@@kevincarr3213 and they usually say how controversial and difficult a question it is. And I'm a man and can answer it simply as adult human female. And an adult human female can't define woman. It's beyond disturbing what has become of women.
@@paulj2948 Exactly what I was going to say a an Adult female human, I confess I'm an overthinker but these women take overthinking to a level so excessive it becomes impossible to decipher!
I love how if you ask random women to describe what a man is they all will jump for joy to gladly tell you their opinion of what a “ real man “ is but the second you ask them to describe what a woman is all of sudden they all have this blank confused 🤨 faces and try to hurry up and scramble for an answer lol
It's a psychological tactic used to demoralize American men because American men are the vanguard against this toxic feminist bullshit, but we can't be that if we're all so broken by the discourse that we just don't fucking care anymore. That's why that is. America can't be destroyed from the outside.
Because you asked all the women this question? Why is a married man or woman 🤭 going up to random women on net and getting in their faces in public asking them, what is that are you a woman? You are conducting proper statistical.sociological research I gather or just acting apish towards innocent and unsuspecting random females? I thought saying goes ask a stupid question ... that might explain the detailed responses you get in response maam or mista 🤷♂️🤷🏻♀️
In her defence as she appears to have nerves. I would give her a second chance to clarify her opinions. They made a point of her being catholic not just because shes a eoman she was put on spot for her religious views on women.
@@heartofpuregold are there any women here ? ( monty python yhe life of Brian) 😆. Fear not I'm deeply familiar with Catholic girls sure isn't my mother one ( irish accent) .. In fairness to the girl is is very nerve racking to do any public speaking. Or performing, singing a speech. Ect Your all nervous energy. Especially with this big an audience. And a hostile environment. Or a group with strong personalities. You know yourself just a group of women having a conversation with a mix of ages and opinion it's a min field. I think as well. She might have a mild case of anxiety ( social) or a little ocd . . One big flaw in her idea. Her plan. Broadcasting the plan on the whatever podcast would defeat the purpose. You would need to conspire in private. Then implement it. And like feminism a hundred year later people would be sitting in a room like this talking about it . I think in a room with less people like a on vs one she would do much better or have more time to explain herself. What bothered me was when people were trying to agree or define a problem she was jumping to a solution. She needed to keep her power dry . ( patience is a virtue)
Im a old man. Things were easier when I was young. Men were men. Women were Women. I pity my grandchildren living in this complex world. Good luck with all this.
@@jamesredacher1987 You are obviously young. I'm American, we boomers had no more control over our rulers than you have over our current rulers. If you believe otherwise, than you have been deceived. To believe that your grandparents are to blame for this situation, shows the power of propaganda. The problems are from the Banks, Corporations, Oligarchs, Hollywood, and corrupt Rulers. You may want do some research on the last 100 years in this country.
Our public education is basically meant to dumb down and brain wash the youth. They want the people just educated enough to push some buttons on a smart phone and use a credit card.
This is the simplest question to answer, but these girl's dance around it, like it's some complexed math equation or something. All of the people responsible for these kids thinking like this, are pure evil. I swear, every time I listen to one of these youngsters give their take on these types of subjects, I feel like I'm in a parallel universe or something! I never thought people could be this brainwashed and think like this. It's hella weird!
@@Inquisitor6321 because everyone answers according to what they know to be true at the time. People can change their minds and opinions. A definition is a definition. The woman is the biological sociological adult human female possessing xx chromosome by gender and that is given at conception by her father. We are talking about the vocations of women ie motherhood, sisterhood, career, educations, status , gender roles etc. Thats what you have control over as a woman. Nicole clarified her position according to her understanding. She hasnt committed a felony... okay Nicoles allowed to think and she doesnt officially represent the catholic church its her own views which shes entitled to express under the USA laws.
@@heartofpuregold You're working under the assumption that there is enough room for doubt to the definition of a woman. No, the definition of a woman is an adult female, one that is born with xx chromosome. A trans woman is not a woman, trans woman does not menstruate, does not have period, does not birth another human being. There is no room for debate on what defines a woman or a man, not even with "what they know to be true at that time". Using sporting events is a great example, trans women should never be allowed to compete in the women division against other women, that gives them an unfair advantage over other women who fought for the right to have their own space. Trans women should not be allowed in the women's bathroom either, or in their locker room, especially if the girls are underage.
The Public schools have not failed from their point of view, they want these girls to answer exactly the way they did! There is a Worldwide conspiracy to brainwash and lie about men and women!
the reason it’s such a stubborn mystery is because it’s not a clear answer. what’s a Christian? is it someone who follows Jesus’ teachings? because two people can both be Christian and believe in different interpretations of what Jesus taught. is someone not a Christian if they sin? everybody sins. can a baby not be a Christian? the baby doesn’t understand enough to follow Jesus. can mentally disabled people not be Christian? my point is, that like the word “woman” the word Christian has nuance that can’t be wholly AND concisely defined. you have to sacrifice clarity and total accuracy for conciseness, but because this is in the context of a discussion, we lean towards the nuance for the sake of the discussion.
@@nicolehicks6555anyone who can't answer a simple question like what is a woman without being circular or blabbering word salad shouldn't be taken seriously.
Who is the loud woman wearing black, sitting next to the blue top blonde woman? I like her voice, its loud and firm and she speaks truth. Her voice is loud because she knows she's making sense and she's speaking truth, we need more women like her. She's cooking.
Emirate chuck is one . I can name several that I know It's remarkably easy to find a large number of them. Name one is a ridiculous question. Plenty of cardinals and Bishops snd priests . I can name any number of Catholics that support abortion and have done so on msm
@@heartofpuregold In the wake of the Harrison Butker speech I've seen hundreds of Catholics-in-name-only posting. A lot of supposed Catholics who don't know what a vocation is, what the Church's position on IVF is, etc.
@@wolfofthewest8019 They were not born knowing all. Catholics in name only. Who are you to judge them are they debating you then go debate them People have a right to learn the faith and grow in grace its the reason why teachers exist they teach the faith they study and they catechise. I dont see how you can call a fellow catholic fake. Are you alleging they sin, well guess what buddy show me one person not sinning and you will see this earth vacate. Why you are worry about people who are not talking to you? They are talking to Harrison. Then he can address them himself on his own platform. I think hes great we needmore godly youth good men to root out allthese evildoers
@@heartofpuregold They have a right to learn the faith, that is true. But if they don't exercise that right and run around telling people what Catholics believe from a position of ignorance, I'm going to call them out on it.
@@rmp5s it's not redundant because one of their main counter arguments, is not all women can have kids. Which makes them crazy as far as I'm concerned.
Literally you burry a trans woman and a "Straight male" in a casket shaped like a heart together in 100 years the scientists aren't looking at them and saying "hm this looks like a gay couple but it could be straight if one of these guys identified as a woman" they're calling it a gay couple
I had a debate with a Leftist UA-camr about this topic. He argued the side of “T-women are women, gender and sex are not the same, you are a woman if you identify as one, and being a woman is about the roles/expectations you fulfill and not your biology” etc. I argued the opposite side of this and presented him with the following thought experiment: For the sake of argument, let’s initially function under the premise that they are correct, sex and gender ARE seperate. “Male and Female” are terms that refer to biological sex, and “Man and Woman” are terms that refer to gender. Now let’s layout 3 possible ways that it can be determined what makes someone a Man or Woman. The 3 possibilities we will look at are: • Biology • Self-Identification • Roles/Expectations So now let's say that I, a biological male, in my every day life were to have long hair, put on make-up, wear dresses and high heels, work as a Nanny, and I'm a homemaker in my relationship. I am as non-masculine as possible, and I fulfill these roles and expectations so well that I am typically perceived as a woman by others. But in spite of ALL of that I still call myself, and tell others that I AM A MAN. Now we FINALLY have something everyone agrees on. I call myself a man, and both sides of this topic agree that I am a man. The Conservative side agrees I'm a man because I am a biological male. Leftists agree I am a man because that is what I identify as. (The UA-camr agreed I would be a man) So now what we can determine is that "Roles/Expectations" are NOT what makes you a man or woman. If they were, how would it be possible for me to be considered a man while fulfilling none of the gender roles/expectations of a man in appearance or lifestyle? How can a woman still be considered a woman when she fulfills none of the roles/expectations of a woman in appearance or lifestyle? If this was truly the determining factor, this should not be possible. So let's cross "Roles/Expectations" off of our possible determinates. In regards to Self-Identification, it should be intuitively obvious that someone's words do not determine reality; I can say I am anything, but that doesn't make it true. I can say I am a refrigerator, but I am clearly not a refrigerator. When I SAY I am a man, even IF it is true, it is not the thing that determines WHY it is true. So let's cross off "Self-Identification" from our possible determinates. All I am left with now is to believe that my Biology IS what makes me a man. It makes perfect sense, the anatomical make-up that is my physical being determines the objective reality of WHAT I am. It should be clear now why these arguments to the contrary are absurd. And so with that I believe I have succinctly shown why Biology is what determines your sex/gender, and why the 2 terms are in fact the same thing. After I made this point the UA-camr refused to engage with it, and shortly after stopped responding 😂
i don’t believe in self-id. i believe that you are essentially what other people say you are. so you have to maintain that roles and expectations are a factor. You can call yourself a man all you want but if you’re living as a woman, you’re essentially a woman.
@@nicolehicks6555 If your a man, living like a woman, you are just a confused man. Even if you do everything to try to look like a woman, you are never going to be a woman.
@@nicolehicks6555 Is what other people say you are not invalid for the same reason self-ID is? Its still just someones words or thoughts, which have no inherent bearing on reality, the only difference is it's other peoples instead of your own. Even if that was the case, you still have to contend with the fact that not everyone would agree on what they see you as. If you are a T-woman who people know to be (T) or can easily tell that you are, then there are people who will see you as a man. If other peoples perception of you is what determines what you are, this would not only include people who see you as a woman, it would also include those who dont. If that’s what we’re left with it seems really messy and unhelpful to determine what you are based on other peoples opinions, because those will conflict. I dont see how that would be more proper to determine WHAT you are than your actual physical being would be. This way of thinking in essence views "woman" as an adjective, when it is very clearly a noun based on its usage in language. This is why you would say "She is a woman" and not "She is very woman".... A "Woman" is a THING, not a descriptor.
@@nicolehicks6555If babies couldn’t tell the difference between men and women, you wouldn’t be here. Because your ancestors would have starved to death in infancy.
It actually is annoying when people say race is a social construct. We wouldn't have genetic markers that differentiate us. I'm mixed and I look white but I can't deny my African genetics because they are there.
Our society today shows us we have too much free time on our hands to think about such things. In the past there was work to be done, everyone accepted their roles as men and women , we’ve become spoiled and have taken things for granted, you don’t know what you got til it’s gone.
Just because a person goes to Holy Mother Church, does not mean the have been properly catechized or formed. Which is no different then anything else. She "identifies" as Catholic. Big difference than practicing Catholicism.
@@jahwoo6292 there is evil everywhere, and evil within the church is condemned by everyone in it, and if it isn't then they need to, though most commit worse and it is ignored
@@heartofpuregold I agree, but I will also say, that when it comes to more wokeness and politics talk, staying Traditional is also naturally staying away from wokeness and the like of it. I myself can't debate a stranger without my heart racing, though I do like to debate family and friends at times, but I understand the stress, I will of course give another chance, as I think everyone needs more than just a second chance, but we can't give in to wokeness in any way at all, including having to strictly define what women are.
@@stryder6253 Ignore her she's made a ton of comments getting angry at anybody daring to say this girl is a fake catholic. She even said that it was "nerves" that made her say these things.
--------> Remember fellas. Rachel censored me off pearls comments because I was telling men that I proved alimony and child support are voluntary payments in January 2008...
Not child support both of you made the child/ ren exist therefore both of you should contribute. Alimony is not required once one is divorced it comes by negotiating on the financial orders there are parenting and financial property orders separate matters at least in Australia dont know other country
@@heartofpuregold Both Alimony and child support are voluntary payments. I proved this in January 2008. In a court. Rachel does not want men to know this.
@@heartofpuregold FYI. I have run cases in the US, Canada, Ireland, UK, Australia and NZ. In every case I have run the courts have agreed alimony and child support are voluntary payments. This is not an opinion. It is a proven fact.
@@heartofpuregold "therefore both of you should contribute". Mothers are under no obligation to contribute to their children and never have been in the history of mankind. So why should men have any obligation? Hm?
@@PeterNolan-009 absolute lies you didnt run any case in Australia as a lawyer nor where you a represented politician its legislated to pay child support until a child turns 18 by the childs recognised father. That person is not the live with parent fulltime so in the event of the divorce break up its the live with parent who shoulders all the responsibility of raising the child and are often precluded from earning an income because of that fact. The other party has the ability to earn a fulltime income without day to day care of the child. Its the childs needs first.
6:55 biggest problem with having these conversations with college attendees is that they want to sound smart at all costs. They're not humble enough to say "you know what, I don't know or I don't know how to answer that"
As a Sociologist who used to be a leftie, I offer my sincerest apologies for my contribution, direct or indirect, to the mainstreaming of this kind of thinking. Rest assured I am doing what I can to the reverse the damage I have done. May God have mercy on my soul.
Men and women are different by nature. We look different, think different, move different, sound different, smell different... That's why when you see a dude trying to look like a lady, you know something is off. It's intuitive. It's in our DNA.
Hearing the question & not being able to answer it with a simple answer is always a red flag to me. Like this shit, by definition, is not rocket science. Changing the narrative to fit your argument is an automatic lose!
The high maintenance blonde in the big clear glasses doesn’t even understand what is being said. She is more worried about her makeup and appearance. She started getting ready on Wednesday to go out Friday.
Imagine spending this amount of time in bettering the world, raising a child - these people spent hours and hours trying to dissect and “prove” how a t-woman is a woman
The million dollar question, what is a woman, stumps them every time 😂😂 I remember when people knew the answer to such a simple question and didn’t hesitate when they answered, what has our world come too wow
I think pink shirt was getting Gender and Gender Identity mixed up, its funny that the supporters of the theory don't actually understand the basics of it.
The only thing I will say is- Everyone needs to learn how to get their points across without personally disrespecting the other individuals. Just have the conversation & leave your emotions at the door. These are good conversations & it’s not a PERSONAL attack.
Brian should ask the question about dating a trans-person with reversed roles to pose it on the girls: If a girl dates a trans-woman, is "S the D" a lesbian act?
It's astonishing that women are afraid to define a woman. Actually fearful. Sad.
And they are the ones that will not speak out, fight back against men invading their sports and other areas.
Caitlyn Jenner was given woman of the year and never had a period. Real women should be pissed.
@@kevincarr3213 and they usually say how controversial and difficult a question it is. And I'm a man and can answer it simply as adult human female. And an adult human female can't define woman. It's beyond disturbing what has become of women.
@@paulj2948 Exactly what I was going to say a an Adult female human, I confess I'm an overthinker but these women take overthinking to a level so excessive it becomes impossible to decipher!
Astonishing is the best descriptor you used, and the consequences are, not surprisingly, profound-LY BAD!
I love how if you ask random women to describe what a man is they all will jump for joy to gladly tell you their opinion of what a “ real man “ is but the second you ask them to describe what a woman is all of sudden they all have this blank confused 🤨 faces and try to hurry up and scramble for an answer lol
So true!
You hit the nail on the head 💯
It's a psychological tactic used to demoralize American men because American men are the vanguard against this toxic feminist bullshit, but we can't be that if we're all so broken by the discourse that we just don't fucking care anymore. That's why that is. America can't be destroyed from the outside.
Because you asked all the women this question? Why is a married man or woman 🤭 going up to random women on net and getting in their faces in public asking them, what is that are you a woman?
You are conducting proper statistical.sociological research I gather or just acting apish towards innocent and unsuspecting random females?
I thought saying goes ask a stupid question ... that might explain the detailed responses you get in response maam or mista 🤷♂️🤷🏻♀️
@@heartofpuregold huh? lol
We need to either sue the education system or tear it down and start over again.
Absolutely! Time to start over!
She’s not a true catholic if she says all that garbage.
In her defence as she appears to have nerves. I would give her a second chance to clarify her opinions. They made a point of her being catholic not just because shes a eoman she was put on spot for her religious views on women.
Agreed
@@heartofpuregold no. nervouseness is lack of security.
Catholicism is Luciferianism/Gnosticism so yes she’s a true Catholic.
@@heartofpuregold are there any women here ? ( monty python yhe life of Brian) 😆.
Fear not I'm deeply familiar with Catholic girls sure isn't my mother one ( irish accent) ..
In fairness to the girl is is very nerve racking to do any public speaking. Or performing, singing a speech. Ect
Your all nervous energy. Especially with this big an audience. And a hostile environment. Or a group with strong personalities.
You know yourself just a group of women having a conversation with a mix of ages and opinion it's a min field.
I think as well. She might have a mild case of anxiety ( social) or a little ocd . .
One big flaw in her idea. Her plan. Broadcasting the plan on the whatever podcast would defeat the purpose. You would need to conspire in private. Then implement it. And like feminism a hundred year later people would be sitting in a room like this talking about it .
I think in a room with less people like a on vs one she would do much better or have more time to explain herself.
What bothered me was when people were trying to agree or define a problem she was jumping to a solution. She needed to keep her power dry . ( patience is a virtue)
She is hesitating so much that its obvious she is terrified of telling the truth
100%
APART FROM HER KNOWING SHE IS A
BIOLOGICAL FEMALE....
SHE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT A WOMAN IS;
LET ALONE KNOW WHAT A WOMAN
EMBODIES.
♠️THE VANITY ADDICT♠️
The righteous are bold as a lion. She does not look like a faithful Catholic if she hesitates to tell the truth.
Im a old man. Things were easier when I was young.
Men were men.
Women were Women.
I pity my grandchildren living in this complex world.
Good luck with all this.
The world isn't much more complex than it was. It's just that we are living in an inverted reality that is trying to make people believe 2+2=5
It's still that simple, some people are just morons.
Your generation is who put this all together for us. Thanks for that!
@@susanwojcickisnicetwin LOL! Good user name.
@@jamesredacher1987
You are obviously young. I'm American, we boomers had no more control over our rulers than you have over our current rulers.
If you believe otherwise, than you have been deceived.
To believe that your grandparents are to blame for this situation, shows the power of propaganda.
The problems are from the Banks, Corporations, Oligarchs, Hollywood, and corrupt Rulers.
You may want do some research on the last 100 years in this country.
Our Education has failed us
Really it did exactly what they wanted it to do they infiltrated and made it this way in purpose..started around the 1950s and spread like a cancer
Their education has failed them.
education has engineered this to destroy us
Our public education is basically meant to dumb down and brain wash the youth.
They want the people just educated enough to push some buttons on a smart phone and use a credit card.
By design
This is the simplest question to answer, but these girl's dance around it, like it's some complexed math equation or something. All of the people responsible for these kids thinking like this, are pure evil. I swear, every time I listen to one of these youngsters give their take on these types of subjects, I feel like I'm in a parallel universe or something! I never thought people could be this brainwashed and think like this. It's hella weird!
Someday I think these women who can't define what a woman is, that they will be embarrassed by the answers they gave here.
Nahh. we all know that females won't admit that they were or are wrong.
Can't hurt the feelings of transformers, it's all about them and newspeak created for them.
@@heartofpuregold Why not??
@@Inquisitor6321 because everyone answers according to what they know to be true at the time. People can change their minds and opinions. A definition is a definition. The woman is the biological sociological adult human female possessing xx chromosome by gender and that is given at conception by her father. We are talking about the vocations of women ie motherhood, sisterhood, career, educations, status , gender roles etc. Thats what you have control over as a woman.
Nicole clarified her position according to her understanding. She hasnt committed a felony... okay Nicoles allowed to think and she doesnt officially represent the catholic church its her own views which shes entitled to express under the USA laws.
@@heartofpuregold You're working under the assumption that there is enough room for doubt to the definition of a woman. No, the definition of a woman is an adult female, one that is born with xx chromosome. A trans woman is not a woman, trans woman does not menstruate, does not have period, does not birth another human being. There is no room for debate on what defines a woman or a man, not even with "what they know to be true at that time".
Using sporting events is a great example, trans women should never be allowed to compete in the women division against other women, that gives them an unfair advantage over other women who fought for the right to have their own space. Trans women should not be allowed in the women's bathroom either, or in their locker room, especially if the girls are underage.
Wow the public schools have failed these people. We need to give the schools back to the states and cancel the department of education wow
Remember, fee mails got rid of all the real men from the schools decades ago.
Please 🙏
Pretty sure about that
No its the soft mfs overall that grew up then spewed the fruity bs to their kids to fit the emotions instead of reality
The Public schools have not failed from their point of view, they want these girls to answer exactly the way they did! There is a Worldwide conspiracy to brainwash and lie about men and women!
'A woman is someone who does what women do.'
That doesn't answer the question. We still don't know what an actual woman is. A stubborn mystery.
the reason it’s such a stubborn mystery is because it’s not a clear answer. what’s a Christian? is it someone who follows Jesus’ teachings? because two people can both be Christian and believe in different interpretations of what Jesus taught. is someone not a Christian if they sin? everybody sins. can a baby not be a Christian? the baby doesn’t understand enough to follow Jesus. can mentally disabled people not be Christian? my point is, that like the word “woman” the word Christian has nuance that can’t be wholly AND concisely defined. you have to sacrifice clarity and total accuracy for conciseness, but because this is in the context of a discussion, we lean towards the nuance for the sake of the discussion.
@@nicolehicks6555 Your parents paid all that money for you to come out like, God help us
Yeah, we have to first define what a woman is before we can establish if anyone is behaving like one.
do you want the biological or legal definition?
@@nicolehicks6555anyone who can't answer a simple question like what is a woman without being circular or blabbering word salad shouldn't be taken seriously.
I only made it half way. I could feel my brain cells being damaged
Who is the loud woman wearing black, sitting next to the blue top blonde woman? I like her voice, its loud and firm and she speaks truth. Her voice is loud because she knows she's making sense and she's speaking truth, we need more women like her. She's cooking.
You mean Rachel, Andrew Wilson's wife? 😄
@@ronrhea2001Nah, he means the one on the end of the table by the windows. You know...the loud one in black. lol
The one that couldn’t name a single Led Zeppelin song even though she’s wearing that shirt?
@@missmeesh no you dummies the one in the black sitting next to the blue top blonde woman
@@missmeesh not that one bro …..
Back in the day. We had two words to describe this young woman.
"She's silly"
2 words, air head.
Stupid.
"She's silly" Actually those are three words.
@@kansashoneybadger7899 Actually🤓
I feel like people are starting to say the stuff they have been scared to for a few years now. Good for them.
This is embarrassing to our educational system that WOMEN cannot define a woman! It's OUTRAGEOUS!
We are just a fashion statement to them
What the feck is that girl in the pink Real Madrid shirt talking about??? She probably doesn't even know Real won the Champions League last night...
She’s an idiot. But football sucks anyway.
She doesnt care about being right but she refuses to be wrong.
To have different definitions of something that should b so simple to define is INSANE!!!
There’s so many Catholics by title only walking around on social media lol
Emirate chuck is one . I can name several that I know
It's remarkably easy to find a large number of them.
Name one is a ridiculous question.
Plenty of cardinals and Bishops snd priests .
I can name any number of Catholics that support abortion and have done so on msm
@@heartofpuregold In the wake of the Harrison Butker speech I've seen hundreds of Catholics-in-name-only posting. A lot of supposed Catholics who don't know what a vocation is, what the Church's position on IVF is, etc.
@@wolfofthewest8019 They were not born knowing all. Catholics in name only. Who are you to judge them are they debating you then go debate them People have a right to learn the faith and grow in grace its the reason why teachers exist they teach the faith they study and they catechise. I dont see how you can call a fellow catholic fake. Are you alleging they sin, well guess what buddy show me one person not sinning and you will see this earth vacate. Why you are worry about people who are not talking to you? They are talking to Harrison. Then he can address them himself on his own platform. I think hes great we needmore godly youth good men to root out allthese evildoers
@@heartofpuregold They have a right to learn the faith, that is true. But if they don't exercise that right and run around telling people what Catholics believe from a position of ignorance, I'm going to call them out on it.
@@heartofpuregold You based on your comments on here
For all their talk about patriarchy how ironic is it that they believe men can be women.
"A woman is a woman" is not a definition. "Adult human female"...THAT is a definition.
An adult human female who has, should have (medical reasons) or has had the capacity to give birth
@@Smell_TheGlove Including that second part is redundant.
@@rmp5s it's not redundant because one of their main counter arguments, is not all women can have kids. Which makes them crazy as far as I'm concerned.
@@Smell_TheGlove Just because not all people have 10 toes doesn't change the fact that humans have 10 toes. It doesn't need to be pointed out.
"no marxist teachings in school" no one for a second believes that except those who are on the wrong side.
Accurate.
If you're talking about the lady in black that said that, she was being sarcastic
@@504gucci4 yea I suppose you're right
@@504gucci4She was based, I liked how she did not let the FIFA girl spout her contradictory nonsense.
lol so when I was home with my kids changing diapers for a short while I was a woman???
"I have nipples, Greg. Can you milk me?"
Please repeal the 19th , ASAP.
this title is incorrect, it was *not* Mrs Wilson who corrected the idiot, but that goddess in black sitting center stage.
I’m white and straight I identify as a black woman lesbian
Yaassss slay you beautiful nubian queen 😂
Wakanda forever, queen!
😂😂😂
And two pinguins 😂😂😂
You got my vote for lesbian of Color of the year
Love the look on Rachel's face. It just screams "I am so done with these children!"
I guess some people reduce a woman to a costume.
and others reduce it to just having a vagina
@@nicolehicks6555 Because that is all it takes. Aside from the miniscule amount of genetic anomalies.
@@nicolehicks6555Right, because you HAVE to let balding middle aged men with autogynephilia into bathrooms with little girls!
Correct biological
are you college edumucated? @@nicolehicks6555
Adult human female. It's as simple as that.
Literally you burry a trans woman and a "Straight male" in a casket shaped like a heart together in 100 years the scientists aren't looking at them and saying "hm this looks like a gay couple but it could be straight if one of these guys identified as a woman" they're calling it a gay couple
You can almost feel your IQ dropping while watching this.
This is the first clip I’ve seen from this channel where everyone who spoke seemed to be willing to have a positive discussion.
Are we surprised that the chick with the deepest vocal fry on the end thinks gender is a social construct?
2:20 "holy muck yes!" LOL! Brian's impatience is me.
I had a debate with a Leftist UA-camr about this topic. He argued the side of “T-women are women, gender and sex are not the same, you are a woman if you identify as one, and being a woman is about the roles/expectations you fulfill and not your biology” etc.
I argued the opposite side of this and presented him with the following thought experiment:
For the sake of argument, let’s initially function under the premise that they are correct, sex and gender ARE seperate.
“Male and Female” are terms that refer to biological sex, and “Man and Woman” are terms that refer to gender.
Now let’s layout 3 possible ways that it can be determined what makes someone a Man or Woman.
The 3 possibilities we will look at are:
• Biology
• Self-Identification
• Roles/Expectations
So now let's say that I, a biological male, in my every day life were to have long hair, put on make-up, wear dresses and high heels, work as a Nanny, and I'm a homemaker in my relationship. I am as non-masculine as possible, and I fulfill these roles and expectations so well that I am typically perceived as a woman by others. But in spite of ALL of that I still call myself, and tell others that I AM A MAN.
Now we FINALLY have something everyone agrees on. I call myself a man, and both sides of this topic agree that I am a man.
The Conservative side agrees I'm a man because I am a biological male.
Leftists agree I am a man because that is what I identify as. (The UA-camr agreed I would be a man)
So now what we can determine is that "Roles/Expectations" are NOT what makes you a man or woman. If they were, how would it be possible for me to be considered a man while fulfilling none of the gender roles/expectations of a man in appearance or lifestyle? How can a woman still be considered a woman when she fulfills none of the roles/expectations of a woman in appearance or lifestyle? If this was truly the determining factor, this should not be possible.
So let's cross "Roles/Expectations" off of our possible determinates.
In regards to Self-Identification, it should be intuitively obvious that someone's words do not determine reality; I can say I am anything, but that doesn't make it true. I can say I am a refrigerator, but I am clearly not a refrigerator. When I SAY I am a man, even IF it is true, it is not the thing that determines WHY it is true.
So let's cross off "Self-Identification" from our possible determinates.
All I am left with now is to believe that my Biology IS what makes me a man. It makes perfect sense, the anatomical make-up that is my physical being determines the objective reality of WHAT I am. It should be clear now why these arguments to the contrary are absurd.
And so with that I believe I have succinctly shown why Biology is what determines your sex/gender, and why the 2 terms are in fact the same thing.
After I made this point the UA-camr refused to engage with it, and shortly after stopped responding 😂
i don’t believe in self-id. i believe that you are essentially what other people say you are. so you have to maintain that roles and expectations are a factor. You can call yourself a man all you want but if you’re living as a woman, you’re essentially a woman.
@@nicolehicks6555 If your a man, living like a woman, you are just a confused man. Even if you do everything to try to look like a woman, you are never going to be a woman.
@@nicolehicks6555 Is what other people say you are not invalid for the same reason self-ID is? Its still just someones words or thoughts, which have no inherent bearing on reality, the only difference is it's other peoples instead of your own. Even if that was the case, you still have to contend with the fact that not everyone would agree on what they see you as. If you are a T-woman who people know to be (T) or can easily tell that you are, then there are people who will see you as a man.
If other peoples perception of you is what determines what you are, this would not only include people who see you as a woman, it would also include those who dont. If that’s what we’re left with it seems really messy and unhelpful to determine what you are based on other peoples opinions, because those will conflict. I dont see how that would be more proper to determine WHAT you are than your actual physical being would be.
This way of thinking in essence views "woman" as an adjective, when it is very clearly a noun based on its usage in language. This is why you would say "She is a woman" and not "She is very woman".... A "Woman" is a THING, not a descriptor.
As a Catholic, i can confirm she isn't. Catholism absolutely rejects everything she said.
Social role? My three year old know's what a woman is AND what a man is!
yeah? how can they tell?
@@nicolehicks6555 You went to college to get this regarded. Let that sink in
@@nicolehicks6555If babies couldn’t tell the difference between men and women, you wouldn’t be here. Because your ancestors would have starved to death in infancy.
@@AndreiGeorgescu-j9pLmfao
I love watch Rachel's facial expressions when all the other women are. Talking and presenting word salads😂
I'm white, can I identify as black?
It actually is annoying when people say race is a social construct. We wouldn't have genetic markers that differentiate us. I'm mixed and I look white but I can't deny my African genetics because they are there.
Absurd
Of you perform as a black person. Perhaps wear black face Perhaps 😂
By their logic, yes. You’re invited to the cookout next week fam. Bring the Ice
@@EditedByGQ LOL!
This is our youth ? ......we're doomed
A woman is someone who identify it self as woman
A jidonga is someone who identify it self as a jidonga
Now, find a jidonga for me...😂
It never ceases to surprise me that a person can say so many words and yet fail to communicate a cogent thought.
The comedian chick should be hosting this show, Brian is too slow !!
Yeah he is so careful not to say what he's thinking, not be offensive, and what's obvious to 90+% of men. Brian is a Beta.
2:00 😂😂😂😂 the way Brian and the girl next to him look up when says that stupid crap is hilarious!
I identify as a Kryptonian.
I identify as a Cybertronian.
Our society today shows us we have too much free time on our hands to think about such things. In the past there was work to be done, everyone accepted their roles as men and women , we’ve become spoiled and have taken things for granted, you don’t know what you got til it’s gone.
Just because a person goes to Holy Mother Church, does not mean the have been properly catechized or formed. Which is no different then anything else. She "identifies" as Catholic. Big difference than practicing Catholicism.
Totally agree
Its not a difficult question
how can you bleed each month and not know what the fuck you are.
The chick sat right of bluetop says what your thinking & that pipe down had me in stitches!!! Nominee for the Based awards 🤣🤣🤣
Adult human female *
I missed the part where Rachel Wilson SCHOOLS Her. In fact RW didn't even speak in this video except for the last 15 or so seconds.
"A woman is about performance". Are we talking indycar now?
Mm yea mm yea mm yea mm yea , can you imagine her in a business meeting .
I hate how many fake Catholics there are, giving us the bad name
Yeah because the catholic church hasn't done anything to tarnish its reputation...lol! 🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡
@@jahwoo6292 there is evil everywhere, and evil within the church is condemned by everyone in it, and if it isn't then they need to, though most commit worse and it is ignored
@@heartofpuregold I agree, but I will also say, that when it comes to more wokeness and politics talk, staying Traditional is also naturally staying away from wokeness and the like of it. I myself can't debate a stranger without my heart racing, though I do like to debate family and friends at times, but I understand the stress, I will of course give another chance, as I think everyone needs more than just a second chance, but we can't give in to wokeness in any way at all, including having to strictly define what women are.
@@stryder6253 Ignore her she's made a ton of comments getting angry at anybody daring to say this girl is a fake catholic. She even said that it was "nerves" that made her say these things.
What did I say that was against Church teachings. I want quotes
People that overuse large, complex words. Are often not as smart as they want you to believe.
--------> Remember fellas. Rachel censored me off pearls comments because I was telling men that I proved alimony and child support are voluntary payments in January 2008...
Not child support both of you made the child/ ren exist therefore both of you should contribute. Alimony is not required once one is divorced it comes by negotiating on the financial orders there are parenting and financial property orders separate matters at least in Australia dont know other country
@@heartofpuregold Both Alimony and child support are voluntary payments. I proved this in January 2008. In a court. Rachel does not want men to know this.
@@heartofpuregold FYI. I have run cases in the US, Canada, Ireland, UK, Australia and NZ. In every case I have run the courts have agreed alimony and child support are voluntary payments. This is not an opinion. It is a proven fact.
@@heartofpuregold "therefore both of you should contribute". Mothers are under no obligation to contribute to their children and never have been in the history of mankind. So why should men have any obligation? Hm?
@@PeterNolan-009 absolute lies you didnt run any case in Australia as a lawyer nor where you a represented politician its legislated to pay child support until a child turns 18 by the childs recognised father. That person is not the live with parent fulltime so in the event of the divorce break up its the live with parent who shoulders all the responsibility of raising the child and are often precluded from earning an income because of that fact. The other party has the ability to earn a fulltime income without day to day care of the child. Its the childs needs first.
Words salad with more "LIKE" 😂
Red nailed the definition of a Woman perfectly.
“We will get to thaaaaat”😂😂😂
❤ she said, "i cannot have a legitimate idea because i am too scared and afraid that someone else won't agree with me" 😂😂😂😂😂 ❤
My brain hurts just listening to these women. Where the heck did they leave their brain at 😂
6:55 biggest problem with having these conversations with college attendees is that they want to sound smart at all costs. They're not humble enough to say "you know what, I don't know or I don't know how to answer that"
This is ridiculous 😂😂😂
The lady in the middle in black is very solid and articulate! Bravo!
This world is getting crazy
Wouldn't one of those duties be to bear children
I have put together a "Dumbest of Whatever Podcast Panel Answers" compilation. I got it edited down to 4278 hours and 23 minutes.
Feminism went from empowering women to convincing them that they cant define what a woman is 😂
What is salt? Salt is something that is salty.
Genre is not a social construct.
Another great episode of Always Sunny in Philadelphia! Nice!
1 person believes something and then others tend to follow the belief until it becomes a social construct.
As a Sociologist who used to be a leftie, I offer my sincerest apologies for my contribution, direct or indirect, to the mainstreaming of this kind of thinking. Rest assured I am doing what I can to the reverse the damage I have done. May God have mercy on my soul.
Apology not accepted. You can be forgiven when the damage has been reversed.
So never.
Junk science
Men and women are different by nature. We look different, think different, move different, sound different, smell different... That's why when you see a dude trying to look like a lady, you know something is off. It's intuitive. It's in our DNA.
"because, uh , like, sss, well" , filler words.
If you were born in the 80s and before......you realised the internet has made people really really stupid
Spinning and lying, nothing important, nothing much.. 😂
Gosh! This girl on a red t-shirt can't give a straight answer and it's so annoying 🙄
Wow.. she had the nerve to say something was dumb 😂
This is embarrassing for America ……. Makes us look weak
Hearing the question & not being able to answer it with a simple answer is always a red flag to me. Like this shit, by definition, is not rocket science. Changing the narrative to fit your argument is an automatic lose!
The one with blue hair , is not joining in .
The high maintenance blonde in the big clear glasses doesn’t even understand what is being said. She is more worried about her makeup and appearance. She started getting ready on Wednesday to go out Friday.
Agreed
Anyone else notice that these women spend 90% of the time staring at themselves on the screen
That was torture.
Imagine spending this amount of time in bettering the world, raising a child - these people spent hours and hours trying to dissect and “prove” how a t-woman is a woman
The million dollar question, what is a woman, stumps them every time 😂😂 I remember when people knew the answer to such a simple question and didn’t hesitate when they answered, what has our world come too wow
"I'm more terrified of the mob than of the truth."
*than DESTROYING the truth
They absolutely fear the truth.
A woman will call a transwoman a man, or be fearful.
A man will not call a transman a man, and never fear.
Rachel you are doing fantastic. I just would have got up and left. They can't answer without spending 10 minutes answering the freaking question!!!!!
I think pink shirt was getting Gender and Gender Identity mixed up, its funny that the supporters of the theory don't actually understand the basics of it.
They truly have no idea what they are talking about.
To expect these products of our educational system to understand reality is in itself ridiculous
The only thing I will say is-
Everyone needs to learn how to get their points across without personally disrespecting the other individuals. Just have the conversation & leave your emotions at the door. These are good conversations & it’s not a PERSONAL attack.
I'm today slow as turtle, may i be turtle today, please?
I don't know how Rachel held out so long lol
Woman in black is on 🔥🔥🔥 .
So is an egg roll an egg roll? or can it be the same as a dinner roll. even though it has different stuff on the inside? Figure that one out first.
Brian should ask the question about dating a trans-person with reversed roles to pose it on the girls: If a girl dates a trans-woman, is "S the D" a lesbian act?
girl in the black was based af being her back
God this is painful…