No, f(x) used to be 5 And also, the wanted it to be their “own” version in order not to be compared to the original just like what NJ did to wondergirls’ tell me.
@@Lovewinter19 right like that whole verse is done by amber so why is it split by giselle and karina in this cover when theyre even less members than f(x)..? 😭😭
I think because aespa tries too hard for every member to have voval and rap parts in a song. While fx have more of a fixed position. Luna and krystal will always have the main vocal parts in the song. Sullie and victoria sub vocalist parts and amber main rapper parts. So rap parts and vocal parts are broken into smaller sections to let everyome member do everything. @gabyreveluv
People get mad at winter, screaming she doesnt deserve the part she got even though girlie got the least line overall😂😂 oh poor girl they will never make me hate you❤
Yes it’s giselle if you know how rumpumpum is sang it is Giselle. That melody is sang by different members at different times. winter started first with the line and she’s still singing the tail end of the note then Giselle starts her line.
![Park Kiyah [기야]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/0xb4b-KPl860hy-q2pHIBjVNKDYCZ8tamefk_BiB0PGbrxm6oWhtZwx1EfrWV_EVkJBB8cgg=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
Giselle's part in 03:21 especially 03:25 are really surprised me 😭
I wasn't the bit surprised
Always knew she had great vocals
Not just enough materials to prove it
This was really nice and accurate. Thanks
I dont understand why aespa divides the song lines into such tiny bits when theyre only 4 members 😭😭
cause they try everything so that giselle gets last place even im a cover💀like even the rap verse
No, f(x) used to be 5
And also, the wanted it to be their “own” version in order not to be compared to the original just like what NJ did to wondergirls’ tell me.
@@gothkirigaya3066 They definitely made it their own but i’m talking about something completely different 💀 stay on topic
@@Lovewinter19 right like that whole verse is done by amber so why is it split by giselle and karina in this cover when theyre even less members than f(x)..? 😭😭
I think because aespa tries too hard for every member to have voval and rap parts in a song. While fx have more of a fixed position. Luna and krystal will always have the main vocal parts in the song. Sullie and victoria sub vocalist parts and amber main rapper parts. So rap parts and vocal parts are broken into smaller sections to let everyome member do everything. @gabyreveluv
Audiz in first 🥺❤️
Welcome back
thank you!!! 😘❤
AESPA
KARINA WINTERING
GISELLE NINGNING
RUM RUM RUM RUM
NINGNING AND KARINA HIGH NOTE👑👑👑👑👑
People get mad at winter, screaming she doesnt deserve the part she got even though girlie got the least line overall😂😂 oh poor girl they will never make me hate you❤
Ikk! as much as I love 2ning, her solo stans are just a diff breed 😭
0:56 is Giselle no winter
no, it is not
@@parkkiyah21 it's Giselle
It's Giselle
okayyy
Yes it’s giselle if you know how rumpumpum is sang it is Giselle. That melody is sang by different members at different times. winter started first with the line and she’s still singing the tail end of the note then Giselle starts her line.
how the hell did you get this audio it sounds perfect
i just searched the smtown 2025 live and i found it like that
nothing new😂 giselle getting saved from last place by small words is sad
Karina voice is pretty
If only Winter practice hard for Sulli’s part instead of Giselle. I think she fits the vibe if she really try.
Its a cover not their song