This song literally gives me goosebump. It has that kinda vibe of regretful yet beautiful memories and desires, that made me feel touched. Love it so much
Me too. I'm just 13 years old and I never have a love before but this song really touch my feelings this is my favorite song in this album so far ❤💛💙💚💜
i relate to the lyrics so bad. ever since I came out to my parents they treat me as if I'm not their son anymore, but in my dreams they still love me. damn red velvet u gonna make me cry :(
Not you and this song making me cry right now!😢 fyi i now it doesn't feel like it but deep down I'm sure they do love you. I hope and pray they come around to accept you for who you are but as long as you love and accept yourself you'll be ok. Sending a big hug your way.
The lyricist for this song is actually a news anchor from S.K. It is amazing how a news anchorcan create such beautiful lyrics thanks to their vast knowledge of words and talent too. If I remember correctly, Yeri and Seulgi said that this is their favorite song in this album too.
This is my new fave RV song, it’s so melancholy but bittersweet, they are sorrowful yet they are happy that at least in their dreams they can be loved ughhh a masterpiece
This is the first kpop song that I can relate. This song reminds me of a certain person who’s constantly coming into my dreams. The lyrics are telling about my situation right now. I wanna cry, cuz this is so beautiful.
Totally I met a person who I was so close to him but I couldn't touch him, I loved him and yes in my dreams he loved me back, I dreamed of him every night, now I dont see him any more and it hurts, and this song is just perfect for the love that he left hanging
same...I thought I had moved on but for some reason they keep appearing in my dreams for nights in a row, and it's always the same "in my dreams you love me back"
I LOVE this song. It's so dreamlike, the harmonisation oh god. The only thing that I wish they would change is to lower the volume of instrumentals in certain parts including the chorus cause it drowns the girls vocals. Which is unfortunate because the harmonisation on those parts are heavenly and I would appreciate it if I could hear it more
Unfortunately SM is notorious for overly processing the vocals or drowning them out in songs >< it drives me crazy because I love the songs but want to hear their voices more clearly.
0:431:40 these parts through the whole song creeped me out. they sang it like they are in front of a magic mirror wishing SURELY to win that love back. And, it also sounded like a glitch in a vinyl record cuz the music stopped abruptly and began again, with that freaking tone of a voice. Scared me up.
1:40 This part. Irene slayed her part. It is hauntingly beautiful and you can also feel bittersweet in that line. Need more of her deep voice in their future songs. 😍
This song is perfection, yeri and seulgi harmonizing in the bridge, seulgi’s highnote, joy and Irene’s lower register pre chorus, Wendy’s final chorus, it’s all just perfect!
This song is goosebumps material, such a beautiful piece. No doubt is my favourite from the album, I can't stop listening to it, the vocals are so touching and beautiful, the lyrics, everything about it is so touching. I'm glad to see so many loving the song as much as I do.
When Harvard Crimson posted an article about this saying Irene's "In my dreams" part is hauntingly beautiful. Confirming that it IS HAUNTINGLY Beautiful. I feel the tone & pressure there.
This song is soooo good. I love the rich low notes and the harmonies of their voices goshh it’s soo satisfying.. feels creamy yet velvety. And Wendy’s high notes at the end 😭 I hope to hear them perform this live someday!! 🙏🙏🙏
The harmonisation of the line starting at 2:59 is everything, it literally makes me tear up it's so beautiful. The way they sing the word "back" in that line is just so so beautiful.
I hate how relatable this is, I have a crush on this guy 3 years older than me who's leaving my school next month. I had so many opportunities to talk to him because we were in a play together but now the plays over, I've missed all my opportunities to interact with him and its only now that I'm realising how much I like him :(
If there is anything true on this earth it is that there will never ever be another Red Velvet. Their voices are truly once in a lifetime. This is probably some of Seulgi's best vocals. Her voice absolutely shook me at 2:28.
One of the best songs they've ever done. It's haunting and reminds me of something interpretive dancers would perform to. The ending gives me chills, perfect.
This has to be the most beautiful vocals I've heard in this album! Like, listen to them harmonies! And wendy kept slaying me with that airy, majestic, classy voice she has! I'M IN LOVE
This is my favourite track, I love it so much. It gives me a Maleficent vibes or any other villains who wants to be love by the main lead but sadly end up becoming cruel and vile due to their unrequited love. Man, I read too much villainess manhwas that reflects this kind of song. I love it so much❤️❤️❤️
This song must hit those stans hard who love their idols so much and dreams of being with them all the time, who fantasize a lot. On the other hand, it also hits hard those who already breaked up with their partner but still can't move on. THIS SONG IS MASTERPIECE & TOUCHING.
I've heard every Red Velvet songs but this gives me so much goosebumps like I WANNA CRY!!! I wanna hear the hidden vocals. The producers should've lowered the volume on the chorus and bridge part so that the harmonization the girls can be heard
somehow im imagining this song as disney princess ost. especially at part "in my dream you love me back" throwing me back to sleeping beauty's 'once upon a dream' vibe. cmon sm x disney collab dont be shy 💕
Why do I imagine this being a song of a couple who break up because one of them has lost their feelings for the other yet the other is still in love especially in Yeri's part 0:36, praying that the other person who left to stay forever with them although they know it's over already. So they always dream about the other person to reciprocate their feelings yet at the same time knows that it's the only place where they'll be love by that person. It's them knowing that they'll never get that love again
My favorite! It's so magical and makes my heart melts everytime. This song is so sad but at the same time it's so beautiful. I really love it 😫 It's also giving me disney vibes. The harmonization is heavenly. They all nailed it! I'm so proud of them, they never disappoint me 💕
GUESS RED VELVET SONGS ✨
ua-cam.com/video/bTlTXpEvm5Y/v-deo.html
🖤TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@hansacreative
This song literally gives me goosebump. It has that kinda vibe of regretful yet beautiful memories and desires, that made me feel touched. Love it so much
Me too. I'm just 13 years old and I never have a love before but this song really touch my feelings this is my favorite song in this album so far ❤💛💙💚💜
Yeah it brings such bittersweet Nostalgia
as expected from red velvet, they’re true artists, not just an idol group following trends❤ 💯
This is my favorite track from the albums so far! It sounds like a disney lullaby and a villain's song at the same time. I love it! 💕
this track kinda familiar bcus it sounds like disney song.. but i cant remember which movie..
@@lyazhr4802 kinda similar to 'once upon a dream' even the vibe of the song. That's also my favorite disney song~
@@mahnameisraine i remember... this song hv similar vibe with dreamwork movie.. how to train your dragon.
Same feels
yes you right
Red Velvet ending tracks always hit hard
Like hello sunset
@@justinkent9338 omg yess I love that one!
FACTS!
LP too
that is 100% fact
Literally my favourite track in the album. There's such chilling, unnerving beauty in this song, like perfectly depicting the flavour of RV
this is japanese album //
i relate to the lyrics so bad. ever since I came out to my parents they treat me as if I'm not their son anymore, but in my dreams they still love me. damn red velvet u gonna make me cry :(
I'm so sorry they feel that way towards you. just remember that people care about you and you are loved! 🤗🤗
@@eval7577 thank you for your kind words :)
That was so brave of you for doing that! You don't deserve to be treated like that :( I hope you'll feel better and be healed as time goes by.
@@vouzmevoyez__8442 thank you so much 😊
Not you and this song making me cry right now!😢 fyi i now it doesn't feel like it but deep down I'm sure they do love you. I hope and pray they come around to accept you for who you are but as long as you love and accept yourself you'll be ok. Sending a big hug your way.
The lyricist for this song is actually a news anchor from S.K. It is amazing how a news anchorcan create such beautiful lyrics thanks to their vast knowledge of words and talent too. If I remember correctly, Yeri and Seulgi said that this is their favorite song in this album too.
Oh wow
a news anchor?? wow…
This song sits prettily on top of the "best bside in K-pop" list, alongside RV’s very own "Kingdom Come".
Same!!!!
Ahh yes, the Kingdom Come appreciation!💝 I love that song so much!!!!!
yessssssssssssssssss oh absolutely!!!
This is my new fave RV song, it’s so melancholy but bittersweet, they are sorrowful yet they are happy that at least in their dreams they can be loved ughhh a masterpiece
This is the first kpop song that I can relate. This song reminds me of a certain person who’s constantly coming into my dreams. The lyrics are telling about my situation right now. I wanna cry, cuz this is so beautiful.
Same..... F* with that guy in my dreams dnt even know him but he makes me cry.
Agree.. I'm literally crying when i first listen to it... That "in my dream you love me back" at the beginning of the song hit hard
Totally I met a person who I was so close to him but I couldn't touch him, I loved him and yes in my dreams he loved me back, I dreamed of him every night, now I dont see him any more and it hurts, and this song is just perfect for the love that he left hanging
yall are making me cry
same...I thought I had moved on but for some reason they keep appearing in my dreams for nights in a row, and it's always the same "in my dreams you love me back"
I LOVE this song. It's so dreamlike, the harmonisation oh god. The only thing that I wish they would change is to lower the volume of instrumentals in certain parts including the chorus cause it drowns the girls vocals. Which is unfortunate because the harmonisation on those parts are heavenly and I would appreciate it if I could hear it more
Unfortunately SM is notorious for overly processing the vocals or drowning them out in songs >< it drives me crazy because I love the songs but want to hear their voices more clearly.
💞
This song is supposed to sound a bit drowning and suffocating and it gives to the overall tone of the track.
I think its supposed to do that
i mean like you got what the song trying to portray
The pre-chrorus of this song sounds like Cinderella's 'A Dream is a Wish Your Heart Makes', so beautiful, one of my favorite Disney songs♡
i think it also sounded like once upon a dreams in sleeping beauty
0:43 1:40 these parts through the whole song creeped me out. they sang it like they are in front of a magic mirror wishing SURELY to win that love back. And, it also sounded like a glitch in a vinyl record cuz the music stopped abruptly and began again, with that freaking tone of a voice. Scared me up.
it’s giving “Once upon a dream” vibe. That’s why it sounded magic and creepy
Because of the fairytale vibes and instrumentals this song fits so well to the real story of the little mermaid. What an intantaneous classic!!!!
irene’s lower register at 1:40 is just 🤌🏼✨ she really came out of monster era for a hot minute to slay
1:40 This part. Irene slayed her part. It is hauntingly beautiful and you can also feel bittersweet in that line. Need more of her deep voice in their future songs. 😍
This song is perfection, yeri and seulgi harmonizing in the bridge, seulgi’s highnote, joy and Irene’s lower register pre chorus, Wendy’s final chorus, it’s all just perfect!
One of my favorite songs on the album. I love Joy's lower register from 0:43. Her tone really is like jade beads rolling.
This song is goosebumps material, such a beautiful piece. No doubt is my favourite from the album, I can't stop listening to it, the vocals are so touching and beautiful, the lyrics, everything about it is so touching. I'm glad to see so many loving the song as much as I do.
This has to be my favourite song in the album. It's so RedVelvet
When Harvard Crimson posted an article about this saying Irene's "In my dreams" part is hauntingly beautiful. Confirming that it IS HAUNTINGLY Beautiful. I feel the tone & pressure there.
“ in my dreams you love me back “ by Irene gives me the same feeling of listening to Lana Del Rey’s “once upon a dream”
YESSS SAME THOUGHT
i really love that part
SHUT UP --
This song is soooo good. I love the rich low notes and the harmonies of their voices goshh it’s soo satisfying.. feels creamy yet velvety. And Wendy’s high notes at the end 😭 I hope to hear them perform this live someday!! 🙏🙏🙏
THEY WILL!!!
@@ayeshalaxa2683 yessss I just saw the news! Ahhhhh so happy and excited!
Yeri leading the chorus 🧎♂️🧎♂️🧎♂️🛐
The harmonisation of the line starting at 2:59 is everything, it literally makes me tear up it's so beautiful. The way they sing the word "back" in that line is just so so beautiful.
I hate how relatable this is, I have a crush on this guy 3 years older than me who's leaving my school next month. I had so many opportunities to talk to him because we were in a play together but now the plays over, I've missed all my opportunities to interact with him and its only now that I'm realising how much I like him :(
I got goosebumps the moment Seulgi start off the song and I love it when they sang "In my dreams you love me back" all together !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1:18 The flow in this part is just ✨
Best part..wendy killed it
2:52 this part is sooo beautiful 😭😭 the way wendy hit that note "in my dreams" and the "woOoOhh~" makes my heart happy 😩💙
my favorite part!!!!
Red Velvet b-side tracks truly never disappointed
1:40 Irene sang it in a perfect villain's voice
I LOVE IRENE'S LOWER REGISTER SOOO MUCH😭
If there is anything true on this earth it is that there will never ever be another Red Velvet. Their voices are truly once in a lifetime.
This is probably some of Seulgi's best vocals. Her voice absolutely shook me at 2:28.
Wow this song gives me goosebumps. Each lyrics and melodies are hardly enchanting
My second most favourite track in the album after feel my rhythm cause this song is totally my type😍😍😍😍I can't stop playing this
One of the best songs they've ever done. It's haunting and reminds me of something interpretive dancers would perform to. The ending gives me chills, perfect.
me when i lie
This is my favorite track from the albums so far! It sounds like a disney lullaby, fairytale and a villain's song at the same time. I love it
yes, it sounds like 'a dream is a wish your heart makes'
*My fav b-side and song on the album it's very relaxing*
I hear seulgi everywhere in this album and this song 🥺 so beautiful!
They all did so wonderfully. RV, The most talented.
This has to be the most beautiful vocals I've heard in this album! Like, listen to them harmonies! And wendy kept slaying me with that airy, majestic, classy voice she has! I'M IN LOVE
2:56 i'm in tears, it's so beautiful. the instrumental and lyrics are crazy good.
This is my favourite track, I love it so much. It gives me a Maleficent vibes or any other villains who wants to be love by the main lead but sadly end up becoming cruel and vile due to their unrequited love. Man, I read too much villainess manhwas that reflects this kind of song. I love it so much❤️❤️❤️
i need red velvet to perform this live. i can now imagine their vocals, harmonization will dominate the whole media.
Music Bank this week
Tomorrow 🥰
This song must hit those stans hard who love their idols so much and dreams of being with them all the time, who fantasize a lot. On the other hand, it also hits hard those who already breaked up with their partner but still can't move on. THIS SONG IS MASTERPIECE & TOUCHING.
Me after hearing the first 10sec was like 'this is my fav song in the album!!!!!!'
me too me too!!!
SAME SAME SAME !!!!!
the emotions this song gives me are immaculate. it's insane how it makes my imaginations run wild. i already have a music video for it in my head.
Joy’s “In my dreams you love me back” is like a disney princess song
So beautiful, eventho the song is aesthetically sad, still soooo beautiful. How Red Velvet portray a sadness into an sophisticated art!
this only shows that even in low register red velvet is still the ace
This is real music, red velvet never disappoints. Bamboleo and In My Dreams best songs
seulgi to joy line starting from 1:26 is sooooo satisfying 💕💕💕
I know they all sing the chorus but I love how I can clearly hear Yeri
their still love you hits different. 🥺🥺
Nah we need a live performance for this! This really sounds so good. It makes me feel heartache but also sound sweet at the same time.
We'll have one this Friday on music bank.
@@kate7912 WE WILL👀👄
@@Ireneisbae it’s out!
my fav b side. it's so hauntingly beautiful!!!!!! I'm so happy they choose to perform this song!
I need an MV for this 😭 This hurt me as much as Wish Tree did!!
I love this song so much! It is so beautiful!
I've heard every Red Velvet songs but this gives me so much goosebumps like I WANNA CRY!!! I wanna hear the hidden vocals. The producers should've lowered the volume on the chorus and bridge part so that the harmonization the girls can be heard
absolutely beautiful!!! their voices send you to sleep and dream of rv!!!
My favourite song from the album, the harmonies and their vocals in general are just 😍
This is the best song I've heard so far in 2022. Such a banger.
having a mental breakdown so time to listen to this banger 😍
full on sobbing rn
yeri's voice 😭😭😭💭💭💭💭♥️👌🏻
Gosh. It is so painfully beautiful. This song hurts but I don't wanna move on from this.
somehow im imagining this song as disney princess ost. especially at part "in my dream you love me back" throwing me back to sleeping beauty's 'once upon a dream' vibe. cmon sm x disney collab dont be shy 💕
I listen to this like 10x today,,, another masterpieceeee, its disney a-like.
I heard they gonna perform this live 😭 I can't wait. This is my fave bside in the album
Why do I imagine this being a song of a couple who break up because one of them has lost their feelings for the other yet the other is still in love especially in Yeri's part 0:36, praying that the other person who left to stay forever with them although they know it's over already. So they always dream about the other person to reciprocate their feelings yet at the same time knows that it's the only place where they'll be love by that person. It's them knowing that they'll never get that love again
So beautiful. Easily my fave in the album. Relatable lyrics, beautiful melodies and harmonies, epic instrumentation. 🧡
The harmonisation in this song is so sick!!!! It always give me goosebumps each time I listen to it 😭😭
If like, Cinderella fell in love with the prince but this one person she thought would love her, didn't.
the lyrics are so pretty... song is so pretty... vocals are so pretty... 💕
2:06 on repeat 😭🥺
A review said Irene's "in my dreams you love me back" line is hauntingly beautiful and I couldn't agree more
My favorite! It's so magical and makes my heart melts everytime. This song is so sad but at the same time it's so beautiful. I really love it 😫 It's also giving me disney vibes. The harmonization is heavenly. They all nailed it! I'm so proud of them, they never disappoint me 💕
2:53 TO 3:03 IS GORGEOUS
Heard this as I was skimming through the new album and it was an instant YES. Saved the best for last.
2:30 seulgi here is like opening a happy ending door
0:58 the Harmonizing of our Queens 😱
This is god tier 😭😭
This deserves a English version!
2:08 the best part for me ✨
The "in my dreams you love me back" has this cinderella/snow white vibe and i love it so much
I just know that if they perform this at any year end awards show/concert everyone's gonna be still and mesmerized by their heavenly vocals.
2:07 👌
Instant classic. The last song on the album is the best on the album. Wow. And Wendy, holy cr@p... She's my ultimate vocal bias
2:52 is just surreal her adliibs always gives CHILLSS
that is Son Seungwan for everyone 💙
Even when they started the song... i just cant control my shiversss
joy’s voice is so beautiful here 0:43
this song is beautiful definitely my fav from this album :)
best song on the album no cap
I literally play this song in full volume it's so beautiful
this song is so dramatic i love it
those opening harmonies I’m so stuck on this song wow
The way they putted in my dreams and beg for me in one album shows that this is their best mini album so far! Like those are such top-tier bsides!!
This song screams a one sided, painful, but you don’t care typa of love, you do a lot for this person he/she uses you but u still love them…..CUZ SAME
It seems that everyone’s voice improved and I love it
Wow they couldn't have released this song at a more perfect time in my life, personally.
I'm crazy or Yeri it's really the main voice in the chorus? All I can hear it's her voice. Especially in the highest parts.
This gives me so much goosebumps, it souds so magical and beautiful and also sad
Such simple words. Such great impact
0:43
For me✌