She sang beautifully but I have heard Shobha Gurtu ji singing the same Thumri and nothing in this wide world can be as melodious as her voice and beautiful as her expressions while singing this piece. ❤
Everything about this version is refreshing and unique , yet reminiscent of the origìnal one . This is the sign of a true artist,who makes each rendition their own without copying. People who are comparing maybe are fond of copyists.
exactly, thank you. I agree that every song has it charm, but that doesnt mean every artist has to stick to one pattern of singing the song, he/she can make their own pattern yet keeping the base of the song similar to the one of the original.
অতিরিক্ত স্বরবিচ্যুতি (নখরা) গানের মুল রাগের ভাবটিকে নষ্ট করে দেয় । খুবই শ্রুতিকটু লাগে। যদিও গলার কাজ অসাধারন । কৌশিকির উচিত এই ব্যাপারটায় একটু নজর দেওয়া ।
Swar bichhyuti ar nakhra ak jinis noy. Ar Ekta kotha ashol gaan ta gawa hoyechilo jokhun sobha ji r onek boyesh to setar bhab r Ekta bachha Mey r bhav alada hobe. Ekdike eta bhalo je uni nijer moto geyechen ar gaan to kauke copy korenna. Jader bhalolage lage ,jader lagenana. No chaap.
Shobha is not expertise of such thumari. She belongs to patiala gharana.. Do you think there is film song copy of thumari too. Every singer sings different
This is not a thumri but a dadra .why are u even comparing idk .yes this is diff than sobhaji's version. Truth is i prefer this over that in this song cz it's youthful , Chanchal and makes my heart flutter in happiness . Sobha ji is a legend but this version matches my vibes. That does not mean I berate the ones I don't like. It's a abomination to compare artists especially of diff eras . Have some sense , she was in her early 30s when she sang this ,sobha ji was in he'd 60s in the version available . An young lady will not sing like a old one n if she does that will never be authentic.
A little touch of Raag Lalit is just fantastic.....The accompanists are also excellent......
She sang beautifully but I have heard Shobha Gurtu ji singing the same Thumri and nothing in this wide world can be as melodious as her voice and beautiful as her expressions while singing this piece. ❤
Everything about this version is refreshing and unique , yet reminiscent of the origìnal one . This is the sign of a true artist,who makes each rendition their own without copying. People who are comparing maybe are fond of copyists.
exactly, thank you. I agree that every song has it charm, but that doesnt mean every artist has to stick to one pattern of singing the song, he/she can make their own pattern yet keeping the base of the song similar to the one of the original.
@@santub4240 most people commenting in youtube has no idea about what they talking about. Cloning is not a sign or true artist.
Honourable Kaushiki ji is the Perfect Definition of Patiala Gharana...
Most favorite thumri is from the most sweet Voice... 🌺🌺🌺
Wow! Such talent Bengal has ....!👏👏👏👏👏👏
nakra of tumri is greatly reflected in kaushiki ji's singing , her playing with notes are great
Words are insufficient to praise her .
Oh, great indeed 💯❤❤❤❤❤
वाह बहुत खूब शानदार सुरीली आवाज़
🎶😢😢 I'm speechless! 🦋🕊️❣️
Omg❤ this is unbelievable
Swayang swaraswati devi er bash apnar konthe.
Pure bliss
Beautiful❤.
Pran কেড়ে নেয় এই কন্ঠে
❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏
অতিরিক্ত স্বরবিচ্যুতি (নখরা) গানের মুল রাগের ভাবটিকে নষ্ট করে দেয় । খুবই শ্রুতিকটু লাগে। যদিও গলার কাজ অসাধারন । কৌশিকির উচিত এই ব্যাপারটায় একটু নজর দেওয়া ।
Swar bichhyuti ar nakhra ak jinis noy. Ar Ekta kotha ashol gaan ta gawa hoyechilo jokhun sobha ji r onek boyesh to setar bhab r Ekta bachha Mey r bhav alada hobe. Ekdike eta bhalo je uni nijer moto geyechen ar gaan to kauke copy korenna. Jader bhalolage lage ,jader lagenana. No chaap.
Bengal classical festival ki 2023 a Bangladesh a hocce????
Very nice
❤❤❤❤❤
Nice😢
At par with Pandit Bhinsen Joshi
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌻🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌼🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
Not even close to Shobha ji. Thumri charm is totally lost but she is a terrific singer
Shobha is not expertise of such thumari. She belongs to patiala gharana.. Do you think there is film song copy of thumari too. Every singer sings different
This is not a thumri but a dadra .why are u even comparing idk .yes this is diff than sobhaji's version. Truth is i prefer this over that in this song cz it's youthful , Chanchal and makes my heart flutter in happiness . Sobha ji is a legend but this version matches my vibes. That does not mean I berate the ones I don't like. It's a abomination to compare artists especially of diff eras . Have some sense , she was in her early 30s when she sang this ,sobha ji was in he'd 60s in the version available . An young lady will not sing like a old one n if she does that will never be authentic.
The nazakat of thumari is lost by her style, her singing skills are not required in this style of singing
Sad you couldn't enjoy or feel the nazakat. This is Marvellous.
Very true
Right you know her she is a excellent classical vocalist kaushiki guru maa I am her big fan she is God gifted ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Please don't use the bad comment Please she is a great singer ❤
Sala tujhe bara malum😂😂😂😂
She is just amazing singing