The original lore had multiple sets of chaos emeralds for different islands and locations. They never needed to be consistent since they’re never the same set
To be fair, Battle seems to just be working with sprite limitations, as Tails mentions all the emerald shards needing to be 'of the same colour' to put them together, something that would be redundant if they were all green.
Fun fact, originally the islands from Sonic 1-3 had their own sets of emeralds. In 3 Knuckles takes West Island's set, and hide them along with the set already on Angel Island, the Super Emeralds. It's not canon now unless they decide to bring it back. But it would make everything fit together better up until Frontiers BUT the Master Emerald is really an open mystery. We need a lore master on that thing.
From my memory, the main Chaos Emeralds and Super Emeralds colors are: Green, Red, Blue, Yellow, Cyan, Purple and White And the fake Chaos Emeralds (Sonic X) are all: Black
- I agree with the more-than-seven concept, as far as a single set of emeralds for the entire world is concerned; I personally would first point out that Sonic 3 has *eight* emeralds in it, including both the "Golden" and Yellow emeralds that are allegedly both the same emerald. A rough estimate of mine would be 21 chaos emeralds, but there might be more or less... - In the anime "Sonic X", the eighth emerald is simply the seven merged together, but I would like to see the magenta emerald be seperate from the others. - To me, the "Golden" emerald from Sonic 3 looks orange in color, and having eight emeralds in the game continues adding one each game. - In my mind, the following emeralds exist (the same goes for the Chaos Rings, the Sol Emeralds, etc.)- Maroon Red (Knuckles) Vermillion Orange (Tails) Yellow (Ray; Bark) Chartreuse Green (Vector; Bean) Seafoam Turquoise Blue (Sonic) Indigo (Fang; Espio; Big) Purple Magenta Light Pink White Light Grey Dark Grey Black Platinum Gold Silver Bronze Iron Steel - To depict several of these using sprites from the games, one might turn to using the color palettes of the characters... See Above /\
Wasn't the 8th "emerald" that Fang was searching for actually something else? I don't remember what it was called, but it ended up not being a chaos emerald
So I always had a theory about why Robotnik had so many blue emeralds in Spinball; Only one was the original blue Chaos Emerald, and the rest were copies he'd made (I mean if Tails can make fake emeralds, so can Robotnik, right?) to power the Veg-O-Fortress. They were powerful enough to run machinery, but not powerful enough for Sonic to turn Super, hence Sonic taking them JUST to power down the fortress as he progresses upwards. Probably not a great theory, probably full of holes I'm not seeing, but it's the way I always figured it.
Spoilers for Fang #3 ... ... ... ... ... Despite Fang's best efforts, there doesn't seem to be an eighth Chaos Emerald at all. Turns out, so-called "eighth Emerald" might've actually been the Warp Topaz the whole time. Who knows... maybe Fang's mysterious informant might be a younger Dr. Starline?
But if we think about it, the chaos emeralds in sonic spin ball look a lot like time stones and they’re also blue just like the time stone eggman took at the end of sonic cd…coincidence?
you missed the 8th emerald in sonic 3 and sonic & Knuckles lol, granted it needs cheat codes to unlock the special stage but if memory serves its an orange yellow one and it has a super emerald counterpart so... sonic 1 they did 6 and sonic 2 did 7 and originally sonic 3 was gonna do 8 but then scrapped it down to 7 to try to be consistent across the now loved franchise but they go off in different directions all around...
You forgot the fleetway comics but ill do it for you theres seven chaos emarlds yellow orange blue purple grey red and green the green emarld is the master emarld
Spinball wasn't made by Sonic Team so is not really canon in the series, plus there's the fact that MS & GG games never have more then 6 emeralds, & are all blue in Sonic 1
@JustMaxT or in sonic 3 first purple was killed by cyan then it got revived and wanted to take its place back from cyan and they started fight but accidentally killed pink in process and decided to do a truce or else other emeralds saw that 1 is missing (emeralds are colorblind here)
@JustMaxT even if u won't "acknowledge the british" , its still a variant of the emeralds, if anything the only version that was missed. And ngl that was kinda racist , considering I have a british background in my family 💀
@@STClover in all seriousness I probably should’ve included them. I mainly didn’t because they’re so similar to the normal emeralds, but you’re right, there are some distinct differences I should’ve acknowledged 😅
The original lore had multiple sets of chaos emeralds for different islands and locations. They never needed to be consistent since they’re never the same set
True and Sega abandoned it and just put 7 emeralds and sonic adventure retcon this
SPINBALL IS CANON, MAXTON MAXWELL SAID SO
I speak the word of god
EVERYTHINGS CANNON
SO I GUESS IM CANNON IN SONIC
@@JustMaxTall hail Maxwell all hail Maxwell
iirc it's canon with the exception of the SATAM character cameos.
@@CMJ06NAH that means all the cringe sonic media is cannon 💀
Emerald colors
* Blue
* Green
* Yellow
* Red
* White
* Pink
* Purple
* Cyan
* Violet
* Orange
* Light Yellow
* Turquoise
* Vermilion
* Black
14 emeralds, so what form would come out of that? Super Duper Sonic?
@@SonicTheBlueFastBoiSonic collects 14 emeralds in sonic 3
@@shellder_gaming The Super Emeralds ain’t canon apparently, they were just a reward for the people who had already collected the Chaos Emeralds
Final color blaster!
@@SonicTheBlueFastBoi their canon in my a**
Battle has all the Chaos Emeralds be green and 8 bit Sonic 1 has them all be light blue.
Shit
To be fair, Battle seems to just be working with sprite limitations, as Tails mentions all the emerald shards needing to be 'of the same colour' to put them together, something that would be redundant if they were all green.
Spinball was confirmed canon by ian flynn, origins and sonic channel (multiple times)
and by nokai
Perhaps it is the forgotten emeralds that power each member of the dodeca-needle. Perhaps they hold more emeralds than we could ever comprehend.
THE 30.5-NEEDLE
@@JustMaxT My god, what have we done?
@@Denymeister we’ve created a monster…
Fun fact: Spinball is canon along with the IDW comics.
Big day for Nokai
Hmmmmm
The comics are, Spinball is not
@Half-Blood_Hufflepuff it was confirmed by ian
@@mediamuncher69 Spinball isn't canon.
every island had its own set of emeralds until adventure rolled around.
Everyone's always asking how many chaos emeralds??
The REAL question is how ARE the chaos emeralds!?
Please tell me the pink one made it home safe....
Chaos Emeralds said they're doing fine and appreciate the check-in
@@JustMaxT oh thank god 🙏
Cyan snook in 1994
I ate the pink one
@@campbell_soup517 you sicken me
Lets not forget the anarchy beryl (Its what they call the chaos emeralds in Scourges Dimension)
Imagine Sonic gathers an indefinite amount of chaos emeralds across the entire franchise. I bet he'll turn into Super Diabetes Sonic or somethin idk
4:03 "WHATS WRONG WITH YOU? WHY ARE YOU BLUE?
Wait, you talked about the comics but completely ignored the Fleetway comics?
I’m not British I forgot, also they’re the same as the normal ones almost (I think)
Fun fact, originally the islands from Sonic 1-3 had their own sets of emeralds. In 3 Knuckles takes West Island's set, and hide them along with the set already on Angel Island, the Super Emeralds.
It's not canon now unless they decide to bring it back. But it would make everything fit together better up until Frontiers BUT the Master Emerald is really an open mystery.
We need a lore master on that thing.
In sonic CD you have 7 time stones and collecting them all you don't Get anything except for the good ending😂
From my memory, the main Chaos Emeralds and Super Emeralds colors are: Green, Red, Blue, Yellow, Cyan, Purple and White
And the fake Chaos Emeralds (Sonic X) are all:
Black
Also i think that blue emerald is the only emerald that exists in every sonic game with emeralds
- I agree with the more-than-seven concept, as far as a single set of emeralds for the entire world is concerned; I personally would first point out that Sonic 3 has *eight* emeralds in it, including both the "Golden" and Yellow emeralds that are allegedly both the same emerald. A rough estimate of mine would be 21 chaos emeralds, but there might be more or less...
- In the anime "Sonic X", the eighth emerald is simply the seven merged together, but I would like to see the magenta emerald be seperate from the others.
- To me, the "Golden" emerald from Sonic 3 looks orange in color, and having eight emeralds in the game continues adding one each game.
- In my mind, the following emeralds exist (the same goes for the Chaos Rings, the Sol Emeralds, etc.)-
Maroon
Red (Knuckles)
Vermillion
Orange (Tails)
Yellow (Ray; Bark)
Chartreuse
Green (Vector; Bean)
Seafoam
Turquoise
Blue (Sonic)
Indigo (Fang; Espio; Big)
Purple
Magenta
Light Pink
White
Light Grey
Dark Grey
Black
Platinum
Gold
Silver
Bronze
Iron
Steel
- To depict several of these using sprites from the games, one might turn to using the color palettes of the characters...
See Above /\
I feel like people who say pinball is canon
Forget that doesn't mean the 16 emeralds are canon
They're just game mechanics
Not a part of story
Btw, in Sonic Chronicles, the white emerald turns pink on one of the colonies you explore ‘cuz it’s infused with the specie’s energy
Mania changed their colors again.
Ayyy! A fellow Dark Sonic fanboy!
Good to see another, it seems like there are less and less of us each day
Wasn't the 8th "emerald" that Fang was searching for actually something else? I don't remember what it was called, but it ended up not being a chaos emerald
@@nwing265 I have no idea, I think it might’ve been revealed after this video came out but I don’t remember finding any info on it
@@JustMaxT Maybe that's it, or maybe my memory of the IDW comics are foggy because I haven't read them in so long
So I always had a theory about why Robotnik had so many blue emeralds in Spinball; Only one was the original blue Chaos Emerald, and the rest were copies he'd made (I mean if Tails can make fake emeralds, so can Robotnik, right?) to power the Veg-O-Fortress. They were powerful enough to run machinery, but not powerful enough for Sonic to turn Super, hence Sonic taking them JUST to power down the fortress as he progresses upwards. Probably not a great theory, probably full of holes I'm not seeing, but it's the way I always figured it.
it might actually be 13.5 as the ones in spinball is actually a broken emerald
I got some theories first off the pink emerald is just the cyan emerald in pink paint😅
I believe it
I have a faint memory of playing Sonic Jump 6-7 years ago... Oh well.
I'm surprised you didn't bring up the movie emeralds.
Spoilers for Fang #3
...
...
...
...
...
Despite Fang's best efforts, there doesn't seem to be an eighth Chaos Emerald at all. Turns out, so-called "eighth Emerald" might've actually been the Warp Topaz the whole time. Who knows... maybe Fang's mysterious informant might be a younger Dr. Starline?
But if we think about it, the chaos emeralds in sonic spin ball look a lot like time stones and they’re also blue just like the time stone eggman took at the end of sonic cd…coincidence?
Bro thinks hes chaomix💀💀
Chaomix thinks he’s me
@@JustMaxT My mistake original gangster
@@JustMaxT Naw it dosent matter, both of yall are goats
@@JustMaxTyou do not enough authority to compare yourself to him
@@flowersgoodsmel8996 chaomix and I chillin, he’s aware we both had the same video idea
2:24 | Its not the pink one replaced. ( look at ur left in the time-stamp. ) its the purple. |
Wiki said pink wiki never lies
You forgot the chaos emeralds in Vectorman (which also has items in TVs) which is included in the Sonic Gems Collection making it canon!
VECTOR THE CROCODILE?!?!?!
WHAT chaos Emeralds in "Vectorman"?
HONEY, HONEY HE’S BACK!!!!!
BACK AND BETTER THAN EVER (maybe)
I DO, in fact, REMEMBER.
you missed the 8th emerald in sonic 3 and sonic & Knuckles lol, granted it needs cheat codes to unlock the special stage but if memory serves its an orange yellow one and it has a super emerald counterpart so... sonic 1 they did 6 and sonic 2 did 7 and originally sonic 3 was gonna do 8 but then scrapped it down to 7 to try to be consistent across the now loved franchise but they go off in different directions all around...
You forgot the fleetway comics but ill do it for you theres seven chaos emarlds yellow orange blue purple grey red and green the green emarld is the master emarld
1:55 that’s *grey*
Heh, wait till you see how they look in sonic labyrinth.
Forgot about time stones and dream stones lol
Dream Stones?
@Half-Blood_Hufflepuff sorry I meant precious stones and force jewels from Sonic Shuffle.
Terrible names. I will forget those.
chaos emeralds
Archie Comics Sonic The Hedgehig had many and then they were combined into 7 Chaos Emeralds
i know i talked about this
Spinball wasn't made by Sonic Team so is not really canon in the series, plus there's the fact that MS & GG games never have more then 6 emeralds, & are all blue in Sonic 1
🤓 ☝
"Rem well exactly thats a light blueish color not a cyan color."
2:28
2:28
The white emerald is actually grey.
One game has like 12 I think
2:24 dude its pink one so cyan actually killed purple one
Wiki don’t lie 🤷♂️
@JustMaxT or in sonic 3 first purple was killed by cyan then it got revived and wanted to take its place back from cyan and they started fight but accidentally killed pink in process and decided to do a truce or else other emeralds saw that 1 is missing (emeralds are colorblind here)
@@DanialProhozdenia what
@JustMaxT it's about as easy as trying to figure out is storybooks are canon
Is it the Sol Emeralds? I just started the video
no
2:24 dude duh there’s already a pink emerald the cyan emerald replaced the purple one
I will admit that the emerald in 3 does look pink, but the wiki lists it as purple and the wiki never lies
@@JustMaxToh ok my fault
what about super emeralds
chaos emeralds
what?
Yo buddy you forgot sonic the comic, check the wiki 😭
I refuse to acknowledge the British
@JustMaxT
even if u won't "acknowledge the british" , its still a variant of the emeralds, if anything the only version that was missed. And ngl that was kinda racist , considering I have a british background in my family 💀
@@STClover i do too bro
@@STClover in all seriousness I probably should’ve included them. I mainly didn’t because they’re so similar to the normal emeralds, but you’re right, there are some distinct differences I should’ve acknowledged 😅
@@JustMaxT naw dw ur cool lol
perhaps some things should stay forgotten
1:18 that’s *grey*
Max is not slick getting the vid idea from Chaomix. 😂
I wrote this two months ago
Implying that a topic can only be discussed once
I did not enjoy this video at all
I love you
Fun fact there are more emeralds than in this video
About the super emeralds
decent video, good editing
Thank you