Them all singing together like this, and both Twilight and Dusk Shine saying Princess Cadance makes it sound like they're all in the same universe helping out... And I LOVE that! :D
And there goes my heart! I swear, this is one of my favorite MLP FiM songs by far! And to hear philsterman sing it...oh Discord, words can't even describe it! Thanks for making my day!
I love this version! It... I don't know, it sounded more complete. I've always loved your vids but DAYUMN this is a good one! I found myself bouncing along. Granted there are (always) some tweaks that can be made. Now, with that said and done, it's still a wonderful, richer, fuller sounding song. I commend you on great work.
Haha, I absolutely loved it!!! This is one of my absolute favorite songs! Hearing a duet with it makes it all the more amazing! The funny thing I see in this is the male Apple Jack. I find it hilarious to see it, cause a colt Apple Jack actually appeared on the newest episode for today
It's hard to separate harmony six different ways, by character and musically...I tried to separate them 2 x 3: 2 characters per each musical cadence. So in sight of this, I do what I can, also, I unintentionally added a vibrato to Elusive because he tends to be more operatic so it probably makes it sound out of tune as opposed to adding texture
You are absolutely amazing! You give every character you play their own voice, and that is especially hard with singing especially! You're just amazing!
Fair enough. We do seem to have similar ideas about it (the Mane Twelve all teaming up to help Cadance with... whatever the problem is). Personally, I felt like this was one of the numbers where it would have been fine for the colts to just sing along due to it being an ensemble song about working together, but I can understand where you're coming from. It probably wouldn't bug me so much if some of the girls had their own unique parts as well, but maybe that's just me.
Also, since the episode is far from being revealed I want to pick you imagination, I have gotten critiques on previous versions of duets where the guys sound like they just are background or unnecessary. This was an effort to make people imagine that they showed up to help Princess Cadence and would then be guest characters and probably would comment and enjoy themselves with the Mane 6
8 years old... And I'm still crying, a lot of time has passed.
Long live On the Cross and Arrow!
i love how they actually bothered to harmonize, not just transpose down an octave.
Them all singing together like this, and both Twilight and Dusk Shine saying Princess Cadance makes it sound like they're all in the same universe helping out...
And I LOVE that! :D
Dude this was freaking awesome! You were really good at not only harmonizing but adding personality to each character. Keep at it.
And there goes my heart! I swear, this is one of my favorite MLP FiM songs by far! And to hear philsterman sing it...oh Discord, words can't even describe it! Thanks for making my day!
I love this version! It... I don't know, it sounded more complete. I've always loved your vids but DAYUMN this is a good one! I found myself bouncing along. Granted there are (always) some tweaks that can be made.
Now, with that said and done, it's still a wonderful, richer, fuller sounding song. I commend you on great work.
Haha, I absolutely loved it!!! This is one of my absolute favorite songs! Hearing a duet with it makes it all the more amazing! The funny thing I see in this is the male Apple Jack. I find it hilarious to see it, cause a colt Apple Jack actually appeared on the newest episode for today
This sounds amazing!
It's hard to separate harmony six different ways, by character and musically...I tried to separate them 2 x 3: 2 characters per each musical cadence. So in sight of this, I do what I can, also, I unintentionally added a vibrato to Elusive because he tends to be more operatic so it probably makes it sound out of tune as opposed to adding texture
I love how Elusive and AppleJack sound ^^o I love the others too but so far those two are my absolute fav!
You are absolutely amazing! You give every character you play their own voice, and that is especially hard with singing especially! You're just amazing!
I love how you can hear the mare and colt cuz most people they make it so you can hear the colt and the mare you can't o
Rainbow bliz and dusk shine is sorta cute
they r!
BEST YET! I always look forward to these things because they're always absolutely brilliant!
Awesome as always, Philsterman! I especially loved the chorus parts between the 12 of them. =)
I'll get requests and I use them for character practice so I usually try to pick ones that allow me to work on the character types thoroughly ^^
AJ sounded like markaplier
no
More like matpat doing a country accent
This was amazing.
You did an amazing job!
and I love the small additions too, it really adds to the piece.
That 12-part harmony... it's why I can't stop listening to this.
Best Colt/Mare duet so far
Phil... This is beyond awesome! You sound like you've gotten better lately, too.
I like how Twilight Sparkle and her friends sing with their male opposites, especially with Rarity heard singing with her male opposite, Elusive.
It's rare that I get shivers from music, but this was awesome!
I've heard a lot of your covers and this one is my favourite, I really love it :D
FINALLY! Someone who understands that taking the original VA down three notes doesn't make a duet. you're the bomb
I'm really looking forward to your r63 true true friend. Nobody can do it like Phil can!
OMG!!!! Butterscotch is so cute! If I met a guy like Butterscotch, I would ask him to marry me! lol
Secret Identity im running away now
You are amazing phil =D I have listened to this non-stop for 2 days now. Your duet cover is awesome.
Great awesome job! I just wish this song was longer. This just became my favorite. It has so much potential
SO AMAZING AND BEAUTIFUL! :D I got chills with Twilight and Dusk Shine's singing @_@ Very well done! :3
Awesome! This is the best duet I have ever heard in my life! Keep it up!
Wow I see much improvement compared to your earlier works! Keep up the good job! -3
You'r best Cross and Arrow Duet yet!
You did a great job harmonizing :)
I really enjoy this i think you did an awesome job with matching the voices to the characters attitude well done sir :D
Excellent work as always nice to listen to and catchy. Congratulations on another excellent work
this is one of my favorite songs
Probably some of the best vocals for the male counterparts so far, that I've heard (all in tandem that is) Pat on the back for you good sir.
I loved AJ's part. And the parts where ALL of them are singing is amazing. O u O
Ack!
I don't normally like On a cross and arrow stuff...
but this was beautiful!
Do the colt versions of the mane six remind anyone of any countries from Hetalia? No? Ok.... *Jumps into a pile of Manga*
Me too *jumps into a pile of anime instead
XDD Yay! Someone understands!
YAY *jumps into lots of Manga and Anime*
This complete blew me away...TOO MUCH EPICNESS!!!!
wow, love how in sync you made this.
10 years later
This was an amazing duet possibly the best one ever!! :D
wasnt expecting u to do these so soon but still great work
Oh dear, this song
Brilliant!
Next Suggestion (when you have the time): The falling scene from Secret of my Excess ... ? Please and thank you!
I love this. I've listened to this so many times. :)
I would like to state that this is probably the best "duet" yet
this is so good i can't stop replaying it.
That's awesome ! Good job phil ! ♥
This is awesome! This the best colt version fandub i ever heard!
i love rainbow dash and rainbow blitz
and cool music ;)
yeah same
Pia Grom I don't like them... I LOVE THEM!!!
Pia Grom g
Pia Grom i do to
this is amazing i love the harmony its so good
WOW. This is...better than I thought it would be.
This sounds so Awesome! I love it
I've been waiting for this!
Sounds perfect! Love it!
I have to look for it. I had no idea about that fanfic. Thanks for telling me! :-)
i love all of them!!!!!
0-0 wow this was......well......AMAZING! HOW DO U DO TYHIS
This is awesome !
wait! you did all of the colts!!!! THATS AMAZING!!!!!!
I like rainbowdash's colt version it sounds cool
0:32 *grins*
Oh that's cute, you even did the sheep genderswap! :D
REPLY, REPLY, REPLY....
LOVE THIS SO!!!
Hmm, never really been into the whole colt/mare diet thing, but this was made very well, really good job
Can anyone else see all of the ponies with their colt version as a couple..?
especially flutter shy and butterscotch
Bravelove Meow
Agreed. Rainbow Dash and Blitz are a close second.
Pinkie Pie i wuv dis woohoo i wuv dese songz
Bravelove Meow Oh of course!
Pinkie Pie Adorable! X3
That was surpisingly GOOD! :3
thank you for your critique ^^
I got goosebumps. As an accomplished musician myself; that doesn't happen often.
Fair enough. We do seem to have similar ideas about it (the Mane Twelve all teaming up to help Cadance with... whatever the problem is). Personally, I felt like this was one of the numbers where it would have been fine for the colts to just sing along due to it being an ensemble song about working together, but I can understand where you're coming from. It probably wouldn't bug me so much if some of the girls had their own unique parts as well, but maybe that's just me.
Good work, as always, sir :3
Their voices sound perfect :D
Funny those two I though had the most diverse harmony that fit smoothly....ah well, thanks for watching ^^
aawww pinkie pie an bubble berry are so cute
i forgot about this one im so glad i waited to listen to them
I don't know why you don't like them, i found them amazing!
Sounds Really Good
you my sir are a god. this is excellent.
alright!?! its awesome i love the harmony it just makes me smile
I love how Fluttershy and Butterscotch are just frolicking with the yues :3
so fing amazing. u have a musical talent!
12 ponies singing at once is so weirdly beautiful.
Also, since the episode is far from being revealed I want to pick you imagination, I have gotten critiques on previous versions of duets where the guys sound like they just are background or unnecessary. This was an effort to make people imagine that they showed up to help Princess Cadence and would then be guest characters and probably would comment and enjoy themselves with the Mane 6
wow, it's awesome, you are a really talented singer And voice actor!
best one yet phil
I didn't even notice them until you mentioned this.
Awesome as always. Great job! ;)
GOD THIS IS SO AWESOME.
OH MY GOSH THIS IS AMAZING!!!
Synched this with the Crystal Pony video. Epicness was had.
AHHHHHHH, THE GOOSEBUMPS!!!!
It's good that you managed to save those images Wicklesmack drew. After she closed down her account, all her drawings became unviewable.
Holy crap, that was so amazing O.O
Best one yet. Love love luv
Mares for the loud part, and the Stallions for the low part
Perfect Harmony
OMG so good just subscribed :D
i see this episode the song was good