No. He likes it. He said it sometimes. And in recent bro & marble series he was continuously saying hyung hyung hyung to the older ones and acting cute. And at night when they were sleeping he can't help but say everytime to hoshi, he really likes the hyungs, I'm really happy. And in last ep he said to hoshi, so this is how it feels to be a maknae and have an older sibling right. It is so nice and so. I mean he is one of the oldest in seventeen so he never had that experience like hoshi, who had both younger and older ones in seventeen.
I'm also an only child but you know i don't like it because when i saw my friends and their siblings i really get sad because i don't have any one who can play with 🥲 who can love me like elder and who can fight like a younger. I really get jealous when i see siblings 🥲🥲
Reminds me of that one video where Joshua opened unwrapped a chocolate wrapper and wonwoo snatched it from his hand cunningly and people who didn't even know svt said there's "no way he didn't know how to beaware with your food in front of your siblings he must definitely be single child"
@@iamb_4u908 Ah you're welcome I didn't do anything special✿ You're not alone in this world❣️ Seungkwan once said it's okay to laugh and it's okay to cry>.< So let's make a better future and pass these hard days:)
That's opposite in my case bcz I am younger and I always start fight with kicks and when my sister fight back I go to my mom and tell her that she hit me 😎😎 ( Happy to be younger )
@@Skzghostingstay lmao i am also younger but i never start fight first but once i start it, i just complain to my father that my older brother start it first 🤣(and my father also believe me cuz i rarely fight😂)
shua definitely suitable for variety shows or talk shows. i know some fans wanted to see him as an actor but variety shows and talk shows seems like his forte. he has his way.
Joshua right there is definitely me! My friends keep telling me how annoying their siblings are but still keep them entertained enough and they never feel bored with their siblings. They think I feel lonely without a sibling but I love it
I have one sister, our relationship is awful. We hate each other but it's not siblings' energy or anything, it's just cold hateness. But I also would never want to be an only child
Hahaha bless you. I have only 1 younger sister. She's 10 years younger than I so I had experienced being the only child. I love having her that even fighting over trivial things feels special to me. I can not imagine myself being an only child forever. I also does not understand why people wants to be an only child, even for me who is extremely introverted.
I'm an only child and I get that question often too . And I'd answer exactly as Shua that it's actually really great . I guess it's each to their own type of thing. Since we don't have sibling we don't feel like we need one . But those who do , might not be able to imagine being alone . That's what I feel . 🩵🩷
I'm the youngest of 3 and i just can't imagine life without my siblings. They're both much older than me (11 and 7 yrs) so as a kid i would usually struggle to relate to their situations and vice-versa; and growing up with age gaps that big made me mature faster (what i'm grateful for, in a way). But now that we're all adults we've found a lot of common ground recently. It's quite fun ❤
ONLY Child here!!! and I 100% agree with Shua in this. Especially when he says that when people ask him if he is sad and he replies he is Not! THAT part is the same for me!!! Being an ONLY child myself is heavenly!!
Shua seems like he has a lot of friends and like to socialize both in the states and SK, i think he’s far from lonely 😂 and the 12 ppl he can’t get rid of ensure that will never happen.
I remember that time when seventeen got asked on a radio show to choose a member that they want to introduce to their sister (the question refers to the members who has a sister) and everyone choose no one except hoshi who's willingly asked them to just take his sister lol😂
As a girl with I younger brother I think about how much I love my brother even though I will fight over stupid things with him like hoshi and his sister.
The thing that Joshua said rn is so true as a single child many people think I am lonely and all but my life is perfectly fine with all the love that I get from my parents and I do not have to share anything with someone, my life is pretty great
As an only child, seriously the only good thing happened in my life 😭🤣 like seriously you store your chocolate in fridge like for a weeks and no one will touch it😂 even tho i eat whole chocolate in one night😅 but yeah sometimes i feel lonely but not alone because god bless me with such a good friends whom i share everything when i feel lonely🥹🤌🏻
yes shua preach 🤣 but being an only child also means we're the all types of child, the pressure and expectation for the first child, the "nah, you'll be fine" dismissal for the middle child, and the all the chores are passed to me of the youngest 😭 the very reason i'm very close with my cousins that i grew up with
I can relate to Joshua as a single child. People used to ask me if I am lonely because I am the only child but I am happy because I can spend my time alone 😅
Man I relate to shua on so many levels. I'm also an old child Korean American who grew up in LA learning Korean from a Korean church. My mom even made me drink Korean oriental medicine which I poured down the sink 😂 Only difference is that I dance like a drunk ostrich and sing like a cat with a hairball
Hoshi is so relatable to me 😭 my sister for some random reason out of no where decides to tell me to get out of my aunts old room cuz apparently my presence annoys her 😭
Do u know how many times I have had people asked me if I like being the only child or they say u are so lucky your an only child oh they say are u lonely like I am not lonely I love being an only child 😂😂😂😂😂
There's pros and cons to be an only child. Pro is you get all the attention and no siblings to annoy you but when something wrong happens there's no one to blame it on or you can't get away with anything 😂
As an elder sister I feel hoshi's story but the only difference is I'm 5.5 yrs elder than my brother and i kinda feel joshua too bcs like when our parents leave me alone at home i like it so much
As someone who has a older sister.. The fighting on random shit is soo real..Like I would give her a Kidney if she needed it but the TV Remote not so much..
![chaotic joshua moments i think about a lot [as a baby carat]🦌💎](/img/n.gif)
Shua is now fade up with siblings because he has his members as siblings😂😂
Totally fight with 12 siblings 😂
No. He likes it. He said it sometimes. And in recent bro & marble series he was continuously saying hyung hyung hyung to the older ones and acting cute. And at night when they were sleeping he can't help but say everytime to hoshi, he really likes the hyungs, I'm really happy. And in last ep he said to hoshi, so this is how it feels to be a maknae and have an older sibling right. It is so nice and so.
I mean he is one of the oldest in seventeen so he never had that experience like hoshi, who had both younger and older ones in seventeen.
He know 😂😂😂
@@SvtB67I guess Joshua need older sibling😂
Exactly he had tol .uch a sibling rivalry and love as his members. He is done😂😂😂
As an only child, I totally agree with Joshua.
Same here🖐
Same 😀
Sameee
I'm also an only child but you know i don't like it because when i saw my friends and their siblings i really get sad because i don't have any one who can play with 🥲 who can love me like elder and who can fight like a younger. I really get jealous when i see siblings 🥲🥲
@@Stay_gold_bts753 haha i feel that too but the priveledge of being a lonely child is also fun somehow 😂
He was an only child but now he has 12 brothers😊
Lol agree😂😂
No,he has 11 brothers and 1 tiger
@@for_keita sorry girl I forgot our tiger😂😂
@@for_keitano he has 4 brothers and a frog,tiger,camel,dinosaur,orange,cat(s),puppy.
@@MyreligionisSPYNUT who are they? i know a few but not all. im a new carat :)
Why did he feel lonely when he had 1 older brother 1 twin and 10 younger brother😂
exactly.,....
That's what he is saying that he doesn't feel lonely!!!
I older brother ,one soulmate and 10 younger brothers
Who is the soulmate. New carat
@@____gggg Jeonghan is the soulmate of Joshua 💎❤️
Shua parents' must be so grateful to have an only child as fine as Joshua
Totally.. His mother is an awesome person.. She brought him up so well!
You're so correct. If I become a mother someday, I would also want a son like Joshua😁
ikr!!
So true I really adore Joshua politeness and then I realised his mother did a good job. If I ever become a mom I really want a fine son like Joshua
"Do you like it? "
🐰:"I do"
"You must"
He must have a sibling 😭
Reminds me of that one video where Joshua opened unwrapped a chocolate wrapper and wonwoo snatched it from his hand cunningly and people who didn't even know svt said there's "no way he didn't know how to beaware with your food in front of your siblings he must definitely be single child"
Do you have a link?
Hoshi just seemed also relatable.. irrespective of the country, siblings fighting over remote and computer lol
I am a single mom with one son, just like Shua and his mom. I hope my son grows up to be as kind and well-adjusted as Shua is. ❤
All the love and power to you and your beautiful son 🩷🩵
@simig2793 thank you. ❤️
Your son is so lucky to have you as his mother❤️I wish you the best and a very beautiful future
@@d.33481 thank you, you just made my day. I've been on the verge of tears all day. Thank you.
@@iamb_4u908 Ah you're welcome I didn't do anything special✿ You're not alone in this world❣️ Seungkwan once said it's okay to laugh and it's okay to cry>.< So let's make a better future and pass these hard days:)
U are not an younger sibling until ur older sibling kick you for no reason and start world war 3 😂
That's opposite in my case bcz I am younger and I always start fight with kicks and when my sister fight back I go to my mom and tell her that she hit me 😎😎
( Happy to be younger )
@@Skzghostingstay lmao i am also younger but i never start fight first but once i start it, i just complain to my father that my older brother start it first 🤣(and my father also believe me cuz i rarely fight😂)
As a younger sibling that's always case for me 😂 but my bro rather starts PILLOW world war 3, and ofc I continue while our parents being annoyed by us
@@k-pop4ever_mylife yes our parents being annoyed with us being constant 😂
shua definitely suitable for variety shows or talk shows. i know some fans wanted to see him as an actor but variety shows and talk shows seems like his forte. he has his way.
Joshua right there is definitely me! My friends keep telling me how annoying their siblings are but still keep them entertained enough and they never feel bored with their siblings. They think I feel lonely without a sibling but I love it
As a girl with an older brother, i envy Joshua
As the youngest in the fam, i can relate to hoshi so much 😂
We are 2 sisters and I literally can't imagine being on my own without her. I just can't understand only child
I have one sister, our relationship is awful. We hate each other but it's not siblings' energy or anything, it's just cold hateness.
But I also would never want to be an only child
Hahaha bless you. I have only 1 younger sister. She's 10 years younger than I so I had experienced being the only child. I love having her that even fighting over trivial things feels special to me. I can not imagine myself being an only child forever. I also does not understand why people wants to be an only child, even for me who is extremely introverted.
I'm an only child and I get that question often too . And I'd answer exactly as Shua that it's actually really great . I guess it's each to their own type of thing. Since we don't have sibling we don't feel like we need one . But those who do , might not be able to imagine being alone . That's what I feel . 🩵🩷
I'm the youngest of 3 and i just can't imagine life without my siblings. They're both much older than me (11 and 7 yrs) so as a kid i would usually struggle to relate to their situations and vice-versa; and growing up with age gaps that big made me mature faster (what i'm grateful for, in a way). But now that we're all adults we've found a lot of common ground recently. It's quite fun ❤
@@simig2793 that sums up everything
ONLY Child here!!! and I 100% agree with Shua in this. Especially when he says that when people ask him if he is sad and he replies he is Not! THAT part is the same for me!!! Being an ONLY child myself is heavenly!!
From an only child to having 12 siblings
Shua seems like he has a lot of friends and like to socialize both in the states and SK, i think he’s far from lonely 😂 and the 12 ppl he can’t get rid of ensure that will never happen.
I remember that time when seventeen got asked on a radio show to choose a member that they want to introduce to their sister (the question refers to the members who has a sister) and everyone choose no one except hoshi who's willingly asked them to just take his sister lol😂
I'm an only child and I'm glad I don't have any siblings 😂
Hoshi: *a typical sibling relationship with sister*
Meanwhile Shua: *enjoying being an only child only to realise he has 12 brothers now😂*
As a girl with I younger brother I think about how much I love my brother even though I will fight over stupid things with him like hoshi and his sister.
why pledis not let joshua become an actor🫣
Same note we need Shua , DK , wonwoo and mingyu Lead actors in Kdrama
@@seventeencarat6284OMG yes 😭❤️
Because SVT will tease him hahahhaha
@@jyramaecuadra601 for sure!!🤣
Maybe he isn't interested in it?
Stop blaming the company because the idols don't do whatever you guys want them to do.
Why I expected him to say he has 12 brothers 😂
As an only child, I agree with shua
But it does get lonely some days 😢
I have siblings and I don’t ever wanna imagine life without them~ I love them and our bond so much❤ I’m very thankful I have them tbh~
Same with Joshua. I can't imagine having siblings. 😅
As on only child, I totally agree that it isn't so lonely. It usually feels so much better.
The thing that Joshua said rn is so true as a single child many people think I am lonely and all but my life is perfectly fine with all the love that I get from my parents and I do not have to share anything with someone, my life is pretty great
One can never get tired of listening to joshua talk... he speaks so softly ❤
Joshua can totally slay gentle character like ML from hidden love.❤
Give him the opportunity to act.
Me being a single child, totally relates to what Shua just said
Sibling Gang Always Sees Single Child As Alien
I am also an single child and I like it as Josh said ❤❤❤❤
Same shua same 😂
Thats so true ppl think an only child is so lonely but no we are so fine
Shua be like "I miss being the only child.... Having 12 rn not really the experience I'm looking forward when I'm young"
As an only child, seriously the only good thing happened in my life 😭🤣 like seriously you store your chocolate in fridge like for a weeks and no one will touch it😂 even tho i eat whole chocolate in one night😅 but yeah sometimes i feel lonely but not alone because god bless me with such a good friends whom i share everything when i feel lonely🥹🤌🏻
His being an only child is very obvious.
I dont think Josh need any other sibling , he has enough
Being an only child is a blessing 😅i can relate
he already has 2 hyungs and 10 dongsaengs and that's enough chaos 😂
I totally agree with joshua lol
As a single child and Joshua biased yes I 100% agree with him 😌😂
me having brother and sister:*fighting*
I agree... Being an only child is a bliss because I have a younger brother and I am jealous of the once who don't have siblings 😭😭😭
Hoshi: she kicked me, we fight a lot😢😢
Bgm: ❤🤩😍😍🥰🥰💝
U can't blame shua..he has 12 bros he really knows the feeling 🤣🤣
Girl proved that she is from south Asia
yes shua preach 🤣 but being an only child also means we're the all types of child, the pressure and expectation for the first child, the "nah, you'll be fine" dismissal for the middle child, and the all the chores are passed to me of the youngest 😭 the very reason i'm very close with my cousins that i grew up with
I bet Hoshi is such a funny brother, like he's crazy around Svt imagine him as a kid with his sister!
As an only child, I agree with Joshua.
I’m crying my life is so sad 💔
Shua is me 😂 I like it that I'm the only child 😂
It's so fun being an only child lol
Pretty sure after being with members shua must be happy to be only child lol. Like they have all types of siblings one could have.
As an only child, i can literally tell i'm very thankful to have no siblings.
Me n my lil bro is like Hoshi with his sister 💀
Common siblings fighting 😂😂
As rhe younger sibling I can relate Hoshi 😂
Shua is me bro, we like it this way only 😭🤣
As a middle child, I always wished I was an only child. 😂 jelly of Shua.
Shua escaped siblings at home but he was bequeathed an entire zoo in his professional life 💀😂😂😂
Shua spoke my mind
I am Shua. Shua is me 😭😂
I can relate to Joshua as a single child. People used to ask me if I am lonely because I am the only child but I am happy because I can spend my time alone 😅
Same shua, I'm jealous of you being an only child
imagine like for real being shua s sibling 🤌
you'll never have a peaceful day
He's the only child, but had to learn how to take care of 10 younger brothers. 🤣😂🩵🩷
Joshua is the only child who likes this situation
Man I relate to shua on so many levels. I'm also an old child Korean American who grew up in LA learning Korean from a Korean church. My mom even made me drink Korean oriental medicine which I poured down the sink 😂 Only difference is that I dance like a drunk ostrich and sing like a cat with a hairball
Joshua happily has 1 wife, 1 tiger and 10 children by his side
Hoshi and his sis are me and my brother 😂
I have one little brother, and our relationship is EXACTLY a as same as Hoshi said.
Siblings = Eternal Enemy
Hoshi is so relatable to me 😭 my sister for some random reason out of no where decides to tell me to get out of my aunts old room cuz apparently my presence annoys her 😭
The song in the background is Bleuming by IU
Its so similar with enhypen jay only child and also a foreign line!
Same here😂😂, I have 2 siblings and fight over the stupidest things
Joshua is just like me
Do u know how many times I have had people asked me if I like being the only child or they say u are so lucky your an only child oh they say are u lonely like I am not lonely I love being an only child 😂😂😂😂😂
There's pros and cons to be an only child. Pro is you get all the attention and no siblings to annoy you but when something wrong happens there's no one to blame it on or you can't get away with anything 😂
i can feel you joshua..I am also only child
Shua is so me🤭❤
ig its really rare for siblings to be nice to each other if they are male and female… cuz i just cant improve the relationship with my brother
Shua: I like it
Hoshi nd me:it must be nice 😢
Why he will alone when he have the craziest and abnormal group in kpop 😂
Shua and I relate!! 😭👍
As an elder sister I feel hoshi's story but the only difference is I'm 5.5 yrs elder than my brother and i kinda feel joshua too bcs like when our parents leave me alone at home i like it so much
Great human being best wishes for him SJK May God bless him and is family 💗💗❤️🎉❤️❤️🎉🎉❤️❤️
As someone who has a older sister.. The fighting on random shit is soo real..Like I would give her a Kidney if she needed it but the TV Remote not so much..
Yeah shua .....I agree with you
Shua already has 12 siblings he doesn't need more😅😂😂
Me & shua we r on the same boat ❤~~
Shua isn't lonely he has 12 crazy siblings😂
as an only child too , shua is so us💪
I totally agree with shua! 😂
Shua is me , I am shua
Me as the only child thinking the same thing as Joshua
As an only child I can relate to joshua ..... We dnt need to ask for attention we have it all the time
as an elder sister w a brother 2 years younger, i agree with hoshi we fight abt the most random shi💀