lilshax7297
    @lilshax7297 Рік тому +3

    TCM
    GT7
    FH5

    • @olavofernandes7286
      @olavofernandes7286 Рік тому +1

      GT7 actually on top in stock form you can here the tone as well of the 2jz not to mention it has recaro seats while the other two are exurated as if they are modified

  • @Maverick9k
    @Maverick9k Рік тому +7

    Easy comparison.
    1. Crew
    2. FH5
    3. GT7

  • @domwolf5966
    @domwolf5966 Рік тому +7

    GT sounds very bad, very muffled 🤯. For me MF beat FH5 in this comparison.

  • @deathnight9991
    @deathnight9991 Рік тому

    need for speed 「why?」