Orwell wrote this essay in 1946. Choose at least two examples of political discourse from current media and discuss, in an essay, the extent to which Orwell's analysis of the language of politics still applies today. Which features he singles out for criticism appear most frequently in your chosen examples?
George Carlin made this exact point famously as well. The difference is that by Carlin’s time, this sort of writing had fully invaded political writing and made its way into every day verbiage.
What kinds of prose does Orwell analyze in this essay? Look, in particular, at the passages he quotes in paragraph 3. Where would you find their contemporary equivalents? I dont understand this
Just making sure: at 1:59 when you say "we don't too much about sloppy, disgusting political discourse these days"--that was sarcasm, right? The first time I thought you were being sincere, but the 2nd time I realized, "ah, he must be joking." I would be interested, though, in a video demonstrating just *how* this practice is utilized in American politics today.
Just as a quick example, we see a lot of political groups use slogans that are less about having productive, nuanced discussions aimed at solving problems and are more about showing what team you're (not) on. The kinds of things that get chanted at political rallies
I think this video essay achieves the clarity Orwell recommend people to strive for
Hey, thanks--that's the dream!
Great! Loved it. The vibe, energy, voice -outstanding!
You're too kind! Thanks a bunch!
Orwell wrote this essay in 1946. Choose at least two examples of political discourse from current media and discuss, in an essay, the extent to which Orwell's analysis of the language of politics still applies today. Which features he singles out for criticism appear most frequently in your chosen examples?
Great video. Very clear summation.
Thanks!
Thanks for posting this explanation Andrew. You are the man kid!
You're welcome--and thanks for the kind words! If somebody has to be the man-kid, I'm honored to fill the role, haha
Another great review, thanks. 'Team Kaput' would look good on a t-shirt.
Hey, thanks! (I'll make a mental note of that)
George Carlin made this exact point famously as well. The difference is that by Carlin’s time, this sort of writing had fully invaded political writing and made its way into every day verbiage.
I never comment on youtube videos, but this one was a true masterpiece. Perfect. Saved me from sheer distraught. Thank you!
Thank a lot--I'm happy to hear it helped!
Thanks for the video!
You bet!
It's time to use those suggestions😄
Amazing video, exactly to thr point!
Thanks!
Holy Shit.... THAT is the best explanation.of what I have been seeing. I get this when speaking to the "new age" crowd too.
Glad to hear it! But for sure--Orwell was talking about political writers, but the same bad habits show up in lots of other places...!
What kinds of prose does Orwell analyze in this essay? Look, in particular, at the passages he quotes in paragraph 3. Where would you find their contemporary equivalents? I dont understand this
He includes citations and some specific examples if you want the actual sources, but they're all politically-oriented texts
The way you clarified everything, i think you should come up with tips for clarity in spoken English.
Interesting idea--I'll put it on the list (but I might have to change the name of the channel after that lol)!
You can make another channel as Modern George Orwell on spoken English 😂
@@MahnoorWaqar-v8j Ha--good idea!
Excellent video.
Thanks!
Just making sure: at 1:59 when you say "we don't too much about sloppy, disgusting political discourse these days"--that was sarcasm, right? The first time I thought you were being sincere, but the 2nd time I realized, "ah, he must be joking." I would be interested, though, in a video demonstrating just *how* this practice is utilized in American politics today.
Just as a quick example, we see a lot of political groups use slogans that are less about having productive, nuanced discussions aimed at solving problems and are more about showing what team you're (not) on. The kinds of things that get chanted at political rallies
Why didn't we listen to Orwell dang it!
Haha, if only! But I guess it's never too late!
thanks for the review
The movement of your eyebrows 😅
Thank you for the video!
You're very welcome!