I'm 69 yrs. 15 yrs ago I suffered major heart attack n I was advised bypass surgery. But instead of bypass I changed my lifestyle n diet. Now I am leading a complete normal life.
I am 42 years old. 9 years before one reputed doctor of kolkata was advised me for bypass.. But i Didn't. Now i am fully fit without any surgery. Just Change lifestyle. Its very effective ❤️
Actually we need any bypass even if you have 90% blocks and we can still live normally and we need to time for body and it will bypass naturally it seems and honest research proved.
Why was bypass suggested?? If u had major blockage multiple places how it went away?? Did you followed it up with test ? Specifically ct angiography???
A so called great and top rating and also a hypocrite cardio surgeon of Bangalore deliberately misguided my father to death. You will be shocked to know how he had cheated my innocent father
Cost of hospital buildings, Cost of imported machines, staff and doctors salary, cost of electricity, cost of house keeping, cost of vehicles,cost of permission,cost of official tours,cost of refreshments,cost of consultancy , cost of training, cost of furnitures, cost of testing lab, cost of phone bills, cost of clinical trails, cost of medicines, loan from supportive bank and financial institutions, education fees.. and taxes ...who has to pay all these ? Only patients.....I mean end customers..
Taxes are transferred to Swiss bank by elected and unelected (Rajya sabha) government officials. Congress officials have huge property and money but no judicial authority or Income tax officials are concerned about this as these tax officials also work with them.. any person who has any enemy in these places can be easily prosecuted by them ..
Cost of all these expenses is nothing infront of your margin in fees, and cost price of medicine, surgical items... I have seen some medicine and surgical items have 90% of margin..you are already saving those money..then why are you looting patients
Big as big salute to the Channel crews and HATS OFF TO THE DOCTOR. THE MIGHTY GOD BLESS YOU AND YOU ALL. I WISH EVERY PLACE WE FIND THESE KIND OF DOCTORS in saving people of our GREAT NATION JAI HIND JAI BHARATH
Please don't write misleading titles for the sake of views.🙏 I don't know why Sir is criticizing Cardiovascular surgery but these kind of remarks can have a really bad impact on the people suffering from Cardiac disease. Respectfully, I would like to clarify some points- - Every patient don't need a CABG(bypass graft).. CABG is done in cases when more than 1 vessel supplying the heart is blocked. - The site from where the vessel graft is taken usually do not have any effect, because collateral vessels are formed in that area which takes care of the blood supply there. -Doctors CAN know the Percentage of BLOCK in Coronary artery by Angiography..but as rightly said by sir..they cannot predict the time when it will get completely blocked and will cause heart attack.(But the rough estimate they give is based on the research and their experience) -NOW COMING TO MOST CONTROVERSIAL PART. - In India with such humongous patient load, patients do not prefer to follow up and come again to doctor..So if a patient has more than 60-70% block then it's better to Take some action in form of medicines, PCI (STENT PLACEMENT) or CABG based on the patient's condition to prevent future Heart attacks. (Along with lifestyle modification which usually patients do not stick to). If these measures are not taken at that time(Surgery or PCI is not done in such patients) they usually come with a severe heart attack which can cause severe morbidity and mostly death in such cases. If a patient watches this kind of video..they will hesitate to go to a doctor which can lead to disastrous outcomes. I request people with great influence in healthcare to choose their words cautiously as it can cause huge impact on the population🙏🙏
While i am seeing that there are comments in favour of the Doctor (speaker) n also some comments opposing him one thing is damn sure in our country in corporate hospitals DOCTORS do have TARGETS n are forced to order for unnecessary tests n treatments much against their wish.. Recently we came across an article wherein an American Cancer Specialist forced many patients to go for Cancer Treatment including Chemotherapy and heis being tried now n the Doctor has Confessed having done that. So Ethics part more or less is gone now n Greed has crept in. We have to be very very careful cant totally rely on these Fellows. What happened during Corona pandemic time have not these Doctors looted mercilessly. I have seen Doctors staight away refusing to treat if they are not having Cash in hand. Your Health Cards other cards etc carried no value at that time. Thank you Mr Gaurav Thakur.
I was a TOF patient, dextracardiya , I was undergone two times open heart surgery, last 27 years im doing well, now I’m 57years old, thank god Dr.km Cherian 🙏
Ye Dr. puer business man hai logo ko lut Raha hai kyonki inke saare centre 25%Se lekar 40% commission par chalate hai maine self inki Puri treatment liya lekin o% result hai... mitha bol kar logon ko bhula rahe hai@@PrayanshAlurkar
We need honest private hospitals, private medical colleges, who should not torture, pressure doctor's to earn money for the hospital. First of all health and education should be free in india.
I underwent bypass and artic valve replacement surgery , total cost about 9 L.my health is good after that. Surgeon fee is 3L, in which GST 18% and , may be 30% IT govt looted 48% without any contribution so surgeon gets only 1.7L. My total bill was taxed at 18% to 36 GST so I paid about 2L GST. So govt looted about 3 L without any contribution. 😢 the govt must not tax medical, they must regulate legally cost and quality so that tax payers benifit.
Ever heard Fractional Flow Reserve (FFR) . This tells your provider how severe the narrowing (stenosis) is in your artery. If FFR < 1 , your surgeon will take a call on angioplasty.
If 0-10 percent may take 10 years, but 70-80 will take only 3 years as circumference of the blood vessel has already reduced. For 90-100 may take only afew months as the cross section of the blood vessel has drastically reduced. Logic explained by the doctor regarding blockage is not right mathematically.
Dr Neetu Mandke, a prominent cardiac surgeon who has performed 10,000 cardiac surgeries successfully died at the age of 55 years due to heart attack in Mumbai.
I heard from one renowned heart surgeon that our body immune system automatically develops new arteries over the blocked portion which acts as bypass. Imagine there are large number of people in rural areas who do not even know about blockage and heart attack, else a huge number of people would have died.
Only a small percentage of people's hearts can build new arteries and I am one of the few. All my arteries are blocked. Cardiologist found only one artery he could stent and did. I regret it I feel sicker after the stents
Exactly this happens in Bangalore also. Whenever a traffic jam happens here, 'automatically' new roads appear in the gullies so that I reach my destination on time every time 😂
There are strict indications for every thing .... the option is given to patient/relatives that there is a risk of impending heart attack .. it may happen in 1 sec or 1 year ...
Blame another doctor and present yourself like an angel.... Good people never do that..Only people with a personal agenda and motive speak ill about others.
Thank you for taking up such an urgent issue that just cries out to be addressed. When will our govt wake up and regulate our medical industry. Yes, industry. That is what our corporate hospitals have made it. Noble profession? Rubbish. We have useless politicians. Thanks for taking up a real issue. 👍
If people go with hospital with normal chest pain the doctors after testing are saying that the he / she is suffered minor heart attack and asking us to implant stent and billing around 7 to 8 lakhs by admitting in hospital for 5 days! Family members were shocked !
@@PhatPhatGhoomeif it's emergency you should go for treatment asap but if it's minor issue n you have doubt than you always have right to say no n go for a second opinion from other doctor.
@@StoryForKids111 they will give u medicine to make your condition worst. Patient won’t get chance for second opinion. Other hospitals won’t take unstable patients on ventilators. Recently lost family member in Max Patparganj Delhi. Just want to warn others.
Although I have negligible heart issues, but as per the advice of SAOL I am taking Arjun Chal overnight soaked water daily morning. I am feeling good. Also I take ashwagandha with lukewarm water before bed to control my blood pressure and attain sound sleep.
Instead of pouring money into surgery, take care of your body properly. Maintain your ideal body weight with good diet and exercise. Spend 20 or 30 thousand and buy a Fitbit or something to monitor your exercise, sleep, heart rate etc.. Not only you will be monitoring your health, you will be encouraged to improve your life style. You can set targets for lower resting heart rate, higher heart rate variability etc. Take a full blood test once in six months to monitor your lipids, kidney function, thyroid, and insulin resistance - HOMA -IR or preferably Triglyceride - Glucose- BMI index. You can buy stuff to monitor your bp and blood glucose at home. They are inexpensive.
I was watching their UA-cam channel since 6 years .. by watching their videos I changed my lifestyle.. as a result I am healthy now… thnx to doctor ji…
1. Most Failed Operations are conducted by Juniors in the name of Support staff. 2. Doctors are very Good at Commitions from Drugs and Writing Tests. Most Hawala Racket happen here
So... Doctor saab wants to say that, a patient should keep avoiding Bypass surgery with only lifestyle changes till the block advances to 90% or 100% ... ? Should we take this message from this whole discussion... ? And when the patient reaches almost at the verge of heart attack, then he should run for the hospital and hope that he gets time slot for a lifesaving emergency bypass surgery... right... ? Problem with this society is that- everyone thinks he can take a better health related decision than the Doctor who has specialized in the subject.... God save this society... 🙏🙏🙏
My father had recurrant chest pains and heart attacks. before 2008. Underwent cardiac bypass surgery in 2008. Thereafter no chestpain. Now he is healthy and very comfortable..
But what if the patient actually suffers from heart attack after denying operation. ,medical science is not so vague that surgeries being done without any indication all surgeries are first assessed and then interpreted if it improves quality of life of patient Not all doctors in this world are here to do business there are 2 extremes some doctors are really doing commendable work following ethics and showing what real excellence in medical science means The reason is that only persons having good business comes on top because this world only judges people based on their wealth not on their credibility ot contribution. Actually the person making great contributions to society are not famous on social media they jus do their work not taking any credit.
if this guy has three arteries blocked in his heart , he would run faster than anyone to heartsurgeon to cut open his chest and do bypass. He is just advertising himself and just use people's fear of surgery to flourish his business, or else with common sense such procedures would have been banned all over the world. please spread the truth.
And unfortunately these youtubers call these unscientific jokers and make podcasts to garner views and subscribers... Atleast when you call someone for an interview get your scientific rights
Your opinion is true but in primary case when blockage is 100% in LAD or else, there is no option other than urgent stenting or operation. Kindly explain this condition. Thanks
i had a blockage of 100% 95% and 70%, and also suffered heart attack, you think i should've waited and changed my life style and not go to the doctor.......what rubbish! after going to several doctors they all said you have to go under bypass and also change your life style.
I attended one of Dr. Chhajer's program on Heart Attack in Kolkata, explaining the nitty-gritty of causes of Cardiac Surgery. He stressed upon Heath Care Management through changing Life Style. It's equally true to avail of Medical Treatments like Cardiac ailments as best options from Renowned Government Hospital as neither Doctors nor Government Hospitals do have any Business Budgetary Targets. Doctors & Hospitals are Patients Centric; not Promoters Centric. Corporate or Private Hospitals simply rent out Decorated Doctor's Chamber with Annual Business Budgets that make them succumbed to compulsive pressures to achieve Business Budgets earmarked by Promoters of Corporate or Private Hospitals. Corporate or Private Hospitals tend to become Business Units as Profit Making Units; not Loss Making Units. So Dictors are burdened with Business Budgetary Targets to each Doctor for survival of Business Units, unlike Government Hospital.
My advise to these type video makers please donot project all heart surgery and heart attack as a scam. Please note there are patient who are serious and needs urgent surgery they will ignore the doctors advise for operation after watching your video. Whether you will take responsibility for all patient .If you have detail facts better file a complaint with police or IMA or health ministry or file writ before high court with your details. We have good doctors committed to their patient. I am a heart patient under went by pass and I never faced any such scam as mentioned in this video.
Please avoid such podcast. Highly misleading. I’m myself a cardiac surgeon. Rarely any surgeon will tell it’s an emergency to operate . There are certain conditions where it’s explained as an emergency. Most(90%) of the cardiac surgeries are elective. Sometimes patient ask can you guarantee us that we want to go home and come back after few days. How the hell in the world someone can GUARANTEE the future. It’s upto the patient to decide what they want not on doctor. We can advise them the available options and the need and risks. No doubt few centres are involved in unethical practices. But to generalise it is a very devastating trend. Can a lawyer guarantee that he’ll win case?? Each case one person wins and the other looses. What’s their liability? Then they must be penalised for loosing the case. !!
Sir I agree, the misfortune of our profession is that we are fighting a losing battle, till now we cannot prevent death. In this era of clickbaits and soundbites there is ever increasing gap in trust between the doctor and patients.
Please get some news regarding what our govt has done with the medical entrance exam this year...govt has sold the question paper thru diff agents for 70 to 80 lacs before the exam, the question paper was on the mobile of paper leak mafias...Supreme Court agreed that the paper was on the mobile but still couldn't give any justice....so ultimately many fraud people who have failed in their board exam got very high marks in this medical entrance exam and are entering into the system...in future these cheaters who have purchased the paper before the exam will not become doctors but murderers
Heart surgery not required. Change your diet. Swallow with water 1 pod of chopped garlic twice a day with lunch and dinner. Your heart shall function normally
There are two reasons for a bypass. Save a life or improve quality of life like less chest pain or improve walking capabilities etc. Doctors are only communicating what they learn from scientific studies. Doctors can not have any opinion of their own or can say like I know this from my 40 years of practicing experience. Please publish your opinion in scientific papers after doing protocol based studies and get peer reviewed etc. Follow the science you have learned from and calling yourselves doctors.
This interview is disrespecting the cardiac surgeons, whose dedication and hard work is impossible to explain. Most difficult work among all branches is done by cardiac surgeons. Never criticize them without a reason . Don't try to attract innocent viewers by comments like you are doing. Patients are sent to the cardiac surgeons for by pass. They cannot go out in search of patients as they are always doing surgery.
Nonsense you speak . Corruption among doctors is same as in society. A persons character remains the same and does not depend on a profession. This interview is perfect because it represents majority of doctors. The percentage of crooks remains the same among doctors/ bureaucrats/ businessmen/ politicians. Just because doctors wear white coat does not make them clean
We must look for why such things are happening in the pious profession like medicine. I feel, firstly the medical education must be made cost effective . Secondly, there should be a cap on the pay and perks of the doctors particularly the senior ones , like in any any govt service . The accounts of the hospitals must be throughly checked . Any cash transaction as hospital charges and cost of medicines must be online only . Private hospitals must not be allowed to operate multiple accounts . All hospital charges must be controlled by realistically worked out by an independent body like CAG . Without controlling the overhead charges in running a hospital this deadly malpractice in medical profession can not be controlled and eradicated.
Recently my mother in law's valve has been replaced which costs around 9 lakhs n after surgery we admitted hospital two times again which costs around 4 lakhs in Assam, health City hospital
Valve replacement is not done routinely. Either stenosis or regurgitation was symptomatic or EF was than 50% . N trust me if it had not been done situation might be worse or death.
This is a very bad misrepresentation of the facts. No one is suggesting a bypass surgery at 30-40% blockage - why? Because the risk of a heart attack is far lower than the risks of undergoing surgery. But at 80-90% block, the risk of having a heart attack is very high compared to the risk of surgery. The misrepresentation of the facts is this: at 70% and above blockage, it doesn't necessarily slowly go from 70 to 71, 72 etc. The risk is high because a sudden clot formed in that area can rapidly make the 70% block from cholesterol into a 100% block from cholesterol + blood clot. A higher risk doesn't mean that it will happen in the next 2 minutes for everyone, but it does mean that majority of such patients are likely to have a heart attack within the next month. The consequences of a heart attack can be devastating. If you are lucky, you will get treatment before anything serious happens or you will die. If you are unlucky, you could land up with a stroke and significant brain injury, damage to kidneys, rupture of the heart muscle and the cost of treatment goes up significantly. The chance of success of treatment goes down significantly. Most cardiologists and cardiac Surgeons in proper set ups actually counsel patients realistically. Today very rarely is someone rushed into having a bypass surgery. Patient often needs proper optimization before they can be safely operated on. A lot of what this "doctor" is saying is biased with no supporting evidence. Decisions made by doctors today are not based on arbitrary factors. There are well researched evidence to support clinical decision making. Doctors are also concerned because if they take an unwarranted decision, they will lose litigation in the courts and have to face significant consequences. If these doctors words were to be challenged in court with evidence refuting his claims of malpractice by doctors, he would have a hard time defending himself against charges of defamation and malicious intent.
Medical seat should be given only to merit student neet me lafda karke .crores donation leke management seats dete hi pagal ko our wo recover karne ke liye patient ko loot te hi
Whether it is dentistry or general medicine, fear is a great marketing tool. Please educate yourself before meeting your doctor. Don’t be afraid to ask inconvenient questions to your doctor. If the doctor is not willing to answer your questions satisfactorily, be careful, get second and third opinion.
You are asking an MD Physiology doctor about heart surgery. This person has never seen an OPD leave aside a Cardiac OT and you ask him about heart surgery. He says bypass grafts get blocked in 5 years, and I say the patients who have critical blockages he tell not to get operated die within a year or develop end stage heart failure. How irresponsible social media influencers have become that all that matters to them is just cringe and fake content which may come from a popular self proclaimed cardiologist like Bimal Chajjer. Ask him to present his qualifications before posting such content and stop playing with the lives of millions of people who need coronary intervention. Collaterals are very small vessels that provide blood supply to the muscles of the heart affected by blockage in coronary arteries. These collaterals come from vessels which are not blocked or have very less disease, so what happens when all the 3 vessels are blocked. Where will the collateral come from? This chap is a fraud, Rah Shamani gathered views by endorsing him and you aren’t any different. Stop this nonsense please.
He is just saying what we want to hear so he seems to be doing great. No body likes to get operated but everybody wants to live a long and healthy life. This is not so simple bcos treatments cannot be gereralised.
Other side of coin is, if doctor says you can do it after a month and something happens before that, will you consider that doctor ok? Will you not ask that doctor a single question? And if it is not predictable that precisely any doctor will play safe and in favour of saving the life. Forget money part, that's a different debate. And I am not a doctor,I am an engineer and thinking completely from engineering POV.
Title should start with - how few heart surgeons ' - ...dont generalize the statement. Doctors dedicates their life to studing and doing service. Just because of a bunch of idiots, you are blaming the entire fraternity. Now a days, there is no protection for doctors from physical assaults. Atleast have a respect.
Dr sahab what are u suggesting I don’t understand. CAD happens not only by life style things or taking bad food, In CAD stenosis do happen due to the disease not by arteriosclerosis or Atherosclerosis.
Super cool Dr, I avoided placing a Sten about 5 months back, took treatment with Madhavbaugh - a whole some natural way of treatment and today am free from the bloc as well
Don't believe Dr.hegde. Some years back , he openly told, coconut oil is bad for heart but now he is telling exactly opposite. All these big multinational companies producing sunflower & other oils must have rewarded this Dr Hegde to endorse their products at the cost of local producer of coconut oils.😊
Pl don't spread misinformation. Ppl are referred for Surgery once not amenable to stenting So pl don't misguide ppl unless you are doing it as charity or for free
Found this worth-watching? Head to our full podcast here 👉
cl.gy/CAbes
Website not available, abe kitna bada chadarmod hai tu apna channel chalane k liye kuch bhi
Link not working
Extremely poor and one sided video such type of videos should be banned as soon as possible
my friend underwent bipass 15 yr past and still living happy life.
Absolutely not worth watching
I'm 69 yrs. 15 yrs ago I suffered major heart attack n I was advised bypass surgery. But instead of bypass I changed my lifestyle n diet. Now I am leading a complete normal life.
Good,god bless you
Please - can you explain your full day diet plans ? ( It will help me to understand what can we do in our diet ) 🙏🙏
nice
Glad to hear that 😊
Eagerly waiting for your experience, please share
🙌🌹God Bless this Doctor to Speak the Truth Loudly.🙌🌹
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
I am 42 years old. 9 years before one reputed doctor of kolkata was advised me for bypass.. But i Didn't. Now i am fully fit without any surgery. Just Change lifestyle. Its very effective ❤️
Very true good luck and long life. God bless you and your family. 🙏👍🙌🙌🙌🙌🤞
Actually we need any bypass even if you have 90% blocks and we can still live normally and we need to time for body and it will bypass naturally it seems and honest research proved.
Why was bypass suggested?? If u had major blockage multiple places how it went away?? Did you followed it up with test ? Specifically ct angiography???
I'm also a doctor and, i did job in corporate Cardiac Hospital also , and i agree that his each and every word is absolutely true .
Sabse pehli bat tum doctor nhi ho you are fake
@@nobitadz2854 Did you Know?
Every People of community are without Brain.
Jee doctor sahab thanks for confirming......
A so called great and top rating and also a hypocrite cardio surgeon of Bangalore deliberately misguided my father to death.
You will be shocked to know how he had cheated my innocent father
@@nobitadz2854 teri kyon jali bey😂😂😂😂😂😂
Cost of hospital buildings, Cost of imported machines, staff and doctors salary, cost of electricity, cost of house keeping, cost of vehicles,cost of permission,cost of official tours,cost of refreshments,cost of consultancy , cost of training, cost of furnitures, cost of testing lab, cost of phone bills, cost of clinical trails, cost of medicines, loan from supportive bank and financial institutions, education fees.. and taxes ...who has to pay all these ? Only patients.....I mean end customers..
Tax to din din bar raha he.... Nahi pata vai itne tax ka karte kya karte he 🥺
Taxes are transferred to Swiss bank by elected and unelected (Rajya sabha) government officials. Congress officials have huge property and money but no judicial authority or Income tax officials are concerned about this as these tax officials also work with them.. any person who has any enemy in these places can be easily prosecuted by them ..
In
Costs are 10% the rest they earn.
Cost of all these expenses is nothing infront of your margin in fees, and cost price of medicine, surgical items...
I have seen some medicine and surgical items have 90% of margin..you are already saving those money..then why are you looting patients
Big as big salute to the Channel crews and HATS OFF TO THE DOCTOR. THE MIGHTY GOD BLESS YOU AND YOU ALL.
I WISH EVERY PLACE WE FIND THESE KIND OF DOCTORS in saving people of our GREAT NATION
JAI HIND JAI BHARATH
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
What a fantastic doctor.we need such type of doctor who can lead the nation.
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
@@RiseUp_Againhe is an MD in Physiology, a non clinical subject. Even his hair is fake 😂
Please don't write misleading titles for the sake of views.🙏 I don't know why Sir is criticizing Cardiovascular surgery but these kind of remarks can have a really bad impact on the people suffering from Cardiac disease. Respectfully, I would like to clarify some points-
- Every patient don't need a CABG(bypass graft).. CABG is done in cases when more than 1 vessel supplying the heart is blocked.
- The site from where the vessel graft is taken usually do not have any effect, because collateral vessels are formed in that area which takes care of the blood supply there.
-Doctors CAN know the Percentage of BLOCK in Coronary artery by Angiography..but as rightly said by sir..they cannot predict the time when it will get completely blocked and will cause heart attack.(But the rough estimate they give is based on the research and their experience)
-NOW COMING TO MOST CONTROVERSIAL PART. - In India with such humongous patient load, patients do not prefer to follow up and come again to doctor..So if a patient has more than 60-70% block then it's better to Take some action in form of medicines, PCI (STENT PLACEMENT) or CABG based on the patient's condition to prevent future Heart attacks. (Along with lifestyle modification which usually patients do not stick to). If these measures are not taken at that time(Surgery or PCI is not done in such patients) they usually come with a severe heart attack which can cause severe morbidity and mostly death in such cases.
If a patient watches this kind of video..they will hesitate to go to a doctor which can lead to disastrous outcomes.
I request people with great influence in healthcare to choose their words cautiously as it can cause huge impact on the population🙏🙏
Very perfectly said. Podcats like this these days are causing more harm than good. As the old saying goes little knowledge is harmful 😕
Thanks Dr Goswami ji... for your precious time to explain it...
Dr you are absolutely right
Dr. Goswami tum sab fraud ho ,sirf patient ko lootna jaante go
Well said sirji. One shouldn't generalise the fact
Thanks
Thanks for being so true and honest to your profession.
While i am seeing that there are comments in favour of the Doctor (speaker) n also some comments opposing him one thing is damn sure in our country in corporate hospitals DOCTORS do have TARGETS n are forced to order for unnecessary tests n treatments much against their wish.. Recently we came across an article wherein an American Cancer Specialist forced many patients to go for Cancer Treatment including Chemotherapy and heis being tried now n the Doctor has Confessed having done that. So Ethics part more or less is gone now n Greed has crept in. We have to be very very careful cant totally rely on these Fellows. What happened during Corona pandemic time have not these Doctors looted mercilessly. I have seen Doctors staight away refusing to treat if they are not having Cash in hand. Your Health Cards other cards etc carried no value at that time. Thank you Mr Gaurav Thakur.
I was a TOF patient, dextracardiya , I was undergone two times open heart surgery, last 27 years im doing well, now I’m 57years old, thank god Dr.km Cherian 🙏
sir you are 57 only, yet to cross 60. dont be so proud of it.
We need honest doctors. Not businessman doctors.
We need honest judiciary
Honest police
Honest politicians
Honest businessman and honest society
It's about hospitals who are owned by businessmen ..politicans
@@drsmmalik7049👍👍✅
Ye Dr. puer business man hai logo ko lut Raha hai kyonki inke saare centre 25%Se lekar 40% commission par chalate hai maine self inki Puri treatment liya lekin o% result hai... mitha bol kar logon ko bhula rahe hai@@PrayanshAlurkar
We need honest private hospitals, private medical colleges, who should not torture, pressure doctor's to earn money for the hospital. First of all health and education should be free in india.
Excellent, advice, if all doctors think the same , poor people 😢
I underwent bypass and artic valve replacement surgery , total cost about 9 L.my health is good after that. Surgeon fee is 3L, in which GST 18% and , may be 30% IT govt looted 48% without any contribution so surgeon gets only 1.7L. My total bill was taxed at 18% to 36 GST so I paid about 2L GST. So govt looted about 3 L without any contribution. 😢 the govt must not tax medical, they must regulate legally cost and quality so that tax payers benifit.
Ever heard Fractional Flow Reserve (FFR) . This tells your provider how severe the narrowing (stenosis) is in your artery. If FFR < 1 , your surgeon will take a call on angioplasty.
If 0-10 percent may take 10 years, but 70-80 will take only 3 years as circumference of the blood vessel has already reduced. For 90-100 may take only afew months as the cross section of the blood vessel has drastically reduced. Logic explained by the doctor regarding blockage is not right mathematically.
Dr Neetu Mandke, a prominent cardiac surgeon who has performed 10,000 cardiac surgeries successfully died at the age of 55 years due to heart attack in Mumbai.
So all the money he looted didn't save his Hart 😮
VERY HAPPY TO HEAR THAT
Successfully?
😮 Oh!
Interesting.Most of the heart surgeons suffer heart attack.
I heard from one renowned heart surgeon that our body immune system automatically develops new arteries over the blocked portion which acts as bypass. Imagine there are large number of people in rural areas who do not even know about blockage and heart attack, else a huge number of people would have died.
But rural people do not get blocks. They eat right and exercise a lot
Only a small percentage of people's hearts can build new arteries and I am one of the few. All my arteries are blocked. Cardiologist found only one artery he could stent and did. I regret it I feel sicker after the stents
Exactly this happens in Bangalore also. Whenever a traffic jam happens here, 'automatically' new roads appear in the gullies so that I reach my destination on time every time 😂
There are strict indications for every thing .... the option is given to patient/relatives that there is a risk of impending heart attack .. it may happen in 1 sec or 1 year ...
Blame another doctor and present yourself like an angel....
Good people never do that..Only people with a personal agenda and motive speak ill about others.
Aaj bhi aise doctor hai jo loyal hai inhe sab ki dua lagegi
Thank you for taking up such an urgent issue that just cries out to be addressed. When will our govt wake up and regulate our medical industry. Yes, industry. That is what our corporate hospitals have made it. Noble profession? Rubbish. We have useless politicians. Thanks for taking up a real issue. 👍
If people go with hospital with normal chest pain the doctors after testing are saying that the he / she is suffered minor heart attack and asking us to implant stent and billing around 7 to 8 lakhs by admitting in hospital for 5 days!
Family members were shocked !
You always have option to say NO
U went with chest pain how can it be normal 🤦♂️
@@PhatPhatGhoomeif it's emergency you should go for treatment asap but if it's minor issue n you have doubt than you always have right to say no n go for a second opinion from other doctor.
absolutely right ...the same thing happen to my father...poor doctor
@@StoryForKids111 they will give u medicine to make your condition worst. Patient won’t get chance for second opinion. Other hospitals won’t take unstable patients on ventilators. Recently lost family member in Max Patparganj Delhi. Just want to warn others.
God bless him for speaking the truth so human don't live in lie and fear..
Although I have negligible heart issues, but as per the advice of SAOL I am taking Arjun Chal overnight soaked water daily morning. I am feeling good. Also I take ashwagandha with lukewarm water before bed to control my blood pressure and attain sound sleep.
Instead of pouring money into surgery, take care of your body properly.
Maintain your ideal body weight with good diet and exercise.
Spend 20 or 30 thousand and buy a Fitbit or something to monitor your exercise, sleep, heart rate etc.. Not only you will be monitoring your health, you will be encouraged to improve your life style.
You can set targets for lower resting heart rate, higher heart rate variability etc.
Take a full blood test once in six months to monitor your lipids, kidney function, thyroid, and insulin resistance - HOMA -IR or preferably Triglyceride - Glucose- BMI index.
You can buy stuff to monitor your bp and blood glucose at home. They are inexpensive.
I was watching their UA-cam channel since 6 years .. by watching their videos I changed my lifestyle.. as a result I am healthy now… thnx to doctor ji…
Other countries do operate on priority basis,and the waiting period is too long thats why surgeries are delayed
Honest man.. exactly they pressurize u not to mention all d side effects..hope people start taking health in their hands..
Glad hes saying all this
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
1. Most Failed Operations are conducted by Juniors in the name of Support staff.
2. Doctors are very Good at Commitions from Drugs and Writing Tests. Most Hawala Racket happen here
So... Doctor saab wants to say that, a patient should keep avoiding Bypass surgery with only lifestyle changes till the block advances to 90% or 100% ... ?
Should we take this message from this whole discussion... ?
And when the patient reaches almost at the verge of heart attack, then he should run for the hospital and hope that he gets time slot for a lifesaving emergency bypass surgery... right... ?
Problem with this society is that- everyone thinks he can take a better health related decision than the Doctor who has specialized in the subject.... God save this society... 🙏🙏🙏
Right.
This is exactly what causes lack of trust in doctors.
Ultimately patients will suffer.
Very honest courageous statements which are going to annoy heart specialists.
You have a right to refuse the doctor's advice ......then leave everything upto God ......but then if anything happens don't curse the doctor.
My father had recurrant chest pains and heart attacks. before 2008. Underwent cardiac bypass surgery in 2008. Thereafter no chestpain. Now he is healthy and very comfortable..
Ya...this video is not for you then😂😂....it depends on which vessel % wise ...this guy is spreading lies.... don't know...how they are coming up
Good to know
@@chethanDoctorare you corporate doctor?
@@kavindratewari3441 may I know...why do you ask that?I have worked in both...
But what if the patient actually suffers from heart attack after denying operation. ,medical science is not so vague that surgeries being done without any indication all surgeries are first assessed and then interpreted if it improves quality of life of patient
Not all doctors in this world are here to do business there are 2 extremes some doctors are really doing commendable work following ethics and showing what real excellence in medical science means
The reason is that only persons having good business comes on top because this world only judges people based on their wealth not on their credibility ot contribution. Actually the person making great contributions to society are not famous on social media they jus do their work not taking any credit.
100%true….
Please dont follow anybody speaking on youtube.Go to best doctor whom you believe and obey his advice.
Apni buddi nahi dodane ka.
Exactly
Very true
Simple solution
No private medical colleges
No NRI quota
Health is Govt responsibility
Khel khatham 😂😂😂
Then give her,sath tax like UK and Canada 😂😂 no free treatment anywhere in this world
U got this guy and he is taking u for a ride. Well done
if this guy has three arteries blocked in his heart , he would run faster than anyone to heartsurgeon to cut open his chest and do bypass. He is just advertising himself and just use people's fear of surgery to flourish his business, or else with common sense such procedures would have been banned all over the world. please spread the truth.
And unfortunately these youtubers call these unscientific jokers and make podcasts to garner views and subscribers...
Atleast when you call someone for an interview get your scientific rights
While trying to run fast he will have cardiac arrest before reaching hospital
Are you doctor? or simply posting it
Sir your speech is eye opening for everyone ❤
Your opinion is true but in primary case when blockage is 100% in LAD or else, there is no option other than urgent stenting or operation. Kindly explain this condition. Thanks
What's the action against such type of medical scam
i had a blockage of 100% 95% and 70%, and also suffered heart attack, you think i should've waited and changed my life style and not go to the doctor.......what rubbish!
after going to several doctors they all said you have to go under bypass and also change your life style.
Did he not mention if operation is not necessary then don’t go for surgery! So in your case if surgery was necessary then that is what you did!
Aise bade Operation sirf gov hospital me hone chahiye .
❤
बहुत अच्छा विडियो है,
विमल सर आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद !
But people keep consuming fatty foods knowing all these risks. And they would rather undergo surgeries than change their lifestyle
Agreed
Seed oils carbs and sugars are a problem not fatty food
I attended one of Dr. Chhajer's program on Heart Attack in Kolkata, explaining the nitty-gritty of causes of Cardiac Surgery. He stressed upon Heath Care Management through changing Life Style.
It's equally true to avail of Medical Treatments like Cardiac ailments as best options from Renowned Government Hospital as neither Doctors nor Government Hospitals do have any Business Budgetary Targets. Doctors & Hospitals are Patients Centric; not Promoters Centric. Corporate or Private Hospitals simply rent out Decorated Doctor's Chamber with Annual Business Budgets that make them succumbed to compulsive pressures to achieve Business Budgets earmarked by Promoters of Corporate or Private Hospitals.
Corporate or Private Hospitals tend to become Business Units as Profit Making Units; not Loss Making Units. So Dictors are burdened with Business Budgetary Targets to each Doctor for survival of Business Units, unlike Government Hospital.
My advise to these type video makers please donot project all heart surgery and heart attack as a scam. Please note there are patient who are serious and needs urgent surgery they will ignore the doctors advise for operation after watching your video. Whether you will take responsibility for all patient .If you have detail facts better file a complaint with police or IMA or health ministry or file writ before high court with your details.
We have good doctors committed to their patient. I am a heart patient under went by pass and I never faced any such scam as mentioned in this video.
With all due respect ..what choice do you have now that your surgery has been done..😅
Because in today's world doctors lost their trust.now patients can't easily trust the doctors,always have the doubts about doctors opinion
Ye doctor to Chief Election commissioner dikh rahe hain 🤔🤭😆
Today’s fact every doctor who works in government hospital has his own hospital 🏥 private hospital
Business
GST should not be charged on life threatening disease. Even doctors are cashing on patients fear. This is too much for a poor country like India.
Please avoid such podcast. Highly misleading. I’m myself a cardiac surgeon. Rarely any surgeon will tell it’s an emergency to operate . There are certain conditions where it’s explained as an emergency. Most(90%) of the cardiac surgeries are elective. Sometimes patient ask can you guarantee us that we want to go home and come back after few days. How the hell in the world someone can GUARANTEE the future. It’s upto the patient to decide what they want not on doctor. We can advise them the available options and the need and risks. No doubt few centres are involved in unethical practices. But to generalise it is a very devastating trend.
Can a lawyer guarantee that he’ll win case?? Each case one person wins and the other looses. What’s their liability? Then they must be penalised for loosing the case. !!
Sir I agree, the misfortune of our profession is that we are fighting a losing battle, till now we cannot prevent death.
In this era of clickbaits and soundbites there is ever increasing gap in trust between the doctor and patients.
Totally agree as I have experienced it and lost someone close due to it.
Wow !! honest and sensible talk by Doctor. Cudous Sir.
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
Health and education must come under government control
Please get some news regarding what our govt has done with the medical entrance exam this year...govt has sold the question paper thru diff agents for 70 to 80 lacs before the exam, the question paper was on the mobile of paper leak mafias...Supreme Court agreed that the paper was on the mobile but still couldn't give any justice....so ultimately many fraud people who have failed in their board exam got very high marks in this medical entrance exam and are entering into the system...in future these cheaters who have purchased the paper before the exam will not become doctors but murderers
Under Government control look at public health and hospitals, look at railways , look at government offices
Heart surgery not required.
Change your diet.
Swallow with water 1 pod of chopped garlic twice a day with lunch and dinner.
Your heart shall function normally
No one can say for sure. Life is a mystery.
There are two reasons for a bypass. Save a life or improve quality of life like less chest pain or improve walking capabilities etc. Doctors are only communicating what they learn from scientific studies. Doctors can not have any opinion of their own or can say like I know this from my 40 years of practicing experience. Please publish your opinion in scientific papers after doing protocol based studies and get peer reviewed etc. Follow the science you have learned from and calling yourselves doctors.
This interview is disrespecting the cardiac surgeons, whose dedication and hard work is impossible to explain. Most difficult work among all branches is done by cardiac surgeons. Never criticize them without a reason . Don't try to attract innocent viewers by comments like you are doing. Patients are sent to the cardiac surgeons for by pass. They cannot go out in search of patients as they are always doing surgery.
Nonsense you speak . Corruption among doctors is same as in society. A persons character remains the same and does not depend on a profession. This interview is perfect because it represents majority of doctors. The percentage of crooks remains the same among doctors/ bureaucrats/ businessmen/ politicians. Just because doctors wear white coat does not make them clean
We must look for why such things are happening in the pious profession like medicine. I feel, firstly the medical education must be made cost effective . Secondly, there should be a cap on the pay and perks of the doctors particularly the senior ones , like in any any govt service . The accounts of the hospitals must be throughly checked . Any cash transaction as hospital charges and cost of medicines must be online only . Private hospitals must not be allowed to operate multiple accounts . All hospital charges must be controlled by realistically worked out by an independent body like CAG . Without controlling the overhead charges in running a hospital this deadly malpractice in medical profession can not be controlled and eradicated.
Misleading, half knowledge is more dangerous than heart attack itself😂
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
Recently my mother in law's valve has been replaced which costs around 9 lakhs n after surgery we admitted hospital two times again which costs around 4 lakhs in Assam, health City hospital
Guwahati is worst before narayana and excel were good now they also loot
Valve replacement is not done routinely. Either stenosis or regurgitation was symptomatic or EF was than 50% . N trust me if it had not been done situation might be worse or death.
Better to go to Apollo in Chennai or CMCH in Vellore or Narayana Hridalya ,Bangalore .They are 35 years ahead of North East and West Bengal.
In U.K. there is a long waiting list for every procedure. In India the healthcare is much cheaper and much easily accessible
This is a very bad misrepresentation of the facts.
No one is suggesting a bypass surgery at 30-40% blockage - why? Because the risk of a heart attack is far lower than the risks of undergoing surgery.
But at 80-90% block, the risk of having a heart attack is very high compared to the risk of surgery.
The misrepresentation of the facts is this: at 70% and above blockage, it doesn't necessarily slowly go from 70 to 71, 72 etc. The risk is high because a sudden clot formed in that area can rapidly make the 70% block from cholesterol into a 100% block from cholesterol + blood clot.
A higher risk doesn't mean that it will happen in the next 2 minutes for everyone, but it does mean that majority of such patients are likely to have a heart attack within the next month. The consequences of a heart attack can be devastating. If you are lucky, you will get treatment before anything serious happens or you will die. If you are unlucky, you could land up with a stroke and significant brain injury, damage to kidneys, rupture of the heart muscle and the cost of treatment goes up significantly. The chance of success of treatment goes down significantly.
Most cardiologists and cardiac Surgeons in proper set ups actually counsel patients realistically. Today very rarely is someone rushed into having a bypass surgery. Patient often needs proper optimization before they can be safely operated on.
A lot of what this "doctor" is saying is biased with no supporting evidence. Decisions made by doctors today are not based on arbitrary factors. There are well researched evidence to support clinical decision making. Doctors are also concerned because if they take an unwarranted decision, they will lose litigation in the courts and have to face significant consequences.
If these doctors words were to be challenged in court with evidence refuting his claims of malpractice by doctors, he would have a hard time defending himself against charges of defamation and malicious intent.
Thank you for being honest.
Medical seat should be given only to merit student neet me lafda karke .crores donation leke management seats dete hi pagal ko our wo recover karne ke liye patient ko loot te hi
From this interview I can conclude that this doctor has never worked in ICCU
Can you please elaborate why you made such comment?
Can you explain why
ICCU is idiot concept. Ayurveda can clean blockage without bypass. Modern medical science are designed to practice "Patient cured is customer lost."
You talk rubbish and you know that!
Abroad in Canada or USA, to see a patient they may take a month. Forget about by pass surgery.
Whether it is dentistry or general medicine, fear is a great marketing tool. Please educate yourself before meeting your doctor. Don’t be afraid to ask inconvenient questions to your doctor. If the doctor is not willing to answer your questions satisfactorily, be careful, get second and third opinion.
Sir you are most honest doctor ❤
Go to his clinic you will come to know
Surprise - He is Not a Doctor, Check it for Yourself, He is Just Promoting a Very Expensive Massage Therapy
You are asking an MD Physiology doctor about heart surgery. This person has never seen an OPD leave aside a Cardiac OT and you ask him about heart surgery. He says bypass grafts get blocked in 5 years, and I say the patients who have critical blockages he tell not to get operated die within a year or develop end stage heart failure. How irresponsible social media influencers have become that all that matters to them is just cringe and fake content which may come from a popular self proclaimed cardiologist like Bimal Chajjer. Ask him to present his qualifications before posting such content and stop playing with the lives of millions of people who need coronary intervention. Collaterals are very small vessels that provide blood supply to the muscles of the heart affected by blockage in coronary arteries. These collaterals come from vessels which are not blocked or have very less disease, so what happens when all the 3 vessels are blocked. Where will the collateral come from? This chap is a fraud, Rah Shamani gathered views by endorsing him and you aren’t any different. Stop this nonsense please.
He is just saying what we want to hear so he seems to be doing great.
No body likes to get operated but everybody wants to live a long and healthy life.
This is not so simple bcos treatments cannot be gereralised.
We need doctor like you sir.
Other side of coin is, if doctor says you can do it after a month and something happens before that, will you consider that doctor ok? Will you not ask that doctor a single question? And if it is not predictable that precisely any doctor will play safe and in favour of saving the life. Forget money part, that's a different debate.
And I am not a doctor,I am an engineer and thinking completely from engineering POV.
Salute to you doctor
Title should start with - how few heart surgeons ' - ...dont generalize the statement. Doctors dedicates their life to studing and doing service. Just because of a bunch of idiots, you are blaming the entire fraternity. Now a days, there is no protection for doctors from physical assaults. Atleast have a respect.
do not generalise . need to report to IMA. if it is true, govt will ban stents and surgeries
Thank you doctor for this useful information
Patient cured customer lost, mindset
These things happen in private hospitals mostly. Extremely high Caesarean section rates in India in private hospitals is a clean example.
Nice and valuable explanation sir.Thank u very much lot.
Iske comment me kisi ki maa,papa,bhaiya ka birthday nhi h kya😅
Dr sahab what are u suggesting I don’t understand. CAD happens not only by life style things or taking bad food, In CAD stenosis do happen due to the disease not by arteriosclerosis or Atherosclerosis.
He has no clue what he is talking about please don’t misguide patients heart suegery is saving millions of lives I’m a heart surgeon and he is wrong
Very good.
Thank you
Super cool Dr, I avoided placing a Sten about 5 months back, took treatment with Madhavbaugh - a whole some natural way of treatment and today am free from the bloc as well
Hello sir please give me your number just iwant to ask u one thing please 🙏🙏
NHS me logo ko bahut jyada problem hai.....wahan doctors bahut kum hai NHS me .... patient ko bahut delayed solution milta hai NHS me
सरकार से निवेदन है मेडिकल इंडस्ट्रीज पर थोड़ा ध्यान दे ताकि जनता का विश्वास बना रहे इस इंडस्ट्री पर
Great bro 👍👍👍 carry on...
Informative video... thank you 😊😊😊
Salute this Doctor ❤
Thank you sir Exlent presentation
If intetviwer gets chest pain , how he is going to handle also should be told.
Fantastic… Good bless you, doctor
Corporates want to know your location 😂
All are 200% true.. Dr B M Hegde already told all these
Hello is an another idiot....
Don't believe Dr.hegde. Some years back , he openly told, coconut oil is bad for heart but now he is telling exactly opposite. All these big multinational companies producing sunflower & other oils must have rewarded this Dr Hegde to endorse their products at the cost of local producer of coconut oils.😊
bm hegde ultimate
Let’s listen to Dr BM HEGADE sir who protecting us from business doctors
But he was also in admitted in a allopathy hospital in 2017
Pl don't spread misinformation.
Ppl are referred for Surgery once not amenable to stenting
So pl don't misguide ppl unless you are doing it as charity or for free
Doctor sahab bahut achcha advice Diya. Aajkal to normal delivery nahin ho raha hai sab surgery ho raha hai Paisa lootane ke liye😢
Last mei video bandh hogaya is episode ka continued episode hei ki nahi?
Medical field is best corporate business in today’s world
absolutely right
So go to govt hospital
Here I beg to differ. My granny had a bypass 30 years back. She lived many years after that. But she had to take ecosprin.
Pakka tu Dr ya fir uska rishtedar hai 😂😂