That is Mr. Yadav. In 24 minutes you have addressed the issue comprehensively. I am inclined to believe that you did influence Rahul Gandhi in taking this decision. Even the driving force behind him . Modi and the Sangh Parivar can not escape Thank you. BIG THANKS
@123xyzabccba Merit doesn't work 100% of the time in reality even in the U.S. Any school and college admission that us based on capitation fees, clearly bypasses merit. Sons and daughters whose fathers pay high capitation fees to medical and engineering colleges are not necessarily being granted admission based on merit.
for those people in the comments saying that hinduism is a caste based religion i would kindly suggest them to first have knowledge and then speak. No hindu text ever speaks of caste based discrimination. The caste system itself was introduced in india when we were colonozed by britishers. The british census commisioner Herbert Risley was the first person to divide the society on the basis of caste. He wrote down the casts and then arranged them according to hierarchy which was later imposed as laws in india. History of india is 5000 years old. Many greek roman and chinese historians had visited india and wrote about the life styles but no one had ever mentioned any caste system in india and even the old indian books never ever talked about caste system
Ya ya blabbering here by seeing the serial Mahabharat. Do you know who Ekalavya really was , whose son he was . First try to find out that then come and bark here.
❤❤❤❤things which yoya missed out 1 . rohini commission 2. sub categorization of obc and sc/ st 3. priviledge of dominant obc castes over land resources 4. land reforms 5. creamy layer in reservation 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@@jitendrasain967 : Reservations was not supposed to remove casteism but to ensure proportional representation to all ; otherwise the minority privileged manuwadi toxic caste-cabal would have cornered everything
@@Nidhi_Tripathiiiiii Reservation khatam karne ke liye you need the majority support. Forget SC-ST-OBC try to convince Muslim General caste which comprises 1/3rd of general caste to support your demand. They wouldn't even support you, removing it is a far fetched dream try to apply creamy layer but the govt clearly just now said they won't apply creamy layer to SC-ST. Make a party convince the majority to vote for you to remove reservation win 2/3rd majority in lok sabha and do it
Caste census should also include Muslims and Christians. We know that 80% or so among Muslims are originally from the disadvantaged Hindu castes. Creating opportunities for Muslims and Christians on the basis of income and caste is definitely justified as much as it is for disadvantaged Hindu communities.
Agreed that knowing the demographics enables you to better help the poor and disenfranchised, like the Dalits. Perhaps modi doesn't want the opposition to know where they are because then the opp would be able to aim their promises, rhetoric and even genuine help better, especially during elections. A united opposition would be able to fight modi much better than a fractured one. Such a pity that each party leader wants all the glory for themselves individually and the INDIAAlliance was formed only for seat sharing. It really was a success and gave so much hope to Indians.
for those people in the comments saying that hinduism is a caste based religion i would kindly suggest them to first have knowledge and then speak. No hindu text ever speaks of caste based discrimination. The caste system itself was introduced in india when we were colonozed by britishers. The british census commisioner Herbert Risley was the first person to divide the society on the basis of caste. He wrote down the casts and then arranged them according to hierarchy which was later imposed as laws in india. History of india is 5000 years old. Many greek roman and chinese historians had visited india and wrote about the life styles but no one had ever mentioned any caste system in india and even the old indian books never ever talked about caste system
This is a man who should have been put behind bars way back. Your forum's tnc stops me to slam him with Bhartiya Gaaliyaan....... But he certainly deserves what i want address him with. Ask this gentleman why Congress isnt doing do it in the states where it is in power to start with.....
Caste census will go a long way to further consolidate the caste hierarchy. It is likely that people down the line will ask for reservation in jobs etc proportional to their numbers. This does violence against article 14 of the constitution. This is against the vision of making india a casteless society. It's a retrograde and stereotype of thinking .
The first caste census was conducted by british in the year 1931 and that exposed the hollowness of the claim made by the minority castes cabal of bamman +bania+kshatri that they are majority when actually their total share in the population was merely 15% but they cheatingly controlled 80% of power and wealth. This proportion has gone down further due to better health care and monopoly over wealth and power. Therefore these minority privileged castes are opposing caste census fearing exposure and consequential backlash from the bahujan castes who have been kept deprived since the days of varnashram reservations as ordained under manusmriti
Then why Nehru stopped it in 1951 ? The whole program behind caste census is to divide the hindus which are getting consolidated and it the script of George Soros which Rahul gandhi is following.
@@123xyzabccba hAhh.. we ruled this country 5000 yrs and 75 yrs since independence as per your all. Why would it fail... Keep your 4000 jaatis infested with reservation virus and fight... We are out ..
Mr Yadav, whom I respect a lot is being clever with his words. See the problem is only in north and particularly in Bihar and UP. The states which are responsible for maximum population growth and anarchy. In rest of India, where population is controlled and social peace has been there since decades, why take up new issues. We in other parts of India are progressing nicely. So please do not burden us with your failures
You are such a lazy person with Lazy argument. If those states can listen to your sarcasm and hate and become progressive then I could understand. You have a third grade attitude towards solving a problem. No nation has become great nation by hating and blasting against poor people. Poor people does not have way to put condoms(social, money etc issue) so they produce more. And you a great philosopher trying to be smartest person on earth by just taunting they will become progressive ?
@@anupammajmudar6752 : The virus of castes has affected the whole nation hence it’s necessary to dissect this virus so that curative measures could be effectively taken ……
You can't compete or identify merit with any country or persons as long as Dronacharya's as masters and Ekalavya 's are there every where and at all levels in this country
Yadav ,Kurmi ,bhi obc mein aate hai jo bahut sampann hai up bihar mein aur unka political representation bhi achcha hai .unko nikalo obc se aur phir sahi se affirmative action kaam karega. Similarly sc st subcategorisation aur sc st creamy layer Lagana chahiye jisse reservation ka faida valmiki aur Musahar samaj ko bhi mile. Rohini commission ne kha hai Sirf 25% jaati 97% jobs le jaa rhi aur usme bhi sirf yadav kurmi milkar up Bihar mein 90% job kha rahe . Aur dusri jaati moorkh bn rhi h.
Padney ji ko janam se jati manni hai, janam se jati dekh kar ristedari nibhani hai lekin reservation mai Creamy layer chahiye😂 btw central cabinet outrightly rejected the bogus idea of Creamy layer in sc and st aur yadav kurmi bihar mai 90% reservation le hie nhi skte kyunki wha sub categorisation hai OBC aur EBC ki, ye propaganda wala chooran kisi aur ko chatana
Instead of focussing on individual rights as equal ciitzens these people want a census so that birth based discrimination by the state can continue for short term political gain
Another myth that needs to be shattered is what the Mandal Commission recimmended. The Mandal Commission clearly recommended a combination of caste and income for creation of opportunities for the disadvantaged. Which is why there are brahmin communities who have been given reservations on the basis of their income levels.
Not only should we not have a caste census but we as Indians should move towards using the indegenous words Varna and Jati instead of caste in discussions and debates. The word caste has its origins in the Portuguese language and as such is a European outlook on Indian society. A caste census would actually reinforce this world view. As a citizen of modern India I reject the legitimacy of the colonial worldview and am more interested in understanding and dealing with our social problems through an indegenious lens. Bhartiya to Bhartiya!
@@lokeshgsadhmaya5499 : Every castes has several subcastes ….in bammans the ppl who perform last rites at the crematorium are treated as lowly bammans by other bammans and are outcasted ….
Please explain "wealth redistribution " similarly. And please do the caste census for Sikhs, Christians, Muslims etc. Also. Jat Sikhs own a disproportionate amount of the farm land .. lower caste Sikhs do not. Similarly Ashrafs and Pashmandas in Islam.
Why is it that Yadav would favour a caste census but wouldnt favour a sub categorization of SC and ST??...already we are facing low skilled workforce...instead of putting ur money and time improving that, u are playing with this narrative simply because it gains u votes...already many communities have been given the obc quota and the list have been long.
@@indianindian9970 how people will get divided. It's only counting of persons and the caste they belong to. Its upto people that they feel like discriminated, so they should not feel so.
@@anonymous-2172 If it does not create differences among people, then why reservation is made only depending on caste? Why caste census is not being done separately in Muslim religion? Why are people from lower communities and upper communities being politicized during elections? This will create more conflict between Brahmins and Dalits. So cast system is not needed at all
Our great social reformers says not to talk about caste ,here this fellow is talking about caste. The media also donot do research just viewed on these jokers,the people who migrate from one state to another born and brought up in another state how much caste benefits they get ,they rise on their own merit
@21:20 so will dominant obc agree to move out of obc quota? Why did this not happen on case of Bihar caste survey where quota was increased but dominant OBC were not out of OBC reservation? Does Rahul Gandhi supports dominant OBC moving out of reservation?
@@kumudbartwal : There’s a creamy layer concept which keeps the dominant obc’s out of reservations But there’s no creamy layer for the privileged castes hence those who are rich n powerful keep dominating generations after generations depriving the others ….
Caste census Britishers ne kyon shuru karwaya aur Nehru ne kyon khatam kiya aur abhi rahul gandhi kyon iski baat kar raha hai ? Inn saare sawalon me hi caste census ka saara jawaab hai.
Sirf naukari me reservation se kya hoga? Itna kam? Loksabha me bhi reservation karo, fir alag alag desh hi bana lo, sabko apna desh milna chahiye. 4000 caste hain, 4 lakh subcaste. To kamse kam 4000 desh, abadi ke hisab se alag alag, aur fir monority ko alag desh, Khalistan, Mughalistan, Christian country.
@@manishshrivastava5201 bhai leftists ko idea maat de adhe sai zyada pagal hote hai .aaj caste census hogaye toh sc ko 20% reservation, st ko 9% ,obc ko 52 % lekin agr 2nd baar caste census hua aur agr sc,st ya obc ka population kam hogaya toh kya inka reservation kaam hoga?😂
CREAMY LAYER AND SUBCLASSIFICATION MUST ALSO BE DONE IN OPEN CATEGORY because those castes and ppl are rich and powerful keep monopolising over power and wealth for generations depriving others within the open category and those thus affected vent their anger unjustifiably towards reservations meant for the oppressed castes …..
@@manjulashanmugasundaram706 OK I say let us abolish all the caste system. Will all the castes agree ? Manusmriti is some very old scriptures, hardly anybody follows it today.
@@rc2k22 will the Brahmin accept such a proposal? None will support including the Kshatriyas. Anti-Caste movement didn't achieve their desired end goal.
@@black__monk400 🤣 Forget the Brahmins, even the SC / ST communities will not accept to give away their castes, because it will also mean giving away Reservations and Job Quotas
You are speaking so much on caste census, even after 75year of indipendenc, what congress did when their government was in power . Mr. Yaadav just wooing Rahul Gandhi
19:29 This is a complete U-turn. When the slogans were raised they were raised as 'Jitni Aabadi Utna Haq' - What Salim Yadav says here is completely opposite. People have been opposed to the Caste Census since last year because on multiple occasions Rahul Gandhi and various proponents have openly asked for reservations in the private sector. Add to this the caste-based wealth survey that the same people were shouting. THESE ARE THE TWO MAIN REASONS PEOPLE ARE OPPOSING IT. What Salim Yadav is saying is completely different and IMO opposite of what the likes of Rahul Gandhi and co are braying non-stop. Stop shifting the goalposts and stop bullsh*tting!
@@123xyzabccba Do it please! I am all in for it. How will we do this? Which political party or movement asks for the abolition of caste? You cannot have caste quotas and caste abolition at the same time. Right?
@@HRC294 : Caste came first with varnashram reservations for bammans and constitutional reservations followed …so that which came first must also go first …isn’t it …..The products of 3 000 yrs of varnashram reservations are shit scared of the products of 70+ years of constitutional reservations 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
मैं कहता हूं मंडल स्वयं ओबीसी से आते थे तो क्यों न सवर्ण का भी एक कमीशन घोषित किया जाए जिसकी चेयरमैन कोई सबर्ण ही हो दूसरी बात अगर किसी को भी क्लास 8 की मैथ्स भी आती हो तो कैलकुलेट कर के बताए की एक कैंडिडेट को अपनी लाइफ में एडमिशन, फॉर्म ,स्कॉलरशिप ,हॉस्टल आदि आदि कई जगह आरक्षण मिलता है तो इसका cumulative effect कितना हो जाता है और इस वजह से एक अनारक्षित कैंडिडेट लाभ की स्थिति में कितना पीछे चला जाता है तीसरी बात उस नागरिक की क्या गलती है जिसकी पूर्वजों ने भेदभाव किया होगा,,(हालांकि लोग राजाराम मोहन राय ईश्वर चंद्र विद्या सागर आदि आदिअनेक महान आत्माओं को नही याद करते )
Ussi Mandal ne 10% EWS bhi recomend kiya tha jisko BJP ne laagu kiya hai aur shadi ristedari toh aaj bhi jaat dekh kar hoti hai kyu sara theekra purvajon par daal rhe ho koi bhut sudhar nhi hua hai abhi
@@Vajra98 वही तो माननीय उच्चतम न्यायालय ने कह दिया कि दलित के अंदर महादलित और पिछड़ों के अंदर अतिपिछड़े हैं तो कुछ लोग कोर्ट पर ही भड़क गए बात रही शादी की तो ये सबका अधिकार है आप किसकी शादी जबरन थोड़ी करवा सकते
@@Vajra9810% Mandal na Nahi Diya ha Woh modi na aapna aap Diya tha sinhoo commission banaya Gaya tha manmohan Ka time ma but SC/st / obc na virodh Kiya tha
What Yogendra Yadav fails to answer is that tomorrow if the caste census shows that 90% of people in this country are Dalits, will you recommend 90% Reservation Job Quota ?
If 90 % of the dalits have.less than 20 % of income and wealth..them ofcourse there is a problem..our nation has to move forward.. taking everyone together..on d oder side..if 90 % are dalits..and they hold atleast 50 % of resources..then the discussion will be to do away with reservation or reduce..its a fair ask. Caste census can work both ways..but we need data.what our people r doing
@@mohithpm4954 Dhirubhai Ambani who built the Ambani empire studied till 7th Standard, and transitioned from rags to riches. This shows that India gives opportunities to even underprivileged people. So this argument of wealth distribution is farce.
@@rc2k22 Okay, then ideally you should have studied till 7th Standard, started your own enterprise, and by now been the path to being a successful entrepreneur, instead of being insecure about your jobs being taken away by reservations, right? I mean, if with all your privilege and education you haven't succeeded yet, it's your incompetence no?? If Ambani sr. was able to do it with much less?
@@mohantysobhi There are so many Dalit self employed people who don't need Reservations. I am not much worried about my job being snatched, I am more worried about Merit being sidelined in this whole Reservations business
You all need to start caring and loving your country Bharatvarsh ..Yadav is a anti india person we all know ..muslim with a hindu name thus his leanings ..sadly .
Mad or what. Living in bubble of those 20% one sidedly dominant in social print n tv news medias. And in generational business inheritances property education jobs and so opportunity while giving directly indirectly to openly and hideously for others to enter job education or other place.
@@ankit5820issue who was living in the bubble of your imaginary world , forgot that they are so called mosts of print social media are under € hinese Soros funded , education job are always should be based on merit and hot based on the reservation
@@pedadasiddardha9655 unlearn the learning you got from from generational beliefs unlearn social ecological cultural educational COLLECTIVE Previlege. Unlearn the misinformation and propaganda what beds in minds of u n ppl from dominance of Savarnas in Print TV news n suicidal Medias. Along with dominance in every place. It's coz of previlege. Brits aren't ahead just becoz of skills the skills n education industry market capture they got from Previlege of Racism N Imperialism, their Colonies in world for centuries.
All the piddis tell me what will be the next step after the caste census is done. Is there any plan to increase the reservation quota to above 50%. Why caste census Hindus only, why not of Muslims ? There are many backward classes in muslims.
Hey Yadhav & Pillai, As long as you are that, you are not going to accept the caste census idea. But why the hell you claim as intellects? Funny😂😂😂One should search where its lost. Privileges lost in the name of caste should be resolved in the name of caste. No other way😂😂😂😂 Learn from Tamilnadu guys😂😂😂😂 ask PTR, he will teach you 😂😂😂
That is Mr. Yadav. In 24 minutes you have addressed the issue comprehensively. I am inclined to believe that you did influence Rahul Gandhi in taking this decision. Even the driving force behind him . Modi and the Sangh Parivar can not escape
Thank you. BIG THANKS
Though I am a Brahmin I am in favour of Caste census. Nothing wrong with it. It helps to know where each caste stands in terms of development
Even the sangh is now in favour of caste census
@krishnamurthy524 Kudos to you for being empathetic and cognizant of the social issues. We need more people like you.
@@krishnamurthy524 when your daughter will get 10 percent to fight other will get 100 what will you do fool
So tell me one thing. After the caste census is done then what's the next step. Is it to raise the reservation quota above 50% , tell me .
@@ashutosh8841 90 percent karna hai bhai inko.. kaahe ki aise to inko fati padi h humse
MERIT IN THIS COUNTRY IS A GREATEST MYTH : it died the day Ekkavyas thumb was severed for the corrupt drona
@123xyzabccba Merit doesn't work 100% of the time in reality even in the U.S.
Any school and college admission that us based on capitation fees, clearly bypasses merit. Sons and daughters whose fathers pay high capitation fees to medical and engineering colleges are not necessarily being granted admission based on merit.
Merit was dead since 2k years.. because of manusmriti.... constitution introduced the concept of merit 😀
@@moc9818 read real manusmriti 😂😂😂 not distorted one
for those people in the comments saying that hinduism is a caste based religion i would kindly suggest them to first have knowledge and then speak.
No hindu text ever speaks of caste based discrimination. The caste system itself was introduced in india when we were colonozed by britishers. The british census commisioner Herbert Risley was the first person to divide the society on the basis of caste. He wrote down the casts and then arranged them according to hierarchy which was later imposed as laws in india. History of india is 5000 years old. Many greek roman and chinese historians had visited india and wrote about the life styles but no one had ever mentioned any caste system in india and even the old indian books never ever talked about caste system
Ya ya blabbering here by seeing the serial Mahabharat. Do you know who Ekalavya really was , whose son he was . First try to find out that then come and bark here.
Excellent conversation.
❤❤❤❤things which yoya missed out
1 . rohini commission
2. sub categorization of obc and sc/ st
3. priviledge of dominant obc castes over land resources
4. land reforms
5. creamy layer in reservation
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Well Creamy layer has been outrightly rejected by central cabinet, everyone knows money doesn't wash away caste and it's associated stigma
So it means reservation is not effective in removing cast based discrimination
@@jitendrasain967 : Reservations was not supposed to remove casteism but to ensure proportional representation to all ; otherwise the minority privileged manuwadi toxic caste-cabal would have cornered everything
Caste census is the need of this country.
reservation band karwaungi 💖
@@Nidhi_Tripathiiiiii Reservation khatam karne ke liye you need the majority support.
Forget SC-ST-OBC try to convince Muslim General caste which comprises 1/3rd of general caste to support your demand. They wouldn't even support you, removing it is a far fetched dream try to apply creamy layer but the govt clearly just now said they won't apply creamy layer to SC-ST.
Make a party convince the majority to vote for you to remove reservation win 2/3rd majority in lok sabha and do it
@@Nidhi_Tripathiiiiii : teri jaat namonishaan hojaaygi
Usse phle alag desh leke rhegnge..chinta na kr...dekhte jaa@@123xyzabccba
Guess how many judges of the Supreme court bench, that put that 50% cap on reservations, were SC, ST, or OBC?
Great discussion
Caste census should also include Muslims and Christians. We know that 80% or so among Muslims are originally from the disadvantaged Hindu castes. Creating opportunities for Muslims and Christians on the basis of income and caste is definitely justified as much as it is for disadvantaged Hindu communities.
Agreed that knowing the demographics enables you to better help the poor and disenfranchised, like the Dalits. Perhaps modi doesn't want the opposition to know where they are because then the opp would be able to aim their promises, rhetoric and even genuine help better, especially during elections. A united opposition would be able to fight modi much better than a fractured one. Such a pity that each party leader wants all the glory for themselves individually and the INDIAAlliance was formed only for seat sharing. It really was a success and gave so much hope to Indians.
for those people in the comments saying that hinduism is a caste based religion i would kindly suggest them to first have knowledge and then speak.
No hindu text ever speaks of caste based discrimination. The caste system itself was introduced in india when we were colonozed by britishers. The british census commisioner Herbert Risley was the first person to divide the society on the basis of caste. He wrote down the casts and then arranged them according to hierarchy which was later imposed as laws in india. History of india is 5000 years old. Many greek roman and chinese historians had visited india and wrote about the life styles but no one had ever mentioned any caste system in india and even the old indian books never ever talked about caste system
This is a man who should have been put behind bars way back. Your forum's tnc stops me to slam him with Bhartiya Gaaliyaan....... But he certainly deserves what i want address him with.
Ask this gentleman why Congress isnt doing do it in the states where it is in power to start with.....
Caste census will go a long way to further consolidate the caste hierarchy. It is likely that people down the line will ask for reservation in jobs etc proportional to their numbers. This does violence against article 14 of the constitution. This is against the vision of making india a casteless society. It's a retrograde and stereotype of thinking .
Informative 👍
Reinforcing caste identities is as sinister as reinforcing our religious identities.
What's the purpose of the caste census ? Further, what about Christian, Muslims etc?
The first caste census was conducted by british in the year 1931 and that exposed the hollowness of the claim made by the minority castes cabal of bamman +bania+kshatri that they are majority when actually their total share in the population was merely 15% but they cheatingly controlled 80% of power and wealth. This proportion has gone down further due to better health care and monopoly over wealth and power. Therefore these minority privileged castes are opposing caste census fearing exposure and consequential backlash from the bahujan castes who have been kept deprived since the days of varnashram reservations as ordained under manusmriti
Then why Nehru stopped it in 1951 ? The whole program behind caste census is to divide the hindus which are getting consolidated and it the script of George Soros which Rahul gandhi is following.
We will have separate country for upper caste wait for it
@@aniketsingh-iw7lq : that country will be doomed because of ur uselessness…..
@@123xyzabccba hAhh.. we ruled this country 5000 yrs and 75 yrs since independence as per your all.
Why would it fail... Keep your 4000 jaatis infested with reservation virus and fight... We are out ..
@@aniketsingh-iw7lq : That country already exists by the name Kailasa and the founder is your saint called nityanand 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂pls migrate asap
Mr Yadav, whom I respect a lot is being clever with his words.
See the problem is only in north and particularly in Bihar and UP. The states which are responsible for maximum population growth and anarchy. In rest of India, where population is controlled and social peace has been there since decades, why take up new issues. We in other parts of India are progressing nicely.
So please do not burden us with your failures
You are such a lazy person with Lazy argument. If those states can listen to your sarcasm and hate and become progressive then I could understand. You have a third grade attitude towards solving a problem. No nation has become great nation by hating and blasting against poor people. Poor people does not have way to put condoms(social, money etc issue) so they produce more. And you a great philosopher trying to be smartest person on earth by just taunting they will become progressive ?
@@anupammajmudar6752 : The virus of castes has affected the whole nation hence it’s necessary to dissect this virus so that curative measures could be effectively taken ……
You can't compete or identify merit with any country or persons as long as Dronacharya's as masters and Ekalavya 's are there every where and at all levels in this country
Yadav ,Kurmi ,bhi obc mein aate hai jo bahut sampann hai up bihar mein aur unka political representation bhi achcha hai .unko nikalo obc se aur phir sahi se affirmative action kaam karega. Similarly sc st subcategorisation aur sc st creamy layer Lagana chahiye jisse reservation ka faida valmiki aur Musahar samaj ko bhi mile. Rohini commission ne kha hai Sirf 25% jaati 97% jobs le jaa rhi aur usme bhi sirf yadav kurmi milkar up Bihar mein 90% job kha rahe . Aur dusri jaati moorkh bn rhi h.
Bihar caste survey check krle😅
Padney ji ko janam se jati manni hai, janam se jati dekh kar ristedari nibhani hai lekin reservation mai Creamy layer chahiye😂 btw central cabinet outrightly rejected the bogus idea of Creamy layer in sc and st aur yadav kurmi bihar mai 90% reservation le hie nhi skte kyunki wha sub categorisation hai OBC aur EBC ki, ye propaganda wala chooran kisi aur ko chatana
రాహులు లాంటి నేత దేశానికి చాలా అవసరం
Instead of focussing on individual rights as equal ciitzens these people want a census so that birth based discrimination by the state can continue for short term political gain
the statute of Gandhi you have in the background will certainly oppose caste census, poona pact clearly indicates his intentions
Another myth that needs to be shattered is what the Mandal Commission recimmended. The Mandal Commission clearly recommended a combination of caste and income for creation of opportunities for the disadvantaged. Which is why there are brahmin communities who have been given reservations on the basis of their income levels.
Not only should we not have a caste census but we as Indians should move towards using the indegenous words Varna and Jati instead of caste in discussions and debates. The word caste has its origins in the Portuguese language and as such is a European outlook on Indian society. A caste census would actually reinforce this world view. As a citizen of modern India I reject the legitimacy of the colonial worldview and am more interested in understanding and dealing with our social problems through an indegenious lens. Bhartiya to Bhartiya!
There are 3 lakh plus castes in India. Happy surveying
@@RavindraSinha
How ?
They tell the story that a country with 3 lakh castes is a country with one culture
@@RavindraSinha sinha ji aapne bataya nhi?
@@lokeshgsadhmaya5499 : Every castes has several subcastes ….in bammans the ppl who perform last rites at the crematorium are treated as lowly bammans by other bammans and are outcasted ….
Please explain "wealth redistribution " similarly.
And please do the caste census for Sikhs, Christians, Muslims etc. Also.
Jat Sikhs own a disproportionate amount of the farm land .. lower caste Sikhs do not.
Similarly Ashrafs and Pashmandas in Islam.
The indian pvt sector is guzzling national resources hence it must be made accountable to implement proportional representation…..
please read cast census by kerala govt in 1968 it is on net
Why is it that Yadav would favour a caste census but wouldnt favour a sub categorization of SC and ST??...already we are facing low skilled workforce...instead of putting ur money and time improving that, u are playing with this narrative simply because it gains u votes...already many communities have been given the obc quota and the list have been long.
Caste census is the NRC of the left...NRC is the Caste census of the right...both the wings need to be cut!
Excellent interview @Pooja Pillai.
Excellent analysis
India needs economic growth Mr. Yadav.
Growth without equity, justice and fairness? No. Thank you
@@jojic5048 Can you get justice and equality by dividing the people of this nation ?
The answer is no !
@@indianindian9970 how people will get divided. It's only counting of persons and the caste they belong to. Its upto people that they feel like discriminated, so they should not feel so.
Brow India needs Development. Not growth.
@@anonymous-2172
If it does not create differences among people, then why reservation is made only depending on caste? Why caste census is not being done separately in Muslim religion? Why are people from lower communities and upper communities being politicized during elections? This will create more conflict between Brahmins and Dalits. So cast system is not needed at all
Our great social reformers says not to talk about caste ,here this fellow is talking about caste. The media also donot do research just viewed on these jokers,the people who migrate from one state to another born and brought up in another state how much caste benefits they get ,they rise on their own merit
@21:20 so will dominant obc agree to move out of obc quota? Why did this not happen on case of Bihar caste survey where quota was increased but dominant OBC were not out of OBC reservation? Does Rahul Gandhi supports dominant OBC moving out of reservation?
You really think they will even address such questions
@@kumudbartwal : There’s a creamy layer concept which keeps the dominant obc’s out of reservations But there’s no creamy layer for the privileged castes hence those who are rich n powerful keep dominating generations after generations depriving the others ….
Caste census Britishers ne kyon shuru karwaya aur Nehru ne kyon khatam kiya aur abhi rahul gandhi kyon iski baat kar raha hai ? Inn saare sawalon me hi caste census ka saara jawaab hai.
If caste census happens today and population of st,sc and obc comes out to be 9%,20%, and 52% respectively will they get reservation according to it?
Sirf naukari me reservation se kya hoga? Itna kam? Loksabha me bhi reservation karo, fir alag alag desh hi bana lo, sabko apna desh milna chahiye. 4000 caste hain, 4 lakh subcaste. To kamse kam 4000 desh, abadi ke hisab se alag alag, aur fir monority ko alag desh, Khalistan, Mughalistan, Christian country.
@@manishshrivastava5201 bhai leftists ko idea maat de adhe sai zyada pagal hote hai .aaj caste census hogaye toh sc ko 20% reservation, st ko 9% ,obc ko 52 % lekin agr 2nd baar caste census hua aur agr sc,st ya obc ka population kam hogaya toh kya inka reservation kaam hoga?😂
@@skr6644 : sahi picture samne aaygaa…fikar not ….
CREAMY LAYER AND SUBCLASSIFICATION MUST ALSO BE DONE IN OPEN CATEGORY because those castes and ppl are rich and powerful keep monopolising over power and wealth for generations depriving others within the open category and those thus affected vent their anger unjustifiably towards reservations meant for the oppressed castes …..
We have to compete with countries like China, and here we are talking about Castes ? What a shameful thing.
China did not have Manusmriti, to its advantage.
@@manjulashanmugasundaram706 OK I say let us abolish all the caste system. Will all the castes agree ? Manusmriti is some very old scriptures, hardly anybody follows it today.
@@rc2k22 Yes I agree. But the problem is, the savarnas will keep enforcing theri biases and nepotism while lying that they are not enforcing it.
@@rc2k22 will the Brahmin accept such a proposal? None will support including the Kshatriyas. Anti-Caste movement didn't achieve their desired end goal.
@@black__monk400 🤣 Forget the Brahmins, even the SC / ST communities will not accept to give away their castes, because it will also mean giving away Reservations and Job Quotas
You are speaking so much on caste census, even after 75year of indipendenc, what congress did when their government was in power . Mr. Yaadav just wooing Rahul Gandhi
19:29 This is a complete U-turn. When the slogans were raised they were raised as 'Jitni Aabadi Utna Haq' - What Salim Yadav says here is completely opposite.
People have been opposed to the Caste Census since last year because on multiple occasions Rahul Gandhi and various proponents have openly asked for reservations in the private sector. Add to this the caste-based wealth survey that the same people were shouting. THESE ARE THE TWO MAIN REASONS PEOPLE ARE OPPOSING IT.
What Salim Yadav is saying is completely different and IMO opposite of what the likes of Rahul Gandhi and co are braying non-stop.
Stop shifting the goalposts and stop bullsh*tting!
You want caste but don’t want caste census 😂😂😂
@@123xyzabccba I neither want caste nor caste census.
@@HRC294 : so first abolish caste and then there will not b any need for caste census …: soooooooo simple …isn’t it 🥴😂🥴
@@123xyzabccba Do it please! I am all in for it.
How will we do this?
Which political party or movement asks for the abolition of caste?
You cannot have caste quotas and caste abolition at the same time. Right?
@@HRC294 : Caste came first with varnashram reservations for bammans and constitutional reservations followed …so that which came first must also go first …isn’t it …..The products of 3 000 yrs of varnashram reservations are shit scared of the products of 70+ years of constitutional reservations 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
मैं कहता हूं मंडल स्वयं ओबीसी से आते थे
तो क्यों न सवर्ण का भी एक कमीशन घोषित किया जाए जिसकी चेयरमैन कोई सबर्ण ही हो
दूसरी बात अगर किसी को भी क्लास 8 की मैथ्स भी आती हो तो कैलकुलेट कर के बताए की एक कैंडिडेट को अपनी लाइफ में एडमिशन, फॉर्म ,स्कॉलरशिप ,हॉस्टल आदि आदि कई जगह आरक्षण मिलता है तो इसका cumulative effect कितना हो जाता है और इस वजह से एक अनारक्षित कैंडिडेट लाभ की स्थिति में कितना पीछे चला जाता है
तीसरी बात उस नागरिक की क्या गलती है जिसकी पूर्वजों ने भेदभाव किया होगा,,(हालांकि लोग राजाराम मोहन राय ईश्वर चंद्र विद्या सागर आदि आदिअनेक महान आत्माओं को नही याद करते )
Ussi Mandal ne 10% EWS bhi recomend kiya tha jisko BJP ne laagu kiya hai aur shadi ristedari toh aaj bhi jaat dekh kar hoti hai kyu sara theekra purvajon par daal rhe ho koi bhut sudhar nhi hua hai abhi
@@Vajra98 वही तो माननीय उच्चतम न्यायालय ने कह दिया कि दलित के अंदर महादलित और पिछड़ों के अंदर अतिपिछड़े हैं तो कुछ लोग कोर्ट पर ही भड़क गए
बात रही शादी की तो ये सबका अधिकार है आप किसकी शादी जबरन थोड़ी करवा सकते
@@Vajra9810% Mandal na Nahi Diya ha Woh modi na aapna aap Diya tha sinhoo commission banaya Gaya tha manmohan Ka time ma but SC/st / obc na virodh Kiya tha
Yogendra is a paid anarchist .
He gives ull 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Caste census is the need of hours
What Yogendra Yadav fails to answer is that tomorrow if the caste census shows that 90% of people in this country are Dalits, will you recommend 90% Reservation Job Quota ?
If 90 % of the dalits have.less than 20 % of income and wealth..them ofcourse there is a problem..our nation has to move forward.. taking everyone together..on d oder side..if 90 % are dalits..and they hold atleast 50 % of resources..then the discussion will be to do away with reservation or reduce..its a fair ask.
Caste census can work both ways..but we need data.what our people r doing
@@mohithpm4954 Dhirubhai Ambani who built the Ambani empire studied till 7th Standard, and transitioned from rags to riches. This shows that India gives opportunities to even underprivileged people. So this argument of wealth distribution is farce.
Padha karu jhaant bhar,Arakshan maangu raat bhar🤙
@@rc2k22 Okay, then ideally you should have studied till 7th Standard, started your own enterprise, and by now been the path to being a successful entrepreneur, instead of being insecure about your jobs being taken away by reservations, right? I mean, if with all your privilege and education you haven't succeeded yet, it's your incompetence no?? If Ambani sr. was able to do it with much less?
@@mohantysobhi There are so many Dalit self employed people who don't need Reservations. I am not much worried about my job being snatched, I am more worried about Merit being sidelined in this whole Reservations business
You all need to start caring and loving your country Bharatvarsh ..Yadav is a anti india person we all know ..muslim with a hindu name thus his leanings ..sadly .
Mad or what.
Living in bubble of those 20% one sidedly dominant in social print n tv news medias. And in generational business inheritances property education jobs and so opportunity while giving directly indirectly to openly and hideously for others to enter job education or other place.
@@ankit5820issue who was living in the bubble of your imaginary world , forgot that they are so called mosts of print social media are under € hinese Soros funded , education job are always should be based on merit and hot based on the reservation
@@ankit5820first learn the reality
@@pedadasiddardha9655 unlearn the learning you got from from generational beliefs unlearn social ecological cultural educational COLLECTIVE Previlege.
Unlearn the misinformation and propaganda what beds in minds of u n ppl from dominance of Savarnas in Print TV news n suicidal Medias. Along with dominance in every place. It's coz of previlege.
Brits aren't ahead just becoz of skills the skills n education industry market capture they got from Previlege of Racism N Imperialism, their Colonies in world for centuries.
Sharma being Sharma.
Can distribute certificate of nationalism.
All the piddis tell me what will be the next step after the caste census is done. Is there any plan to increase the reservation quota to above 50%. Why caste census Hindus only, why not of Muslims ? There are many backward classes in muslims.
Hey Yadhav & Pillai,
As long as you are that, you are not going to accept the caste census idea. But why the hell you claim as intellects? Funny😂😂😂One should search where its lost. Privileges lost in the name of caste should be resolved in the name of caste. No other way😂😂😂😂
Learn from Tamilnadu guys😂😂😂😂 ask PTR, he will teach you 😂😂😂