arjen robben is the best example of the surprise element. Sometimes he would cut in to his left foot, and other times he would cut in to his left foot.
I'd add 2 more factors: 1. Skillset of receiver - Not only that ball possessor's skill set but the skillset of the potential receiving player 2. Situational - similar to dictating this is about managing the game particularly the scoreline, playing home or away, etc. Also relates to the team tactics for the match and style of play.
IMHO: the selection of candidates mainly consists of the 18-21 yo - at 2:11 . At this age, even pros are more focused on their technique and their position within the team rather than understanding the context of decision making. No wonder their answer was: "Unpredictability". I would expect 25+ or even 30+ folks to give you more insights on how they make decisions because this skill comes only with experience
I would add two things for decision-making I consider for myself, my teammates and the 12 year olds I coach, as very valuable. First, "Make the best out of your teammate's decisions". This means, that you should trust and support the actions of your team. If the Center Back decides to play a long ball to you as a Winger, follow into this, even if you disagree with the decision. If you are a Left Back and your Left Winger takes the 1v2, follow the Winger to either minimize the damage of the decision or to get the most out of it. It sounds very basic and indeed it is not complicated. However, the discipline in doing this is a huge difference between amateurs and professionals. Second, "Receiving is a Skill". I catch the attention of the youth players by asking what Florian Wirtz, Cole Palmer and Neymar are best at. And to their surprise my (personal and educational) answer is receiving the ball. When watching football, I tend more and more to not look at the ball, but instead observe the movements of players that intend to receive the ball. Even there, body feints, sprints, coordination with team mates comes to play, which is very interesting. Especially in the attacking third, where space is severely limited, this skill is helpful and should be emphasized more.
This is such a great video, very good information and also easy to understand, I already shared it with a few players and I would recommend it to anyone, regardless of their level. The only thing I would add is that this study only incorporates controlled decisions, not habitual ones. The habitual decisions happen instinctively when, because of stress, fatigue etc you are no longer capable of having analytical thinking. So, if you are a player reading this: study this video, it’s the cheat code to unlocking your best footballing self and also you should control your mind and body, not the other way around.
This is a very informative video about how football should be played. The style of play should always be determined by the individual qualities of the players and not the other way around. Only the best coaches pay attention to this. If you can train each player individually to enhance their best qualities, integrate them into the team, and as a coach are willing to adapt your game to this, you will always have a winning team. The well-supported science adds great value to this video and confirms that football is not as simple as it seems, offering more insight into how the game should be played! Top!
Great video, the options changed in an instant, so it just proves how dynamic football is and how you have to be tuned in mentally 24/7. My first instinct was the give and go with the center midfielder and then knock it out to the full-back but when the center mid pushed right, I would have gone for a dink over the head of the white to the winger out wide,
I'm really impressed by your findings-thank you! I'll be reaching out to Dr. Ramsey to discuss the role of communication in football. Hope You might find it helpful as well.
"Not be the best at everything" at the premier league level yes. But to get to PL, every player will need to be top 1% at almost every technical skill (pass, dribble, shoot, movement, defending, etc.). Guehi would still crush a 50 yd diagonal pass 9/10 times at the amateur level.
Psalm 34:18 "The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit." This verse offers comfort, reminding us that God is near to those who are sad or struggling and provides hope and healing.
it is all about coordination and game knowledge, if you don't know how to play and when and where to play , you can't be good player.. even though many players scans the area but they can't make a good choice , because their game vision and focus level is less than other players
This is the problem with the English there futbol has no context. These factors are taken in isolation with a myopic personal view of the game. The perceptual cues need to be much broader and take into account phases of play and the "meta" Argentines track exponentially more perceptive cues than what's described in this paper
@@Crazy_edits23 they track position on field by VAEP /inversion of shape / pitch control whatever you want to call it. they track shape at point of engagement both offense and defense, the likely pattern and any "read options" this is the "boca system" it's like a read option offense in football nfl that is
Implying he is saying anything remotely contrary to what you're saying... He is only speaking about being surprising is important, and it is pros already know the "best pass option" you need something else to get pass the defense. Any game is situational, there's not a secret formula.
@@PEDROGARCIA-qj3gr a soccer game is played in Tactical combinations like boxing or music the South Americans and Croatians learn the combinations in 2s 4ths 8ths and 16ths scaling executive functioning of the brain and creating g a neural net by training change of decision mechanics this is why they call the English and Germans naive. It's methodology of Bielsa and Lobanovskiy and it somewhat permeated what the English call "relationism" . Games are not "situational" they are automated
Nós não temos muito o direito de julgar pois não estamos na visão do jogador, não é tão fácil assim como parece, ter a visão de todo o campo e de todos os jogadores é um luxo impossível para quem está dentro do campo.
I think there's an underlying bias in this: professional players are built differently than other players. Processing speed, eye-leg coordination, intuition and so on which are not trainable. So, what emerged from a study involving professional or semi-professional players I think concerns only professionals and semi-professionals, not the others. Although improving scanning and decision making certainly improves the quality of each player
@@stnbch3025 Eye-limb coordination, as well as processing speed (and reaction speed), have a low trainability percentage. What I mean is that it is not possible to train those characteristics in such a way as to turn a non-pro player into a professional player. To become a pro you must already possess those characteristics.
@@baxthepaz89This is how I know you are the type that likes to talk even though you’re wrong. This is literally not true, these things are built up with training. Of course you don’t become amateur to pro in a short time, it takes thousands of hours of necessary training. And these skills are learned through experience on the field as well as training. Others learn faster sure, but to say you cannot train it is very amateur of you.
45sec in, and you mention 4 options, which neither seem optimal? He should have changed sides to the left back, so the back could cut towards the centre to pick up the opponents right back's attention, so he can play his winger free into depth? And if the other team the adjusts sideways correctly instead, then there should be a central midfielder coming in a central overlap run, who could be passed into depth.
Save some time: they do it by visually scanning and making decisions according to their particular skills. Now I saved you time, go and watch some Vinicius top plays.
arjen robben is the best example of the surprise element. Sometimes he would cut in to his left foot, and other times he would cut in to his left foot.
"Surely he won't do it agai-oh he scored"
Predictable but unstoppable 🎉
“Proving the doubters wrong”?
😂😅
😂😂😂😂
I'd add 2 more factors:
1. Skillset of receiver - Not only that ball possessor's skill set but the skillset of the potential receiving player
2. Situational - similar to dictating this is about managing the game particularly the scoreline, playing home or away, etc. Also relates to the team tactics for the match and style of play.
IMHO: the selection of candidates mainly consists of the 18-21 yo - at 2:11 . At this age, even pros are more focused on their technique and their position within the team rather than understanding the context of decision making. No wonder their answer was: "Unpredictability". I would expect 25+ or even 30+ folks to give you more insights on how they make decisions because this skill comes only with experience
I would add two things for decision-making I consider for myself, my teammates and the 12 year olds I coach, as very valuable.
First, "Make the best out of your teammate's decisions". This means, that you should trust and support the actions of your team. If the Center Back decides to play a long ball to you as a Winger, follow into this, even if you disagree with the decision. If you are a Left Back and your Left Winger takes the 1v2, follow the Winger to either minimize the damage of the decision or to get the most out of it. It sounds very basic and indeed it is not complicated. However, the discipline in doing this is a huge difference between amateurs and professionals.
Second, "Receiving is a Skill". I catch the attention of the youth players by asking what Florian Wirtz, Cole Palmer and Neymar are best at. And to their surprise my (personal and educational) answer is receiving the ball. When watching football, I tend more and more to not look at the ball, but instead observe the movements of players that intend to receive the ball. Even there, body feints, sprints, coordination with team mates comes to play, which is very interesting. Especially in the attacking third, where space is severely limited, this skill is helpful and should be emphasized more.
This is such a great video, very good information and also easy to understand, I already shared it with a few players and I would recommend it to anyone, regardless of their level.
The only thing I would add is that this study only incorporates controlled decisions, not habitual ones. The habitual decisions happen instinctively when, because of stress, fatigue etc you are no longer capable of having analytical thinking. So, if you are a player reading this: study this video, it’s the cheat code to unlocking your best footballing self and also you should control your mind and body, not the other way around.
Finally we back 🎉🎉 all the way from 🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦 love your videos
This is a very informative video about how football should be played. The style of play should always be determined by the individual qualities of the players and not the other way around. Only the best coaches pay attention to this. If you can train each player individually to enhance their best qualities, integrate them into the team, and as a coach are willing to adapt your game to this, you will always have a winning team. The well-supported science adds great value to this video and confirms that football is not as simple as it seems, offering more insight into how the game should be played! Top!
Great video, the options changed in an instant, so it just proves how dynamic football is and how you have to be tuned in mentally 24/7. My first instinct was the give and go with the center midfielder and then knock it out to the full-back but when the center mid pushed right, I would have gone for a dink over the head of the white to the winger out wide,
Unbelievable video. The detail and the quality is unbelievable
You're an absolute gem. Fantastic video, immediately shared with my team.
I'm really impressed by your findings-thank you! I'll be reaching out to Dr. Ramsey to discuss the role of communication in football. Hope You might find it helpful as well.
Sociology tell us you should expect different outcomes with players/ group sample outside the UK!
Love this video! We need more of this
Thank you for grounding your video in research. It's interesting how so much of decision making happens without the ball.
Thank you for this informative video ❤️ You helped a lot 🙌🏻
"Not be the best at everything" at the premier league level yes. But to get to PL, every player will need to be top 1% at almost every technical skill (pass, dribble, shoot, movement, defending, etc.). Guehi would still crush a 50 yd diagonal pass 9/10 times at the amateur level.
Love you ❤ brother,ypu are the only one that goes into depth and making me a better thinker of the game.
Love your videos mate❤❤
Thank God you are back, eagerly waiting for upcoming more contents of yours 😊😊😊
great video subbed
Love the videos keep em coming! New subscriber here!
Psalm 34:18
"The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit."
This verse offers comfort, reminding us that God is near to those who are sad or struggling and provides hope and healing.
Now instill a variety of goal scoring strategies like the cutback low cross, rebound shots, set plays etc
it is all about coordination and game knowledge, if you don't know how to play and when and where to play , you can't be good player.. even though many players scans the area but they can't make a good choice , because their game vision and focus level is less than other players
Thank you
This is the problem with the English there futbol has no context. These factors are taken in isolation with a myopic personal view of the game. The perceptual cues need to be much broader and take into account phases of play and the "meta" Argentines track exponentially more perceptive cues than what's described in this paper
bro has english like i’ve never seen befor😂e
Could you elaborate "Argentines track exponentially more perceptive cues than what's described in this paper". Thanks.
@@Crazy_edits23 they track position on field by VAEP /inversion of shape / pitch control whatever you want to call it. they track shape at point of engagement both offense and defense, the likely pattern and any "read options" this is the "boca system" it's like a read option offense in football nfl that is
Implying he is saying anything remotely contrary to what you're saying...
He is only speaking about being surprising is important, and it is pros already know the "best pass option" you need something else to get pass the defense.
Any game is situational, there's not a secret formula.
@@PEDROGARCIA-qj3gr a soccer game is played in Tactical combinations like boxing or music the South Americans and Croatians learn the combinations in 2s 4ths 8ths and 16ths scaling executive functioning of the brain and creating g a neural net by training change of decision mechanics this is why they call the English and Germans naive. It's methodology of Bielsa and Lobanovskiy and it somewhat permeated what the English call "relationism" . Games are not "situational" they are automated
Nós não temos muito o direito de julgar pois não estamos na visão do jogador, não é tão fácil assim como parece, ter a visão de todo o campo e de todos os jogadores é um luxo impossível para quem está dentro do campo.
Very informative video of all time
Appreciated a great informative video
This video made me understand football more and love it more thank you
Anticipation of situations. Having 2-3 decisions already planned subject to the opponents action.
am I the only one that thought passing to the left back 00:01
Great content video.. go ahead ❤
how do you edit your vedios
this is great food for thought
Great content as per
love love very helpful
What video editing tool do you use?
I think there's an underlying bias in this: professional players are built differently than other players. Processing speed, eye-leg coordination, intuition and so on which are not trainable. So, what emerged from a study involving professional or semi-professional players I think concerns only professionals and semi-professionals, not the others. Although improving scanning and decision making certainly improves the quality of each player
Coordination, processing speed not trainable... 😂😂😂😂
@@stnbch3025 Eye-limb coordination, as well as processing speed (and reaction speed), have a low trainability percentage. What I mean is that it is not possible to train those characteristics in such a way as to turn a non-pro player into a professional player. To become a pro you must already possess those characteristics.
@@baxthepaz89 what is your source that you must already have it to become a pro?
@@danialkhan3959 My mum
@@baxthepaz89This is how I know you are the type that likes to talk even though you’re wrong. This is literally not true, these things are built up with training. Of course you don’t become amateur to pro in a short time, it takes thousands of hours of necessary training. And these skills are learned through experience on the field as well as training. Others learn faster sure, but to say you cannot train it is very amateur of you.
What colorway is that?!
thanks
great video
45sec in, and you mention 4 options, which neither seem optimal?
He should have changed sides to the left back, so the back could cut towards the centre to pick up the opponents right back's attention, so he can play his winger free into depth?
And if the other team the adjusts sideways correctly instead, then there should be a central midfielder coming in a central overlap run, who could be passed into depth.
See at 7:20 I would pass to 7
Wait what are you doing here? I thought you had a different channel
don't know what you're on about mate
Save some time: they do it by visually scanning and making decisions according to their particular skills.
Now I saved you time, go and watch some Vinicius top plays.
Cool
I play fifa I’m crossing it to the left wing
Lmfao I thought it’s fifa tactics tutorial
football meta is this u
maybe
@@FootballMeta😂
Прикольно
DZ power 🇩🇿💯
Scanning is such a dumb verb for visual perception...
Its accurate
Visual perception is a skill scanning is a tool