Were the Ancient Romans Really Wildly Debauched or Actually Prudes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
  • Check out Squarespace: squarespace.com... for 10% off on your first purchase.
    This video is #sponsored by Squarespace.
    Love content? Check out Simon's other UA-cam Channels:
    Biographics: / @biographics
    Geographics: / @geographicstravel
    Warographics: / @warographics643
    MegaProjects: / @megaprojects9649
    SideProjects: / @sideprojects
    Into The Shadows: / intotheshadows
    TopTenz: / toptenznet
    Highlight History: / @highlighthistory
    Business Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
    Casual Criminalist: / thecasualcriminalist
    Decoding the Unknown: / @decodingtheunknown2373
    →Some of our favorites: • Featured
    →Subscribe for new videos every day!
    www.youtube.co...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 398

  • @TodayIFoundOut
    @TodayIFoundOut  2 роки тому +17

    Check out Squarespace: squarespace.com/BRAINFOOD for 10% off on your first purchase.

    • @ryvyr
      @ryvyr 2 роки тому

      Thank you kindly for having non-adsense at beginning or end rather than interrupting. It allows me to click Like, enjoy video, and consider your promotion.

  • @DneilB007
    @DneilB007 2 роки тому +342

    I’ve always wondered if the myth of Romulus & Remus being raised by a she-wolf was at all related to the Roman slang of “she-wolf” for a lower-class sex worker.

    • @dsxa918
      @dsxa918 2 роки тому +47

      Good question, i would think there is probability there, while I was unaware of this, before now.

    • @someonebald2022
      @someonebald2022 2 роки тому

      Not sure the Romans would have liked it if their enemies had said "You're all sons of a wh*re!!". Maybe that's why they were so uptight?

    • @taylorlibby7642
      @taylorlibby7642 2 роки тому +21

      Possible, but that particular slang showed up a lot in the ancient world.

    • @carltonleboss
      @carltonleboss 2 роки тому +41

      They were adopted by a shepherd (I.e. a person of lower status), so that could be connected.

    • @cramerfloro5936
      @cramerfloro5936 2 роки тому +14

      Great question! We are still trying to fully unpack the significance of wolves in roman culture and how exactly different wolf-related elements, from the sacred to the slang, were connected.

  • @giantred
    @giantred 2 роки тому +185

    Heh, small brain is knowing Simon is a bit tired of Roman history and feeling bad for him, galaxy brain is knowing that Simon is a capitalist and the traffic he gets on Roman videos more than makes up for it.

    • @nickosmond
      @nickosmond 2 роки тому +10

      Man I was really expecting this video to already have 100,000 views by now

    • @GimmeJimmy23
      @GimmeJimmy23 2 роки тому +7

      No smooth brain here!

    • @NoName-de1fn
      @NoName-de1fn 2 роки тому

      @@taylorfusher2997 What are you trying to get at?

    • @A.Severan
      @A.Severan Рік тому +1

      Roman history is just that interesting. And I’d love for people two thousand years later to look back on us too.

    • @Wertsir
      @Wertsir Рік тому

      @@A.Severan Hey future creeps, yeah you! Stop looking at me, you’re making me uncomfortable.

  • @AnimusDecolor
    @AnimusDecolor Рік тому +13

    Fantastic and informative video! Perhaps part of the reason why the notion of Roman sexual 'debauchery' became popularized was also due to early Christian influence. The early Christians favored to portray themselves as islands of virtue in a sea of pagan immorality and promiscuity. It feel that the stereotype stuck, and is still seen in Hollywood films, etc.

  • @Darth_Cornpop
    @Darth_Cornpop 2 роки тому +102

    *Ancient Greek:* "We invented sex!"
    *Ancient Roman:* "True, but we introduced it to women!"

  • @danieljohnson2005
    @danieljohnson2005 2 роки тому +110

    A lot of it depends on the time period as well. The Roman civilization lasted for almost 2,000 years if you count the Eastern Empire, so a lot changed in that time.

    • @Tjalve70
      @Tjalve70 2 роки тому +15

      While that is true, when we think of the sex practices of Rome, we think of Ancient Rome, before they became christened.
      But still, that's almost 1000 years.

    • @danieljohnson2005
      @danieljohnson2005 2 роки тому +13

      @@Tjalve70 Yes, but what about Augustus’ morality laws? His reforms changed Roman society for generations. Of course, Roman values continued to change, but that was my whole point. The Ancient World wasn’t a lot different than our civilization is today in that generations change for better or worse, and the older generation almost always thinks society is crumbling.

    • @danieljohnson2005
      @danieljohnson2005 2 роки тому +2

      @@taylorfusher2997 I’m sorry, but I don’t see what your point is.

    • @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks
      @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks 2 роки тому +5

      @@danieljohnson2005 that's a bot. check other replies/

    • @TaeSunWoo
      @TaeSunWoo Рік тому +2

      Oh we always count the Eastern Roman Empire 💜

  • @cirnuioan9325
    @cirnuioan9325 2 роки тому +61

    'Malcom McDowell, also, noted, British person', definitely should have put this on Highlight History😂

    • @ryanstewart116
      @ryanstewart116 2 роки тому +2

      Does it even matter which channel anymore lol

    • @duncancurtis5971
      @duncancurtis5971 2 роки тому

      More like Lurcio with Frankie Howerd.

    • @RictusHolloweye
      @RictusHolloweye 2 роки тому +1

      I assume he was making a reference toward the Great Expectations episode of South Park.

  • @jesway
    @jesway 2 роки тому +29

    Hey Simon. You should do a video about morality police in different countries. I think people would find this practice interesting since it’s not a thing in the west.

    • @mammajamma4397
      @mammajamma4397 Рік тому +2

      We have them in the West. They're called politicians.

    • @Dan_Kanerva
      @Dan_Kanerva Рік тому

      @@mammajamma4397 politicians bend the knee to the demands of the public...
      you think any politician promoting child P would ever be elected?

  • @tplyons5459
    @tplyons5459 2 роки тому +15

    You left out the Festival of Eros. During this 7-10 day festival orgies were the norm especially for barren couples. The couples would attend as many as they could handle and if the woman fell pregnant it was considered a gift of the gods and raise like a normal child. Obviously we are talking about the lack of children the man's fault and if it was the woman's infertility, well there's always next year.

    • @LittleLordFancyLad
      @LittleLordFancyLad Рік тому

      Are you referring to the Erotidia? I know it had sacrifices, wrestling, boxing, pancratium, horse and chariot races, etc., but I've never heard of orgies as part of the festivities.
      Now I'm not disagreeing with you, just that I've never heard about orgies in the context of the festival. Do you have a source so that I can learn more about it?

    • @tplyons5459
      @tplyons5459 Рік тому +2

      @@LittleLordFancyLad I learned about it in college. The topic wasn't the parties/orgies per say but a study of fertility and breeding issues of the Greeks and Romans. I guess you could say that it was a form of fertility care today where a doner's material is inserted by a doctor. Oddly in my senior year I had to do a very long paper on so called swinging. Myself and another female student attended a dozen swingers parties at a place called The RETREAT (now closed I believe) and much to our surprise found that it's still being done. As one woman put it, why give some clinic $10 to 20 grand when you can come here, find a couple of men that fit their chosen profile and go for it. She said their first kid was conceived that way and they were there for another. If nothing else if this is not successful then its not the males fault.

    • @LittleLordFancyLad
      @LittleLordFancyLad Рік тому

      @@tplyons5459 Ah, thanks.

  • @mrmr446
    @mrmr446 2 роки тому +29

    There were early Christian cults that were very liberated as, in their eyes, their sins had already been forgiven after Jesus sacrificed himself or they could do whatever as long as they asked for forgiveness before dying. Other early Christians came up with the idea that sex should only be for procreation which sounds like less fun all round.

    • @earlgrey2130
      @earlgrey2130 2 роки тому

      Christians.. people assuming that they need no morals because the only person they need to please is an imaginary entity..

    • @jeffreyodell9994
      @jeffreyodell9994 2 роки тому

      GOD created sex, humor and beauty.
      You shouldn't speak on things you obviously don't know shit about ;)

    • @jonathandewberry289
      @jonathandewberry289 2 роки тому +3

      What were those early Christian cults? Something we could look up and read about?

    • @Ken_Scaletta
      @Ken_Scaletta Рік тому

      Early Christians thought the world was going to end. Paul was saying not to Start families. The idea that sex was for procreation came from Augustus Caesar's morality laws. After the world kept not ending, Christians started adhering to Roman morality so as not to look. weird. Polygamy was discouraged for that reason too. It's a lot like how the LDS Church gave itself a squeaky clean makeover.

    • @Ken_Scaletta
      @Ken_Scaletta Рік тому

      @@jonathandewberry289 Sure. Try Bart Ehrman's "Lost Christianities." There were many competing sects in early Christianity. Pauline, Hellenized Chrisitianity became "Orthodox," but there were dozens of other sects with other beliefs. The earliest Palestinian cult was Torah observant and thought Jesus was an angel.

  • @Marinanor
    @Marinanor 2 роки тому +25

    Pederasty is so, so disgusting

    • @dsxa918
      @dsxa918 2 роки тому +1

      It's so over the top

    • @MusicalRaichu
      @MusicalRaichu 2 роки тому +4

      their problem was that if a man was attracted to men, the penetrated man would end up being a social outcast. the workaround was to make the penetrated partner a boy. that way he wouldn't have adult social status to lose. society imposed safeguards: it was voluntary; the boy had to be old enough; in exchange the "beloved" would receive an education from his "lover"; most important to the boy's welfare the relationship had to end by the time he reached adulthood.
      unacceptable by modern standards for sure. i wonder if anyone has been able to study how much harm it did. but what else could they do given the constraints of their culture?

    • @Iconoclasher
      @Iconoclasher 2 роки тому +3

      "Disgusting" is a culturally relative term. The boys were mentored and educated while under the guidance of the elder. They might think we're "disgusting" for not practicing it.
      Every culture and civilization sets their own standards. Who are we to judge?
      Kids today are being mentored by the internet. I'm not sure that's any better than what the Greeks practiced.

    • @Marinanor
      @Marinanor 2 роки тому +4

      @@Iconoclasher Two wrongs don't make a right. etc etc etc

    • @Tugela60
      @Tugela60 2 роки тому +1

      They would probably say the same thing about you. What you consider to be a child is not necessarily what they would consider to be a child, or even that children were considered any different from adults at all, certainly not in the modern sense.
      There are likely a lot of things about modern society that would seem sick and disgusting to them but perfectly normal to you, and vica versa. It all relates to the specific cultural mores in place at any point in time. You can't judge other societies using your societies yardsticks.

  • @EdwardLCheeverII
    @EdwardLCheeverII 2 роки тому +15

    I gained a new appreciation for Etruscans today.

  • @videogamevalley7523
    @videogamevalley7523 2 роки тому +5

    so does that mean the elites were jus rich and powerful people who became….weird

  • @odinfromcentr2
    @odinfromcentr2 2 роки тому +6

    "Were they debauched or prudes?"
    Kinda both. To oversimplify things, they (mostly the rich) were neat in the streets yet freaks in the sheets; just don't get caught.

  • @CartoonHero1986
    @CartoonHero1986 2 роки тому +12

    Another thing Pop Culture has made us think was true of Roman and Greek Ancient Culture was all the swearing and calling people "cocks or c**ts" which was not at all how they spoke. If you've ever seen Rome or Spartacus the TV Shows you'll know "Jupiter's Cock" was favorite in both shows for swearing in Roman, but that was something the writers made up and used to get around the censorship board to let the characters swear like sailors and not be hit with standards and practices limits for excessive swearing.

  • @RyoHazuki224
    @RyoHazuki224 2 роки тому +4

    Haha, I got a kick out of the "Please... we have the internet. And Rule 34."
    Those who know, they know. XD

  • @carlaharris9645
    @carlaharris9645 2 роки тому +2

    I could have learned more had the speed of speech slowed down from 1,000 MPH

  • @glenngriffon8032
    @glenngriffon8032 2 роки тому +8

    The Etruscans were insanely wild. Did they also practice pedastry? Cause that seems dsturbing enough if anyone can just start getting it on with someone else but jeeze if kids could also get involved...
    Things that make you go **shudders**

  • @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks
    @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks 2 роки тому +108

    dude, like.... if you live in modern society the impressions you would get are that we are a very very debauched society, yet that's generally not the case... 900 years in the future, they will have very interesting words to say about how "f-ed" our society was, while simaltaniously being about the same. but our media, and our culture seems to reflect more about the things we find objectionable or have an issue with then what we tend to actually do on a daily basis, you will find a thousand movies about the hero getting a harem of ladies before you find the movie about an every day joe doing every day things.

    • @eliharper6616
      @eliharper6616 2 роки тому +17

      I'm imagining a future where all that survived is celebrity sex scandals, cheap paperback romance novels, and religious text about how women belong in the home. Those poor confused archeologists 😂

    • @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks
      @TheObsesedAnimeFreaks 2 роки тому +8

      until they get to japan, where it's just pr0n, only pr0n. that and one piece.

    • @johngarcia4139
      @johngarcia4139 2 роки тому +2

      humans...

    • @eliharper6616
      @eliharper6616 2 роки тому +13

      @@TheObsesedAnimeFreaks "We have been able to piece together the epic tale of the god like warrior Saitama and his battles with hulking mythological monsters from fragments of an ancient illustrated text. In the same collection we have found several illustrations depicting teenage girls in various sexual acts, including acts performed with differing forms of sea life."

    • @lpieters5
      @lpieters5 2 роки тому +4

      @@taylorfusher2997 it's called Hellenism... There's a clue. In early Roman times the dominant, most powerful and most wealthy region was the Greeks. The Romans really wanted to look like a civilized society in the same way we might look up to the US today. Many if not all the Roman elite spoke Greek primarily, not Latin. It is then quite understandable that you want to connect your own culture to that of the Greeks.

  • @TJDious
    @TJDious 2 роки тому +29

    2pm before Simon shows up in my feed GET IT TOGETHER FACT BOY

  • @maxdanielj
    @maxdanielj 2 роки тому +5

    Pedastry was common in Sparta yet so many "manly men" love to compare themselves to Spartans 😆

    • @matthewjay660
      @matthewjay660 2 роки тому +1

      I second this. I read a Greek history book in university and learned that Sparta actually TAXED 💰💸 men who did NOT take a young lover, (a catamite.) The state financially penalized them! 😲🤯

  • @tskmaster3837
    @tskmaster3837 2 роки тому +13

    I'll take "You'd never guess what Simon says" for 1000.
    "An elite man would never passively bottom."
    What did Simon say about the Romans?

  • @Dank-gb6jn
    @Dank-gb6jn 2 роки тому +15

    1:21 scene is from the 1979 uh...drama...film...”Caligula”. Penthouse founder Bob Guccione was the initial script writer I believe and got plenty of Penthouse models to get involved. It’s a uh...well, you’d have to watch it.

    • @Hillbilly001
      @Hillbilly001 2 роки тому +3

      I have decades ago and that was the one and only time. LoL. Yep, gotta see it at least once.

    • @Dank-gb6jn
      @Dank-gb6jn 2 роки тому +3

      @@Hillbilly001 I endeavor to watch movies at least twice. Once just to experience it, and then a second time to evaluate what I’ve seen; I personally would’ve called it an art film instead of a drama tbh.

  • @someonebald2022
    @someonebald2022 2 роки тому +8

    Ada Palmer said “Celibacy is the most extreme of sexual perversions”.

  • @stelladonaconfredobutler9459
    @stelladonaconfredobutler9459 2 роки тому +3

    Well St Paul was a eunuch, he should have had no say in sex

  • @Xcamr1
    @Xcamr1 2 роки тому +3

    I think I vomited a little when the topic of kids came up...seriously wtf

  • @Kuudere-Kun
    @Kuudere-Kun 2 роки тому +2

    I'm really annoyed that your title is just about Rome but then your intro is throwing Greece in, contrary to popular opinion those two subject shouldn't be crammed together, at least not in a video this short.
    The books Plato or Paul?: The Origins of Western Homophobia by Theodore W. Jennings Jr and The Classical Origins of Modern Homophobia by Robert H. Allen firmly document how Prudish Ancient Rome was.

  • @michaelpowell-ngatchou6274
    @michaelpowell-ngatchou6274 Рік тому +2

    The wildly debauched and prudes are sometimes the same people.

  • @RoseNZieg
    @RoseNZieg 2 роки тому +24

    if I ever wonder how wild the past was, I just look to the present. the more things changed, the more things stay the same.

  • @taylorlibby7642
    @taylorlibby7642 2 роки тому +5

    ",also noted British person."😂🤣

  • @xxLivingMyWayxx
    @xxLivingMyWayxx 2 роки тому +2

    What were they using for lube in ancient Greece? I hope they had something.. olive oil?

  • @MusicalRaichu
    @MusicalRaichu 2 роки тому +13

    Please make lots more videos about ancient Greece and Rome! I love them!!

  • @bhartley868
    @bhartley868 2 роки тому +8

    The book , CASTRATION an abbreviated history of western manhood, by Gary Taylor , is a fun addition to this topic for a look at history usually overlooked.

  • @tpl608
    @tpl608 2 роки тому +9

    Do a video on the beds the ancient Romans slept on. From carved stone in stores people just walked into to wooden framed.

  • @tymiller176
    @tymiller176 2 роки тому +2

    Let's keep in mind Spartan women had very different set of rights and lifestyle than, say, Athenian women. In short, it depends.

  • @boldCactuslad
    @boldCactuslad 2 роки тому +53

    remember that a lot of what we have left is rumor, innuendo, insults - writings written by opposing politicians and peoples. Their graffiti is practically identical to our graffiti or tweets. The similarity between modern man and the Romans is frankly absurd and deeply humbling. It's entirely possible that Incitatus was not a literal horse, for example, but instead took offense at being called a horseface, or dumb as a horse, or what have you.
    With a culture rooted in metaphors relating to books lost to time and a people who when asked what year it is respond with how long ago a politician became the whatever, it's very difficult to say if they were more or less like us. I find it quite likely that we, as humans, bear striking resemblance to them in the majority of aspects.

    • @Aemilius46
      @Aemilius46 Рік тому

      The Romans we're FAR Greater than people today.... NO ONE today would last in the Ancient World!! So sit down bro!! 🤚

  • @GimmeJimmy23
    @GimmeJimmy23 2 роки тому +3

    No oral? Seems drab. Am I wrong?

  • @taylorlibby7642
    @taylorlibby7642 2 роки тому +5

    Interested in a discussion on the proper pronunciation of the world "chaste". ; )

    • @AidanWigger
      @AidanWigger 2 роки тому

      British pronunciation, not North American.

  • @thecommenternobodycaresabout
    @thecommenternobodycaresabout 2 роки тому +52

    I loled when you mentioned internet and especially Rule34. Also, I love the fact you said multiple times "Hellenic" (the true name the current falsely named Greece has) world instead of "Greek" (name which originated from a "tribe" (sorry can't find a better word to describe it) called Grekos but is not how we are actually called).

    • @reinernst8203
      @reinernst8203 2 роки тому

      I don't care about you, or this comment.

    • @Nusma
      @Nusma 2 роки тому +3

      1. I care, this was a good comment.
      2. Is "Hellenic" really the right name? Or is it just the adjective?

    • @demonzabrak
      @demonzabrak 2 роки тому +2

      @@Nusma Hellenes, technically.
      Edit: that wasn’t clear was it? Ehem.
      Yes, Hellenic is the adjective form of the name. Hellenes is the noun form, technically.

    • @Wertsir
      @Wertsir Рік тому

      It’s impossible for anything to be falsely named, a name is just the thing we call something, if many people call something by one name, then that is its name. First Rome, then Italy. First Londinium, then London. First Persia, then Iran. First Asia Minor then Anatolia then Byzantium then the Ottomans then Turkey. First Gaul then Germania then East Francia then the Holy Roman Empire, then Germany. First Hellas, now Greece. Names change, but what is in a name? A rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
      If you prefer to call it something else that is your prerogative, most countries have different names for things. For example, Germany is actually Deutschland in German, Germany is just what english speakers call it, Japan is Nippon to its native residents, and so on. Someone is not wrong just because their culture calls something a different name than you. And nothing is incorrectly named, just called different things by different people.
      It is however true that Greece as a name was originally based on a mistake, its only a mistake until you’ve doubled down on it a million time, at which point it becomes a culture. The same way that a word mispronounced by a sufficiently large group of people becomes a regional dialect or accent rather than a mispronunciation, its all about reaching that critical mass.

  • @kylerswamp1075
    @kylerswamp1075 2 роки тому +6

    Corinthians says, “it’s better to marry than burn with passion.” Not like burn in hell. You guys left out a couple words that totally change the meaning. Just saying

    • @cericat
      @cericat 2 роки тому

      It varies a lot between translations which can really change interpretation. Wycliffe's translation it definitely has more of a burn in hell tone to the chapter and verse.

    • @NickSteffen
      @NickSteffen 2 роки тому

      To be fair the original Greek text just uses the word for burning as well. Nothing about passion. I believe is about as ambiguous in Greek as it is in English too but it's hard to know for sure with ancient Greek. It might have just meant burning back then.

    • @MusicalRaichu
      @MusicalRaichu 2 роки тому

      I think Paul's concern was that out of the options available at the time - staying single with unsatisfied desires ("burn"), using prostitoots, raiping slaivs or marriage - he recommended marriage.
      correct me if I'm wrong but did Paul even use the term "burn" in reference to consequence of divine judgement? He never made reference to Gehenna.

    • @cericat
      @cericat 2 роки тому

      @@NickSteffen that's where context helps, and why certain verses don't always make sense where they sit in modern rewrites of older translations, unfortunately though my understanding of Greek ancient or modern is limited so I have to rely on translations, translations that are always impacted by the biases of the author and their patrons in the case of say the KJV.

    • @NickSteffen
      @NickSteffen 2 роки тому

      @@MusicalRaichu the problem is that the original text sounds more like "get married or your will burn" as in burn in hell. Instead of "Get married or you will burn with passion" The second one is kind of a weird thing to say.

  • @kriz2432
    @kriz2432 2 роки тому +1

    Ah, Rule 34... the BEST, and WORST, thing about the Internet, lololololololololo!! 🤣

  • @LaylaSpellwind
    @LaylaSpellwind 2 роки тому +1

    "Why are you eating here, woman?"
    I dunno, I like food, piss off?
    I would not have lived long in ancient Rome.

  • @gentlemandemon
    @gentlemandemon Рік тому +1

    I'm not quite ready to accept that account of Etruscan society without some first hand Etruscan sources. That very much sounds like xenophobic propoganda from historical contemporaries.

  • @jopiet821
    @jopiet821 2 роки тому +1

    Ethnocentric thinking Englishman! You will no know unless you were there, but sure study away!

  • @No-tw6qj
    @No-tw6qj 2 роки тому +1

    8:33 wait lesbos was a real place and not a south park joke????????????????????????????????????????????????

  • @zzzaaayyynnn
    @zzzaaayyynnn 2 роки тому +4

    Simon's beard is becoming magisterial...

  • @dalhaw6760
    @dalhaw6760 2 роки тому +1

    Was there ever male on male marriage or I high ranking bringing up the lower rank to an elite

  • @TheDukeofMadness
    @TheDukeofMadness 2 роки тому +2

    When they dug through the ruins of Pompeii, they found, written on the walls: 'An vere fama susrrat grandia te medii tenta vorare viri.' It's a long, roundabout way of saying 'fellatio.'

  • @BaronessErsatz
    @BaronessErsatz 2 роки тому +8

    Now that I have my housemate well and thoroughly addicted to your videos: "No pressure, Fact Boy!"

    • @Aaron-TheHandsome
      @Aaron-TheHandsome 2 роки тому +1

      I sense you're being not passive.... remember your station, girl 👧💕 😉 😂😂🤣😉✌🏽

    • @BaronessErsatz
      @BaronessErsatz 2 роки тому

      @@Aaron-TheHandsome, I'm given to believe that there's only room for ONE hot mess here. Sorry, old bean, but it's been surreal......

    • @Aaron-TheHandsome
      @Aaron-TheHandsome 2 роки тому

      @@BaronessErsatz Old as my big bean is😏, it'll take the impertinent taste of youtube commentary defeat out of your mouth 👄👅.... Fact girl!! 👧 😉😉🤣🤣😂👍🏽😎✌🏽

  • @annoneemoose
    @annoneemoose 2 роки тому +2

    You can thank Christianity for the concept of men sleeping with women not their wives as being equally as wrong as women sleeping with men not their husband.

    • @miguelatkinson
      @miguelatkinson Рік тому

      I am pretty sure there where other religions and cultures which had that idea and isn't just centered around the christian religion

    • @annoneemoose
      @annoneemoose Рік тому

      @@miguelatkinson You'd be wrong

    • @miguelatkinson
      @miguelatkinson Рік тому

      @@annoneemoose umm how now ? Like any actual argument or just...

    • @annoneemoose
      @annoneemoose Рік тому

      @@miguelatkinson Nope. I've asserted my opinion, I don't care if you change your mind or not. If you're curious look into it, if you're not don't. I'm not writing a thesis to support my statement in youtube comments.

  • @Hillbilly001
    @Hillbilly001 2 роки тому +3

    Thanks, Simon. Now my Monday ain't so bad after all. Cheers.

  • @RoScFan
    @RoScFan 2 роки тому +4

    Holy shit, i wanna be an etruscan!

  • @WmRod
    @WmRod 2 роки тому +3

    Idk, they could do it with anyone, anywhere, anytime - but because of hierarchy and not taking it from the behind, we are less prudent than them.
    I mean... Maybe dependent on your reference population, but I would tend to disagree.

  • @sgtbb1905
    @sgtbb1905 2 роки тому +1

    Art being censored. Sickening

  • @rochelle586
    @rochelle586 2 роки тому +7

    Ah, Simon. Making my Monday morning more interesting

    • @dsxa918
      @dsxa918 2 роки тому

      This is a long way of saying....

  • @Gr3gaM
    @Gr3gaM 2 роки тому +1

    If you have to pronounce a new word so many times at least look it up... Pederasty or paederasty (US: /ˈpɛdəræsti/ or UK: /ˈpiːdəræsti/)

  • @nnaauujjddaa
    @nnaauujjddaa 2 роки тому +1

    So what you are saying is that is difficult to compare the level of sexuality through time? Why, is almost like sex is not a scale where you go from 0 sex to 100 sex. Wild eh?

  • @OriginalAutumnbear
    @OriginalAutumnbear 2 роки тому +2

    You wouldn't be here if they weren't... ^_^

  • @nickneuharth
    @nickneuharth 2 роки тому +1

    Great so all the tops were in Ancient Rome. That explains a lot about the current state of my Grindr

  • @The1stDukeDroklar
    @The1stDukeDroklar 2 роки тому +2

    Sounds like they had a lot of things right

  • @l.scales7516
    @l.scales7516 2 роки тому +1

    what is rule 34?

  • @brianthomas2434
    @brianthomas2434 2 роки тому +1

    Chaste is pronounced chayst. More as in moral is pronounced moray. At least in the US.

  • @betkay1018
    @betkay1018 Рік тому +1

    A very energetic narration and incredibly interesting. I have the strong impression that this chap is either SAfrican or an extraction of such (Dutch for instance) The "Wallahby" Island pronunciation for Wallaby seems to indicate that. Don't think there could be any more debauchery and criminal intent included in this horror history as nothing has been left for any imagination - too much to envisage or relate to the senses. How did they ever sleep or rest at all ... must have been quivering wrecks !!

  • @daviddevlogger
    @daviddevlogger 2 роки тому +7

    Sometimes struggles are exactly what we need in our life. If we were to go through our life without any obstacles, we would be crippled. We would not be as strong as what we could have been. Give every opportunity a chance, leave no room for regrets

    • @GimmeJimmy23
      @GimmeJimmy23 2 роки тому +4

      Agreed. I most certainly feel like there's a law of diminishing returns premise that applies to this, however. If your whole life is struggle, every minute of every day, eventually, you're fighting a losing battle. Ice skating uphill, if you will... Then, it's time for a change in one's approach (or circumstance.)

  • @adamloadsman2133
    @adamloadsman2133 Рік тому

    "Hello. I'm a brittish person" - Malcolm McDowell, South Park

  • @randalmayeux8880
    @randalmayeux8880 2 роки тому +1

    Read the play " Lysisrata"

  • @breannanorthrup5498
    @breannanorthrup5498 Рік тому

    ANNDDDDD if you're paying attention, so much of this history is very applicable to the new testament and the things they say about homosexuality. It is important to realize the loving consenting adults that are in same-sex relationship are drastically different than what the bible depicts of homosexuality.

  • @steven0837
    @steven0837 Рік тому

    So sad, in 2023 there is rampant blurring of female nipples and both sex's organs when showing works of art in this video.

  • @LuDux
    @LuDux Місяць тому

    Some say Sapho invented guitar/lyra pick, before her lyrists used their fingernails

  • @romypotash7114
    @romypotash7114 2 роки тому +1

    Keep being surprised about how much of the captive prince trilogy takes from history

  • @Tera_B_Twilight
    @Tera_B_Twilight Рік тому

    At the beginning of the video: I believe the answer is both. They were both prudes and randy. I mean that's a lot of history to cover.

  • @brucetutty9984
    @brucetutty9984 2 роки тому

    wow...just like the older Kray....ref The Movie of the same

  • @damianBTSot7
    @damianBTSot7 2 роки тому +2

    I'm curious about something you didn't mention. Was it considered Deviant and passive for an elite Man to have intercourse with a woman on top? As she would more or less be in the "driver's seat" in that position.

    • @GirlPhoenix85
      @GirlPhoenix85 2 роки тому +1

      It certainly seems analogous to the other "passive" behaviors. I would guess it would be scandalous in the same way.

    • @johanmalm8378
      @johanmalm8378 Рік тому +1

      Read Ovid "The Art of Love". Being ridden is not being dominated. Ovid is a good poet/writer. "Heroides" is a fun read.

    • @damianBTSot7
      @damianBTSot7 Рік тому +1

      @@johanmalm8378 I've read it. And obviously you've never been ridden properly.

    • @johanmalm8378
      @johanmalm8378 Рік тому +1

      😁! I've had most kinds of good times.

  • @zackerymeltonturdle5648
    @zackerymeltonturdle5648 Рік тому

    11:25 You telling me my dudes couldn't bust? That's an atrocity.

  • @kylemendoza8860
    @kylemendoza8860 Рік тому

    They were debauched in private. What women wear out on the streets today. Would not be acceptable outside of a red light district in ancient Rome.

  • @brydon5721
    @brydon5721 Рік тому

    Control of the rights and freedoms of women was common practice in ancient Rome and Greece, and modern day America.

  • @Xayver1082
    @Xayver1082 Рік тому

    One of my favorite jokes is "the Greeks invented sex and the Roman figured out you can do it with women"

  • @DarthReaper
    @DarthReaper Рік тому

    They were bored is always my guess for why ancient people did the things they did. We have all these things to keep us entertained and still get bored.

  • @DrinkTheKoolAid62
    @DrinkTheKoolAid62 2 роки тому +8

    Another great report. Today I began thinking about the expression "Ship of fools" (supposedly a ship crewed by the insane) and wondered if there ever really was a ship of fools or even ships of fools?

  • @hughbarton5743
    @hughbarton5743 2 роки тому +1

    Not to quibble, but I have researched this as best I can, and it would seem that word "chaste" is pronounced with a long"a" sound....the example usually give as sounding like cheyst....
    unless this another example of oddball differences between British english and American english......
    Any linguists out there have any thoughts on this?
    A very interesting video, Mr.Whistler. Thanks!

    • @CallMeNiel
      @CallMeNiel 2 роки тому

      I'm convinced that Simon chooses to mispronounce one or two word per episode to encourage comments.

  • @kev3d
    @kev3d 2 роки тому +1

    I suggest everyone read Catullus.

  • @TBJ1118
    @TBJ1118 Рік тому

    🤔 is there a rule34 for Simon? I'm afraid to google

  • @sonnysantana5454
    @sonnysantana5454 Рік тому

    yes the llamas never felt safe enough when the legionnaires were marching through

  • @lilaccilla
    @lilaccilla Рік тому

    omg a Such a Fast Talker ! thank you for the transcript

  • @cassieoz1702
    @cassieoz1702 Рік тому

    Good grief Simon, your pronunciation is getting worse.

  • @danielreuben1058
    @danielreuben1058 2 роки тому +14

    Great video. I wonder, if prostitution was legal and regulated, would society see a decline in rape, and sexual assault? I also think the notion of dominant and submissive is still a large part of how society views sexual relations in modern times.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo 2 роки тому +11

      Nope. Women were treated as property, objects. You don't ask an object for consent before using it. Moreover, countries where prostitution is legal see higher rates of trafficking and sexual violence. Prostitution devalues people in the eyes of the consumer. It makes people into objects.
      You have to remember that most cases of rape and sexual assault doesn't involve overt violence. It is exceedingly rare that the perpetrator is a stranger. The difference is that when it happens, you hear about it. That's what you see in movies or series. In reality, most of the time the perpetrator is someone the victim knows. And often, it boils down to the rapist - usually a guy - not taking no for an answer or ignoring clear signs of non-verbal refusal. The whole playing-hard-to-get idea makes it even worse.
      In addition, you have the issue of martial rape. This has been and still is the most common type of rape. However, in many cultures it is completely legal. Even in countries where it is illegal it is nearly impossible to prove. Historically, women belonged to their husbands. With no right to say no.
      So, no. Prostitution doesn't prevent rape. What does help is better laws, clearer legal definitions, better understanding on how people react in a state of panic, and a police force that is properly trained on how to handle a case involving rape. Having specialised teams with all every professional the victim needs also helps.

    • @demonzabrak
      @demonzabrak 2 роки тому +3

      @@Ikajo ​ marital* rape. In case you aren’t a native English speaker, martial is like combat, martial arts. Marital is related to marriage, or husband and wife. If you are, whoopsies you did a typo.
      I’d have to check some numbers to dispute your other points about prostitution because they seem counterintuitive, but many things in modern society are, so I’m not gonna challenge that now.
      Not that I think you’re wrong about most of it, I just don’t know any data sets that conclusively prove “rape is more common when prostitution is legal.”
      For sure that thing about it normally not being strangers is true, and so is the “hard to get” thing. Also the bits about social support structures and systemic changes being the best way to combat the problem.
      Real solid response, generally speaking. It would be better with links to the data you reference.
      Got any of them data sets?

    • @fenrirr22
      @fenrirr22 2 роки тому +7

      @@Ikajo Considering, that rape is more common in most of the developing countries, and prostitution is almost always illegal in these places, while in some of the western countries it is legal to a certain extent, it is 100%, that you are factually wrong in your statement, about the relationship of prostitution and rape. (The other parts of your comment seemed fine).
      Just like legalizing drugs leads to decreased drug related violence, and doesn't increase the number of addicts.
      Prohibition never ever helped in anything, that is a simple fact, with many historical evidences.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo 2 роки тому

      @@demonzabrak UA-cam delete comments with links in them unfortunately. You could read this book though The Pimping of Prostitution - Abolishing the Sex Work Myth.
      I also want to point to the Swedish model. In Sweden it is legal to sell sex, but illegal to buy it. As a result, cases of trafficking has gone down. The law also protects the victims while targeting the source. Without buyers, no demand. No demand, no supply. Additionally, law changes has made the definition of rape wider and each instance counts as its own crime.
      Then you have the fact that most statistics are incomplete since they are based on reported cases. Over 90% of all sexual assault cases are never reported, more in countries where women's rights are neglected. Instead, surveys and interviews tend to form a better picture.
      There is also the fact that a lot of people tend to answer no to the question "Have you been raped?" but answer yes to the question "Have you been forced or pushed into having sex?". Due to common depiction of rape, people don't always realise that a lack of consent is still rape.
      When folks say prostitution should be legal, they usually mean it should be legal to buy sex. That doesn't reduce rape. The Swedish model on the other hand has proven effective.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo 2 роки тому +4

      @@fenrirr22 In most developing countries, spousal rape is completely legal and women tend to lack the most basic human rights. Those are the determining factors, not the legal status of prostitution. Add in war and civil unrest. In many developing countries, women are viewed as lesser. As property. With no right to their own body.
      Legal prostitution wouldn't do anything for them. All it would do is cause more exploitation. Including from sex tourism. The women wouldn't have any more agency.
      High gender equality lowers rape because it gives women rights and agency. Prostitution does not.

  • @RobSchellinger
    @RobSchellinger 2 роки тому +1

    How did I not find out The Greatest Beer Run Ever from Simon?

  • @daralic2255
    @daralic2255 2 роки тому +1

    I need sources! I want to read about this.

  • @dearbrad1996
    @dearbrad1996 Рік тому

    At least, ancient people weren't arrested for being naked

  • @tonymirarchi
    @tonymirarchi 2 роки тому +1

    As with any luxury, it correlates to the available money.

  • @curtism-w6b
    @curtism-w6b 2 роки тому +5

    I think the connection between being a lesbian and being a sex worker is still clear today. Bad childhood experiences with men often leads to sex work and disliking serious relationships with men. When I was in college, I was the doorman at a gentleman's club that I wasn't even old enough to have a drink in (you could work in a place that served alcohol at 19 years and a day ... yep, that 1 day actually mattered). Nearly half of the girls who worked there were lesbians. 2 girls even got fired because they had a female pimp who would come every night to make sure they weren't holding out tip money from her.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo 2 роки тому +3

      Being homosexual, which include lesbian, is inborn and has _nothing_ to do with upbringing or life experience. Your comment is both homophobic and sexist.

    • @curtism-w6b
      @curtism-w6b 2 роки тому +2

      @@Ikajo so if I come with 5 university studies from universities that you can't into and a couple of friends with similar experiences, you'd still say this? Do me a favor ... shut up.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo 2 роки тому

      @@curtism-w6b Ah, so you think personal experience trumps established facts. Alright, here's one for you. I'm literally part of LGBT+ community. There are study after study that prove sexuality isn't chosen nor is it a result of ones upbringing. It is a part of who we are.
      You are still a homophobe and a big one at that.

    • @lilaccilla
      @lilaccilla Рік тому

      @@Ikajo i do not agree with that . I think being molested as a child by men usually , does lead to hating men in general and then preferring the company of women to feel safe , which leads to intimacy with women too. I think most prostitutes are damaged as children growing up in horrific circumstances , like the sex trades worldwide . And Epstein was a part of this world . I do not doubt we know nothing of what really is happening behind the scenes of those in powerful positions everywhere . It has always been covered up . Hopefully someday women and men will be treated with respect and can hold on to their self respect and dignity . But it really is not looking well for the children of this world who are born into poverty . Too many odds against them with the all to powerful elites.

    • @Ikajo
      @Ikajo Рік тому

      @@lilaccilla You are conflating trauma with sexuality. Those are not in the same realm of existence. Grow up.

  • @QuantumRift
    @QuantumRift 2 роки тому +1

    ..what if he was the middle man in 3-man BF? LOL...

  • @annoyingbookgirl
    @annoyingbookgirl Рік тому

    So Greek and Roman life is just like a/b/o fics

  • @minagica
    @minagica 2 роки тому +1

    Poor Simon, but at least his little capitalist heart gets to pound 😂

  • @ignaciomoreno9655
    @ignaciomoreno9655 Рік тому

    We have internet and rule 34... 😆 🤣 😆 🤣 😆

  • @zackmedina1245
    @zackmedina1245 2 роки тому +1

    "what's a pederast Walter?"

  • @jenniferlonnes7420
    @jenniferlonnes7420 2 роки тому +1

    I just realized the Pences are Greek.

  • @cosmicpolitan
    @cosmicpolitan Рік тому

    Paul: the wet blanket of history.

  • @donaldkelly3983
    @donaldkelly3983 2 роки тому +1

    Another excellent video!
    But did I hear you call "Caligula" a classic? Gore Vidal said "Caligula" was Latin for "turkey."

    • @jojo-pk
      @jojo-pk 2 роки тому

      It means "small boots"

  • @jackcarson5401
    @jackcarson5401 Рік тому

    Before viewing the video, I'm predicting the answer is something like, "some were perverts, some were prudes."