to put it plainly, its cuz she's in a group of vocal monsters. if she was in another group her vocal power would shine entirely, but when ur group mates consist of wendy and seulgi, it hard to get out of their shadows.
The Emotions that I hear when they sing this: 1. Wendy - the calm before the storm. She's letting you know she's mad but like...not screaming. 2. Seulgi - Anger in it's middle stage. She's definitely raised her tone but she's not yelling. Showing signs of physical aggression. 3. Joy - The Storm. She's screaming, throwing things, getting her stabby stabby because knives are friends.
For me it was Wendy-the calm before the storm Seulgi- the storm Joy- the sobbing and emotional state after the storm, looking at the destruction and terror and just sobbing in disbelief.
Wouldn’t say so. That ‘other group’ would definitely be subpar on the vocal department if the best they could get was Seulgi. Don’t get me wrong, she can sing! But she’s no main vocalist material.
Wendy - The stage b4 anger where ur worked up and stressed Seulgi - During anger, confronting them, saying u can't believe them Joy- Getting emotional wants to believe in them but just can't, and that fact hurts her
The thing is that, while Joy is an amazing vocalist, she is nowhere near being as good as Seulgi. And Seulgi is not really on Wendy’s level yet, she struggled to sing Wendy’s parts in Psycho but was the only one who could actually sing them.
@@lioness6995 The thing is also that I wasn’t comparing her to Seulgi at all. She’s fine on her current vocal technique, can actually carry a tune with a decent support, and does great on the lines assigned to her.
joy needs to be a lead vocalist along with seulgi, her vocals are so underated. i get chills every time i listen to her voice, it's so unique and beautiful
I love the progression of vocals in the pre-chorus/bridge. The song is about the lover lying and them getting manipulated, and from Wendy to Seulgi to Joy, they break down even more. Authoritative to upset, to crying because they were lied to and fell for it.
I had never thought of it like that, now that I tie the emotions to each voice and how they executed them and portrayed them very well, especially joy imo, I’ve become more addicted to these parts
Wendy has Fus Ro Dah in terms of powerful it is. Seulgi to she has a way of singing like a sensual sexy lady. Even though she is not how she is IRL. Joy can sing but is the actual sensual Sexy lady IRL.
I dont think you can compare joy here she sang it as bridge not pre chorus. The tone was different in bridge then to pre chorus like seulgi and wendy sang
Hands down WENDY is my girl. Her voice touches me because it's heart felt as with Joy's so tender and sweet. Seulgi is very bright I think when she starts using dynamics and feeling, her singing will touch me too although her 28 Reasons was a killer.
![Lets redesign Marinette!! [this took 3 years to make]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cgXLx4jklZU/mqdefault.jpg)
wendy : powerful
seulgi : calm
joy : emotional
Wendy - Anger
Seulgi - Betrayal
Joy - Sorrow
ooo nice one!
wowww thats exact
wendy - disappointed/powerful yet calm
seulgi - mad
joy - upset/emotional
Joy’s vocal gives me goosebumps omg why she is so underrated
Bro fr she is ky bais
I've never pay any attention to her voice but from chill kill just found out that she was actually a good vocalist,
Joy has a very pretty voice but don't think she is underrated 😭😭😭
to put it plainly, its cuz she's in a group of vocal monsters. if she was in another group her vocal power would shine entirely, but when ur group mates consist of wendy and seulgi, it hard to get out of their shadows.
@@nubee3471not exactly even in other groups she would probably still be subvocal
Wendy Voice-🌪🧛♀
Seulgi Voice-🔥🧜♀
Joy Voice-❄🧚♀
Exactly
The Emotions that I hear when they sing this:
1. Wendy - the calm before the storm. She's letting you know she's mad but like...not screaming.
2. Seulgi - Anger in it's middle stage. She's definitely raised her tone but she's not yelling. Showing signs of physical aggression.
3. Joy - The Storm. She's screaming, throwing things, getting her stabby stabby because knives are friends.
This is cringe asf
OMG you put it in words so well
I also feel like joy sounds so fed up she could be so angry thats shes nearing tears
For me it was
Wendy-the calm before the storm
Seulgi- the storm
Joy- the sobbing and emotional state after the storm, looking at the destruction and terror and just sobbing in disbelief.
I love your explanation ❤
joy's voice is angelic
the song is “zoom” by red velvet for anyone curious!
thank you so much!
Thank you!
Wendy:Mermaid voice
Seulgi:Queen voice
Joy:Fairy voice
Joy- Siren voice it's just so magical it attracts you❤️
I'd switch wendy and seulgi but this is accurate
I'm with you on that, regardless all🔥👑's
seulgi sounds like a mom.. in those musicals like elizabeth singing burn to hamilton
Definitivamente
joy’s voice is so smooth and gorgeous thats why shes my bias. i can never get enough of her and her vocals!
SM be making sub vocalists that could be main vocalist anywhere else
Joy vocal tone is so rare..
Seulgi can be main vocalist in any other group
So can joy honestly
@@belamielczarski8089 joy E+, probably lead vocal
@@okbos-uq2bsActually she's D-
Wouldn’t say so. That ‘other group’ would definitely be subpar on the vocal department if the best they could get was Seulgi. Don’t get me wrong, she can sing! But she’s no main vocalist material.
Bru these vocal tiers are not accurate nor real. Many vocal coaches KEEP saying this
Wendy - The stage b4 anger where ur worked up and stressed
Seulgi - During anger, confronting them, saying u can't believe them
Joy- Getting emotional wants to believe in them but just can't, and that fact hurts her
Joy's voice... 🫠
Who said Joy can't belt? Listen she can belt here.
Seulgi n joy voices have so much flavor
My favourite;
1:Joy (I can feel the pain in her verse)
2:Wendy (Powerful & Wonderful)
3:Seulgi (I really love her voice)
Joy ❤
everyone was part of these amazing lines
seulgi did back vocals in Wendy's part.
Irene in Seulgi's
and Yeri in Joy's
Wendy's back vocals in Joy, not yeri
@@je1337 noooo, it's herself
The backvocals for all of them are themselves. Irene took part in Seulgi's. But at the end with "your lies", those are backed up with Wendy's.
I like all version 😆
just red velvet thing's
Flexing on how they make it more perfect when it already perfect 😄
The part of Joy always have me like 😍
It's amazing how they show their emotions in vocals
Come on SM don't be shy, give Joy that promotion to Lead Vocalist alongside Seulgi.
She got more than seulgi.
She had more ost and collab song than seulgi. And recently for line distribution she get more than seulgi.
The thing is that, while Joy is an amazing vocalist, she is nowhere near being as good as Seulgi.
And Seulgi is not really on Wendy’s level yet, she struggled to sing Wendy’s parts in Psycho but was the only one who could actually sing them.
@@lioness6995 The thing is also that I wasn’t comparing her to Seulgi at all. She’s fine on her current vocal technique, can actually carry a tune with a decent support, and does great on the lines assigned to her.
They actually don’t have these fixed tbh
@@selenaazalea3604joy has no where as many collabs as seulgi does, seulgi has way more sm station and collabs within sm.
Joy came in the studio MAD. AS HELL.
joy needs to be a lead vocalist along with seulgi, her vocals are so underated. i get chills every time i listen to her voice, it's so unique and beautiful
@@lix.cloud_6483 the fact that she can be main vocalist in many groups out there
i think Joy is Lead Vocalist too
All of them, perfection. I have to say though, I get goosebumps when I hear Joy’s voice. You can hear the emotion.
My favorite female vocal line 💛💎💚
Joy deserves to be lead Vocalist! My girl vocals are amazing!
Joy omg ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
your vocals joyyyy
Seulgi and joy can be the main vocalist for other groups!!!
I love how Red Velvet have unique voices that are beautiful together, but are just so interesting and distinct in their own right.
Joy's vocal is already the MAIN VOCAL of some newer groups 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
They don't debut idols with power vocals anymore
Sounds like Irene backing up Seulgi too
seulgi did back vocals in Wendy's part.
Irene in Seulgi's
and Yeri in Joy's
@@arturomonasterio9371 Wendy and joy did the back vocals themselves on their part
@@arturomonasterio9371 actually Irene did the low note for (your lies) and (chaja) for all of them
Joy really be sounding like a princess, such a delicate vocal tone. It’s so lovely for the ear.
Wendy : goose bumps
Seulgi : chills
Joy. : takes breath away
Joy's part make me cry
I swear, joy’s part is my favorite
Joy’s voice is so beautiful
Love seulgi's version could feel raw anger in her voice
wendy resonance
seulgi absolutely siren
joy dreamy
Wendy vocal😭🫂🥰
Joy's tone is really pretty ❤
Joy hits diff
Joy has the prettiest tone omg
I think Joy's one is more iconic... That's how I remember the song being hahaha
The talent level is insanely great. Red Velvet is the most talented group in the industry. 💖💛💙💚💜
i like joy’s the most
I love the progression of vocals in the pre-chorus/bridge. The song is about the lover lying and them getting manipulated, and from Wendy to Seulgi to Joy, they break down even more. Authoritative to upset, to crying because they were lied to and fell for it.
I had never thought of it like that, now that I tie the emotions to each voice and how they executed them and portrayed them very well, especially joy imo, I’ve become more addicted to these parts
what song is this
@@ireneasare9552 Zoom, from the Birthday EP.
Seulgi Her tone is power and given feels good and bad I love this
red velvet has some of the best vocals out of any kpop girl group and you can never change my mind
Wendy - Suspicion and warnings
Seulgi - Certainty and anger
Joy - Betrayed and hurt
Joyaaa
Powerful vocalist
Joyyy meu coração um segundo por causa da sua voz angelical🎵🎤❤️🔥 Que voz maravilhosa, amei Joy
If I have to choose, I want Joy’s voice
Joy can be a lead vocal in itzy
In itzy she would be main😭
@@enahelg7730 yes
Main vocal in many groups
Main Vocal me thinks. 🙈🙈🤭
Main
Mreka yg nyanyi mreka juga yg jd paduan suaranya....keren mmg RV❤❤
Joy could only ever be a sub vocal in a group like Red Velvet. In any other group she would easily be lead or even main
I am legit getting goosebumps my hairs on my legs and arms stood up omg this is so beautiful
Wait omg Irene is doing the low ad libs for seulgi 🥺 my seulrene heart
Wendy has Fus Ro Dah in terms of powerful it is. Seulgi to she has a way of singing like a sensual sexy lady. Even though she is not how she is IRL. Joy can sing but is the actual sensual Sexy lady IRL.
My ranking
1. Joy
2. Wendy
3. Seulgi
Joy ate the song...by the way Seulgi's my bias
Omggg that's my video ❤❤ red velvet vocal line is amazing 💛💙💚
A voz da Joy sooa tão melancólica, é delicioso e sofrido!
so no one's talking about Irene's adlibs behind Seulgi voice?
That 3 vocals always expect them during bridges of their songs
Wendy: Perfection
Seulgi: Sweetness
Joy: Warmth
I REALLY LIKE JOY VOICE 😢😢😢😢❤❤❤❤
I dont think you can compare joy here she sang it as bridge not pre chorus. The tone was different in bridge then to pre chorus like seulgi and wendy sang
Sm has some of the best vocalists thats all i can say. I loveeeee Red Velvet with all my hearrrttt
wendy is the MAIN VOCAL for a reason
God damn I am a fan from the start and listened to this song for thousand of times and I am still getting goosebumps. THEY ARE GREAT. not good. GREAT.
song?
@@ireneasare9552zoom - red velvet
it's zoom from their birthday ep @@ireneasare9552
They slaps hard!!!
Team Rocket is just 🔥🔥🔥
I think Wendy's vocal character is close to Taeyeon while Seulgi's is close to Winter and Joy's is close to Ningning
Joy and Ningning are nothing alike💀
Very very addictive
For me Joy is a lead vocalist
Fight me
Wendy : Power
Seulgi : Tone
Joy : Emotion
Nothing less than amazing 😍
Wendy was really great omg❤
Seulgi>>>>>
JOY 😻✨
That's why I love these girls
okay but irenes adlibs during seulgis OMFFFF
joy is a lead vocalist
seulgi's voice is my fav
VOCAL QUEENS SLAY
Wendy: otw divorce
Seulgi: couldn't believe has to divorce
Joy: divorce for 308173626 times
It’s the way Joy as a sub vocal is leagues ahead of almost any 4th gen gg main vocal.
And yes, I know experience is a thing but still.
Not lily and ningning
uh.. no? seulgi sure but joy really isn’t “leagues ahead” of any 4th gen main vocals apart from the weak ones like sieun & lia
Hands down WENDY is my girl. Her voice touches me because it's heart felt as with
Joy's so tender and sweet.
Seulgi is very bright I think when she starts using dynamics and feeling, her singing will touch me too although her 28 Reasons was a killer.
Sm should fix their position though, joy really deserve that lead vocalist position.
Rv really stand for real vocal
Everyone talking about the song, but not the song title 💀
I was trying to look too but I'm p sure it's Zoom lmao
not a fan of red velvet, but their vocals are on another level
They singing together-
HEAVEN 💘
I love Joy's voice so much I can't describe it with words
wendy’s voice is always so clear ✨