Which government has taken the most loans?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 січ 2022
- #IMF #Loans #PTI #PMLN #PPP #FarrukhSaleem
Official Facebook: www. arynewsasia
Official Twitter: / arynewsofficial
Official Instagram: / arynewstv
Website: arynews.tv
Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: live.arynews.tv
Listen Live: live.arynews.tv/audio
Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: / arynewsofficial
#ARYNews
ARY News Official UA-cam Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.
Subscribe to our channel so you never miss any news updates bit.ly/3e0SwKP
Iam baloch iam balochistan iam freedom iam
Jahannam China ka Dalaal jhooth riyasat jhooth
@@bigbiig2884 +q++++
@@bigbiig2884 vvvhuuuuuuuu9p))&¥₩₩0090¥0**
,for
Pakistan se friendship MAAF KARO
GAZWA-E-HIND KE GAAZI AUR UNKA TREAD DONO KO 🙏🙏🙏 (MAFF KARO)
Pakistani apni friendship (for India) Apne pichwade m rakhe
اگر عمران خان صاحب نے اتنا قرضہ لیا بھی ہے اور ساتھ 400 فیصد مہنگاہی بھی کی ہے۔۔تو پھر یہ سمجھ جانا چاہیے کے ناکام حکومت ہے عمران خان کی
Absolutely right bro ❤️💯👍👏✌️👌💕💘
پہلی دفعہ ary کا پروگرام اچھا لگا ھے ملک کی صورتحال پر گفتگو ھوئ اچھی بات بات ھے
عمران خان جس سلیقے اور ڈھٹائی سے جھوٹ بول رہے ہیں اسکی کوئی بھی مثال نہیں لیکن ستم یہ ہے کہ قوم اب بھی، بھی اس کو آخری امید سمجھ بیٹھی ہے 🤔
PML-N is far better than PTI.
PTI debt run rate is 17 arab per day as comparison to 8 arab per day.
PTI is making people fools.
شبر زیدی نے بھی پیٹی آئ میں ایک عرصہ گزارہ ہے اسلئے اپنی قابیلت سے زیادہ انہیں لوگوں کی قابلیت پے بات اور تنقید کرنے کی بڑی عادت پڑتی رہتی ہے
If loan in Dollar compare in Dollar don't compare in PKR bcz we return Dollar loan in Dollar not in PKR
اللہ تعالیٰ پی ٹی آئی کو اور سزا دے
furrukh saleem sb ke figure 100 % corect hein . sb se curency delevalue pti ny ke .
Point is why loans has been taken .why .to provide lavish life to govt officials with luxury cars.fuel electricity n so on . On what account govt proving these facilities on loans which a normal person tax
Sham to PML N and PTI
Jesa b ha pti thk ha hm fr b pti ko e vot daga inshallah
Pml n zindabad nawaz sharif
Nawaz Sharif London wala Zindabad ?
@@ahmedvelani6989Bhoonkoo bhoonkoo imrandu kottoo, bhoonk bhoonk k maroo khanzeeroo, ghandi nali k keeroo, tumhari qismat ma ab bhoonk bhoonk k Marna he likha hai Ghaddaroo, inshallah
Farrukh Saleem is as much an expert in economy as Waseem Badami is in cricket. Call some real experts
Almost every educated person here in government college lahore recommends students to read dr farrukh,s articles to understand the economic situations. So you are barking because you cannot bite.
@@hafizadeel8210 well that explains the sorry state of our academia then. He’s never studied economics, never published a peer reviewed article in economics, never worked as an economist.
شوکت ترین کے کل ہی کے بیان کے مطابق ساٹھ ارب ڈالر نواز ڈار نے ڈالر کو ڈی ویلیو رکھنے کے لئے کرنسی مارکیٹ میں جھونک دئیے تھے
@@barkaatkhan6945 ...o jnaab pti ki ratio b btao zra .... or jahil insaan 60 aran dollar ... aqal ha tumhe ander kuch... 6 Arab dollar k lye hm imf ki minnatain krte han... or 60 Arab dollar they b hmare pass???? Aqal say pti walon kia kya lena dena ha... or agr ishaq ne dollar market m lgaya to iska fayeda b pakistan ko hua ... inflation or dollar exchange rate ki sorat m pasa bahir ni gya ... or gdp growth continues increase hui.... or hr government hr country dollar ko stable rakhne k lye asa hi krta ha.... ye shokat tareen ko hm pehle b nakam hota dekh chuke han
@@hafizadeel8210 کوئی متوازن ذہن کا بندہ بتائےکہ PIA کا خسارہ 400ارب سٹیل مل کا خسارہ 300 ارب ریکوڈک کاجرمانہ 6 بلین$، براڈ شیٹ کاجرمانہ 30ملین$ ائی پی پیز کا گردشی قرضہ 2300 ارب۔غیر ملکی قرضہ 95بلین $۔اینڈ so on۔سمجھ نہی آتی ملک کو اس حال پہنچانےوالے ناسور وجود ابھی تک سیاسی طور پر کیوں زندہ ہیں.
حکومت مخالف جلسے بھی کررہے ہیں. کرپشن بھی انہوں نے نہیں کی. عدالت سے سزا یافتہ ہونے کے باوجود آزاد گھوم رہے ہیں. لوگوں"سرکاری زمینوں" اور قبرستانوں کی زمین پر فبضے بھی یہ کرتے ہیں.
تمام باتوں کے بعد نتیجہ یہی نکلتا ہے کہ جو حالات ملک کے چل رہے ہیں ان کا ذمہ دار کوئی اور نہیں ہماری عوام ہے. لہذا مہنگائی " ناانصافی اور ملکی حالات پر بعد میں رونا پہلے اپنی اخلاقی اقدار پر ماتم کرلیں. 🙄😢
بادامی صاحب چور سے پوچھتے ہیں چوری میں کون کون شامل ھے۔
TLP Zindabad
Imran khan zindabaad he zindabaad rhay gaa inshaahlla Kotay bohnkty rhayn gay
Wouldn’t it be better to figure out debt in dollar amount rather than Pk Rupees?
This is the magic of words for common man. The debt is being told in pkr, where it was taken in dollars. What about the repaying of debts.
It's tough cause now cause of devaluation the foreign debt gonna hit more hard
What difference does it make whether in Pakistan rupee Or dollar. Pakistan is already bankrupt, it's beyond its capacity. Nobody is talking about domestic loans.
ایک پہلے سے مقروض شخص زیادہ قرض لے گا کے نیا نیا مقروض ؟؟
Pm imran khan zinda Bad pti zinda Bad pm imran khan is great honest strong leader
Imran Khan zindabad
In this situation govt hv to 1)minimize it's own expenses, like allowances of ministers, pm,governers,secretory and all officers having grade 16 n above. 2)Minimize Tex collection expenses.
3)Stop black-marketing.
4)control over price of daily use items
5) take some steps to enhance awareness about export
6) provide water,seeds,fertilizeres,etc to farmers, maximize all eatable items which are being imported.
Otherwise no one can stable this economy.😶
Bro ye khud Pury hon gy tu he awam k bary mein b kuch sochen gy na
Fail stretegy
@@AwaisAli-ws6dv yeah kabhi pooray nahi honagay
qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq?qq?q?qqq?
قرضہ کس حکومت نے کتنا لیا ؟
اور واپس کتنا کیا ؟
یہ بھی بتایا جائے۔
Ya ALLAH Pak Apny Habib ky Sadqy me Hmary Pakistan ky karz door farmay Ameen
The honest analysis requires to tell how much loans also repaid during their tenure.
39000billion repaid...
Net kia hota ha?
Awesome 👍 talent for you so beautifully ❤️ love 💓 Allah Muhammad Ali's and bro hosting for you so beautifully ❤️
Allah pak Wazire Azam Shahah Baz Sahib ko mulk wa quam ke liye sabet qadm frmay Ameen
Pti,zindabad
If anyone in Pakistan understands how circular debt works you will know why debt will keep rising.
Muftah Ismail is industrialist how he know poor people of Pakistan 🇵🇰?
یہ ترقی یافتہ مہذب معاشرے ہی ہیں جو ان کے مال کی حفاظت کر رہے ہیں
Pmln Zindabad
We always talking about Turkey, Turkey face hard time now I think Turkey free from debt 🤔
لوگ بھول گئے لیرا کیسے ذلیل ھوتا تھا ایرانی ریال تھیلا بھر کے کلو سبزی ملتی تھی
قوموں پہ سخت وقت آتے ھیں
Yr simple rule bnao...jo govt jitna qarza legee wo otna recover krke bhe degee..agr kisi govt ne aisa na kia to wo govt complete ban krdi jaige hameshe kelia plus us cabimet mai jitne ministers honge unke assets ko sieze kia jaiga or unke nam ecl mai dalai jainge..dts it
PPP and pmln zindabad
Pls asked how may paid by 1 , 2 ,3 ,government + long term if your turn 5 years payment after 6 years who will pay.
Pakistan needs to federalize and levy property tax on non-primary residences and commercial properties at 2.5% of their values. Also make it personal tax deductible. How do people pay a few thousands in federal income tax and live in the houses worth billions?
This is an oversimplified version . How can a person with no active income and living in an expensive house pay the taxes . Active income must be included in such an evaluy
If property tax happens to be more then he pays zero income tax. This will bring people on tax net as well. How can Zardari and NS live in houses worth billions and do pay Rs. 16,000 income tax?
Good questions good simple answers well behaved guests.
WA pti
Lanat ho supreme court
one thing no journalist telling. the increase of det is due to the devaluation of rupe. secondly the debt taken by pti is to pay the installments of the pervious det.
don't miss lead the peoples they are very inocent and don't have those sanders of wisdom to figure out what media and politicians doing with them
Sahiwal coal power plant is real mess as supplying coal to the site is way expensive plus return on dollar investment is huge like tsunami waves. Further the agri economy of sahiwal will eventually collapse as pollution is the by product.
Jo Hakumat b ay usey chahiay Dam banain.
Money londonderry na Karen.
Allah sey Darna chahiay.
Allah Pak Awam aur Hukamranon sab ko Hidayat Ataa Farmain.
AaMeen
Such pora bol imran khan zindabad 💖💖
N league ne 3 times turn le kr q nae sb teek kiya jo ab kah rahe k kr de ge, they are making us fool bc we are fool we always make wrong decisions and every wrong decision has impact on future
3 times kahte ho ye nahi batate in 3 times men total kitne saal hukumat ki aur jitne bhi saal hukumat ki mahengai ko kam aur GDP ko ziada karke dikhaya
Farukh saleem sb, well explained....
Muftah Ismail sb also well replied to Waseem who is Chamcha/oversmart person...........
یہ آسان ہے کہ مسلے کے جواز بیان کر کے سابقہ حکومتوں کو زمہ دار ٹھہرا دیں اور موجودہ مسائل کو سابقہ خرابیوں سے لنک کر دیں یہ ایسا ہی ہے جیسے کوئی بیمار ہو جائے تو اسکے علاج کے بجائے یہ تفتیش کیجائے کے بیمار کیوں ہوا کیا کھایا تھا کہاں گیا تھا کیوں کھایا کیوں گیا تھا کس نے کھلایا کیوں دیا کیسے کھایا وغیرہ وغیرہ. یہ نہیں کہ اچھے ڈاکٹرز سے کنسلٹ کریں اور علاج ممکن بنائیں بیماری پکڑے جانے کے بعد علاج کیا جاتا ہے لیکن ہماری سیاست و ریاست صرف بیماری کی توجیحات و تشریحات سے آگے نہیں بڑھتی بلکہ بیماری کی وجوہات کو بھی اڈریس نہیں کرتی نہ ہی ان وجوہات کی روک تھام کے لیے اقدامات کرتی ہے بس ایک ہی راگ الاپنا ہے یہ پچھلی حکومتوں کا کیا دھرا ہے ہم کیا کریں.... آپ بھی تو وہی کر رہے ہیں جو پچھلوں نے کیا.... علاج کون کریگا ؟ کہاں سے آئیگا؟ کیا مرض لاعلاج ہوچکا ہے؟ کیا مریض کے مر جانے کا انتظار ہے.؟ اگر نہیں تو پھر اقدامات کیا ہیں!
Farukh saleem sahb good
Last hakoomat ne qarza liya but cooking oil 170 rupey petrol 70 rupey cheeni 60 rupey ataa 40 rupey bijli unit 9 rupey is hokoomat ne qarzt liye cooking oil 400 petrol 145 cheeni 100 bijli unit 20 + ab sb khud ho samjh Jao Kia hakoomat ne Kia Kiya hai
And which government has returned post loans.
Ya imf walay agar gherat karein tou pmln ppp pti insab ko apnay costodi main rakein or inkay jitnay bhi Asasay hain inko imf accunt main jama karein pakistan zindabad ho jaye ga insha Allah
I love PTI 🇧🇫♥️🇧🇫✌️
SUPPORT PTI INSHALLAH EVERYTHING IS GONNA BE OKAY 👍
Lora
In shaa Allah 👍
All baseless claims by M Ismail. Do you have any detailed feasibility report to demonstrate how electricity will meat all requirements of energy for domestic use?
N LEAGUE HAS TO MAKE SUCH CLAIMS ; Last time this govt doubled electricity rates ; Its availability was more than PPP
Imran khan is the best leader our nation
خیر جو بھی ھے اللہ تعالی آپ کو حدیت دے سب کھو امین
agar loan ki figure in terms of US dollar men compare keren to better samajh ayega
Oh bhai ab latest report hai statebank ki yeh tu devaluation kr ke hi bataya hai aunhonnne
How can we manage economy with out taking loans ? This is the question, anchor must ask.
Simple boost your income. By export reducing import controlling corruption.
Perfect
@@haseebmahmood829 corruption jo abhi government abhi aye hay woh bill kull nahi kerti. Lol
Pakistani people needs to be honest not only the leaders. Pay taxes and bills honestly. Pakistani people are more responsible than leaders of this crisis.
@@SaraSara-ee7hu well said...👍
Sorry no more pti 😢 go go
Right subject to discuss!
Better question to ask is what did the governments do with the loans?
Nothing just repayment..also the debt that came went some to corruption some for devloment..but the development is not translating to growth...with current political turmoil the fpi and fdi will be hesitant too.. let's see what happens
bring taliban ae Pakistan in power(government) and abolish ur Constitution, Institutions and countries accepting loans repayment would certainly give up on Pakistan and hence, u are saved.
@@somchin110 good idea, it’s a possibility
Why dont you also talk about ..who paid back the most...
Love you imran khan par karoro salam
Pm imran khan is the best pm in Pakistan🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰✨✨✨✨✨✨
Pti is only one honest strong party in pakistan they have great diliver hospital University school roads good Systems
😂😂
itna bra jhoot
کریمنل مافیا نون لیگ۔اللہ پاک پاکستان کو اندرونی اور بیرونی دشمنوں سے محفوظ رکھے۔امین یارب العالمین
iy~?&
اللہ اس عقل کے اندھے کو صحیح توفیق عطا فرماے۔
😂😂
عقل کے اندھے کب سمجھ آۓ گی تمھیں
اللہ تم رحم فرماۓ اور عقل وشعور دے
Pray for imran khan
Please follow ARY because ARY stand with truth
O Bhai mulk he bech do ...yehi reh gyaa ab ...qarz utry ga kesy ..koi plan ni ....Nwaz Sharif k pass plan tha ...us ne din rat mehnat kr k economy ko stable kia ...sath bijli bnae...power sector strong bnayaa ta k industry chaly ...phr C pec pe din rat kam tez kia ...q k us way se he mulk qarz se bhir nikalna tha ....PTI k pass koi plan ni hai abi tak
Yeh usi Ki waja sy Mulak K L lagy hoa hain
PTI is enforced to use the bad contracts made by Nawaz sharif government
Be shak Allah ko hazir kar k
Zinda bad ImranKhan
Could you plz tell me that when the any government takes so much taxes why do we then have to take loans from IMF China Saudia
Because unfortunately Pakistanis don't pay the right amount of taxes
Meaningful program
Waseem keep it up nice and intelligent questions you ask thanks ❤️❤️
Wasseem vai,,,,an extraordinary neutral person & journalist
External Loans are acquired in dollars and paid back in dollars
Salim Sahab is distorting facts.
$1 borrowed in 2013 was equivalent to PKR63, fast forward today
the same loan is now PKR183. The debt has increased due to exchange rate not because more borrowed.
PTI had to borrow to repay PMNL and PPP's loans.
Devaluation is included in figures. Ap kiya sun rahay ha
Karz utarnay k liye karz matlab mazeed karz
$ terms mein bhi dekhlein. Its the same story.
And what about trade deficit left behind by PMLN for PTI of around 19 billion dollars?
اب کتنا ٹریڈ ڈیفاسیٹ ھے
کیا تین سال چھ ماہ کے جیل میں بیٹھ کر بھی ذمہ دار وھی کمینے ھیں
PPP 6hazar Arab PMLN 30hazar Arab PTI 50 hazar Arab
سود کے خلاف خدا تعالیٰ نے اعلان جنگ کیا اور خدا تعالی معاف کرئے سود کیسے کم ہو گا بڑھتا ہی جائے گا
On what grounds have you called Shabbar Zaidi who was given responsibility to correct things. Not only he ran away but lifted up his hands. How can he give suggestions on what needs to be done when he did not do it?
They are talking about Internal debt which is in 50000 billion Pkr.
Don't confused.
External debt on Pakistan has reached 127 billion dollars.... Massive jump under PTI from 85 billion dollars
This is due to devaluation of rupee its not about PTI govt.
@@nomaa_j It's the government who did the devaluation 🤑
@@aj_0073 it pkr returning back to its original positoin
@@tsmkcs12 Back to it's original position? It's now close to 200 and it will continue to devalue in coming months because the foreign exchange reserves are just 10 billion dollars and most of the money can't be used so right now pakistan economic situation is getting worsen day by day.
@@tsmkcs12 now PKR is 223 rs so we also can't blame PDM because it's the actual value right???
گریٹ مفتاح صاحب
Pti 💚❤️💕💓💗♥️
Pmln zindabad
Dako nwaja chor zardare jahal fazlo basharm bagarat 🐕
Never to come again government of PMLN and PPP
Beshak
Khuda ki Lanat ho har us insan per jisne Pakistan ka bura Kiya or bura socha
زبردستی روپوش۔ماورائے عدالت قتل اور جھوٹھے مقدمے بنانے والوں کے خلاف احتجاج۔
28فروری ملک گیر احتجاج
او ظالم کے خلاف مظلوم کی فریاد بنیں
Absurd nonsensical narrative.
Lians now are being taken to return previous loans
Allah raham keray.
Pakistan may FOJ may BAGAWAT ka khatra.
America kamyab.
Waseem badami sab plz aisa detail mn ik aur program kry
Pakistani awam ko pta ho k 2024 tak har Pakistani kitna maqrooz hy
30 سالوں میں کونسا تیر مارا ھے ں لیگ اور پیپلز پارٹی نے سندھ میں کیا کیا ھے
Niazi ne to bahot teer mar liye jo sirf yuthiyon ko hi dikhayi dete hain magar jo sab ko dikhayi deta hai ki noon leagh ne mahengai ko qabu men rakha sugar poore paanch saal 55 ki rahi jabke yahi niazi ke 3 teen saalon men 110 ki rahi isi tarah aata adwiyaat bijli gas aur doosri chezen sasti then isi tarah kai sadken metros bijli ke plants banaye GDP aur rozgar men izafa kia ye sab in yuthiyon ko nazar nahi aata is liye phir poochte hain noon league ne ksuna teer mar liya
Three biggest problems ( decreased exports , IPP projects & grow import economy ) created by pmln . IPP projects with capacity charges , imported fuel , in $ payment for 30 years not only create 2500 billion circular debt but imported fuel ( coal , lng & rng ) increased demand for $ and put pressure on rupee . Imports base economy also decrease inflow of $ and on the other pmln exports came down to 20 billion $ from 25 billion$ and in same time period Bangladesh exports gone up from 25 to 40 billion$ . From 2013 to 2018 Bangladedh make 50 billion$ more from exports than pakistan . If pmln just increased exports from 25 billion $ to 30 billion i m sure pakistan would,t need of IMF , no need of rupee depreciation and inflation would be much better . Dr farrukh is a dumb economist he did not mention 20 billion$ current account deficit & artificial maintaining value of rupee with borrowed $ from IMF both these problems pti inherit from previous govt .
The problem is that what this govt has to decrease the use of ipps project so that we don't have to go for ipps and go for some cheap resources.
Ipps was signed and started by pp Banazir govt.
Thumbs up Sir
@@Tipsona - Correct and PPP took major kickbacks in setting the pricing. I remember one contract that they signed was almost 3 times the price that the same company signed with Bangladesh in the same week. I was shocked beyond belief to hear about our pricing.
Jahil admi sab sai zyada exports pmln kai era main thi ratio check krl loo ap logon nai imran khan ko sir pai charha liya
Hm ye kreangy hm wo kreangy Allah Imran khan pr Raham farma Amean Imran Khan Zindabad 🌺💎💎🌻💯💕💕🌟💯🌛🌟💕🌼🌹🌺
Pti ny sab say lia qaraz wah
مفتا ح اسماعیل صاحب آپ قرضہ لیں یا نا لیں لیکن آپ کا وہ بجٹ پیش کرنا ہمیشہ یاد رکھا جاۓ گا جس میں آپ نے شاعر مشرق قائد اعظم رحمت اللہ علیہ کا وہ شعر سنایا تھا
2008 / 2013 Qarza increase 6,000 Trillion increase / 16,000 Trillion increase 2013 / 2018 Qarza increase 16,000 Trillion increase / 30,000 Trillion increase 2018 / January 2022 Qarza increase 51,000 Trillion increase Us Dollar Rate in Pakistan 2008 / 2021 / 60 / 176
Trillion nhi hai billion hai 😊
Sehi keha agr 60 rupee k hisab sy Imran Khan ka karza account kerain to Nawaz sharif sy Kam bnta
تیس سال حکومت کر کےچوروں نے پاکستان کابیڑا غرق کیا ۔ دنیا کو علم ھے
Very Honest Admittence