Ported vs Sealed Subwoofer Pros and Cons
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 чер 2020
- In this video, I explain the pros and cons of Sealed vs Ported Subwoofers. Comment below your thoughts on the subject and why you'd choose one or the other.
Subwoofers I Recommend:
SVS SB1000 PRO: bit.ly/3Qscxw9
SVS PB-1000 PRO: bit.ly/44DnCRb
Klipsch RP1200 SW: bit.ly/3wqyULA
MartinLogan Dynamo 600X Subwoofer: bit.ly/4dnnk4A
DIY Subwoofer Video: • Home Theater Guru’s Th...
Shop for your favorite audio goodies:
Amazon: amzn.to/3y28kJl
Best Buy: howl.me/cl9Fdbp03Ae
Audio Advice: bit.ly/3xZB5X2
Crutchfield: howl.me/cl9FeSNnwFm
👕 Merchandise:
Grab your exclusive HiFi T-shirts here: michael-andrew-shop.fourthwal...
🌟 Support My Work:
Join my Patreon for exclusive "After Filming Commentary" and more: bit.ly/41Qpnc6
🔗 Stay Connected:
📸 / _mykandrew
🐦⬛ / _mykandrew
🎵 / _mykandrew
🎧 / discord
📧 Contact:
For business inquiries or collaborations, email: mike@hypehive.io
Full Disclosure:
Some of the links in this description are affiliate links, which means if you purchase through them, I'll earn a little commission to keep this channel running. Think of it as a little tip for a job well done, and thank you for supporting the channel 🤙
#subwoofer #subwoofers #sealedsubwoofer #portedsubwoofer #hometheater - Розваги
Sealed subs for life. Way more definition / speed. So much more clear and sharp.
Gamer19 doing a DIY project right now 15” Stereo Integrity HST in a sealed GSG custom box. Video coming soon.... ;)
Can sealed boxed hit low? Like 30hz with authority (if another power is given)
@@sanj5026 yes! My sealed Punisher build doesn’t start to roll off until 18hz
@@mykandrew nice!! I think I am gonna put my new sub in a sealed box
Both.
A sealed subwoofer sounds nice when listening at low volume at night, subtly thumping in the background with good definition and speed. You can still have a good audio experience without waking up the whole house. I wonder whether other fans of sealed subwoofers have a similar experience.
Exact same experience for me ;)
💯
I prefer sealed in the form of an infinite baffled sub.
Yes but in a car. I also like I can have it loud but you can't really hear it outside
Thanks
That’s what I wanted to hear as I’m starting another system with SB because my PB rumble the house even at low volume.
Wife and kids
😬😵💫🙆🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️😅🤷🏻♂️
I’m Picking up duals tomorrow.
Mike this is lit man. This was very easy to learn from you
Great job bro & you’re 100% right! 😎👍🏻
Awesome video Mike! We love passive radiators 😉
Great video! I totally agree!
Thanks for this video, really helped me on my next project. God bless... 😁😁😁
1155views and 40 likes? What’s wrong guys!!! That video deserves more ASAP🔥🔥🔥👏👏👏
It is a fantastic explanation... Thanks!
If you have a ported sub,you can test the difference for yourself. I just plugged the port with a thick car washing sponge. It helped me with the "boominess" when listening to music. Now is a lot tighter.
Not even close to accurate. Every single speaker will have different volume requirements for sealed and ported enclosures.
@@AwesomeFinish Like he mentioned "listening to music" because in many cases they position their subs incorrectly and if they have a port it may be aimed into the room to suffer a negative interaction with it. On a good sub (for example the SVS lineup) you can plug the ports are get a decent enough sound vs output because their volume is most likely towards the larger end of the driver's design parameter while on a poorly designed sub (like what you see in most htib or soundbars) plugging the port will impact the output and depth severely.
sound quality comes first, so sealed for me, open baffle is another diskussion, but if you want a box make it sealed.
if people are on a low budget, cheap subwoofers might not reach deep enough or you have no dsp option to get the deepest bass.
how loud you can play or how deep is alway the biggest limitation of the budget, do not compromise on the sound quality.
both movies or music benefits from sealed sound quality subwoofers, same with bass extension to 15hz.
"who has ever really heard a gunshot"? Every person I know. So, sealed. Ha.
Dude thats awesome 🙂🙂
Thanks!
I use a sealed dual 10” subwoofer and a ported subwoofer.
I have the sealed for when listening to music and the ported set up on a kill switch for watching movies
nice setup😃
Hi, i have a jbl sw10 10" subwoofer, it's ported now, but would it be better to seal it? Many thanks!
You can put sponges in the port to seal it and give it a try ;)
I have a problem. my 15 inch sub box sealed can't rumble in the chest, I don't know what's wrong?
thank you..
Q: Do you like sealed or ported subwoofer?
A: Yes.
My main gripe is the silly .1 single sub. I use two sealed subs for the left and right channels, and a large, ported dual-driver sub for the .1 channel.
With Dolby Prologic you can convert pure stereo to pseudo 5.1 for those times when volume is all you need.
... or you can use two really good 12-15" drivers and keep them sealed, and with room gain it should be more than enough for home theater.
If your doing a two sub setup and you like both movies and music would you recommend one sub ported and the other sub sealed?
I own sealed i own ported I own lots of subs. Now there's lots of factors room size, structure carpeting draps... Etc
Musical preference as my sealed sub really shines with classic rock and Metal as my ported really shines with hip hop music and for home theater. Also cost you really can't compare a $300 sub to a $2,000 SVS as those svs will make you happy if it's sealed or not. It's also personal preference what my ears hear and like can differ from yours. My advice is to buy both and test them in your home see what gives you a better Bass.
My current home theater has 4 Definitive Super Cubes 1's which have 1 driver and 2 passive radiators each. The passive radiator is the port so they are ported but they are airtight sealed. The radiators give it an acoustic suspension keeping the bass tight so you kind get the best of both worlds sealed/ported.
thankssss
🔥🔥🔥🔥
I have Two - 6.5 inch subwoofers in a Sealed box for my Mini Cooper.
I chose sealed because I wanted the extra sound range from mid to low end - because of the type of music I listen to.
What type of music do you listen to if I may ask? And does a sealed setup do the right job based on the genre and frequency of the lows in the music you listen to?
@@weeAmos Check out my 10's in sealed box....
ua-cam.com/video/7i7UucDUUgY/v-deo.html
Part of the reason you can get away with such small drivers is the cabin gain you get from a car. This is why the same sub outdoors won't sound as good as when it's in the car.
@@MrWirelesscaller When you roll down the port (window) it's a 4th order.... lol
Depends on set up also they both sound good but I'm running sealed rn bass sounds better clear but ported does hit louder my experience doing set ups with diff subs .
I want a sealed sub but what size? 2x8" 2x10" 1x12" 1x15" ? ... I also don't find many inexpensive ones so thinking of building my own
Building your own can be great! Check out the build I did with the Punisher, it’s a sealed 15 and is honestly one of the best subwoofers I’ve ever owned!
Ive found that 10 inch drivers are the sweet spot vs 8 for speed and 12 or more for thump.
And a subwoofer box for a 10-inch driver also happens to hit the sweet spot for size. I bought a passive 10-inch sub from a car audio store, carried it home on a bus, and hooked it up to an automotive subwoofer amp in my bedroom. As for speed and thump, it is as you described above.
which subwoofer tends to have better bass at longer range? (the kind of bass you often hear from far concert)
Thanks :)
@Jerrime Williams but sealed are less loud than ported I think
Concert subs can be a 24” in a scoop box for air flow. It is tuned for low 15hz. The power is 2-5k just for one sub. Also at a concert there is a mixing console that a Engineer adjust highs, miss and lows separately. So what this means for home is how big your room is, how big your budget is, start with a amp that is separate from the receiver and it is cleaner sound. Yamaha makes awesome home amps and for studios. Definitive Technology makes towers that have the subwoofer built into it. I have had these with a 12” sub each and a designated amp built in. I sold them for more than what I bought them for when I moved.
I prefer the lower bass from ported boxes. I have had both sealed and ported and I’m a bigger fan of ported
ported= for hip-hop
sealed= for heavy metal
that's all folks
nope, there's also subs with passive radiators
@@carewser yes, i forgot
I used to have a Velodyne home sub which was 15” front fired and 12” Dow fired passive. This shock the room and worked with metal, hip hop and moviies
What would u recommend I put a 12" Pioneer Champion series in ?
Car or home?
That’s a car sub right?
@@mykandrew car i believe. Im using it for a car
Do a sealed enclosure with a ton of power! That sub can do work, put it to work ;)
What about for your vehicle what would you recommend
Stereo Integrity Subwoofers!
@@mykandrew Pretty sure she meant sealed or ported?
I made a little box for a 1 inch speaker and used to be sealed but once I made a hole and made a port for it, sounded so much better and could hear the bass better and surprised how much bass a 1 inch speaker could produce
no mention of subs with passive radiators? I own two and they're the rarer third option but I really think the industry is moving in that direction, albeit slowly
so I need two for music and two for movies?
Get yourself a couple sealed 15” subwoofers with good power and you’ll be fine for both!
Now I’m confused 🤷♂️. Home theater Ported is recommendation for all reviewer. But starke don’t make ported 🤔. Your thoughts mike? Thanks 😊
The SUB35 is passive radiator which I like better than ported. It has the best of both worlds. It’s nice and loud but still tight and musical
Audio Arkitekts anyway I love to listen to music too. So Hope in wall starke speakers will give me good impression. I’m Looking forward to listen to it this coming Monday.
For home cinema, with 3000i set up, I decided to go with a sealed. But stuck between SVS SB2000 or REL ht1205?
Sukh Singh R1983 ohhhhhh both of those are super nice. I did a video on the SB2000 pro check it out
@@mykandrew do you prefer sealed subs?
@@bennya5171 it all depends on the situation and the sub. I’m a bit of a sub snob lol 😂
@@mykandrew I have a sealed sub works wonderful but not sure if I made a mistake purchasing a sealed one since some folks talk about it not being the best.
@@bennya5171 whoever told you that obviously has a preference. Sealed subs provide more musicality and are a bit more accurate when reproducing music than ported. However ported can get much louder without as much power. Just wait until I finish the Punisher sealed sub build. You’ll be convinced.
My bass guitar speakers (1 1x15 and 1 4x10) are both vented, but made for huge volumes.
I have to say as an owner of both the SVS PB3000 in theater room and SB 2000pro in my bedroom, I will never purchase another sealed sub for home theater again. As far as my truck audio, sealed all day even though the JL TW5 12” doesn’t hit the 22-18 hz frequencies with authority like a ported box would.
But the PB 3000 is already on a diff class level than the 2000
Would’ve been more interesting to see the PB 3000 vs SB 3000 instead
I use 2 12,s rockfordfosgate p1 in a ported box meant for a car for my home theater system and it sounds killer with the rest of my speakers for mids
2-12"s in 3 cubes sealed ❤
i still and always will prefer ported
So, i do think a sealed with passive radiators is the way to go. It has both benneffits from sealed and portes boxes in a compact enclosure. Problem is, there are really a few of them only availlable here and there among the models aabd usually pricey. I use to have a RSW-10d klipsch subwoofer that was 500rms/1200peak as today Klipsch speakers on 10 inch got 200rms/400peak power. Even the SPL150 got 400/800 (despite it’s higher db output die to size). They simple left me orfaned after problema with the sub! But it was wonderfull for music and for moovies at the same time with a perfect fast attack, chest thumping bass in a small enclosure…
I have the Starke Sound SUB35 which is an amazing option in that category.
It is Music in movies allways in some way then. I have a 15 square meter room then.
I do not want the driver unloading so unless the box can be tuned to 16Hz I will go for sealed. A ported or better yet horn or TL can be OK if it is being properly high passed. The biggest obstacle these days is finding drivers appropriate for sealed enclosures.
Do a search for Dayton drivers (their subs are mostly designed for home theater). They should have a few subs to meet your criteria.
this is bad but.....I put 2 paradigm servo 15's in my trunk and ran wire direct to the sub bypassing everything and its nuts I have never had ported ever
Passive radiator same as portred? No way.
Yup, subs with passive radiators are the weird, third option that don't fit into either category
one small detail here is that the high pass filter should be lower than the port tune not exactly at, the port tune is where the excursion is the lowest high passing there you are wasting potential
Just make a 4th order subwoofer box😅
for example 2kw sealed subwoofer, sounds like 1kw ported subwoofer
so i choose ported for home cinema, thanks
Awesome glad I could help
What about gaming?
It has music and movies in one?
Oh great, so in fact I need both types and switch between them.
What would it happens if you put bass reflex in sealed woofer?
You missed alot lol it depends on cubic feet of a box, and how you tune the box. You can't use those universal Walmart boxes for a good sound system. You have to tune a box, and you can tune either box, ported or sealed, for any frequency or use.
So here's where I'm gonna fill in his gaps. If you prefer rap, and sound pressure level, ported can be better if tuned correctly.
If you listen to metal, rock music, or dubstep, a proper tuned sealed box will enhance quality. But you can tune either way. Pay attention to box cubic feet, reverb within the box, port dimensions, length, shape etc.
Camera too close to your face. Back up a little.
ported best
It all depends....
But what does science say apart from your opinions?
Well, these weren’t my opinions alone. I consulted with a veteran Speaker designer when I put this together. So you can take from it what you will ;)
You need air for volume and deep ness. No port sub limited.
Speakes too fast makes me nervous.
Car: ported for rap music, sealed for Rock. Home: both