Yassss huhuh, Naeun's face was not blurred. OT6 will always have a special place in my heart. I will always support and love you my six queens. Happy 11th anniversary ❤️❤️❤️🐼❤️❤️❤️
I think they only have to blur and censor people if they are in some scandal. She just withdrew from the group so it's not necessary to censor her out.
Apink fans should be grateful with this group .. every anniversary they do prepare something. So every year they surely got new music from the whole group...
판다들과 멤버들이 써온 4019일간의 기적 같은 소중한 이야기들! 우리가 함께 걸어온 과정이 늘 꽃길은 아니고 가끔씩 불어오는 바람에 흔들릴 뻔 한 적도 있었지만 판다들과 멤버들이 서로 의지해서 여기까지 함께 올 수 있었던 것 같아요💖 우리들 이 마음 항상 유지해서 오래오래 함께하자🙏 항상 그대들이 축복받아야 할 날에 우리들을 감동시켜줘서 너무 고맙습니다!
Other than for Pandas, I felt this song also a message to Naeun who left the group. They just want her to be happy with whatever she choose and will always support each other.
The fact that Apink keeps on releasing fan songs every year since 2011. But some 'pandas' have the urge to leave fandom just because it will be OT5 from now. Sick.
Aww…I got so emotional when hearing this. I don’t know I miss Naeun that much! I was Eunji’s fan but gradually love Apink and every member are treasure for me.(That’s not surprising cause they are all so talented and adorable!) I cried and smile when listening to this. Thank you Apink for staying with us 11years. And there will be more years that we will spend together in the future. Thank you pandas for loving our queens even more and more!❤ Love you Apink!❤
I'm here again after 9 months this song is released. I'm actually crying, I just hear the song and had my eyes bawling. Apink will be always and forever in my heart. I never had any girl group stan other than Apink. My first and only, Ei-pink-keu 🤍🩷
Have been a long time listener and supporter of Apink. It's not an end, it's a continuation, a new chapter. It's not a separation, It's together separately. We're all always on a journey, separately but together. To a bright future together, Apink, Panda, everybody. 💖
에이핑크 진짜진짜 사랑해♡♡♡ 당신들 같은 사람들을 알게되서 정말 행복합니당 매년 이렇게 팬송 내주는 거 너무너무 고마워여ㅠ 영원한 건 없다지만, 그래도 힘이 닿는 그 순간까지 함께 했으면 해요!!! 뛰는게 힘들면 걸으면 되고, 걷는게 힘들면 앉았다 가고, 삐끗해서 다치면 치료하고 가도 되는거니까요 어쨌든 그 길로 가고 있는 거잖아요! 우리 핑순이들 멋있고! 예쁘고! 노래 미쳤어요!ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 건강 챙기면서! 무리하지 말고요!! 지금까지 진짜 고생했어요 너무 자랑스러워!!! 그치만 한 29년? 정도만 더 고생하자구요!!!ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 앞으로도 에이핑크를 사랑하는 핑크판다가 되겠습니다!!! 진짜 많이많이 고맙고 사랑해요 에이핑크!!!♡♡♡
언니들 11년동안 너무너무 고생 많았어. 판다 앞에서는 밝고 완벽한 모습 보여줬는데 그 뒤에서 얼마나 고생하고 노력했을지 가늠도 안가. 11년이 결코 짧은시간이 아닌데 이렇게 오랫동안 활동해줘서 고마워. 항상 팬들만 생각하는, 너무나 예쁜 마음을 가진 에이핑크의 팬인게 항상 자랑스러워. 박초롱 윤보미 정은지 김남주 오하영 그리고 나은언니도 11년동안 에이핑크를 빛내줘서 고마웠어. 비록 앞으로는 5핑크일테지만 손나은도 판다들에겐 영원한 에이핑크야. 에이핑크랑 판다들 앞으로도 예쁜추억 많이쌓자. 언제나 우린 함께일거야🐼
I didn't even realise that tears started to flow down to my cheeks😭 This mv really touched my heart as I remember being their fans 10 years ago. Not to mention that this is the very first song that sing by 5 members and not 6🥲😭... But Apink OT6 will always be in my heart, love you guys 😘
Bittersweet feelings. We're celebrating Apink's 11th anniversary today but it's also the last day Naeun will be an Apink member, but in my heart she will always be an APINK MEMBER. I'm still hurting but just like how I stayed as a Panda supporting them throughout these years despite everything that happened, I will still continue to love and support them. I know we'll eventually see them complete again. Happy 11th Anniversary to my ultimate GG, my fairy-dols, my youth - APINK!🐼💖 APINK FOREVER! APINK FIGHTING! I LOVE YOU GIRLS!!!! THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
As time past by, I just realized that my love for Apink is not just a fan to an Idol. It's a real love where you will get happiness, hope, strength and courage to continue what you start. They are a perfect example that even there's a big problem, you just need to trust your love one and the people around you who believe in you. In my 11years as Panda they inspired me that there still people that will help you to fight your battle and ignore the negative people. They're like a family to me even if i didn't have a chance to meet them in person. Apink will still be Apink even yook yung and naeun left, they will still be part of Apink and remain as a beautiful memories that gave us happiness. Happy 11th Anniversary Apink. Apink and Panda's as One ❤️✨
The real comforts that I found every everyday, everytime my ears catch their voices, their jokes and laughing, their vocals when singinggg~ The one and only who have it and bring all those to me ♡ Apink~
에이핑크의 데뷔 11 주년을 축하해요. 11년 동안 함께한 모든 순간들이 저에게 정말 기적이에요. 좋은 음악 만들어 줘서 고마워요. 멀리 있어도 맘은 항상 널 향해요. 건강하고 행복하길 바래요. 네가 여기 있으면 우리 여기 있어줄게, 화이팅! 우리가 힘들때나 기쁠때나 모두 옆에서 힘이 되어주는 에이핑크 사랑해요~ 💞
"I'll just be the one who knows the tears I dropped alone" ...Forget the negativity of other people..Apink will be the one for me.. Apink forever Panda forever❤🐼
I can't hold my tears while realising this is the first song (even a fansong...) sung by 5 members not 6... Can't hear Naeun's in their future new songs anymore😭 - I want you to be happy too Chorong Bomi Eunji Naeun Namjoo Hayoung❤️
Love their voice. Love their friendship. Hwayoung's voice is so calming for me. And Namjoo's high note is so ❤️❤️. And their voices are very well mixed together. Thank you for being together as Apink. Happy 11th anniversary.
happy anniversary Apink love you forever, my love will never end for you, you always have a place in my heart, your struggle was great from ot7 until now, even though some members left but you are still Pink Panda family forever I love you Apink Thank you for everything, you guys are so great, Pink Panda will always love you
Thank you for still holding Apink name and thank you to my fellow Panda too. We manage going through this 11 years and its not easy where all those newcomer and popular group nowadays. I love you Apink and I love you Panda To Naeun, you always be part of Apink and always be our nangni. 💓💓💓💓
에이핑크 11주년 진심으로 축하합니다! 저는 9년 동안 팬이었고 지금도 여전히 여기 있고 영원히 팬더가 될 거예요! 저희 에이핑크는 내 마음에서 사라지지 않아요! 6핑크 항상 기억할게요! 우리 늙을 때까지 영원히 함께해요! 너무 감사드리고 11년째 아이돌이 된 것을 다시 한 번 축하드립니다!!!!! 영원히 에이핑크! 영원히 사랑해요! A P I N K & P I N K P A N D A ^^ I LOVE THE THUMBNAIL!!!!!!!!
노래가 영상이랑 너무 잘맞았어.......... 신인 때 부터 지금 현재까지에 모습들이 담겨 있었는데 중간중간 나오는 판다들.. 이 영상만 보고서도 알수 있네.. 판다들 곁에는 핑순 언니들이 핑순 언니들 곁에는 판다들이 서로 서로 위로해 가며 우리 함께 성장 했다는 걸 이 영상을 통해서 다시 깨달았어요.. 그리고 앞으로도 함께 성장 할거 또 알았구요 이 팬송은 핀순이 언니들이 떠나지 않을 거라는 걸 증명해 준다는 거 같아 들으면서 너무 마음 아팠어요 핑순이 언니들 11주년(11살) 축하해요 20주년(20살) 때는 이 영상에 더 많은 추억들이 담길거라 믿어요 20주년(20살) 때 까지 판다들이 언니들 응원하며 언니들 보며 응원할게요 박초롱 윤보미 정은지 김남주 오하영 이제는 5맴버 모두가 함께 있어요 한명이라도 빠지지 말고 우리 판다들이랑 약속할거죠..? 다시 한번 11주년 축하하고 판다들이 항상 언니들 곁에 있다는 걸 잊지 말아요 사랑해요 영원히 사랑해❤️ 영원히 함께해🐼 영원히 우리는 에!이!핑!크
I love you group Apink is the best, talented, beautiful, perfect, wonderful, amazing and cute queens girls, we will support and love this group, they are talented in everything, I really like their content.
"you should be happy" yes of course, i'm going to be happy start from now on. thank u for the memories, Apink. also, happy anniversary~~! u guys really are the greatest kpop girlband that have a special space in my heart, for real. i love all of u, and promise me that u will always be happy too.
Apink will always be my no. 1....... They are the most unproblematic group until recently (Naeun departure) but still it will always be OT6/7 in my heart. Queens 👑
항상 꽃길만 걸어온 건 아니였지만, 지금까지 걸어온 이 길 그 과정이 힘들고 아팠지만 그대들덕에 덜 힘들고 덜 아플 수 있었어요. 정말 고마워요. 우리 서로 의지하면서 영원한건 없다지만 우리가 만들어나가봐요. 그 영원이란거. 그리고 진짜 말하고 말해도 모자르지만 사랑해요 ❤ 미치도록 사랑해 ~~ !!
I can’t stop crying Apink is my favorite group since 2011 I’m so proud of them, pink panda will be happy always if they are Apink by our side. I will Support APINK FOREVER AND SUPPORT NAEUN FOREVER 💓 APINK & PINK PANDA FOREVER👑💞
초등학생때부터 좋아해서 어느덧 21살이 되었네요 11주년 너무 축하해요 지금도 여전히 언니들만 생각하지만 앞으로도 판다들은 에이핑크라는 걸 알아줬으면 좋겠어요💓 언제나 힘들때나 슬플때 옆에 있을 거고 매년 좋은 팬송을 이렇게 선물 해줘서 너무 고마워요 저는 이 구호를 외쳐줄때마다 너무 기분이 좋더라구요 우리가 누구 ? 에이핑크 여기가 어디 ? 우리가 꿈 꾸던 그 곳 💕 사랑해요 언니들‼️
Apink, Thank you once again for releasing a fansong to us. This masterpiece sure touched me as a long time fan. No matter what happens, Apink is always Apink and your dedication to us Pandas r something we will always hold true to our hearts. Happy 11th Anniversary!
Happy 11th Anniversary Apink and also to my co-Pandas🥺No matter how many members they are now, let's keep supporting and loving them on each path they are taking together or even alone💖
Happy anniversary my queens I had personally followed you all for 9 years. The words I wanna say to you is same as the title of this “i want you to be happy”❤️please stay healthy and strong. No matter what happened I am always panda and will support forever❤️cannot wait to see you all again in Hong Kong❤️nice song and thanks for the anniversary gift❤️
에이핑크에겐 힘들었던 2021년을 표현한 곡 같아요 판다 앞에서는 괜찮다고는 하지만 뒤에서는 맘고생이 많았겠지요ㅜㅜ 그런 마음을 담은 것 같아서 더 슬프네요 "흔들리지 않고 피는 꽃이라는 건 없잖아"라는 가사처럼 더 예쁜 꽃을 피우기 위한 과정일 뿐이라고 생각해요 앞으로 얼마나 아름다운 꽃이 피어날지 기대되네요 앞으로의 활동 기대할게요!!!
Uri Apink and Pandadeul happy 11th anniversary. Apink is one and only group where i treasure a lot. Panda will be my only fandom, my home. Uri Apink, thank you for everything. Lets be together. Love u so much guys
This is a hard & sad time for us pandas but imagine it must be 1000 times harder for Chorong, Bomi, Eunji, Namjoo, Hayoung because they lost a family member. Naeun surely feel the same too.. Despite that, they still trying to cheer us & make us Pandas happy. This fan song, its also feel like a blessing sending Naeun away with a smile from the members with a message "I WANT YOU TO BE HAPPY" & will keep cheering for you.. OT7, OT6, OT5.. it doesnt matter. Lets be together till the end. Chorong, Bomi, Eunji, Namjoo, Hayoung & Naeun too remember Pandas are always behind you! Apink+Panda are ONE!
There are so many groups that I stand. However, Apink is always in my heart. Because of them, I'm become a kpoppers when I was 10 years old (2016). I love them so much. They're my home. Always and forever 🥺💗 idc what people say. ot6 forever 😊❤️❤️❤️🐼🐼
Nearly crying realizing how precious Apink creativity is to many people. No matter what, they songs, music and voice full of goodness and harmony, i'ts like they are reviving souls, purifying it from ashes, evil and dirt after so many years supporting.
Last night I just realized I really had swinging mood... if it all comes to Apink (": I am suddenly sooo soft... Thanks for choosing the hardest way, keep being together and singing for US ♥︎ SARANGHAE
Apink has been giving us good music for 11 years, I will always be grateful for that because every song lifted me up. This group has been my therapy for all those year. I love apink, I love their color. Always.
The fact that they are willing to suffer and keep their tears from falling just so panda's won't know what they were going through, so that panda's won't feel pain and only happiness hurts me so much....
I've watched Apink performed live, i could never imagine they are moving forward as 5. However life is just like that, sometimes we part ways with people we love the most. Congratulations on your 11th Anniversary 💕 please keep on singing good music for us
팬 가장 잘 챙겨주는 그룹은 에이핑크가 최고인듯
Yassss huhuh, Naeun's face was not blurred. OT6 will always have a special place in my heart. I will always support and love you my six queens. Happy 11th anniversary ❤️❤️❤️🐼❤️❤️❤️
Wait why would it be blurred? When was she blurred? Isnt she still apart of apink? Is there something bad between them?
I just saw the article so now i understand.
@@kpoplovinpanda i think there's an article said Naeun officially left group
I think they only have to blur and censor people if they are in some scandal. She just withdrew from the group so it's not necessary to censor her out.
This group used to be 7
Apink fans should be grateful with this group .. every anniversary they do prepare something. So every year they surely got new music from the whole group...
thankyou for everything. i dont care about what other people, "fans", bashers, says. i love you apink. forever. happy 11th anniversary!!
Same
What going on now?
@@Danzin_Danzibar as I know , one of the member, left the group (Naeun)
@@Danzin_Danzibar naeun left apink :'(
팔년 동안 저희 곁에 있어줘서 좋은 음악 내줘서 고마워요 . 어렸을 때부터 꿈 쿠 게 해줘서 기적 같은 삶을 사게 해줘서 힘이 되는 비타민 같은 우리 에이핑크 오래 오래 가자 .
시간이 정말 빨리 흐르네요 저도 이제 대학생입니다.
제목이… 너무너무 슬프다…나만 알면된다는 말처럼 지금껏 에이핑크가 겪어온 힘든 길의 전부를 우리는 다 알아주지 못했다고 생각하니 더 마음이 아프다.. 힘든건 본인들만 알면 된다는 그 마음이 너무 고마우면서도 팬으로서 한없이 미안해져..🥺
판다들과 멤버들이 써온 4019일간의 기적 같은 소중한 이야기들! 우리가 함께 걸어온 과정이 늘 꽃길은 아니고 가끔씩 불어오는 바람에 흔들릴 뻔 한 적도 있었지만 판다들과 멤버들이 서로 의지해서 여기까지 함께 올 수 있었던 것 같아요💖 우리들 이 마음 항상 유지해서 오래오래 함께하자🙏 항상 그대들이 축복받아야 할 날에 우리들을 감동시켜줘서 너무 고맙습니다!
Other than for Pandas, I felt this song also a message to Naeun who left the group. They just want her to be happy with whatever she choose and will always support each other.
Every day with Apink!!!!
Only Apink can sing such a beautiful emotional song!!!!
Apink is the best!!!!
apink is super amazing, they can sing, dance, having a variety show skills, they are all visual, they are an actress, yes they are that talented.
The fact that Apink keeps on releasing fan songs every year since 2011. But some 'pandas' have the urge to leave fandom just because it will be OT5 from now.
Sick.
Aww…I got so emotional when hearing this. I don’t know I miss Naeun that much! I was Eunji’s fan but gradually love Apink and every member are treasure for me.(That’s not surprising cause they are all so talented and adorable!) I cried and smile when listening to this. Thank you Apink for staying with us 11years. And there will be more years that we will spend together in the future. Thank you pandas for loving our queens even more and more!❤ Love you Apink!❤
I admire Apink's career longevity.
Only Apink can make and sing such a deeply meaningful beautiful song so wonderfully!!!!!
Apink is really the best!!!!!
이번 뮤비가 너무 감동적이야... 사랑합니다 에이핑크!
나은아 … 언제든 꼭 돌아와서 여섯명이서 함께 무대에 서는 모습 보여줘 ….
I'm here again after 9 months this song is released. I'm actually crying, I just hear the song and had my eyes bawling. Apink will be always and forever in my heart. I never had any girl group stan other than Apink. My first and only, Ei-pink-keu 🤍🩷
Have been a long time listener and supporter of Apink.
It's not an end, it's a continuation, a new chapter.
It's not a separation, It's together separately.
We're all always on a journey, separately but together.
To a bright future together, Apink, Panda, everybody. 💖
에이핑크 진짜진짜 사랑해♡♡♡
당신들 같은 사람들을 알게되서 정말 행복합니당
매년 이렇게 팬송 내주는 거 너무너무 고마워여ㅠ
영원한 건 없다지만,
그래도 힘이 닿는 그 순간까지 함께 했으면 해요!!!
뛰는게 힘들면 걸으면 되고,
걷는게 힘들면 앉았다 가고, 삐끗해서 다치면 치료하고 가도 되는거니까요
어쨌든 그 길로 가고 있는 거잖아요!
우리 핑순이들 멋있고! 예쁘고! 노래 미쳤어요!ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
건강 챙기면서! 무리하지 말고요!!
지금까지 진짜 고생했어요 너무 자랑스러워!!! 그치만 한 29년? 정도만 더 고생하자구요!!!ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
앞으로도 에이핑크를 사랑하는 핑크판다가 되겠습니다!!!
진짜 많이많이 고맙고 사랑해요 에이핑크!!!♡♡♡
nonono 영상나올때부터 엉엉 울면서 봤다ㅠㅠ
초등학교때부터 함께해준 에이핑크 너무 사랑하고 11살 생일 축하해요!♡♡
언니들 11년동안 너무너무 고생 많았어. 판다 앞에서는 밝고 완벽한 모습 보여줬는데 그 뒤에서 얼마나 고생하고 노력했을지 가늠도 안가. 11년이 결코 짧은시간이 아닌데 이렇게 오랫동안 활동해줘서 고마워. 항상 팬들만 생각하는, 너무나 예쁜 마음을 가진 에이핑크의 팬인게 항상 자랑스러워. 박초롱 윤보미 정은지 김남주 오하영 그리고 나은언니도 11년동안 에이핑크를 빛내줘서 고마웠어. 비록 앞으로는 5핑크일테지만 손나은도 판다들에겐 영원한 에이핑크야. 에이핑크랑 판다들 앞으로도 예쁜추억 많이쌓자. 언제나 우린 함께일거야🐼
seriously this group need more recognition, the song is so gorgeous and how they are singing with telling stories is beautiful
그대들이 있어서 정말 행복해요 💝 앞으로도 더욱 사랑할게요 판다들을 위해서 고생한만큼 우리가 보답해줄게요 이번 곡 만드니라고 너무 고생 많았고 앞으로도 행복만해요 우리! 🐼🐼
I didn't even realise that tears started to flow down to my cheeks😭 This mv really touched my heart as I remember being their fans 10 years ago. Not to mention that this is the very first song that sing by 5 members and not 6🥲😭... But Apink OT6 will always be in my heart, love you guys 😘
Whaaaaat who left ???
@@소원시대 Naeun just leaving the group🥲
@@소원시대 Naeun left for YG, for her acting career... :(
OT7 to me 😭
@@amiradiary OF COURSE😭😭
Although I love Apink, I love Chorong, Bomi, Eunji, Naeun, Namjoo, Hayoung and Yookyung more💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
Bittersweet feelings. We're celebrating Apink's 11th anniversary today but it's also the last day Naeun will be an Apink member, but in my heart she will always be an APINK MEMBER.
I'm still hurting but just like how I stayed as a Panda supporting them throughout these years despite everything that happened, I will still continue to love and support them.
I know we'll eventually see them complete again.
Happy 11th Anniversary to my ultimate GG, my fairy-dols, my youth - APINK!🐼💖
APINK FOREVER! APINK FIGHTING! I LOVE YOU GIRLS!!!! THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING.❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
판다라서 행복한 오늘이다 진짜ㅠ 팬들은 누구보다도 생각해주는 우리핑크 영원히 사랑할 거고 영원히 함께하자
As time past by, I just realized that my love for Apink is not just a fan to an Idol. It's a real love where you will get happiness, hope, strength and courage to continue what you start. They are a perfect example that even there's a big problem, you just need to trust your love one and the people around you who believe in you. In my 11years as Panda they inspired me that there still people that will help you to fight your battle and ignore the negative people. They're like a family to me even if i didn't have a chance to meet them in person. Apink will still be Apink even yook yung and naeun left, they will still be part of Apink and remain as a beautiful memories that gave us happiness. Happy 11th Anniversary Apink. Apink and Panda's as One ❤️✨
에이핑크 팬은아닌데 고마워도 그렇고 이노래도 너무 힐링되는 노래 ㅠㅠ
Let's continue to bloom like this, my SIX FLOWERS! Congratulations on our 11th anniversary🥺
Happy 11th anniversary APINK!🎉
Apink 사랑해♥️
언니들은 저의 영원한 가수이고 에이핑크예요 앞으로도 판다로서 언니들 노래하는 모든날들 응원할께요!
The real comforts that I found every everyday, everytime my ears catch their voices, their jokes and laughing, their vocals when singinggg~
The one and only who have it and bring all those to me ♡ Apink~
I'm crying but i'm happy..
Apink+panda=family forever
에이핑크의 데뷔 11 주년을 축하해요. 11년 동안 함께한 모든 순간들이 저에게 정말 기적이에요. 좋은 음악 만들어 줘서 고마워요. 멀리 있어도 맘은 항상 널 향해요. 건강하고 행복하길 바래요. 네가 여기 있으면 우리 여기 있어줄게, 화이팅! 우리가 힘들때나 기쁠때나 모두 옆에서 힘이 되어주는 에이핑크 사랑해요~ 💞
Thank u for all APINK ❤️❤️ WE LOVE U 💖💖💖💖💖
2013년 NoNoNo 때부터 좋아해서 지금까지도 응원하고 사랑하고 있어요 항상 4월 19일이 될때면 이렇게 좋은 노래들을 들을 수 있게 해줘서 너무 고마워요 에이핑크 ❤
노래 너무 좋고 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 우리 생각하는 언니들 마음은 더 더 좋고 🥺🥺❤️ 고마워요 항상… 항상 곁에 있을게요🐼🤍 사랑해요!!!!!
Eventhough I'm still sad that now they are only 5 I still adore their family-like bond in the past 12 years
"I'll just be the one who knows the tears I dropped alone" ...Forget the negativity of other people..Apink will be the one for me.. Apink forever Panda forever❤🐼
Your not I did
I can't hold my tears while realising this is the first song (even a fansong...) sung by 5 members not 6... Can't hear Naeun's in their future new songs anymore😭
-
I want you to be happy too Chorong Bomi Eunji Naeun Namjoo Hayoung❤️
Love their voice. Love their friendship. Hwayoung's voice is so calming for me. And Namjoo's high note is so ❤️❤️. And their voices are very well mixed together. Thank you for being together as Apink. Happy 11th anniversary.
내가 많이 사랑하는 에이핑크! 앞으로도 기쁜일 슬픈일 모두 함께해요! 지금까지도 에이핑크로 있어줘서 고맙고… 늘 이런 이쁜 노래들 내줘서 정말 고마워. 그대들 덕에 하루하루 힘내고 위로 받고 있어요. 남은 2022년도 앞으로도 더 소중하고 이쁜 추억 많이 만들어가요❤️
온 맘을 다해 감사합니다. 에이핑크가 제 청춘이에요
from OT7 to OT6 now OT5 , i hope there's no one leaving the group again, Apink forever❣️ . so glad, naeun still in this video tho.
Apink fighting... You did well.. please always happy and stay healthy ... Pink Panda always with you. We love you gurls... ❤️
Hope everyone happy for every moment, always :) no matter where u are or whenever, wishh u still in ur happiness
happy anniversary Apink love you forever, my love will never end for you, you always have a place in my heart, your struggle was great from ot7 until now, even though some members left but you are still Pink Panda family forever
I love you Apink
Thank you for everything, you guys are so great, Pink Panda will always love you
Happy 11th anniversary Apink, thank you for everything. We'll here for you no matter what happen, let's be together forever! Pandas love all of you!
Thank you for still holding Apink name and thank you to my fellow Panda too. We manage going through this 11 years and its not easy where all those newcomer and popular group nowadays. I love you Apink and I love you Panda
To Naeun, you always be part of Apink and always be our nangni. 💓💓💓💓
I love you Apink 💕❤️ from Malaysia 🇲🇾
에이핑크 11주년 축하해! 앞으로도 좋은추억 남기자
Apink forever.panda malaysia here waiting next concert here
최근 들어 이런저런 우여곡절이 많았지만, 멤버들이 그에 굴하지 않고 "에이핑크"라는 이름을 유지하기 위해 수많은 노력을 했다는 것을 알 수 있는 노래. 12주년을 넘어, 슈퍼주니어와 신화처럼 20년 가까이 장수할 수 있는 걸그룹이 되길 소망함.
you can’t imagine all the emotions i kept while listening😭thanks for 9 years with me apink my precious girls 🙏🏻👑 Happy 11th anniversary
에이핑크 11주년 진심으로 축하합니다! 저는 9년 동안 팬이었고 지금도 여전히 여기 있고 영원히 팬더가 될 거예요! 저희 에이핑크는 내 마음에서 사라지지 않아요! 6핑크 항상 기억할게요! 우리 늙을 때까지 영원히 함께해요! 너무 감사드리고 11년째 아이돌이 된 것을 다시 한 번 축하드립니다!!!!! 영원히 에이핑크! 영원히 사랑해요! A P I N K & P I N K P A N D A ^^ I LOVE THE THUMBNAIL!!!!!!!!
에이핑크는 늘 6명이였고 끝까지 6명이야 늘 응원해 우리 핑순이들!!♡
I really love Apink!!!!
Eunji's stage yesterday was soooo good!!!!
My dream is to enjoy Apink stage with my grandchild some day!!!!!
노래가 영상이랑 너무 잘맞았어..........
신인 때 부터 지금 현재까지에 모습들이 담겨 있었는데 중간중간 나오는 판다들..
이 영상만 보고서도 알수 있네..
판다들 곁에는 핑순 언니들이 핑순 언니들 곁에는 판다들이 서로 서로 위로해 가며 우리 함께 성장 했다는 걸 이 영상을 통해서 다시 깨달았어요..
그리고 앞으로도 함께 성장 할거 또 알았구요
이 팬송은 핀순이 언니들이 떠나지
않을 거라는 걸 증명해 준다는 거 같아
들으면서 너무 마음 아팠어요
핑순이 언니들 11주년(11살) 축하해요
20주년(20살) 때는 이 영상에
더 많은 추억들이 담길거라 믿어요
20주년(20살) 때 까지 판다들이 언니들 응원하며
언니들 보며 응원할게요
박초롱 윤보미 정은지 김남주 오하영 이제는 5맴버 모두가 함께 있어요 한명이라도 빠지지 말고 우리 판다들이랑 약속할거죠..?
다시 한번 11주년 축하하고 판다들이 항상 언니들 곁에 있다는 걸 잊지 말아요 사랑해요
영원히 사랑해❤️ 영원히 함께해🐼
영원히 우리는 에!이!핑!크
중학생시절에 데뷔했던 에이핑크가 아직도 현역이라는게 기쁘다
팬클럽은 아니지만 보통 탑급이면 7년째에 바이바이하거나 각자 떨어져나가거나 하는데 계속 유지하면서 신화나 슈퍼주니어, 하이라이트 같은 여자 그룹이 없어서 슬펐는데 에이핑크는 사건사고없이 쭉 유지하는게 진짜 신기하면서 여돌도 할 수 있다는걸 보여줘서 고맙네요
I love you group Apink is the best, talented, beautiful, perfect, wonderful, amazing and cute queens girls, we will support and love this group, they are talented in everything, I really like their content.
에이핑크가 지금까지 이뤄온 것, 그리고 앞으로 만들어 갈 것 그 모든 순간에 함께할 생각에 너무 기뻐 . 지금까지도 항상 함께해왔지만 앞으로도 잘 부탁하고 사랑해 영원히 함께하자 ❤
Happy 11th anniversary APINK!
one of the best groups I've ever seen...
love youuuuu
🤍슬픔을 느끼는 대신🤍감사함을 느낀다 🤍감사합니다 에이핑크 🙇🏻♀️ happy 11th anniversary🎂🎉
"you should be happy"
yes of course, i'm going to be happy start from now on. thank u for the memories, Apink. also, happy anniversary~~! u guys really are the greatest kpop girlband that have a special space in my heart, for real. i love all of u, and promise me that u will always be happy too.
Apink will always be my no. 1....... They are the most unproblematic group until recently (Naeun departure) but still it will always be OT6/7 in my heart. Queens 👑
pink wave ♡ saranghae apink!
항상 꽃길만 걸어온 건 아니였지만, 지금까지 걸어온 이 길 그 과정이 힘들고 아팠지만 그대들덕에 덜 힘들고 덜 아플 수 있었어요. 정말 고마워요. 우리 서로 의지하면서 영원한건 없다지만 우리가 만들어나가봐요. 그 영원이란거.
그리고 진짜 말하고 말해도 모자르지만 사랑해요 ❤
미치도록 사랑해 ~~ !!
I can’t stop crying Apink is my favorite group since 2011 I’m so proud of them, pink panda will be happy always if they are Apink by our side. I will Support APINK FOREVER AND SUPPORT NAEUN FOREVER 💓
APINK & PINK PANDA FOREVER👑💞
초등학생때부터 좋아해서 어느덧 21살이 되었네요 11주년 너무 축하해요 지금도 여전히 언니들만 생각하지만 앞으로도 판다들은 에이핑크라는 걸 알아줬으면 좋겠어요💓 언제나 힘들때나 슬플때 옆에 있을 거고 매년 좋은 팬송을 이렇게 선물 해줘서 너무 고마워요 저는 이 구호를 외쳐줄때마다 너무 기분이 좋더라구요 우리가 누구 ? 에이핑크 여기가 어디 ? 우리가 꿈 꾸던 그 곳 💕 사랑해요 언니들‼️
Apink, Thank you once again for releasing a fansong to us.
This masterpiece sure touched me as a long time fan. No matter what happens, Apink is always Apink and your dedication to us Pandas r something we will always hold true to our hearts. Happy 11th Anniversary!
I watch it everydayy
Happy 11th Anniversary Apink and also to my co-Pandas🥺No matter how many members they are now, let's keep supporting and loving them on each path they are taking together or even alone💖
Apink is really the best!!!!!^^
Happy anniversary my queens I had personally followed you all for 9 years. The words I wanna say to you is same as the title of this “i want you to be happy”❤️please stay healthy and strong. No matter what happened I am always panda and will support forever❤️cannot wait to see you all again in Hong Kong❤️nice song and thanks for the anniversary gift❤️
에이핑크에겐 힘들었던
2021년을 표현한 곡 같아요
판다 앞에서는 괜찮다고는 하지만
뒤에서는 맘고생이 많았겠지요ㅜㅜ
그런 마음을 담은 것 같아서 더 슬프네요
"흔들리지 않고 피는 꽃이라는 건 없잖아"라는 가사처럼 더 예쁜 꽃을 피우기 위한 과정일 뿐이라고 생각해요
앞으로 얼마나 아름다운 꽃이 피어날지 기대되네요 앞으로의 활동 기대할게요!!!
Happy Anniversary Apink💕
I'm in love with this song! The lyrics is so beautiful! Apink Forever!!! ♡
Uri Apink and Pandadeul happy 11th anniversary. Apink is one and only group where i treasure a lot. Panda will be my only fandom, my home. Uri Apink, thank you for everything. Lets be together. Love u so much guys
Chorus and high note simply amazing
I’ve been with them since debut and this song mean so much to me. OT6 forever! Apink ❤️ Pink Panda
This is a hard & sad time for us pandas but imagine it must be 1000 times harder for Chorong, Bomi, Eunji, Namjoo, Hayoung because they lost a family member. Naeun surely feel the same too..
Despite that, they still trying to cheer us & make us Pandas happy.
This fan song, its also feel like a blessing sending Naeun away with a smile from the members with a message "I WANT YOU TO BE HAPPY" & will keep cheering for you..
OT7, OT6, OT5.. it doesnt matter. Lets be together till the end.
Chorong, Bomi, Eunji, Namjoo, Hayoung & Naeun too remember Pandas are always behind you!
Apink+Panda are ONE!
There are so many groups that I stand. However, Apink is always in my heart. Because of them, I'm become a kpoppers when I was 10 years old (2016). I love them so much. They're my home. Always and forever 🥺💗 idc what people say. ot6 forever 😊❤️❤️❤️🐼🐼
yeah, so u came when it was the most difficult time for Panda and Apink. glad u are being a Panda now
Nearly crying realizing how precious Apink creativity is to many people. No matter what, they songs, music and voice full of goodness and harmony, i'ts like they are reviving souls, purifying it from ashes, evil and dirt after so many years supporting.
Last night
I just realized
I really had swinging mood... if it all comes to Apink (": I am suddenly sooo soft...
Thanks for choosing the hardest way, keep being together and singing for US ♥︎ SARANGHAE
I love this songs and i will be crying 😭😭😭😢💖💖💖💖
I'm so happy they included Naeun in the MV rather than cutting her out just because she left
Apink has been giving us good music for 11 years, I will always be grateful for that because every song lifted me up. This group has been my therapy for all those year. I love apink, I love their color. Always.
kept crying when listening to this... Apink is forever. No matter what
Apink for live!
The fact that they are willing to suffer and keep their tears from falling just so panda's won't know what they were going through, so that panda's won't feel pain and only happiness hurts me so much....
Support Apink as always. Panda from Hong Kong. Love from Hong Kong. Thank you Apink for bringing us so much joy💕💕And forever OT 7!!
OT7 FOREVER!!!
Thank you Apink for bringing my teenager life special 😍
- PINKPANDA 🐼
The harmony is excellent!!!!!
Apink is the best!!!^^
I've watched Apink performed live, i could never imagine they are moving forward as 5. However life is just like that, sometimes we part ways with people we love the most. Congratulations on your 11th Anniversary 💕 please keep on singing good music for us
well, nothing lasts in this world
Apink can sing many types of songs so wonderfully!!!!!
Beautiful emotional song!!!!^^
벌써 7월이 다가옴
내년 4월19일이 기대
좋네요 매년 노래로 마음을 만져주고
희망을 주니
They were the first girl group I've ever known.
Apink will live forever in my heart.
Happy Anniversary.
"There's no such thing as a flower that blooms without swaying" ❤️
If only Naeun was here to record this song as a farewell to the fans and to the group