One cannot simply say this is best in case of Choosing one between Carnatic and Western music. Both are almost like learning a new language and they are equally appreciable.. If a kid is interested in music they can choose either of those two. Whatever they learn let them learn happily...And that's the best opinion I can give.
Learning violin (from Western classical music standpoint) is like planting a bamboo tree. One needs to play for years continuously to get a sweet sound. It takes anywhere between 10-15 years to professionally play stuff, all the techniques. The investment is also a huge factor, you need to keep upgrading your instrument as your level keeps increasing. A good French violin costs about USD 2500.
Can same violin instrument be used for learning both western and classical? I got a second hand violin from carnatic player and I am learning western style
Can a same violin be used in western and Carnatic?? I'm learning Carnatic for about 6 months. I was interested in western too. So I bought another violin. Both violin sounds different. My interest in learning Western is no more. So that's why I'm asking. The brand of violin that I bought for learning Western is Havana.
Nice video brother. Could you make a video on how to use a Carnatic background to make pop music? Can’t find anyone doing this. If we can find a way to bring Carnatic music to mass appeal, it will be massu.
Saravana Violinist thank u for the quick reply! And is it essential for us to buy a costly violin ? And upto how much? Currently i am a beginner so i have bought the indian made one!
Hello Bro... I am a carnatic violin learner.... I want to buy E shruthi strings ... but those are different from the EADG for western right....so how to buy.... so should i buy e3 b3 and e4 b4....is that right
Use the same GDAE (Western)strings for Carnatic..G and D remains the same...Use tuning pegs to change A and E to G and D.. so it becomes GDGD(Carnatic)
It takes so much time to play in 3rd position in case of Western Violin. You cannot simply go to 3rd position unless you play in tune with your 1st position..Even playing in tune in case of 1st position takes so much time if you are a beginner.. Whereas in carnatic their is no such thing called 1st 3rd or 5th position...Even the basic lessons like Geetham(basic songs) consist of all kind of notes which are considered difficult to reach in Western music..And that's why you can see most of the carnatic Violinist playing in 3rd position often..
@@saravanaviolinist1215 Thank you for the explanation. Video was very helpful. How many days will it take to tune a simple movie song for a beginner in western violin and in carnatic violin?
I want u r opinion . Which is the best for kids. carnatic r western
One cannot simply say this is best in case of Choosing one between Carnatic and Western music. Both are almost like learning a new language and they are equally appreciable..
If a kid is interested in music they can choose either of those two. Whatever they learn let them learn happily...And that's the best opinion I can give.
I think western is difficult but that is most powerfull
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thank you for the information and I loved your explanations .
Very nice Saravana. Simple and useful.
Learning violin (from Western classical music standpoint) is like planting a bamboo tree. One needs to play for years continuously to get a sweet sound. It takes anywhere between 10-15 years to professionally play stuff, all the techniques. The investment is also a huge factor, you need to keep upgrading your instrument as your level keeps increasing. A good French violin costs about USD 2500.
Exactly. Do u know any good ones in India that can be played in a western style? I've had a beginner one for 7 years and I want an upgrade
Thala explain to high and medium strings difference
Master you are awesome. Saravana what a fabulous name.
Thala iam struggling for finger change any idea
Practice makes perfect in all cases
Yass!!!
Anna songs la difference sollunga....like cine songs la ethu kathukuta easy carnatic uh western uh?
Hi sir.my child interested in music he is 8 years old.carnatic or western musicwhich is suitable for 8 years kid sir?
Can same violin instrument be used for learning both western and classical?
I got a second hand violin from carnatic player and I am learning western style
Yes u can..But need to change tuning to sa pa sa pa..
What type of violin do you use?
I have Acoustic Violin. Other than that there are semi acoustic and Electric Violins.
Bridge shape... Position . Pathi oru vdo panunga bro .....
Sure I'll do!!✌️
Can a same violin be used in western and Carnatic??
I'm learning Carnatic for about 6 months. I was interested in western too. So I bought another violin. Both violin sounds different. My interest in learning Western is no more. So that's why I'm asking.
The brand of violin that I bought for learning Western is Havana.
I want to play movie songs which one I study carnatic or western
You can play movie songs by learning either Western or Carnatic music...
Only thing differs is playing method..
Can I use the same tuning of the strings(GDAE) if I wanted to play a carnatic song on the violin
No you need to change
Nice video brother. Could you make a video on how to use a Carnatic background to make pop music? Can’t find anyone doing this. If we can find a way to bring Carnatic music to mass appeal, it will be massu.
Sure bro ! Thank you for suggesting..✌️
Saravana Violinist I’ll be looking forward to it bro
Tamil song oda example soluga bro please
Clasical and carnatic are same..??
Indian Classical means Carnatic music
Western Classical means - Western music
Is there a difference between carnatic and western violins??
Can the indian made violins be used for western music?
No there is no difference..You can use same Violin to play both
Saravana Violinist thank u for the quick reply!
And is it essential for us to buy a costly violin ? And upto how much?
Currently i am a beginner so i have bought the indian made one!
Good for now.. keep practicing with what you have..✌️
Hello Bro... I am a carnatic violin learner.... I want to buy E shruthi strings ... but those are different from the EADG for western right....so how to buy.... so should i buy e3 b3 and e4 b4....is that right
Use the same GDAE (Western)strings for Carnatic..G and D remains the same...Use tuning pegs to change A and E to G and D.. so it becomes GDGD(Carnatic)
@@saravanaviolinist1215 thanks for the fine point
Tq ....
Welcome 👍
@@saravanaviolinist1215 bro.. keetham epdi vaacikkanum nu oru video podunga bro... Plz...
Sure bro..!! I'll do..✌️
Hii Saravana. Could you please explain me in English about 3rd position, 1st position which you discussed at the end.
It takes so much time to play in 3rd position in case of Western Violin. You cannot simply go to 3rd position unless you play in tune with your 1st position..Even playing in tune in case of 1st position takes so much time if you are a beginner..
Whereas in carnatic their is no such thing called 1st 3rd or 5th position...Even the basic lessons like Geetham(basic songs) consist of all kind of notes which are considered difficult to reach in Western music..And that's why you can see most of the carnatic Violinist playing in 3rd position often..
@@saravanaviolinist1215 Thank you for the explanation. Video was very helpful. How many days will it take to tune a simple movie song for a beginner in western violin and in carnatic violin?
It depends on your practice..For me it took around 1year.
If possible watch my 2 years progress Video..You may get a clear answer..😊
@@saravanaviolinist1215 Sure Saravana... Thank you so much
Is it possible to learn violin through UA-cam?
You can try..but as a beginner it's tough
Violin la carnatic & western style matitum dhan irruka bro
Hindustan eruku nu nanaikuren..North side la learn pannuvanga
@@saravanaviolinist1215 oh. Bro 👍
whats ur insta ID?