Minx Sua with long hair is really pretty. But then somebody spoiled her image with strange short blond hair( She is my bias now in dreamcatcher. And she is really pretty now❤
You don't understand how bad I need this on Spotify like this would be played all day. My dream is that they could release this as OT7 for next year, since it is Minx' 10th anniversary... there's even a ballad they performed on this concert too that has no official release, so even a b-side!
I'm strongly convinced that Happy Face and the girls themselves are a one in a million case of never even having looked outward for how to be idols. I don't think they looked at the competition and thought about doing things the way other groups did, whether it's dancing trends or singing live or not. I think for them after DalShabet ended and they needed another group, the plan was that idols sing and dance - end of. The better they do those two, the better the group is. What I mean is basically that I think they never really "grew through the 3rd gen to 4th gen" per say, because they didn't really emulate those eras. They just did their own Minxcatcher thing and the industry was changing around them. @@totalwar1793
Happyface tested both Action and Home before the debut, and audiences didn’t really like Action… that’s why it quietly disappeared. (Not even released as a single or album.)
Not sure if it's because I bias her in Dreamcatcher, but in any Action stage, I can't take my eyes off Sua. Usually it's Jiu that keeps my eyes in Minx era, but some stages (especially when Sua has long hair), Sua just captivates me.
@@jaeger2780 I mean WDYCTMH was liked by fans the main problem was the amount of time it took them for them to have their first comeback. Even if they released Action, it wouldn't change Minx's fate really.
I would actually not be against this, imagine how Dami and Siyeons voices would sound especially since they are much deeper. They are more more mature, I have a feeling Gahyeon would suit it
SuA Bit Siyeon's Lip They don't even talk about Minx unless a fan, an interviewer or someone else brings it up. They're probably told to by the company, or they're trying to pretend that Minx never existed in the first place, since they technically flopped as Minx. 😔
They all were. Yoohyeon seems like shes the only member comfortable with more revealing outfits, the other girls dont mind it when its suited and not blatantly sexual to bring certain audiances in.
![[14.08.16] MinX(밍스) 액션 직캠 (오크밸리) by 헤임달](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5N3EXGk0KSU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[14.08.16] MinX(밍스) 액션 직캠 (오크밸리) by 헤임달](/img/tr.png)
![(ENG CC) [해결솨] 서울 홍대에서 만난 동물들? 1화 사육솨 I SOLUTION SUA, Zookeeper, 드림캐쳐, 수아 Dreamcatcher](/img/n.gif)
Minx Sua with long hair is really pretty. But then somebody spoiled her image with strange short blond hair( She is my bias now in dreamcatcher. And she is really pretty now❤
You don't understand how bad I need this on Spotify like this would be played all day. My dream is that they could release this as OT7 for next year, since it is Minx' 10th anniversary... there's even a ballad they performed on this concert too that has no official release, so even a b-side!
Stable live vocals way before Dreamcatcher, it's a no brainer why HFE never gave up on them.
It must be interesting growing through the years where lip-syncing was less prominent, then having the times change to now.
I'm strongly convinced that Happy Face and the girls themselves are a one in a million case of never even having looked outward for how to be idols. I don't think they looked at the competition and thought about doing things the way other groups did, whether it's dancing trends or singing live or not. I think for them after DalShabet ended and they needed another group, the plan was that idols sing and dance - end of. The better they do those two, the better the group is. What I mean is basically that I think they never really "grew through the 3rd gen to 4th gen" per say, because they didn't really emulate those eras. They just did their own Minxcatcher thing and the industry was changing around them. @@totalwar1793
This is a good performance, but on average Minx were not quite as insane a Dreamcatcher. They had some rough lives. Which is obvious but still.
This is brilliant. They may be DC now that we all love, but they certainly had the talent right from the start as Minx.
didn't anyone notice how Jiu took Sua's mike and gave it back? that was professional!
@2:17 I had to see that again to see what was going on there, and noticed it was so that SuA could do her dance break!
94 duo combi is 👍 since 10years ago apparantly
probably my fave minx song T_T wish it was on spotify
If they took this song for debut instead of "Why did you come to my home?"they would got more recognition definitely.
I'm kinda happy minx kinda flopped because that led to the birth of dreamcatcher and also the addition of Handong and Gahyeon
@@rus-poo same!!🥺 we wouldve never seen Handong and Gahyeon with this group and the thought of that makes me so sad😭😭
Happyface tested both Action and Home before the debut, and audiences didn’t really like Action… that’s why it quietly disappeared. (Not even released as a single or album.)
@@rus-pooyeah but it would be hilarious though
Not sure if it's because I bias her in Dreamcatcher, but in any Action stage, I can't take my eyes off Sua. Usually it's Jiu that keeps my eyes in Minx era, but some stages (especially when Sua has long hair), Sua just captivates me.
you gotta admit,
minx released some b o p s
i love this song so much wow everything about it is great
You can see Dreamcatcher is there, the fierce in the stage regardless of the genre is their trademark for me.
Nice song live performance
와~ 진짜 좋다.
I actually really like this song
If they had taken this song instead of Love Shake, maybe they would have noticed a little more.
Let's be thankful they didn't. They were meant for greater things
@@jaeger2780 Yep, if they would’ve been successful as minx, Dreamcatcher would’ve never happened.
@@Dos004 Agree, they wouldn't be with Handong and Gahyeon rn
@@jaeger2780 I mean WDYCTMH was liked by fans the main problem was the amount of time it took them for them to have their first comeback. Even if they released Action, it wouldn't change Minx's fate really.
Great performers from the very beginning.
We got served by MinxCatcher !! ^^ xD
Bora I could never 2:24
Sua reacted to this on today's vlive!!!
Really? Do you know the date pls?
A whole bop :(
Petition for DCC to upload this as a DC b-side
I would actually not be against this, imagine how Dami and Siyeons voices would sound especially since they are much deeper. They are more more mature, I have a feeling Gahyeon would suit it
JiU 💞💞💞💞
Happyface ent why you buried this song???You got sued or what.. lol (#joke)
Esta canción es increíble. Ojalá la hubiesen grabado, aún como Dreamcatcher.
Wow I actually love this
I’d love to see dreamcatcher cover this some day🌝
New find. Where have i been...
I really love seeing them enjoying the performance
애기애기해ㅋㅋ
really perfect.😍
They were always so cool...😭😭💕💜💕
Thank you!! ^^
10 years🥹❤️
Thank You! Amazing!
Wait, Minx Sua with long hair?? This is before they shot the mv for Why Did You Come to My Home. 😯
Its before they debut as minx
헤임달님 옛날 영상에 정말 죄송한데 혹시 이 영상을 유튜브에 사용해도 될까요..?
제 유튜브 체널이 이 친구들인데 좋은 자료가 될 수 있을 것 같아서요;)
불쾌하시다면 바로 삭제하겠습니다🙏
I see why hello venus got dami into happyface
remind me of 4minutes
what song?
Action
Does anyone know what happened to the fancam of Jiu from this exact event? I wanted to post about it on Instagram
This was before they even debut as minx?
Wow i didn't notice the date. It seems so. I know that this hadn't been released studio. Maybe it was a pre release
Yes it was pre debut, presumably to test the waters. They also performed WDYCTMH and another unreleased slower song.
가현은 이 곡을 잘모름 ㅋㅋ 미발매곡이라
😬😬
What is the title?
"Action" It's one of their predebut songs that have never been released... :(
Arikiana Aion just if this is their title track. They will gained nore fans. But im glad they are dreamcatcger now
Dang minx era,they wear the short pant ..glad they not do this concept again
This song for who ???? 😭
Dreamcatcher News This was a Minx predebut song that they never released on an album, it's titled Action.
pearlofivris why didnt they release it? Its awesome! *cries in a corner cause now there is no official release to download it in good quality*
Niki S. time to pray they release a special clip of this
SuA Bit Siyeon's Lip omg, now that they've gotten better just imagine the dance break on the special clip ( *^*) great, now i'm even more hyped!
SuA Bit Siyeon's Lip They don't even talk about Minx unless a fan, an interviewer or someone else brings it up. They're probably told to by the company, or they're trying to pretend that Minx never existed in the first place, since they technically flopped as Minx. 😔
my only problem with this is I think JiU is a little oversexualized
They were all sexualized which is one of the reasons I feel awkward watching minx vids
They all were. Yoohyeon seems like shes the only member comfortable with more revealing outfits, the other girls dont mind it when its suited and not blatantly sexual to bring certain audiances in.